11 ms·
Covid-19: death rate is 0.66% and increases with age, study estimates
- eof 7y agoI’m no statistician, but I’m very doubtful of the numbers coming out of China. I’d be interested to see how this changes with any given countries data excluded. My suspicion is removing China’s would move the needle more than any other country.
- api 7y agoFor reference seasonal flu is around 0.1% and also increases with age, so Covid-19 is at least 6X as deadly as the flu. This article also doesn't mention lasting effects. I have seen reports of people with bad cases being left with lung damage but I have seen no statistics on this. Everyone is focusing on mortality so I wonder if they're bothering to collect this info. If it leaves a lot of people with pulmonary scar tissue that's a big deal.
- libertine 7y ago> If it leaves a lot of people with pulmonary scar tissue that's a big deal. I think it's simply to early, maybe in the next 1-3 years you can have a more precise picture. We don't know if people with pulmonary scar tissue will end up recovering, or if it's permanent damage (from what I've seen it will depend on many variables, age being one of them). Even for mortality rate, we need to see this through to collect unbiased data from USA and Europe.
- KozmoNau7 7y agoAccording to reports here, some patients need assisted breathing for upwards of a month, in some cases at >80% oxygen, to have a chance at making it.
- matwood 7y ago> I have seen reports of people with bad cases being left with lung damage Unfortunately this will be hard to know without more time. Bad respiratory diseases, and COVID-19 is one, can take months to fully recover.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoIt will likely fall to a lesser amount as testing rolls out to a larger sample size of the population.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoHere's a source backing my assertion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22787076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22787076
- rectang 7y ago> This article also doesn't mention lasting effects. The problem is ARDS: Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome. Some portion of the people who enter the ICU develop ARDS and typically need to be put on a ventilator. A large percentage (~40%) of those people die, and the many of the rest may be left with lasting effects. Here's a great video detailing the mechanism of ARDS: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPtH42Lnt_Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPtH42Lnt_Y COVID-19 patients who don't develop ARDS seem to have a much better long term prognosis.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoLooking at current US data I see Covid-19 deaths almost exactly 6x influenza & pneumonia deaths. And that's with flu being endemic but Covid-19 still not having done a lot to areas with little international travel. Once it's hitting those areas I expect it to be the #1 killer in the US.
- rurban 7y agoDepends on the country and the age pyramid. IFR in Italy is 1% fir the flu as well as for C0VID-19, so just 1x, not 6x higher. For Germany I got to 2x. Lung damage is of course a serious issue, yes. And ICU overload which does not happen with the normal flu.
- drcode 7y agoIt worries me that this study is relying on Chinese data.
- jonplackett 7y agoYeah, that seems foolish at this point. Italy is doing a reasonable amount of testing and has more like 10% death rate. Could there be 15X more infected in Italy than detected? Or is it that they have mostly old people catching it? Seems like a large discrepancy either way.
- Leary 7y agoMeanwhile Germany has a 1.5% cfr, how did that happen. Did Germany underreport deaths or Italy underreport cases
- virgilp 7y agoGermany tests a lot more, and started testing earlier. Italy got overwhelmed, for a very long while only tested suspected people (those that have fairly severe symptoms)
- ufo 7y agoFrom what I've read the lethaliy is higher both because they can't test enough people (meaning that they tend to only test the more severe cases) and also because the hospitals were overwhelmed (meaning they can't provide appropriate treatment for everyone).
- greedo 7y agoGermany's CFR has been steadily rising.
- endorphone 7y agoIndeed, today it is 1.5%. 7 days ago it was 0.75%. 14 days ago it was 0.375%. It has literally doubled each week.
- brenden2 7y agoThese numbers seem much more realistic versus the previous doomsday predictions of 3%. To compare this to base rates, the age adjusted base rate for deaths in the US in 2018 was about 0.7%[0]. Depending on how you look at it, this is either really bad (i.e., 6x worse than the flu) or not that bad (i.e., less deadly than death by any cause). 3% would have been really bad, that's more than 3x higher than the normal death base rate. [0]: https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db355.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db355.htm Edit: fixed wording for correctness.
- matwood 7y agoIt will be years before we get proper studies, but there are also going to be deaths caused by the COVID-19 situation. I'm about to take my wife to a clinic because she sprained her ankle. All of the nearby clinics have been converted to handling COVID-19 cases only, so we have to go to one much farther away. Luckily a sprained ankle isn't typically life threatening, but if it was, driving that much farther could have led to a negative outcome.
- macintux 7y agoNo matter how much I hide at home and don’t do anything risky, I can’t help but worry about things like appendicitis. Something that most days would be dangerous but manageable if I catch it in time, would be much worse right now.
- pedrocr 7y agoThis is similar to the best estimates we've had so far for the death rate with great care. Even then doubling the yearly deaths is still a very large event, and that's if we can flatten the curve enough that the health system copes. If not multiply the number by 5x.
- pen2l 7y agoThe comparison is meaningless and maybe anti-productive. What you're saying harkens back to political fights about what are the numbers. The first sentence of the article is: The overall death rate from covid-19 has been estimated at 0.66%, rising sharply to 7.8% in people aged over 80 and declining to 0.0016% in children aged 9 and under.1 Nearly 8% death rate for folks over 80 is pretty remarkable. If people out there start saying "it's just 0.7%! Less than the flu!" old people will not take the precautions they need to. Because of the contagiousness of this virus, it should be treated as the huge monster that it is by old folks.
- H8crilA 7y agoAssuming good coverage of ICU care. What is it if there's ~zero equipment available, at least when compared to the number of patients?
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI think there's plenty of reason to be suspect of Communist China's data. A case could be made that they underreported the numbers in order to subvert The West's preparation and response. Probably not a popular idea on HN, but that doesn't mean it's incorrect.
- eganist 7y agoThe tone behind chiefalchemist's comment is not appropriate ("Communist China" intends to evoke specific emotions, which doesn't have a place on hackernews). That said, while the citation for this is unlikely to be widely trusted, there is a kernel of truth here. Can't find a specific citation for the reason behind the underreporting, but the underreporting has been widely discussed, as has the misinformation campaign attempting to relocate the source outside Hubei. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/us/politics/cia-coronavirus-china.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/02/us/politics/cia-coronavir... In any case, I'd like to see more research that accounts for totals from only countries that are accurately reporting their data. Unfortunately, that might not be for a while until e.g. Iceland has a chance to give their numbers now that they're testing literally 1/8th of their population. As other comments have suggested, cruise ships could also be another good data source. Looking forward to constructive discussion on whether or not numbers from countries such as China and Brazil can be trusted.
- wolco 7y agoIt is how they count cases. How they refused patients in hospitals at some point. Other countries are playing games too. France only tests those in hospitals.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "Communist China" intends to evoke specific emotion. As. It. Should. China IS a communist based country. That is 100% fact. If the phrase evokes anything, it's a reminded for those who have forgotten. Thank you for proving my point. The naive are many. They need to be reminded.
- JadeNB 7y ago
- mhb 7y agoWhy is anyone interested in age independent of comorbidities? Yes - age and comorbidities are correlated. But wouldn't it be more helpful as an actionable guide to have statistics for death rate vs. comorbidity rather than, or in addition to, age?
- jschwartzi 7y agoAge is probably an excellent proxy for comorbidities.
- kobe_bryant 7y agonot when obesity varies so much geographically
- mhb 7y agoYes but that's not very helpful for a healthy 60 year old.
- jesseschalken 7y agoMost likely lack of data. NYC has data with deaths vs comorbidity but I haven't seen it for anywhere else: https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/imm/covid-19-daily-data-summary-deaths-04042020-2.pdf https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/doh/downloads/pdf/imm/covid-19-d...
- nopinsight 7y agoBased on Diamond Princess data, where almost everyone was tested, the lower bound of COVID19's IFR (Infection Fatality Rate) should be > 0.5% for many/most countries. This uses a data source independent from what the paper uses. Here's the calculation... Current Diamond Princess' CFR (Case Fatality Rate) is at 11 deaths / 712 infected = ~1.54%. Ten more are in serious/critical conditions, so it could increase. Since testing in DP was almost universal, IFR ~= CFR. DP's demographics is representative of > 30% of population of many/most countries. (See figure 1 here: https://wattsupwiththat.com/2020/03/16/diamond-princess-mysteries/ https://wattsupwiththat.com/2020/03/16/diamond-princess-myst...) Assuming no one in other age groups/health conditions in a country of interest dies (unrealistic) and everyone from Diamond Princess who is in severe/critical condition recovers (optimistic), population's IFR would be = 1.54%/0.3 = ~0.51%. Also, cases from Diamond Princess have received good care. If the healthcare system gets overwhelmed as has happened in many places, population's IFR would shoot up to multiple times as high. Thus, 0.5% is a lower bound for COVID19's IFR, unless a better treatment protocol/medication is invented. Alternatively, if there are successful measures to shield the elderly from getting infected, a region's overall IFR could be lowered.
- learc83 7y ago>DP's demographics is representative of > 30% of population of most countries. However no one under 70 died from what I've read. So we can only get an upper bound on CFR for people under 70.
- nopinsight 7y agoFor a country with ~10% over 70 years old, and assuming infection fatality rate of ~6% among those, then IFR would already be 0.6%. So suppose that what you've read is the current statistics, it does not contradict the calculation above. People 65 and over comprise >16% of US population, which is relatively young for a developed country. Here's US age structure: https://www.indexmundi.com/united_states/age_structure.html https://www.indexmundi.com/united_states/age_structure.html
- 7y ago
- JetBen 7y ago"The estimates, calculated by researchers in the UK, used aggregate data on cases and deaths in mainland China." The problem with this is that China lies about everything. The state dictates what "facts" should be released. So this research is based on junk. To get an accurate analysis, you need to use data from a more trustworthy country like the USA, Italy, or Spain. Don't truth anything that comes out of the autocracy of China.
- k__ 7y agoI would love to see the numbers for people with pre-existing conditions, smokers, alcoholics, etc.
- dboreham 7y agoThat doesn't really matter when the underlying problem is that your healthcare system went offline.
- crazygringo 7y agoLink to the actual paper: https://www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S1473-3099%2820%2930243-7 https://www.thelancet.com/action/showPdf?pii=S1473-3099%2820... Estimates are in the last column of Table 1 (page 5). These seem roughly in line with CDC estimates for the US, see e.g. the first chart in this article from 6 days ago which compares flu mortality rates with COVID-19 per age bracket: https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-compared-seasonal-flu-in-the-us-death-rates-2020-3 https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-compared-seasona... To the (many) commenters here dismissive of the paper -- because in a "foolish" way it relies on "doubtful" "suspect" "junk" "Communist" Chinese data making it "not worth the paper it's written on" (all quotes from other comments here) -- the authors specifically address "adjusting for demography and under-ascertainment". The fact that they came to results similar to US data, as long as their methodology wasn't cherry-picked, would seem to be a good sign. And remember -- The Lancet is one of the most prestigious medical journals in the world. They're not going to publish something "junk".
- Jabbles 7y ago> And remember -- The Lancet is one of the most prestigious medical journals in the world. They're not going to publish something "junk". Let's not resort to arguments of authority. They have, quite recently, published junk. https://retractionwatch.com/2020/02/27/lancet-journal-retracts-letter-on-coronavirus-because-authors-say-it-was-not-a-first-hand-account-after-all/ https://retractionwatch.com/2020/02/27/lancet-journal-retrac...
- JauntyHatAngle 7y agoThat appears to be a letter to the editor, not a paper though.
- endorphone 7y agoThis isn't a peer reviewed paper. It's an extremely brief summary piece based upon a complete absence of evidence and then suppositions. And to what the guy above said, the Lancet infamously published Wakefield's since debunked repeatedly claim that MMR vaccines cause autism. A paper that has literally led to many deaths.
- steve_taylor 7y agoThis is somewhat at odds with 21% of recorded outcomes so far having been deaths. There would have to be a hell of a lot of undiagnosed cases to bring that down to 0.66%.
- jchallis 7y agoWhatever the confusing data in this epidemic might say, there are unquestionably a hell of a lot of undiagnosed cases. 10x to 100x depending on your country's testing.
- jschwartzi 7y agoIceland tested their entire populace and found several people who tested positive but remained asymptotic while infected. Given that testing in most countries is limited to people who can get into their doctor’s office the people who get tested and who test positive have more severe symptoms. There are probably a lot of people who have it and are spreading it unawares.
- lsllc 7y agoIt wasn't "several people", it was an estimated 50% asymptomatic (based on sampling at least 5% of their population): https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/01/europe/iceland-testing-coronavirus-intl/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/01/europe/iceland-testing-corona...
- pezo1919 7y agoI'm always sceptical with people said to be asymptomatic. It might be asymptomatic for 3-28+ days. The existence of antibodies will be a better measure.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- herman_toothrot 7y agoWhere did you obtain the figure of 21% outcomes being death? I only ask because this does not coincide with any statistics I've read personally.
- grej 7y agoFrom the abstract: “The estimates, calculated by researchers in the UK, used aggregate data on cases and deaths in mainland China.” - Sadly this makes the paper not worth the paper it’s written on (or whatever the data traffic fees are to serve it)
- einarvollset 7y agoThe paper uses data from expatriated foreigners from mainland China, so likely a reasonable dataset.
- Cactus2018 7y agoFYI COVID-19 Cases by Age Grouping for Oklahoma State: https://coronavirus.health.ok.gov/ https://coronavirus.health.ok.gov/
- mabbo 7y agoLet's presume this death rate is accurate to within an order of 2- 1.33% to 0.33%. We can use that to do some interesting estimates on the true infection rate. https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ https://www.worldometers.info/coronavirus/ (trust it if you like) says that the USA has (as of 2020-04-05T15:13:00Z) had 9,119 deaths- and I was going to say 8,486 but I refreshed the page and it jumped to 9,119 because of course it did. 9,119 / 0.33% = 2,763,333 infections. 9,119 / 1.33% = 685,639 infections. But, we also have to consider that death isn't instant- so add in everyone who became infected in the last 5-10 days. That'll be a bigger number. The reported number of infections because of limited testing is 320,828. I think it's not unreasonable to say that probably 1m Americans have now been infected by this virus. And the longer ago this comment was made, the more likely that estimate is correct. Edit to add: I trust the number of deaths more than the number of infections because it's easy to say "don't come to the hospital to get tested if you don't need to" but it's hard to say "let's pretend that dead body died of something else".
- slovenlyrobot 7y agoIf you click into the per-country view on Worldometers you can see their sources. For example the current numbers for USA came from nyc.gov.
- nradov 7y agoThe trouble is that numbers are not being gathered in a consistent way in every country. It's not an apples-to-apples comparison.
- fnord123 7y agoSal Khan's excellent video on extrapolating the probable existing cases from deaths: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCa0JXEwDEk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mCa0JXEwDEk
- LorenPechtel 7y agoYou're assuming they have an accurate cause of death for everyone. In the absence of a Covid-19 diagnosis it will simply look like pneumonia.
- joncrane 7y agoI wonder how much the death rate for other diseases will rise due to an overwhelmed heath care system.
- animalnewbie 7y agoYou quote communist as if it was somehow wrong to blame communism (and the associated authoritarianism) for their purported lies.
- DangitBobby 7y agoThey quoted communist as if it were a quote from other comments in the thread... And plenty of "Democratic" countries such as North Korea have authoritarian regimes. It seems that without significant effort or intervention that governments can become authoritarian regardless of their purported underlying system of governance.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoChina isn't communist anymore.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads into nationalistic flamewar hell. They don't come back out. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22785907 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22785907. Edit: we've banned this account for breaking the site guidelines repeatedly. Please don't create accounts to do that with. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- avsteele 7y agoIt relies critically on estimating the number of asymptomatic cases. To do this accurately you need either the PCR test to report a positive for a long time after contraction, or you need a serology-based test. They are basing the asymptomatic case % from the Diamond Princess data and assuming that all people who tested positive where the only ones who had cornavirus. Is this warranted? Has anyone seen any data on the period of time after contraction during which the standard PCR test will return positive?
- LatteLazy 7y agoFatality rate with treatment is basically irrelevant at this point. We need to know the hospitalisation rate, the ventilation rate and R0 under different levels of lockdown. The actual rare of deaths will depend on these numbers, 0.66% is just the baseline.
- badfrog 7y ago> It reported that 0.04% of 10-19 year olds would probably require hospital care—as would 1.0% of people in their 20s, 3.4% of people aged 30-39, 4.3% aged 40-49, 8.2% aged 50-59, 11.8% in their 60s, 16.6% in their 70s, and 18.4% of those over 80. This is quite a bit lower than the 20% number that people have been using for while.
- arrty88 7y agoFor medical professionals, do they suffer worse because they come in contact with many variations / mutations of the same virus?
- iQuercus 7y agoAt the cellular level it’s a numbers game. The more enemy combatants, the sicker you will be. The more exposure to the virus, the more viruses you’ll have in your body, the more intense the symptoms. Hospitals don’t have great access to fresh flowing outside air. So as they fill up with infected people the air just becomes a cesspool of virus.
- sam_goody 7y agoI have seen many articles with similar thoughts - that the death rate of Covid is < 1%, similar or less than the flu and other well known viruses. But, anecdotally, two close associates have died of Covid, and a neighbor is now on life support. May he get better soon! I (fortunately) have not heard of anyone even being put into a life-threatening position by Flu. Asking a few friends, their experiences match mine, though the victims differ. Can someone with more understanding explain - are we just the exceptions, or is there some reason that the anecdotal evidence is so far different from the numbers?
- theferalrobot 7y agoAgain maybe just an anecdotal outlier but I know quite a few people that have died of the flu, from a couple kids when I was young to some of my elderly relatives.
- learc83 7y agoLess than 1% is still much higher than the the flu. But the flu kills tens of thousands per year in the US alone, so it's fairly common.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoUnder 1% is still far above the flu. And note that parts of Italy have excess mortality of 1% of the population even though most of them aren't listed as Covid-19 deaths.
- thebruce87m 7y agoDo you have links to data for excess mortality? I’m struggling to find any localised data. Here is country wide mortality data: https://www.euromomo.eu/index.html https://www.euromomo.eu/index.html
- dboreham 7y agoCommon flu does not have a ~1% CFR. More like 0.1%. So those articles are (deliberately?) wrong. If you mean "less than the 1918 flu", then yes you're right.
- Alex3917 7y agoYour death rate is roughly double your 10 year mortality. So if you're in your mid 30s and your risk of dying at any time over the next 10 years is 0.2%, then your risk of dying if you get Covid-19 is 0.4%.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- loftyal 7y agoThey haven't done any widespread testing, they need to do complete antibodies tests. how is it possible to know it
- winddude 7y agoGreat who gives a fuck. The R0 is high 2-3. And the case fatality rate is 21% in the world, and 65% in the US.
- yread 7y agoAnother lower bound on death rate estimated from Bergamo (of total population): 0.44% 4500/1112187 https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=it&u=https://www.agi.it/cronaca/news/2020-04-01/coronavirus-eco-bergamo-stima-morti-8070220/&prev=search https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=it&u=https:/... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Province_of_Bergamo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Province_of_Bergamo