24 ms·
Google cancels AI ethics board in response to outcry
- nosseo 8y agoHey HN, I'm the author of this article (also the precursor predicting this, which was on the front page yesterday). My impression is that the best place to look for an explanation is actually the facebook post by Luciano Floridi: https://www.facebook.com/floridi/posts/10157226054696031 https://www.facebook.com/floridi/posts/10157226054696031. My sources at Google just couldn't see the panelists constructively working together on a panel at this point. Obviously, protests by Google employees played a role too.
- geofft 8y ago> My sources at Google just couldn't see the panelists constructively working together on a panel at this point. Well, that's the point, isn't it? If the AI ethics council is meeting four times a year for a couple hours at most, and and has people who can't even agree on "Which bathroom should this person use," how are they going to produce productive advice for actual hard questions that haven't been well-explored? There is a place for debate between people who don't agree on worldview. This council was never going to be it.
- mc32 8y agoPresumably there would be many more issues beside bathroom policies. Moreover one person isn’t s majority among eight.
- yalue 8y agoYou're right about all of that, but shouldn't a meaningful board at least make some show of trying to include diverse opinions? The key word of course is "meaningful", and I think you're right on the money that Google wasn't interested in having a panel to discuss meaningful issues in the first place; it seems more likely that they wanted to be able to point to a source of "external" "unbiased" opinions to justify what they were planning to do already. (Obviously the people who complained about a prominent right-wing figure would just argue something hypocritical like "only the right kind of diversity of opinion", but that's beside the point; the panel was a dumb idea to begin with, coming from a group with so much of a stake in trying to advance AI for the sake of advertising)
- durability 8y agoDiversity is great! Putting someone who advocates for not using AI on an AI ethics board is diversity. Putting someone who advocates for more/less/self regulation is diversity. Putting someone hostile towards the LGBTQ community and LGBTQ rights? That’s not diversity. That has no place in 2019.
- yalue 8y agoSure, but if they're not debating that topic, why should it be an issue? Not that I think such a person belongs on the panel, but the reason they're not invited should be, as you said, that they have few or no qualifications to discuss either ethics or AI. The fact that they don't agree with the others on LGBT rights should only be an issue if they insist on trying to espouse their unrelated viewpoints using the panel, in which case by all means kick them off.
- durability 8y agoBecause you can’t look at these beliefs in a vacuum. Someone who’s against LGBTQ rights isn’t against it for the hell of it, they have some underlying reason such as religious ideology. I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with religion, but when you believe that a man and a man together is unnatural and a sin against nature, then I have to wonder what other backwards regressive medieval beliefs they hold as well.
- yalue 8y ago(Note that I'm not trying to straw-man you here, because I know you're only talking about the specific instance of this panel, which I've already agree was a farce to begin with. However,...) I still think it's harmful to society as a whole to try to use someone's views on any given topic as an excuse to refuse to work with them on something unrelated. Say, for instance, that you're asked by a supervisor to collaborate with a Muslim living in a middle eastern country on writing a piece of software. For the sake of argument, say that this particular person believed that the laws recently enacted in Brunei were in line with the commands of Islam, and therefore just. (For the sake of argument only--obviously not everybody in those categories is like this at all--but clearly at least some must be or we wouldn't have situations like this recent one.) Would it be right to refuse to work with this person on writing say, some python code, when the topic of "sharia law" is never going to be a factor? Furthermore, by your argument, would you be willing to trust this person's judgement on software architecture when they have exhibited a, in your view, extreme lack of good judgement in another field? Second, you can even take this argument to a higher level. You admit that the opposing party has a reason to believe what they believe, and I'd imagine that you'd even grant that they probably believe that their reasons for their particular position are good reasons. Leaving aside whether the positions themselves are good or not, how do you evaluate whether someone's reasons for holding a particular position are good? After all, a religious person may believe that one day an omniscient being will call them to answer for why they failed to keep holy commands in their life. To the holder of such a view, that's a pretty good reason to do some twisted stuff. If anything, (if their religion is right) such a reason for them holding their particular position (fear of eternal condemnation) may even be better to them than your reasons for your position are to you!
- gubbrora 8y agoWhy should they agree? They could have produced advice of the form "from perspective A we should do x but from perspective B we should do y".
- geofft 8y agoThe point of debate is to test ideas by argument and logic and strengthen the strong ones and reject the weak ones. If you just say "Here are our thoughts," then the "what about robust debate" rationale doesn't hold up, and we can get to the direct question of whether James' worldview is moral or immoral, because the people taking the "advice" are going to have to pick either perspective A or perspective B. And if you're going to pick one in the end, why not get everyone from that worldview? There are lots of Roman Catholic theologians, for instance, that they could have included. I don't personally agree with them either, but they absolutely have a rich history of thinking about ethics, and they mostly also don't believe in trans people. Why leave James to fend for herself?
- gubbrora 8y agoWell in the hypothetical, whoever takes their advice would need to make a synthesis of it somehow. E.g. most perspectives agree so let's do it this way. Or this question doesn't matter that much from most perspectives and according to this one it matters a lot so let's go with that one. Or even just ignoring them from time to time.
- qmanjamz 8y agoIt seems to me that if they limited their recommendations to only things the entire board could agree on, they could still be productive. For example, they may not agree on how bathrooms should be organized, but they probably all agree that bathrooms should exist. The fact that the board had wildly varying opinions is a feature, not a bug. The outputs of this board should be widely agreed upon. If they make declarations that half the country disagrees with, they're going to lose credibility fast. Having an ideologically diverse board helps to secure their credibility.
- geofft 8y agoBut the board is there to advise Google on hard questions, not easy ones. Is it unethical, for instance, to use AI to detect and block potential child pornography and flag it for potential referral to law enforcement? Probably not, but anyone can tell you that. Is it unethical to use AI to identify "gender ideology propaganda" and refer that to law enforcement in places where it's illegal? Depends on whether you think such laws are ethical. If the council can't answer that, what use is it? (If the point of the council is to tell you things that anyone with a functioning conscience could tell you, then the fact that it's needed is a serious indictment of Google management. I'd like to think the council is here for the hard questions.)
- qmanjamz 8y agoIf you stack your council with people of entirely one viewpoint, there's little point in having a council at all. Create a board entirely of Muslims and it's going to say we should fast during Ramadan. If Google tries to cite that board as an ethical authority to justify a policy of mandatory fasting, they're not going to convince many people. With a diverse board, the answers to some questions are going to be inconclusive. But that doesn't mean the board shouldn't exist at all. And it certainly doesn't mean we should eliminate all diversity in the board.
- educationdata 8y agoHow many conservatives do they have on the board? I feel viewpoint diversity should at least be close to nationwide percentage.
- educationdata 8y agoIs "Which bathroom should this person use" an easy question? If it is really easy, why it is so controversial? You may think it is an easy question, in reality it is an actual hard question.
- kevingadd 8y agoIt's a very easy question, almost all countries have resolved answers for it. They don't all agree, but it was very easy to answer. Many of them have clear, objective standards on how to apply the rules (that people choose to ignore or argue over), though some certainly are determined to make it as fuzzy as possible for their own agendas. You can easily find local regulations addressing this topic pretty easily for most parts of the US and european countries, also some other countries like Japan. There's also the standard fallback answer for "which bathroom": if you make them all single occupancy, it doesn't matter which one. Sometimes that's the solution used in situations like schools. So maybe pick a better example of a hard question that seems easy. (Though I get the relevance here, given the decried panelist's history and views)
- matt4077 8y ago„Some say you shouldn’t exist. Others say you have a right to live. Hard question“
- 93s6oz 8y agoThat is polarising. An extreme take. I haven't seen anybody make the argument that trans people should be killed. Just that men should not be able to use women bathrooms. In this case, that's the argument. Turning it into something like that is not going to help anybody.
- matt4077 8y agoIt’s polarizing only if you accept the you-should-die part one of the poles, which is sort of the problem I was getting at. I would characterize it more as reductio ad absurdum.
- 8y ago
- compiler-guy 8y agoNot only could the panelists themselves not work together constructively. Googler's were so enraged by the inclusion of certain people that any recommendation with those people's sign-on would have been DOA.
- andrenth 8y agoThis is the cause of Googler rage: https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/273360/how-african-american-grandmother-enraged-1000-daniel-greenfield https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/273360/how-african-american...
- skj 8y agoI tried to read it, to see what she did that was considered objectionable, but I couldn't get past the trite putdowns the article slipped in all over the place about lefties and millennials. I was three pages deep before I gave up.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoI found a tweet where she opposed a law that would force women’s sports leagues to let men play, require people to let men use women’s bathrooms, and force doctors to sterilize teenagers.
- skj 8y agoAny possibility you're going to link to any of that sauce so we can decode it?
- SamReidHughes 8y agoLooks like it's already in this thread.
- geofft 8y agoIf the "highest-profile African-American woman at Google" is someone who shows up for a meeting every few months and isn't even paid for it, isn't that kind of a problem? If they're trying to play the race card, they should look more carefully at what happens when you tap it....
- mc32 8y agoSo what now? No ethics board at all and it just proceeds without ethics oversight? Isn’t that state worse than having someone you disagree with on some principles but in theory provide constructive criticism where the politics don’t intersect? I mean, making some jobs obsolete or making decisions on recidivism etc I think are distinct from what a panelist thinks about an unrelated issue. Moreover this person didn’t provide s majority view. Presumably the other panelists would have good arguments against her controversial views.
- tomlock 8y agoI feel like an extreme view would be to say any ethics board is better than no ethics board. If you disagree with that statement then I think the question is: Was this ethics board bad enough that it was worse than no ethics board? And, I trust that you're being charitable enough to believe that the people that wanted the board removed asked the same, very basic, ethical question. On the other hand - it might be easier to think they didn't ask or think about that question and discard their position based on what could frankly be called a strawman.
- effics 8y agoOh, I think the problem might just be a little bit more complicated than that. In a sense (and this is a gross exaguration, but just to frame the concept), an ethics panel formed by Charles Manson, Ted Bundy, John Wayne Gacy, Jeffrey Dahmer and David Berkowicz would not be an improvement over nothing at all. It would be a step backwards, and the world would be worse for tolerating it. This is not to say that any of the people involved in this particular episode are abominable monsters, far from it, but to drive home the point, whether you pick the right people or the best people really matters, and it does make a difference. In some respects, I'm not sure I'd want individuals with a vested interest and enthusiasm for AI to play watchdog over appropriate, responsible behavior. In a way, an ethics board in something of a no fun zone. It would likely make more sense to invite members from areas that might run counter to industry wonks, in ways that AI experts might prove tone deaf to self policing concerns. Does that make sense? We don't want to stifle the best parts of progress, but an ethics board shouldn't be made of people inclined to rubber stamp Skynet, because they'd tend toward seeing AI as progress by default.
- itg 8y agoWhy can’t leadership at Google stand by any of their decisions, instead of caving in to the demands of a small yet vocal group of people.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoThey stand up to all sorts of things when their bottom line is at stake, see AMP. When it comes to things they never cared about to begin with though, they fold like a cheap suit.
- dqpb 8y agoDo cheap suits fold easier than expensive suits?
- SpicyLemonZest 8y agoIt sounds like the problem was that the board members themselves started weighing in. There's no point in having an AI ethics board that spends most of its time discussing what kind of people should be allowed on an AI ethics board.
- geofft 8y agoEngineering at Google objected, and leadership at Google can't do anything without engineering at Google.
- usepgp 8y agoNot sure this is entirely true. Compared to some of the previous petitions / walkouts, this one was relatively minor, and was mostly the whiny ones.
- Pfhreak 8y agoWhat duty does the majority have to respect the feelings of the minority? Google recently posted that less than one percent of their population was non binary. If there was a concern that impacted every non binary Googler and they all spoke out passionately, it might not register as a major voice, but it still seems important to listen. Should we only concern ourselves with what the majority thinks? Isn't that the groupthink I see everyone talking about? Or should we take time to listen to these minority viewpoints and ensure we are building an environment where they feel welcome?
- stareatgoats 8y agoWe need an independent AI ethics oversight panel (not just for Google), period. But with everything ethical so tainted with insanely polarized politics it is unfortunately impossible to envisage such a board operating with the required general legitimacy. Which doesn't bode well for human control over technology in the future.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoThe Heritage Foundation is very much in the mainstream of conservatism in the United States. They are not a fringe right wing organization. This very public protest about the appointment of the Heritage Foundation president to the AI ethics panel, and Google's subsequent dissolution of it, deepens the mistrust that conservatives have about Google and Silicon Valley in general being hostile to them and the feeling that Silicon Valley does not even want to give them a voice in the debate. Given that conservatives make up between 35-40% of American adults, and that the way Senators and Electoral College votes are allocated gives them more political power than just the number would suggest, I fear that this alienation by Silicon Valley will prove to be detrimental in the long-term. https://news.gallup.com/poll/225074/conservative-lead-ideology-down-single-digits.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/225074/conservative-lead-ideolo... In the near term, I think this will cause more conservatives to embrace the need for a government AI ethics oversight panel as opposed to a Silicon Valley selected one.
- ilaksh 8y agoI don't think this should be downvoted. I'm not sure it's 40% but it is quite a lot and pretending people who have different worldviews don't exists or don't matter is not workable in the long run. Someone just trying to point out reality shouldn't be downvoted.
- kevingadd 8y agoThere's an argument to be made on the political basis, but unfortunately the choice of conservative was poor given the complete lack of qualifications and unnecessarily toxic public speech background. It's really worthwhile to vet your selections in advance to ensure they're not militant anarchists or antisemites or homophobes or anything else in their historical tweets or public speeches - regardless of their expertise on the subject (in this case, also none) it prevents them from doing their job without interference. There are numerous conservatives you could find to do the job who wouldn't have set off this controversy.
- jcims 8y agoMaybe they thought that any conservative they pick is going to have a similar history but that her diversity ups would buy her a pass.
- hollasch 8y agoWe should establish a committee to establish the Ultimate Human Purity Test. Use this to select an ecclesiastic convention of the resulting saints to deliver papal encyclicals on the topic. This might be what it takes to remove from sinners the freedom to speak.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- knolax 8y agoa.
- AndrewKemendo 8y agoI'm on an IEEE AI ethics standards working group and I can tell you that these kinds of boards, without deep expertise in technology and logic/philosophy don't end up producing anything of much value. Human ethics is hard, messy and forever changing. Codifying human ethics into systems that can be tested and implemented are what politics and economic philosophy are all about. It's ungodly hard and not something that can be taken lightly.
- zuse 8y ago"[T]he inclusion of a drone company executive had raised debate over use of Google’s AI for military applications." Lovely.
- Reelin 8y agoI share your distaste for militarized AI (unless I mistake you?), but if AI are to be used in such applications then competent representation and examination of such use cases by a public ethics body would seem to me to be a good thing.
- swang 8y agoyes if you dislike militarized AI you should discuss it. the woman in question that runs the drone company is ex-military, so i would feel like she would be in favor of militarizing drones (albeit to be fair her drone company currently does not do that) and thus probably shouldn't be on the board in the first place
- Reelin 8y agoWhat? No. The fact that she's ex-military and runs a drone company is precisely why she should be on such a board. If there is no one on the board with the relevant knowledge and experience to competently represent a given use case, then the board will likely be unable to produce results relevant to such use cases. For example, if I form a board to hash out software version control system best practices but actively exclude experts on distributed VCS such as git and mercurial, then the resulting "best practices" are unlikely to prove useful for anyone actually using a DVCS in reality. My point here is that excluding her almost certainly won't actually do anything to prevent the development of militarized AI. Rather, it will simply reduce the likelihood that anything the board puts out has influence on such matters.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 8y agoSo, the idea of "discussing it" is to first exclude everybody who might hold an opinion different from the one you want to arrive at (preferably without even actually asking them - why bother to ask a person if she's for or against military drones if she served in the military so you already know everything about her views from one single factoid?). At which point I'm not sure why indeed waste time on having any council at all - a dozen people that think all the same can be replaced by just one person at 12x more efficiency.
- throwawaysea 8y agoI don't get why Google caves to pressure from internal activism. Only 2000 of 98000 employees signed the letter. And they are themselves a very skewed cohort, unrepresentative of the general population of customers Google has.
- swang 8y agoeh you know that doesn't mean 96000 opposed this though? do you yourself actually care other than the fact that a specific group of people complained?
- throwawaysea 8y agoSure, but it doesn't mean 96000 are in agreement either. So why wouldn't leadership just trust their own judgment and stay their course? That seems not just spineless, but also irresponsible since it means they are willing to discard all prior careful deliberation and research at the drop of a hat. > do you yourself actually care other than the fact that a specific group of people complained? Yes, I want a diverse set of views on such a council, representing multiple areas of the political spectrum - that is, left, moderate, and conservative views rather than just the far-left. There are also a wide range of opinions out there on topics like the use of AI for military purposes or on the modern transgender movement (which is the subject of controversy relating to this council). Only 8% of America are progressives after all (https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/10/large-majorities-dislike-political-correctness/572581/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/10/large-majo...). And all this is still without consideration of the worldviews that exist around the globe, which is important given Google has customers globally.
- smsm42 8y ago> Yes, I want a diverse set of views on such a council, representing multiple areas of the political spectrum You may want it, but a lot of googlers definitely won't. A lot of people on the far left define ideological disagreement as "violence" and would be very vocally attack anybody that holds view they disapprove. And Google management is not invested in this project enough to spend a lot of political capital on it - plus they themselves are probably on the left side, so why would they battle for including somebody who they don't even agree with?
- Reelin 8y ago> “It’s become clear that in the current environment, ATEAC can’t function as we wanted. So we’re ending the council and going back to the drawing board,” The current environment is so overly toxic that I doubt it will be possible for any process that might produce reasonably useful results to be run in an open manner. This is particularly troubling given the number of very plausible potential problems posed by AI in the near-ish future. Unfortunately it also seems unlikely to me that any government regulation that emerges will be at all competent.
- raxxorrax 8y agoI think the questions about ethics is already behind, because most people like to think about artificial general intelligence. The little routines that are separate but together begin to quantity every aspect of out lives? Welcomed with open arms... Privacy rights could help a lot...
- ananth22by7 8y agoI fail to understand. Is “comments” and “views on issues” enough to cause such a stir? People’s sensitivity boggles my mind. Can we not say things without having to walk on eggshells? What kind of unforgiving and judgemental culture are we living in?
- dx87 8y agoIf it makes you feel any better, not everywhere is like that. I work at a mid sized technology consulting company on the east coast, and I've heard multiple managers say that they hate when they have to manage developers from the west coast. My manager told us about a time she got a nasty email from the lead developer of a team because she started an email with "Hey guys" instead of a gender neutral greeting.
- cube2222 8y agoJust saying, guys in the plural is gender neutral. https://www.dictionary.com/browse/guy https://www.dictionary.com/browse/guy
- moultano 8y agoHow many guys have you dated?
- muchachos 8y agoIs it that some would prefer we only speak in gender neutral esperanto? Many languages operate with a defacto indeterminate/masculine combination gender as default. With no harm implied, it presumes that, as with opinions, everyone has an asshole, and you can bet their shit stinks, and that's all you really need to know about anyone, when push comes to shove. Assume all strangers are diseased and untouchable.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoContext matters.
- 8y ago
- mensetmanusman 8y agoThey should just work with local medical ethics boards at Stanford. AI interactions with humans could be considered a class of medical experimentation as a thought experiment. Would have interesting output, and the system already exists...
- everdev 8y agoThis article is a little light on details, but there's a more in depth article here: https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/4/18295933/google-cancels-ai-ethics-board https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/4/18295933/google-... The initial complaint was around comments from 1 of the 8 board members: Kay Coles James The complaint was published Apr. 1 in a Medium post: https://medium.com/@against.transphobia/googlers-against-transphobia-and-hate-b1b0a5dbf76 https://medium.com/@against.transphobia/googlers-against-tra... As evidence the post lists 3 tweets from Kay Cole James: https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108768455141007360 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108768455141007360 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1108365238779498497
- m1el 8y agoThe two last links are the same.
- everdev 8y agoGood catch. Here's the 3rd tweet: https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1100488434500685824 https://twitter.com/KayColesJames/status/1100488434500685824
- Veelox 8y agoI would just like to provide my outlook. tweet 1: Against the Equality Act which would have made sexual orientation and gender identity federally protected classes using standard right wing talking points. tweet 2: Promoting Heritage foundations critique of gender identify at the UN using standard right wing talking points. tweet 3: (linked below) Support for the border wall using standard right wing talking points. It really seems like she is getting hammered for being mainstream conservative. I understand the critiques about her not being technically qualified to understand the AI ethics issues. The idea that if you disagree with current transgender talking point you are not allow to work with Google in a public capacity seems extreme.
- vilhelm_s 8y agoI thought this twitter thread by Kelsey Piper was pretty good: > as I look through her history I am mostly confused why she was chosen in the first place. She doesn't have any background in tech. She doesn't have any prior writing or research related to AI. No background in the other topics that come up - surveillance, data privacy, international security. She's mostly a culture warrior, so no wonder now we're having a culture war. https://twitter.com/KelseyTuoc/status/1113544871292182528 https://twitter.com/KelseyTuoc/status/1113544871292182528
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoAgreed, thank you very much for posting. I don't know who Kelsey Piper is, but I feel it's exceedingly rare when I read something on Twitter that makes me come away feeling like I learned something at a deeper level. I'd encourage other folks to read the whole thread. It's not really mainly about Kay Cole James, more about how the whole panel looked like simply a PR exercise from the start, and I especially liked how she compares it against what OpenAI is doing.
- MBlume 8y agoShe's actually the one who broke the story https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/4/18295933/google-cancels-ai-ethics-board https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/4/4/18295933/google-... Not sure why the Reuters follow-up made the front page instead.
- Symmetry 8y agoKelsey is frankly one of the best communicators I know. I was very glad to hear that she became a journalist because I've been a fan of her Tumblr[1] for years. [1]https://theunitofcaring.tumblr.com/ https://theunitofcaring.tumblr.com/
- Mirioron 8y agoI read her piece on the AlphaStar StarCraft 2 match and it was quite wrong. Even the basic idea that the AI crushed pro gamers while being more limited than humans was completely wrong. Anybody that has played the game even a bit saw that the AI did things that are physically impossible to do for a human. So, I'm not so sure about being one of the best communicators.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- antpls 8y agoI admire what Google is trying to do, but this looks more like an AI lobby to defend Google interests in the process of making laws than an altruism move. I guess it's good enough if it sparks discussion and a debate about ethic more generally
- Proven 8y agoThe idea was poorly conceived to begin with. What should be okay can’t be okay because of the raging SJWs and various people who think non-shareholders ought to have a say how a private company is run. In such an environment modern academic types wouldn’t last and others would be attacked for their opinions. Consider it was supposed to be pro bono work with only an advisory role, why bother?
- dang 8y agoWe merged the comments from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19578963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19578963 into this thread. The previous discussion on the story is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19567290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19567290.
- kenneth 8y ago@dang — came through the Reuters article. Prefer it to the new Vox article, due to being factual and objective, instead of editorialized and showing bias. Vox's article implies Google was in the wrong. Reuters makes no such implications. I have no opinion on the topic at hand, but I am saddened that journalism these days falls far too often into the trap of being lynch-mob. I would've preferred to see the objective and factual article win over the opinion piece.
- tanilama 8y agoAI ethics is a non-issue, self-inflicted hype machine anyway.
- redwood 8y agoThis is a shameful situation. We need to all wake up and take a step back and realize what's happening here: increasingly you can't have a conversation about one issue unless you are a hundred percent pure in the eyes of a frankly self-proclaimed judge jury and executioner for 100% of your other views. I am of the left myself but on a meta-level what we're doing is essentially making it impossible to ever find middle ground on issues if we're unable to talk to folks who we don't agree with on 100% of things. This is a dangerous trend for all of us because it makes it impossible find common ground in an open democracy even if half the country in our eyes have essentially deplorable views, we need to recognize that they feel the same about us and then it's simply not constructive to be unable to find common ground.
- kuzehanka 8y agoYou articulated so well what I've been observing. With the widening political divide, we find ourselves in this weird situation where any decision makers are swarmed with moral outrage attacks unless they're the bastions of politically correct ideology. An increasing number of topics are taboo because merely opening up a discussion around them summons the moral outrage army. Moral outrage has become most effective social manipulation technique, and morality has long ago stopped playing into the equation. The entire point of ethics discussions is to capture the views of the population in a proportionate manner and try to come to a set of mutually positive outcomes. Bonus points for not stomping on minority views. Instead even on HN we have people claiming that their views are the Correct views and the opposition should not even be given a voice. No matter how disagreeable you may find some particular viewpoint, if it happens to be held by a non negligible number of people and you marginalise them, it will eventually result in tremendous blowback. I don't know how we got here, it's a bit scary.
- redwood 8y agoWhat I find especially sad is I am a total believer in political correctness as a general courtesy to people and I think it's the right thing to do. However by simply sharing my upthread viewpoint that we need to be careful about this meta-trend I will probably be lumped in as one of these dark web right wing types even though it couldn't be further from the truth.
- helen___keller 8y agoIn the information age, people perceive authority and trustworthiness differently. This can be both a good thing and a bad thing. What we really need is a solution to the problem of `building diverse expert opinion` that doesn't rely on a panel of flawed humans, because in the 21st century it's obvious the public will refuse to trust said expert panel when it conflicts with their worldview in an entirely unrelated way (eg a members view on climate change). I don't think there's a point fighting against the public outcry on this, as many commenters here seek to do. People don't trust authority the same in the information age, and the world needs to adapt to that.
- dangerface 8y agoIf you want people to believe something unreasonable stop trying to reason with them, this is the result of deplatforming. Resorting to ostracisation is proof that your point of view is unreasonable, which then makes their point of view seem more reasonable as there is no counter. This society seems obsessed with the idea of ostracisation and deplatforming its ultimately a breeding group for fascism and bigotry.