24 ms·
50% – 75% of cases of Covid-19 are asymptomatic
- sfj 7y agoGoogly translation: https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?depth=1&nv=1&rurl=translate.google.com&sl=auto&sp=nmt4&tl=en&u=https://www.repubblica.it/salute/medicina-e-ricerca/2020/03/16/news/coronavirus_studio_il_50-75_dei_casi_a_vo_sono_asintomatici_e_molto_contagiosi-251474302/%3Fref%3DRHPPTP-BH-I251454518-C12-P3-S2.4-T1&usg=ALkJrhjf5jbEmuELu9C0C1rvhLi7PpCuHQ https://translate.googleusercontent.com/translate_c?depth=1&...
- xupybd 7y agoThat sounds like the perfect way for a disease to spread. Do nothing to most.
- uoaei 7y agoIf you've ever played Plague, Inc. you will find eerie similarities.
- DeonPenny 7y agoIts cause it's completely accurate trust me I've been playing it. Also the Corrupted Blood virus from world of warcraft.
- Mirioron 7y agoI wonder if games had more mechanics like that whether people would become more aware of how to handle a disease outbreak.
- DoofusOfDeath 7y agoYou just convinced me to move to Greenland.
- abiogenesis 7y agoThe best evolutionary strategy for a virus is to not cause any disease at all.
- lovecg 7y agoBetter still, it would make the host feel unusually social.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoToxoplasmosis.
- thinkingemote 7y agoThere is a paper that showed that the flu virus makes people more socialable. It was done with students who took flu vaccine. They found people socialised more after they had the vaccine (and thus, were a little bit infected) compared to before. A literature review looked at the study and came up with the negative explanation - that people felt more secure or relaxed after getting the vaccine as they felt safer. Or were more nervous about needles before. Ancedote: I think I have covid-19 and the days before symptoms I felt unusually anxious to get outside and amongst fellow humans. I'm usually an introvert and stay inside mostly so it was notable. Suggestion: Online interview people with symptoms now to collect data on peoples behaviour in the days before symptoms showed, when they were infected but not showing, compared to 2 weeks before.
- rabidrat 7y agoA vaccine does not make people "a little bit infected". Vaccines are deactivated virii, so your body develops the antibodies, without any actual infection.
- Gibbon1 7y agoThat's not totally true the live Polio Vaccine used a live weak infectious virus. Which had the advantage of conferring immunity to unvaccinated people. At the expense of very rarely reverting and causing full blown disease. Far as I know it's no longer being used because of that.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoIt seems like the less deadly a virus is, the higher the total kill count. Ebola was so much more deadly but it killed people quickly or at least kept them in bed. Covid-19 lets people walk around for weeks without even knowing they have it.
- pabo 7y agoYes. This sounds astonishing, and really explains the expansion we see in Italy and other countries. I live in Hungary, where health care workers don't get (enough) protective wear, the health care system is neglected since decades, and government is not willing to communicate clearly. Also, most of the people who should be tested are not tested, because of the "protocol". I fear this, and the rate of asymptomatic cases will lead to a deadly mixture here.
- discordance 7y agoReminds me of old malware that used to destroy their host, which then evolved to dormant malware that didn't disrupt the host PC to evade detection.
- globular-toast 7y agoDo nothing to everyone. The virus doesn't benefit from killing its host. Quite the opposite, in fact. Successful viruses keep their hosts alive. Think influenza, rhinovirus, herpes etc. Viruses that kill tend to be ones that crossed the species barrier (ie. we're not the original hosts).
- jader201 7y agoIn case this thread doesn’t gain momentum, some more (potentially interesting) discussion on Reddit [1]. Particularly this post [2]: > I wonder if they plan to follow up and monitor... From the Diamond Princess they initially found 50% of people had no symptoms. However upon following them over the course of weeks that dropped down to about 18%. Due to the long incubation period it can take some time to determine if someone is truly asymptomatic or just not symptomatic yet. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fjuj24/5075_of_covid19_cases_are_completely_asymptomatic/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fjuj24/5075_of... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fjuj24/comment/fkpkiac https://www.reddit.com/r/Coronavirus/comments/fjuj24/comment...
- hooloovoo_zoo 7y agoHow reputable is this paper?
- arthens 7y agoVery. Repubblica and Corriere are the two main newspapers in Italy, and they are both quite reliable. Repubblica is left leaning, Corriere is right leaning.
- olliej 7y agonot super surprising - plenty of other diseases are similar. Even serious things like HIV are contagious for a long time while being completely asymptomatic.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoAsymptomatic for the entire duration of infection? That sounds bad for reducing R but good for the health of the individual.
- mkagenius 7y agoI would assume that asymptomatic person has a lesser concentration of virus and hence would be less contagious than the really sick ones
- pabo 7y agoUnfortunately that's not necessarily the case. I don't have the reference, but I read somewhere that asymptomatic patients may have even larger amounts of the virus, compared to symptomatic people.
- alexanderhorl 7y agoAt least asymptomatic patients wouldn’t cough around like symptomatic ones do. They’d "only" spread through talking.
- Mirioron 7y agoThis isn't necessarily true. The big symptoms of almost any infectious disease are actually the body's response to the disease rather than being caused by the disease itself. Things like fever, cough, runny nose are usually (very very often) caused by the body to help fight the infection, rather than the infection itself causing them. This means that not having these symptoms isn't necessarily indicative of not having the disease or having less of it. Sometimes the body doesn't respond right.
- kalleboo 7y agoIf you're asymptomatic, you're not coughing droplets everywhere, which ought to make you less contagious
- tomp 7y ago
- DeonPenny 7y agoWe've known this for a while. Everyone will get it. You might have it now. Nothing will happen. Still, quarantine for a while because you'll give it to an older person or kid. This isn't about a 20-something year old getting sick. Let your anti-bodies make yourself non-contagious. We are all kindergartens and this is chickenpox basically.
- chance_state 7y agoI don't want to spread misinformation here, but u thought I had read several times that children are almost immune from symptoms but can still carry it.
- DeonPenny 7y agoYeh but like babies. Or really sickly people.
- alkonaut 7y agoNot even babies, and of thousands of small children I'm sure there have been those exposed that have all kinds of diseases such as severe asthma, diabetes, heard conditions, cystic fibrosis etc. Luckily it seems that small children either don't contract the illness at all, or do so with little to no symptoms.
- nostromo 7y agoCorrect. Not a single child fatality worldwide. This is very different than Spanish Flu and even the regular flu.
- abiogenesis 7y agoThere is one 14 year old who sadly died, but yes, it is close to zero.
- BiteCode_dev 7y agoIf everyone will get it as you say, the elders will too.
- username90 7y ago"Everyone we found to have Covid-19 had serious symptoms, so we don't want to waste money testing you if you don't!" I feel this is a trillion dollar mistake, testing more aggressively like South Korea means that you don't have to deploy the army and quarantine people. I had mild symptoms and they refused to test me, what am I to do? Self quarantine without a notice and hence without pay? I could work from home, but most can't so they will just go to work as normal and spread it. And now it is all over the world so only drastic measures will help.
- trymas 7y ago> Self quarantine without a notice and hence without pay? If you have symptoms of _any_ illness you should always get a sick leave and stay at home. It does not matter if it's covid, seasonal flu or just a common cold - sick leave and stay at home.
- uluyol 7y agoUnfortunately this is not an option for many people. I don't disagree with the sentiment - avoiding the spread of disease is good - but often the reward systems in place don't optimize for the best global outcomes.
- ta999999171 7y agoSo why do we keep accepting these conditions?
- nordsieck 7y ago> So why do we keep accepting these conditions? Probably because the negative repercussions of that behavior are typically not very severe.
- maigret 7y agoThey actually cost a lot of money to businesses, but no one cares to track to show the ugly truth. Europe has a lot of data showing that going to work sick ends up costing much more than staying home, thus this is a irresponsible attitude - given you keep getting your pay of course.
- nostromo 7y agoI wonder if this will be like H1N1. At first we only identified extreme cases and we had these terrifying reported fatality rates. Then we identify more and more mild or asymptomatic cases and the rates drop and drop. We’ve already seen how CFR was reported as 3 or 4%. Then on the cruise ship full of people over 60 it’s 0.7%. If there are lots of mild or asymptomatic cases it will likely be much lower. H1N1 was identified as having a scary 0.4% CFR early on and was later found to be much lower, but we didn’t know until after the fact. An example report from 2009: https://www.who.int/immunization/sage/1.Briand_epi_7th_July_2009_(rev_6July_09).pdf https://www.who.int/immunization/sage/1.Briand_epi_7th_July_... In the end it may have killed over half a million people in 2009 - but for some reason people barely noticed. (Tangent: I wonder if it’s partly the changing media landscape from 2009 to 2020.)
- jamesrcole 7y agoCFR, whatever it is, isn’t the most significant detail. What is “terrifying” is its high contagiousness combined with its high hospitalisation and ICU rates.
- dragonwriter 7y agoYeah,and the high hospitalization and ICU rates become high case fatality rates once medical infrastructure is saturated, as well as increasing the case fatality rate for every other condition that creates a critical need for inpatient care. That's where Italy definitely is, and where it seems Iran is evn moreso (though they are less public about it.)
- 12elephant 7y agoWhat no one is talking about is how much social distancing/isolation is needed to avoid hospital saturation. I ran the numbers for Canada, and it looks like we'd need isolation measures for 2+ years. I don't see how that's a feasible solution long-term.
- Loughla 7y ago
- allovernow 7y agoDoes that mean 25-50% are severe? Is this a bimodal distribution?
- alexanderhorl 7y agoProbably not, the other 25-50% get symptoms of which 80% are mild and 20% severe.
- confeit 7y ago> "The vast majority of people infected with Covid-19, between 50 and 75%, are completely asymptomatic but represent a formidable source of contagion". The Professor of Clinical Immunology of the University of Florence, Sergio Romagnani > Asymptomatic infection has been reported, but the majority of the relatively rare cases who are asymptomatic on the date of identification/report went on to develop disease. The proportion of truly asymptomatic infections is unclear but appears to be relatively rare and does not appear to be a major driver of transmission. https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-china-joint-mission-on-covid-19-final-report.pdf https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/who-chi... > Clinical and epidemiological data from the Chinese CDC and regarding 72,314 case records (confirmed, suspected, diagnosed, and asymptomatic cases) were shared in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) (February 24, 2020), providing an important illustration of the epidemiologic curve of the Chinese outbreak. There were 62% confirmed cases, including 1% of cases that were asymptomatic, but were laboratory-positive (viral nucleic acid test). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK554776/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK554776/ Weird discrepancy on the order of 75x. I'd love to trust the experts, but who? I am leaning towards truly asymptomatic spread being rare, since you get infected by SARS-CoV-2, not COVID-19 (COVID-19 is the disease), the level of uncertainty of 25% is higher than for other reports, and the main reported mode of transmission is through symptomatic cough droplets.
- endogui 7y agoThe Italian number (75%) comes from testing everyone in a village of 3000 people. The Chinese number (1%) comes from testing everyone who comes to hospitals and maybe their family members. I would guess that the Chinese sample was selected for people displaying symptoms (asymptomatic people will not go to the clinic), while the Italian number biases for people early in the course of the disease. For the purposes of public health and controlling disease spread, the Italian number is more meaningful. Note also that it is possible the virus has evolved to spread more easily, which in the context of a lot of screening and social distancing of symptomatic people would mean more asymptomatic spreading.
- lgats 7y ago
- lend000 7y agoI'm not a confirmed case, but I'm a 90% sure case based on symptoms and symptoms of people I have been in close contact with, and so far the experience has been relatively mild, in the literal sense. The primary discomfort has likely been the anxiety of how the tightness in my chest might progress (which ironically can also cause chest tightness). I'm in a low risk group. I had lethargy and high fever the first day of symptoms (a little over a day after high contact exposure to my suspected source), then no fever (or very mild fever, can't tell because I have no thermometer), dry eyes, consistent mild chest tightness and occasional cough for the following two days (to present). The person I believe I contracted it from is also in a low risk group and had a sore throat and persistent cough for about 5 days, and is currently asymptomatic. She had been going about her business thinking it was just a cold for the duration of her symptoms. Testing is still difficult in my area, and many folks with mild symptoms like the aforementioned aren't even attempting to get tested, so I suspect the true numbers are about 10x-50x the reported confirmed cases. This is good in that it means the death rate is also off by that factor, but bad in that there will not be enough fear/incentive for the primary carriers (young adults) to adhere to adequate social distancing. It's an unfortunate externality when an infectious disease has discriminatory consequences.
- mtsr 7y agoMean incubation period is 5.6 days (range 1-14). So while possible, it’s highly unlikely you got it 1 day after infection.
- lend000 7y ago"Mean" means nothing in the context of probability distributions. It's possible I picked it up elsewhere, and less likely that I have something else with these unique symptoms (I've never a had fever without nasal congestion or gastrointestinal symptoms before). However, I think it makes sense I would be at the lower incubation period range due to the high level of contact with said suspect and the fact that I'm an otherwise healthy young adult, which as I understand it can lead to the immune system reacting faster.
- 7y ago
- jopsen 7y agoInteresting, but it doesn't change the fact that health systems are overwhelmed. If the rate of hospitalization is 15-10%, lockdowns seems the only realistic option.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- merricksb 7y agoAnother thread about a Chinese study on this topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22598803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22598803
- GreaterFool 7y agoI keep hearing “masks are useless”. If every person who has any cough or any chest tightness or any sore throat, however mild, put on a mask, wouldn’t that stop the spread? I live in Japan. It started here earlier but didn’t explode. Nothing is closed. Business as usual. everyone wears masks. Most cases in Hokkaido. Maybe because it is much colder there and easy to overexposed and tax the immune system.
- kevingadd 7y agoI think some of the logic behind "masks are useless" is that if people believe masks will prevent it, they'll get too reckless about going out as long as they have a mask. Sadly many people wear masks incorrectly and other people will wear masks that don't actually block viral particulates while out there acting more dangerously than otherwise, spreading disease. IIRC anything below N95 isn't going to do much, and from experience (yay wildfires) I can say wearing N95s is very uncomfortable. Incidentally even physicians wearing proper PPE (n95 or better, etc) can still catch COVID, so it wouldn't be appropriate to say that those are good enough. It's certainly better than nothing - I'd prefer it if everyone out and about was wearing masks - but the risk of false security leading to dangerous behavior is strong, and we already have issues with mask supplies, so it makes sense to discourage it.
- himinlomax 7y ago> I think some of the logic behind "masks are useless" is that if people believe masks will prevent it, they'll get too reckless about going out as long as they have a mask. Lying to people for their own good may be acceptable in some circumstances, but in the long run it's always going to have deleterious effects. It erodes trust, it disincentivizes responsible people, and if the people doing the lying are wrong ... it makes things worse.
- krzat 7y agoThat's very convoluted reasoning. I think the main goal of surgical masks for entire population would be to limit amount of virus floating in the air. They are also good at stopping people from touching their faces. IMO the goverments should make masks mandatory, even if it's DYI mask made from few layers of tshirt. And start teaching people how to use them and why.
- GreaterFool 7y agoHere’s another question: isolation... and then what? Sit at home until 2021 when we maybe have a vaccine? I don’t see how we make this virus disappear so while I can see how people staying at home can stop the spread, what happens when they leave? Back to square one? Maybe UK approach is better. Maybe we should infect young people deliberately. Here’s Netflix, some books, some video games, some virus, stay at home for 2 weeks. Build up herd immunity. Get a paper, move on. That’s UK approach except they wait for clusters to pop up. Why not make them? Control the infection rate. If the chances are everyone gets infected would be better to chose when!
- smichel17 7y agoIsolation is too slow the spread. Let the currently sick people get treated, then let the next wave of people catch the virus, once the hospitals have more capacity again. The virus is not that dangerous (under 1% fatality) as long as the healthcare system does not collapse.
- spookthesunset 7y agoIt really bothers me to see comments like this get buried. The comment asks a perfectly valid, well articulated question. How long can these lockdowns continue before their costs outweigh their befits? It should be safe and okay to question and criticize the actions society is taking right now. Groupthink is its own form of a virus and can be just as destructive, if not more destructive than a physical virus.
- robocat 7y agoYet another full population study estimates: “We estimated the asymptomatic proportion at 17.9%” - https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.20.20025866v2 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.02.20.20025866v...
- adam-a 7y agoI read this study and the recorded figure is around 50%. They're using some probability estimation based on the 50% discovered cases to account for people who had mild symptoms but not at the time they were tested (potentially after they left the ship). They identify flaws in the study though: the passengers were mostly old, so they are more likely to be symptomatic. They also didn't test everyone on the boat, only vulnerable, or symptomatic people, so their base numbers are missing some number of asymptomatic cases. It's not a perfect study and I think you could take 19% as a low bound on the figure and in wider society 50% is plausible.
- bronzeage 7y agoIf a virus takes a week to develop symptoms, and doubles every 3.5 days, that's exactly what do you would expect: after a week 3/4 of the cases are new and too early to detect symptoms. asymptomatic proportion sampled at a moment grows exponentially with incubation period, it means nothing about who will eventually develop symptoms.
- xenonite 7y agoThe original source of the linked article is a letter by Prof. Sergio Romagnani, sent to the newspaper Corriere Fiorentino, published here on March 15: https://corrierefiorentino.corriere.it/firenze/notizie/cronaca/20_marzo_15/dobbiamo-cambiare-rotta-ef23a500-669a-11ea-a40a-86d505f82a96.shtml https://corrierefiorentino.corriere.it/firenze/notizie/crona... As follow-up, they interviewed him, published on March 17: https://corrierefiorentino.corriere.it/firenze/notizie/cronaca/20_marzo_17/tamponi-tutti-bivio-adesso-cominciamo-ospedali-edb36ab4-682c-11ea-8372-e06aa5c607e8.shtml https://corrierefiorentino.corriere.it/firenze/notizie/crona...
- chimprich 7y agoVery interesting, thanks. Translation of the follow-up article: https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=it&tl=en&u=https%3A%2F%2Fcorrierefiorentino.corriere.it%2Ffirenze%2Fnotizie%2Fcronaca%2F20_marzo_17%2Ftamponi-tutti-bivio-adesso-cominciamo-ospedali-edb36ab4-682c-11ea-8372-e06aa5c607e8.shtml https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=&sl=it&tl=en&u=htt...
- vannevar 7y agoIt's a largely academic question, at least in terms of mortality and treatment. If you're asymptomatic, you're unlikely to get tested, and you'll never even know you had it. On the other hand, if you have enough symptoms to be tested, you have a higher mortality risk than asymptomatic cases by definition, so the overall mortality rate doesn't matter to you anyway. Where it does matter (a lot) is in containment, where we should assume many more people are contagious than the reported cases, so the average individual risk of catching it is much higher.
- nscalf 7y agoI saw a discussion of this on reddit, there was NOT info on if these individuals eventually developed symptoms, so take this with a grain of salt.
- warabe 7y agoI live in Japan and I experience mild symptoms since last Wednesday but not sure if my symptom is due to Covid-19. In Japan, You have meet two conditions to take a CPR test. 1. the symptoms with fever of 37.5 degrees or more continue for 4 days or more (for the eldery and those with underlying disease, "4 days" becomes "2 days") 2. you have strong laxity (malaise) or breathlessness (dyspnea), or you have underlying diseases (diabetes, heart failure, respiratory diseases (such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease)) I don't meet the first condition, so I was refused to take a test, but I still have chest tightness and consistent coughing. I wonder where the number "37.5" comes from, and 4 squeal days!? If the article in question is true, these two conditions are totally meaningless. So why is taking a PCR test so hard in Japan? Most people believe it is due to Olympic. The Japanese prime minister, Shinzo Abe, still believes we can hold Olympic as planned at this point. To that end, they want to hide the case of infection as possible. I feel strong anger towards my government since they care more about Olympic than human lives. At this point, Olympic will be inevitably postponed. I hope my government is smart enough to loosen the conditions and let people to take PCR tests immediately…
- johnohara 7y agoThe symptoms you describe are very similar to those articulated by these two CoV patients who were aboard the Diamond Princess cruise ship which docked in Japan. Here is their vlog on youtube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2E1t3yMXgE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2E1t3yMXgE The husband describes his experience with temperature and thermometers in the first 5 minutes. The similarity to your symptoms begins at ~ 5:00. This whole video is worth an investment of 38 minutes. 5M+ views.
- leftyted 7y agoSounds like the government is correctly rationing tests. My sense is that the vast majority of the healthy population shouldn't get tested even if they might have the virus because the infrastructure doesn't support widespread testing (anywhere -- as far as I know). They should act as if they have the virus and stay home, rest, drink a lot of water, and take NSAIDs if the pain gets out of hand. I've been sick since last week (much improved yesterday and today) and it could definitely be covid-19. But there's no point in trying to get tested. If I felt the symptoms were serious (significant difficulty breathing) then I'd go to an ER or call 911. Also, 37.5 is a fairly low fever.
- willart4food 7y agoSo, how do I know if I am one of those asymptomatic cases?
- timbit42 7y agoAssume and act as if you are.
- andrewseanryan 7y agoThis article on hacker news a couple of days ago could explain a lot of this. There is a possibility that a very large number of the asymptomatic positive tests are in fact false-positives. This could be good news for the world, but I'm not betting on that yet. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32133832 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32133832.
- postalrat 7y agoWouldn't it be great news if so many are asymptomatic or mild? It might explain why China seems to have so few current cases given its population. Maybe many people have already caught it and now have some form of immunity.
- andrewseanryan 7y agoI suppose you have a point there. I was thinking that it could be bad that so many are spreading without knowing it. Also, if many are asymptomatic, and the test is creating a large number of false-positives for those that are asymptomatic, there is a chance that this crisis is not as big as we think it is. Let's hope...
- 013a 7y agoDuring the US coronavirus task force briefing just an hour ago, one of the heads of the HHS suggested (without outright saying) that one of the reasons (just one of them) the US is lagging on testing is because they're concerned about the efficacy of tests other countries are running. High false-positive and false-negative rates were both mentioned, in "tens of thousands of tests" distributed to other countries. There's an underlying truth to this disease that no one has a grasp on right now, and the only way we get to it is the widespread execution of accurate tests. That doesn't happen quickly. Just think about that the next time you feel mad about our testing situation; a core doctrine of medicine (at least in our country) is First, Do No Harm. Telling someone they're infected, when they're not, is doing harm. Telling someone they're clear, when they're not, is doing harm. Enacting policy based on numbers derived from a bad test is doing harm. And, most importantly, the single thing that represents the entire point of the doctrine: doing nothing is not doing harm.
- medbrane 7y ago>because they're concerned about the efficacy of tests other countries are running. That's rich. I understand that the US developed test had a lot more issues that the standard not-invented-here one. And a lot of countries do the test twice, and only act on double positives or double negatives. >doing nothing is not doing harm How can this be OK? People will spread it if they think they are not sick.
- 013a 7y ago> And a lot of countries do the test twice, and only act on double positives or double negatives. The false-positivity or false-negativity of a test is not independent across multiple runs. Its not like each test rolls a dice and decides if it wants to be accurate or not. Its more accurately based on the human being tested; a false-positive test for one human would increase the likelihood for a subsequent false-positive test on that same human. Double-testing helps, but its not the solution. > How can this be OK? People will spread it if they think they are not sick. First, do no harm. This often means the first response for doctors is to do nothing (and gather information), until they're certain enough that their actions will not result in harm. Doing nothing is not causing harm; the harm has already come to their patient. The doctor is not the cause of that harm; the world caused it. Its a core responsibility of a doctor to not make it worse accidentally. Sure, people may spread it if they think they're not sick. But what if a doctor provides a false-negative result to an asymptomatic patient? Now, that patient has been told by a doctor "you're fine". They go back to work. Now, they're spreading it. "My doctor said I'm fine, this little cough is probably just a cold." Patient doesn't go back to get it checked out again. What if they provide a false-positive result to an asymptomatic patient? "Wow, that's crazy. I must have just gotten lucky" the patient says. Two weeks later, they leave quarantine after getting an accurate negative result. A month later, they actually contract the disease. "But, that's impossible. I already had it! My other doctor told me so, he even gave me a Test." Can coronavirus re-infect patients? Now, we're not so sure. Panic. Research studies. The truth is obscure. This is how doctors everywhere operate, and this is true at the FDA/CDC more than nearly every other country. Our standards for drug development, testing kit development, etc are among the most stringent in the world. It would take a disease far, far more deadly than the coronavirus to compromise them.
- timwis 7y agoHoly cow......I really need to learn Italian
- surfsvammel 7y agoI have shortness of breath, cannot go up the stairs in our house without having to stop and rest. 37 years old and otherwise quite healthy. Have underlying autoimmune disease, and am on immunomod. Coughing and light fever. I’ve had this for 5 days. When I called the hospital they told me to come in and get tested, but when I came to the hospital they did not test me. The doctor told me, it wouldn’t make a difference anyway. No matter what the test would show he would tell me the same thing: go home, isolate yourself, and come back if your fever worsens. Once your area reach a certain number of persons affected, there is little use to try to track each one. When they have changed to a strategy of trying to protect the weak, and just slow down the spread. Testing doesn’t really add much value or information.
- wirrbel 7y agoI hope you get better soon. I think your comment describes very well the economics of the pandemic when it spreads further. Basically you can treat everyone with Corona-like symptoms like a corona patient. It doesn't make much difference anymore. Isolation and monitoring of the condition. If it's a severe common cold the advice isn't that much off, too.
- annamargot 7y agoIt would sure be nice to know whether you’ve had it though. If I thought I’d already recovered from a mild COVID-19 - assuming I’d then have immunity for a decent chunk of time - I might think I could now move from the sidelines and into the fight and help others. But if I was wrong and I never did actually have it, then I’d be making things worse. Widespread testing could obv illuminate much.
- cjohansson 7y agoThe best way or reducing new positives test-results is by not allowing any new testing.
- lazyjones 7y agoLet's talk about false positives: there seems to be no solid estimate regarding common Cov-19 tests. I've seen numbers from 40% to 85% in papers suggesting at least a high number, some of which will probably be sloppily classified as "asymptomatic" cases.
- robocat 7y agoI read that the false positive rate is extremely low (below 1%). False positives are not a huge problem when you are only testing people with symptoms. False positives would only become a problem when you are doing a large number of tests on people who have no symptoms (e.g. 1% of 1 million people when close to none have the virus). I think your numbers are the detection rate: false negative rate is high (up to 40% for early tests).
- gioscarab 7y agoGuys, don't underestimate this pandemic, wear plastic gloves, FFP3 masks and if possible protective glasses when you are going outside. Leave your shoes out of the door and wash frequently your hands.
- PhaedrusV 7y agoOccam's Razor would imply that the "asymptomatic non-transmissive" cases are really just false positives. The only work I've seen on false positives is these guys, who estimate the FP rate for the active nucleic acid test screening at 75% chance of there being a 'false positive rate' greater than 47%. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32133832/?fbclid=IwAR3LHLplRtmPZED3jt_Hjf2ZKysmDcXMU5LgVgNPcqNAtb9EzcQBKMtCIoI https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32133832/?fbclid=IwAR3LHLplR...
- MR4D 7y agoWhy is this post title in English while the actual article linked is in Italian? Shouldn’t they have to match?
- teslaAC 7y agoMOST COVID19 CASES ARE ATYPICAL AND NOT REPRESENTED BY ADVERTISED SIDE EFFECTS ATYPICAL SIDE EFFECTS: Light Fever, Severe Lightheadedness, Long Duration Headache, Sore Throat, Severe Body Aches, Tight Chest, Very Light Cough No Phlegm, Sharp Edged Flush on Cheeks with Pale Circle Surrounding Lips, Slight Runny Nose, Lethargy, Confusion, Hot Flashes, Inconsistant Diarrhoea Without Discomfort, Trouble Focusing on Conversations, Shakiness, No Issues Breathing Until Exercise, Flush After Taking Anti-Inflammatories, Very Shakey Legs on Rising, Swollen Lymph Nodes (under arms), Nervous System Issues: Anxiety, Change in Perception of Senses, Insomnia These symptoms will cycle and not present at the same time which is indicative of COVID19 YOU WILL NOT HAVE THE COUGH OR FEVER YOU EXPECT AND MOST PEOPLE BLAME IT ON STRESS,ALLERGIES,COLD,FLU,ETC. DO NOT TAKE NAPROXEN, IBUPROFEN OR ANY ANTI-INFLAMMATORIES Example Symptom Progression From an Interview: “ I’ve been so tired and so winded and just kind of moody and had a constant headache for a week and hot flashes mostly at night where it felt like I had a fever but only at night, random coughing. I figured it was just the weather and stress. Then last night came to a head—terrible brain fog yesterday could barely hold a convo, would shake (like when you’re blood sugar crashes) when I’d try to get up and do something, Had the worst migraine ever last night and terrible nausea and was throwing up. Then today this is my face with a huge rash.” Examples of Corona Rash: https://imgur.com/a/dXz52rR https://imgur.com/a/dXz52rR