15 ms·
Sign In with Apple [video]
- olliej 7y agoJust so people can watch the detailed developer introduction. Specifically: It verifies the "realness" of the account, so everyone claiming that they need user's real email address for "fraud detection" can't argue that nonsense anymore. We all know that argument was just a cover for "we want to be able to spam our users with impunity", but this specifically addresses that argument just to be sure.
- Reedx 7y ago> ...can't argue that nonsense anymore. We all know that argument was just a cover for "we want to be able to spam our users with impunity" Run a site that allows/displays user submitted content and you'll likely change your mind about that being a cover or bogus argument.
- adamc 7y agoThen say that: "we want your email in case there are issues with your content".
- olliej 7y agoBut that doesn’t explain why they need your actual email. The only reason they want a user’s real address is because they want an address the user cant stop them from spamming. There is literally no other reason.
- omarchowdhury 7y ago> The only reason they want a user’s real address is because they want an address the user cant stop them from spamming. Unsubscribe and report to spam doesn't exist in our world, anymore?
- stephenr 7y agoUnsubscribe relies on the sender honouring your choice. Deleting the anonymous redirect address they’ve been given requires no such cooperation.
- ballenf 7y agoBut requiring an email hardly solves that problem. And very few apps (at least of what I use) that have 3rd party auth have features where user content is displayed to others.
- endlessvoid94 7y agoIt does significantly reduce the problem.
- olliej 7y agoHow? Is it because you have "proof" that it's a real user? If you watch the presentation or read the transcript, you'll hear that they already do a bunch of fraud prevention. I'm going to go out on a limb and say Apple is doing much more anti-fraud/fake account work that most others are able to.
- vlozko 7y agoI’d imagine there’s a lot of criteria being used. Maybe something like the age of the account, how often it’s used, of it was created from an often used IP address. Whatever it is, it’s probably not in Apple’s interest to disclose it.
- olliej 7y agoSorry what exactly does having a cloaking address do that makes this a problem? You get an email address you can contact them through.
- paulmd 7y agoYou can still ban the underlying iOS account, you just don't get an email address to spam/sell.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- buboard 7y agoJust because an account is real doesn't mean it isn't spam. Most of the forum registration spam is done by real people. Also, I think most users anyway use a secondary or "throwaway" mail account to sign up to various websites that are not critical to them. This problem is largely already solved.
- olliej 7y agoBut what does getting a real email address do in that case? If you watch the presentation or read the transcript, they explicitly say that they're doing fraud/spam account prevention. Do you really think you're doing more fraud/spam detection and prevention work than apple?
- buboard 7y agoThe email is not the relevant part. Apple sign in requires the purchase of an apple device so it's almost guaranteed to not be a bot. However apple cant know (and shouldn't know btw) if the iphone user uses it to sign up and spam various websites.
- olliej 7y agoApple already has a lot of anti-spam/fraud accounts because they need to prevent iMessage spam (is your forum going to be subject to the same spam account pressure of a system like iMessage or iCloud?) But also any argument that the makes spam harder to block also applies to Facebook or google logins - I can’t imagine spammers are using real email addresses with those services. The only people this changes the experience for are actual users. Spammers already have a huge array of options to get “real email addresses”.
- simonw 7y agoHas anyone seen a live online demo of "Sign in with Apple" anywhere on the internet? I've seen a few tutorials - https://developer.okta.com/blog/2019/06/04/what-the-heck-is-sign-in-with-apple https://developer.okta.com/blog/2019/06/04/what-the-heck-is-... is particularly good - but no one seems to have deployed a button I can click anywhere yet.
- sirn 7y agoIf you’re using iOS 13, https://appleid.apple.com/ https://appleid.apple.com/ now use Sign in with Apple, although obviously there’s no granting flow (where you can choose whether to give them the real email).
- WalterSobchak 7y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20086045 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20086045
- olliej 7y agoThe previous discussion was the announcement not the developer presentation that actually goes over the full details. That conversation has a lot of people arguing about things that this video addresses.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThere's confirmation in the PDF that there's a JavaScript SDK, which is nice. Native widget in Safari, but it looks like a fairly standard OAuth flow in others.
- dubcanada 7y agoJavaScript example https://developer.apple.com/documentation/signinwithapplejs/configuring_your_webpage_for_sign_in_with_apple https://developer.apple.com/documentation/signinwithapplejs/...
- the_gipsy 7y agoCan you do oauth? I'm not gonna add a random script hosted by apple to my page.
- simonw 7y agoYes you can - here's some example code that uses an OAuth redirect rather than Apple's JavaScript: https://github.com/aaronpk/sign-in-with-apple-example https://github.com/aaronpk/sign-in-with-apple-example
- busymom0 7y agoThis is amazing. Am I right to conclude that this lets us use it in apps older than iOS 13 as well as it’s based off of oauth redirect?
- monkin 7y agoYou can, and you can also read source of that file to know what that "random script" does.
- the_gipsy 7y agoThat's good then. My point was more "random sdk/library", rather than script, sorry.
- jeena 7y agoAaron Parecki, the author of the "OAuth 2.0 Simplified" book, wrote a blog post on the misunderstandings around Sign in with Apple: https://aaronparecki.com/2019/06/04/23/sign-in-with-apple-misunderstandings https://aaronparecki.com/2019/06/04/23/sign-in-with-apple-mi...
- 3JPLW 7y agoThat article seems worthy of discussion on its own. I submitted it (expecting to find an existing discussion) but it turns out it hadn't been submitted yet. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20128029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20128029
- oakesm9 7y agoCAUTION: There's a redirect loop bug when you open this link in Safari. Seems to be an error in their JS. The only option is to close the tab. Works fine in Firefox and Chrome.
- atonse 7y agoI'm thrilled about implementing this on our app so we can make registration and login even more smooth without having to be in bed with Google and Facebook. Can't wait to implement it. I'm even more thrilled to see, that according to the Okta article linked in another thread by simonw [1], Apple uses OAuth and OpenID Connect for this, and not some home-grown protocol. Great news all-round. [1] https://developer.okta.com/blog/2019/06/04/what-the-heck-is-sign-in-with-apple https://developer.okta.com/blog/2019/06/04/what-the-heck-is-...
- techntoke 7y agoGitLab and many others have been doing this for years already. Apple could say that they are coming out with a new computer $3000 tomorrow based on 5 year old hardware that cost $500 in parts, and people would be posting articles on HN claiming that it changes the world because it has an Apple logo on it.
- fhood 7y agoHang on, let me count all the times I've seen an option to sign in to a third party service with my gitlab account.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- atonse 7y agoI'm not really sure what you're ranting about. Are you under the impression that I'm implying third party identity federation is something new? Because I'm not. I'm implying that, it's great that we have an additional identity provider who isn't a drug addict about user data like google and facebook are, that's run by a company who has shown a history of actually caring about user privacy. It gives those of us that are concerned about privacy, an option to use for identity federation. And I'm saying the opposite, that it's great that Apple's using an existing standard (which implies they didn't invent it) instead of doing something totally custom. It sounds like you had that post already written and ready based on this being an apple post.
- marpstar 7y agoMy team has been wondering: We allow third-party login via one OAuth provider (Esri) in addition to "local" accounts. Users who log in with Esri do so to access content in their Esri account, not as a matter of convenience. Apple's guidelines stipulate that it will be "required as an option for users in apps that support third-party sign-in". In contrast with social logins, you cannot create an account with our app via the Esri login, and your Esri account must be set up first in the back-end to even use it at all. We can't think of a way to feasibly support this per their requirements, unless Esri allows it via their OAuth flow as well (they do support Facebook/Google today).
- mpweiher 7y ago> Users who log in with Esri do so to access content in their Esri account, not as a matter of convenience. So this is not a third-party sign in. This is access to third party data which requires signing in with them.
- paxys 7y agoI really hope this is the first step to them adding scopes for accessing iCloud data (mail, calendar, notes, reminders, photos, others). Being able to write better apps for them on Android & web would be amazing.
- albertgoeswoof 7y agoThe killer feature here is the anonymous email address forwarding. It shows Apple actively ceding an opportunity for exchanging marketing data in favour of user privacy. It does feel like Apple are taking privacy seriously and positioning it as more than just a marketing campaign. I am tired of seeing my email address popping up on leaks and I don't want to rely on spam filters any more. The best spam filter out there is built into gmail, but they are no longer interested in actually preventing spam, instead they want to control it. Now Google shows me ads that look exactly like emails in my inbox, inside the iOS app. I wasn't happy with this so I built https://idbloc.co https://idbloc.co, which is basically equivalent to the disposable email element of Sign in with Apple, now that Apple built it into their Sign In, I guess now it exists for users who don't want to or can't use Apple.
- jsgo 7y agoI'm a big fan of the feature, was quite thrilled to see it, but aren't they the provider of the redirect? So there is privacy to anyone but Apple: they'll know (if they wish to) that you signed up on Some Site with a burner email in a way they might not have if you used a regular burner email service. Personally, I'm fine with Apple having that kind of info as I generally trust them and also that my main concern is the same with your frustration of my email ending up in yet another leak seemingly frequently.
- thaumaturgy 7y ago> Personally, I'm fine with Apple having that kind of info as I generally trust them ...up until Apple decides to change their leadership, or their business model, or the mobile market implodes and they start looking for new revenue streams, or their relationship with the US government changes, or ... I get that as a practical matter we are forced to trust somebody somewhere eventually, but at best we should be saying that "Apple doesn't seem motivated to abuse this information for now."
- olliej 7y agoWhich is why Apple protects your data in a way they can't access it - in the event that they change into Google and Facebook in future they have no access to the current information.
- edandersen 7y agoWill "Sign in with Apple" be available on non Apple devices? If not how will cross device syncing etc work?
- beering 7y agoIn the presentation they mentioned that it's available for JavaScript, and said that's the way to do Sign in with Apple on web and Android.
- closetohome 7y agoSeems like it would be less useful on a non-Apple device though. I don't know about you but my Apple login is a nightmarishly long password and 2FA. Authenticating through FaceID or TouchID is what makes it usable.
- TimothyBJacobs 7y agoWhat about using a password manager?
- closetohome 7y agoGood point. I have an irrational paranoia putting really vital stuff in those, but it would work.
- lukejduncan 7y agoThis type of issue is why I use LastPass, and not Apples Password manager. I'm very weary of how this would work on a non-mac device and I definitely use multiple non-mac devices regularly through a given day or week.
- habosa 7y agoIt seems like it could be really good for users, but the fact that it's _required_ for any apps that use other 3rd-party sign-in options and that it's _required_ to be listed first among those options leaves a bad taste in my mouth. I can't even imagine what would happen if Google did the same thing with Google Sign In and the Play store. Disclaimer: I work for Google, not on anything related, and am speaking for myself (as always).
- redbergy 7y agoI know what you're saying but I'm okay with it. In this case Apple chose users over developers. iOS developers have to do a little more work (Apple has made it very easy from what I've seen of the framework) and have a little less freedom but users signing in to apps using 3rd party auth are guaranteed the privacy protections Apple is promising. They drew a line in the sand by making their solution mandatory but I think they had to to deliver what they're promising to users (which I think is great).
- stefano 7y agoThat privacy seems a bit overboard though. This is fine if a user can create his account directly inside the app. But it's not very clear how to support a workflow where you have an organization with multiple users authorized by an admin to use the app. How can the admin add a user to his organization, if he doesn't know in advance the user randomly generated email? I guess you could send an invitation code, and let the user enter that code after the apple sign in, to associate the account to the authorized user. This sounds more complex for the user than a workflow where the admin can directly authorize specific emails.
- MBCook 7y agoDoes this apply to enterprise apps distributed outside the normal App Store? I bet it doesn’t. Also I think you’re given the choice of using your real email address instead if the anonymizes one. At least that was my understanding.
- buboard 7y agoPeople are very enthusiastic about this but this is actually not going to gain a lot of traction because - it's more difficult to implement than FB sign in and websites don't get any of the benefits - it works with apple devices, and it will be a nightmare to use in other devices, esp. if the user uses the private email - Apple would control and route the emails of the user and the app! This is a big privacy hole imho. - Apple drops users or apps without second thoughts from their ecosystem, and the web is not used to this (and is not going to change) - Maintaining new sign options is already a hassle, adding a new one that will only be accessible to a relatively small user base, with a number of hoops makes it seem less worth it. On the plus side though, you do know that users coming from apple sign in are probably richer and better monetizable.
- coder543 7y ago> but this is actually not going to gain a lot of traction You're forgetting the part where Apple is going to mandate that app developers must offer Sign In With Apple if the app offers any social logins like Facebook or Twitter, and that the Sign In With Apple option is strongly suggested to be the first one on the list. It absolutely will gain traction.
- buboard 7y agoit will never be more popular than fb because they don't have the user base. And this only applies for new signups, generally there is no option to switch from fb sign in -> apple sign in.
- jaydz 7y agoI think the more likely scenario will be apps removing social logins and implementing their own login logic.
- dev_tty01 7y agoHuh? Add a handful of lines of code in your iOS/Mac app to add another login button or implement a whole server based authentication scheme? Maintain and keep secure the server based authentication for the lifetime of your app? That is not at all likely given the relative cost in money and time between the two choices.
- drampelt 7y agoHow will the mandatory implementation of this affect apps that rely on a third party as the data storage system? For example https://moo.do https://moo.do stores everything in Google Drive, if they have to implement Sign in with Apple the app won't function
- olliej 7y agoMy interpretation is that the rule applies to using a third party service to create the identity you use for your own service, vs. actually logging into the service. e.g. * You have a forum that needs a per user identity, but you recognize that managing account login information securely is challenging, and the most cost effective solution is to offload on a separate authentication service (Google, Facebook, etc) vs * You're a 3rd party mail client for gmail, and you app is actually signing into the third party service itself. Of course I'm sure all of this will be clearly and unambiguously explained by release :-/
- stefano 7y agoHow does authorization (as opposed to authentication) work with apple sign in? With Google sign in you get an actual email that can be pre-authorized on the server. With this, the server only has a phony email to work with, so how can you match that phony email to authorized users?
- burlesona 7y agoIIRC users have the option to share their real email or not.
- larkost 7y agoIn this sort of login authorization is considered the severs responsibility, and in most cases that use it it amounts to: you get access to you stuff. This only handles authentication. If you need managed authorization, you are going to have to handle that yourself.
- scotchio 7y agoWhat I REALLY want is simpler 2 factor auth. Love iMessage autofill on text inputs from text message codes But... Authy (arguably more secure) is super annoying to open, click, copy, re-window over, click, and then finally paste. Would be cool if this somehow cleaned up the whole process.
- juniper411 7y agoYubikeys are great, but perhaps out of scope of this discussion.
- bubblethink 7y ago>Authy (arguably more secure) What's the argument ? >Would be cool if this somehow cleaned up the whole process. Everyone, just leave 2FA alone. No sms. No custom garbage that sends a push from a cloud and uses a blob on the device. Use TOTP. It's simple and easy. If you want fancier phishing protection, optionally add the newer fido2 or whatever the newer standards end up being. Just no custom garbage.
- olliej 7y agoFor regular users TOTP isn't simple: * you have to install an app, but you can't tell which app you're meant to use * you have to configure the app with whatever your signin service is * If you ever delete the app (something that is generally not harmful) you lose the ability to sign in, and reinstalling frequently does not bring back your old authorizations. But yeah, SMS 2fa is garbage from a security stand point (and will remain so until carriers can be held liable for costs from transferring your number without your authorization), but it is usable and is leaps and bounds better than nothing at all, which is what users will do if you make 2fa hard to set up.
- scotchio 7y agoLittle beyond me on why It’s considered more secure. Just what I read a while ago. I just want cleaner integration for the user. Don’t care about messing with it
- jetpks 7y ago
- stickydink 7y agoIs there any word on when this is going to be enforced as a requirement (assuming you already have FB/Google etc.)? Is it implied that as soon as iOS 13 goes out we'll start getting app updates rejected unless this is integrated?
- MBCook 7y agoI would expect soon after, so some people have time to update. Maybe day one. But it didn’t sound like it would be long.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- papa_bear 7y agoDoes anyone else dislike when websites offer a lot of 3rd party sign-in options? Maybe it's just me, but when there's more than one option, I often forget which one I used and it ends up being a process of checking all of them. The service I run only offers email and Facebook, and now I'll have to either remove Facebook, or add both Google and Apple (I can't just add Apple because it'll look annoying for our Android users if there's Apple and no Google). Also, when OAUTH uses the real email address, it makes it simple to switch between the different login options without much friction, which won't work anymore for people using Apple ID. Maybe I'll just have to make it a habit to use only Apple when available, and plain email otherwise.
- jeena 7y agoI had this problem two or three times and that - and the fact that some of those got removed after a couple of years like mozillas persona and OpenID - made me go back and always use email, which has the added value that I don't expose the usage of that website to a 3rd party.
- dstaley 7y ago> can't just add Apple because it'll look annoying for our Android users if there's Apple and no Google just like it looks annoying for your Android users that there's Facebook but no Google?
- PhilippGille 7y agoFacebook is not related to Android or iOS. But Google is related to Android and Apple is related to iOS.
- crazygringo 7y agoI don't like that it's required for developers to include if they include any other third-party sign-in. US competition laws are outdated with undue reliance on the concept of a monopoly. I don't care if you're a monopoly or a third of the market or even a small company. If you run a marketplace or app store or similar platform, you should NOT be able to: - Force usage of a separate product of yours over/with competitors (in this case, Apple sign-in, but also Apple Pay instead of Google Pay, etc.) - Prevent competing products from appearing (whether Apple not allowing other browser rendering engines, Amazon not allowing Google Home or Chromecast to be sold, etc.) - Rank your own items higher in search results etc. if competitors can't bid to do the same e.g. sponsored results for everyone including yourself (so Amazon Basics or Google Shopping needs to be listed as a sponsored result, not as a separate feature) This is the kind of thing 21st-century legislation for fair competition should address.
- marcell 7y agoCompletely agree. There needs to be some concept of a marketplace that doesn't have monopoly power, and a list of "fair play" rules around those. The only difference between Apple's actions and 90's Microsoft is marketshare. It's a similarly anti-competitive in intent.
- miohtama 7y agoEuropean Union has some regulation for financial markets that have had similar issues in the past. The regulators must approve a rule book for market place, in this case of trading venue, which including onboarding and listing rules. Those rules must not discriminate against anyone - one cannot do arbitrary decisions to block or hinder someone. Everybody must access the markets fairly. We already seen the regulatory outreach coming to app stores when EU ruled that Google was hindering the distribution of Aptoide store for Android.
- kalleboo 7y ago> There needs to be some concept of a marketplace that doesn't have monopoly power The Web? I've seen reports that Apple is finally starting to fix issued related to adding PWAs to the home screen as well.
- glitchc 7y agoWhat’s the incentive for vendors to participate? Why would they switch to a less-featured product from ones that exposes all manner of user analytics?
- mkmk 7y agoWill Apple be able to read all the emails that are sent to/via the forwarding address?
- rgovostes 7y agoYes, unless services are sending encrypted e-mails to their users via keys that are established out-of-band.
- aaronbrager 7y agoTechnically they could. According to the docs, they destroy the email after delivery.
- MR4D 7y agoWhen “@privaterelay.appleid.com” starts showing up in lists like haveibeenpwnd, you know you made the right choice. If for no other reason, this is a great reason to use it.
- aclelland 7y agoI'd love if someone could explain if the 'fake email' address that the developer gets from Apple will be the same across all apps from the same developer? Or is there some way for the developer to link a login on one app to the same user on another app from the same developer? I'm all in favour of increasing user privacy and the general direction that Apple is moving but we've got multiple Apps which allow users to log in via Game Centre, Facebook or Twitch to the same account. This allows them to access their friends, messages and support tickets from any of our Apps. We're able to do this because each of those providers gives us a unique identifier for each user (we only store that id and don't ever store the email address from them). I fear that Apple are going to make this impossible for us to do this going forward which would be a negative experience for our users.
- flixic 7y agoIn the presentation they talk about how the authorisation returns a stable, team-scoped (that means same developer) id.
- ljm 7y agoIdeal world: Apple implements this feature the way they did to test the water. With a successful result we have open source tech to mask email addresses.
- earth2mars 7y agoif its not open source, I can't trust even Apple.
- rahulrav 7y agoUnfortunately, Apple Sign In for the Web - insists on using HTTP POST's for the redirect_uri. This is a snippet from their official JavaScript library. const t = { baseURI: "https://appleid.apple.com" https://appleid.apple.com", path: "/auth/authorize", originURI: "", env: "prod", uxMode: "redirect", responseType: "code id_token", responseMode: "form_post", client: { clientId: "", scope: "", redirectURI: "", state: "" } }; Notice the responseMode which is set to form_post which I believe is the only supported mode. This means you can no longer do things like localhost redirect_uri's for testing, or even use Apple Sign In on an internal web-app. Also, goes against OAuth2. :( I submitted this feedback. Hopefully, someone takes a look.
- jchook 7y ago> This means you can no longer do things like localhost redirect_uri's for testing, or even use Apple Sign In on an internal web-app. Seems this might provide some security benefit, e.g. no credentials showing up in web server access logs. Either way, are you sure the final POST isn't made by the client? If so, the client would resolve the address. On their JS configuration page[1], I don't see any obvious evidence that Apple will make the post. They show this line: `AppleID.auth.signIn();` P.S. Aghghgh the mixed camelCase and under_score makes me cringe. [1] https://developer.apple.com/documentation/signinwithapplejs/configuring_your_webpage_for_sign_in_with_apple
- rahulrav 7y agoThey already don’t show up if you use fragment URIs. The real issue I have is that the OAuth2 spec covers all this and we don’t have to rehash this every time a new IDP creates an Auth system. No. The final post is not made by the client and a server has to handle the request. Webapps cannot handle POST requests from an Authorization server.
- alwillis 7y agoThis seems to be a case of “anyone but Apple” logic by naysayers. If Mozilla or name your blessed organization of choice came up with this system, most of them would be fine with it. But because it’s Apple, there’s all this consternation about it. Apple’s huge advantage: their revenue comes from devices and services, not advertising. It would be different if this was a one-off but they’ve been implementing privacy features for several years…
- buboard 7y ago> they’ve been implementing privacy features for several years… Yet this one is not a pro-privacy feature, it's an "apple owns your privacy" feature. Apple will control your account access and even be able to read your emails. Sure you trust them, but in the future they 'll use it to push their own ecosystem (like apple payments) to developers. We 've had single sign-ons for too many years to know that any ecosystem lock-in is a bad thing. As bad as email sounds, it's still the free-est , most decentralized login provider available. > If Mozilla or name your blessed organization of choice came up with this system, most of them would be fine with it. Mozilla came up with Persona, which would be great if they pushed it further and perhapps provided an anonymous email relayer like this instead of being based on existing email providers. With Mozilla the big advantage is that your account is not tied to any other service, real name, credit card etc. I wouldn't use Apple Login to sign up to a porn site, despite the high standards of apple's security.
- cwills 7y agoNot because it’s Apple, but rather because Apple are exploiting their position as iOS App Store gatekeepers to require developers to add Sign In With Apple. Mozilla don’t have this position / power. I think people would have the same issue if Google required ‘Sign In With Google’ in play store apps that have Facebook login, and returned throwaway / proxies email addresses.
- jarjoura 7y agoI haven’t seen anyone upset over the feature set. The only complaints I’ve seen are those uneasy with Apple’s forceful hand. They are both the gatekeeper to the store and now gatekeeper to the login. This is happening at the same time they are being investigated for anti-trust.
- millettjon 7y agoMicrosoft has a better decentralized approach https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/technology/own-your-identity https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/security/technology/own-your.... Things have come full circle.
- ardit33 7y agough, this totally vendor lock-in . 1. If my app is both in IOS and Android, and maybe Windows, would this work across platforms? The answer looks like no... Apple's definition of "multiplatform" means iOS, TVOS and WatchOS, and some javascript for the web. (given Apple's poor track record for anything web-based, good luck with that). If you want to port your app to Android or Native Windows, good luck with that. Your users are locked in. 2. If I have an app that is a competitor to Facebook, and FB decides to cut me off, I can use the existing emails so the user are not locked out the app (i.e. they will be sent an email with a link to create a password and keep their account). This looks impossible with the apple sign in. Basically if Apple decides to cut you off, your user's accounts are lost. No matter what some folks believe that 'everything social is evil', some applications providers provide the social log-in just because the user that prefer using them over entering the same information over and over. Instead of entering email, authorizing/verifying it, and having a profile picture, a social log-in provides those for you. As I am building an app that has the social login (Google and Facebook) as well as simple email sign in, this feels like an additional burden that I'd prefer not to (for the two main reasons above). Feels very anti-competitive.... Apple should provide the log-in as an option, and compete with its own merits, but not force app makers to use it. Also, I think apple is being totally evil now: By forcing companies like Spotify and other competitors to use their log in, they are creating an very intrusive/invasive way to monitor their competitors. Eg. Netflix and Spotify and a myriad of other Apple's direct competitor are forced to be locked in the Apple's vendor sign in trap.
- kalleboo 7y agoAs for 1, just use a webview? That's how the iOS SDKs for Facebook/Twitter worked for the longest time. edit: Also it looks like it's just OAuth and you could implement it directly
- xenospn 7y agoThey actually stated that it supports iOS, Android and Web.
- aaronbrager 7y agoYou can use the REST API if you don’t want to use the JavaScript SDK.
- mrfusion 7y agoSo how do I benefit as a consumer?
- mindgam3 7y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20086045 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20086045
- mderazon 7y agoWhat happens if an app has iOS, web and Android versions ? Do they all have to implement apple log in now just because the iOS app needs to implement it and they want users to be able to use the app across platforms?
- jarjoura 7y agoIt's quite amazing that Apple is doing this at the exact time the government is investigating them for anti-trust violations. Essentially what Apple is doing is creating a new gate as they've done before with forcing developers to use their payment processing system for digital goods that costs 30% of the total fee. Facebook Login already supports users blocking sending sites their email, as I disable that all the time. They even have published guidelines with what a site should do when they think they need that piece of information. So I'm not sold on the privacy story here. Go on, give it a try the next time you are signing in for the first time. You can even go back and remove your email permission from the security page in FB. Apple did do one thing though, they created a bigger market for junk email services and made it easy to send those to services you expect to get notifications from. Still, this is something Apple could have built into iOS just like they did with password managers. It's not a feature that needed to be forced on anyone for any reason. As a user of the device, I can just pick, get me a junk email and presto, it's done. I get it though, I can imagine the scenario last year right after news broke with Cambridge Analytica. This was enabled from a shady 3rd party developer using FB single sign-on and execs at Apple were pissed. They probably hastily demanded someone at Apple create something to circumvent FB's position. However, this doesn't just affect FB, it affects Twitter, Google, GitHub, Microsoft as well. Yes Apple has good-will in this community, and its to their competitive advantage that they continue to build out more privacy focused features. However, I still do not appreciate that Apple gets the final say. This should have been a bigger conversation across the entire industry. Why didn't Apple come out and say, we are investing in the Oauth organization and then published papers on best practices? It would have been a much bigger win to get Microsoft or Google on board from the start and launched together. Hundreds of researchers all over the world would have jumped on it. Instead now we're left with another moral authority move, shoved in developers faces at the whims of Apple Execs.
- askafriend 7y agoI don't see how this is an anti-trust issue at all. I don't get why people keep bringing it up. Developers are free not to implement social login. If they do implement social login then this provides a unique user benefit (privacy) while also increasing user choice (users are still free to login how they want).
- dcbadacd 7y agoUnless this becomes open for everyone, even for web devs that do not specifically have an Apple device and Apple Developer Licence, I do not see it getting far.
- steve_taylor 7y ago> It will be required as an option for users in apps that support third-party sign-in when it is commercially available later this year. This is absolutely ridiculous. What about games that allow you to sign in with Facebook specifically for the purpose of tracking your progress relative to your friends? Sign in with Apple has precisely zero purpose in this scenario. I can sort of understand making this a requirement if sign in is required to use the app at all. I really hope that exemptions will be allowed where Sign in with Apple is 100% pointless.
- dannyw 7y agoIf sign in with Facebook is optional and for providing specific features, then its not really using Facebook as an account management system - it’s more connecting to Facebook - so I think you’ll be fine.
- steve_taylor 7y agoThe updated guidelines say nothing about the login being required vs. optional.
- PunksATawnyFill 7y agoThis is a classic Apple workaround to a problem THEY perpetuate. Apple suddenly decided on the amateur-hour policy of forcing users to use an E-mail address as their user ID. And more recently they've doubled down on that stupidity by requiring that it be a WORKING E-mail address, giving you no way to specify (in your user profile) a real E-mail address at which you can be contacted. The public at large isn't all that savvy about how this works; so when asked to set up an account with their E-mail address and password, what percentage would you guess assumes that they have to use the same password as their actual E-mail account? I'm guessing that percentage is very high, maybe 50%. When sites implement this asinine policy, they become responsible not just for the user's security on that one site, but the security of the user's E-mail account. Talk about a ripe opportunity for identity theft or more, if the site's database is hacked or stolen. You don't see banks or brokerage houses forcing people to log in with an E-mail address. Apple's ignorance of online services continues...
- jay_kyburz 7y agoSo, you can sign in with apple, but the app can then ask for a real email address as well if they wanted to right?
- xenospn 7y agoI'm currently using Firebase Auth to manage my logins; Wonder if I'll have to add on another authentication layer on top of it now to add this. Don't see Google adding native support for Apple Auth any time soon.
- msravi 7y agoYahoo has had disposable email for a long time. You can create upto 500 disposable email addresses (by going to Settings->More Settings->Mailboxes). Also, you can give this email address a base name that is different from your normal email address so if your normal address is xyz@yahoo.com, you can have "abc" as the base name of your disposable addresses, and your disposable emails will have addresses of the form abc-<your-chosen-disposable-id>@yahoo.com (abc-spamsite1@yahoo.com for example). So unlike gmail's "plus" email addresses, it's not possible to decipher your real email id from the disposable one. Very handy. Combine this with Firefox's ability to remember userid/passwords and sync across devices, and you have a powerful privacy toolset that is not a pain to use and is not controlled by any single entity.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoI create unique email addresses per service. The pain is in autocompleting email inputs in signup forms. It will suggest a bunch of email addresses that I used on other services and not a new one to use for this service.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoGoogle's and Microsoft's sign in PMs should be ashamed they hadn't implemented this already. Giving a stable email to all services leaks valuable information that would be more lucrative for them to keep to themselves.
- lucasverra 7y agoTested a sample demo and working OK https://github.com/nov/apple_id/issues/1 https://github.com/nov/apple_id/issues/1
- rcarmo 7y ago" * You may only use the Sign In with Apple software if you are enrolled in the Apple Developer Program." This taken directly from their JS at https://appleid.cdn-apple.com/appleauth/static/jsapi/appleid/1/en_US/appleid.auth.js https://appleid.cdn-apple.com/appleauth/static/jsapi/appleid... This seems to imply that using this for your personal site, for instance, requires the $99 "developer tax"...
- martamorena 7y agoWow, 11 years too late, it's finally here. The new ingenious invention, by Apple, to let me sign in to apps with the account I am already logged in on my device. But hey, it's Apple, let's cheer... WOW what a great feature, you have have done it again Apple. Keep the innovations coming!! :DDD And apparently, to make up for the 11 year delay in developing this feature, they now force everyone to show it alongside of Google & Facebook sign-in.