21 ms·
Is Amazon Violating U.S. Antitrust Laws?
- licnep 8y agoWhat about Uber and Lyft? Aren't they known to operate at a loss to undercut the competition, and couldn't taxi drivers bring them to court for that?
- Guest42 8y agoArticle was written about a specific incident rather than every incident.
- astura 8y agoThe article touches on this briefly >The paper could also spur the Federal Trade Commission to make a simple rule change that would lay bare Amazon’s practices. And, it could blow up a scheme that Uber, Lime, and numerous other startups have been accused of undertaking.
- imglorp 8y agoThat seems like you could easily circumvent by claiming the underpriced service is a loss leader, routing customers towards more profitable upsells at other points in the relationship. Printers and toner, handles and razors, banks and toasters.
- munk-a 8y agoThese all[1], along with the general concept of a loss leader, are instances where a company is leveraging patent or protected data laws in an unintended manner to set up a moat against competition - as this is anti-competitive all these examples should be examined to see to what extent are preventing free enterprise - printer toner is a particularly egregious example of using device lock down to prevent a legitimate use of a product. [1] Except banks and toasters which is... a weird example case
- imglorp 8y agoOkay, poor examples? How about quickie marts selling underpriced drinks in the back... but you usually end up buying other things on your way to the drinks that have the big margins. The drinks are probably undercutting other stores.
- munk-a 8y agoI have less of an issue with this sort of an arrangement as the low saturation point for selling drinks means that the locality of the quickie mart already gives it a huge competitive advantage, under-pricing their drinks isn't likely to effect competitors - just spur on more sales as a sort of advertising. That said if a drink stand (maybe a food-cart) was unable to match the prices offered by a quickie mart because they were selling at a loss - then I think we've returned to a situation where loss leading is creating a barrier to market entry. The quickie mart is a really good example (I also like toy stores that sell cheap diapers to try and leverage free eyeballs as they pass through the store) where the market has a very low natural level of competition and there aren't as many specialized sellers - I think in these cases a loss-leader could be permitted on a small scale, but still be held subject to legal action if the disparity started suppressing the local market. (Also, sorry, I didn't mean to criticize the bank toaster example, I was actually quite amused by it, I've never heard that described as a loss-leader but it totally is)
- mars4rp 8y agoaccording to the article, if the company is operate at loss and it benefit customers, it is fine! "Both of these outcomes reflect consumers failing to share in Amazon’s bounty, which is key for current antitrust law. Right now, anti-competitive conduct like predatory pricing is judged under the “consumer welfare standard,” which has been interpreted to mean simply whether a market dominated by a single company results in higher or lower prices. But even though prices are the same on Amazon, consumers are arguably missing out, Sussman explains, because they’re not benefiting from Amazon’s soaring profits. “It’s illegal and even the most conservative neoclassical thinker would agree,” he says."
- aeternus 8y agoI'd argue consumers are benefiting greatly from Amazon's profits. They have overall re-invested those profits into other businesses that benefit consumers. Ex: Purchased Whole Foods and have brought down those prices overall plus building Amazon Go stores which offer a much better consumer experience than traditional grocery. Amazon's Web Services platform has leveled the playing field and enabled many startups. Amazon has pressured almost all other retailers online & offline to offer free or cheap delivery which is great for consumers. Walmart would likely never have done this without pressure from Amazon.
- rootusrootus 8y agoBenefiting now perhaps, but isn't the point that in the long run customers will be worse off because of what Amazon is doing?
- aeternus 8y agoMaybe, but Amazon faces competition from Ebay, Alibaba, even Walmart. It's unlikely they can raise prices significantly and maintain market share, nor is it likely that they can push out all of those competitors.
- gowld 8y agoFree delivery isn't free; it's just amortized baked into the price. The real savings come from logistics like getting one shipment from the Everything Store instead of 5 separate shipments.
- ajross 8y agoMaybe. But the fact that Uber and Lyft are actively competing (both with taxis and each other) using that model would be a pretty strong argument to the contrary. At the end of the day, antitrust legislation exists to protect consumers and markets, not established businesses. Prices under cost, in isolation, pretty much can't be antitrust violations by definition. They have to be used to effect a harm to the market in other ways.
- munk-a 8y agoYes, via vertical integration[1] - this should be obvious to anyone outside of the FTC[2]. [1] For people unaware of Amazon's practice of pushing out middlemen who conduct high volumes of business: http://fortune.com/2016/04/20/amazon-copies-merchants/ http://fortune.com/2016/04/20/amazon-copies-merchants/ [2] People inside of the FTC are almost certainly aware, but happily continue to shove their fingers in their ears and sing "la la la I can't hear you la la la".
- mr_toad 8y agoVertical integration, or cutting out the ‘middle-man’ is not in and of itself illegal. What might be illegal would be selling products at a loss to drive others away.
- munk-a 8y agoOr controlling the market place where those middle-men are operating from which you're forcing them out? Really, the burden of proof here is on Amazon and I'd be amazed if there wasn't really clear cut proof that they used analytics they don't offer to outside clients (private information) to specifically undercut the existing sellers (under pricing) or selling the products at a profitable point unrealizable if you need to pay their listing fee (again under pricing) or even just delisted their competitors products or discouraged searches from returning them as valid options. Pretty certain amazon checked at least one of those boxes - reasonably confident they checked at least three of them.
- microcolonel 8y ago> the burden of proof here is on Amazon What? What kind of standard is that?
- mehrdadn 8y agoLoss leaders are legal, right? What's the effective difference between those and predatory pricing? Is it just the intention rather than the actual effect?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 8y agoDoes that mean VC Fund My Life may eventually be irrelevant? I'd hate to get outcompeted by someone blowing VC money to undercut me, and it seems like standard practice. http://www.vcfml.com/ http://www.vcfml.com/
- _4vew 8y ago(Disclaimer: I work for Amazon, but not in the retail, legal, or finance departments, and I have no inside information about what the company is doing with respect to its pricing. Opinions are my own and not of the company.) Yet another sensationalist headline that is unsubstantiated by the article. "This law student" has a theory. He does not have evidence -- and, in fact, much ink in the article is spilled on the fact that the evidence needed to sustain an antitrust case against Amazon isn't readily available to the public or to the Government. Nor has any Court ever held, to my knowledge, that an antitrust action can be sustained without consumer prices going up - merely keeping them the same is not enough. Key quotes (emphasis mine): "Sussman believes that if Amazon gave the full picture, it would show negative cash flow." "No current accounting rules force full disclosure of itemized costs. Considered highly confidential, they’re typically redacted from public legal documents, even when a company is sued. More definitive cash flow numbers could help prove whether Amazon sells items below cost." "Sussman believes that the Federal Trade Commission should force companies to break down their costs in confidential examinations." "Right now, anti-competitive conduct like predatory pricing is judged under the “consumer welfare standard,” which has been interpreted to mean simply whether a market dominated by a single company results in higher or lower prices. But even though prices are the same on Amazon, consumers are arguably missing out, Sussman explains, because they’re not benefiting from Amazon’s soaring profits." (This is not my understanding of an actionable situation under current antitrust law.)
- lvs 8y agoOh come on. You're clearly engineering on how to evade antitrust law. But the better argument is simply that if antitrust law doesn't sufficiently cover Amazon's business, then it needs to be changed to ensure that it does.
- judge2020 8y agoYou can disagree on whether or not Amazon is pricing things ethically, or whether or not antitrust laws should cover Amazon's actions, but the article title is "Is Amazon Violating U.S. Antitrust Laws" which, in the current state of US law, it (probably) isn't.
- nanoscopic 8y agoAmazon has a team called "Amazon Profitability Group". I used to work for said team, albeit only briefly. The purpose of the team is to calculate the proper price to sell items for, the "discount" to vendors, and the items to put in the "buy box" in order to make the most profit for Amazon. I think the what is described here in the article is only the tip of the iceberg. Amazon isn't doing something as simplistic as cutting out the competition with low prices... they are feeding all the numbers into neural networks and analyzing and predicting competition and profits, and then doing what the systems tell them is the most profitable. That is, anything that Amazon can predict will make them more money or gain more market share... they are doing. I have full confidence that they are doing all of the terrible things outlined and more. The bigger question is whether government and law allow them to continue doing this. I think that it will continue to be allowed, despite being super shady and destroying both small and medium size businesses. It cannot easily be proven that there is anyone orchestrating the monopolistic processes, because Amazon has essentially turned the process of dominating the market into an equation and they just do what the equation tells them to. Amazon will claim "we are just being smarter; we mean no harm", and without providing open minutes of their internal discussions it will be impossible to prove wrongdoing. What is needed is open accountability for internal plans, but that is against the "American way" so I doubt it will happen anytime soon.
- ajhurliman 8y ago"and then doing what the systems tell them is the most profitable." ...so, not predatory pricing then?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 8y agoIt seems to me that, by this description, Amazon is admirably fulfilling its legal and fiscal duties, and to a greater degree than I thought before receiving this information.
- 8y ago
- danschumann 8y agoAmazon took away his prime membership. - South Park
- Mikeb85 8y agoIt's not illegal to drive down prices in a competitive environment. In fact, economic theory says that in a sector that has 'perfect' competition, prices will essentially be the cost of production. What Amazon is currently doing isn't illegal. In the future, if they abuse their dominant position to jack up prices, they might be in some trouble. But running on thin margins isn't illegal, and it seems Amazon has created avenues to produce profit without increasing prices, thus falling within the law and also with what economic theory predicts should happen.
- munk-a 8y agoIt is illegal to do this when you slip below the cost of production line - at that point your lost profit becomes an investment (if you're doing it right) in either securing long term profits[1] (printers and toner) or driving competitors out of business (predatory pricing[2] or possibly dumping[3] if done for market control) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predatory_pricing [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) Dumping is a particularly interesting instance since there isn't a direct realized economic gain.
- Mikeb85 8y agoFrom the article: > 5 percent profit margin on Amazon’s own retail sales Last I checked, 5 percent margin is still making a profit, and definitely doesn't fit the definition of dumping nor predatory pricing. Part of the theory hinges on this: > However, Sussman asserts in his paper, “Amazon utilizes existing loopholes in Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) disclosure regulations to exclude a significant portion of its expenses.” > Amazon accomplishes this in part through using capital leases to purchase equipment and some of its 288 million square feet of office space. Instead of paying cash, Amazon borrows and finances these purchases over time. The leases don’t show up as expenses in Amazon’s free cash flow calculations, even though the equipment is listed as an asset. A 2017 Motley Fool report showed that, when you add in capital leases, Amazon’s 2017 cash flow was indeed over $1 billion in the red, although more recent numbers have bounced back. Again though, there's nothing illegal about a firm using debt to finance expansion, nor is there anything illegal about a firm's net profit being negative, especially if there's positive cashflow from selling to consumers. The whole article is nothing more than theories without any proof that Amazon is actually dumping products. And like I said, running thin margins isn't illegal. Undercutting your competition isn't illegal. Scaling out so your costs are less than your competition isn't illegal. You need to prove that a firm is actually dumping, it's not enough to think that they might be because they're out-competing you. More from the article: > As Sussman explains, if Amazon is recouping losses from a predatory pricing scheme by reducing its costs, the windfall profits aren’t being transferred to customers. Reducing their costs to realize a profit literally is passing on the benefits to customers by continuing to sell at a low price.
- 0815test 8y agoEconomically speaking, the question should boil down to "is Amazon operating in a contestable market, and/or are they engaging in abusive behavior to raise barriers to entry in the market, lowering its contestability". The notion of predatory pricing per se, in contrast, is not really well-defined. Is there some inherent reason why the suppliers and wholesalers who are supposedly being harmed by this monopoly could not simply move to an established competitor, e.g. eBay, Alibaba or whatever, or even start a platform of their own along more favorable principles?
- munk-a 8y agoAnd that's the question that seems pretty clear cut as a violation - not currently provable but highly indicated by evidence. The portion of Amazon that sells things to consumers provides a clear incentive to raise barrier to entry in the market that they sell those things in - and Amazon also happens to own the market that these things are sold over. This is part of the reason I think there should be concern over Amazon, Google & Apple's profitability (and to a lesser extent Microsoft and Valve) creating a walled garden app store opens up all sorts of crazy anti-trust exposure, just because the FTC is currently declawed doesn't mean that exposure doesn't exist, that risk is just being deferred. In cases like Amazon where they are actively competing against competitors on their own platform... the question of how their suggestion algorithm works is a huge can of legal liability.
- int_19h 8y agoIt should, but the "consumer welfare standard" explicitly repudiates such approach. In US, a company can be a complete monopoly, wiping out all competition, and still not cross the line for anti-trust purposes. This is actually kinda ironic, given that US is generally considered to be more on the side of the spectrum that strongly believes in the "invisible hand of the market" - and so it would make more sense for anti-trust to be defined in terms that would protect that hand from being "broken". And indeed, it was so defined originally, until this new standard came to be. Since then, we've seen steadily increasing market concentration [1], and the corresponding decline in competition, all while being assured that it's not harmful to us as consumers, and with some people even openly extolling the virtues of monopolies for consumers (e.g. Thiel). To me, these sound very similar to the arguments that are used to justify "benevolent dictatorships", except here we're talking about economic power rather than political (and, of course, the two are not independent). [1] https://concentrationcrisis.openmarketsinstitute.org/ https://concentrationcrisis.openmarketsinstitute.org/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- rdlecler1 8y agoCompanies achieving a kind of monopoly status should be subject to additional financial disclosures and reporting. The benefit here is (1) not all companies need to meet this compliance standard (2) we get a much better look into the books to determine if there is something illegal/nefarious going on (3) this additional reporting gives upstarts an insight to chip away at any monopoly by having access to data that sustains that monopoly in the first place. Let’s not use a heavy hand of busting up a company, just let capitalism do the work.
- rdlecler1 8y ago>Sellers can use “Fulfillment by Amazon,” so Amazon handles storage and shipping of its products through its vast logistics network. But Amazon also charges for that privilege. We used to call this kind of activity a ‘service’ but apparently it’s now called a ‘privilege’
- jgowdy 8y agoRight? I wonder if we take storage out of it... >Sellers can use “Fulfillment by UPS,” so UPS handles shipping of its products through its vast logistics network. But UPS also charges for that privilege. Spooky!
- Retra 8y agohttps://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22charge+for+the+privelege%22&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%22charge+for+the+privelege%22&ia=... It's just an expression.
- ClassyJacket 8y ago"Privilege" in this context is sarcastic or exaggerated. It's a common figure of speech.
- _tb1_ 8y agoThat Bork theory is nutty. Imagine thinking that businesses don't take calculated risks. There is a conveyor belt of judges supported and moved forward by big money corporate interests.
- rdlecler1 8y agoThe real danger is in debasement—something we’ve seen with product over the past 40-50 years and it’s no different than Walmart putting pricing pressure on it’s suppliers. If suppliers can’t increase costs and they’ve maxed out economies of scale then they need to debase their product to Suppliers need to cut corners to generate additional profits.
- ThrustVectoring 8y agoThis squeeze on suppliers is a big part of why Amazon has such a problem with counterfeit goods, IMO. If you start blindly optimizing on supplier prices, counterfeiters can often win those price competitions.
- markwkw 8y agoInteresting piece from the article: "Sussman points to evidence that Amazon has already flipped the switch, moving from dominating the market by undercutting rivals to reaping the profits from that dominance." So according to Sussman, Amazon is already making money. I wonder what point in time the author thinks Amazon started making money. If the author claims that happened e.g. in 2016, them Amazon was actually losing money for the first 20 years of its operation. That would require Amazon to have been raising capital for a long, long time. Can that be verified? Are there stock market metrics on total amount of capital raised/net borrowed in a given year? Has anyone been able to access the actual article to check the details of authors claims?
- Despegar 8y agoThey haven't needed outside capital because Amazon has been generating free cash flow since 2002 or 2003. They were losing money on a GAAP basis because they were investing in capex heavy things like warehouses and data centers. Looking at Amazon's aggregate financials doesn't tell us anything about whether they're doing something anticompetitive.
- markwkw 8y agoThe root of Sussman's claim is that Amazon was hiding some expenses to _pretend_ that they were cash flow positive. (since being cash flow positive strongly suggests that there is no predatory pricing) <quote>However, Sussman asserts in his paper, “Amazon utilizes existing loopholes in Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) disclosure regulations to exclude a significant portion of its expenses.”</quote> So the author is claiming amazon's _not_ been cash flow positive. If that is the case, then where was the money coming from?
- TulliusCicero 8y agoYeah, this is what I don't get. Amazon has been steadily growing without injections of investor cash for a long time now. If they were constantly selling stuff at a loss, that would be impossible.
- ilaksh 8y agoI think if it's this complicated or needs internal documents then the laws need to be revised. To me it's very obvious that Amazon has a monopoly that is harmful to retailers. It also seems straightforward that it is an undesirable situation for consumers because it puts everyone at the mercy of this monopoly. Just because it isn't obvious that they are screwing us yet doesn't mean we should let them have total control until they do. Anyone who wants to sell online has to worry what Amazon is going to do with them. It's as if there was a big public square in the middle of the city and some day one of the vendors bought the entire square and then started charging all of the other vendors for the privilege of using the square. The reason they are successful I think is because people need a platform for online shopping. Websites are not that platform. What I think we need are public decentralized protocols that vendors, logistics, and applications can plug into. Similar to what Amazon is doing now, but not controlled by one company who is also a competitor.
- elamje 8y agoRegardless of law, they are profitably delivering a very wide variety of items to my door for significantly cheaper than anywhere else I look. I cannot ignore that
- paxy 8y agoWhat about if/when they are the only retail company left and significantly raise prices? This is the reason such laws exist.
- nickik 8y agoIts funny how this is a worry but it basically never happens. There is basically a incredibly tiny number of actual cases where this 'predatory pricing and then raise prices' has worked and not in markets as open as e-commerce and delivery that other companies could easily get into. In fact historically this has not happened before Anti-Trust laws. It has basically been used by competitors who couldn't compete on the market so they went to their friends in government to stop their competition. Since they didn't want to argue 'Their product is better and cheaper' they argued, 'Its predatory pricing, as soon as I'm gone this company is gone raise prices'. The first US anti-trust law was enacted because butchers were extremely angry about centralized slaughtering houses that used refrigerated trains to transport meat. Classic special interest politics. But somehow 150 years later the evil centralized slaughtering houses haven't raised the prices yet.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoDo you really think they're ever going to be the only online retail company in the country?
- elamje 8y agoAmazon has always focused on lowering prices, as long as Bezos is around I don’t expect that to change. By the way Walmart clobbered competition with lower prices for last 60 years, did all retail go away? No, in fact several places like Target, Costco etc popped up and have carved out a niche and they all still compete on prices
- ssnistfajen 8y agoMaybe this so-called "law student" should read up on retail marketing terms from time to time. Loss-leaders have been a thing for decades if not longer. Amazon is just able to maintain more loss-leaders than your average brick-and-mortar store (chain or non-chain), and their operations are diversified beyond E-commerce/retail with higher margins which can polish the numbers quite a bit. The world has yet to see another monopoly on the scale of Standard Oil, and no, Amazon (specifically in the E-commerce market) is nowhere even close to that. One law student's "predatory pricing" is just another business' loss-leader. I hope Mr.Sussman will one day acquire the knowledge that he won't be the first nor the last to come up with ideas on how to challenge Amazon.
- C1sc0cat 8y agoAnd look at some of the super aggressive (ok bullying) that the big supermarket chains do to suppliers /farmers etc.
- skookumchuck 8y agoReminds me of the astonishing anti-trust case against Microsoft arguing that giving consumers free stuff was harming them.
- PorterDuff 8y agoDoes antitrust law apply to a monopsony?
- thesumofall 8y agoFor me, this is difficult to reconcile with my experience that there is barely any product left on Amazon where they really are the cheapest. You’ll almost always find well rated smaller online shops across all categories that sell substantially below Amazon’s prices. This is even more so true if you want something sold and fulfilled by Amazon.
- TulliusCicero 8y agoYes, but it's unlikely that they have fast, free/cheap shipping. And Amazon's customer service/return policy/overall UX is top notch compared to smaller retailers.
- c3534l 8y agoAs an accounting student, the idea that Amazon is using capital leases as way of manipulating their financials is hilarious. That's the exact opposite of what everyone else does. Most companies try to hide debt they incur to buy infrastructure by claiming that they're actually renting it. This is why there are complicated rules about what kind leasing agreements count as debt and which count as expenses. The claim repeatedly and misleadingly made in the article that Amazon doesn't post a profit is easily debunked by the fact that they're a publicly traded company that legally has to have it profits made publicly available. They make a profit. They have for a long time. It goes up and it goes down as they expand and reinvest, but they're definitely not intentionally taking a loss. And they have to have their accounting methods and control systems used to be audited by an independent third party annually to ensure compliance with generally accepted accounting principles. As far as I'm aware, they've never had an adverse opinion issued against them. The whole point of making public companies undergo an audit every single year is to make sure they're doing any shenanigans that make their annual statements in some way not comparable to the financial statements of other companies in that industry. It's incredibly annoying to see an article like this get shared because it's incredibly obvious the author doesn't know what the heck he's talking about, but just enough to fool readers into thinking he does.
- jasonsync 8y agoA little late. Amazon launched a product called "Amazon Drive" in 2015 ... Unlimited cloud storage! $11.99/year for photos and $59.99/year for everything: https://venturebeat.com/2015/03/26/amazon-launches-two-new-cloud-drive-unlimited-plans-11-99year-for-photos-and-59-99year-for-everything/ https://venturebeat.com/2015/03/26/amazon-launches-two-new-c... At the time, anyone familiar with cloud storage (Dropbox, Sync.com, Box etc.) knew that Amazon was undercutting their rivals (selling at a loss) to enter the consumer market. Worse, many cloud providers resell AWS storage (Dropbox did at the time, and was an Amazon customer). Amazon ran this "loss leader" for almost 2 years, hoping to drive the competition out. In the end all they did was upset existing AWS customers, and eventually duped their own newly minted Amazon Drive customers, because they shuttered the service 2 years later (the losses started adding up on both sides): https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/08/amazon-ends-its-unlimited-cloud-storage-plan/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/06/08/amazon-ends-its-unlimited-... https://www.geekwire.com/2018/dropbox-saved-almost-75-million-two-years-building-tech-infrastructure/ https://www.geekwire.com/2018/dropbox-saved-almost-75-millio...
- jondubois 8y agoThe root of the problem is that corporations have fooled governments into mixing up 'consumers' with 'people'. Governments should serve people, not consumers. This is a big mistake because people spend most of their lives working; this means that the average person spends the vast majority of their time producing value instead of consuming it. So the average person is not a consumer, they're a producer. The biggest consumers are rich people. Whenever you make laws to protect consumers, you're mostly protecting rich people. As wealth becomes increasingly centralized, this statement becomes increasingly true and it becomes a vicious cycle.