21 ms·
Am I Unique?
- mattmein 7y agoWhat does it mean that I have a unique user agent? I just use normal brave browser.
- mynegation 7y agoI hope it is a joke (pretty good one if it is), but on an off-chance it is not: it is entirely plausible that you are the first Brave browser user to visit the site (or at least Brave of that version).
- thatcat 7y agoNot a joke, panopticlick by eff does this too and explains how it works.
- trashcan 7y agoMost likely that it isn't very common. Mine said <0.01% for the Brave user-agent.
- dantle 7y agoAre you sure you're looking only the "User Agent"? The text at the top is describing your entire "browser fingerprint." It includes everything the server could gather from you. Including cookies, browser version, width/height of the window, etc. In case it's not clear, uniqueness should be seen as bad in this case. It means you can be tracked.
- filoeleven 7y agoNo idea what it means, but I am also curious. I literally just installed Brave on IOS before checking it out, so I tried it on IOS Chrome and the fingerprint was still unique. I think it might just mean that we leak waaaay more data than most of us realize...
- ubercow13 7y agoMy user agent also says 0.16% similarity and I’m just using safari on an iphone. How can that be?
- Zenbit_UX 7y agoThere's more than one iPhone, more than one IOS version and more than one version of safari. Multiply the odds of someone having your exact setup AND browsing this site.
- codingmess 7y agoI get just 0,31% similarity rating with the latest Firefox.
- runninganyways 7y agoGood news! I am unique. My experience is valid. I really needed to hear this.
- droithomme 7y agoThe above site beachballed and was nonfunctional for me. A better site with similar functioning is: https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/
- fnord77 7y agopanopticlick said my chrome browser was not unique. this tool said it is.
- tialaramex 7y agoPanopticlick is interested in solving a problem (and considerable progress has been made on that), this site is as it's name suggests here to sell you on a belief. It'll cheerfully tell an unlimited number of identical browsers that they're "unique" because that's the message it is here to sell. If it gave these supposedly "Unique" browsers an actually unique identifier they'd be able to compare it and see that they're not so "unique" as claimed or worse that the same browser gets different "unique" identifiers and so they aren't identifiers at all. So that's why it doesn't do that.
- dang 7y agoA thread from last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19212123 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19212123
- zamadatix 7y agoInterestingly this led me to notice Firefox limits hardware concurrency to a max of 16, changeable in about:config via the key dom.maxHardwareConcurrency
- michaelhoffman 7y agoThe irony in using the "Do Not Track" attribute to track users is delicious.
- fragsworth 7y agoI appreciate that you pointed this out, I would have missed it. Brilliant and terrible.
- hanniabu 7y agoMind expanding on this? Where can I learn more about this attribute?
- alangpierce 7y agoIt was an attempt at standardizing a browser setting to opt out of tracking, but it was ultimately unsuccessful. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Do_Not_Track
- cpeterso 7y agoApple even removed Do Not Track option from Safari last year: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/safari_release_notes/safari_12_1_release_notes https://developer.apple.com/documentation/safari_release_not...
- OrgNet 7y agoI think that I am still going to keep it enabled, as a matter of principles.
- Nursie 7y agoThat flag was hilarious and pointless from day 1. So we're going to ask the profit-motivated bad-actors across the web to pretty-please exempt us from your tracking because we asked nicely? And we need to hide this away in settings and have it default-off because otherwise how will they know we really meant it? It's like it was designed by someone with an early 90s understanding of the web, and no comprehension whatsoever of just how awful marketing can be. Tracking should never be opt-out in the first place, and it needs to be fought with technological and legal measures, not silly http request flags.
- jdc 7y agoIs it just me or would people rather be able to spoof or disable these fields without drudging through thousands of lines of C++ code?
- zamadatix 7y agoMost of these fields you don't want to disable or spoof because either it breaks your web experience (imagine images randomly not loading because you spoofed your headers and the server thinks your browser supports .whatever or because you emptied the list and the server doesn't know what to send) or because it makes you unique (having your build id be "" is certainly more unique than whatever others actually use). The tests you can spoof like the canvas fingerprinting where it doesn't break the canvas and the results are already so spread out being unique isn't an identifier itself are already built into a lot of browsers. The site doesn't really acknowledge this though, it just says "you're unique" without checking if it's a different unique value each time in which case it doesn't identify you at all.
- jedimastert 7y agoFor some, no it would not really be possible. The Canvas fingerprint is the biggest one, as it relies on different forms of hardware acceleration which is based on GPU+CPU+configs for your computer and browser.
- Deukhoofd 7y agoCan't be that hard, considering Firefox allows for blocking Canvas fingerprinting in its settings, and the site indeed shows that my canvas data is shared with around 6% of the users, so definitely not unique.
- michael-ax 7y agoHowever, your full fingerprint is unique among the 1545859 collected so far.
- anidea01 7y agoGreat idea! Targeted advertising is really upsetting. If we take it one step further: 1. Find out the top non-unique fingerprint [of the year.] 2. Create a Firefox add-on (or modify Firefox source if an add-on is not powerful enough), which uses the most non-unique fingerprint [this year.] 3. Targeted advertising ends for those who use the plug-in/add-on. It's a cat and mouse game as fingerprint parameters keep increasing, but I think it's possible to win this one.
- MivLives 7y agoThe problem with this is the less unique you are, the more you start looking like a bot. The more you look like a bot the more times you have to do things to prove you aren't, like captchas
- WWLink 7y agoIf everyone looks like a bot, then nobody's a bot, and they can go fuck off.
- anidea01 7y agoTrue. But I only care about filling captchas on say banking websites, which is approximately happens once a month. The rest, I just close the tab: the content never worth it. The most obnoxious ads don't care about captchas, they just blast you with ads from your previous search keywords/browsing history. p.s. Would the amount of captchas reduce if we take not the top most non-unique fingerprint, but say "slightly below average"? It will be still severely non-unique for ads purposes.
- twelvechairs 7y agoThis is Google's strategy to defeat privacy in a nutshell
- TTPrograms 7y agoA better solution would be to scramble parts of this fingerprint for each domain.
- jammygit 7y agoWhat terrible browser design to send all that data. I would never have imagined my computer was sending all that off 10 years ago
- gowld 7y agoIt's doesn't "send the data" so much as "a general purpose UI platform cannot work unless a program knows the configuration of the UI". The idea that your complex computing environment could have an arbitrary complex conversation with an app, and not expose its identity, while perhaps desirable, it impractical. You can browser behind a generic user-agent firewall, but you'll get a severely degraded experience that treats an Apple watch the same as a desktop workstation.
- rovr138 7y agoUsing the user agent string for this is not needed and is not common now for new projects.
- lonelappde 7y agoIndeed, I didn't write "user agent string"; I wrote "user agent".
- skybrian 7y agoStandardization on only a few design variations might fix this? People would complain about monocultures, though.
- dkarras 7y agoIt's not just about design. For instance there is Canvas and WebGL for interactive content. Different GPU's draw things slightly differently. Someone creates a canvas in the background, draws stuff, reads it back and since your machine has a particular way of drawing things (because of GPU design, drivers, different browser implementations of the painting stack) you can be tracked. Same goes for audio capabilities. If you don't want multimedia, then fine, it is slightly easier. Then the server can probably try to track you with your upload / download speed, ping etc. They can tax your cpu to see how fast it is. Then they get your browser width / height. Combine them and you can be tracked pretty accurately. There are countless avenues for fingerprinting.
- milofeynman 7y agoAlright, so how do I fix the unique ones like Canvas? Edit: To block canvas fingerprinting I set `privacy.resistFingerprinting` to true in Firefox's about:config. Now I am trying to figure out how to disable the font list and Media devices, etc.
- gavreh 7y agoI am looking into this too. Looks like it's `font.system.whitelist` but I'm not sure of a "generic, common" list to add there.
- Mirioron 7y agoI am unique through the useragent. Apparently Brave and Chrome both put the device model of your phone into the useragent string. It also contains your OS version and Chromium version. I guess those three points alone are able to very significantly narrow you down.
- idclip 7y agoIm unsure why all that data is needed when i simply visit a website to read stuff or watch stuff on youtube. Is it really necessary?
- cies 7y agoNope. Not at all. There is a browser[1] that tries to hide this stuff for you (it's the FF-derived TOR browser w/o the TOR bit). That should be a good start. 1: https://www.whonix.org/wiki/SecBrowser https://www.whonix.org/wiki/SecBrowser
- arkadiyt 7y agoChrome published an intent to freeze the user-agent string: https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!msg/blink-dev/-2JIRNMWJ7s/yHe4tQNLCgAJ https://groups.google.com/a/chromium.org/forum/#!msg/blink-d...
- lonelappde 7y agoAnd replace it by Client Hints. How does that prevent fingerprinting?
- floatingatoll 7y agoIn a nutshell, to my best understanding; User-Agent is divulged publicly with all requests to all sites, so no protections exist around using it, because it is freely offered up by the user without requiring consent. Client Hints have to be specifically requested by the remote website, which demonstrates intent to collect data, and thus falls under data collection laws.
- notatoad 7y agoWhat does it mean when i load the test, and it says i'm unique, and then i go back five minutes later without changing anything and it says i'm still unique? are they tracking that i've run the test before, verifying that i'm me, and telling me i'm still unique, or is my fingerprint differing between two subsequent tests? also, i'm suspicious about some of these values - only 0.13% of people have a querty keyboard layout? Only 7% of tests have no gyroscope? That doesn't sound right.
- codingmess 7y agoIt says they set a cookie for 4 months.
- hollander 7y agoOpen a private tab and the cookie is not there.
- alamortsubite 7y agoYour username leads me to believe you're browsing from an IP address within the GDPR. Accept cookies and try again. 'AmIUniqueId', expires Mon, 25 May 2020 12:28:29 GMT
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 7y agoThe number which seemed strangest to me is that my up-to-date pixel 3a phone has a user agent shared with only 0.01% of browsers.
- notatoad 7y agothat doesn't sound too far out of whack to me, considering the user-agent string changes every time your OS version and your browser version increment.
- cle 7y agoIs there something actionable I can take based on the results of this page? E.g. is there some Firefox add-on that obfuscates attributes used for fingerprinting?
- codingmess 7y agoWhat I don't understand that the user agent for the latest version of Firefox (on Windows 10) has a similarity rating of just 0,31%.
- rgoulter 7y agoThat's across "all time", not just the last 7 days. But for the last 7 days, Firefox has over 300%, and Windows over 285%. Gecko is over 700%. Screen left of 0 is 250%. -- I'm guessing some kind of calculation error?
- ropiwqefjnpoa 7y agoTOR browser on highest security level, javascript disabled and windowed returns: Almost! (You can most certainly be tracked.)
- thepete2 7y agoI've just tried the same, but the HTTP header user agent and the javascript one are different. Maybe TOR varies some attributes?
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoI tried it myself in Tor Browser, and I think this conclusion "You can most certainly be tracked" is highly misleading. Without JavaScript, the only information collected by the website is the headers sent by the browser, listed below... > User agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; rv:68.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/68.0 (all time: 2.19% / 30 days: 10.80%) > Accept: text/html,application/xhtml+xml,application/xml;q=0.9,/;q=0.8 (all time: 52.15% / 30 days: 37.04%) > Content encoding: gzip, deflate, br (all time: 66.35% / 30 days: 92.02%) > Upgrade Insecure Requests: 1 (all time: 27.33% / 30 days: 85.86%) > Referer: https://amiunique.org/ https://amiunique.org/ (all time: 16.55% / 30 days: 60.97%) > JavaScript disabled (all time: 4.70% / 30 days: 14.09%) Surely, there are ways to track users without JavaScript, but none of them is inspected by the website. The website only inspects the headers, and from the listed information above, the tracker doesn't learn anything more than "This user is running the latest release of Tor Browser with JavaScript disabled", and at least 100,000 people are doing it right now. But because the sample size of this website is limited, it only sees the fact that these attributes seem to be a very small percentage of the overall traffic, while ignoring the fact that these headers are generic, it makes the conclusion. > "You can most certainly be tracked" Which is misleading. A Tor Browser with JavaScript disabled is still one of the most difficult browsers to track. The website actually tells you that, > But only 1440 browsers out of the 1560340 observed browsers (<0.01 %) have exactly the same fingerprint as yours. If you are the only person using the latest version of Tor Browser to access this website with JavaScript disabled, yes, you can be tracked as a "Tor user without JavaScript", and if you enter personal information, your identity can be crosstracked between websites (if you are still the only Tor user with JavaScript disabled). Otherwise, not much. Interestingly, when a new Tor Browser release comes out, there will always be an user to upgrade the browser before everyone else, then goes to a fingerprint testing website, tests the browser, and says "OMG! I'm unique and trackable!". In this case, don't panic, just keep using it, you won't be unique anymore within a week.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ggreer 7y agoSites like this and the EFF’s panopticlick err on the side of saying you can be tracked when that might not be true. For example: I visited this same site a while ago with the same device, and both times it has said I was unique. A new version of iOS came out, so my user agent changed. Unless sites are also storing unique data on your machine (through cookies or localstorage), browser fingerprinting is a crapshoot. This goes double for mobile devices.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoAnother unusual circumstance is when you're the first users who have just installed the latest software update, a fingerprint testing website will identify you as an unique user. But you won't be unique anymore within a few days. It happens a lot in the Tor mailing list. Often, a new major release of Tor Browser comes out, a user is shocked by the upgrade, "OMG! I'm unique and trackable!". Don't panic, just keep using it.
- clarry 7y agoOf course most sites that try to track you are also storing cookies or local storage. It only takes one to tie your two unique fingerprints together... of course your IP address might suffice. Or account/email address, if you're logged into a site that shares data with third parties and use the same address. I'm sure someone's also devised a way to guess how to bind two fingerprints together when OS or browser updates but many other parameters (timezone, ip, language, screen size, fonts, etc) remain similar enough.
- daniel_iversen 7y agoWould I be right in saying that if you use iOS safari (which a decent number of mobile users use) you are not very unique at all and any tracking based on browser fingerprinting is pretty useless? (Or is it the combination of a non unique browser fingerprint with a slightly more targeted origin IP address from the ISP) that makes it almost worth/possible trying to identify a person without cookies?
- snailmailman 7y agoI’m surprised at how low the percentages are on my iPhone. It says only ~35 other people have had the same fingerprint as me. I’m running safari, private mode, plus a single content blocker app.
- PebblesHD 7y agoI was quite surprised that on my iPhone 8 Plus with iOS 13 I was totally unique apparently. How exactly could that be possible if this is a device where I cannot install any plugins, change fonts, or really do anything to make it more or less different to another iPhone?
- bdz 7y ago>ANGLE (NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 Direct3D11 vs_5_0 ps_5_0) Wow I didn't know it reveals the GPU
- hmexx 7y agoMy fonts alone makes me pretty unique it seems (<0.01%). 180 or so fonts that the browser is happy to share with the world. Does seem a little unnecessary.
- Jonnax 7y agoI can't remember which but either Firefox or Chrome only send a standard list of fonts.
- hmexx 7y agoDoesn't seem to be the case. I tried both browsers and got the same result, i.e. 180+ fonts sent (<0.01% match)
- systoll 7y agoSafari does that. Firefox has an about:config preference that would let you set up a font whitelist yourself, but it doesn’t have a standard set.
- cpeterso 7y agoFirefox's preference is "font.system.whitelist". You can specify a list of which fonts are exposed to web content (such as the default set shipped with your OS). The preference is used by the Tor browser. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1121643 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1121643 Does Safari actually do something similar? On my Mac, amiunique.org reports 344 fonts in Safari, 331 in Firefox (not using "font.system.whitelist"), and 309 in Chrome.
- smoyer 7y agoMy list of fonts includes OpenDyslexic and OpenDyslexicMono and puts me at < 0.01% as well.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mNovak 7y agoQwerty keyboard layout yields 0.7% uniqueness? Do other browsers just not declare this?
- toxicFork 7y agoIn my Firefox it says "Not supported"
- 1_player 7y agoNot supported is 3.96% So anything that's not QWERTY nor "unsupported" makes up the remaining ~95%?
- kmm 7y agoAZERTY gave me 0.03%, even though France and Belgium together have >1% of the world population, and definitely more than one percent of all internet users.
- mikenew 7y agoApparently I'm the only person in the world using linux-5.4.14-zen with a Radeon VII. Which would be kinda cool if that information wasn't being broadcast to every site I visit.
- Arnavion 7y agouser_pref("webgl.enable-debug-renderer-info", false); for Firefox.
- account42 7y agoThe problem is that even if you can disable this one, it's enabled by default and browserv vendors keep adding this shit without any concern for the privacy impact.
- BenjiWiebe 7y agoAnd I'm the only person using the materialistic app (HN reader) on Android 5.1 on a 1st gen Moto X. That I can believe...
- MH15 7y agoHello from a Materialistic on Pixel user!
- fortran77 7y agoIt's not that you're special for running Linux, it's just that it's very easy to be unique! I'm running a stock Windows 10. Microsoft Edge with Ublock Origin as only browser extension. Software installed is Visual Studio, Visual Studio Code, NVidia CUDA development System, Erlang Dev System, and Microsoft Office. That's it. You'd think there would at least be "dozens" of us. Nope: > Your full fingerprint is unique among the 1572109 collected so far. User Agent is < .01% > Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/81.0.4023.0 Safari/537.36 Edg/81.0.396.0 and my fonts are < .01% > Agency FB, Aharoni, Algerian, Arial, Arial Black and 171 others Other < .01% are "WebGL Parameters", "Connection" and "Navigator Properties"
- XCSme 7y agoI have multiple attributes that are each unique: * Content language (HTTP header) * Content language (JS) * List of fonts (JS) * Media devices A bit surprised that it doesn't even need to do any fancy combinations of identifiers to get a uid in my case.
- hollander 7y agoRemember that you are unique in the list of visitors to this website. That is a limited group. You are probably unique anyway, but the numbers here are not acurate.
- verst 7y agoSame for me. Content languages are all unique. Same for fonts and media devices. Really wonder how I can hide that information from my browser...
- wink 7y agoI switched to 30d because with browser update cycles "all time" is kinda useless, imho. > Content language 31.51% en-US,en;q=0.5 This is a default Firefox. I didn't change anything. Surely there's probably only Chinese that has more users of this language? I'm not even an American or in the US... (all time it was just below 30%, not teal-colored, but already orange..) Also why is the JS result for Content language 35.40%? Whereas my list of plugins is 46.2% (higher value seems better) - but I'm absolutely sure there's at least one uncommon one among them... Hardware concurrency 16 is really interesting, 3.32%, probably all fellow Ryzen users. TLDR: Surely there are some of those properties where it absolutely makes sense to avoid the uniqueness, but others seem a bit like bullshit metrics. But on the other hand, my user agent (OS+Browser) = 7.37% is a really good sign for me. I find this a very, very high percentage. (Ok, it's Win10+Firefox, but still...)
- 1_player 7y agoAgreed, some of those stats are questionable. A basic Microsoft Edge installation with en-GB content language header has a similarity ratio of 0.18% -- really? Java enabled: true -- 0.26% Java enabled: false (on Brave) -- 8.75%
- wolco 7y agoThey make sense. en-GB would start below 5%, having en-GB on edge means someone would have to be using edge (under 1%) and not on the mobile for a mobile first site. Keeping a current java version enabled is difficult. Each browser update, each java update disables java by default now. Could be a small Brave sample size.
- kelnos 7y agoI fired up Chrome (I'm a Firefox user too), and for content-language it showed "en-US,en;q=0.9" (FF is q=0.5), so I guess each language is broken down into a few buckets.
- abjKT26nO8 7y agoI'd suspected that having JS completely disabled would make my fingerprint more distinct, since presumably few people have it disabled. However, on visiting the page with JS enabled I received a 100% unique fingerprint. Any one of the following identifies me uniquely: WebGL Renderer, List of fonts (JS), Media devices. Then there is a long list of properties which can be sniffed with JavaScript that identify me with >99.9% accuracy. When I disable JS, there are 108 browsers with the exact same fingerprint as mine. That prompts me to reconsider my policy of blocking JS. Until now, I've been blocking only third-party JS. Now I am considering blocking all JS by default.
- tln 7y agoThe most identifiable data points for me are from JS, except User agent.
- neltnerb 7y agoSame, I was one of 83 with javascript disabled, when I turned it on the information gained was way more than the information gained by knowing I have it off.
- divbzero 7y agoDitto with my browser: unique with JavaScript, but a few dozen identical browsers with JavaScript disabled. Keeping JavaScript off for now as an experiment, see how many graceful websites are still out there…
- dmje 7y agoUm..how’s your web browsing experience with no JS...?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoFast?
- 7y ago
- winrid 7y agoThis includes battery level which I think is pretty weird.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoAgreed, that was the only thing which stood out to me as a surprise. Why would any website need to know my battery level, without an explicit permission? Seems like a gross oversight.
- winrid 7y agoWell that, and it makes you appear more unique than probably desired (to the site).
- Santosh83 7y agoFingerprinting needs the active effort of browser vendors to tackle. Otherwise no amount of blocking will help as it will either identify you more uniquely or cripple browsing the web to such an extent that almost no one will opt for it. Browser vendors should implement a resist fingerprint mode where browsers respond with a set of standard, agreed-upon values, or completely random ones for those that can't have a standardised value. This will probably break browsing to some extent but not as much as the 'nuclear', disable Javascript option that everyone suggests whenever this discussion comes up. But of course most browser vendors don't have an incentive to resist fingerprinting. And if only one vendor does this then the anti-fingerprinting is likely to be less effective, as the pool of browsers is much smaller.
- tln 7y agoChrome is making user-agent non trackable (in some time).. https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-to-phase-out-user-agent-strings-in-chrome/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-to-phase-out-user-agent... I think there are actually plenty of examples where the browser vendors are doing this. Google gets so much free tracking from analytics, ads, and OpenID, I don't think they really need to resist privacy oriented browser changes. They might resist some privacy changes, idk, and are probably trailing safari and firefox and brave etc
- Angeo34 7y agoBrave is easier to fingerprint than Internet Explorer
- dorgo 7y agoWouldn't a user script be enough? Just hack all the APIs javascript has access to to return random or default values before the first website script is executed.
- jefftk 7y agoI don't think your user script will apply to IFrames? So all the fingerprinter would have to do is open an iFrame, get a fresh JS environment, and run their code there. (Separately, your proposal would break tons of sites.)
- simias 7y agoThe site tells me that 41% of users share my web browser, that is Firefox. That seems insanely high given the general market share of FF. Any idea why it's so popular on this website? Of course I would expect privacy conscious people to be more likely to use FF but 40+% seems unbelievably huge especially when you factor mobile browsers and the like.
- vdfs 7y agoProbably because must of that website users worry about their privacy and use Firefox instead of Chrome But Chromium show as 0.66% share and Chrome show 38.28% usage share
- verst 7y agoWhat is most surprising to me: Apparently my content language (JavaScript) alone is already unique (en-US,en,de,zh-CN,zh). Being a native German speaker who speaks American English (I live in the US) and Chinese and actually has those languages enabled in their operating system. Without JavaScript enabled the HTTP header for Content language is <0.01% -- (en-US,en;q=0.9,de;q=0.8,zh-CN;q=0.7,zh;q=0.6) Is there any way to have a language installed in the operating system without leaking that information to the browser?
- vdfs 7y agoI've changed my language to only "en-US,en;q=0.9" and it show as 8.05% You can do that in Chrome from Settings > Languages, remove what you don't need, but i guess you will lose auto-correct for those languages
- missblit 7y agoThere is (I'm assuming you mean to the web, not to the browser). On Firefox: Options -> Language -> Choose your preferred language for displaying pages
- Taniwha 7y agoYeah I get the same from: en-NZ,zh-CN,zh,en-GB,en-US,en
- robocat 7y agoBrowsers could defend against this (especially in combo with central malicious site protection) : no legitimate page should be using many of these features, and certainly not the combination of features. Also turning JavaScript off helps (although that becomes a signal too, just like DNT).
- crorella 7y agoWhy not intercept the different system calls and randomize their outputs?
- nebulous1 7y agoThis is great. I knew fingerprinting in this fashion was possible, but seeing the actual figures attached to some of these headers and attributes is a real eye-opener.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoAll time : However, your full fingerprint is unique among the 1556046 collected so far. Android - default Chrome. --- Fyi, this whole tracking thing isn't that hard to circomemvent. You only need one parameter to change to generate a unique hash. With all the parameters they include, this should be done fairly easy.
- floatingatoll 7y agoIt accurately identifies my model of iPhone and that I’m running an iOS beta, but it doesn’t appear to know anything that isn’t “I am an iOS developer”. That’s probably still something that can be tracked, but it boils down entirely to User-Agent which will vary weekly in lockstep with thousands of others. I am hesitant to extend the result that I can be uniquely tracked to category “iOS developers” beyond that.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoHaving a billion people using the exact same model of a computer (iPhone), with almost identical hardware, software, peripherals, and system configuration, is surely an advantage in terms of anti-tracking. I recommend you to try visiting the same page on your computer, the slightest variation of your hardware or software configuration will pinpoint your identity to 99% certainty: What is the position tolerance of your canvas? What is the list of fonts or browser plugins you have installed? What is the latency of your audio interface?
- floatingatoll 7y agoI use an Apple computer, too, and I only use the system fonts, don’t use adblockers in any browser, and don’t use plugins either. (Yes, I know how tracking works. It’s ironic to watch people realize that all their protest actions are tracking beacons. I wish it was more widely understood that being obvious is a consequence of being obviously different.)
- cnst 7y ago> WebGL Renderer Wait, any website knows what sort of graphics card I have?! Or how many CPUs? That's just ridiculous! No wonder folks can write and target exploits so perfectly nowadays! If it's an integrated graphics, you have the processor family, easy. Wow. Why would any random site need to know this sorts of information when all I'm trying to do is read text and view images?
- segfaultbuserr 7y ago> when all I'm trying to do is read text and view images? Often, the "images" on the web are increasingly becoming 3D graphics dynamically generated and rendered by OpenGL on-the-fly, perhaps real-time ray-tracing is coming soon... You can see a lot of applications of in-browser 3D graphics on data visualization websites, for example. And naturally, the program needs these information to render graphics, but it can be repurposed as a tracking tool. I disable WebGL manually, and use it only when it's necessary. There are a few plugins that allow you to manage it as well, for example, NoScript, but it's overkill to use it just for this single task. I think the solution should be an opt-in option. WebGL shouldn't be activated unless the user gives the permission to a specific, first-party website.
- cnst 7y agoThanks for the idea, I just toggled the "webgl.disabled" switch in about:config; we'll see what difference it makes; I would only assume that my browsing will become faster now and will crash less frequently. Is there a list of these useless things that any sane user should disable? I already have had fonts disabled with "gfx.downloadable_fonts.enabled" toggled away from the default; any other useless attack vectors with buffer overflows could likewise be disabled?
- mirimir 7y agoYeah, I always disable WebGL. I was really freaked to discover that all Debian family VMs on a given VirtualBox host have the same WebGL fingerprint. Same for all Windows VMs, all Red Hat family VMs, etc. But then you can't see all the cool WebGL stuff that gets posted here.
- CapacitorSet 7y agoAll the fingerprinting tools I've seen so far do not include JA3 signatures, which in my opinion make for an interesting bit of information - they introduce few bits of entropy since they depend on the TLS implementation, but for the same reason they can't be easily spoofed. Plugging in an article and demo I wrote some time ago: https://jwlss.pw/ja3/ https://jwlss.pw/ja3/
- GordonS 7y agoI was going to mention the lack of TCP and TLS fingerprinting too - I wonder if those are actually used by rogue advertisers? Also, I guess TLS fingerprints would change over time, with browser upgrades, although I'd expect changes to be relatively infrequent.
- wholeness 7y agoHow much of this requires JS to detect and then send to the server? as opposed to can be processed entirely server-side?
- qwerty456127 7y agoHow do I configure Chrome spell checking dictionaries without letting it inform the websites about the languages I use? The set of languages makes me unique.
- air7 7y agoSomething here doesn't add up. I'm unique even on my standard Samsung S10e with up-to-date Chrome or the stock browser. My screen height has a similarly ratio of 0.11%. My user agent is <0.01%. Perhaps their data is under-representing mobiles? I can see how fingerprinting would work on a Windows PC with its vast number of possible combinations of cpu/gpu/installed system fonts/add ons etc. But how would this works on mobile?
- Tagbert 7y agoYea, I’ve gone there using a stock iphone and a stock iPad both using Safari and neither one with custom fonts, plugins, etc. iPhone: only 48 browsers have exactly this fingerprint IPad: only 14 browsers have this fingerprint. My list of fonts is only 0.55% similar And user agent is only 0.34% similar Those are hard to believe on a device where these things really don’t get customized.
- tinco 7y agoMy fingerprint is unique apparently. Some water got in my main phone, so now I'm using an older Android 7.0 phone with Firefox. Just that fact got me to 0.02% of all users.
- ff7c11 7y agoThe results on https://panopticlick.eff.org https://panopticlick.eff.org seem much more accurate. Probably since Panopticlick by EFF is more well-known and therefore has better data.
- ac130kz 7y agoThey also recommend to install Ublock botnet (not Ublock Origin) and to enable DNT (a well-known way to track), I wouldn't trust those guys
- 32gbsd 7y agoI am pretty sure I am going to be unique browsing on a version of chrome which is 65 versions old so I am not even going to jump into that pool.
- emmanueloga_ 7y agoReminds me of evercookie. Previously, in HN ... [1] (10 years ago!) 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1714446 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1714446
- kelnos 7y agoI was surprised that being in the US Pacific time zone was only shared by 2.25% of their data set. Assuming users are evenly distributed across time zones, it'd be 4.2%; but of course they aren't evenly distributed, and I'd expect the west coast of the US to have a disproportionately large number of internet users as well as people who would visit a website like this. (Though, to be fair, they go by UTC offset, so it's only UTC-8 for a few months of the year due to DST. That probably affects the number; maybe the percentage is higher for UTC-7.)
- Izmaki 7y agoThere’s a lot more Asians/TZ than Americans/TZ
- smoyer 7y agoI am unique! It looks like the main culprit is that I'm running Firefox Developer Edition so my reported version is a tiny percent of all users and combined with Linux, Firefox, UTC-5 and en, that makes me one in 1561147.
- kelnos 7y agoIt really bothers me that all this information is available through JS (no, please don't suggest I disable it). Why does a website need to know the list of installed fonts? Why can they enumerate the list of "videoinput" and "audioinput" devices before they've asked for video/microphone permission? Why is information about how I've set various permissions (prompt vs. allow vs. deny) available? Exposing the visibility of menu/tool/personal/status bar is just weird (though for me all of them say "Visible", which isn't the case, so I guess Firefox is lying).
- cperciva 7y agoI can't speak to the rest, but the list of installed fonts is presumably so that websites can decide whether to download a font or to pick from the options already available.
- marcosdumay 7y agoIn CSS you list the fonts you want, and the browser will decide if it downloads them or not. There is simply no reason JS shouldn't do the same.
- cperciva 7y agoIt's easy to specify a font in CSS and then watch to see if the browser downloads it or not. JS isn't revealing anything which you can't already trivially get.
- marcosdumay 7y agoFor a start, you have to specify it. If I have some weird font installed, you don't get to know it for free. Anyway, if the site had to ask for the fonts, it would be viable for the browsers to impose some sane limitations on their API.
- mnm1 7y agoI have JS turned off and still have plenty of other factors that make me unique so it's not just JS. My question is why is the rest of the information available / given, especially the user agent? The other headers mostly make sense. I can see the argument to turn 'do not track' off. But user agent? I've been making websites and apps for almost a quarter century and have never even read of a good use for that outside the tracking industry, let alone seen a good use of it.
- leoh 7y ago"(<0.01 %) have exactly the same fingerprint as yours." If Apple cares about privacy, they need to get on this in mobile Safari ASAP.
- acdha 7y agoThat made me want to see whether the calculations have some assumptions about variables being independent: it seems unlikely that the default browser on an OS shipping in 7+ volumes has various headers, fonts, etc. which are so identifying. I could believe some hardware variation with canvas/WebGL but the iOS font list wasn’t even customizable until 13.
- proidgeree1 7y agoHonest question here about the risk of being “unique”...: If my unique identifier changes with each browser version + os version + timezone + build id + fontpack + screen size... am I really trackable through this vector? Those things change all the time for me at least. Seems like a very short term method of tracking at best. Why should we be afraid of these things? I had the same question about panopticlick (or whatever EFF called it).
- mobjack 7y agoFingerprinting has lots of flaws like you mentioned. Too many people have similar devices for it to be the primary way to track people. It is really a backup method of tracking that works some of the time based on a probabilistic match. Your IP address is also a big factor in finding a match.
- c3534l 7y agoNo one has the same fonts I do, apparently. You could also probably infer my occupation from my preponderance of monospaced fonts. I'm surprised to find that simply by having Ubuntu that I tweaked to my liking and a laptop, you can uniquely identify me by how much screen space I have left. Can anyone give me an explanation of how the media devices thing works, though? Is video in and audio in given some random hash which websites can then use as the random hash which identifies me?
- muxator 7y agoOnly 4% of the users who visited this test page use Ubuntu. Linux on the desktop is really not a thing.
- xioxox 7y agoDoesn't seem so bad. It's probably double that number including other distributions. Desktop users are also diluted by all those mobile users.
- clarry 7y agoWhere does it say your distro? For me, it just detects that it's Linux (all time: 8.15%), while Platform is Linux x86_64 (all time: 10.93%). Kinda funny that there are more x86_64 Linux users than Linux users. Makes me wonder whether Ubuntu users are considered Linux users at all..
- londons_explore 7y agoI doubt the accuracy of this fingerprint. It claims my user agent (the latest stable Google Chrome - default browser - on a stock Umidigi android device) is unique. Considering there are probably 5 million people worldwide with my setup, I am surprised it's unique.
- suixo 7y agoKeep in mind that those 5 million people did not submit their fingerprint on this website, so they are not "known" by this tool.
- darkkindness 7y agoI use Firefox on Android with NoScript and an adblocker. Yet I'm uniquely identifiable. One culprit is screen size putting me at <0.01%. Does that make defeating fingerprinting on mobile hopeless for the casual user? Edit: more info. All JS is blocked, and I have privacy.resistFingerprinting. The page doesn't detect my adblocker. Still, there are just too many things I can't change: - hardware concurrency: 1.7% - audio formats: 0.2% - navigator properties: 0.2% - audio data: 0.1% I was surprised at this one: - Media devices: Unique What are media device identifiers for, exactly? Why does the browser supply it without JS?
- dorgo 7y agoIf I disable Javascript (or don't enable it) I see everywhere 'NA' (except for HTTP headers) and no similarity rates are shown. Are you sure your Javascript is disabled?
- jokoon 7y agoWhat is the best way to disable javascript on firefox? Is there an addon that can whitelist certain websites to not disable javascript everywhere, while turning it of by default? EDIT: I just discovered ublock origin can disable js by default. Now I wish I could change the user agent...
- duck 7y agoHow can the percentage be greater than 100%?
- mirimir 7y agoBrowser fingerprints being so unique cuts both ways. So if I hit this site from the VM that one of my evil twins uses, its Firefox fingerprint will also be ~unique. And I can have lots of VMs. Maybe not all running at once, but still. And yeah, they use different exit VPNs.
- bhrgunatha 7y agoGiven the number of ways of fingerprinting, how can we reduce our uniqueness? Is it even possible not to be unique?
- quotz 7y agoHow to protect?
- tmoravec 7y ago> 30 days : But only 40 browsers out of the 10774 observed browsers (<0.01 %) have exactly the same fingerprint as yours. Updated iPhone Safari. En locale. I have hard time believing it's that unique.
- longtom 7y agoThis misses innerHeight, availHeight etc. which are also highly idiosyncratic due to different settings of the dock/task bar size, installed browser plug-ins, opened bookmark side windows and bars etc.
- nneonneo 7y agoThe Media Devices query might always return "unique" on some browsers (e.g. Firefox). Firefox, for example, returns a random string which persists for that origin across a single browsing session (but which is different after the browser is restarted, for example). It's therefore like a cookie, but weaker in that it gets cleared on browser restart (and, in private browsing, it's always changing). So it's not very useful for tracking, since a site could just use a cookie instead. If that's your only Unique attribute, then your browser might be less unique than the website claims.
- axegon 7y agoThough I'm not surprised by the results, the one that sticks out most to me is the content language: > Content language <0.01% en-US,en,bg,es Bruh... 0.01%?!!? Seriously?!?!?
- oneeyedpigeon 7y agoI’m en-gb alone and that’s only 0.69%. By comparison, 0.01% for the highly specific combination of languages you have set doesn’t seem that strange.
- Tomte 7y agoOver the last seven days, 109,5 percent of all users have been using my operating system, and 129,86 percent of users have been using my web browser? I think not.
- dmje 7y agoRead this, did it, felt vaguely appalled. But: seems to me that if you do something unusual (turn off JS, use weird and wonderful browser, hide browser stuff from The Internet) then you make yourself even "more unique". Turning JS off still doesn't really help - and more to the point makes the modern web basically unusable. I ended up with: meh, nothing anyone can do, why worry?
- enriquto 7y ago> Turning JS off still doesn't really help - and more to the point makes the modern web basically unusable. I have the opposite experience. Turning JS off makes the modern web much more usable! Regarding "uniqueness", if you browse from a fixed IP address then you are unique anyway and your browser fingerprint does not really matter.
- oneeyedpigeon 7y agoDo you have a good example of a reasonably high profile site that is unusable without js? One option (I know this sounds like a lot of work!) would be to disable js and whitelist only those sites you trust not to track you, that require js to be usable.
- cyphar 7y agoIt's a bit strange that they recommend using the Tor Browser, but the Tor Browser is shown as being "unique" using their fingerprinting setup. Presumably this is just a lack of data rather than a real claim that browsers like the Tor Browser are actually not sufficiently resisting fingerprinting (after all, apparently 55% of people they've got data for use Linux and 41% use Firefox!).
- FabHK 7y agoFWIW, my Tor Browser also shows up as unique. Just the fonts alone are <0.01%.
- chx 7y agoIs this dataset correct? The accelerometer, gyroscope and proximity sensor has a ~9% false ratio here which I intepret as 9% laptops/desktops and 91% phones. That's a bit too many phones. But use of Adblock is over 34%. Also, I see 15.36% Chrome PDF Plugin and 23.81% Native Client both which only exist on PCs and again doesn't really mesh with only 9% non-phone. What's going on...? Are there laptops with all three things listed...? Also, everything else puts Chrome market share above 60% these days, only 38% here.
- XelNika 7y ago> The accelerometer, gyroscope and proximity sensor has a ~9% false ratio here which I intepret as 9% laptops/desktops and 91% phones. Some of the stats are clearly broken. For the 7 day duration, those stats are closer to 95% false. For the 90 days duration, I see values like Platform 153.00% Linux x86_64 Screen height 253.53% 1080 Media devices 159.95% Timeout > Also, I see 15.36% Chrome PDF Plugin and 23.81% Native Client I don't see PDF reader stats at all. > Also, everything else puts Chrome market share above 60% these days, only 38% here. Easily explained by bias if it's even correct. The kinds of people who would try this service are also the kinds of people who would use a niche browser.
- hacker_9 7y agoHang on, how is this unique: Keyboard layout 0.09% Qwerty Is this saying less than 1% of users use a Querty keyboard? I must be living under a rock if that's the case.
- sergioro 7y agomy user-agent (in particular my Linux distribution) was making me unique. To be "less unique" i went to about:config and created these preferences: general.useragent.override: "user_agent" general.useragent.overridepreference: "user_agent" replace user_agent the UA of your choice. This made me less trackable according to https://panopticlick.eff.org https://panopticlick.eff.org and https://amiunique.org https://amiunique.org
- 0xff00ffee 7y agoFunny, this website has been posted over a dozen times on HN since 2014, and only recently has it broken above 10 points to 512! Look at this link: https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=amiunique.org https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=amiunique.org