9 ms·
This should be interesting. Maybe they’re both guilty of wrongdoing. In the end it’ll likely be difficult for them to prevail over Google. Plus, as many peop
by mc32 7y ago
This should be interesting.
Maybe they’re both guilty of wrongdoing. In the end it’ll likely be difficult for them to prevail over Google.
Plus, as many people have said over and over, leave your politics at home, despite this “bring your whole self to work”. It just opens you up to more scrutiny. Of course google is to blame for fostering this attitude. I’m sure they regret their initial idealism and realize you simply cannot mould people into your vision any more than a few societies have tried and failed at raising the perfect citizen.
To be clear, there is a right to unionize. There isn’t a right to politicize work and bring your personal politics into the work realm.
I don’t want to hear your take on 1A, 2A, reproductive rights, medical rights, whatever, at work unless it’s a conversation we volunteer to enjoin in.
- hprotagonist 7y ago“leave your politics at home” must remain explicitly disjoint from “workers have a right to self organization”. if it doesn’t, then workers don’t have a right to self organization , and that, uh, doesn’t end well.
- danharaj 7y ago"leave your politics at home" while working for a company that is shaping tomorrow's society. that is to say, adopt the politics of your boss at work. i don't like that.
- hprotagonist 7y ago“inaction is implicit support of the status quo” is, unfortunately, true.
- mc32 7y agoIsn’t that why people have a right to vote?
- t34543 7y agoYes, I would rather see Google accept/tolerate all political viewpoints. Google is mostly liberal but that doesn’t represent everyone. They have a significant influence. We should all be free to form our own opinions, whatever they may be, and not fear retribution from anyone.
- arkades 7y agoDon’t work there? Vote for policies that shape tomorrow? “Accept large sums of money for building your boss’ vision for tomorrow while complaining about it” has a lot going for it, but I have a hard time actually sympathizing for folks that think they’ve a right to that.
- mc32 7y agoI see your point but allowing workers to decide the politics of a company is populism. People feel confident because they have many like minded colleagues. What happens when the winds change? Are people going to be happy when the workers of Exxon decide that it’s in their best interest to extract from some wildlife refuge? It’s not a good idea. We have laws that should govern corporations and businesses . It should not be a referendum for everything.
- bluntfang 7y agoAre you suggesting that Exxon doesn't already lobby governments to make the laws that allow them to extract oil from places where they really probably shouldn't? And that the employee's opinions don't matter?
- bluntfang 7y agocan anyone help me with why this post got downvoted?
- pjc50 7y agoIf not the workers deciding what the politics of a company, then who? It's going to be a much smaller number of people from a much more privileged class; the managers and key shareholders. > Are people going to be happy when the workers of Exxon decide that it’s in their best interest to extract from some wildlife refuge? No, but that's because they're not happy when the managers of Exxon decide that either? Really the underlying problem is that giant companies and especially media companies like Google have a very large amount of political power. Almost more than the big parties, and certainly more than the average grassroots organisation. How google uses that power matters. If Google want to be apolitical, the very first step should be to end all their corporate political donations and PACs. A good second step would be to end all recommendations (ie free promotion) for political videos on youtube.
- zarkov99 7y agoWell, I don't like a bunch of activist techies trying to shape tomorrow's society using the assets of their host corporation. The answer, I believe, is to reduce the "shaping" impact of corporations in the first place.
- mc32 7y agoI think these things are distinct. You can advocate for unionization without being political. For example you can advocate for unions but you don’t have to conflate that with your personal politics.
- danharaj 7y agoIf you don't consider unions a political issue then what is your definition of politics? The organization of labor is one of the central pillars of civilization and has been political since time immemorial.
- goatinaboat 7y ago“We should have a Union to negotiate with management” is orthogonal to “we should cease all work for law enforcement”.
- danharaj 7y agoSo which politics are OK and which aren't? They're both politics even if they're "orthogonal".
- goatinaboat 7y agoThe first one is protected by law, which is what this case hinges on. But it’s not at all clear that everyone who wants a union at work also shares an identical opinion on open borders, drone strikes, facial recognition etc etc
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe kind of politics where you point at specific people or groups and say "ooh, they're nasty" isn't OK.
- shadowgovt 7y agoUnions have traditionally painted management as adversarial to employee best interests. Is agitating for unionization therefore the kind of politics that isn't okay?
- BickNowstrom 7y agoOk. Then bring your politics to work. But when you have to make a difficult decision (whether to ban a popular Youtuber for hate speech), make that decision based on precedent, the good of the company, and for the users. Don't view it as a personal attack to your political beliefs, and default to banning when the free speech happens to clash with your beliefs, while defaulting to complaining when people talking about LGBT+ rights get demonitized. Also, if you are allowed to take your politics to work, accept that others may bring their opposing politics to work too. The vocal conservative-right Googlers are in the minority, and are mistreated as such by the political power brokers. A union should be for all the workers.
- ummonk 7y agoThe NLRA protect's worker's rights to organize around labor conditions at the workplace. Labor conditions are only a subset of politics.
- Hokusai 7y ago>, leave your politics at home, If you accept sexual harassment, abuse of power, support of dictatorial regimes, etc. at the workplace you are going to live in a hell hole for the lest of your life. I will recommend being smart about politics and do it from inside a union or other protected group. But, to never just accept that things are bad without remedy. We have gotten really far as a society to give up now that things are easier to change than ever. > I’m sure they regret their initial idealism What great things Google have done since? Google is big enough and rich enough to not have to innovate or do anything interesting anymore. Google is just another part of the system. But, for any startup is impossible to succeed without people involved with strong believes and able to move and inspire others. Google change makes sense from an economic perspective. But, as a society hurts us and we need to fix their attitude individually and together through unions and other collective actions.
- cobbzilla 7y ago> In the end it’ll likely be difficult for them to prevail over Google Why do you believe this is true? CA has arguably the most employee-favorable laws in the country, particularly wrt workplace discrimination. I would withhold judgement until more facts come to light; an important one being which legal firm(s) they have chosen to represent them. If I had to bet now: Google settles before it goes to trial; plaintiffs walk away very rich in exchange for signing a non-disparagement agreement; no one else will know the full story.
- lightedman 7y ago"Maybe they’re both guilty of wrongdoing." If she had personal photos on the phone, she had copyright on those and Google flat-out violated that specific right by denying her access to her works. Remember, what's written in a contract cannot go against the law. Copyright is very firmly enshrined in our legal system.
- cameldrv 7y agoCopyright says that Google can't copy her photos without her permission. It creates no obligation for them to not delete them or provide any kind of access.
- wnoise 7y agoCopyright is not deleteright.
- ddalex 7y agoOr non delete right.
- nkrisc 7y agoThat's the strangest interpretation of copyright law I've ever seen.
- lightedman 7y agoYou're destroying property and work. Denying someone access to their work is just as bad as usurping control over it. Remember, copyright gives the owner of the work full control over it. For Google to remove that specific control without a court order means they're violating the law. Go read chapters 2 and 5 of Title 17. This makes it abundantly clear.
- shadowgovt 7y agoIf you store your copyrighted paintings in a storage unit, cease to pay for that unit, and fail to clear that unit, the owner of the storage company has the right to dispose of your personal belongings. It's understood in the contracts one signs when renting a storage unit. There is similar understanding about how de-corpification works if someone's phone gets de-corped (though I doubt most employees read the fine print).
- grumple 7y agoLife is political. "Leave your politics at home" has been a driver of injustice and war crimes for ages. "I don't think we should murder Jews" was political speech and verboden in the Reich. Work is the most significant part of our lives in terms of how much time it requires. It's a give and take - you can ask for concessions from your employer just as they can ask for concessions from you. It's not just "accept everyone and everything exactly as it was before", that's ludicrous. And unionizing has been made political by corporations - it's simply a smart and legally protected right to improve workers' negotiation power in the face of huge corporations. Hiring women and racial minorities at all, and then to particular positions, was a political issue for a long time. It still is, in many places and companies in the world (hiring a woman or minority to positions could get you killed). The idea that politics and people and corporations are not intimately intertwined is a reflection of privilege.
- mc32 7y agoSure life is political. We can have protests, vote for candidates, engage in civil disobedience and all that. What I don’t want is anyone making it a point to bring their personal politics to work. We have other forums for that. Don’t politicize every part of our existence. I wanna go to work and provide some productivity to my employer. If I don’t like their politics I can vote at the ballot box, donate to causes, volunteer etc. I don’t need to bring my POVs to work. You may not like mine, I may not like yours. We don’t need this kind of confrontation at work. Unionization is political but it’s on a different plane. It’s worker vs employer rather than potentially worker vs worker. Do we really want to approach a time when one group of workers takes one side, another takes another side and they protest against each other and cause disruption to the vast majority who have no interest in getting personally involved? Presumably both groups would have this “right” though be their opinions different.
- biztos 7y agoI share your preference for keeping politics out of the office, but: * In the US, and in Tech, I hardly think trying to organize a union is going to not have worker v. worker politics. "We should organize" involves all kinds of Why's and How's about which there are widely divergent opinions among today's workforce. * Employers routinely bring politics into the office, for starters by funding Political Action Committees and lobbying for what they perceive to be in "the company's" interest. I actually heard a COO in an all-hands once say "yeah I guess we don't support the Democrats <chuckle>" -- so if your employer is going to make their support of Candidate X part of the work culture, is there any reason other than job security why I'd want to keep my support for Candidate Y under wraps?
- threatofrain 7y ago"Leave your politics at home" is more stupid than ever as we think about unions. Politics is the negotiation of power, and unions are a counterbalancing act to power. Any conversation about minority outreach is a discussion of power. The talk around immigration and H1-B visas is a conversation about power.
- shadowgovt 7y agoUnions are political constructs, so by definition a right to unionize implies a right to politicize work (at least for a narrow wedge of "politicize"). And Google spans such a wide range of users' lives, that at Google at least, it's going to be hard to do one's job properly in a lot of areas of the company without having some political / philosophical conversations about free speech (YouTube bans and censorship), the right to bear arms (Google's block against firearm ads), etc. One can consider the decisions the company makes to be divorced from political issues, but politics ultimately rides atop philosophy, and companies are entities within societies, so the politics will inevitably come into play. If political strategic decisions are something Google is deciding is "above the pay grade" of swathes of engineers, that's a decision they can make but it is a shift for the company from its roots.