26 ms·
Huawei 5G kit must be removed from UK by 2027
- euix 6y agoHere is a meta comment: having read this entire thread, it's pretty obvious that if even reasonably educated and intelligent people on a technical forum like this descend into complete disagreement then one can think what happens among the society and people at large on both sides of the Pacific and how easily it is to descend into a conflict.
- msla 6y agoI wonder how much of the disagreement is paid-for, to ensure no actual discussion is allowed to break out.
- Thorentis 6y agoI automatically assume that astro-turfing happens on a large scale on every public forum. HN has been around long enough and has enough high profile people on it, to make it a target. The moderation is generally quite good, but unfortunately as the astro-turfing ramps up, the moderation will need to make HN a blander and blander place as any form of opinion is censored. We aren't there yet though, so enjoy it while you can!
- dang 6y agoInternet users are a thousand (actually probably more like a hundred thousand) times too quick to jump to such insidious but exciting conclusions. Having spent countless hours investigating such things I can tell you confidently that the overwhelming explanation is the boring and obvious one, the one Mr. Occam will give if you ask: people just disagree. People are biased toward underestimating how much legitimate disagreement there is in any large, distributed population sample—which HN is. Probably we're hard-wired to evaluate the world by local conditions around us, and most of us are surrounded by people who see things similarly to how we do. Then we come online, bump into views that are harsh outliers in our world, and poof: an astroturfer under every bed and a spy in every closet. This is so close to a universal mechanism that we have a rule about it in https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html: "Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data." Please note: this is not to say that abuse doesn't exist. But the overwhelming majority of such insinuations are imaginary, so in investigating real abuse we need concrete evidence to go on—something, anything. The presence of opposing views on an internet forum does not clear that bar—it is evidence of nothing but that the topic is divisive. Piles of past explanation are at https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=true&page=0&query=by:dang%20astroturf https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme...
- CamperBob2 6y agoI wonder if you can talk a little about how you determine whether or not astroturfing is going on. How can you be sure that a given post with a political or nationalist slant is made in good faith? You seem pretty confident that it's not a widespread problem, which is great, but it would be good if the rest of us could share at least some of that confidence. Is it really enough to look at the account history and observe that the same user has participated in other unrelated threads? Or are there more subtle cues that you go by?
- dang 6y agoWe can't know for sure. Past account histories count for a lot—if people would simply look at them, I think most accusations of this sort would vaporize. It's not plausible that $secret-enemy planted $hn-user in 2013 to comment about syntactic whitespace and Google Fiber or whatever, so they'd be more credible seven years later when promoting $political-agenda. Beyond that, we look at relationships between accounts, patterns of site access...I'm not sure what else to tell you. The private data confirms what the public data already shows. There are exceptions, but they don't determine the discourse on the site. What determines that is people simply having different views. Mostly I just wish people would realize that the spectrum of genuine disagreement is much broader than it seems like it should be, would be, or could be. The world is just a bigger place than we feel like it is.
- wyuenho 6y agoDoes HN have anything like Twitter or Facebook to detect organized network of sock puppets?
- dang 6y agoI don't know what they do so I can't say. We certainly have lots of code dedicated to such things.
- dependenttypes 6y agoThat brings a surprisingly amount of false positives. After all nobody would think that two users might share a proxy ip address.
- rdxm 6y agook, so I would have thought someone would have taken the bait on my earlier post, but true to HN form there's was much over analysis due after my early response. Here's the deal. The UK, politically in no way want's to kick the Chinese out. But! Boris has to appease the facile idiot in the White House, so the answer is (produced after much coaching from his MP's and Constituents), to announce a ban that will come to fruition long after The Donald has left the White House...DUH! But wait there's more. There's no question the Chinese run supply chain operations just like the 5 Eye's do. That's how the game is played, so it's telling how quiet GCHQ has been on this. How many times do people have to see the I/CI/I game get played out before they connect the dots? FFS, this has been going on for close to a hundred years in modern society alone...
- kimsant 6y agoa very simple person here: Does this mean that operators will have to pay for it, so new investments will be required? If 5G deployment price increase due to this political stuff, is gonna be then more expensive for the end user no? price will reflect it i guess...
- TwoNineFive 6y agoThe ghost of Nortel haunts thee.
- tibbydudeza 6y agoJust the beginning of a new cold war. The Belt and Road initiative was a clear sign that China is confident and more assertive geo-political player and intends to eventually replace the US as the dominant world power. An easy choice of the UK to make considering they export very little of consequence to China ... Australia on the other hand.
- dependenttypes 6y agoI am actually glad for this. Not because of any nationalistic reason but rather because Huawei is an extremely anti-user company (locked bootloader etc) and I would be glad if it went down.
- macspoofing 6y agoThe China-US tensions are not going to get better, and, in fact, will get worse as years go by. More and more nations will be forced to choose sides. It's not good and I'm not sure what a resolution even looks like.
- flattone 6y agoMy 'being honest with ourselves' view is we know whats going to happen and its going to suck.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThe alternative to Huawei in 5G is either Nokia or Ericsson. As an European I don't what to think that the US seems so against kit from a Chinese company and completely fine with kit from an European company. They should be worried about both. We also have a long term world domination plan (version 2.0)... ;)
- ceilingcorner 6y agoMaybe the fact that one is a totalitarian state and the other is an ally?
- orwin 6y agoBut for at least Portugal and Greece, and maybe Italy and some eastern European countries, the ally is china since 2014? While Obama made his move over SE Asia, the CCP applied the strategy they used in Australia with the PIGS. And while Trump very successfully destroyed what Obama tried to do in SE Asia, the CCP installed foreign military bases near center of trade in the Indian ocean while gaining political goodwill with middle east poorest countries. Most of Iraki oil is sold to China. I'm not claiming i know what should be done, i'm just saying that China have already a lot of political allies and try to gain more, and now reached europe.
- gberger 6y agoThe justification is that the equipment presents a national security risk. If that's true, how is it reasonable to allow this equipment to operate in the UK for 7 more years? Doesn't that mean the UK is willingly under national security risk for 7 years? Unless, of course, there was never a security risk...
- tomfanning 6y agoNot dissimilar to how face masks are being made compulsory in shops by the British government. In 11 days' time.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoAnd 2 days ago Gove said they wouldn't be compulsory. They are just panicking because of the economy (latest figures show a 20% crash).
- nicky0 6y agoFuture-dating it is a sensible move to allow people to get used to the idea, to disseminate the news, and to allow time to obtain the necessary equipment. It will increase compliance compared to an immediate rule change. Bear in mind that only about 5%-10% of people in UK currently are wearing masks in shops (based on my own local observations).
- ben_w 6y agoWhile that is true, these rules should’ve been brought in months ago. (Also: do people really need more than one week?)
- nicky0 6y agoMonths ago there were massive shortages of PPE and UK was largely in lockdown with most people only going out to exercise and to shop, not going anywhere else, and not seeing famliy, friends etc. Now the risk profile of things has changed because people are out and about more. But 11 days does seem a bit long, sure.
- elicox 6y ago2027? I guess to install 6G
- someperson 6y ago> UK's mobile providers are being banned from buying new Huawei 5G equipment after 31 December 2020
- est 6y agogood news, huawei just got bunch of 4G LTE Advanced++ gears to sell
- rdxm 6y agolol....by 2027....what's the point?! if you think your comm's infra is popped for real you don't sit around with your d* in your hands for 6 years!
- room271 6y agoThis kind of thing is going to play out a lot over the next few years. It's a tough question: how to marry globalisation with the political realities. When China was very poor, it didn't really matter, or perhaps the assumption was that China would liberalise more quickly than it has. But China, while increasingly mature economically, has not developed proper civil society, human rights, freedom of expression, democracy, and so on. Let us hope they do so as quickly as possible, not least for the sake of the Chinese people themselves. And let us work to improve our example and unity too in countries where we do have these things, however imperfectly.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoWhether China liberalise is a red herring. This is a geopolitical clash of power. It's not about respective political regimes, it's about relative power and influence. If China liberalises tomorrow none of the fundamental issues will change and China will still be a threat to the US. The only thing that will change is that the US will have to find something else in order to label China 'evil'.
- ahelwer 6y agoThis is a good analysis. You aren't seeing a constant drumbeat of bad China news because the US suddenly cares very deeply about Muslim lives - otherwise we'd be hearing a lot more about India, for example. China threatens the US' global hegemony. To the extent people in power care about China's political system, it is used to rope in liberals to an anti-China stance and manufacture consent for various measures against them, military or otherwise.
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoA trade war masquerading as national security concerns.
- msla 6y agoNo, the security concerns are real, given the TikTok example and so on.
- msla 6y agoAh, this is proof I struck a nerve!
- jaekash 6y agoReally this is a war of value systems masquerading as a trade war masquerading as national security concerns. I would much rather the west comes out and say this has nothing to do with national security concerns or trade or economics, but that there is no way the west can tolerate how the Chinese Communist Party conducts itself, regardless of how many people get rich from their immoral actions.
- pinkfoot 6y agoAt the risk of attracting the ire of the whataboutism nerds, value-systems are only 'values' and a 'system' when they are well-defined and consistently applied. So most of the planet will only buy thise elaborate line when Saudi Arabia and Pakistan get told to keep their riches.
- jaekash 6y ago> value-systems are only 'values' and a 'system' when they are well-defined and consistently applied. I get what you are trying to say but definitely a value system requires neither of those things. > So most of the planet will only buy thise elaborate line when Saudi Arabia and Pakistan get told to keep their riches. There is hypocrisy but the threat posed by China to the liberal world order is much more serious than the thread posed by Saudi Arabia and Pakistan, and in both those cases there is a bit of a deal with the devil. If the Saudi and Pakistani regimes fall we will probably see much worse things popping up.
- AdrianB1 6y agoTotal crap;either it is a security risk and it has to be removed yesterday or it is not. 2027 is meaningless.
- dogma1138 6y agoA potential security risk in a conflict with China doesn’t mean an existential eminent risk. That equipment is everywhere it will take years and cost billions to remove and replace. And yes there has been already pushback around it both in terms of demands to lower the time frame to 3 years and to increase it to 10.
- totalZero 6y agoThe date is a compromise between security concerns from the government and its allies, and business concerns from telcos that have already shelled out the cash to buy Huawei infrastructure.
- jaekash 6y agoDeferred action is better than nothing, but yes, I would prefer it happened immediately also.
- AdrianB1 6y agoI have no preference, I am questioning the rationale; if one can use the equipment for 8 more years, then it is safe enough to continue using it.
- IshKebab 6y agoThat's not how risks work.
- sixstringtheory 6y agoDo you buckle your seatbelt before you start driving or when you're 68% of the way to your destination?
- 6y ago
- neximo64 6y agoFollowing the German strategy I see. Just put things so far out they’re the next governments responsibility
- tzs 6y agoOr maybe the idea is to put it far enough out that no one actually has to start replacing equipment until the US has a new administration and they can see where that administration stands on China. If Trump gets reelected this year that will be his second term which is the limit, and so there will be a new administration in January 2025. If he doesn't get reelected there will be a new administration on January 2021.
- aphroz 6y agoWill the brexit still be in progress by then?
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoI'm constantly seeing westerners whine about Chinese human rights violations while simultaneously ignoring the HR violations occurring everywhere else, especially in the west. American cops routinely kill people. Yet, how many people have died in Hong Kong because of their protests? The notion that China lacks 'proper civil society' is in my mind rooted in a western sense of orientalism and good old fashioned racism. I'm no defender of China, but let's recognize that the same nations trying to punish China because 'human rights'(US, UK) are the same ones responsible for killing close to 1 million Iraqis and creating the largest humanitarian crisis on earth(Yemen).
- Nursie 6y ago> The notion that China lacks 'proper civil society' is in my mind rooted in a western sense of orientalism and good old fashioned racism. And this is good, old fashioned bullshit. Chinese citizens do not have the same rights and protections westerners do, nor a democratic system. They don't have the right to speak freely, congregate as they wish, protest or foment change in their own society. Western societies are imperfect, those rights are not protected or executed perfectly there. But they do exist, and the problems with them are orders of magnitude smaller than their total lack in China.
- FartyMcFarter 6y agoWhataboutism. China is literally running concentration camps to persecute religious minorities. This is happening at a huge scale and without any oversight on human rights.
- sbx25 6y agoI am really pissed. It's weird this showed up... i'm planning to apply for Y Combinator next deadline.. I just googled whataboutism Anyways Here is the reason i'm pissed: (I am user SeriousHyena in this thread) https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/black-girl-sent-to-juvie-because-she-didn%E2%80%99t-turn-in-her-homework-in-the-middle-of-the-pandemic.3710326/page-12#post-60148506 https://www.lipstickalley.com/threads/black-girl-sent-to-juv...
- 6y ago
- aaron695 6y agoGiven we've found zero proof that China has ever put backdoors in hardware. And the devastation to their economy if we did find backdoors which would forever poison Chinese electronics is a far greater security risk to them, than any advantage they may possibly get from implementing backdoors. I assume it's actually because 5G has to be found causing the Coronvirus and they are covering it up?
- LatteLazy 6y agoYou're right about back doors, but this is about (like it or not) supporting the US and sanctioning China without saying so (likely a good think because of coronavirus, HK, minorities, democracy, etc).
- rich_sasha 6y agoIf this is just Realpolitik/hardware independence, fine, but security..? Any worthwhile Internet traffic should be encrypted in 2020, and if it isn’t, Huawei probably isn’t the most immediate concern. And if it is encrypted, does it really matter who is listening? Comments welcome, I know zilch about telecoms hardware.
- cm2187 6y agoEven if everything was encrypted (which is not the case) and that encryption could not be downgraded by a mitm (which is not the case - cf starttls), it can still be used to track whereabouts, or disrupt the connectivity or utilise any mitm zero day. But a good question would be why 5g, and not every other computer chip in any computer and network equipment, which could be backdoored, and I doubt anyone verified the conformity of the chip to the blueprint sent to the factory.
- pas 6y ago5G is the line in the sand. It's basically the point of no return, we're fully and firmly in the "cyber era" or whatever we want to call it. Where (when) even the backup and disaster recovery plans are (at least partially) Internet dependent. Going forward this kind of infrastructure will probably be more important than any other kind (because this will control all the others too). Will this finally move the cost-benefit needle toward verifiable computing (open chips, open fabs, open *ware)? Who knows. But so far it seems the power brokers of the old era (eg. countries) are trying to maintain control.
- yodelshady 6y agoYou can't encrypt "metadata" that the machine needs to know to do its job, and with enough of that, you can de-anonymise any public posters. And you'll have metadata on (some of) their contacts too. Plus, if it's your tower, you can just switch it off, at an opportune moment.
- rich_sasha 6y agoOk, that’s fair enough
- einpoklum 6y agoThe UK shows itself again as a lap dog for the US.
- Spearchucker 6y agoWell because Brexit does the UK have much choice? No one survives alone. Not even China.
- einpoklum 6y agoNo longer will we Britons live under the iron heel of the Germans and the French! From now own we shall only grovel at the White House!
- mr_gibbins 6y agoWhat a short-sighted, backwards knee-jerk, racist reaction. If Huawei's 5G infrastructure had leaks allowing Chinese control it would more than likely be spotted by UK engineers. The application of controls as simple as IP whitelists or air-gapped systems helps ensure no leakage. Transparency of schematics and specifications means both Chinese and UK engineers get to see what's going on.
- kwistzhaderach 6y agoYes the UK is delaying their technology simply because they are ‘racist’
- catherd 6y agoWhat's the expected service life for that kind of network gear? Wouldn't most of it be gone or upgraded by then anyway?
- franklampard 6y ago4G lasted probably 5 years
- jk20 6y agoU.S. is just concerned that China, and not them, will get an edge in spying and the next industrial revolution. Speaking of human rights it should be noted that U.S. not only wantonly attacks or bullies other countries, but it also has the highest incarceration rate in the world - in absolute terms the number of inmates is comparable to that of China and India combined.
- msla 6y agoLiterally no country which fought the Nazis was completely moral. Should nobody have fought the Nazis?
- msla 6y agoDoes nobody have a counterargument to this?
- rashkov 6y agoRegarding your first point, yes, that’s an interesting take. Regarding the criticism of the US, yes you’re probably correct, but this is a “what about” argument that doesn’t really aid the discussion in my opinion.
- Barrin92 6y agoWhataboutism gets brought out too fast to dismiss discussion. Democratic systems project their values by demonstrating them. A democratic state that cannot show that its values work will have no ability to demand of others to emulate it. In that context the failures of the US (as it is de-facto the standard-bearer of political liberalism in a broad sense), have real influence. When the Chinese look around the world and they see the state of the US on imprisonment, racial conflict, failure during the current covid crisis and so on, this strengthens the domestic control of the party and the alternative autocratic system the government is advocating.
- Nursie 6y agoBut it is whataboutery. We're discussing why the UK might not want a Chinese state-allied (if not owned) actor embedded in its comms networks, and here everyone is saying "buh buh buh America!" And frankly if you look at what's happening with BLM (mass protest in the US over a pattern of racist police murders, significant parts of the country vocally criticising the apparatus of state) and consider that somehow worse than the semi-secret genocide of millions, with all discussion suppressed, going on in China....
- stephenheron 6y agoI would encourage people to read the NCSC blog post on this as it goes into technical detail on why the decision was made. https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/a-different-future-for-telecoms-in-the-uk https://www.ncsc.gov.uk/blog-post/a-different-future-for-tel...
- LatteLazy 6y agoSo at least park of the justification here is that we have to comply with Americas foreign policy?
- jaekash 6y agoSometimes USA still manages to do the right thing it seems.
- pqhwan 6y agoEffectively US is pulling US-made chip design tools from under huawei’s manufacturing process. Seems that the political calculus is that this will damage huawei’s standing, at the expense of global technological cooperation. But to what end? It falls short of providing Huawei (and the state behind it) with incentives to be more transparent with their technology, and at best creates a necessity for them to become wholly independent in their process. I guess the US is betting they can’t pull this off, but if they do, this policy has bought US nothing but a few years of suppression and a fiercer competition.
- melonkidney 6y agoAccording to [1], Huawei employs 1,500 people in the UK. I'm curious - if anyone from Huawei UK is reading, how is this news being perceived? [1] https://www.huawei.com/uk/facts/huawei-uk https://www.huawei.com/uk/facts/huawei-uk
- georgespencer 6y agoRe-posting a nested comment at top level for those who see incongruity in "national security risk" and "seven years to phase out Huawei": This is a good example of the kinds of tradeoffs which must be made at the highest levels of public service. Huawei, just like any Chinese corporation operating overseas, is an attack vector for intelligence gathering. Anyone presenting a counter-argument to this is either a shill for the Chinese government, or totally uninformed. China has a culturally distinct attitude towards intelligence and intelligence gathering to nearly every western country. The national emphasis on the collective good blurs the line between private citizens, acting in a personal or professional capacity, and the stereotypical impression of a "spy" perpetuated in the west: on the payroll, going to their cubicle at the CIA each day. China's voracious appetite for intelligence (and, particularly in recent years, industrial espionage), means that it is impossible to distinguish between the commercial interests of a Chinese company and the Chinese state furthering its apparatus. Remember Crypto AG? The Swiss crypto company jointly-operated by the CIA and German intelligence?[1] That's newsworthy because it's unusual: western states are typically limited to publicly lobbying their corporations for backdoor access, or working around things like end-to-end encryption (e.g. I believe PRISM used a combination of vulnerabilities to exfiltrate data from Hotmail and MSN prior to encryption taking place). In China, we must assume that the reverse is the norm: the Chinese government does not need to lobby its companies to provide it with data, or to build-in backdoors or exploits. A Chinese corporation can be compelled to turn over everything it has, silently, and to compromise users and products to benefit the Chinese government, silently. Crucially this is not a criticism of China. China can best be understood by Westerners as a series of tradeoffs to benefit the collective good, at the expense of personal liberty and privacy. Literally the argument you might encounter would be: "If you have nothing to hide then why do you care?" The information gathered is not always as exciting as you might imagine. It's not just deployed into military intelligence or kompromat. It might "just" be used as a means of preserving China's status quo as a leading manufacturing hub (and, therefore, China's position as a growing economic power). So China a) has a vast appetite for intelligence of all kinds, and b) does not draw a distinction between private citizens/corporations and state actors/corporations. To answer your question: Huawei has been a cornerstone of the UK's telecoms infrastructure for nearly twenty years, and in order to gain its foothold committed to allowing GCHQ full access to its codebase (HCSEC)[2]. The stipulation from Britain's intelligence community was that Huawei must not be allowed to have a monopoly position, or even a significant market share beyond a certain level. I am not familiar with the specific technical reason that Huawei at 70% vs. Huawei at 40% of the UK's telecoms infrastructure would represent a disproportionate increase in risk, but I believe it is likely to be related to resource constraints -- fuck me guys, GCHQ is having to actively monitor and review the code deployed across a double-digit % of our telecoms infrastructure from the starting position of "this is provided by a bad actor"! -- and the doomsday scenario that Huawei's position of market dominance would drive competition down, resulting in a choice to either have e.g. 7G with Huawei, or not at all (7G is a fictitious example, but you see my point). The UK is balancing the very real ongoing nightmare of monitoring Huawei's involvement in UK telecoms with the fact that it's a cheap, high quality supplier, and the fact that our closest allies -- the United States -- have been on a warpath over Chinese intelligence gathering since long before Obama put the kibosh on China acquiring Aixtron in Germany for national security reasons. Oh, and we want to get a trade deal out of the US in the near future. The risk:reward for Huawei is at a point where it's no longer sustainable. Phasing its removal from our infrastructure will smooth our relationship with our closest ally, reduce our reliance on a Chinese state manufacturer, and reduce the workload on our signals analysts in GCHQ. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/feb/11/crypto-ag-cia-bnd-germany-intelligence-report https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/feb/11/crypto-ag-ci... [2] https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/790270/HCSEC_OversightBoardReport-2019.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- jaekash 6y agoAnd we already know China has been backdooring other equipment: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-10-04/the-big-hack-how-china-used-a-tiny-chip-to-infiltrate-america-s-top-companies https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2018-10-04/the-big-h... So yes, this is a small victory in a massive war.
- enitihas 6y agoYou aren't helping your case by citing the Supermicro article, which was denied by both Amazon and Apple, led to widespread criticism of Bloomberg, and no source came forward.
- jaekash 6y agoCorporations getting rich off the CCP's action siding with the CCP is hardly surprising.
- disgu 6y agoBloomberg is not to be trusted when it comes to technology news. Seriously, they're absolutely incompetent. They called Telnet a secret backdoor. Their articles about China are annoying because they're either without any tangible proof whatsoever or simply factually wrong. There are other, better sources.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThis is fallacious thinking, if you already have biases that confirm or deny information in accordance with your conclusion. If you continue to apply different standards of proof you will end up with a distorted perception of the world. Maybe not in this subject (but maybe so), though certainly in many more.
- londons_explore 6y agoThe cost of that victory, according to the BBC, is a 1 year delay in the rollout of 5G tech. That's a pretty large economic cost. Bob can't watch his medical lectures on the train, so ends up behind in class, Mary's company looses a contract to a foreign competitor because she got frustrated with her bad VPN and didn't read over the bid one last time, Fred couldn't afford the cost of the new 5G contracts so didn't get much data and ended up losing touch with his friends who were all group video calling eachother. All these socio-economic costs cascade for decades or more. Do they really outweigh the theoretical ability for another nation to disrupt network traffic for a few hours until a mitigation is put in place?
- chosenbreed37 6y agoHonest question. Can someone explain why the comment below was flagged? I can see why some might disagree but I fail to see any problematic about any of the statements made. I think of HN as one of the few places were people can have open discussions where everyone is free to state their opinion and have it up for debate/rebuttal. "I disagree. Reports about China from many western media tend to exaggerate things about China, mostly influenced by western politics, not good at all. Also, western media tend to report selective facts to only show things they want people to hear and see. The right to life is the first clause of human right, which I see they are violated in many western countries. They refuse to treat the poor and old. Do you hear China criticise? Maybe they are, but for sure western media choose not to report them. Freedom of speech is a relative term in today’s world. I can say some of the things you shouldn’t say in China are equally not welcomed in many western countries. If you split US, see how many troubles could come to you? On democracy, I’m not sure what to comment. China has ran 4000 years under one empire system, and it’s just the culture there. Why democratic society is better than the 1 party system? What’s more important is to have the party represent people’s interests. In many democratic countries, each party represents the interests from certain groups, that’s why it’s necessity to have multiple parties perhaps. The downsides to democratic system is also quite obvious. There are countless debate on many small matters which waste tax payer’s money etc.. Also, the democracy can be manipulated, and if it is the case, it’s worse."
- poiuytrewqa 6y agoI'm new here and I faced the same issue in many topic not only related to politics. If your opinion is not following the sentiment of the majority then you can get down votes.
- Karunamon 6y agoBecause it is false equivalence of the highest order. - Yes, the US has a police brutality problem. (Though not near as bad) - Yes, the US has a government corruption problem. (Though not near as bad) That acknowledged: * At no point will you disappear in the US for criticizing the government. * At no point will you be placed into a concentration camp and tortured. * At no point will you be barred from participating in society because you lost points on a "social score" calculated on things such as following the wrong religion or criticizing the government. * At no point will you be subject to ethnic cleansing. * This list could be many times longer. The US is not a totalitarian police state and it is fundamentally dishonest, to the point of mendacity and/or trolling, to equate the two. There are no countries on this planet with entirely clean hands. All have committed abuses, all have fallen short. With the binary 1 and 0 off the table, that leaves us with a matter of degrees, and some countries objectively have worse human rights records than others. On top of all that, most of the posts like the one you quoted amount to whataboutism, or the tu quoque fallacy. This is an ancient trope. Soviet-era Russia tried it[1] too. The response to "China puts people that disagree with them into concentration camps" is not "But the US..", or "that's not fair because.. (it's not as if these accusations are unsubstantiated by fact)", the answer is "that is wrong and should be condemned". [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/And_you_are_lynching_Negroes
- violetyellow 6y agoSecurity flaw, sometimes may not root in technology side, but politics side. China is treating everything they own as a politics weapon now. 5G contract is a perfect weapon in this view. Telecom infrastructure is huge, and almost monoplied by the base infrastructure builder due to compatibility issues. Once Huawei finished the 5G base infrastructure, China can coerce UK by attach extra terms for maintaining, upgrading or selling 5G equipments. China has already used this approach on loans of asia investment bank. The countries which supports HK Security Law coincidentally matches with the countries which receives loans from investment bank. There may be more under water. Some may already exposed: (China's evil virus plan) https://www.foxnews.com/world/chinese-virologist-coronavirus-cover-up-flee-hong-kong-whistleblower https://www.foxnews.com/world/chinese-virologist-coronavirus... Some may still remains to be conspiracy theory: China increased production of hydroxychloroquine, in their reports (http://tn.china-embassy.org/chn/dtxws/t1787078.htm http://tn.china-embassy.org/chn/dtxws/t1787078.htm), they already used Chloroquine in treating their patients. However, WHO, FDA and even Lancet banned or announced inefficiency of hydroxychloroquine, and people died from this misinformation. What role did China play remains suspicious and mysterious.
- oliwarner 6y agoThis makes me nervous. If the last few years mismanagement of Brexit, privatising the NHS, "universal" credit, historic immigration renegs, the perpetually delayed reaction to Covid19, PPE procurement contracts going to zero-asset companies monetarily linked to Tory members and donors... Well... A large part of me hopes it's mere incompetence. But the bigger picture seems to be a party that —starting with May as Home Secretary— has been pushing harder and harder at knowing everything about everybody. Kicking out incumbent foreign hardware providers seems like a bloody good way to plant your own hardware in its place and achieve another level of control.
- BrandoElFollito 6y agoAll providers had their infamy moment at some point, leaving a backdoor behind. Maybe for spying, maybe because QA failed. Huawei is on the US radar but somehow when Cisco left a backdoor on some routers it was "just a mistake". Every country is guilty of stabbing in the back others (occasionally or all the time), it has been the case for centuries and is not likely to change. I am French, we do not have our own tech so we get stuff from everyone around - we are probably in the worst spot from that perspective.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoI've wondered how EU people feel about things like this. Euros have been inundated with "Americana" for the last 40 years or so. They watch TV shows about Americans, movies about Americans. They use American social media networks. It's like a culture-overload like USA is always "in your face". USA never had any problem with Skype as a Danish company being used by a significant number of Americans. But TikTok, a Chinese company, is stirring up national security issues.
- arp242 6y agoI think the issue is that the United States – for all its faults and Snowden leaks and whatnot – can still be trusted, somewhat, to do the right thing. There clearly are trust issues (for good reasons) but I would sure trust the US gov't more to not install backdoors in equipment private companies deliver to befriended foreign nations. China, on the other hand, has no clear separation between the state and large private companies, and has a state which does not acknowledge basic human rights in a myriad of ways. Again, the US is not perfect here either, but it sure is better. Personally, I wish Europeans would use more, well, European equipment for this kind of stuff. This isn't out of some nationalistic sentiment (I have no problems using foreign equipment as such), but given the state of the world's affairs and the direction I fear it might be heading, a strong and independent Europe will probably be more important than ever in the coming decades.
- DiogenesKynikos 6y ago
- mrbonner 6y agoIt is increasingly appears that the CCP government wants to confront every countries at the same time. First, I thought this was just the power struggle/grab between US-CCP economically. Then, it spread to the political issues like the South China sea claims which pisses off Viet Nam, The Philippines , Taiwan. The CCP even manages to engage India into its territorial issue resulted in sanction from Indian gov. In the north-east side, the CCP is irritating Japan to a point Japan is considering ramping up its army. If the CCP wants conflicts at least it needs to find allies, right? So why then it tries to piss off just about every countries it's surrounded by?
- cameldrv 6y agoMaybe they just feel that it's a good time strategically to push the envelope on multiple fronts while everyone is distracted by COVID.
- _jgdh 6y ago> it needs to find allies No shortage of Chinese allies - 70+ countries supported China's recent change to Hong Kong's laws (https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1193422.shtml https://www.globaltimes.cn/content/1193422.shtml). Certainly none of these countries are bastions of freedom - North Korea, Venezuela, Chad, Myanmar, Cambodia, Kyrgyzstan. But all of them support China to the hilt. Tanzania didn't even stop with an endorsement of the HK law, they also felt it necessary to mention that Taiwan is a part of China. Turns out Chinese loans go a long way in creating a sense of gratitude. All countries barring the US need China more than China needs them. And China only needs the US until it has semiconductors of it's own. The US and EU were asleep at the wheel these last 30 years - allowing China to grow powerful without also creating a counterweight like India. Now the world's dependence on Chinese manufacturing and Chinese consumption means that no one dares to criticise China, and there's no shortage of countries lining up to praise every action of Comrade Xi's. That's why China can screw over every neighbour, taking what they please. Who's going to stop them? Is Vietnam or Malaysia suddenly going to stand up to China? No, they will merely grumble. Is India willing to provoke an actual war? No, they will merely ban TikTok and call it a day.
- 6y ago
- dang 6y agoAll: HN has been seeing a dismaying increase in nationalistic flamewar. This is not allowed here. I know it feels important when you're caught up in the intensity of such feelings, but it is not interesting, which is what HN is for. Worse, it has the effect on interesting discussion that tank battles have on a city park. If you don't have something thoughtful and substantive to say, please don't post until you do. Drop denunciatory rhetoric—it's tedious and evokes worse from others. Remember that the community is divided on divisive topics and that the person disagreeing with you is probably not a spy, but just someone who disagrees with you. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dang 6y agoThis is a stub comment to collect replies in one place. That way we can collapse it and prevent too much offtopicness at the top of thread.
- echlebek 6y agoFWIW, I downvoted the GP comment, in hopes that it will not be the top thread in this discussion, even though I agree with the moderation.
- UnbugMe 6y agoIt's incredible how when its not China, you are always "its up to the community to decide". But when it comes to China, you go out of your way to freeze discussion. People like you are weak ass hypocrite pussies when it comes to China, you should be ashamed of yourself. Dan G you pussy ass communist appeaser, shame on you.
- toiletfuneral 6y agoLook I don't Dang either. I feel like he nukes all my class war against the rich posts, but you have to realize I have personally accused of him fostering a white nationalist site for promoting assholes like you and also for hiding all my pro-communist comments. So only one of us can be right, is dang a commie or nationalist?....or maybe everyone is complex and not entirely composed of a single ideology and also he was chosen to curate this website and that will ultimately anger both of us? Anyway, here's the tea :https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23400445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23400445
- alexnewman 6y agoCarrier maintenance modes still allow you to access the memory of the device and force screenshots to fire
- pilsetnieks 6y agoThis is about carrier equipment, not phones. In fact, phones are exempt from this decision.
- alexnewman 6y agoPlease re-read what I said. The carrier equipment can read the memory of your phone remotely dog. It's a "feature" in nearly all Qualcomm chips
- simonkafan 6y agoImpressive how much power the USA has over UK. It is known that Cisco has backdoors in their routers - and UK politics doesn't care. Now the Trump administration is spreading the rumor that Huawei hardware _might_ have backdoors (when the most plausible actual reason for this warning is to gain the upper hand in the trade war) and England is already putting the wish into action.
- fluffything 6y agoUK is in a weird spot now alone in the world out of the EU. The country is essentially for sale. China just needs to make the "right" political donations.
- puppymaster 6y agoThey did try and it wasn't enough. Or as you put it, wasn't the 'right' candidate. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2020/07/14/lord-browne-quits-huawei-uk-chairman-ahead-government-ban/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2020/07/14/lord-brown...
- coliveira 6y agoWe will end up like cavemen if we start to banish every new technology coming from China based on racism. China will not stop developing new technology just because the US doesn't like it.
- justwalt 6y agoI don’t think people dislike Chinese tech because it’s made by Chinese people, but rather because the Chinese government is assumed to have some hand in it. Best faith interpretation and all that, right?
- coliveira 6y agoTechnology has no political badges or flags. First of all, scientists and engineers are not political actors. Moreover, I have all the right to use a technology if I want it, even if it was developed in a totalitarian regime. For the US to prevent me from using this technology is infringing on my freedoms.
- thekyle 6y agoWhat freedoms does banning Chinese products infringe? I'm pretty sure that the national government has the right to control international trade in the same way that the state governments have a right to control interstate trade.
- newbie578 6y agoGet of your high horse. Scientists and engineers in China, are political actors. Everything done in china is political. And your right is superseded by national security, and good luck trying to find infringment on it. I for one am rooting to start boycotting the whole of China, until their communist regime which conducts genocide is forced to change and play humane and fair.
- dang 6y agoPlease stop posting flamewar comments. We ban accounts that do that. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- CodesInChaos 6y agoIf the protocols used for mobile networks were designed to be secure, most of the infrastructure couldn't do anything worse than a DoS attack. It'd still need some trusted servers for key management, but those could be standard hardware with relatively simple software.
- chopin 6y agoHow would that be in the interest of any government? Even in the most liberal democracies (I know of) there is a strong surveillance tendency.
- pedrocr 6y agoThat could be solved one layer up by just using Signal or similar for messaging and calls. Unfortunately voice over an LTE IP link is still quite unreliable compared to an actual call.
- electronWizard 6y agoIf China can cause a denial of service attack on a country by remotely bricking all the network infrastructure or even slowing it down to a degree, this would still be economically devastating at the least.
- Traster 6y agoI think there's a difference worth noting between subtle monitoring & coersion vs. a full out act of war. By the time China is trying to denial of service the UK's 5G infrastructure we've got other things to worry about.
- Swenrekcah 6y agoBut they don't need to dos the whole country, just interfere up to the point of plausible deniability. They could do targeted outages for some UK firm at a stratetic moment or something. Also in the case of an actual war, it's surely better to not have your entire nations communications under enemy control.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- godelmachine 6y agoGuys, just my lame thought but can’t differential privacy be legally enforced in every software on every digital device? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_privacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Differential_privacy
- haecceity 6y agoI think the issue is that things that can not encrypted because of protocol requirements is enough to be dangerous https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2014/05/ex-nsa-chief-we-kill-people-based-on-metadata https://abcnews.go.com/blogs/headlines/2014/05/ex-nsa-chief-...
- m3kw9 6y ago5 years serves 2 things, one is to show UK is with their partner US and two, 5 years is a long time for a punishment to be effective because so much policies can change(2 elections) during this, and China knows this isn’t really a big punishment.
- Huntsecker 6y agothere is so much talk on here that this is about security or that the USA has some hold over the UK. The one and only reason this has gone back to parliment to vote on and that it has been decided not to use Huawei is because due to the sanctions the US has placed on Huawei around procuring chips the UK has come to the conclusion that its not safe to use Huawei due to the risk that replacement devices might become an issue.
- benlumen 6y agoSomething I don't see many people talking about is how Openreach, the UK's main physical layer broadband provider, uses Huawei kit in the majority of its street cabinets and has done since FTTC VDSL was rolled out a decade ago. 5G is the tip of the iceberg with respect to the UK's communications infrastructure involvement with Huawei.
- WatchDog 6y agoWireless edge infrastructure is probably a higher value target than FTTC cabinet infra. You don't need lateral movement within the network to access it/enter your backdoor, it can provide you location information of people nearby, and bricking a wireless device denies service to more people than a FTTC cabinet.
- wyuenho 6y agoWorse, Hyperoptic gives everyone a terrible ZTE router lol
- dastx 6y agoNot sure about Hyperoptic, but CommunityFibre (gigabit FTTP) also uses Huawei routers (and presuming kit in the rest of their infra). I can hands down say, as much as it was a shit router, it still was better than the routers I've been given with any other provider.
- Deathmax 6y agoAt least for the two Hyperoptic installs I've had or seen in the past 2 years have been Tilgin routers (https://hyperoptic.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Tilgin-HG2381-admin-manual.pdf https://hyperoptic.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/Tilgin-HG2...) instead of ZTE routers.
- wyuenho 6y agoI think they've ran out of them a long time ago. I requested a non-ZTE that support 5Ghz last year. They didn't have any and they said they weren't ordering them anymore. Those Tilgin are probably old stock.