43 ms·
The Lonely Work of Moderating Hacker News
- amrrs 7y ago> On any given day, its top links might include a Medium post about technical hiring Isn't it quite ironic to see the article suggesting that HN top link might include Medium post. I've usually read not-so-positive feedback about Medium posts. Isn't it the case?
- malux85 7y agoWhy not judge the post by the insightfulness of the content, rather than the domain from which it originates?
- paulgb 7y agoWhen you're looking at a page of 30 links, the signaling value of a domain is useful. Medium is a low-barrier place to publish, and has discovery built in, so it ends up attracting a lot of bad writing and promotional material. That, combined with the degraded reading experience, is why I am happy to judge a book by its cover in this case.
- LandR 7y agoI've found the majority of content on medium.com to be so useless that I now run a plugin in my browser to block medium.com from my DDG results.
- dredmorbius 7y agoBatched signals matter. A publication's "editorial voice", ranging from grammar and typography, to selection and discussion philosophy, are significant. There's a reason we see things as "New York Times" or "Fox News" or "Mad Magazine" or "Cosmo" or "The Economist" or "Soldier of Fortune" in voice or tone. This is harder to pin down with blogs and social media, though distinctions can emerge, whether through self-selection, path-dependency, gross scale, algorithms, or some combination of the set. Prejudice can be misused, but its advantage (to the judger) is that it makes judgement cheaper by reducing the set of what needs to be considered, at least for an initial judgement. That's characteristic of any domain in which there's an information overload, or in which distinctions are subtle and difficult to identify initially. And argument, by the way, for dealing with copious information less by enhanced processing and more by expedited (and cheap!) discarding heuristics.
- e12e 7y agoAll links on the front page are "top links".
- pjc50 7y agoMedium has good content behind an increasingly infuriating presentation. Mechanically it's the opposite of HN, but for various reasons (reach, possibility of reimbursment) people do write some quality content there.
- DanBC 7y agoSturgeon's Law says 90% of anything is crap. Since anyone can write for medium, and anyone with an HN account can post medium links here, there are huge amounts of medium content. So we see a lot of that 90%, as well as the 10% that's useful.
- fphhotchips 7y agoI think the argument goes that Medium, the platform, is bad for the internet as a whole and probably getting worse for its users, too. Articles on Medium range from quite insightful to clickbait junk, as is the way of most open-ish access platforms.
- prepend 7y ago“In April, when a story about Katie Bouman, an M.I.T. researcher who helped develop a technology that captured the first photo of a black hole, rose to the front page, users combed through her code on GitHub in an effort to undermine the weight of her contributions.” This is an odd statement as it implies the purpose was to undermine. Reading code and critiquing isn’t meant to “undermine” but to identify truth and constantly look for better ways.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y ago...and here we go again. What was, or at least felt, obvious was that there was a double standard being applied. Not just in the sense that such a witch hunt would be unlikely to happen to a man being lauded. But also that if there's one point that Hacker News could probably agree on it's that lines-of-code is a bad metric for evaluating programmers, let alone scientists. There was also the pervasive sense of being on the side of the rest of the team, even though highlighting their contribution was the first thing Katie Bouman did. And at least Andrew Chael, who did write the plurality of the code in the GitHub repo, did come out strongly in favor of her and was horrified of the hate she got. Quote: "So apparently some (I hope very few) people online are using the fact that I am the primary developer of the eht-imaging software library to launch awful and sexist attacks on my colleague and friend Katie Bouman. Stop." (https://twitter.com/thisgreyspirit/status/1116518544961830918 https://twitter.com/thisgreyspirit/status/111651854496183091...) It's curious that, at least in my subjective impression, the tech community has a far larger problem with women than any of the other groups that have traditionally suffered discrimination: racism and especially homophobia really are extremely rare, at least overtly. But the uglyness Katie Bouman, or Ellen Pao, or Marissa Meyers brought out seems to be alive and well.
- nailer 7y agoIf a man received personal acclaim for a discovery, and someone looked at the repo and found that someone other than the man wrote most of the crunchier code, then yes I'd evaluate the acclaim for the man the same way. Note most of the acclaim aimed at the scientist, rather than the team, was from the media. Whom as usual, likes to omit their own role.
- sohkamyung 7y agoCurious to know why this post has a "unvote" option. I don't recall seeing that before. Is there a link that explains what it does?
- pas 7y agoMaybe you clicked upvote before coming to the comments?
- ChrisCinelli 7y agoI see both upvote and down vote on any thread. I used to see only upvotes that flipped to undo. Something changed.
- mjlee 7y agoYou got more than (I think) 500 karma is what changed. Downvote is disabled for users before that threshold.
- nothrabannosir 7y agoIt’s not this story, it’s a global feature on both comments and stories which serves as a “undo” for fat fingering the upvote button. Before this feature you’d often see comments along the likes of “sorry, I accidentally downvoted you while trying to upvote.”
- sohkamyung 7y agoAh, I see. Thanks for the explanation.
- hef19898 7y agoOne great improvement of UI for HN, don't ask me how often I fat fingered before.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago
- raverbashing 7y agoIt's a very interesting take to put a face on people who we only know for short acronyms and interaction which usually happen when things are not going smooth. It's easy to think moderation might be too active (or not active enough) though it's not us sitting on their seats. (Though I agree with the critique that the site is "too orange" and I'm all too happy to use the available customization option)
- kuu 7y agoInteresting that only 2 people can moderate million users
- mschuster91 7y agoMillions of readers, the amount of active commenters is much lower. In addition, HN doesn't get much of the "classic" troll crowd (no matter if 4chan/8chan/outright real Nazis/gamergate) or Trump supporters - from the occasional politics thread aside, there's nothing much of interest for them here, and so the biggest blocks of trolls simply stay away.
- pjc50 7y agoPartly due to a virtuous circle; the community downvotes the more obvious ones into invisibility, and persistent trolls get banned, and the discussions are curated to select less fertile topics, and the controversy-ometer pushes flamewars off the front page. The moderators here are very good at doing work upfront to save themselves work later, by making the site infertile ground for troublemakers.
- kuu 7y agoStill... I wonder how many messages are reported per day. BTW, I don't get why you're being downvoted...
- mschuster91 7y agoProbably because I mentioned Trump supporters and -chan trolls as the biggest block of trolls on the 'net and have "Antifa" in my profile. Ah well.
- fphhotchips 7y agoI do. The direct call-out of a specific group of people for their position on the political spectrum is pretty much directly against what (I think) we're trying to do here. It's unnecessary, too. Could have just left it at "classic troll crowd".
- agumonkey 7y agoHN being it's own top topic. Such Y
- arethuza 7y agoA recursive application of Y-combinator to itself seems appropriate? :-)
- kreetx 7y agoThe "Show HN: This upvotes itself" came to mind. :) But regarding the article: I don't think HN is getting worse. But why it might look like it is is that it has become a very very busy site - which makes it seem hectic and thus might appear "worse".
- onion2k 7y agoI've been reading "dang" as the word "dang!" without realising it's actually "dan g" all this time. :)
- shawnps 7y agoI thought it was a surname Dang.
- pieter_mj 7y ago"Woo sh"! Joking aside, if there were to be forum awards, Hacker News would top it all the time. Best moderated, high level, most interesting discussion forum award goes to ...
- lordnacho 7y agoI thought it was a Chinese name
- bookofjoe 7y agoRelated: My daughter's second grade teacher was Mrs. Emily Chewning, of Scottish extraction. She told me that when the first parent-teacher conferences happened, a number of parents were surprised at her appearance: kids always referred to her as "Miss Chew" and from the sound of the name, parents assumed she was Chinese.
- benjaminbrodie 7y agoYou shouldn't just mention her full name like that lol bruh
- hoorayimhelping 7y agoSame! I think I'm going to keep referring to Dan G as dang, cause it's a really endearing name for a moderator in my opinion.
- dang 7y agoIt's both. That's why. Edit: see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7494093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7494093 from way back when.
- Mizza 7y agoShout out to dang! You're doing a great job! Thank you! Strict moderation is the reason HN is the only reasonable discussion forum remaining on the internet. I wish good moderation was a skill that more people learned - would you ever be interested in writing a guide or teaching a class on moderation?
- TelmoMenezes 7y ago> Strict moderation is the reason HN is the only reasonable discussion forum remaining on the internet. Don't you find it a bit suspicious that the forum you happen to like is "the only reasonable discussion forum remaining on the internet"?
- Mizza 7y agoI don't know what you mean by "suspicious." I'm part of a ton of other forums and communities, and over time almost all of them have devolved into complete and utter dogshit, just an endless stream of memes and screenshots of Twitter posts. The communities that remain successful either have total strict moderation or a "shitposts" section where all of the garbage ends up, but even then the quarantine zone ends up sucking up a lot of the forum energy. I think it's best to just not have it at all.
- DanBC 7y agoYou might like Tildes. Here's their blog and docs which describe what Tildes is about. https://blog.tildes.net/ https://blog.tildes.net/ https://docs.tildes.net/ https://docs.tildes.net/ You may also like Lobste.rs https://lobste.rs/ https://lobste.rs/
- ckris 7y agoTildes is a bit ironic. Overall it is a lot better. The topics, timeline, moderation, structure and even comments. And a think some people might enjoy that. But it also sort of highlights the greater problem which is that most people who frequent these forums these days just aren't that interesting, or interested. Or it is at least hard for those who are to show that and get something out of it.
- Insanity 7y agoMostly off-topic: for anyone wondering, the image looks like a poker II keyboard. (slight glow under the right-hand). Which is a great 60% keyboard!
- adrian_mrd 7y agoAmidst all the ambient craziness of our ever-changing world, I raise a glass to Hacker News, the team who moderate it and to all who wish to make it a community driven by erudite discussions :)
- chmaynard 7y agoI'll drink to that. There's a constant tension in my life between time devoted to reading books vs. time perusing HN stories and comments. It's hard to reach a good balance.
- MrXOR 7y agoSuch a lovely place! Thanks Paul Graham, @dang and @sctb for HN.
- tomcam 7y agoSeconded. This is a very special gift to our community.
- nailer 7y agodang / sctb: do you get alerts when we mention your usernames? You always seem to respond relatively quickly.
- pjc50 7y agoI wouldn't be surprised if they got a continuous feed of all comments. The volume is just about possible to keep up with.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y agoThere exists a public feed of all comments (just click on 'comments' in top bar), but we don't monitor the site that way. It's too much. We basically read the threads spottily like anyone else, plus rely on moderation lists, such as what has been flagged by users.
- dang 7y agoNo, we don't. I used to have client-side software that would highlight specific regexes in comment text, but it stopped working one of the times that we rewrote the client-side Lisp that we used (Parenscript -> Lumen -> Arc) and I haven't gotten around to getting it working again.
- kentrado 7y agoMy experience with dang have been limited to him accusing me of making a personal swipe and me trying convince him that's not the case. I think sometimes overly sensitive moderation is not good.
- pmyteh 7y agoFor what it's worth, my only interaction with dang was being gently chided for a slightly glib dismissal at the top of a comment I made. The phrasing I used is very common (and treated as harmless) where I was brought up in Yorkshire. But he was right; without the benefit of that context it came over as rude. I've been a bit more careful since. Thanks, dang. A triumph of moderation.
- frereubu 7y agoThat's been my experience too. It's the only online forum where the style of moderation has made me think twice about what I said.
- krapp 7y agoI've gotten into a couple of arguments with dang and have never found him to be unfair, although I do think he sometimes interprets criticism of the site or the community as an insult to him personally. That said, it's better to have moderators who care than moderators who don't.
- nkurz 7y agoUsually when I read a comment like this, I find that the commenter is grossly misrepresenting the situation, usually by leaving out important details. But in this case, yes, that seems like an accurate description: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20467198 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20467198 Personally, I like Dan's "Nietzschean flamewars" phrasing, and I sort of agree that "trying to get him to conform to slave morality" was a personal swipe. But if so, only barely. This could well be an example of overly sensitive moderation. The real problem with that thread (in my opinion) is that Rayiner's comment was allowed to stay flagged to death. One might not agree with his opinion, but it's a viewpoint worthy of reply (as you did) rather than censorship.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoCongratulations to "paulmd" for getting a flagged comment cited in The New Yorker! (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13094354 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13094354 is the comment, which I find entirely reasonable but obviously people disagreed, or at least it was considered off-topic)
- danso 7y agoReally surprising to see that comment, which, full disclosure, I agree with, get flag-killed. I wouldn’t be surprised to see it get a few downvotes. But rarely have I ever seen a thorough, well-sourced, and civil comment actually be flag-killed. If anything, the shallow replies to his comment are the type of things that typically seem to get downvoted (though not necessarily flagged either).
- vonmoltke 7y agoI think this is a side effect of self-moderation. By making everyone in the community (over a certain threshold of participation) a mini-mod you turn rules enforcement into a popularity contest. Valid, interesting, yet unpopular points get suppressed. Rules violations that are popular get ignored, and sometimes even lauded. There is no reason, based on the HN guidelines, that the referenced post should have been downvoted, let alone flagged. Whoever did so abused their power to make such decisions.
- danso 7y agoI agree with what you said, but my presumption has been that the HN status quo would generally be receptive to the argument that u/paulmd made, or at least, not offended/angered enough to flag it. Especially it being so well-written, and in response to someone whose argument was entirely speculative or based on emotional appeal, and who didn't bother using basic capitalization or punctuation. It's even more surprising since HN had the "vouch" feature since before Dec. 2016 [0]. My best guess is that people might have reflexively downvoted/flagged upon seeing the opening sentence of "Black people are measurably less likely to own a car or have a bank account". [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11589410 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11589410
- lapnitnelav 7y ago> “There’s often a strong wish to solve these contentious problems by changing the software, and, to the extent that we’ve tried things like that, we haven’t found it to work.“ Software might be eating the world, I don't think people will eat software anytime soon. It's a good reminder that we can't solve all problems by just throwing some code at it. Unfortunately ...
- Sukotto 7y agoI've been enjoying the "Against the Rules" podcast [1] hosted by Michael Lewis [2]. It's related to moderation so I'll post it here. The show is series of stories/reports on the work of refereeing fairness in different parts of life. With views into how those referees are changing, and in some cases, outright disappearing. Fascinating stuff from an author who really knows how to tell an engaging story about a potentially dry topic. (Moneyball, The Big Short, Liar's Poker, etc.) [1] https://atrpodcast.com/ https://atrpodcast.com/ [2] https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/776.Michael_Lewis https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/776.Michael_Lewis
- artemisbot 7y agoI've been on a bit of a Michael Lewis binge myself recently, just finishing his book "The Undoing Project" - would definitely recommend if you're even tangentially interested in human psychology. It's a great introduction into why we make errors on a cognitive level and is a great follow-up to some of the concepts discussed in Moneyball.
- batmenace 7y agoAtR is a really good podcast, I agree. Lewis is great at writing/ presenting in an engaging manner. Listening to the podcasts felt to me like listening to short audio books of his. Who knows if moderation in the way he analyses it will rebound again in the future, one can only hope...
- interfixus 7y agoAlthough being - sometimes wildly - at odds with many of the leanings, assumptions, and perceived biases underlying the generality of HN, and often not sharing editorial viewpoints as expressed by dang and sctb, I am consistently in awe and absolutely drooling fanboy adulation over the quality of the moderation and everything else which keep - miraculously - this site running, healthy, useful, and mostly spam-free. From over here in a very different set of values and mind: Thank you for all that. As for the article: King Canute was a Danish and for a while English king. Never Swedish.
- tomcam 7y agoHell to the yes on your first point. I’m in the same boat.
- uptown 7y agoWhy is this on the front page? /s
- flexie 7y agoVery interesting article :-) I had no idea that the community is this large and that there are only two moderators. The article could have explained the other part of the moderation better - the user moderation provided by up and down votes. Bad comments are not only flagged but also tend to be pushed further down the page towards oblivion, while better comments tend to be lifted up towards the top of the page. Anyways, King Canute: He was Danish, not Swedish :-)
- eyeundersand 7y agoHa! After rigorously reading the article and the commentary here, I found the end of your comment deliciously humorous. Oh, the irony! Also if the author or any of the moderators read this comment, Hello!
- 2T1Qka0rEiPr 7y agoThanks to Dan and Scott for their moderation, and whilst the article highlights some of negative aspects of discussion on HN, I for one keep coming here because it's still on average the most reasoned and thought provoking part of the internet I'm aware of - so, thanks to you all for your positive contributions :)
- Thorrez 7y ago>Then my eyes moved down the thread, where a third user had left a new comment. It read: “King Canute was supposed to stop the tide, you couch alluder.” It seems to me that comment is a joke. Playfully nitpicking word choice while putting in a bit of banter. But the article seems to be taking the comment as a serious argument/insult.
- LandR 7y agoI think this is quite a common thing on the internet, people feigning ignorance to be upset about something.
- tomcam 7y agoI can tell you as a person who has been spanked by dang a few times that there truly are people who can be ignorant in the other direction. I have written a number of replies that to me were simply neutral questions but which felt like an attack, from what I can tell, because they were harshly downvoted and I was even throttled by the mods. I have to assume that’s on me and I have largely stopped asking for clarification because I seem to do it without sufficient empathy or something. dang did reply thoughtfully to my inquiries about what I had done and that actually made me feel worse! I know those two are busy doing way more important things and I hate making their day worse.
- oska 7y agoYes, it's an obvious joke. "You couch alluder" is the wink.
- AceJohnny2 7y agoRef to the comment and context in question: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20522668 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20522668
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoThis article does seem to get at the essence of HN, appreciative of dang and sctb's humanity while not ignoring the problems. Personally, I would actually consider it an excellent demonstration of the fallibility of one of HN's favourite tropes, Gell-Mann amnesia. If there's one critique that I believe is paramount it's that HN has, due to its readership, an ethical obligation that goes beyond making discussions all nice and civil. Political issues are obviously divisive and it's perfectly fine to keep stuff like the El Paso massacre of the front page. But when hot-button issues intersect with technology, the HN readership is in a position of power, and shouldn't routinely be spared the anguish of being reminded of their responsibility. Yes, articles about, for example, discriminatory ML do often make it to the front page. But in my impression, that topic (as well as employment discrimination, culture-wars-adjacent scandals in tech academia etc) are far more likely to be quickly flagged into oblivion than similarly political takes that just happen to be in line with HN's prevailing attitude (e.g. cloudflare-shouldnt-ban-<x>). The article impressively articulates what toll divisiveness takes on the moderators: Even if I read the same ugly comments, I am unlikely to experience the sharpness of emotion that apparently comes with considering the community one's baby, and making it's failures one's own. When such divisiveness is then reflected in the "real world" of mass media, the pressure only increases. But as this article shows, abdicating the responsibility by keeping the topics sterile is similarly suspect, in the sense of fiddling while Rome burns. I believe a willingness to confront the ugly sides of technology with some courage of conviction would eventually be recognised, even if it may occasionally involve a bit of a mess.
- elorant 7y ago... the HN readership is in a position of power, and shouldn't routinely be spared the anguish of being reminded of their responsibility. What kind of power do you think we have? We can't even convince our friends and family to stay the fuck off of Facebook. Aside from the fact that some people from our industry have a shitton of money I don't see us having any kind of social influence.
- jacobush 7y agoBecause we are busy building Facebook. Or some other similar facet of online life.
- sgt101 7y ago"Gackle replied. “We can’t stop that any more than King Canute”—the ancient Swedish king who demonstrated the limits of his power by trying, in an ironic spirit, to command the sea—“could stop the waves."" Canute was King of England, Denmark and Norway. He was not Swedish. I think that The Newyorker is trolling Hacker News by dropping this quote in.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- everybodyknows 7y agoNever ascribe to malice what can be put down to incompetence. The article hasn't even been properly proofread, let alone fact-checked: >... experiment with and idea ...
- jessaustin 7y agoI took the final paragraph of TFA as an indication that this is just ironic fun. "Couch alluder", indeed.
- mieseratte 7y agoI think the HN culture is slowly dying. Reflexive downvoting has become very common as of late, the eternal September is brining in more people steeped in political hivemindedness. That isn’t to say all is lost, but this site feels markedly different from the beginning of the decade.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoI would argue that HN culture is evolving within the culture it exists in. I don't recall the beginning of the decade having so many intersections of tech and everyday life. In the beginning of the decade, Google wasn't known to have paid off high level employees for sexual harassment, Facebook wasn't known to have hordes of contractors watching horrible stuff for their job, no one knew the good and bad effects of the 'gig economy' yet, etc. That is to say, I don't recall the beginning of the decade tech and politics to be so intertwined due to how tech has become more and more a part of people's lives.
- mieseratte 7y agoMy problem doesn't come from topics but the discourse one finds in the threads themselves. > Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That destroys intellectual curiosity, which is what the site exists for. Perhaps I'm just an old man yelling about "back in the day," but on these axis I feel HN is trending downward.
- 18pfsmt 7y agoI remember exactly where I was when I first heard NPR tell listeners they could visit "their FB" or follow them On Twitter in 2010. I got a visceral bad feeling. In the 90s, the prevailing wisdom was not to disclose personal info on the internet because it was understood that "the IP stack" was designed with maximum liberty and tolerance for all kinds of garbage (with personal tools to filter, and the assumption of personal responsibility). Comparing the dynamics of Usenet vs. FB is quite revealing and brings insight into the discussion about distributed vs. centralized power. We've dumbed everything down to the point of ridiculousness.
- vinceguidry 7y ago> The site’s now characteristic tone of performative erudition—hyperrational, dispassionate, contrarian, authoritative—often masks a deeper recklessness. I recently started contributing on another online community, a Slack, and I've found the rhetorical habits I've unwittingly cultivated creating a weird sort of mood. Nothing I'm saying is wrong, but HN has managed to make me somewhat oblivious to tone. It's exactly as she describes, 'reckless'. I dare to go places that will rile people up. The silence that met my initial posts was deafening. I initially wanted to retreat back to my familiar communities, Quora, HN. But I've never backed down from this kind of challenge before and I'm not about to now. I'm slowly managing to discover better 'hygiene' so I can fit better into this particular community of wonderful people. But I wouldn't give back my participation in HN for anything. More than any other place I've ever found, HN makes me feel like I belong.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 7y agoI may be misinterpreting what you're saying, but just in case: the critique isn't about "style", as in being too direct or offensive or anything like that. It's about the value system, and about how arguments are evaluated. Case in point: a few days ago an article about India/Kashmir shortly made the front page (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20612461 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20612461) The ensuing discussion is entirely obsessed with the legalistic details of India's action: what sort of law is it/who has the authority to recind it/etc. Read any news report on the topic and those questions are secondary to the intentions and actual effects of the policy, i. e. "is this intended to allow resettling a majority-muslim province with Hindus and thereby dilute it's culture as part of a nationalistic campaign?" That sort of superficial legalism is rather prevalent. Any discussion of a public protest will include some people complaining about protesters not staying on the sidewalks. Discussions on law frequently find really clever "cheats" relying on too-literal a reading of the text ("Freedom of 'Speech', not of 'Writing', the New York Times doesn't have a case"). If I were to over-psychoanalyse, this approach seems to gell with a certain type of uber-rationality that denies the value of anything that cannot be measured. Hence, I've seen repeated suggestions that web fonts shouldn't exist because nobody needs more than one readable font or, more generally, that "design" is superfluous wastefulness at best and often akin to lying.
- creaghpatr 7y ago>For decades, the phrase “Eternal September” has been used to describe the tipping point for a message board or online community—the inclusion, or invasion, of new users who dramatically change the existing subculture. I’m guessing that’s why this article was written.
- danso 7y agoI’ve always thought HN is so relatively pleasant because of the investment it puts into quality moderation. But reading this profile really underscored how different things would be had two other people, of different temperaments and perspectives on life, been selected as mods. I imagined the mods to stereotypically be, at oldest, late-20s techies in SV. But it makes sense in retrospect one is in his mid-30s, and one is old enough to have 2 children of his own.
- nickpsecurity 7y agoHeck, raising kids might even have helped Dan get better at moderating. Both in terms of doing it and handling the mental burden. Seems like there's some overlap in skills like trying to understand them, giving guidance, having patience about the process, etc.
- FakeComments 7y agodang’s style of censoring viewpoints via decorum is the same policy which has Google et al facing federal investigation for bias against conservatives. It’s not good. I hope the government does pass non-discrimination legislation for online platforms — seeing dang get sued for his behavior would be very satisfying. (And let’s be honest — he’s not going to stop censoring for wrongthink before then.)
- scoot_718 7y agoSince account creation was disabled, I'm sure it's the easiest moderation job going.
- maaaats 7y agoIt's not disabled?
- thisabled 7y agoI always make a fresh new throwaway account here every time I make a post, and,so, by this post you can deduce yourself. This is a zero-minute account, as all my accounts are. You're welcome.
- nkurz 7y agoI wish you wouldn't do that, as I think it's destructive to the community. Certainly things aren't perfect here, but certainly they could become worse. Violating the (difficult to enforce) rule that one maintain an "identity that others can relate to" contributes to making things worse.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoI think anonymity per se is not that bad, and I'm pretty sure many regularly create throwaway accounts for harmless discussion on many forums just for privacy reasons (avoid profiling & analysis, big brother, personal attacks, etc), not for posting inflammatory or controversial comments. Websites like Reddit Profile (https://redditprofile.com/about https://redditprofile.com/about) and HN Profile (https://hnprofile.com https://hnprofile.com) systematically scans all HN comments and identifies all users' expertise, personal interests, activities and emotions, and allow employers to uncover their E-mails and hire them. And it's just a one-man's startup as a social experiment, larger agencies and corporations have at least many order-of-magnitude higher budgets. And I definitely think not everyone wants that. The problem, I think, is this type of behavior encourages inappropriate uses and abuses of anonymity.
- dredmorbius 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jasoneckert 7y agoI'm relatively new (this year) to HN, but it has quickly become my favorite site for news (and tech news). While part of the reason for this is the clean, non-commercialized interface, the primary reason I frequent this site is the expert commentary on posts.
- whiteopinions 7y ago>Strict moderation I don't consider the moderation on this site to be strict at all? It's tone police more than it is content police. HN continually lets comments and statements go completely unquestioned, and in some cases actively supports view points, that are objectively wrong in the most vanilla fashion all because it was said in the correct manner.
- danso 7y agoAnd what's your point? You'd prefer the site take the more active role required to moderate based on content – which ostensibly includes opinions, and not just objective facts – rather than enforcing general civility?
- whiteopinions 7y ago>You'd prefer the site take the more active role required to moderate based on content No, the point was that bad content continually and consistently gets through moderation and community enforcement BECAUSE of the value of tone over content and sometimes this content is extremely hostile. It absolutely has nothing to do with civility. Civility and "tone" are not intertwined. You can be completely uncivil without an aggressive or strident tone. Moderation sets precedent. Moderator action typically only comes about when the community is offended in some way. Flagged posts never get corrected or vouched for despite the effort put into them if they go against a particular tone in the conversation or ideological perspective. Some of these were even presented in the article as examples. >rather than enforcing general civility? This forum isn't civil. It's distilled.
- magpi3 7y agoAre you suggesting that the moderators should make decisions about what is objectively wrong or right? Because that would be a lot of work for them and they would probably get it wrong. When it comes to the content, we (the commenters) are the ones responsible for holding each other accountable.
- toasterlovin 7y agoTone is important. Nobody was ever convinced by being screamed at. People who argue against tone policing are mostly just using that as a way to shut down their opponents.
- TailgateShrub 7y agoSkipping from thread to thread felt a bit like arriving at a party where half the room was sipping non-alcoholic shrubs and the other half had spent the afternoon tailgating in a stadium parking lot. This kind of vibe is why I read HN.
- 52-6F-62 7y agoI think it was much in the tone you described—at least that's how I read it. As for myself, I like that I can—on different days, or times of day—one of either camp!
- tanilama 7y agoDefinitely noticing the trend of politicizing of this place. But yeah, if that is what people cares about then so be it. Performative erudition is an interesting characterization, especially when this is from New Yorker.
- ppod 7y ago>The site’s now characteristic tone of performative erudition—hyperrational, dispassionate, It's a good article overall, but it would be nice, just for once, to read something in a mainstream "arts and culture" outlet that wasn't absolutely dripping with fear and contempt for anything related to tech culture.
- krapp 7y agoI didn't read anything dripping fear and contempt for tech culture in the article, much less the excerpt you quoted. It seems accurate to me.
- repolfx 7y agoI think the way it describes discussions here could be described as "dripping fear and contempt", slightly poetic though that wording is. Consider these quotes (I posted some above too): A recent comment thread ... yielded a response likening journalism and propaganda users combed through her code on GitHub in an effort to undermine the weight of her contributions The site’s now characteristic tone ... masks a deeper recklessness Ill-advised citations proliferate; thought experiments abound; humane arguments are dismissed as emotional or irrational. Logic, applied narrowly, is used to justify broad moral positions. The most admired arguments are made with data, but the origins, veracity, and malleability of those data tend to be ancillary concerns. (the last part of this quote seems to contradict the other accusations, but we can't check what she means by the veracity of data being an ancillary concern because ironically she provides no data) Hacker News readers who visit the site to learn how engineers and entrepreneurs talk, and what they talk about, can find themselves immersed in conversations that resemble the output of duelling Markov bots trained on libertarian economics blogs In the span of just one paragraph the journalist has: - Dehumanized us (we sound like bots) - Cast us as a weird outgroup (learn how they talk) - Dismissed logic and thought experiments as legitimate - Argued we aren't interested in "humane" arguments - Accused the community of ignoring the truth of data - Called us reckless If you really think all that stuff is accurate, why post here at all?
- krapp 7y ago
- dunkelheit 7y agoI guess it is a perfect opportunity to thank dang and sctb for their unobtrusive and friendly moderation efforts. The article itself was a bit disappointing because it focused on political issues. In my opinion the strength of HN in this regard is that it is both a "sjw cesspool" and a "haven for alt-right", as evidenced by the fact that a comment on a controversial topic can easily float near zero points while raking in both upvotes and downvotes. And even those who refer to it as "the orange site" still come back and comment. In other words, HN may be an echo chamber but it is a pretty big one with a lot of voices in it.
- ohaideredevs 7y agoDon't know sctb, but I have had run-ins with dang on multiple occasions where he asked me to stop arguing when I felt I wasn't being hostile. Nonetheless, it's always in a very moderate tone of doing his job, rather than trying to express power, and I respect that. (Nor am I implying that I didn't take the arguments too far, in some cases I did) The real proof that they do their job though is that I can still occasionally fine deep insights here that just aren't available in other places.
- Raphmedia 7y agoSame here. Dang has sent me such warnings before and it's always with such politeness that you end up feeling like an uneducated fool. HN has some of the best moderation that I have seen in a while. I have been a moderator for a large website in early 2000's and I can only admire them. This is no easy task.
- madez 7y agoI was also once called out by dang. He did it so respectingly and understandingly that it made a change for me. This was much better for my reflection about what was wrong about my behaviour than if I had been moderated more heavihandidly. I don't understand the amount of attention and patience that is necessary for it, but it makes a difference.
- radicalbyte 7y ago
- SoylentOrange 7y agoBig thanks to dang and sctb. You’re doing an impossible job, and doing it as well as two humans can. As others have said, this makes HN the best forum left on the Internet. I want you to know your efforts aren’t wasted or invisible to me. I am very appreciative of the tough work you both do.
- danso 7y agoIf the author is reading this, I would really enjoy hearing what the story pitch process for this was like. Even if it punches above its weight in terms of "mindshare", HN is still niche as far as tech subjects go. And, in terms of online communities, boring as hell compared to Reddit, 4/8chans, and even Usenet. The angle of focusing on the two human mods – particularly in the context of contemporary online content being associated with algorithmic moderation – is a good one, but still seems niche for the New Yorker. OTOH, it would definitely be a more obviously attractive pitch to Ars Technica or WIRED.
- ergl 7y agoShe has written several posts about Silicon Valley culture before, both for the New Yorker and other publications—I learned about her work back in 2016, on N+1. I recommend reading it, it was quite fun and depressing at the same time: https://nplusonemag.com/issue-25/on-the-fringe/uncanny-valley/ https://nplusonemag.com/issue-25/on-the-fringe/uncanny-valle...
- hos234 7y agoDiscussion in todays world is highly over rated. There are people who build hospitals and there are people who stand around talking about who should build hospitals. The former group in any population in any country is very small. The latter group is very large and thanks to the current architecture of the internet have gotten so over amplified that they think they actually matter. Their resumes don't have any actual achievement beyond drawing attention to things. They don't matter. People who are driven to build hospitals will keep building hospitals irrespective of all the "discussions" going on.
- FussyZeus 7y agoThe idea that the 'doers' are the only ones that matter, and that drawing attention to issues is mere posturing for social standing is a bad-faith critique of many people who act with good intentions. Yes, there are always those seeking to attach their names to worthy causes for their own gains. However people have taken that legitimate critique and amplified it to the degree that "If you aren't fixing the problem, you have zero right to complain about it" which is flatly ridiculous. You can be in a position where helping fix a given problem is simply not possible for any one of thousands of understandable reasons, but that doesn't mean you aren't allowed to speak about it, if for no other reason than so the other people who are able to help might know about it. People like to rip on others for the perception that they only draw awareness to issues and nothing more, but what exactly is a 20-something in college supposed to do? They often don't have disposable income, they often lack the means to travel to places, unless they are in the right college chances are they can't join a protest, the one resource they have in abundance is time. And so they use what they have to generate whatever impact they can. However small it might be, that impact is still worlds more helpful than the collected caws of "WhY aReN'T yoU fIxINg iT YOuRseLf?!"
- vorpalhex 7y agoIt doesn't take money to join protests. It doesn't take money to volunteer, even if it's just maintaining a newsletter or occasionally seeking donations for your local org. It's very easy to throw stones from afar when you've never been in the trenches. Those who don't do often make unreasonable demands because they have no connection to the reality of the situation of actually getting a thing done.
- romaaeterna 7y agoHacker News is a well-moderated community, but it's illustrative to see where Hacker News fails at moderation. While Hacker News is great at protecting the community from disruptive individuals, it tends to fall down when protecting unpopular individuals against the community turned mob. I support Hacker News moderating itself however it chooses. However, if we are looking at it as a moderation model for large, open, non-editorial platforms (Youtube, Facebook) -- which I believe should all be covered under public accommodation law -- it clearly fails. And even if when we are looking at ostensibly neutral, publicly-orientated sites like newspaper comment boards, it fails. Hacker News moderation is not appealable, not auditable, does not have bright line rules, and there are no due process rights. It simply does not respect individual rights. So while this moderation method succeeds for Hacker News, and perhaps should become the model for small private sites, we should not try to scale it internet-size companies. Platform companies (Google, Facebook, Twitter) and backbone companies (ISPs, Cloudflare!) need a different set of rules geared towards protecting individual rights and freedoms instead of protecting a community.
- epc 7y agoWhich "public accommodation law" do you refer to?
- romaaeterna 7y agoIn the US, that would be title II of the 1964 civil rights act, taking the broad view of it that has developed in case law over the years. I would also support new FCC net neutrality style regulations or even new acts of Congress that strengthened this.
- epc 7y agoAny changes to include internet services under the Civil Rights act would likely run into a First Amendment challenge fairly quickly, and likely lose. Net neutrality was probably constitutional as long as it applied to physical carriers using public land (for wires) or regulated spectrum. A more likely path would be through Section 508 (the accessibility act). Even that is unlikely with the current partisan makeup of Congress and the US Supreme Court.
- justin66 7y agodang and sctb possess admirable patience and persistence but I've always enjoyed dang's posts when he participates in a conversation. I wonder if his time spent serving as a moderator somewhat robs hn of an especially thoughtful poster. Thanks guys.
- dredmorbius 7y agodang does submit articles with some regularity. They're suprisingly rarely voted up, though as a reading queue are themselves very highly recommended by me.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoHow do you know their names, how do you know there are only 2? One of the problems for me about HN is the secretive nature of moderation.
- ergl 7y agoIt's right there in the article.
- magpi3 7y agoBecause 2T1Qka0rEiPr read the article :-)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoMy only question now is why can't I flag my own comment ;o)
- yorwba 7y agoWe know their names because they told us: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7493856 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7493856 (pg leaves dang in charge of moderation) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12073675 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12073675 (dang introduces sctb) Both those posts mention them already being involved in moderation before officially being declared moderators; you can do that too if you want! Just write email to hn@ycombinator.com if you see anything that you believe requires moderator intervention and they'll consider it.
- krapp 7y ago>One of the problems for me about HN is the secretive nature of moderation. I agree some aspects of moderation here are too opaque. While the mods will mention to users that they're about to be banned, or warn them about their behavior, this can take place enough after the fact that it's unlikely the comment will be read. Also, flags on your account, such as the loss of vouching or flagging privileges, or being slow-banned (as my account currently is,) aren't always apparent. What might be useful is a message queue from moderators that appears on your account. This would not only make certain that users were aware of penalties to their account, but it would sequester discussion about it away from the primary threads.
- yesand 7y agoThis is the largest circle jerk I’ve ever found myself in unwillingly.
- sittingnut 7y agomore like far from lonely, western establishment approved, comforted, and rewarded, work of moderating and censiring hn. fact.
- julienreszka 7y agoThis apologetic article changes nothing. The moderation of hackernews should be independently audited for biased censorship.
- danso 7y agoWhich independent authority do you suggest?
- dredmorbius 7y agoHow would you propose doing that? I've suggested some sort of transparency report. That wasn't warmly embraced, but a viable model might stil work.
- fallingfrog 7y agoI want to just say that I really appreciate the work that the hn mods do: thank you and keep up the good work!
- HNLurker2 7y ago>Every single time poll restrictions have been proposed, it’s been for racist causes,” wrote one user, in response to a commenter with the username rokosbasilisk, who... This is why I don't read hacker news, unexpectedly you will get an existential nightmare. (Lucky for those who never heard of LessWrong )
- HNLurker2 7y agoRokosbasilisk is what I mean. I suggest not googling that, down voters go ahead
- Fnoord 7y ago> Gackle is drawn to healing workshops; Bell, to Indian philosophy. They seem, at times, to be applying old, humanist techniques to a culture obsessed with the future. I wouldn't have guessed that. What's next though is even more interesting: > “Something that’s deeply interesting, I think, to both of us,” Gackle said, “is the way in which one can arrive at a nonviolent reaction to somebody by having greater awareness of the—” He paused. “I’ll say violence in oneself. By which I mean the kind of agitation and activation that is causing people, including ourselves, to react in a kind of fight-or-flight way that leads to misunderstanding, conflict, and, ultimately, Internet flame wars. This seemingly trivial stuff, about people getting mad at other people on the Internet, is actually tied to this much deeper and more fascinating process of what goes on between people and what goes on in oneself.” Essentially, the task of Dan and Scott is akin to the task of a (good) teacher. A communication teacher, perhaps?
- chippy 7y agoThis also caught my eye and it would be something I'd like to read about and discuss here too!
- carapace 7y agoI was taught a metaphysical law (a psychological heuristic, if you prefer) called "the Mirror Principle" (it has other names), to wit: When someone has some behaviour or quality that irritates or upsets you, you will often find that you have that behaviour or quality yourself but are unaware of it. Becoming aware of it helps to "move your energy" on the underlying issue or tension.
- peterwwillis 7y agoAre the moderators interested in automating their jobs at all? I really don't understand why the site continues to have no means to help people communicate better, other than a couple dudes that manually respond to people over and over all day. From a technologist perspective it seems archaic.
- dang 7y agoHow can we automate our jobs?
- peterwwillis 7y agoBy applying a process to begin identifying the needs for moderation and developing automated solutions. Later, designs can be modified to remove the need for the automation.
- dang 7y agoI feel like this begs the question. How do we develop automated solutions? This seems much harder to me than it appears to seem to you.
- peterwwillis 7y agoWell granted it's not something you can finish in a weekend. A lot of things seem hard because they're difficult to imagine at the beginning. Who in the past would have guessed that in the future we'd all be running around in carriages whose front part literally explodes 25 times per second? From a general standpoint, we develop automated solutions by following new product development[1]. More specifically, we develop features for users to provide different kinds of feedback, and write functions that combine that feedback with machine learning to perform actions when necessary. Even more specifically, the entirety of forum interaction is an input/output of information in people's brains, computed along with emotion, heuristics, and whatever knowledge the brain has, and generates output. By collecting meta-information about the input and output (such as crowdsourced content flags like category of information, perceived intent of a comment, training data models on old content, etc) we can make functions that use the metadata to perform actions, such as auto-detaching threads, muting users, delaying reply buttons, providing feedback to commenters, and highlighting or shadowing content. A lot of these are already done (some automated, some not), but I think the big feature is when these are done; find the emotional pain points, provide functions that mitigate them based on metadata. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_product_development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_product_development
- samgranieri 7y agoI didn't even realize this place had mods or needed moderation, and I've been reading it for almost a decade.
- sunstone 7y agoInteresting that almost all the comments on this thread are related to politics whereas the primary value to me of HN are the technical topics and discussions. There are plenty of other places on the net to argue politics with bots and paid influencers.
- danaos 7y ago> In April, when a story about Katie Bouman, an M.I.T. researcher who helped develop a technology that captured the first photo of a black hole, rose to the front page, users combed through her code on GitHub in an effort to undermine the weight of her contributions. Hmm. I guess citation needed?
- raldi 7y agoThis seems to have been either a complete, sensationalistic fabrication, or at best, a totally negligent misread. See for yourself: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19632086 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19632086 The thread began, "If Katie was a man do you think people would be going through git histories and their published papers trying to determine if she is being over-credited for her achievements?" And it's not referring to others on HN; as the replies make clear, it's about people elsewhere.
- minimaxir 7y agoScroll down to the very bottom of that discussion thread and unfurl the flagged threads. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19634262 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19634262 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19632301 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19632301
- raldi 7y agoThe comments on that story were nothing like the impression any reader would get from the reporter's description. Again: "users combed through her code on GitHub" Reality: One user, in a detached, downvoted, flagged, dead comment invisible to 99% of visitors to the site posted a link to an image analyzing her GH contributions, and was immediately and widely rebuked.
- minimaxir 7y agoI was in that thread while it was active: it took awhile for those discussions to become "detached, downvoted, flagged, dead".
- lucb1e 7y agoHas anyone ever seen an online community (with more than a handful of users) that focuses on more than cute puppy pictures and that is not described as "toxic" by "critics"? I'd say that HN does a great job at avoiding that. The article is titled "moderating hacker news" but fails to describe just how good a job the moderators and owners are doing. The moderators for moderation, and the owners for (as I perceive it) giving the moderators the freedom to try things that are best for the community (such as the politics-free experiment).
- catacombs 7y agoIt's not up to The New Yorker to give praise to moderators or owners. That's inserting bias. It's up to the readers (us) to determine whether the moderators are doing a good job.
- anchpop 7y agoI agree with you, but this article certainly had plenty of bias
- slang800 7y ago> That's inserting bias. Are you implying that this article was trying to be bias-free? The author spent entire paragraphs just cherry-picking "toxic" things that have been said on HN to make discussion here look bad.
- lucb1e 7y agoThat's a very good description of what I mind about the article. Cherry-picking "toxic" things, that's exactly it.
- floatingatoll 7y agoYes, I have.
- dredmorbius 7y agoMetafilter certainly comes to mind. Though I believe it's well below HN in scale. On Reddit, there are several immensely moderated subs with persistent high quality, and millions of subscribers, notably /r/AskScience and /r/AskHistorians (though also numerous others). Smaller subreddits are relatively easy to maintain at quality, though sustaining engagement is hard (much of the Reddit dynamic actively works against this). Keeping large subs sane is exceptionally difficult. Getting "defaulted" (being added to the list of default-subscribed subreddits) was long seen as the kiss of death for smaller, quality, subreddits.
- TACIXAT 7y agoThe moderation here is amazing. Thanks to the mods!
- howard941 7y agoGuys, thanks for the work you do.
- billfruit 7y agoStrange that the article seems to hinge mostly on moderation, rather than any of the other things that make HN a great resource. To me the great difference of HN over anything else has been the expectation on commentors to write something thoughtfull and well argued, and it's discouragement of frivolous commentary. The mainstream media seems hungup on the concept of moderation when discussing online communities, and I think the moderation framework is only a minor part of what make these communities work.
- tomcam 7y ago> I think the moderation framework is only a minor part of what make these communities work. With all due respect, it feels to me that you have never had the experience of running an online community at scale. I believe the moderation for this site is the only thing that keeps it from deteriorating into complete chaos and toxicity. I am also amazed that the two moderators have managed to hang on for so long. It seems to me like the archetypal burnout job.
- drinane 7y agoYeah if I don't fall in line with our un-elected SJWs and push out bay area propaganda I get flamed. Very interesting.
- balozi 7y agoCall me cynical but that piece reads like an ad. Normally you see this sort of articles when an entity is trying to raise it's profile for some reason. Maybe a funding round coming up, asset sale, IPO, etc.
- julienreszka 7y agoThey are preparing for government audits of their censorship practices
- slang800 7y agoI didn't think it was very ad-like. If Anna Wiener were trying to boost the profile of HN then she probably wouldn't have included all those random examples of "toxic" comments and political discussions that she disagrees with. It was certainly positive toward the moderators, but not the site as a whole.
- dredmorbius 7y agoIt's interesting to compare HN with attempts which claimed they were striving to create an inclusive space but which failed. I'd encountered one such newly-launched site, heralded as "a kinder, gentler Reddit" in 2016. Not only did the site itself collapse and fail a year later, but it failed, in the extreme, to live up to its promise, in part through the user community (always a confounding factor) but also through exceedingly poor moderation both by volunteer user mods and the site's paid staff and management. I'll note: I was largely in agreement with the site's stated principles and politics, and still found myself very much on the dark side of it. Contrast with HN where I consider myself frequently contrarian and yet reasonably well tolerated. In writing on the experience I called out the contrast with HN specifically. In part: The really striking thing for me is that a bastion of one representation of what Internet critics, erm, criticise, HN, is proving much more effective at accomplishing and embodying the goals which Imzy, a "kinder, gentler" place, has set out to achieve. ... with a longer discussion of the things that seem to work particularly well. See: https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/500ysb/the_imzy_experience_well_that_escalated_quickly/ https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/500ysb/the_imz... I disagree with dang and sctb on occaision. I am disappointed that there are topics that HN doesn't seem able to discuss (and have called these out). I've been admonished a few times. But on balance, the site works, and rewards time spent on it. And credit must go to dang and sctb. Thanks, guys.
- tomcam 7y agoI disagree with dang and sctb on occaision. I am disappointed that there are topics that HN doesn't seem able to discuss (and have called these out). I've been admonished a few times. But on balance, the site works, and rewards time spent on it. And credit must go to dang and sctb. Thanks, guys. Same here. I believe I have been throttled unjustifiably on a couple of occasions, but so what. They responded quickly to my pleas for help and I also learned stuff. I feel very grateful to have this site as part of my life.
- stormtv 7y agoI'm surprised that the quality of HN hasn't fallen as drastically with user growth as much as other sites such as reddit. Thanks to the moderators for keeping HN great.
- meowface 7y agoI think it's all our own fault if we ever expected expert political philosophy or scientific debate from a group of people who mostly just, at the end of the day, program websites and phone apps. A high percentage of IT, software engineering, and professional advice on HN is very valuable, but the percentage of other kinds of commentary that's valuable is much lower. I occasionally also get sucked into the sorts of debates that I just shat on, but most of the time I find myself having to scroll past huge chunks of comment sections because half the sub-threads are pedantic political debates over some term or whatever, nested 10+ levels deep.
- jacquesm 7y agoTo save you some scrolling: if you click the little [-] the thread will collapse. I've campaigned to make the default an all-collapsed page but it did not get much support.
- nkurz 7y agoArguably, by putting the comments on a separate page they already are collapsed by default. Going to the comments page signifies that one wants to view the comments. Why do you think a further level of collapsing would be beneficial? Would you expand things once they are upvoted, or always require an additional click to view the deeper levels?
- cgriswald 7y agoI wouldn’t mind seeing sub threads collapsed by default. (Of course I could always do that myself.) It would make for a cleaner page. I could scan the top level comments for interest subtopics/responses, and it would discourage thread-jacking.
- dorgo 7y agoJust tried: [].slice.call( document.querySelectorAll( '.togg' ) ).forEach( x => x.click() ) It's really slow. Takes 5-10 seconds for 100 comments. Maybe I just need one of these new AMD processors.
- 7y ago
- diminoten 7y agoI'm concerned that articles like these paper over the myriad issues that arose when one person (dang) holds a monopoly on the content of a community. I further worry that this is only going to embolden dang into further deluded thought that he can't make mistakes, that his judgement is without flaw.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 7y ago> “Almost every post deals with the same topics: these are people who spend their lives trying to identify all the ways they can extract money from others without quite going to jail[...]” A money quote for me, but it's not inclusive of the angry bystander programmers raging about externalities and corruption, and the employees trying to figure out a way that they can ethically stay employed when their boss (and probably their company's business model) is this. HN is all three. Less so with time, though, it was once a more equal mix.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoSome heroes don't wear capes, and I believe our moderators here are heroes. Providing a platform for free expression and creative thinking. It's truly a noble pursuit. I can't imagine the personal toll of moderating people's baser instincts (my own included)
- ymAg 7y agoI'm not an unconditional HN fan (avid reader of n-gate), but the article is just a silly covert hit piece against the evil nerd morlocks (who of course build the infra that the NewYorker Eloi use to distribute their vapid opinions).
- PieUser 7y agoThis is a wonderful article. I love The New Yorker.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pastor_elm 7y agoNo mention of perma bans of specific users? Michael O. Church comes to mind.
- carapace 7y agoHuge thanks to dang and sctb! I really appreciate your work. I feel like it is working, FWIW.
- Tiktaalik 7y agoYep strict moderation is required for (quasi) anonymous internet discussion sites. Strict moderation is why olde forums like Somethingawful don't have nazis, but weak/no moderation twitter is full of them.
- the8472 7y agoTwitter may be full of nazis, but when I am looking at a feed of cute cat pictures I don't see any of them. That they merely exist shouldn't matter, what matters is giving users the tools they need to look at the content they want to see instead of random crap injected by others. Choose your filter bubble.
- Eiriksmal 7y agoDeeply impressed by the author's dedication to fleshing out this story. Learning about n-gate's existence, and then tracking down the creator to get his take on Hacker News? Excellent work. N-gate's comments are an excellent summary of the portion of HN's population that gives the website its unique reputation: >>>The proprietor of N-gate is an engineer who grew up in Palo Alto and now lives in the Pacific Northwest, where he works in high-performance computing. He agreed to exchange e-mails on condition of anonymity. “Almost every post deals with the same topics: these are people who spend their lives trying to identify all the ways they can extract money from others without quite going to jail,” he wrote. “They’re people who are convinced that they are too special for rules, and too smart for education. They don’t regard themselves as inhabiting the world the way other people do; they’re secret royalty, detached from society’s expectations and unfailingly outraged when faced with normal consequences for bad decisions. Society, and especially economics, is a logic puzzle where you just have to find the right set of loopholes to win the game. Rules are made to be slipped past, never stopping to consider why someone might have made those rules to start with. Silicon Valley has an ethics problem, and ‘Hacker’ ‘News’ is where it’s easiest to see.”
- klez 7y agoYou just violated the prime directive.
- yters 7y agoMy account gets the 'posting too fast ban' more than I'd like, but cannot say it is always unearned. My runin with the mods is always cordial. I will say HN is more open minded than most forums these days. Good job mods.
- mushufasa 7y agoI liked this article, though I think it missed the best part of Hacker News. To me, Hacker News can feel like walking through Dumbledore's office -- magical and mind-bending collections of incredible devices, ideas, and oddities. Just yesterday someone posted a comment with links to UI design libraries that I've been subconsciously wishing for in my dreams (humaans, undraw.co), and I used it in a product demo. As a self-taught technologist, HN has exposed me to SICP, functional programming, and just yesterday someone posted a book about Data Structures and Algorithms that I started reading. Dang was quoted as describing HN as a "hall of mirrors" or "fractal tree." The author's focus on the controversial political parts of HN seems to me like going to a music festival and commenting on the food trucks. Yes, it's part of the experience, but that's not why people go and not what makes it magical. Communicating the beauty of unfamiliar technical topics to a lay reader is much harder than politics, but the New Yorker has done well at that elsewhere (I like the Sanjay and Jeff profile). Moderation is an interesting topic in its own right, though, especially in the age of the IRA and meme-warfare.
- mfoy_ 7y agoDon't suppose you saved a link to that comment?
- ckris 7y agoIn defense of the article, what you are talking about is a different story more "finding the Internet and programming" that isn't really unique to Hacker News. It can surely be used that way, and people likely do, but you can also find those things by searching for "top programming books" (or hanging around twitter, quora, medium or other sites). They did sort of talk about that with the early motivations for Hacker News. And you could absolutely go to a music festival and write about the food trucks, the people and the atmosphere that if that is what unique about that festival. I think they did a good job in that regard. People don't obsessively read Hacker News to help newcomers, they do so because it is all in all a technical tabloid.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- KyleEckert 7y agoMods here clearly have an agenda, and are far from unbiased. How much do these guys make?
- tosh 7y agoThe profile was exciting to read. Similar to devouring "making of" bonus material that used to be bundled with dvds. Made me think: I'd like to read/hear more from dang & sctb and how they look at things. Have you ever thought about something like a podcast or blog or something like a microblog or commented bookmark feed? edit: completely forgot: thank you so much for pouring your hearts and souls into this community. like another commenter already noted: hn is one of the few remaining well moderated corners of the web. feels a bit like all the other elves already left middle earth. it is wonderful to have you.
- tomcam 7y agoCompletely agree. It’s also stunningly impressive to me that the parent company pays the salaries of two full-time, severely overqualified moderators for site I can use for free.
- rbancroft 7y agoCongratulations Dan and Scott! Well deserved recognition and I learned a thing or two about you that I didn't know. All the best from Ryan in Calgary.
- thwythwy 7y agoThis reads like a mediocre college admissions essay full of breathless, overdramatic characterizations of minor, anodyne exchanges. I had to stop reading when a two word response from a user gave the author "a small rush of triumph." The tone and word choice is just nauseating. Examples abound: > "Commenters . . . . bickered about the word 'soul.'" > "Conversation spiralled, with users making arguments about Cartesian metaphysics and quoting Socrates." The interesting aspects of this article could fill a tweet. "1/3 of HN users come from europe. It has mods. They have tatts. Check out @shit_hn_says"
- dang 7y agoOne has tatts.
- tptacek 7y agoYou know you want "Please don't do this here" on your arm. Maybe in, like, kanji characters or something.
- amyjess 7y agoProbably not the best phrase to get done in Japanese. There's no kanji; you'd write all of it in hiragana. ここでしないでください。 [koko de shinaide kudasai] Or maybe if you wanted to emphasize the "this": ここでこれをしないでください。 [koko de kore o shinaide kudasai]
- tptacek 7y agoSeriously, what's the number we'd have to hit in a charity Kickstarter to make Dan do this?
- intentionalmeta 7y agoPlease don't do this here. > Don't be snarky. Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- citilife 7y agoI gotta say, I appreciate the moderation on Hacker News. I've appreciated several messages back and forth with dang and sctb, about moderation, my behavior, even UI. From my experience, it's the best moderated sites on the internet. Kudos moderating team!
- bifrost 7y agoI had the honor and privilege of working along side the HN team and I think the best description I can put out there is that they're wonderful. HN is a unique place on the internet, I'm hoping it never changes.
- rebuilder 7y agoA complete sideline, but I thought the age of the IRA was past. What have I missed?
- monocasa 7y agoInternet Research Agency, not Irish Republican Army
- etchalon 7y agoI don't have anything insightful or critical to add, but I did want to say how much I enjoyed the article.
- arendtio 7y agoFWIW, I find that the political discussions here are still a lot better than in most other places on the internet and sometimes I find them quite valuable. For example, I have a pretty solid attitude against genetically enhanced food and where I live, there are quite some people who think likewise (central Europe). But through HN I learned, that there are other places in the world, where such food can significantly improve the lives of many humans and where educated people can't understand how on earth you can possibly be against using such technology. I find such insights very valuable because it shows me how limited and filtered ones real-live perception can be.
- burfog 7y agoThe attitude against genetically enhanced food is purposely promoted in Europe. You could say the attitude is not organic. :-) It serves as a non-tariff trade barrier against the USA. Promoting this attitude serves the European agricultural producers, particularly the seed suppliers. European consumers of course pay higher prices.
- lynnetye 7y agoI loved this article and just want to thank Dan and Scott for all that they do. I appreciate how moderating a forum like HN leads to deep introspection about what triggers us. "This seemingly trivial stuff, about people getting mad at other people on the Internet, is actually tied to this much deeper and more fascinating process of what goes on between people and what goes on in oneself." It's too easy to judge quickly (i.e. never reading but criticizing an article based on its title) and misunderstand strangers on the Internet. I admire the extreme patience that our HN mods have in helping us to judge less quickly and respond more thoughtfully to one another here. It's no doubt a challenging, emotionally taxing, and never-ending job, but y'all are doing it and doing it well. Thank you.
- khawkins 7y ago>The most ideologically motivated or extreme posts and comments on Hacker News—an interview piece from Quillette titled “Understanding Victimhood Culture”; a link to a video of James Damore and Jordan Peterson in conversation; one user telling another that all Jewish people should relocate to Israel—tend to get flagged by the community or the site’s anti-abuse systems, many of which Bell and Gackle have written themselves... >When stories that focus on structural barriers faced by women in the workplace, or on diversity in tech, or on race or masculinity—stories, admittedly, that are more intriguing to me, a person interested in the humanities, than stories on technical topics—hit the front page, users often flag them, presumably for being off topic, so fast that hardly any comments accrue. These are features, not bugs, and testaments to the quality moderation. All over the internet these topics are discussed, ad nauseam, and they're some of the most divisive issues in modern day discourse. Even the author can't seem to represent her political opponents fairly. Without removing these topics, these ideological wars will irrevocably divide the community, sending one segment away in deep frustration. If we'd like to unify society, it's far more important to have spaces which don't immediately polarize along these lines.
- roymurdock 7y agoThank you @dang and @sctb!! Loved learning more about you and reading about your passion for the community, it really comes through in the quotes. Keep up the great work.
- ilamont 7y agoTwo questions I had after reading this article: 1) Of the 5 million users, how many are active readers and active commenters? 2) How can the careful moderation described in the article scale?
- debbiedowner 7y agoVery nice that dang and sctb were involved in such a timely and solid startup idea! If they were luckier, they could have been bought by Google sheets, which acquired XL2Web, DocVerse, Quickoffice in their improvements 2006-2012: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Sheets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Sheets
- stefantalpalaru 7y ago> Gackle is drawn to healing workshops Yeah, I bet he has a lot of healing to do after getting Ian Murdock's blood on his hands. How's that working out for you, Danny boy?
- laurex 7y agoI admit that when I joined Hacker News, I viewed it to some extent as an anthropology experiment, since discussions I encountered reflected some of the issues cited in the article, specifically that some discussions seemed to reflect a myopia that suggested participants were likely rarely exposed to people outside their bubble, and often a lack of respect for views that were outside that paradigm. However, I've seen discussions become more tempered, and a great influence from Dan and Scott as moderators (thank you!). At this point, I do read and contribute to Hacker News in lieu of most other social media, though sometimes I still read comments that feel arrogant or dismissive of outside views, especially when topics that are cultural enter the picture. My general approach is to just ignore them and move on to more productive discussions, and sometimes to feel like it might be time for a break for me, though I'm not sure there are any online communities I think do a much better job of having civil discourse.
- tomcam 7y agoAlso, I often find it that it is better to skip right to the commentary because it is often so much better than the length article.
- _hardwaregeek 7y ago> N-gate, a satirical Web site with the slogan “We can’t both be right” (a NAND gate is a kind of logic gate that only outputs “false” if all of its inputs read “true”), offers a weekly summary of Hacker News discussions, dubbed “webshit weekly.” I always find these critics a little funny. It's like the classic Beatles joke about record burners: They're still buying the record. If you're writing weekly newsletter about how Hacker News sucks, you're still reading Hacker News every week. Seems like every internet community has some form of built in hatred of itself as a gestalt. Redditors bemoan how much the "hivemind" sucks. There's endless Facebook posts about how Facebook is so terrible.
- MarcScott 7y agoFrom the N-gate proprietor > these are people who spend their lives trying to identify all the ways they can extract money from others without quite going to jail I don't think this individual understands how diverse this community is. I was a teacher when I started reading HN, and now work in the charitable sector (albeit tech centered). I know musicians, educators, academic scientists and historians that read and participate here. We're not all founding or working for startups.
- StonyBrook84 7y agoAs a Jewish coder, I would like to take this opportunity to thank moderator "dang" for banning antisemites wholesale. As a fellow Jew, he has gone above and beyond in preventing hate and ignorance from spreading on this website, ensuring that there's absolutely zero tolerance for intolerance. Dang, thank you for silencing the antisemites!
- rland 7y agoI have seen dang's tailored-to-individual responses to provocative comments on HN, and in my view they are THE gold standard method of diffusing these difficult sorts of discussions, both in real life and on the internet. That type of moderation is rare and it is the thing that sets HN apart from other forums.
- jrvarela56 7y agoDoes anyone here have a forum they like more than HN? Don't tell me 'it depends for what'. Just your overall go-to place on the internet to find content and read discussions about it.
- alanh 7y agoI love the article illustration. It's really stellar work. Good job, Scott Gelber! [Explaining more is difficult, and vague praise can seem insincere. I am serious, not sarcastic]
- incompatible 7y agoCouch alluder? https://duckduckgo.com/?q=couch+alluder https://duckduckgo.com/?q=couch+alluder
- defterGoose 7y agoJust last night I went down a rabbit hole reading about perspectives on climate change. I googled "hacker news for environmentalism", looking for a forum similar to this but with a less direct focus on software tech. This led back to an ask HN thread asking what users were doing to help combat climate change. This in turn led me to a comment that mentioned the "Deep Adaptation" paper by Jem Bendell which was something of an epiphany in that it's an almost perfect exposition on the existential dread that has come to be a low-level hum in my everyday life. It was also comforting to know that someone had codified my attitude about this dread being not a hindrance but rather a good thing. Anyway, it just goes to show that while I wish this forum had more of a focus on these issues, the discussion here is almost always a great source of thoughtful perspectives and a place to come express oneself honestly and openly. So thanks for that, HN.
- kingkawn 7y agoI think that the censorship of viciousness rather than content is a reasonable compromise. I have engaged in a wide range of political and ethical debates on hn, and the few times the mods have shown interest has only been if I am beefing too hard with someone. The exercise of power is not to be superior, but to give the forum a sense of shape so that people can relate to it more readily. I think given the scale of the site they are doing good work.
- 75dvtwin 7y agoI liked the article's info on the background of the moderators. It was informative if anything. And made me feel that they are more human than I thought :-). However, I disagree with these nuance-avoiding characterization of participation and discussion. Eg, the article makes participants in Boeing crash discussion, seem inhumane and devoid of 'outrage' that the authors of the article were expecting. On the other hand, the article is not analytical enough (or purposefully avoiding) mentioning the potential causes, that make moderation of a technical forum difficult. As I had noted somewhere else in my posts, this forum allows a disproportionaly high number of one-sided article submissions. It is those type of submissions, by often high-karma users (eg. https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=jbegley https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=jbegley ) that continue to create selective-outrage, counter-selective-outrage arguments, and overall high stress, low technical information content discussions. And cause continuous moderation stress.
- kashyapc 7y ago[Forgive if I've missed this in the deservedly KM-long thread; I didn't find any in a couple of rushed `grep`s.] On the "sheer quantity of it is so overwhelming": Not that I didn't already guess the workload would be staggering, given the gargantuan flow of comments and submissions ... still, I find the above somewhat disquieting—for the long-term health of both the moderators. I realize that some long-time members of this community assist dang & sctb in helping moderate. Regardless, I hope they can have a slightly larger "official" team to spread the unstoppable stream of workload. Not merely for the sake of quantity, but to have fewer occurrences of having your psychological buttons get stress-tested. (I'm sure they know this, and consider this topic from time-to-time, as mentioned in the article.) - - - Also happy to have learnt some background and interests of the human moderators. Thanks for the fine work, folks.
- ausjke 7y agofor fair and balance as a moderator, I hope they're not too left or too right, though I will not be surprised their political view are already on the left, since it's from Silicon Valley. also the system should have a way to know who is upvoting all the time or downvoting all the time, those are noises statistically and should be somehow mitigated.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoIt doesn't really seem to do justice to the problem that all moderation has: 1) Moderators always assume the worst of people. I remember asking one time about car repair online, and at the time, I had a repair that needed to be made to make driving at high speeds safe. But moderators and others seem to assume that when you can't do something 100% right immediately, you are therefore going to do something wrong. I simply wasn't driving at high speeds to make up for the issue - not everyone has access to the money they need all the time. I mean why would I even be posting such a question on a forum otherwise. 2) Downvotes are based upon agreeing with your answer and not especially geared towards how qualitative your answers are. I've gotten upvotes for basically stupid answers, which have no business being upvoted ad infinitum for essentially being a dumb meme. I've been downvoted (rather than debated) for answers that others outright disagreed with. At this point, it really feels like online forums are a place to beat people's opinions into submission, which is something I strongly disagree with. There's a famous saying that states "If everyone is thinking the same thing, then someone isn't thinking." I hold fast to this comment, and I look forward to hearing why people think and believe different things, especially when they are able to articulate why. No forum I have ever been to has really appreciated this, especially in the face of controversy. This feels too much like a new breed of close mindedness, which I am supposing is not too different from the thought crime, which if I recall correctly was conceived in the book 1984.
- brightball 7y ago2) That's also been my experience. I've always been interested to see if a forum moderator would "down vote proof" a post that falls into that category: Unpopular but well reasoned and not inflammatory. In the same way that "anti-brigading" approaches watch for floods of upvotes from a single referral source, it seems like clearing + blocking down votes would be beneficial in the other direction (or temporarily suspending access to down voting for users exhibiting the behavior).
- overcast 7y agoVoting, since DIGG popularized the entire idea, will always be an agree/disagree button. Not the intended see more of / see less of.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- g00s3_caLL_x2 7y agoFuck the mods. Most are paid shill cucks. Fucking faggots.
- PaulHoule 7y agoOne thing the article got wrong is that the Hacker News community is not limited to Silicon Valley. For instance, the person who has the highest karma is in Brazil. Very few of the people I have met on Hacker News are in the Valley and San Francisco, but I have met people from North Carolina, Philadelphia, Portugal, India, Singapore, ... If you're interested in both technology and business and you've had enough of the self-promoters promoting self promotion that dominate LinkedIn and other social media places, Hacker News is a refuge. What is missing from Hacker News is a handful of sensationalist topics that dominate the mass media but lead to discussions that never go anywhere and never terminate. That's what they are designed to do. Neither the democrats or republicans want the situation with guns or abortion to change dramatically because it would disturb an ecosystem where they can count on a large proportion of the population to vote for them automatically, thus they can get elected while promising less. What both sides have in common is they look at a place like HN and think that their side is being discriminated against because they are special snowflakes who really have something to say that matters about fake controversies and they don't seem to be satisfied posting to the 99.99% of forums that are choked with that stuff. The real difference between HN and the social media giants is the business model. I believe Y Combinator runs HN to extend it's reputation, attract startups to join Y Combinator and otherwise participate in it's ecosystem. To do that it has to have quality. Facebook, Google and other companies based on advertising pretty much have to be merchants of outrage because that is what people click on.
- edubs25 7y ago>One thing the article got wrong is that the Hacker News community is not limited to Silicon Valley. I thought the article was pretty clear that Hacker News user base is predominantly North America and Europe, not just the valley? I don't have any data to back this up, but based on the sources that are posted and gain traction in the community, I suspect majority NA & Europe is accurate. But that's just an observation based on my personal experiences that different regions of the world view information sources differently in terms of reputation and trust. Has HN or anyone else ever tried to aggregate stats on content sources or user location data?
- 7y ago
- g00s3_caLL_x2 7y agoFAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!! FAGGOTS!!!! ALL CUCK MOD FAGGOTS!!!
- piketty 7y agoI loved this article. I'm a software engineer in Chicago and I had stayed away from HN, not knowing that there might be a humanist angle to the site that would be appealing to someone like me.
- piketty 7y agoI liked this article a lot. I'm a swe in Chicago and I had stayed away from HN previously, not knowing that there was a humanist side to the site that would appeal to someone like me.
- belisarius48 7y agoI have little experience is functioning modern society so I suppose taciturn skepticism is my best posture.
- ggm 7y agoI think HN like ALdaily has a curated "you can't bottle it" quality. They might add another, or pass it on and ... It would change. Don't change.
- gigama 7y ago"They are hopeful that, as Hacker News continues to grow, it will become, simultaneously, more diverse, more interesting, and more humane, while remaining in some fundamental sense a single community with a common goal." Right on. Greatly value this melting pot of diverse views and links that often lead to serendipitous discovery, clever ideas, and considered thought. What I originally hoped the internet would turn out to be. So in case no one's said it in awhile, thank you to Paul Graham for starting and sustaining this outlet for reckless thought experiments, and to Scott and Daniel for their devoted management to herding all us feral cats. Keep up the good work! Now back to the lab to continue coding my dueling libertarian Markov bots...