14 ms·
Any claim without a URI should be treated as suspicious
- reiichiroh 6y agoWhy isn’t the L in uppercase for the URL acronym?
- uniqueid 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Resource_Identifier https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uniform_Resource_Identifier
- njsubedi 6y ago>The whole investigation took me 5 minutes. A Web search, a few clicks, and some ctrl+f’ing. Am I the only one who thinks the last phrase sounds weird? I might be used to reading lots of articles that sensor words, but couldn't help reading it as "control-fucking". (Edit: uncensored)
- cpach 6y agoNow that you mentioned it I can’t unsee it ;-)
- CincinnatiMan 6y agoI understood it to be searching the page with the Ctrl+F keyboard shortcut.
- phoe-krk 6y agoYou have successfully ruined the formerly innocent and inconspicious image of this phrase in my mind. Have an upvote.
- Zhyl 6y agoI think Ctrl+F seems to be more popular than 'grepping' these days, although I would very much be in favour of bringing 'grepping' back.
- black_puppydog 6y agothere's just so few people who still grep through website code directly. :P
- ben509 6y agoIn Firefox the / key is bound to quick find, so it's there in spirit.
- _Microft 6y agoFirefox also allows to search without bringing up the search bar first by setting "accessibility.typeaheadfind" in "about:config" to true. Reducing the timeout for the search bar to disappear after the last keypress is very useful as well. This is hidden behind "accessibility.typeaheadfind.timeout". Caveat: is messes with pages that use normal letters as keyboard inputs, like WASD as movement keys. One might need to disable it temporarily if that happens.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI use Firefox developer edition - I assume that's set up by default. Though I've learned to work around it, it has driven me mad for so long - I didn't know you could turn it off! Finally, it's fixed! Thank you!
- _Microft 6y agoEveryday a good deed - I'm glad I could help ;)
- zentiggr 6y agoTIL - Thanks!
- sepulchers 6y agoYou mean you don't `curl | rg` web pages?
- cosmodisk 6y agoHow do I unread your last sentence? Now I want a T-shirt with 'Go away,or I'll CTRL-F you'.
- anonymfus 6y agoI read what you wrote as "control-finding".
- specialist 6y agoI misread it as 'ctrl-fsck'.
- rapnie 6y agocontrol-freaking is what I saw.
- black_puppydog 6y agoThis really connects with the "Cool URIs don't change" mantra.
- raxxorrax 6y agoJudge me all you want, but I would have clicked on "dirty hippy vibes"... Honestly, I don't really believe in ubiquitous misinformation being as a large problem as it is made out to be. Everyone arguing for more content regulation had their own motivations or was in some kind of panic. There will always be people misinformed on the net. Doesn't mean I want a babysitter cleaning everything up, even if I thought they wouldn't just want to suppress dissidents. I have no facebook account and people say it is really bad there, but I also think major news networks spread bullshit in regular intervals. Doesn't mean everything they report is bullshit, but the normal citizen would be cancelled already.
- edent 6y agoI'm not sure where you got the impression that I wanted people to clean up misinformation from the web. That certainly wasn't my intent. Perhaps you and I move in different social circles - but I get a lot of forwarded "claims" on WhatsApp and Twitter. Well-meaning people who see an image with some text on it and send it to their friends & family. My blog post is mostly aimed at them - showing how easy it can be to check sources.
- dleslie 6y agoI find much of that sort of instant messaging communication is less about informing others and is more about social signalling. The sender is asking for emotional support and social solidarity.
- anoraca 6y agoWhat are you basing that on?
- dleslie 6y agoMy understanding is that text messaging is rarely used for knowledge sharing, and is primarily used for social bonding[0]. In my own experience, I never receive such messages from individuals that aren't aware that I already agree with their intended interpretation. 0: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/221270858_A_large_scale_study_of_text-messaging_use https://www.researchgate.net/publication/221270858_A_large_s...
- jermier 6y agoVery soon everything will exist cryptographically on some uncensorable blockchain, and websites & files will exist on the Interplanetary Filesystem[0] and will be impossible to take down. And 'things' will all be categorized and have their own QR code which when scanned, will reveal the context (or even price!) of the item. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterPlanetary_File_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/InterPlanetary_File_System
- dsun179 6y agoI do not think so. Most of my ipfs bookmarks from 2 years ago are offline now, everything gone because no peer has the content.
- noman-land 6y agoFileCoin just recently launched and it aims to fix this exact problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y agoHow does adding crypto fix this problem? I presume it's to incentivize peers into retaining and serving the content, but who's going to pay? The author? The viewer? How is either going to work for long tail content that's been abandoned by the author?
- bottled_poe 6y agoWait, hmm... maybe if we use the blockchain here we can solve those problems too?
- dsun179 6y agoOr machine learning?
- londons_explore 6y agoSite down... Shows ReCAPTCHA in an infinite loop...
- vezycash 6y ago>Site down... Shows ReCAPTCHA I suppose this is cloudflare + their new captcha provider. This behavior is annoying / suspicious. They know the site is down, yet make people solve captcha repeatedly before finally telling them that the site is down.
- wizzwizz4 6y agoThey're incentivised to do this. hCAPTCHA pays them for it.
- donarb 6y agoWell, the site may be active once you are finally able to solve the CAPTCHA.
- londons_explore 6y agoCurious... The page I saw was actual Google Recaptcha...
- Trufa 6y agoCompletely tangential, I never understand why people use URI instead of URL. He obviously means URL and goes an abstraction lower. You could also say without the corresponding internet uniquely scheme or whatever. Sorry for the rant. But I am missing something?
- corty 6y agoThe difference between URI and URL is practically meaningless except to a very small circle of specialists. Noone uses the name "URI", even when they are talking about one. Except if they explicitly want to signal their membership in that circle of experts.
- wjnc 6y agoAm I wrong to suppose that L is locator and I is indicator, thus I being a more broadly term and a somewhat nerdy term for Source?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- corty 6y agoL is locator, I is identifier. URLs are a subset of URIs. Both start with a schema (something:...), but URIs lack the information about the location and way to get at a resource. The canonical example for identifier-but-not-location is an ISBN or DOI. That interpretation however requires a very peculiar interpretation of "location", because imho "where can I read about that" can precisely be answered by "ISBN ...". The usual copout "but you don't know where the next library will be" also makes all the traditional URLs non-locations, because you then also don't always know where the next browser is or how to operate it. The rest of the responsible RFC is also not very useful: https://danielmiessler.com/study/difference-between-uri-url/ https://danielmiessler.com/study/difference-between-uri-url/
- sukilot 6y ago
- dontcarethrow2 6y agoI would've agreed with this a bit more if we hadn't started banning content we don't like from the internet. Here I am without a link, but chasing away groups we don't agree with to the dark side of the web makes it very convenient for the current political saints to shape our views. I take any claim with URIs or without, try to think about who gains from such perspectives, weigh it with past experiences. I'd hate to just see a URI and go "OK, I am convinced ty" and automatically pick up the pitchforks against those without. I doubt even newspapers did this. It sounds like a good idea but only on an open internet and not what we have today.
- DarkmSparks 6y agoAmen
- Aerroon 6y ago>I'd hate to just see a URI and go "OK, I am convinced ty" and automatically pick up the pitchforks against those without. Something to particularly consider are circular references. If you make the reference graph large enough then it's easy to fool people into thinking that there is a valid source for a claim when there actually isn't one. All you have are references that refer to one another. It gets particularly bad when some of those references end up as dead links, because then you can't even find out whether the chain ended up at a valid source or not. Related to this are long reference chains that end up on a shaky source. A poorly done study (or simply a bought one) can end up being referenced in a long chain. The links in the chain might end up giving more credibility to the source.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI don't think you even need a large graph! People have observed this happening with just two nodes, where one of the nodes is Wikipedia [1] — some website states information they learned on (or copied from) Wikipedia, and then Wikipedia cites that website as a primary source. [1] https://slate.com/technology/2019/03/wikipedia-citogenesis-circular-reporting-problem.html https://slate.com/technology/2019/03/wikipedia-citogenesis-c...
- lysium 6y agoWhile I agree, what does the URl in this particular case tell us? Is it a true quote? Does the new context change its meaning? Can someone please elaborate, I don’t get it.
- cochne 6y agoI'll start of by saying the author has provided some nice research. However, this particular example is the kind of thing where it doesn't even really matter wether its legitimate or not. The fact that it doesn't attribute it to any particular source makes it almost meaningless. It's basically just saying that some person 100 years ago said "X". Does it really matter if I have a source for that? This content is clearly not meant to convince, only entertain.
- edent 6y agoThe claim is "even a hundred years ago we had prats who didn't want to wear masks because they were embarrassed." This citation shows that, yes, this was a trope even back then.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoIt’s strange, because a mask can mask identity, so why would you be embarrassed if few can recognize you?
- jpswade 6y agoSurely "don't trust everything you read on the Internet" is just a given at this point, especially if it originates on Twitter.
- donarb 6y agoThat was such a great, prescient quote by Abraham Lincoln.
- DavidVoid 6y agoI can really recommend having a look through the blog Yesterday's Print that's mentioned in the post [1]. It's an excellent collection of some interesting, relatable, and humorous snippets from ca. a hundred years ago. This one they posted about a year ago stuck with me [2]. The saying, "Life is just one damn thing after another," is a gross understatement. The damn things overlap. -- The Cincinnati Enquirer, Ohio, February 21, 1947. [1] https://yesterdaysprint.tumblr.com/ https://yesterdaysprint.tumblr.com/ [2] https://yesterdaysprint.tumblr.com/post/176557878119/the-cincinnati-enquirer-ohio-february-21-1947 https://yesterdaysprint.tumblr.com/post/176557878119/the-cin...
- keithalewis 6y agoAnd any claim with one, doubly so. -- Abe Lincoln abe@I-chopped-the-cherry-tree.gov
- dom96 6y ago> The whole investigation took me 5 minutes. A Web search, a few clicks, and some ctrl+f’ing. Yes, it took you, a person with a blog and the technical know how. I bet you that 99.99% of people that have access to the internet have a very basic understanding of how to use a search engine, in particular the trick of quoting a phrase to match it exactly is not something I would expect the mainstream to be aware of. What we need is a better education so that it is effortless to the majority, just like it is for you or me.
- btrettel 6y agoAs many of those who have read academic papers know, even claims with citations are often suspicious. Time and time again I've found cited sources that don't say what was claimed. Sometimes, citations are not specific enough (e.g., citing a huge book rather than the specific page with the evidence). So, better than giving a URL would be to give a URL with a "fragment" if possible, i.e., #id. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/URI_fragment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/URI_fragment Chrome can be even more specific now with this extension: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/link-to-text-fragment/pbcodcjpfjdpcineamnnmbkkmkdpajjg https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/link-to-text-fragm...
- arp242 6y ago> Time and time again I've found cited sources that don't say what was claimed. I have similar experiences with Wikipedia; if I want to know about something I generally go to Wikipedia first and just loads a bunch of the references. They usually pan out, but not infrequently the reference simply doesn't contain whatever the Wikipedia article claimed.
- TazeTSchnitzel 6y agoOne of the problems with Wikipedia is that the citation syntax does not require (it's possible but quite rare) specifying what part of the preceding text the citation relates to. As a result it often covers, deceptively, only part of the sentence it's attached to, or the paragraph it's attached to, and it can get worse with editing which doesn't account for the citation's content.
- melvinroest 6y agoThis is exactly why I submitted [1] to HN, coincidentally a few hours ago. IMO, assertions should be computable (if possible) and backed by data. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23896279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23896279
- tW4r 6y agoI think this could be a great application for a DAG blockchain, with the axioms of a given scientific field as initial seed blocks. Then any proofs can be derived using the previous blocks, and, should any proof be disproved the whole sub chain depending on it would collapse and need to be rewritten “remined”
- newen 6y agoWe're going to need to issue some Verrit cards for this link.
- mapgrep 6y agoAny claim with a URI should also be treated with suspicion. There is plenty of reliable information locked away in offline books and government documents and all kinds of other non Google-able locations. This is true even for brand new information (which is why we continue to have “leaks”). Meanwhile there is plenty of misinformation with URIs. I would go so far as to say online status is almost orthogonal to accuracy, except that in theory at least online information is more readily disproven. (Never mind that the whole core example of the article is off. The sketchy unsourced image also has a URI.)
- ceejayoz 6y ago> Any claim with a URI should also be treated with suspicion. Agreed. I've noticed a huge uptick of "here is a random YouTuber's 45 minute rant about X" used as "evidence" in discussions. Opting to not watch it in its entirety is then dismissed as being unwilling to discuss; watching it and picking it apart leads to "oh, but you haven't seen his OTHER videos".
- saagarjha 6y agoSounds like run-of-the-mill bad faith discussion :/
- taytus 6y agoI thought this was about all those gpt-3 gifs demos on twitter...
- duxup 6y agoI hate URL fights. I give little extra value to people providing links with their clams. I largely given up providing links to information when called out as well. It's not worth the time. Discussion on the internet is broken in most places (HN is less broken than most). I find little value providing URLs. Much of the time I provide them, few folks seem to read it, fewer actually want to read it in an intellectually honest way and usually they respond with some bonkers links of their own that don't say what they think they're saying. Much (not all) of the time I've given up providing links to basic information it doesn't change the conversation in any meaningful way. It's usually just an argument where folks who feel like URLs are some sort of scoring device. I get the idea put forward here, but I don't know if it makes sense in an age where you can find an URL that says anything and discussion on the internet is so bad that nobody is really reading them anyway.
- DangitBobby 6y agoI frequently visit the links found in comments here. But in these instances I am reading someone else's "URL fight."
- duxup 6y agoHN is certainly an exception I'll make for providing / reading links.
- the_duke 6y ago> Much of the time I provide them, few folks seem to read it I wouldn't be so pessimistic. Only a small fraction of people that read comments will respond. Plenty of viewers will probably check out the link and derive value from it, but won't have anything valuable to contribute to the discussion. Antagonistic viewers that already strongly disagree will be much more likely to respond (and without reading the link), skewing your perception.
- hinkley 6y agoIt helps me sometimes to remember that my conversation has an audience, and just because my opponent didn't learn anything doesn't mean that I wasted my breath.
- crazygringo 6y agoNot a URI -- a citation, which may or may not include a URI. Not all academic literature has been digitized, you know. (As someone who hunts down a lot of citations, you can trust me on that.) Also URI's break, while citations include enough information (publisher, title, author, etc.) that the source can be found regardless.
- carapace 6y agoCan we "pin" this to HN front page in perpetuity? I'm joking but I'm also serious. It's (IMO) basic hygiene at this point. The Internet used to be like Burning Man, today it's more like Bangkok. Flipping it around what this really means is that taking any particular assertion made online seriously without some "certificate" (same root as "certain") as to who stands by it, is wildly, childishly, naive. (Including that one, and this one.) The real question (as alluded to in TFA) is, "Whom do you trust?"
- tegiddrone 6y agoI begin to think about how to build a linter/scorecard for this sort of stuff. Example linter rules: This article does not have a source. This article has no sources from a known resource [this community] find reputable. This article has a source from a source known to this community to be non-reputable. This article has a "shallow" source such as a blog (tumblr, medium, blogspot, youtube) Probably would need a mechanism to build/aggregate/crowdsource reputable source lists. edit: formatting
- snowwrestler 6y agoI think the key lesson in this story is the author's willingness to do the work. IMO it's not enough to be skeptical; you also should have a set of criteria by which you'll be satisfied, and be willing to go try to satisfy those criteria yourself. I don't think that merely pointing out a lack of citation is sufficient as a counterargument.
- 6510 6y agoTo quote a friend of mine: But then I would have to doubt and question everything. It kept me laughing for many years.
- xenocyon 6y agoA lot of the comments here focus on claims made in bad faith. But the biggest value of citations is when one is trying to make or check a claim in good faith. Many times I find that my own long-held beliefs turn out to be incorrect or partially incorrect or misunderstandings when I fact-check them with a reliable expert source. As for claims made in bad faith? Don't trust these whether they have citations or not. Because there are a variety of primary sources on every topic and most things in life are uncertain, it is frequently possible to cherry pick an expert opinion that aligns with yours if you look hard enough. This makes fact the servant of opinion rather than the other way around.
- pacija 6y agoA great number of people, even smart ones, have been tricked into believing the Truth can be found on the Internet. It can't.
- k_sze 6y agoI believe that there are two things at play here: 1. epistemology (a.k.a. ToK - Theory of Knowledge) and 2. emotion vs rationality. What the author says should be completely natural to a person who is has studied ToK and who is in a rather rational state of mind. A person who doesn't understand the problem of ToK would simply be oblivious. A person who is under the influence of emotion, well, would be unable to help themself from believing whatever fits their emotion. The ultimate evidence of truthfulness need not be a URL, depending on the claim. Nor is a URL necessarily sufficient. After all, how do you know the ultimate URL of origin is trustworthy? All you can do is to recursively ask yourself "how do you know?", either until you accumulate enough doubt or until the question sounds absurd.
- anjc 6y agoEven source data itself is not free from contexts and biases. Just treat everything with suspicion. And treat people with extra suspicion if they always provide a URL, especially if the URL is to somebody's interpretation of an interpretation etc.
- danso 6y agoI wish this sentiment were even stronger when it comes to screenshots, e.g. screenshots of purportedly deleted tweets/articles. As we get closer to deepfake-video-on-demand becoming a thing, I'm still astonished at how the vast majority of people don't understand how trivial it is to create pixel-perfect fake web content. My default response to a screenshot is to assume it's faked unless there's an accompanying Wayback Machine/archive.today URL.
- kiplkipl 6y agoThis should go for almost everything written in a newspaper. We all know about the the intentional spin and unintentional failure to understand technical topics but, when written in a newspaper, hearsay is treated as factual secondary source.
- tomp 6y agoIsn't this just a submarine post to put a quote about masks and people who don't wear them on top of HN?
- staycoolboy 6y agoHow are citations not the fallacy of "appeal to authority"? Citations are basically an attempt at X.509 or Certificate Authority "root of trust": follow the certs until you find one we all agree is "trustyworthy". Except in this case, that "someone" may or may not be provable, because the root of trust could potentially go back centuries. I'm not impugning the work of historians, I realize this is part of what they do: follow the citations, cross-correlate, and seek "the truth" through painstaking research. But outside of extensive historical effort, it seems like a pretty flimsy strategy for contentious topics.
- mcnamaratw 6y agoIf the citation contains data then using a citation is not an appeal to authority.
- jakear 6y agoIn general I do agree citations are a good thing. But in this case and ones like it, does it really matter? Someone is making a humorous statement, it’s not of particular importance to me if it was made 100 years ago first or not, so why should I care to look it up? Rephrased: what would change if you found the image was “fake”?
- alextheparrot 6y ago> The whole investigation took me 5 minutes. A Web search, a few clicks, and some ctrl+f‘ing I think this is the core issue with this post. There is an intersection between how much this new claim would update my mental model and how much time it will take to prove. The idea of "how much time it will take to prove" is important, because we all have a limited amount of intellectual bandwidth that we use to receive and integrate new information. Intellectual bandwidth means we need prioritization. Without prioritization we have two suboptimal states that are available. The first is where we are being DDOS'd in bad-faith by low-value claims, that have some amount of work to prove. The second is that whichever claims we do resolve are likely not the set of claims which result in optimal utility; updating our mental model results in utility, assuming that our update function only accepts "good" updates. One strategy, that I think I use, is to break things into four categories: (1) A claim close to my current mental model (2) A claim not far but not close to my mental model (3) A claim far from my mental model (4) A claim unrelated to my mental model. If a claim is close to my mental model (1), I'd probably just accept it out of hand. This newspaper clipping is one example, because proving that the clipping is real does not update my mental model (Nor does disproving it, honestly), so it is low value. This is the cheap filter that reduces redundancy. If a claim is far from my mental model (3), I'll probably just dismiss it out of hand. I'm not going to go to the work to prove or disprove something, insofar. There are exceptions here, wherein the statement is so orthogonal to the mental model that it might have high value and is therefore still with looking into. In my experience, claims of high value that are completely orthogonal from my mental model tend to be rarer than claims of low value. One case I can think of is an article on oil prices I read, where there was a claim that the breakeven oil price was ~$200 a barrel as support for Iran having a broken economy. This didn't make sense, as it would mean Iran is not a viable economy even with oil, but then why are western nations wasting political capital embargoing an unviable product? So I spent time investigating it (Investing intellectual bandwidth). In the end, it seemed like a bad-faith argument as it assumed that the oil price would be the only thing to balance the Iranian national budget and didn't speak to the fact that Iran is subject to artificial export constraints via embargoes. Engaging with claims in this category seems to result in finding a lot of gravel and maybe a piece of gold from time to time. The medium category (2) is where I think most of us should be spending our time, the frontiers of our mental model where things are both foreign as well as familiar. When you can take different parts of evidence and see that some of it makes sense and some of it doesn't. I think this area is ripe for bad-faith disruption, as I'm much more willing to engage with this type of premise. I remember reading and putting down a book lately because it proposed an interesting question, around what has changed in the America of my parent's and of today. It was asserting, without even worrying about supporting evidence, that traditional family values were the cause. The last category (4) is not an unimportant one, which is just the area where you might say "I don't know" or "Why does that matter". If someone claims Charles II was born in 1629, I also wouldn't derive much value by looking it up and saying "No, he was actually born in 1630". In that sense, it is low-value information because it doesn't intersect with meaning for me. Overall, I think the problem with the line of thinking I quoted is that it puts a lot of burden on the individual for what usually has zero or negative value to that individual. That work exists whether or not a URI is included, and is possible exacerbated by there now being "evidence" provided even insofar as the linked context provides no value. Aside: The phrase "ctrl+f'ing" written out is a bit humorous.
- fit2rule 6y agoWe can no longer really know what the truth is, honestly. This is why the political foo-ha about "facts having a liberal bias" and all that was so poignant - it was an admission that the Internet had won.
- ardy42 6y ago> Treat any claim without a URl as suspicious. This assumes that the web is the only information source you should be using as a reference. You definitely should cite your sources if you can, but saying they have to be web soruces is a pretty limiting requirement. The tumblr page that gave the print citation did just fine.
- kens 6y agoA timely quip from the same 1918 newspaper page: "Why don't you wear your influenza mask?" "I'm afraid I might look funny." "Suppose you do. Wouldn't you rather introduce a little comedy into your household than subject it to tragedy?"
- ScottWRobinson 6y agoMaybe GPT-3 can just do our fact-checking for us...
- agustif 6y agoCitationLint is needed.
- CM30 6y agoThis is something more online media outlets should taken into consideration, especially for their own articles. Too many think linking out to potential 'competitors' is a bad thing, or make it too difficult to find the source for their data/conclusions. Newspapers and magazines are especially bad for this, as are YouTube channels and other video format content creators.
- drewda 6y agoOn a somewhat related note, here's an enjoyable read about how citations in scholarly papers can sometimes mask shoddy thinking and spread "Academic urban legends": > Many of the messages presented in respectable scientific publications are, in fact, based on various forms of rumors. Some of these rumors appear so frequently, and in such complex, colorful, and entertaining ways that we can think of them as academic urban legends. The explanation for this phenomenon is usually that authors have lazily, sloppily, or fraudulently employed sources, and peer reviewers and editors have not discovered these weaknesses in the manuscripts during evaluation. To illustrate this phenomenon, I draw upon a remarkable case in which a decimal point error appears to have misled millions into believing that spinach is a good nutritional source of iron. Through this example, I demonstrate how an academic urban legend can be conceived and born, and can continue to grow and reproduce within academia and beyond. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0306312714535679 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/03063127145356...
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI agree, but even that isn't any kind of guarantee. I have noticed that many sites simply repost single-origin garbage, so it can easily look like it's multi-sourced. Scammers and politrolls use this all the time. Marketers work really hard to get talking points pushed out to as many outlets as possible, so the "origin" may be different, but the text all came from one place. "Don't believe everything you read on the Internet." -Benjamin Franklin
- arpa 6y agoHmmm, I don't see any URI supporting the original claim. I find it suspicious.
- jmchuster 6y agoIf you're curious about what a forum would look like if it required URL citations, you can take a look at http://old.reddit.com/r/neutralnews http://old.reddit.com/r/neutralnews. It has pretty strict modding e.g. rule #2 > 2) Source your facts. If you're claiming something to be true, you need to back it up by linking to a qualified and relevant source. There is no "common knowledge" exception, and anecdotal evidence is not allowed.
- jgalt212 6y ago16 + 26 = 42 [1] [2] [1] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=16+%2B+26 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=16+%2B+26 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/42_(number)#The_Hitchhiker's_Guide_to_the_Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/42_(number)#The_Hitchhiker's_G...
- mcculley 6y agoFor a few years, I was looking forward to newspapers embedding navigable links to the sources of their reporting. I figured that we just had to wait for the pre-Internet generation of journalists to retire and the next generation would cite better. But now it is apparent that newspapers have no interest in doing this as it would encourage readers to go to another site and deprive them of advertisement revenue. I would really love to subscribe to a newspaper that prioritized readers/subscribers.
- amelius 6y agoEvery viral social media fake news story spreads from URI to URI ...
- dublin 6y agoOr perhaps, any claim with a URI and without a physical card in a library card catalog should be treated as suspicious... Just sayin'...
- rrauenza 6y agoI ranted about one of these on facebook yesterday. Attached to a stock photo of an Amish lumber worker: > I had a conversation with an Amish gentleman yesterday while I was loading at a mill, and at the end of the conversation he asked me one question that should really get one thinking. He asked "Do you know why this virus hasn't affected us yet?" no "well because we don't have television" The good friend who posted this was like, "this really got me thinking!" (I presumed the subtext was that this virus is just blown out of proportion.) My response was -- WHY? Why do we even assume this quote is TRUE? And why would you let fake things like this give you something to think about? These are no better than the junk faxes people used to pass around claiming Proctor & Gamble worshiped the devil. I was kind of glad I stopped getting them in email from relatives because they moved to facebook instead, but ... so much of our society's ... gestalt? mindset? ... is formed by these junk memes being passed around as truth. (And this isn't unique to one political persuasion.) The best evidence that Facebook and Twitter are drugs I think is that for some reason brains turn off when consuming media on them. Where has our critical thinking gone? We’re hopeless as a society without it.