18 ms·
Maker Faire halts operations and lays off all staff
- algaeontoast 7y agoThis is really sad. I still remember being excited to pick up a new issue of Make: every month or so when I was in middle school. Also fondly remember watching “Weekend Projects” with Bre Petis (well before his MakerBot Years). Lots of great folks - Sad to see this movement die.
- detaro 7y agoIMHO, the movement is just fine. Make as a company, and partially as a brand, failed, but that doesn't mean that much.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deevolution 7y agoMakerfaire as an experience was great. Food, wonky projects, competitions, and overall a fun event to hang out with friends, connect with others and learn. I would say kill the magazine and focus on improving the event experience and focus on community building and find a way to reduce or eliminate the dependence on corporate sponsors. Maybe the community has changed or moved on or matured and makerfair has served its purpose. Maybe this marks the end of an era and it's time to move onto something new. I went 4 years in a row while in undergrad but stopped attending after graduation I think because it was getting a bit stale. Seemed like lots of projects year after year were simple iterations or very similar to previous ones. Also it felt like at some point there was a transition from wow look at this funky science/tech/art project to hey do you want to buy my product?
- di3goleite 7y agoSome folks from the community created that initiative! Let's support!!! https://twitter.com/MATRIX_Creator/status/1137224658691002368 https://twitter.com/MATRIX_Creator/status/113722465869100236...
- sdicongo 7y agoSDICONGO
- lloydde 7y agoCoincidentally, I found myself on Obvious Ventures earlier today and was impressed to see they backed Make:. https://obvious.com/portfolio/maker-media https://obvious.com/portfolio/maker-media That brought back fond memories of early Make Magazine collaborator, I think editor, Phillip Torrone presenting at one of the first WordPress WordCamps.
- inflatableDodo 7y ago>"1.45 million people attended its events in 2016. MAKE: magazine had 125,000 paid subscribers and the company had racked up over one million YouTube subscribers." This should be able to pay for 22 staff.
- paxys 7y agoNot if you also have to get your VCs the return they are expecting.
- inflatableDodo 7y agoI think that there should be an exit clause for VC backed businesses along the lines of, 'well, we were all morons to think this would make everyone wildly rich, but this can be an ongoing business, so lets not shut it down.'
- citrablue 7y agoBecause investors are paid for taking risk, that decision has to happen at the point of investment. Or, the entrepreneurs would have to be willing to massively sacrifice their upside for their vision. The exit clause is "don't take VC money if you want to run an ongoing business". Otherwise, the buoyancy of a somewhat profitable business is sunk by the history of leverage, debt, and expectation.
- bubblewrap 7y agoI don't completely understand the logic. After all, if they shut down, the VCs won't get anything, either. So why not keep it running and reap at least little rewards.
- paxys 7y agoOnce you take the funding, you have to spend it all on expanding operations, new staff, marketing, promotions etc. If you then can't generate a profit, unless you raise more rounds the increased expenses are going to kill your business. So in this case the VCs cut their losses instead of giving them more money.
- URSpider94 7y agoIt poured rain at this year’s Bay Area Maker Faire in late May, which is absolutely unheard-of. I had a really bad feeling when that happened that it might be the end of the venture. The cash outlay to run an event like that must run into the hundreds of thousands, and if attendance was cut in half, then they lost their shirts on it.
- alanlovestea 7y agoYea, I had planned to bring my 5 and 2 years old there, but due to the rain, we went to the mall :(
- bsimpson 7y ago> Dougherty said that despite rain, Maker Faire’s big Bay Area event last week met its ticket sales target.
- binarysolo 7y agoHuge bummer, I loved it as a participant. Didn't realize it was a venture-backed business... for some reason I thought it was a nonprofit.
- beenBoutIT 7y agoIt had the feel of a non-profit. It's too bad they can't rework Make magazine into something PBS would be into.
- anticensor 7y agoThe fairs can be reworked into something non-profit, though.
- bkraz 7y agoIt's a real loss. It likely could have survived as a bootstrapped business, but being venture backed meant either large growth or death. Dale hints at this in the article, and the choices Maker Media has made over time make more sense knowing the pressures of investment were top priority.
- tonydiv 7y agounfortunately, this. Oh you will be missed, especially by the kids! :(
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoI didn't know it was venture backed. I am having a hard time imagining that as a swing-for-fences, 100x-1000x return kind of business. It sounds more like the kind if thing where a cash strapped business works out a long term deal with an understanding property owner who has maker kids constantly asking for a better 3-D printer.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThanks capitalism
- ummonk 7y agoBetween this and the tech shop bankruptcy, is there a broader issue with financial viability in the maker industry?
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoShit doesn't make money.
- therealgranton 7y agoCorrect. Maker spaces are the loss leader for the services provided. They survive on donations and class costs. Really sad to see, but not unbelievably so.
- bkraz 7y agoThe early issues of Make Magazine were filled with articles about repairing devices, building needed things instead of buying them, cobbling stuff together from scrap. It had a very distinct anti-consumerist vibe, which made it appealing to a lot folks including myself. The Faires were filled with like-minded folks who were there only to enjoy the process of building stuff. What do you sell this group of customers? In my mind, inspiration and a venue to share their projects with each other. Over time, though the maker movement became more focused on commerce, including tools that people needed to buy to become makers, and also startups founded by makers with the goal of selling stuff to the public. I'm surprised that I'm being critical on this point, since I really like business, and was a small business owner myself for years. What I'm trying to say is that Make lost sight of their original target customer profile (maybe due to pressure from investors), which is not an uncommon mistake. Smaller venues will crop up to support folks who like building things, which is a relatively niche group, and there may not be enough of us to support a the size business that the investors desired.
- ineedasername 7y agoThis. It was at that inflection point that I cancelled my Make subscription. It just didn't have the vibe any more. I also remember them developing their own fairly expensive custom ARM development board during the time the arduidnos were rapidly proliferating, and thinking, "why do they think people will buy this?" So maybe there were some sub par investments on that front as well?
- mankyd 7y agoNot indicated in the current headline is that it appears that Make Magazine is halting as well. From the first paragraph: > [...] Maker Media, the company behind crafting publication MAKE: magazine as well as [...] Maker Faire, [has laid] off its entire staff of 22 and pause all operations.
- trentnix 7y agoBreaks my heart. I've been a subscriber since the beginning and I've got issue 1 sitting on the shelf just to my left. I've got a list of things I want to make as a result of reading Make Magazine that would last me 5 lifetimes. If this is, indeed, the end, huge thanks to the entire crew at Maker Media (and the hundreds that contributed to Make Magazine over the years). You did what you did as well as it can be done.
- timthorn 7y agoTake a look at Hackspace magazine if you're feeling the loss. https://hackspace.raspberrypi.org https://hackspace.raspberrypi.org
- blhack 7y agoWhoa! That seems like a MUCH larger story!
- Digory 7y agoI'd guess the print part was the downfall. The Faires were licensed and should have been cash cows (I see local one is still selling tickets).
- ssorc 7y agoThe magazine website is still accepting new subscriptions: https://readerservices.makezine.com/mk/default.aspx?pc=MK&pk=M8JMKT https://readerservices.makezine.com/mk/default.aspx?pc=MK&pk...
- rrauenza 7y agoI wonder if they'll be able to fulfill the N-magazine subscription I paid for when I bought my ticket this year?
- stuart78 7y agoI took my kid to the most recent one in the Bay Area, which was fun. And crowded. And a bit expensive. Too bad it wasn’t working out, but glad we got a chance to go once.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- PopeDotNinja 7y agoBummer. I hate seeing cool & quirky things go down the drain. On a recent visit to SoCal, I saw a billboard for the Renaissance Pleasure Faire. I haven't been in years, I'm no longer a local, but I was happy to see it still going more than 30 years after I first heard of it. Hopefully it's still as much fun for people experiencing it now as it was for me back in highschool!
- propter_hoc 7y agoDoes anyone here have context on the pitch that got them $10 million in venture funding? Hard for me to envision how that could have worked, but their VCs must have had a pretty articulated investment thesis.
- reilly3000 7y agoI got into Maker Faire and making things, then I ran out of time. I had to learn Kubernetes. My kids were interested then they weren’t. My son is very technical and expressed interest in robotics, but he keeps coming back to game development and blender, and that is fantastic. I have a half dozen micro boards gathering dust for projects I was going to Make. I guess I haven’t seen value enough in my daily life from my little creations, and fundamentally making something novel is remarkably difficult. I’d really like to wire that gear up with MaxMSP or processing and make some beautiful sonic spaces, but for now it stays on the shelf. Is this just me or did something fundamental of that kind of experience undermine the maker movement in general?
- taurath 7y agoI’ll be honest - if I had nothing but time and a paid off house, I’d be sorely tempted to just tinker for a while. The bay is no place to do that though - it’s too expensive.
- shortoncash 7y agoSo true. The rent forces you to be on the hamster wheel.
- taurath 7y agoIt USED to be the place to experiment. Now it’s the place to try to make money before the landlords get you.
- worldsayshi 7y agoThis is likely severely limiting the innovation output of that area. You need breathing space to do groundbreaking stuff.
- madengr 7y agoI live in flyover country, with a paid off house, and good income. If you don’t have a mortgage, then it will be medical insurance (which costs just a much). If not that, the college savings, which is also equivalent.
- redbonsai 7y agoWorked there for a couple of years and really loved it. The people were wonderful, and the Faires were an incredible experience. It will be missed.
- mathattack 7y agoThe first Maker Faire I brought the kids to was awesome. Over time they got more expensive, crowded and less fun. The kids complained so much at the last one I decided to stop taking them.
- rpmcmurphy 7y agoThis seems like a predictable outcome in a consumerist society driven by planned obsolescence and the need for infinite growth.
- equalunique 7y agoThe reality is that this isn't the kind of venture that brings in money, and that's not as much an indictment against Maker Media so much as it is against the adverse conditions of which any venture is up against. I.e., we live in a (flawed) society. At least the ethos behind the Maker movement lives on.
- kyeb 7y agoI was gifted a subscription to their publication for years as a kid, but never got as into it as I wanted to. I loved reading about what others had made but felt like I never had the experience or expertise or money to make things myself. In hindsight, I probably could have done lots of cool thints. When the subscription expired I didn't renew. This makes me so sad to see now - I feel like there's a world where I would have been extremely into this culture, and I feel like not having this publication around will prevent others from becoming that.
- beenBoutIT 7y agoMake and the reprints will forever be one of those things that's inspiring to read. In reality, outside of Chinese factories there aren't communities of mechanically inclined tech savvy people interested in spending their time putting together other people's EE projects. Anyone capable of completing a Make project is unlikely to want to follow along and retrace someone else's project unless there's a real incentive to do so, such as saving money or building something that's impossible to buy.
- CalChris 7y agoThings don't last forever but it was impressive that Maker Faire got started in 2006 and survived the Great Recession which hit the Bay Area particularly hard. I went to the Maker Faire twice, the first time being especially magical. But I never went to any of the sub Faires. I think like Tech Shop, expansion was never going to be sustainable. Again, things don't last forever but I'm grateful for what it was, when it was.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shanev 7y agoRadio Shack should buy Maker Faire.
- dymk 7y agoOnly if both get acquired by a Yahoo/Barnes and Noble merger
- m0llusk 7y agoWalk softly on the Earth.
- blhack 7y agoI’ve had a minor bone with make media over their ownership of the term “makerfaire”. To me, a makerfaire is a generic term that has absolutely nothing to do with the magazine. Our local hackerspace tried to organize a makerfaire, and when we found out how much we had to pay to make media to use that name (I don’t remember the specifics, but it was enough to make us all reel back a bit) we ended up just changing the name to maker “fest” instead. It’s very sad that the magazine is also dying :(, but I have always been a bit salty of make media’s attempt to own the term “maker”. Perhaps this saltiness was more common in the community. It honestly soured me against any of their products. I still think that what they did was amazing, but there was just always that little sourness in the back of my mind when I’d recommend their publication to anybody. I think there is a lesson in there about branding. To my mind, allowing thousands of volunteers all over the world to throw “maker faires” is like a dream come true for a magazine like that. It’s a huge amount of advertising and brand association for them. If it was me, I would have put together an open set of graphics and styles for people to use at all of the maker faires, to make sure that every single one of those events was associated with my magazine.
- octorian 7y ago> I have always been a bit salty of make media’s attempt to own the term “maker” The concept of "people who build stuff as a hobby" is not really new at all. The coining of the term "maker" is, and honestly feels a little awkward to me. However, its possible they were part of the coining of that term, so its probably okay that they tried to capitalize on it. Maybe if we had a more general/less-branded term to use, it wouldn't feel so forced.
- TylerE 7y agoIt seems not only forced but a bit back-handed. Like a certain connotation of a lack of...rigor. Like "coder" vs programmer/software developer.
- NikolaeVarius 7y agoI mean, as an engineer by BS, makers have a "i'm not a engineer" vibe with it.
- mrlambchop 7y agoA totally naive point of view, but it would be awesome if some players in the maker space that are profitable (Adafruit, R-Pi, Arduino etc..) could band together and form a non-profit to keep this effort going. The maker community is generally so very non-corporate that I'd hope a partisan organization would be easy to form and run with out individual agendas or products getting involved in any overwhelming way.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoMaker Faire did so much good. No matter what happens, I know thousands of people saw a Maker in themselves because of MAKE and Maker Faire. I know it inspired me.
- asmithmd1 7y agoI was a Make magazine subscriber since the second year and gave several gift subscriptions. I contributed a couple of small (unpaid) pieces to the magazine, and was an exhibitor (also unpaid) multiple times at the NYC Maker Faire. I thoroughly enjoyed the Maker Faire set-up days and thought they made exhibiting worthwhile. It was like having a back-stage pass to the Oscars of Makerdom - all the stars were there and happy to talk shop. I knew I was creating free content for them that they were profiting from but thought I was getting a fair deal. My subscription lapsed just about every year for some glitch or another and they were unable to convert any of the gift subscriptions which should have been very easy sales. My opinion about supporting Make Media changed after the RealSexyCyborg incident in the winter of 2017: https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kassycho/a-male-ceo-has-apologized-after-saying-that-this-female https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/kassycho/a-male-ceo-has... Bunnie Haung (who I met at a Maker Faire set-up day) vouched for her and Dale still persisted in slandering her. I let my subscription lapse and quit going to the NYC Maker Faire. 2017 was the Maker Faire highest attendance and has been declining since then.
- stareatgoats 7y ago> Dale still persisted in slandering her FWIW, Dale finally apologized: https://twitter.com/dalepd/status/927712935987707904 https://twitter.com/dalepd/status/927712935987707904
- barry-cotter 7y agoFuck him, fuck Vice Media and fuck Sarah Jeong. Never forgive, never forget.
- skrebbel 7y ago> Never forgive, never forget. Most of the pain in the world is caused by this attitude.
- barry-cotter 7y agoTell RealSexyCyborg that as she watches people who conspired to destroy her livelihood enjoy their comfortable lives.
- briandear 7y agoTheir faire in San Mateo was crazy expensive. Kids tickets (for even 4 year olds,) were $30 and adult tickets were $50. Parking was ridiculous at $35 per day, despite this being San Mateo and the events center having plenty of parking. Parking for the Oakland A’s and Warriors is cheaper than that. The proximity to the Caltrain was advertised as a “10-15 minute walk” despite the distance being almost a mile. With several small kids and it being rainy that weekend, the thought of walking a mile in the rain wasn’t very attractive only to pay $220 for two adults and four kids under age 7. Helpfully there were bicycle instructions from San Francisco in case someone thought that might be a good idea. For being billed as a “family friendly event,” It was anything but, just on the logistics front alone. It’s like the organizers are detached from reality and live in some kind of dream world where $245 is a fair price for a family of 4 with parking. That’s about double what I pay to go to Major League Baseball games with the family. I get it, they don’t like cars, because climate and all that. But some of us live in reality. To get to the Caltrain from my house in Mountain View, it’s a two mile walk. So with kids we’d have to load the car to drive to the station, so we might as well just drive to San Mateo. My point is simple: tickets and parking were insanely priced and it’s no wonder that the overall business failed because clearly the management had some trouble reconciling reality with their perception of their own value.
- URSpider94 7y agoFWIW, you could always park for free at one of their satellite lots and take a bus right to the front gate. We did that for years and it worked fine. I don’t think they run the parking concession on-site, and they charge $35 for those spots because the lot fills up fast at that price. If they charged less, the lot would just fill up sooner.
- flomo 7y agoYes, the location was really not ideal in terms of access, but tbh I don't know where else in the bay area you could hold that kind of event. I think the bigger issue was that every year it felt like 98% of the same exhibits in the same places. So it was the kind of thing you did once. Twice was a mistake. In 2016(?) I volunteered at a friend's booth, and didn't even really want to walk around because I'd already seen it all. And ppl gobbed the booth because it something different.
- nemild 7y agoI thought this was remarkably self-reflective: > "It works for people but it doesn’t necessarily work as a business today, at least under my oversight"
- dopeboy 7y agoI went to the one in San Mateo a couple weeks ago. It is the only time in life I have seen hobbyists, tinkerers, professional engineers, entrepreneurs, hippies, cosplay fans, university students, and kids under one roof.
- projektir 7y agoI have somehow never heard of this and now I feel as if I've missed out.
- jypepin 7y ago+1. Never heard of this. Would have probably been a customer. I bought a few raspPi to tinker with stuff but have no idea how those things work and always end up not doing much and getting stuck. Something like MAKE would have helped a lot!
- kosei 7y ago> "Dougherty said that despite rain, Maker Faire’s big Bay Area event last week met its ticket sales target." Why would you set a target so low that meeting it still results in bankruptcy?
- crystaln 7y agoThis seems like the sort of social good organization that should be revived as a non-profit with government support. This is such an important organization for the future of education and economic innovation.
- avian 7y agoI've never been to any of the events in US, but I really liked going to Mini Makerfaires in Europe. I understand these were all licensed under the Makerfaire brand. I hope they will continue in the future, even if under a different name.
- blablabla123 7y agoMaker Faire was a really cool event, I also exhibited there once. The barrier to show something used to be actually quite low and it was easy to get in touch with people dealing with similar topics. On the other hand I never understood why that had so much focus on kids stuff. Of course it's easy to get attention from kids as long as things move, blink etc. But this stuff isn't really sophisticated, neither are the associated workshops - of which there are plenty. If you think about it, it makes no sense because kids don't have money and complex projects require actually a lot of planning and deep understanding of the topics involved. I think they should have focussed on more advanced projects. In fact a lot of projects both at Maker Faire but also in the Maker scene in general are quite unfinished. This can be nice when it comes to art but technical projects are most interesting when they reach MVP / release status.
- camtarn 7y agoPart of it might be the reason I've never particularly gotten into Maker culture. It's very easy to make a little beginner project which is fun but doesn't do anything particularly useful. However, more advanced projects either require a) an unfilled need, or b) an artistic imagination. And even if you have a or b, you may still be looking at more money than you're willing to spend. I much prefer the repair-and-reuse end of maker culture.
- camillomiller 7y agoThis is an issue I always found was diluting the Makers' movement: everything was mostly focused on beginners.
- Iv 7y agoTechcrunch's privacy policy is just an insulting joke. It proposes to opt out of their tracking through their hundred of partners, by clicking through each, one at the time. I wanted to share that article, I think I just wont...
- LeonM 7y agoIt's the latest and greatest in dark UI. The same goes for the fake progress spinners that take ~30 seconds to 'store' your privacy settings if you want to opt out, and for some reason don't take time at all if you just accept. 'services' like oath and trustarc (TRUSTe) should be illegal.
- Maarten88 7y agoIn EU, they are. I'm still hopeful that authorities will start fining websites that use this. Someday...
- hedora 7y agoThere was an article on HN a while back about regulatory capture in Ireland. Apparently GPDR complaints flow through them, and they ignore (almost) all the GDPR complaints. In turn, that protects the tax haven scheme they’ve established for data centers. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19741976 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19741976
- skrebbel 7y agoI love that you think that Oath is a privacy settings service and not an enormous media company. These dark patterns are hurting their brand.
- LeonM 7y agoYou're right. So many times I had a bad privacy consent experience while seeing their logo under it. Now I automatically associate Oath with that bad experience. I guess that's why I assumed Oath to be some privacy settings service similar to Trustarc.
- anonymous5133 7y agoEducation products is always a tough market due to people viewing education as basically discretionary instead of an investment.
- deng 7y agoIn Germany we have a German edition of Make:, which is done by Heise Verlag (of c't fame), and they seem to be doing fine (and there is no VC involved). It seems they have licensed the trademark (it was called "c't hardware hacks" before) but operations are done through the Maker Media GmbH. They also organize Maker Faires all over Germany, so I guess it is possible to do this and make a profit, at least in Germany. https://www.heise.de/make/ https://www.heise.de/make/
- fyfy18 7y agoIt sounds like the wrong type of business for receiving VC investment. Expos/conferences can make good money, but I expect it's a few magnitudes less than what an investor would want as a return. I wonder what the pitch deck looked like when they raised the investment.
- airbreather 7y agoCouple of points. When I was a lad, making electronics meant you could listen to shortwave radio or talk to people around the world, when there was little other opportunity. Plus, things like cars were still hackable with a few transistors and passive components, you could make a customised indicator timer, or turbo timer or what ever, and it was probably way cheaper if you knew what you were doing. Fast forward, very little you can now make is cheaper, or creates a functionality not otherwise available retail/off the shelf. Now for me, it was great - my dad was a radio amateur, I grew up with the those things, he lectured at uni and I had access to PDP-8 and 11 when no one had a computer at home and most people interacted with punch cards. I spent literally years of my younger life tinkering and discovered/learned by direct exploration and experimentation all sorts of things eg the rectification of copper oxide, Q factor and how to get it and use it, all the things you can use as earthing and antennas in radio systems (some pretty strange things in there), I wrote and sold Atari 400 games when I was 13 on, learning things like how to write a floating point library in a 6502 in minimal space, create physics engines for games, just to name a few, the list goes on. Now I have worked as an electrical engineer designing and building large and small industrial power and control systems for over 30 years. Most days I draw down on some former hobby or tinkering experience in some way in my work. Not sure the maker movement we have seen recently will create the same trajectory for too may others, maybe I am wrong, but a lot of what I did was because there were no equivalent consumer goods and the best info available was at the local library or maybe the odd magazine if you were lucky.
- m463 7y ago> Fast forward, very little you can now make is cheaper, or creates a functionality not otherwise available retail/off the shelf. I think this is a matter of perspective. The components you string together are now scaled up, as are the experiences of younger folks. I think of some friends who were saying "people just can't become a private pilot nowadays", but later I wondered if maybe there are new opportunities they don't recognize (like powered paragliding).
- JVIDEL 7y agoNot the same generation (waaay later) but I too had a PC at home back in the DOS days when computers were not that common. I learned to use the command line before I learned to read and write in my native language. Anyway, I went through a similar thinkering scene but it was in software, the FOSS scene of the late nineties up to early this decade was very active and there were tons of tools and programs that surpassed retail software of the time. As for electronics right now, there's some crazy things in the FOSH scene and if I had the money I would get more into that, but when it comes to retail electronic and IoT stuff I'm skeptic: too many corners cut, too many security holes, too much data going into opaque servers, etc. And that's just security and privacy, don't get me started on planed obsolescence and repairability. And there's still a lot of stuff you can make that have no retail equivalent, from console clones with FPGAs for perfect emulation to car automation with comma.ai
- airbreather 7y agoWith a bit of further reflection, I have a 15 year old that lives for computers esp games, taught himself multiple computer languages from Youtube and Khan etc. He actually writes OK code and thinks about it the right way. He won bits and pieces like Minecraft Mod of the Month, the school EMITS (STEM) prize, at a school that specialises in it etc etc I thought he was going to program games, but he has decided he wants to be an electrical engineer (which I am) still not sure of the exact motivation, I have a pretty good life with lots of interesting work, maybe he hopes for that. But, if he wasn't so highly motivated towards computers, I think I would tell him to spend the equivalent time he would spend getting a 4 year or 6 year EE degree and learn to make fine hand crafted shoes. Send him to Florence. Some big money in custom shoes if you build a name and quite rewarding if you like that sort of thing. An Arduino isn't going to keep my feet warm, dry and stylish, for $800 (or even $5000 in extreme cases) a pair. And that need isn't going away because Arduinos exist.
- codingdave 7y agoFunny you should mention shoes - my wife was demoing making socks at our local mini Maker Faire last year. There is a small, but devoted community of people who use their machine shops to build modern versions of the antique hand-cranked knitting machines used to makes socks. She has a room full of them, and it is a great blend of modern tech, antique machines, and hand crafted goods that was perfect for a Maker Faire. We're interested to see what fallout this has on such local gatherings, whether they will continue or not.
- kilpikaarna 7y ago> There is a small, but devoted community of people who use their machine shops to build modern versions of the antique hand-cranked knitting machines used to makes socks. Whoa, what? Okay, super interested in this. Especially after seeing so many local schools and universities auction off or scrap what probably amounts to tons of old-iron textile processing machinery. Please let me know if you have any relevant links! Would appreciate muchly.
- 7y ago
- upbeatlinux 7y agoThere's been some of talk of trying to own the "maker" space rather than fostering "maker" spaces. I suppose that's part of the problem. I subscribed to Make for a few years in the late aughts but let my subscription lapse because I stopped having time to tinker. It was a great medium to learn until it wasn't. I suppose many events coalesced over the years leading to its shuttering - proliferation of YouTube DIY - shuttering of print media and electronics stores - cost decrease of prefab devices - cost decrease in means of production - bundled kits - "democratization" of means of production (3d printing, etc) - Make attitude shift from "hacking" to selling you shit / custom brands This sucks for the maker community and Make folks but is a serious win for anyone still soldering on or trying to foster the hacker / maker mentality.
- ineedasername 7y agoI kind of wish they'd tried to restructure and reboot with some sort of crowd-funded initiative. Though perhaps they considered and discarded the idea for good reason.
- xtat 7y agoNothing of creative or artistic value will survive in the Bay Area - I'm done trying to fix this wasteland.
- soapdog 7y agoomg, I went to the Maker Faire in the Bay Area for the first time this year. It has always been a dream of me to go but I was never in the US at the right time. I remember thinking that I wanted to go again, I was not expecting it to be the last one.
- souterrain 7y agoThey’ve been paid their owed wages and PTO, but did not receive any severance or two-week notice. Are there any VC out there that have ethics standards around winding down a failed venture, especially towards termination of employees?
- p_l 7y agoYes, those standards are usually about not paying anything including owed wages or PTO (why do you think "unlimited PTO" exists? It means you don't have to pay it back or accumulate it over time, making it easier to reject any PTO request)
- foobiekr 7y agoThat’s on the founders and management, not the VC. You can choose to plan ahead and make sure you treat employees and customers fairly based on tracking your expenditures and reserves or you can run into the wall at full speed. We did this. It wasn’t that hard but it required a lot of honesty. Having been through it I’m always shocked when startups fail with no warning.
- dekhn 7y agoI went to the maker faire for the first time some 6 years ago when my wife asked me to, it wasn't something I really thought I'd find interesting. When I got there I Realized I was dropped into a community of like minded hackers and builders and art makers. It lead to a real epiphany and I ended up joining a team at Google that ran their Maker Faire presence. Over the subsequent years I built and demo'd some really cool things including a scanning microscope made from a shapeoko, a fully interactive Google Doodle, a demonstration of the North American solar eclipse. I learned a ton of electronics and how to 3d print and laser cut. I went back this year and while Google had a booth, it was scaled down a lot, but still filled with cool projects done by googlers in their spare time. I was always unimpressed with Intel's high budget spectacle (run by an external marketing firm) and I have to conclude that the indie portions of the maker faire, which aren't particularly cost-effective, are ultimately the most interesting parts. I saw a guy who built a self-solving rubik's cube- servos inside (https://hackaday.com/2018/09/24/self-solving-rubiks-cube/ https://hackaday.com/2018/09/24/self-solving-rubiks-cube/) and met with people who grind their own telescope lenses, etc, etc, and have tons of admiration for their passion and abilities. With all that said, Make was never particularly well-run and we kind of saw this coming over the years.
- pixelrevision 7y agoThe art minded part of it is what is really important to me. Hopefully someone can figure out some way to make that profitable (or at least sustainable) in the future. There is no shortage of tech conferences but I do not see a lot of gatherings where people share and talk about their exploratory projects that are done just because they feel like they would be interesting.
- Kagerjay 7y agoThat's sad to hear. I went to my first makerfaire last year, and I got to experience some of the most amazing things ever - Making my own T-shirt through a heat press - Watching battlebots fight live in person. I got to see how battlebots were maintenanced and designed. And take a look firsthand on how the Kraken (one of the battlebots) was built from prototype to what it is today (it uses a air compressor which is kind of weird) - Seeing all sorts of cool cosplay - really interesting side projects - micro-3d photography and photo stiching of insects, 3D gif makers from 30 cameras in a single room using python, arcattack music from tesla coils, zoetropes, etc - K-12 local community projects - kids were teaching adults how to solder, make DIY type of stuff, etc. There's lots more to be said but makerfaire is one of a kind
- jjoonathan 7y ago> it uses a air compressor which is kind of weird If you want lots of mechanical power in short bursts, compressed air is a winner, because compressing air is a very good way to store lots of energy that you can release quickly, and it can be coupled into mechanical action without bulky coils. Industrial tooling (you've heard air tools in your local auto shop, probably) and heavy robotics love the stuff. The big downside is noise, which explains why you might not encounter compressed air in your day-to-day life, even though it is every bit as fundamental as, say, high voltage power transmission.
- Kagerjay 7y agoAir compressor was weird to me because most battle bots AFAIK use a hydraulic systems, Kraken is one of the few to use compressed air. Actually, to be precise they use SCUBA tanks used in ocean diving. Also they got a cool logo and have their own font-face
- donatj 7y agoDamn that makes me so sad. I LOVED Make in my late teens and early 20s. I always intended to subscribe when I could, but life happened and I don’t make things nearly as much...
- mcshicks 7y agoI was surprised to find out that they were backed by venture capital. When he says that "I’m committed to keeping the print magazine going and the Maker Faire licensing program.” I'm assuming that is for the various other maker and mini maker faires that are organized outside Maker media? I think it would be great if they could reorganize as a non profit and continue with a scaled back operation. I also wonder if by doing the interview with the media they are not trying to strengthen their negotiating position with their creditors. I've attended a couple of the Bay Area maker faires, and several ones in San Diego and while there definitely has been a dropoff is attendance and exhibitors (both quantity and to some extent quality) I still think it's a good event and has a lot to offer. I think it would be good if they also had some exhibits focused also on repair and reuse. The last San Diego County Fair I went to I think the neatest thing I saw was some guy from a local phone repair shop fixing phones.
- danans 7y agoMaybe we should go back to shop class in public schools. For me at least, this was my earliest exposure to making things, at it set off a lifetime continuing curiosity.
- p_b_r 7y agoPrint is dead. Worst industry on the planet to focus on. Had maker picked one thing and done it right, it could still be here. It tried to be too many things at the same time.
- sixothree 7y agoPrint may be dead but I read every Make magazine and am always happy to find it in the mailbox. edit: Not meant to add anecdotal data but instead to validate target audience of article.
- sircastor 7y agoI think print has a place, even magazines. Make doesn't age quite the same as other magazine issues, and I've found it quite enjoyable to flip through.
- pontifier 7y agoI "run" a makerspace... I put that in quotes because its barely running, and I've basically quit. Wealth innequality is extreme. The people who can afford it buy their own 3D printer or laser, do. The people who can't afford them, can't afford to pay dues. Everybody wants to donate their broken junk to the space, but nobody wants to give us cash to pay the rent.
- applecrazy 7y agoI believe the easiest way to alleviate this issue is to pool together capital to buy machines that can’t be purchased by individuals. This encourages more affluent makers to join and pay dues.
- corysama 7y agoThat was the business plan of TechShop. It didn't work out in the long run. In SF, the TechShop space is sort of reborn as https://theshop.build/ https://theshop.build/ Also, https://www.noisebridge.net/ https://www.noisebridge.net/ is still cranking along.
- kqr2 7y agoWhat makes noisebridge more successful? It seems like they have a smaller space and less machines than Techshop RIP but host a lot more meetups.
- corysama 7y agoThat would be my guess. Never actually been there, but I get the impression they keep costs very low. More of an old-skool club space than a modernized work space.
- detaro 7y agoMy impression is it's more a community like most hackerspaces, less "tools as a service" most commercial makerspaces are seen as, so people are more willing to volunteer time or resources.
- mattnewton 7y agoI could not understand this news the first time I heard whispers of it. I’d been to makers faire many times and they showed every sign of slow growth and tons of enthusiasm. It took me this paragraph to understand what happened: > “It started as a venture-backed company but we realized it wasn’t a venture-backed opportunity” Dougherty admits, as his company had raised $10 million from Obvious Ventures, Raine Ventures, and Floodgate. > “The company wasn’t that interesting to its investors anymore. It was failing as a business but not as a mission. Should it be a non-profit or something like that? Some of our best successes for instance are in education.”
- RIMR 7y agoShouldn't they have updated their websites by now? You can still buy a new subscription to the magazine...
- AstroJetson 7y agoI've been a "maker" since I was a kid. Same Ham radio, dad tinkered with stuff, best friends family ran a lawn mower repair business that others have chronicled. Now most of the things I make are electronics with mostly a CPU, and some way to talk to the remote device but 90% is code. Woodworking is via either my own tools, or a friend's shop. I'm on the board of a Maker group and our two big things is rental (pontifier's comment) and our insurance. It's sad to see people pay $400 for an Apple Watch and then whine about a $10 a month shop fee. Interesting thing is Public Libraries are becoming Maker Spaces (not a TM) with printers, laser cutters, sewing machines, etc. Our county built a new library with an "innovation center" in it with all this stuff. A local museum runs a "Fair for Makers" (again not a TM) that this year had 22 exhibitors in their main building and about 40 outside. Also had craft brew and food trucks, all for $5 a person. No fee to present so it was a nice day for everyone. Sorry to see them go out of business, I think they started something very cool.
- dogline 7y agoI've been a subscriber since the first issue, and still have every copy of the magazine they mailed, although most were just kept and unread. Is there any market for a full set of magazines?
- codesushi42 7y agoThis is terrible news. The first MakerFaire I attended was in 2013 in San Mateo. Going gave me a ton of inspiration to get into electronics and 3d printing, and that's what I have been doing in my spare time since then. There was nothing like it, the Faire was like a Disneyland for nerds. Admittedly the past few Maker Faires had become a bit lackluster as the focus of the faire shifted from attracting adults in the industry to children instead. Still a shame.
- stefek99 7y agoMake cool shit (great) profitable again.