24 ms·
Smart TVs sending sensitive user data to Netflix and Facebook
- taurath 7y agoI wonder - how prevalent is this in vehicles now? My car probably knows where I am, what podcasts I listen to, my daily routine, all sorts of things. It can connect via 3g without me knowing it and send all sorts of usage data. This is why regulation is IMPORTANT. A whole industry can decide this is their business model, an industry where competitors can't really get in, and consumers are screwed. Well just don't drive a car, just don't use a tv is not a valid argument.
- metafunctor 7y agoDo these TVs have different default settings for the EU market (GDPR)? If not, this seems like a great way to get slapped with handsome fines for GDRP noncompliance...
- ping_pong 7y agoThis is why I (currently) trust Apple, because they appear to care about privacy. I am not blinding myself to the possibility that this may change, but right now this is their selling poin tto me.
- slivanes 7y agoApple cares about privacy enough to make Google their default search provider for many billions each year. Apple pays lip service to your privacy and obviously cares more about money just like any other corporation.
- throwaway122378 7y agoYou can make DuckDuckGo your default search engine on all Apple devices. Apple is definitely a for profit business and they charge for their products instead of subsidizing with data aggregation or theft.
- bryan_w 7y agoStill doesn't change the fact that if Apple was principled on privacy, they would refuse google's billions in spy money and wouldn't, by default, send their customers to Google search engine to be harvested
- throwaway122378 7y agoI hear ya but if DDG doubled googles offer Apple would change the default. They are for profit and don’t hide it. Google and Facebook on the other hand hide or at least try to hide their illegal business models
- a_imho 7y agoIt is not their fault the highest bidder is the shadiest of them all? That is some weird mental gymnastics to give Apple some moral high ground.
- askafriend 7y agoApple takes more proactive steps to ensuring user privacy than anyone else in the industry at their scale. They put out products that are by far the privacy conscious of the bunch. Statements like yours seem to exist in some weird ideological vacuum. Reality is far messier and much more nuanced. So unless you're willing to let your ideology clash with reality to produce something of value in the real world, it's essentially grandstanding.
- neonate 7y agohttp://archive.is/vB4XC http://archive.is/vB4XC
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kminehart 7y agoWhen can I buy a TV without smart features? I don't doubt that my smart TV is reporting some data about my usage, but I barely have a choice in the matter.
- Despegar 7y agoBlock your TV from having internet access and get an Apple TV
- Simon_says 7y agoYou can buy it, but it's called a "monitor". Projectors also work.
- journalctl 7y agoTVs and monitors serve different purposes, as evidenced by them having different features.
- cesarb 7y agoA monitor wouldn't have a built-in ISDB-Tb receiver. To me, that's the defining feature which distinguishes between a "TV" and a "monitor": a TV has a built-in receiver for over-the-air TV broadcasts, while a monitor doesn't.
- CraneWorm 7y agoThere is an increasing number of monitors running Android. Projectors are safe for now, but I think it's because they are seen as a niche/hipster thing.
- cactus2093 7y agoIt's surprising to me that you can't find a single medium or high-ish end TV without smart features, but at the same time chromecast/firetv/apple tv units and sticks also seem to be selling very well. Is everyone just putting up with the shitty built-in smart interface, but then switching inputs to their separate unit of choice?
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoAndroid phones talk to Facebook too even if you don't have an account or any of their apps.
- huhtenberg 7y agoSource?
- lern_too_spel 7y agoIf you run an app that uses Facebook libraries. This is true on iOS, the web, and any other platform as well.
- _verandaguy 7y agoThis feels less like an Android issue than it is a Facebook issue (which I say without implicitly defending Google's privacy-breach record).
- propogandist 7y agothe first things most apps try to do is attempt to connect w/ graph.facebook.com at launch (and periodically) this is true for your banking apps to music apps like Pandora and Spotify you can get Netguard, which functions as VPN/Firewall and get visibility into the data exfilitration that is happening right now on your Android phone (and block some of it). Similar things should exist on iPhone too CCC had some coverage recently, but this has been happening for a long long time - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0vlD7r-kTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0vlD7r-kTc * google apps are also constantly trying to phone home and panic when they cannot connect to the mothership, causing signficant battery drain... I haven't seen them trying to call facebook directly though
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoFacebook.com will show up in NoRoot Firewall after a factory restore. For me the "MyPhone" system component does it as well as the default camera app.
- amdelamar 7y agoOne of the first images to appear on my Samsung TV, after purchasing and plugging it in to the power outlet, was a prompt asking to connect to my WiFi. They almost got me, but thankfully there was an option to skip that step. But I'm sure they'd hook my parents and friends for sure.
- farisjarrah 7y agoNext time, make a VLAN with its own Wifi, then connect the TV to that VLAN and then what you want to do is block any incoming or outgoing network traffic to the smart TV. If you do this then no one else can attempt to hijack or connect to your TV and the TV wont ask you to connect it to a network, because its already connected to a network. This worked great on my LG smart TV.
- amdelamar 7y agoThat's cool. I also saw someone mention PI-hole. I'd pick whichever method is easiest to setup for my parents, and lowest-maintenance so they don't have to call me. ;)
- RussianCow 7y agoWhat is the point of doing this as opposed to just skipping that step? Does it keep nagging you? Or are certain features disabled if you don't connect?
- blackflame7000 7y agoI would skip the VLAN step and just block communication from the TV to the internet. That way you could still access media on other devices on your lan via DLNA or something
- PenguinCoder 7y agoWhat happens when you want to use Netflix, Amazon prime, or an external Plex server with the smart TV? You NEED internet access for those
- the_svd_doctor 7y agoI tried to never connect my Smart TV to anything, but I realized one day (when someone's stuff was playing on it without me accepting any request...) it connected an open network in my residence. The only trick that worked to prevent it from connecting was putting the wrong password, and let it loop forever, trying to connect. Ugly.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoI have an extra SSID which has no internet access and logs all of the things for exactly this reason.
- inafewwords 7y agoPick up anything interesting off your IoT and smart devices
- spydum 7y agoI would imagine. Otho g but a bunch of DNS queries? Maybe the occasional fall back hardcoded IP?
- mastazi 7y agoThat's a very good idea! Thank you for sharing!
- milofeynman 7y agoWhat's the simple setup for something like this?
- sp332 7y agoLots of consumer routers these days let you set parental controls. Disable access entirely, or put time limits on it, then remove all the allowed times.
- paulie_a 7y agoUbiqti makes it really simple Basically create a new hidden ssid and make a new rout that goes nowhere Then enter SSID and password into the tv You can monitor that interface too
- isostatic 7y agoJust wait for TVs and other gadgets with built in 5g and iot sim cards that you can’t simply “skip network” on.
- 0xEFF 7y agoMany new cars already have this anti-feature.
- Godel_unicode 7y ago5g is incredibly sensitive to physical interference, I'm sure someone will make a cool looking antenna cover for popular models.
- favorited 7y agoI was shocked when a medical device I got had a built-in CDMA modem to send telemetry to my insurance company. Thankfully there's an airplane mode.
- abstractbarista 7y agoThat's terrifying! If it weren't for the airplane mode, I'd open it up and destroy the antenna traces.
- isostatic 7y agoJust hope it's not a pacemaker
- abacadaba 7y agoPatient appears to not be using device, increase rates accordingly.
- favorited 7y agoThat's pretty much what it's for! If you don't use the modem, you need to export usage data onto an SD card and mail it in. Conceptually, I understand that they don't want to continue paying for a therapy if you're not actually using the equipment. But having a wireless modem built-in is a bridge too far.
- throw03172019 7y agoI disabled WiFi on my Samsung TV after they were injecting ads into the home screen. Spend $800 to get ads served in their shitty/slow UI.
- lrem 7y agoAn acquaintance attempted that with Kindle, by keeping it in flight mode. After some days it popped up a message kindly asking to give it some network access. After a few more days it simply ignored the flight mode and connected to get fresh ads. Edit: I've checked with my wife who has an ad supported Kindle for over a year and keeps it in flight mode for months at a time. It never did that to her. So either Amazon changed that a long time ago, or I've believed a lie.
- cameronbrown 7y ago> After a few more days it simply ignored the flight mode and connected to get fresh ads. Worrying. "Flight" mode exists for a reason and should not be overridden.
- arcticbull 7y agoFlight mode exists because the FAA applies unsafe-until-proven-safe methodology to everything flight related (as they should). If flight mode mattered at all planes would be falling out of the sky on the regular, many people just leave their phones on the whole trip. The only reason I turn my phone off is because it wastes a lot of battery as it tries to manage tower hopping the whole time. Planes are getting blasted by RF in the cellular bands continuously from the ground, too, so this is taken into consideration in the design process. Don't get me wrong the Kindle shouldn't do what it's doing but it's by no means a safety issue.
- jacquesm 7y ago> Planes are getting blasted by RF in the cellular bands continuously from the ground, too, so this is taken into consideration in the design process. It's a totally different affair if you are receiving a signal by a 100 Watt transmitter at 10 Km or a signal from a 1 Watt transmitter at 5 meters distance. The 1 Watt transmitter will overpower anything in its band with great ease and any dirt on the spectral output will have the same effect in other bands. Note that most cellphones will crank up their output if they can't connect to a base station that they can receive. Of course plane designers will still do what they can to reduce this nuisance but leaving our phone on makes it harder than it should be. Please turn your phone off or to airplane mode and consider it a very small price to pay for flying an airplane. Yes, flight mode does matter, no it probably won't crash a plane but does it have to before you would consider following a very simple rule?
- tibbon 7y agoMy LG C8, which I've done anything on with apps aside from installing Amazon, Youtube and Netflix (which I hope are "safe" and "reputable") is frequently trying to connect out with what appears to be a rootkit in Googling: > Threat Management Alert 1: A Network Trojan was Detected. Signature ET MALWARE Misspelled Mozilla User-Agent (Mozila). From: 192.168.1.x:46372, to: 23.52.164.68:80, protocol: TCP My firewall picks this up, otherwise I'd never know it.
- Godel_unicode 7y agoThat's a really loose signature, it's just a misspelling which is actually pretty common in low-qa software that talks to the internet. The dst IP in your alert is an akamai one according to centralops.
- sys_64738 7y agoDid anybody really believe that data wasn't being sent to ad companies like Facebook? Our default position should be to assume it is so until it is proven otherwise.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- vxxzy 7y agoI’ve had great luck blocking SmartTVs with a PiHole and a custom list. Also adding regex blacklists like “samsungtv” and “roku” seems to help. Granted, I sometimes disable to block to install updates and apps - but it seems to work. My next move is to start whitelisting destination IPs for smart devices and putting them on their own SSID/VLAN.
- U8dcN7vx 7y agoIn-application DNS resolution (e.g., DoH aka DNS over HTTPS) will defeat a PiHole. Will anyone bother
- beamatronic 7y agoYou can make a Smart TV into a dumb TV by simply not allowing it to connect to the Internet, ever.
- boring_twenties 7y agoIn a hn thread the other day, someone told me their TV will simply connect to any open wifi networks it comes across, just to phone home. I couldn't get the brand or model out of them, though.
- beamatronic 7y agoThat’s awful. We need to find out that brand.
- boring_twenties 7y agoWell, there's another guy now saying the same thing in this thread, too: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21010777 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21010777 Also on this thread is the supposition that eventually TVs will just have their own cellular data connections: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21010790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21010790 Sickening, really.
- mikeryan 7y agoThis is a pretty open secret within the industry. Geographic data can be provided via setup (a lot of TV's ask for a zip code on setup) or usually simply via GeoIP lookup. Dig a bit deeper and you get into service provided by Samba TV and or Inscape and you can find that they're sending back frames of video in a lot of cases to track what you're watching. This data is becoming a huge mechanism for subsidizing TV sales and the interactivity is being looked at as a huge opportunity to recoup some of the ad spend being lost via streaming and fewer 30 second spots. With new TV's its time to view them as private as a browser (With less controls). https://samba.tv/ https://samba.tv/ https://www.inscape.tv/ https://www.inscape.tv/
- paxys 7y agoNot even a secret. A TV manufacturer publicly said a while ago that a TV without "smart" features is more expensive for the company (even if sold at the same retail price) because they cannot make any money from selling usage data.
- phreack 7y agoIt was the Vizio CTO, while trying to spin it positively it came out a bit too honest. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190114/08084341384/vizio-admits-modern-tv-sets-are-cheaper-because-theyre-spying-you.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20190114/08084341384/vizio...
- bduerst 7y agoThis is kind of spot on to Succession's "ATN News: We're listening"
- sk5t 7y ago"We hear... for you."
- conradfr 7y agoThat assumes that developing the smart system (and supporting the infrastructure) does cost the same as for the dumb one, which seems wrong to me. Or maybe at high volume it becomes negligible anyway.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jamiepenney 7y agoIs there a manufacturer that is better in this regard? I assume Samsung would be the worst.
- throwaway122378 7y agoCan we breakup Facebook and put their executives on trial already?
- SiVal 7y ago(I'm asking because I don't know. It's not advocacy. I have NONE of this equipment currently.) So, if I get gigabit cable internet and want to buy a 4K tv and plug it in for streaming Netflix, Amazon Prime, YouTube, etc. (no broadcast, no WiFi to reduce bandwidth), is the solution to leave the WiFi off on TV setup (or give it a bad password to avoid opportunistic connection) and to plug the ethernet cable coming out of the cable modem into an Apple TV and/or Roku instead of into the TV, getting all of my programming thru wires coming out of these secondary boxes?
- codingdave 7y agoThe last time bought a TV, we simply looked around and found one that wasn't a "Smart TV". We stream through a Roku.
- banana_giraffe 7y agoGenerally yes. In my (accidental) experience, don't give it a bad WiFi key, it'll just complain. Just leave it disconnected. Honestly, given the unnecessary updates, ads, and just horrid UI that WiFi brought me on my TV, I'd suggest leaving it offline even if you don't care about the privacy issues. Oh, and WiFi won't change how much bandwidth you're using. And given the low (compared to Bluray) bitrate of 4k content on the streaming services, you probably don't need gigabit. And, it's not for everyone, but I personally like just hooking up a small PC (Intel's NUC works well here) and using that instead of AppleTV or Roku.
- Enginerrrd 7y agoBasically, yes. And you can and should also put all of those IOT devices on separate VLANs which you can control and monitor via firewall rules and packet inspection.
- mullen 7y agoOr just configure your WiFi to use something like AdGuard (https://adguard.com/en/adguard-dns/overview.html https://adguard.com/en/adguard-dns/overview.html) and then every device that connects to your WiFi will block ads. I have a Sony TV that I absolutely love but the built in Android TV will have a row of ads on the main screen. I configured my WiFi to use AdGuard DNS and now they have just disappeared. The Android TV is bit faster too.
- api 7y agoJust assume almost everything is a data grab and you will be right more often than wrong.
- dehrmann 7y agoEx-spotifier here. I'm only somewhat familiar with this, it's been a while, and I'm not speaking for Spotify, but I wouldn't be surprised if the data is being sent for speaker/remote control device discovery. It's probably the same for Google and Chromecast. Knowing what else gets collected online, this isn't a big concern for me. I'm more worried about these devices not having great security and not getting security updates for their entire life.
- excalibur 7y agoBut why would anybody NOT want a smart TV? /s
- bxio 7y agoGet yourself a Pi-hole. Block all phone home attempts. https://pi-hole.net/ https://pi-hole.net/
- drdrey 7y agoIt can't possibly block all phone home attempts. How would the Netflix or YouTube apps work on those devices if network traffic to those respective third-parties were blocked?
- dangrover 7y agoIt is not clear why we should necessarily be suspicious of smart TVs based on the findings here. The lines seem to be blurred between what data is being sent by the TV OS itself versus a third party app that someone may have decided to use during the period that the researchers watched outbound network connections. If someone is using the Netflix app, this necessitates that the TV must communicate with Netflix. How else would it work? Similarly, if you use the YouTube app, you would definitely get some requests to Google. Surely some developers of smart TV apps have decided to use Mixpanel or Adobe for analytics. The "sensitive user data" alluded to in the headline is later admitted to be, at a minimum, "information about the device people are using, their locations, and possibly even when they are interacting with it". Let's unpack that. It's pretty common for every web browser to send a user agent. Why shouldn't apps for a TV send device info to the app maker? Location can be inferred via IP, like any network request (nothing special here). And with any request, you of course know the time it was made (and could infer the interaction that produced it, like opening the app). So they've told us nothing to support the headline. Indeed, the original paper from Northeastern notes that they did not try to inspect the data or MITM encrypted connections, so all we know is that requests are being made to these services during the course of operating the device and its apps. Not that the device manufacturer itself is sending your data, unprompted, to these third parties. So, the headline does not match the story. Seems like university PR office must have gone a little crazy with this one. Why is nobody on HN questioning such a sensationalist, substanceless article?
- freeone3000 7y agoBecause it interferes with the idea of a TV being a display. A TV should not have apps. If it does have apps, these apps should not communicate data to the manufacturer. It shouldn't send back data about the operating system because a TV shouldn't have an operating system.
- dangrover 7y agoI agree having an OS on a TV is gratuitous. But that doesn't change that the claims the headline made are not actually proven by the evidence presented.
- duxup 7y agoI've made a point to not enable or connect my smart TV to any network. I'd rather use services over other devices anyway. Granted there are plenty of other ways to get that data.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoOdd. Most of the discussion here is about the TV and the collection, few seem interested in where that data is being sent? Has the shameless nature of Netflix's and FB's privacy invasions been normalized? Ironic given that Snowden's book dropped this week.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abstractbarista 7y agoI couldn't find info in the article about the whether LG (WebOS) Smart TV's still do this even if you opt-out of all the "Channel Plus" and other sketchy advertising/user-tracking features in the menu. I guess it's time to fire up Wireshark. I love these TV's because they can be integrated with home automation like Home Assistant. But maybe it's time to put it on a VLAN with no access to the WAN.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aussieguy1234 7y agoI use Kodi on a Rasbperry pi. There is a plugin for Netflix (which I dont use due to the content restrictions they have in Australia thanks to the Foxtel monopoly). Problem solved.
- fitzroy 7y agoPSA: If you mostly like to watch movies and/or cinematic TV (with the lights off, or in a dimly lit room), consider a home theater projector instead of a TV. In a dark room (even with white walls) the image is fanatic in cinema mode, and nearly as good (and quite a bit brighter) in "living room" mode. Best of all, they have absolutely zero "smart" features. I bought an Epson PowerLite Home Cinema 8345 Projector refurbished for around $470 a couple years ago to replace my 720p Panasonic AX200U. The Epsons have a solid warranty and will easily project a 100"+ image in a dark room on a basic (<$200) screen. The bulbs work out to about 10 cents/hour of usage. This 3100 is basically the newer (and better) version of mine for $684, and the one I'd get if I was buying today. https://epson.com/Clearance-Center/Home-Entertainment/Home-Cinema-3100-Full-HD-1080p-3LCD-Projector---Refurbished/p/V11H800020-N https://epson.com/Clearance-Center/Home-Entertainment/Home-C...
- sunstone 7y agoSmart TV's are only for stupid people. If you have one, unplug it from the internet, this removes the smartness. Add back your own smartness with a "NUC" kind of computer. Now you have a dumb TV and a smart owner.
- RyanAF7 7y agoHow do we hack these TVs to route around the invasion of privacy?
- mirimir 7y agoI will never buy a "smart TV". For one thing, I don't have much use for any TV. What I have is a large display attached to a media server. It doesn't have Internet access, except when I need to update packages. If there's something that I want to watch on it, I just use a DVD, or get a copy of the file.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- etxm 7y agoGreat!
- phy6 7y agoI blocked these URLs on my router, and my Samsung TV went into a setup mode, eventually switching languages into German. config.samsungads.com samsungacr.com samsungads.com samsungcloudsolution.com samsungcloudsolution.net samsungotn.net samsungtvads.com
- kevindong 7y agoThe next time that Apple comes out with a new model of their Apple TV 4K (likely next month), I plan on buying one and completely disconnecting my smart TV from the internet. My TV's UI is incredibly laggy and Vizio forces upon me a barely tolerable UI with the first two rows on the main page consisting of unhideable suggestions on what I should watch---even content that I cannot watch since I'm not subscribed to every service.
- ChuckMcM 7y agoWhich is why I have firewall rules inside my freakin' house which prevent things from sending packets outside. It really is annoying. If you allow DNS and ping it seems the TV won't constantly complain that it doesn't have an internet connection.
- dzonga 7y agowhen I wanted a 4K, I made sure it wasn't a smartTv for the reasons outlined in the article and comments. hard to find, but walmart had their own dumb 4k tv
- p1mrx 7y agoMy TV (Vizio P55-C1) doesn't have a "disconnect" option. I either need to do a factory reset, or change passwords three times (WiFi AP to temporary, TV to temporary, WiFi AP back to normal.) I suppose I could just never connect it to WiFi, but then it wouldn't get firmware updates.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoTVs should be dumb enough to never need firmware updates. I realize many do, but I consider that a design flaw.
- rrsx 7y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/you-watch-tv-your-tv-watches-back/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/09/18/you-wat...
- jeffk_teh_haxor 7y agoWhat if the communication is benign? What if the TV is simply refreshing a list of recommendations? Everybody - including this forum - is so primed to read nefarious motives into basically anything a computer can do now. Soon we're not going to be able to write a single "hello world" app w/o having to fill out a ream of EU paperwork and get licensed and bonded in advance.
- jeffk_teh_haxor 7y agoAlso, what if the TV communicated with its OEM's backends instead, which communicated with malicious third parties behind the scenes?
- partialrecall 7y ago"Recommendations" is just newspeak for advertising. I don't want my TV doing that. Here is a novel idea: if your shit is so great for users, not contrary to their interests, why don't you ask them to opt-in?
- anotherrobot 7y agoGuess what. Apple tv NOT on the list..spend the 150$
- gundmc 7y agoBut the Apple TV doesn't have a screen and it's hard to find a decent "Dumb" TV to even hook up a Roku/Apple TV/Chromecast to these days.
- Johnny555 7y agoDoes anyone publish a set of firewall rules (pfSense would be ideal) that allows Netflix, Hulu, etc to work with a Roku or Smart TV while blocking things like facebook? I understand that Netflix is going to track me when I'm a Netflix subscriber, but why should Facebook do it?
- ignoramous 7y agoOn an Android smart TV, I run a DNS changer and point it to local pi-hole to block trackers and ads aggressively. Not sure if it ends up cleaning up everything but I do see 15% of the DNS queries pi-holed.
- dandare 7y agoI still don't understand this whole "business model". Could someone ELI5 these three questions? 1) How exactly is this targeting information useful to advertisers? Do they pay for targeting in order to pay for fewer ads? 2) Where is the market for "user data"? How do you sell your blog visitor's data? 3) How much is the data worth? Some equivalent to CPM? Could you monetize your blog not by showing ads but by selling user information?
- nabla9 7y ago>Do they pay for targeting in order to pay for fewer ads? Yes. There can be more and smaller advertisers when you can tailor ads to the market. Nontargeted advertising is economic only for biggest brands. Data that is collected sparsely can help to identify interests and match ads to users. Geographic location helps to match adds from your local market to the blog the user is currently reading, for example. Continuously collected information can be used to direct and predict behavior. The user matches profile of stressed person. People under stress have low impulse control, show them ads for products that are typical impulse purchases. S >Where is the market for "user data"? How do you sell your blog visitor's data? You don't. You add common trackers to your site and receive income from ads trough them. > Could you monetize your blog not by showing ads but by selling user information? No. This does not work in small scale. Single blogger can't create much value by selling data directly. Google or Facebook do that.
- switch007 7y agoSpy TVs are nothing compared to Spy energy meters. They will bring in a new era of surge-based pricing, which will eliminate all tariff comparisons as it will be impossible to compare. Higher pricing is already starting with non-spy tariffs being more expensive than spy tariffs. If you happen to buy a home with one, and want the spy meter removed, you are at the mercy of the supplier and they will embark on a campaign against you to keep it. The lies will soon start saying they have no analogue meters in stock etc.
- abacadaba 7y agoAny AOSP android tv boxes out there?
- ghostpepper 7y agoI would love to update my 10 year old 1080p Philips non-smart TV to a 55" or so 4K HDR screen but I don't want any of the smart features. Does anyone know of any manufacturers selling high end "dumb" TVs? For now I'm comfortable using my appleTV but I like the fact that I can disconnect it at any time. I want a TV that will simply display whatever signal it receives without any connectivity required.
- kokx 7y agoI have a Humax "monitor". It only has 4 HDMI inputs and a USB input (never used it, probably for viewing things on a random USB stick). If you have a separate box for TV anyways, its perfect. Don't need anything else. Otherwise, you can simply not connect your smart TV to the internet. Just leave it unconnected and use it as if it is a dumb TV.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- exolymph 7y agoWhat you're looking for is a monitor.
- CraneWorm 7y agoExcept for a monitor you are likely to pay thrice as much as for a TV of comparable screen size. It doesn't end there; while I was looking for a monitor I found several models running Android! One can not be too careful these days. That said, it is still possible to get a Dumb TV, say up to 55'. Larger devices are almost exclusively ~~spies~~ smart.
- theshrike79 7y agoLG seems to be the least crappy option here. But if you're willing to spend some extra $$, you can get a "meeting room display" with the same panel, but zero smart features and no speakers.
- homerhomer 7y agono surprise here, but is my pi-hole blocking this crap?
- dngray 7y agohttps://archive.is/jOJ3R https://archive.is/jOJ3R link to archived version of article. FT usually hides things behind a metered paywall.
- kungito 7y agoDoes this happen with Chromecast as well? I'm totally fine with disconnecting my tv since I only use it via Chromecast anyways. Smart tv makes no sense to me simce they are all 10x shittier than Chromecast
- mrweasel 7y agoThe spying is one thing, but you're right: SmartTVs doesn't make sense, because the software sucks. If Sony, Phillips or some other manufacture made a SmartTV with software that rivalled the AppleTV, or even just a Chromecast, then it would make some sense to save the money from the AppleTV and buy a better TV. The thing is that all of the SmartTVs I tried are slow and confusing. You're better off buying a cheaper TV and getting the $200 AppleTV HD. If you factor in the cost of developing shitty software, then maybe there would be more profit in just release a new dumb TV.
- myle 7y agoStallman has been telling for a while that "smart" devices mean devices that spy on you.
- Libre___ 7y agoMy TV is completely airgapped now for privacy reasons, but I really wish there was a way to replace the OS running on it. I used to be(and still am) a big fan of the Smart TV concept, seeing as there's a whole quad core ARM SoC built into my TV that might as well take the streaming duty instead of having an extra HTPC or Chromecast lying outside of it.
- shoaibakbar 7y agoand we don't answer out names to unknown phone calls made by our friends :P
- FairKing 7y agoI think is must be possible to shutdown the smart TV OS and watch your TV box with Libreelec via HDMI instead.
- siempreb 7y ago> Smart TVs sending sensitive user data to Netflix and Facebook No way! Has that ever been news? It is the first thing that comes to mind when some product 'needs' to be connected to the internet. Sending private data is most likely the only reason a internet connection can be made with the device. All the 'great' software around it is only fluff supporting to lure people sending their private data unknowingly. Do they send microphone and camera data home? Of course, that's the cream. Oh, and do they protect your sensitive data well? Nah, that's not a priority, who cares.. In the past you bought a new tv, and the manufacturer was happy and treated you with respect. Today you think you buy a tv, but tv is actually the secondary feature, you just bought an intrusion device that collects your private life in order to send it to the manufacturer for selling it. I have a new x-large smart tv which I would never connect to the internet for these reasons. I use a dedicated pc with a good graphics card that connects through HDMI. On my couch I have a wireless mouse and keyboard. With this dead simple setup I cannot only watch regular tv, I can of course do anything you can think of doing on a pc. It also has become my favorite gaming setup. I think governments should be more active to protect citizens of course. Non-technical people are prey nowadays. I despise this new economy and I'll never ever want to make any money of of it, I'd rather live and die poor.
- gambiting 7y agoThe problem is that I want to just use the netflix built-into the TV. Firing up a separate device just to watch something seems like a waste of energy to me, and then I probably need a separate controller for it(like, I can control the PS4 with my TV remote, but I cannot switch it on remotely without using the DS4). >>I have a new x-large smart tv which I would never connect to the internet for these reasons. I use a dedicated pc with a good graphics card that connects through HDMI. Assuming you use windows on it, haven't you just traded one type of telemetry for the other?
- siempreb 7y agoNo. It's a linux, and there is no mic or cam connected. I use Netflix too, works like a charm. And I can understand your temptation of using the Netflix button on the remote control, it's one of the lures.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI every now and then I have to have this conversation with my mum and dad: "the TV will occasionally ask you to tell it your name, where you live, your birthday etc. Don't tell it ANYTHING. They can't make you." I wish the people who make my parents' TV would stop trying to trick them into doxing themselves.
- robinduckett 7y agoWorked in this industry for years. It didn't really feel right at the time. Adverts on volume buttons. Frames of video sent to third parties. Etc
- accounn 7y agoScam & spy business.
- hootbootscoot 7y agoGee who would have seen that coming...
- hootbootscoot 7y agoMight as well buy an Alexa, LOL... At this point, people have to wonder what benefits the IOT fabric provides THEM versus what benefits it provides the vendor or configurator/bundler... Of far greater concern is the pile of unpatched linuces these crapware bloatware "embedded linux" devices tend to be equipped with. It's an entry vector... or hardcoded "admin:admin" login credentials...
- zerop 7y agoI have assumed any device around me is sending my data somewhere not intended. Period.
- timvisee 7y agoPlease, stop linking paywalled crap.
- gorbypark 7y agoKind of off topic, but I have an older Samsung smart tv. It has an ethernet connection, but it didn't have any option for WiFi. For a few years I had it wired up to ethernet, and after rearranging where my router lived in the house I didn't have a long enough ethernet cable, so I hooked up a USB WiFi dongle. It worked great for a few months until I needed that dongle to connect a Raspberry Pi to WiFi, so I stole it from the TV...and lo and behold the TV still had internet access via WiFi! The only thing that I think could have happened is that the TV had WiFi hardware but was disabled in software, because at the time a WiFi TV was selling at a premium and this was a cheapo one I bought from Wal-Mart. So I guess hooking up the USB dongle somehow unlocked it. It kinda freaked me out that there was hidden WiFi hardware in there. edit The tv definitely phones home too, my Pi Hole blocks a few hundred attempts to lookup log-ingestion.samsungacr.com, xpu.samsungelectronics.com and upu.samsungelectronics.com per day.
- squarefoot 7y agoI wouldn't be that hard to make a small firewall to put in between the TV and the Internet, with rules that block unwanted traffic - or better, block it and inject fake data - while allowing normal use of the TV. This cheap SBC comes to mind, there's a very similar one from OrangePI too. https://www.friendlyarm.com/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=248 https://www.friendlyarm.com/index.php?route=product/product&... It would be nice having say a version for traveling with laptops etc if we don't trust the hotel connection and one to protect from being spied by the SmartTVs, where changing from one to the other requires nothing more than swapping an SD and reboot.
- natmaka 7y agoHow will it detect unwanted (spying) traffic from legitimate operations (software update...)? Moreover it is a moving target, as the firmware can, at some point in time, use another endpoint (especially after an update).
- squarefoot 7y ago"How will it detect unwanted (spying) traffic from legitimate operations (software update...)?" That would be harder, especially true in case of encrypted traffic. "Moreover it is a moving target, as the firmware can, at some point in time, use another endpoint (especially after an update)." This one might be easier to fight than the former. Upgradabe black lists might be a solution, not unlike some antispam software work: the firewall software downloads weekly/daily from a central server (1) a list of all legit/evil addresses and checks where the TV attempts to connect against that list, then filters traffic as required. (1) I would assume we would trust a centralized server for this purpose as much as we would trust a server holding spam and malware sites.
- natmaka 7y agoEach firmware update may come with a large list of endpoints. They also may use the very same servers (IP addresses) in order to spy and also for the updates or legitimate apps. For the customer eager to benefit from a connection to the Internet it may be a lost battle, he will be spied on.
- rb666 7y agoKodi > SmartTV
- ck425 7y agoDo they send data from games consoles? I watch TV entirely through my PS4, with the actual smart TV not hooked up to my wifi. I presume that would stop TV companies from getting my data, but then again Sony might sell it themselves.
- decoyworker 7y agoThere is a simple way around this- never connect these to your LAN. I don't need the features, I don't need the data collection, and I certainly do not need the extra security footprint.
- user56785678 7y agoMy LG TV webOS YouTube app, generates some hard to hear sounds when menus and content is navigated. Even thought I am not logged in in YouTube app, I suspect they can be captured by an Android device nearby and correlated with that device user. The apps that have the login data already can share whatever they like. There was a story some years ago when even shared local media names were shared by some TVs. If you have a device connected to network, you can be sure it will share whatever it can, malice intent or not.
- bsenftner 7y agoIt's been this way for a while. That is why I get 4K Monitors, not a "smart TV". If a monitor has anything beyond a hdmi jack, I skip it. Cars are going this way too. The current model year has all car manufacturers producing these ruined vehicles. Hold what you got, or buy used until this bullshit is regulated away.
- ubermonkey 7y agoI am really baffled that anyone with a clue would enable "smart" behavior from a consumer electronics product like a TV (ie, one from a company not known for privacy and security). Our TV is old enough that it's not smart. We mostly watch things from the AppleTV on it, plus some from our very small cable package/DVR. Choosing a set-top-box vendor you trust (and for us, that's Apple) gives you everything you'd get by trusting Samsung or Vizio, right? What even turn ON the network features of the TV?
- geggam 7y agoI am starting to think I should block all traffic out of my home network and force everything to go through a proxy server where I can manage all outbound traffic. The number of devices I have plugged into my home network is astonishing and the chatter / discovery they do to each other is interesting to watch. Zero trust model for everything ... I guess ?
- everdrive 7y agoFor years, we've been avoiding this whole problem. We have a dumb TV hooked up to a computer. The computer doesn't even have a fancy couch-friendly interface installed. It's just a computer. And therefore, it literally plays all media we want, and if we prefer, it blocks ads and plays music too. The computer doesn't spy on us because we control it, and websites only spy on us to the degree that we're unable to prevent. (pihole, ublock, etc)
- woopdedoo 7y agotime to get a dreambox with a keylist
- JohnFen 7y agoNot just to Netflix and Facebook. This is why I don't, and won't ever, own a smart TV.
- cityzen 7y agoI went in to my router to block my Samsung TV last night and thought it was cute that instead of using the device name I set it was using "localhost". I guess these companies will go to any extreme to steal your info.