21 ms·
“I'm not sure there is an acceptable solution to the problem we are facing”
- allovernow 7y agoThis is basically a summary of most of the worst case rumors turning out to be true. This is very bad. We should be preparing to isolate ourselves from society as much as possible for a few months. Times are going to get rough. The good news is that this may be a cleansing fire that the US is long overdue for. By now some of you have undoubtedly realized that 2019ncov is not just a virus - it is a chaotic geopolitical force. It is changing the way we live in front of our eyes. These are exciting times. There's your silver lining. >Health and the economy are closely linked. The correlation between per-capita GDP and health (life expectancy) is essentially perfect. If the covid-19 pandemic leads to a global economy collapse, many more lives will be lost than covid-19 would ever be able to claim I don't agree with his derivation, I think he's mixing correlation and causation a little, but his conclusion is undoubtedly correct.
- rapsey 7y agoIs covid-19 the biggest world event since WW2?
- alex_duf 7y agoTime will tell
- woahitsraj 7y agoCertainly up there. It's impossible to say at this point. We will only know with the benefit of years of hindsight
- kijin 7y agoDepends on how you measure bigness. It could very well be the biggest world event since WW2 in terms of the number of ordinary people whose daily routines are directly affected.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoDepends how you measure and what you call a "world event". * Mao Zedong killed 40 to 80 million people during his rule after WW2, but "only" in China. * 2-5 million died in the Second Congo Civil War between 1998-2003, but to a first approximation only Congo and its immediate neighbors even noticed. * The US response to 9/11 killed around 500,000 people directly (war violence) and a lot more indirectly (health, economy, etc). The direct death toll of COVID-19 is unlikely to get anywhere close to this, but the indirect economic impact will clearly be global and massive.
- rapsey 7y agoI would measure it in terms of daily life being completely altered in most regions of the world and persisting after the event (which is yet to be determined but pretty much impossible to think it wont).
- marvin 7y ago2-5 million dead seems perfectly plausible at this point. But remember we're not only talking about deaths, we're also talking about disruptions in society. IMHO, we're already well into reorganization to a war economy in many countries, USA included. Meaning, truly exceptional circumstances where the status quo is suspended and different, urgent priorities are taken. Also, at this rate I wouldn't be surprised if Trump tries to postpone the elections in November.
- mcv 7y agoThose were certainly big events, but they were mostly local. COVID-19 is more global than anything I can think of. Social life is getting shut down in east Asia, India, Europe and the US. I'm not sure what South America, Africa and the Middle East are doing, but COVID-19 will hit them too. Even if the death toll is going to me more limited than other big events (we don't know that, though), it is absolutely massive and truly global. As for the potential death toll, if half the world gets it and 2% of them die, we're looking at a 80 million death count.
- scotty79 7y agoCovid could kill 40 million people globally in just the first wave of infections and not counting deaths caused by collateral damage. Just multiply half of the world population by mortality rate of 1%.
- redis_mlc 7y agoWell, I would say no, since there were multiple famines since then. 1) Post-WW2, most of the Eastern Hemisphere experienced famine and underemployment for a decade. (Britain had food ration coupons for 9 years afterwards.) 2) The Cold War was pretty scary and greatly impoverished the Eastern Bloc, Cuba, N. Vietnam and N. Korea. China had the Great Famine from 1959 - 1961, killing "tens of millions." 4) Polio was a scourge until vaccines were developed: 2 to 5 percent of children and up to 15 to 30 percent of adults die 5) USA has a serious crack and meth epidemic, and Russia lost a lot of men to vodka poisoning. We'll see about Covid-19, but the next famine will dwarf it by 10x or 20x in total fatalities.
- rapsey 7y agoSounds cruel but famines are localised suffering that have little effect on the rest of the world. Of course if you measure deaths it is not anywhere close to anything. If you measure global life impact it is surpassing everything since ww2.
- redis_mlc 7y agoI suggest you read my comment again. Famine due to global warfare is not localized, and each one listed had tens of millions of fatalities.
- Dylan16807 7y agoPolio, drugs, and >40 years of Cold War fail the "event" part of "world event" The Great Famine fails the "world" part. Your first item is sort of arguable, but I'd say it's half not an event, and half not independent enough of WW2 to count.
- OskarS 7y agoNo, but "since the end of the cold war", probably.
- username90 7y agoI think the end of Soviet was bigger. This is probably the biggest thing since then.
- titzer 7y agoHonestly, I think the Moon Landing was a bigger deal for humanity. But only because it was the deepest spike of scientific exploration that we ever had, and probably the single most dangerous thing humans have ever done. But you could shrug that off, it didn't affect you. This is probably the worst event since WW2, IMHO, yes. It is going to be as bad as the 1918 flu. Its effects will be more far-reaching. Unlike WW2, this will affect every single corner of the globe. This will change society forever.
- aaron695 7y agoHIV, I doubt cov-19 will be bigger, but possible if it circles. Economic deaths from both are huge. But everyone seems to have forgotten HIV, which says a bit.
- ohazi 7y ago> How long immunity lasts for following covid-19 infection is the biggest unknown. Comparison with other Coronaviridae suggests it may be relatively short-lived (i.e. months). Anyone have sources for this? I've been skeptical of the rumors about reinfection, because they seem to be based on tests coming back positive after recovery, but the tests are rt-PCR based, and your body will be shedding leftover bits of RNA as it flushes out viral remnants long after recovery, so this seems expected. As far as I'm aware, immunity to most viruses is long-lasting or permanent, with the obvious exception being if the virus mutates enough to look different to your immune system. Is this assumption wildly off?
- Arkhaine_kupo 7y agoI remember reading they expect immunity to last as little as 6 months for Covid-19, found this paper about the SARS outbreak of 2002 which was also a type of corona virus, saying patients had an average immunity of 2 years. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2851497/
- ohazi 7y agoWikipedia-grade non-biologist here, so again, feel free to correct me if I'm wrong. As far as I'm aware, antibodies don't stick around after they're no longer needed... They're produced by B cells when an infection is detected, and after an initial infection, some B cells that learned how to make effective antibodies stick around in your body as "memory B cells" - these will produce the same antibodies again upon reinfection. Counting antibodies a few years after a SARS infection doesn't seem like it would tell you much about immunity.
- Pepe1vo 7y agoIt's correct that the memory cells in your body will last a long time. However, (I think) what the parent is getting at is that within a relatively short amount of time the virus will have mutated just enough to evade detection by those memory cells.
- timwaagh 7y agoI'm sure if china can shut people inside their houses to prevent spread, so can we. We just have to adopt a different attitude towards fundamental rights. Besides, medicine development seems to go rather quickly. I am sure it will be mostly dealt with in a years time.
- woahitsraj 7y agoThis is impossible to know. Just because months after the outbreak China has managed to contain it, doesn't mean that there can't be a second wave of reinfection
- timwaagh 7y agoYes, most likely. But it can be more or less severe depending on whether we manage to contain the 'first wave'
- kingkawn 7y agoYour certainty is as factual as a wish upon a star
- timwaagh 7y agoI am basing this on the news reports which say a german company is ready for in-human-trials which last months. after that, they would be able to produce millions of vaccinations in weeks. I think it's very promising. The us president apparantly also thinks so, since he has been trying to bribe them into exclusivity.
- macintux 7y agoWe don’t even know that a long-term vaccine is possible, much less that this specific one is going to work and not have catastrophic health impact on the trial subjects.
- lbeltrame 7y ago> I am sure it will be mostly dealt with in a years time. What do you mean exactly? If you mean locking people up in their homes for a whole year, I think this will have not only economic, but also deep social impacts.
- jhoechtl 7y agoThis is probably the shittiest reading experience possible. Covered in ad and stitched together of 11 tweets. WTF? Where has rationality been heading that such a medium became the go-to tool to transport important messages? Oh wait, a red-haired in the corridors of power is using it too..
- TuringTest 7y agoThis is a Twitter thread summarizer, that stitches together all the separate posts in a thread. You can enjoy the original here[1], with the experience that the platform creators intended. [1] https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/1238837158007447558 https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/12388371580074475...
- jonrimmer 7y agoIn this event, the solution will be the creation of a permanent, South Korea and China inspired infrastructure for testing, tracking and constraining infectious citizens by all developed countries. Regardless of the privacy and civil liberty concerns, I think that's where we'll eventually end up, and to your children it will one day seem crazy that a person with an infectious illness was once able to freely walk the streets.
- ekianjo 7y ago> tracking and constraining infectious citizens by all developed countries. That would be ridiculous if you get to millions of people infected, because that would effectively destroy all economic activity. Even during the 1918-1919 epidemic with high mortality rates people did not stop going to work. Our strategy to isolate ourselves is fine if it's short term but it can't continue more than a few months.
- londons_explore 7y agoIf you can make it fine grained enough so people are only isolated for a few days around their personal most infectious time, productivity losses would be minimal. The productivity loss only happens when testing is inaccurate and entire communities are told to stay home for months just because it's hard to identify exactly who is coughing out germs each day.
- jonrimmer 7y agoTracking and testing doesn't destroy economic activity. Complete lock-downs, as we're seeing in China, Italy, Spain and soon elsewhere do. But it does let you get a grip on the situation when you have millions infected. However you're right that you can't maintain that long term, so what's the off-ramp? South Korea has proved you can do mass testing and tracking which, combined with voluntary and state-enforced control of movement, lets you keep infections at a low level. What I'm contending is that, if the situation is bad enough, all countries that can will implement similar controls, and those controls will a permanent situation, not a temporary one. People will still be able to go to work, just not if they're potentially sick or infectious.
- ekianjo 7y ago> If the covid-19 pandemic leads to a global economy collapse Very unlikely it happens. At some point people/countries will decide to take the risk rather than letting their own economies collapse (which is in the interest of absolutely no one, even the patients at risk).
- trevyn 7y agoThe collapse coin has a flipside: New growth.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- black_puppydog 7y agoI don't agree with the conclusion. We can scale down our economies and still maintain production of essentials by ``drumroll`` scaling back shit that nobody needs. Starting with an overblown healthcare admin system in the US, IMHO, but also including less inflammatory non-essential things like yet another range of plastic toys and luxury perfumes and and and. Essentially in this scenario, we should take this as an opportunity to prune all Bullshit Jobs [1] and focus on things securing social, mental, and healthcare subsistence. Oh and maybe just don't move troops all around the planet to fuck up other people's place. It wasn't a good idea before, (both during the 1918 influenza wave and after that) and it's certainly not a good idea now. Save that money and manpower, put it to use for something constructive for a change. There you go, I guess I just pissed on every holy cow this crowd has. You know where the downvote button is. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_Jobs
- skrebbel 7y ago> There you go, I guess I just pissed on every holy cow this crowd has. You know where the downvote button is. Your comment would've been stronger without this line.
- TuringTest 7y ago> ``drumroll`` scaling back shit that nobody needs. Maybe, but what do you do with people whose livelihood depend on those superfluous bullshit jobs? Until we have a system that guarantees a right to life even if you do nothing productive, those busyworks are used to justify giving food, shelter and healthcare to those people.
- netsharc 7y agoThe sane/benovelent governments will probably switch to universal basic income, i.e. go deep into debt and just pay everyone money to live. And no, actually going into debt is not a huge problem, ask Keynes, or what happened in WW2; it was an emergency and governments borrowed and borrowed with no fear.
- 7y ago
- roenxi 7y ago> The correlation between per-capita GDP and health (life expectancy) is essentially perfect. I've seen this said before; this is not considering correlation vs. causation. High per capita GDP correlates exceedingly well with technological and scientific mastery. A global economic collapse would lead to some lives lost and be very painful, obviously. But if the economic damage is in the tourism industry or entertainment that will be far less damaging than if the food supply lines collapse or the oil stops flowing. One of those is inconvenient, the other would lead to militaries being deployed.
- grandinj 7y agoExactly. Also, that scatter has very high variance. I feel a lot less confident about the authors conclusions if they call that a "perfect" correlation
- numair 7y agoI am 100% in agreement with the author. It’s refreshing to see someone admit how much they don’t know — one of the most annoying things about our social media era, when combined with this current situation, is that everyone thinks they’re an expert and that their course of action is the One True Way to defeat the virus. Fact of the matter is, we’re flying blind, and governmental action is more about crowd control than a real fix. My advice to the young people for whom this virus is not a major threat is ... Enjoy yourself, enjoy your time with your friends. There’s a chance that this virus could mutate to pose as much of a threat to young, healthy people as old, unhealthy ones (and ironically there’s a chance this whole quarantine thing might be of assistance, as OP carefully alludes to). That’s not a sci-fi disaster scenario, that’s just 1918, baby. Governments really need to increase the penalties — meaning, jail time, huge fines, etc — on spreading misinformation on social media. That is as big of a problem as any during this time. And so-called “medical experts” on Twitter or Facebook or whatever, trying to validate themselves, are a large component of that. If we don’t get people to stop playing games online about this now, we are going to have a full-scale meltdown if this virus mutates later in the year.
- tsimionescu 7y agoYou are wrong on almost every count. Crowd control is a real fix for an epidemic. And while we don't know the details of the infection, we know enough to understand that we can't let it roam free. Your advice to young people is horrible, and based on nothing. One of the things we don't know is whether there is any lasting damage in recovered patients. We don't know if the virus might mutate. The only safe thing to do is to avoid catching it, whether you are 80 or 20. Note that SARS left permanent damage in some recovered patients. Even without that, the death rate among less than 40 is similar to the flu in the entire population. This is all not to mention that young people have old relatives that may need their help, especially if they are to stay in isolation for extended periods of time. And while fake news in the media is a problem, it is one of the last things that governments should be spending resources on at this time,especially as there have been no cases of breaking quarantine or isolation based on fake news.
- ojilles 7y ago
- seapunk 7y agoOriginal source: https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/1238837158007447558 https://twitter.com/BallouxFrancois/status/12388371580074475... Threader's version (if you want to read it without ads and fake news recommendations): https://threader.app/thread/1238837158007447558 https://threader.app/thread/1238837158007447558
- bsder 7y agoOn what basis is anybody predicting a second wave which gets worse? This seems completely backwards from everything we know. The Spanish Flu accidentally had an inverted forcing function--we sent the worst cases back to their home countries which helped spread the most severe cases rather than the mildest. For Covid-19, the cases most likely to spread are going to be the mildest. The worse you feel, the more likely you will pull yourself out of circulation. And, if you are obviously unwell, people are going to force you home.
- dvdcxn 7y agoYes this is my predection too. We are enforcing evolutionary pressure that favours a less dangerous strain of the virus.
- scotty79 7y agoGiven that this virus can spread well before there are any symptoms and well after symptoms are gone I think there are very little evolutionary pressures on it right now and it can evolve into milder strains with pretty much same probability as more lethal strains. If we are vigilant then the only thing that the virus might be pressure toward is having even longer asymptomatic spread and even higher survivability in the air and on the surfaces.
- codeulike 7y agoI think they're expecting second wave to be bad due to winter in northern hemisphere, not because of mutations
- Taek 7y agoHeavy testing and aggressive isolation of infected persons and areas seems to be effective. In the absence of heavy testing, broad quarantine seems to be effective. The answer at this point seems to be heavy, widespread quarantine until testing infrastructure is sufficient to closely track every active case. Once that testing is in place, most quarantines can be lifted, and any second wave can be managed. There are numerous promising treatments as well in development. HIV drugs, Ebola drugs, and Malaria drugs are all showing promise in pre-print research. If any of those pan out, it's likely that the mortality rate will go substantially down so long as we can suppress the spread until treatment infrastructure has scaled up.
- Udik 7y agoLet me dream: how hard would it be to create a test that can be distributed by the billions on paper strips like a ph test? You take one every evening and by the morning it tells you if you can go out or not. Is it conceivable or (borderline) impossible?
- neuronic 7y agoBioinformatician here (well, former): I would never say something is impossible but the way these things are tested right now, it pretty much is impossible. We need to amplify some molecules and run a process called PCR on them for which you need a full lab setup. It would take nothing short of a revolution in detection to achieve this.
- pas 7y agoWhat would the cost be to set up testing machines every few blocks? People just get a swab, drop it into the machine, and get a code (just take a picture of a QR code) that they can later check for results.
- neuronic 7y ago> What would the cost be to set up testing machines every few blocks? Where are you getting near infinite qualified and trained lab personnel from? Machines that can mostly automate the process cost $500k - $1m easily. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6P-jaC3_d3o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6P-jaC3_d3o (Roche commercial!)
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSome solutions that already exist, are already in use and could be firmed up: 1. Working from home. 2. Ordering online and getting takeout. 3. Using self checkout. 4. Collaboration and socialization via phone and internet. You can't get sick if you aren't exposed. People don't get sick due to some random number generator. You have to have a vector. We already know a great many ways to disrupt the spread. The antidote to a global crisis is not a global solution. It's a local solution. When Ebola was initially a problem, the epidemic was stopped by African tribal elders, not advanced Western medicine. They told their people "Don't go to the white man's hospital" because you would go for something fixable, like a broken leg, and die of Ebola. They blockaded the roads and stopped letting outsiders in. They quarantined those who were infected and left food on the doorstep to take care of them. If the food stopped disappearing, they burned the hut down. We know a lot about how to stop this. What we currently lack is some means to get people to do all the basic stuff we already know works, like wash your hands, stop touching your face and don't lick your fingers to separate bags. I'm disappointed in seeing this handwringing, angsting piece at number one. It's not really factual. It's someone being emotional. It isn't 1918. We have vastly better technology and information these days. We just have to deploy it and leverage it. This is mostly about shaping culture. The primary question is "How do you get people to voluntarily comply instead of blowing it off as usual?"
- dbmueller 7y agoDo you have any source/reference on the Ebola stuff you're talking about?
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI think the book was called The Hot Zone. Here you go. This should be it. http://projectavalon.net/THE_HOT_ZONE_Richard_Preston.pdf http://projectavalon.net/THE_HOT_ZONE_Richard_Preston.pdf
- dbmueller 7y agoInteresting, thanks!
- kortilla 7y agoFlagged because there is nothing in the article but a tweet author admitting he/she doesn’t know much and is guessing without sources. > and have spent five years in a world class 'pandemic response modelling' unit A pretty damming thing for the field of “pandemic response modeling”, but not really worth worrying about on its own.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoDavid Graeber is a stupid person, and the thesis of that book is stupid. There are boring jobs, and there are jobs that wouldn't exist in utopia, but he has no idea why jobs exist or what function they serve. His book is paradoxically feel-good, in that just because we can imagine a world in which nobody has to shovel shit that we can eliminate all shit-shoveling jobs today. Shit, I actually worked at the kinds of jobs he calls "flunkies" as a temp, and it wasn't a big mystery to me what the jobs were for. When I had a temp job as a receptionist, my job was literally answering the phone. People would call, and I would answer. It did not require a Ph.D. in anthropology to figure out the function of the job, or why someone would pay me to do it.
- loopz 7y agoI don't know this person, but many today strike me as cynical, short-sighted and narrow-minded, when they portray a world where nobody needs you, as some kind of utopia.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoBullshit jobs are the job market equivalent of software bloat. They have the same issues: you can take a popular modern webapp or "desktop" app and notice that it's 80% of fat that isn't necessary for it to deliver all its value, but if you zoom in, almost every single piece of that fat can justify its existence because of other pieces. So you can't just start cutting it out piece by piece, you'd have to redesign the whole application. Same with the job market: a lot of jobs are just fixing the damage done by other jobs, or implementing a distributed consensus algorithm through zero-sum competition. Every job is justifiable in terms of other jobs it serves, even though a whole lot of them could be pruned with no loss in value created for the society.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoDefining jobs as "bullshit" requires imagining you can design large chunks of society from scratch. Sometimes you can, but more often you end up with a system as complicated at the current system. In utopia, we wouldn't need any lawyers. But we have lawyers now because we have disputes. Utopian planners always skip to the part where all the disputes are magically settled, or invent a mechanism only tested within their own minds. They leave the messy work of actually making working systems to the rest of us.
- saneshark 7y agoIt's a beautiful thing if it can bring humanity together towards a common aim. But if it leads to the collapse of monetary systems, the collapse of civil society, looting, rioting, the rise of nationalism, and WWIII that's most certainly going to lead more death and destruction than the virus itself.
- neuronic 7y agoWay to escalate the situation. Let's see how well quarantine measures work and how the next 4 weeks pan out with the economy in hibernation. It will cost us dearly but I wouldn't say it's going to lead to rioting and WW3. If anything, this is a global problem for which we need global solutions and not fucking nationalism merely 100 years after it already screwed our societies. Let's hope that China will enforce prohibition of wild animal trade/use as much as possible. It's not in the CCPs interest to let that kind of instability rain down on it.
- mcsb4 7y agoI don't understand why we are not trying to interrupt the transmission vectors with masks and hand sanitizer like the Chinese do. They ramped the daily production from 10M to 100M and even advised the use of make-shift masks. The reaction in the west: masks are not protecting 100% and also we don't have any and we are too lazy to produce them, although they are much cheaper than the economic impact covid-19 has. 1. you go out, you wear a mask 2. you are not allowed into a super market without hand sanitizing 3. you clean your hands when coming home or going into your office 4. wear any kind of glasses We know the transmission vectors but the whole response in the west is solely based on quarantaine - like we would still not know what viruses are and how they are transmitted. Reducing social contact is one thing, reducing virus dispersion is the other and it is cheap. You have a sewing machine? Go start making masks.
- bosswipe 7y agoThe anti-mask thing in the west is so upsetting, and it's more aggravating because it's the health care workers giving the horrible advice. I don't care that we don't have enough N95 masks for everybody, N95 are for preventing inhalation of virus. What we need are the disparaged "surgical" masks which are for preventing spittle flying everywhere. And they do not have to be high-tech they just have to cover the mouth. It should be mandatory to wear one out of the house. That's what China did.
- geomark 7y agoIt seems strange to me as well. I am in Thailand and, in Bangkok at least, most people wear masks, carry disinfecting hand gel and are very wary about close contact with people and surfaces. Stores like Makro (Thai version of CostCo) have mask-wearing guards at the store entrance that take your temperature and provide hand gel, while cleaning crews wipe down the handles of shopping carts with disinfectant. To be fair, many people in Bangkok already wore masks because of the pollution. So there is no stigma. But it seems that the Thais started taking Covid-19 serious right away, so maybe that's why Thailand, which was on the leader board in number of infections early on, has reached only 114 confirmed infectinos with 1 death as of yesterday. But only time will tell if all the precautions can slow down the spread since it only takes a few infected but symptomless highly social spreaders to really blow things up. And it looks like that may have happened in the last few days.
- wiz21c 7y agoInterestingly, when we face a problem where deaths can be attributed to a very specific, identifiable killer, politicians don't fail to act in strong ways... Let's talk about action against climate change now...
- neuronic 7y agoClimate change is not the immediate threat to old men that it needs to be in order to get things moving.
- Erlich_Bachman 7y ago> Let's talk about action against climate change now... What do you mean exactly by "talk"? People have been "talking" about it for decades, what are you proposing or predicting will change now?
- wiz21c 7y agoI was just telling that a little sense of urgency would not be bad to accelerate things about climate (ie move from a decade rythm to something like a yearly one would be so much better)
- blueblimp 7y agoThere absolutely is an acceptable way out of this. China, South Korea, Taiwan and Singapore, at least, are going to be just fine. They are focused on suppressing and controlling the virus. Once they get few enough imports from travel (presumably by restricting travel from countries where the virus is uncontrolled) and eliminate local transmission, they can resume life-as-usual, apart from being on high alert for imported cases. There is no other acceptable solution. Countries hoping to avoid the short-term economic cost of suppressing the virus will find themselves paying a greater economic cost over the long-term along with a massive cost in lives. The question is now: which countries will adopt the correct approach before it's too late?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hackandtrip 7y agoIn 5-10 days we'll see if the first EU country to adopt police-state measures will be added to that list. Spain and France are on the right track too, other than Italy.
- blueblimp 7y agoI'm not sure exactly what Italy is doing at the moment, but an important result out of China is that they found quarantine-at-home was not good enough for R<1. They needed centralized quarantine to achieve R<1. https://twitter.com/XihongLin/status/1236076749491929094 https://twitter.com/XihongLin/status/1236076749491929094 So the first attempt does not necessarily work. But I hope it does, and if not, I hope they quickly iterate to find one that does.
- closeparen 7y agoYou can have as many nines of reduction as you want; they are all worthless the moment the social graph reconnects. I'm skeptical that "life-as-usual" is a serious possibility.
- blueblimp 7y ago
- growlist 7y agoThe acceptable solution is for society to adapt. That includes everyone accepting their lives will change, and rich people in particular accepting they'll be poorer for a while. And if we have to move to a war footing to stop people dying, then that's what we have to do. To say 'it's either continue as close to normal or people will die' is a false dichotomy. Also: there's this 'oh well' attitude afoot here in the UK that we can't enforce curfews etc. because the people won't have it. To this I say: we lock people up here for hurty words on the Internet. The only reason it can't happen is because some people in power don't want it to happen.
- lazylizard 7y agoI'm sure many will point this out. A few east asian countries beg to differ. Namely China, s.korea, taiwan, singapore. Solutions even come in different sizes!
- 0-_-0 7y ago> How long immunity lasts for following covid-19 infection is the biggest unknown. Comparison with other Coronaviridae suggests it may be relatively short-lived (i.e. months). Could this mean that covid-19 is here to stay? Is it the new common cold, but more serious?
- notacoward 7y agoThat's the outcome that worries me. Continual reinfection plus disproportionate effect on certain groups means we're going to have a lot fewer people in those groups unless we develop and deploy a vaccine in less time than seems likely. We're also going to have a lot more people with permanent lung scarring from "moderate" cases. Will that cause society to collapse? Of course not. We'll adapt, but it's still pretty horrible to contemplate.