41 ms·
Spotify to Apple: Time to Play Fair
- Nextgrid 8y agoThis is long overdue. I really hope this leads to something. The anticompetitive behaviour described on that website is just the tip of the iceberg. Apple is doing a lot worse behind the scenes. Cellular service on Apple Watch for example - as a carrier you can't just provide service for the Watch - you have to be an "approved" carrier and this means being friends with Apple and selling iPhones among other things (you only provide SIM-only plans and not interested in selling phones? Tough luck.). Same for visual voicemail, etc.
- yaseer 8y agoSeeing this makes me want to get even further away from Apple's ecosystem. 4 years ago, I was all in- Mac, iPad, iPhone. In the last 4 years, I've been driven away by Apple seeming contempt for professional users. Their contempt for other competition is even graver cause for concern.
- kalleboo 8y agoSometimes I think so too. And then I look at the alternative ecosystems. Google? Amazon? Microsoft? Not even tempted...
- novaRom 8y agoWhy do you need ecosystem own by one company? You can have Ubuntu laptop, Android phone, WebOS TV. They all support Spotify and Netflix, you can cast videos from Android phone to your LG TV.
- kalleboo 8y agoI support friends & family with mixed ecosystems. Nothing ever works right. Maybe they just made unlucky choices.
- AimForTheBushes 8y agoThe problem with going that route is that you have to be involved in creating and maintaining a great user experience. I love ubuntu, but it's not without it's quirks that require a certain amount of troubleshooting to overcome.
- bgeeek 8y agoLike others, this is why I could never buy a HomePod and exactly why I like Sonos. I prefer choice.
- ChrisRR 8y agoWhile I was ready to leave a comment about Spotify not playing fair with artists, I have seen Apple's unfair business practices first hand with developing apps and bluetooth devices. Unfortunately they are abusing their power, and are being flat out unfair if you want to develop a bluetooth device or app. If you want to vet apps to ensure a safe environment, that's fine, but these practices go beyond that and are unfair.
- dmitriid 8y ago> Spotify not playing fair with artists Spotify is paying as much as music industry extorts from it. Where does the money go? Ask the big labels that are the ones paying artists.
- tomphoolery 8y agoThe big labels aren't important, they're going to get their money anyway. This hurts the smaller labels, like my label, and countless others who never see a god damn dime from Spotify streaming. Meanwhile, Bandcamp streams the songs for free but they allow you to pay what you want. I've made at least 10x the profit from selling tracks on Bandcamp than I ever did in the streaming world. If Spotify wants to play fair, they need to pay artists more for streams. This site is just another instance of tech bros thinking they know better and meanwhile fucking over everyone else involved.
- simongr3dal 8y agoI agree with you, but maybe bandcamp is just that much more lucrative because people pay more money for each song/play?
- m000 8y agoSo what kind of payment scheme would count as fair-play from your point of view?
- dmitriid 8y ago> If Spotify wants to play fair, they need to pay artists more for streams. How? 90% of their catalog is owned by big labels. They cannot sign up artists directly because it will put them directly into competition with the labels. They are trying to move towards paying artists directly [1], but you have to be eligible (most likely read: not signed up for a label already). This is a legal and financial nitghmare. [1] https://artists.spotify.com/upload https://artists.spotify.com/upload
- owenwil 8y agoThe claims in here are pretty wild, particularly around how Apple has favored its own products: - Apple blocked Spotify from working with Apple Watch - It blocked Spotify from building apps for HomePod - It blocked Spotify from building apps for Siri - It blocks Spotify updates on a regular basis - It blocked Spotify from using a podcasting API after it acquired 2x major podcasting companies I genuinely hope Europe takes this seriously. The issue of the 30% cut alone is enough for further investigation, particularly as Apple now uses that as an advantage to undercut Spotify with Apple Music.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> - Apple blocked Spotify from working with Apple Watch / HomePad But they've blocked every streaming music thing, right? It wasn't a vindictive campaign targetted at Spotify as this timeline is suggesting - no-one got to build streaming music apps for the Watch or HomePod IIRC.
- owenwil 8y agoI believe this is their point: Apple deliberately leaves those features unbuilt in order to give itself a market position that others can't compete with
- darklion 8y agoWhich raises the question: to what degree does a platform owner have a responsibility to support the businesses of others? Rephrased, Spotify seems to think it has a /right/ to run its software on Apple platforms in an identical fashion to Apple's first-party software. Does that mean Apple has an obligation to provide an equivalent technical capacity for literally any software that runs on its devices? An app store? A payment provider? A cloud provider? A health data store? An update mechanism?
- dmitriid 8y agoEDIT: This is no longer true, and doesn't exist in the guidelines [---- obsolete info ----] Yeah, it's a bit of a grey area. However, App Store policies explicitly forbid apps that duplicate iOS and first-party functionality IIRC. Now that Apple has Maps, and Apple Music, and Podcasts, and..., and... should they enforce those rules? [---- obsolete info ----]
- steve1977 8y agoSpotify asking someone else to play fair, ha, that really made my day... I mean, of all companies, Spotify. Their whole business model is built upon not playing fair with content creators.
- hbosch 8y agoWhich streaming service plays the most fair?
- spunker540 8y agoGoing by the latest lawsuit against songwriters (suit filed by google, Spotify, amazon and pandora), it’s probably Apple. https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2019/03/11/spotify-amazon-google-pandora-backlash/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2019/03/11/spotify-amazon-g...
- dmitriid 8y agoYeah. Only it's not against songwriters per se. Quote: "Early last month, the US Copyright Board (CRB) officially ruled in favor of a 44% increase on streaming music royalties for songwriters and publishers." Care to guess how much of those services' content comes from publishers (read: labels), and how much those services already pay to them (hint: as much as 70% of their revenue)? Also, strangely enough, the article quotes everyone except Spotify, Amazon etc. But is happily quoting .... (substitute expletives) various music vultures^W associations who directly benefit from this arrangement (and not the songwriters).
- mastercheif 8y agoNapster, Tidal, then Apple Music. Source: https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2018/12/25/streaming-music-services-pay-2019/ https://www.digitalmusicnews.com/2018/12/25/streaming-music-...
- gnud 8y agoTidal apparently inflated the play numbers of their owners - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17028313 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17028313.
- digianarchist 8y agoPretty annoying as an Apple Watch user to find out only Apple Music is allowed to store music on the device itself.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don't see why other watchOS apps cannot store music on the watch itself. Don't apps get some local storage space? Why can't they use that?
- g105b 8y agoDownloading and Streaming are two different royalty models. Legally, you have to pay more expensive royalties if you download music (referred to as "right to reproduce") rather than stream (right to transmit), so a special type of downloaded file must be used that can't be exported in any way. This is what Apple are prohibiting.
- Nextgrid 8y agoSee https://marco.org/2017/09/24/what-watch-podcast-apps-need https://marco.org/2017/09/24/what-watch-podcast-apps-need.
- filleokus 8y agoAlso see https://marco.org/2018/09/17/overcast5 https://marco.org/2018/09/17/overcast5 > That’s why I nearly jumped for joy during the watchOS 5 announcement in June, when Apple unveiled most of my list of watchOS changes needed to make good podcast apps. In my understanding, an Apple Watch Spotify app would surely be technically feasible as of watchOS 5 (but I might be in the wrong here, I haven't tried myself more than read the available API docs).
- Nextgrid 8y agoSeems like there's still the issue of networking, and I guess if the accusations about the Spotify app rejections are true then I wouldn't be surprised if a Watch app that allows offline playback would get rejected.
- spork12 8y agoHmm, after seeing this I think I should switch to apple music.
- numair 8y agoConsidering all of the dirty tricks and favoritism between Spotify and Facebook, I’m not sure they are the right messengers for this. Oh, and one of the early execs involved with Spotify told me, point blank, “that man needs to die already” in reference to Steve Jobs before his passing. Yeah, I was just as shocked as you might be in reading that. I doubt I was the only one aware of such dark sentiments. The executive team at Apple is probably looking at this website and thinking, “sorry but not sorry.” Making life difficult for Spotify could be seen as a way to carry on Steve’s legacy.
- ianai 8y agoDoesnt really matter where the sentiment comes from if we’re to have an efficient economy. There should be more choices available. Any idea what made the spotify execs wish death on Jobs?
- westpfelia 8y ago'Any idea what made the spotify execs wish death on Jobs?' Does it honestly matter? First of all its probably just a joke. But second of all if we assume he said it the day he died that means the joke was made in 2011 when Spotify was a small company. When chances are the joke was made when they were still just in Sweden.
- Gigablah 8y agoYou’re not really painting Apple in a good light here, either.
- alibarber 8y ago"Making life difficult for Spotify could be seen as a way to carry on Steve’s legacy" - how does this benefit me as an Apple customer?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- numair 8y ago
- ayvdl 8y agoTo whoever is responsible for this page: in the svg files, turn the text into paths, otherwise they look like Arial with terrible kerning. https://i.imgur.com/uLaVwnd.png https://i.imgur.com/uLaVwnd.png
- crossman 8y agoThat was my first thought. The kerning is so bad that some of this is just unreadable
- simongr3dal 8y agoIt's also very bad on the "There's an app for that" image. The other parts of the page are very nice though. The font contrast is fine and the font has a nice weight to it. When they want us to read something they actually still know how to make a proper webpage. And it works fine without JS.
- have_faith 8y agoGlad I searched before commenting, it's the first thing I noticed. Could be a covert tactic to trigger Apple though, more deadly than a computer virus, will probably shut infinite loop down for a day.
- ukyrgf 8y agoAs someone who constantly curses their Android app design, seeing them make such a rookie move was a nice bit of schadenfreude.
- yeldarb 8y agoThe timing of this is interesting in the context of Elizabeth Warren’s recent proposal to forbid platform operators from also being participants on their own platforms. It looks like they’ve filed a complaint with the EU Commission; I wonder if it will become a talking point in US politics as well.
- atestu 8y agoDidn't Elizabeth Warren say Apple shouldn't distribute its own apps in the App Store? Apple Music isn't in the App Store…
- sneak 8y agoFor the purposes of reasoning about this, Apple iOS and Apple's iOS App Store and the iOS Apple Music app are all the same entity, equivalent. It doesn't matter that it's not in the App Store, it ships on the phone alongside the App Store. That's the same as being in the App Store and getting autoinstalled on every device.
- judah 8y agoThis exemplifies some of the reasons proprietary app store lock-in is bad for consumers. Progressive Web Apps -- web apps that are installable and available offline without any app store -- are a viable alternative, and ultimately a threat to Apple's app store racket. It's likely why iOS Safari continues to drag it's feet on PWA support.
- fmo91 8y agoI agree with that. However, what worries me about PWAs is discoverability. How can I find a catalog of available PWAs to download? Is there a way?
- VBprogrammer 8y agoCounter point: the discoverability on all of the app stores I've tried has been pretty terrible. Unless I know the name of an app that I'm trying to install I almost never find what I'm looking for. Most often I search for 'the best app to do X' on Google and then put a name from that into the app store.
- Sharlin 8y agoApp store UX is so horrible I’m sure it is intentional. But I have no idea what they’re trying to achieve. In the case of Apple’s store, I have literally never wanted to browse any of the curated lists of apps, just to open the search view which doesn’t even have the search textbox focused by default!
- cobookman 8y agoGoogle could easily come in here. Note I work for Google but have no knowledge of Googles PWA products or PWA roadmap
- aylmao 8y agoIn theory that's an easy problem: anyone could make an "App Store", especially considering they wouldn't have to host binaries or deliver updates. Something mimicking today's stores would essentially be links you can rate and comment on. Kind of like Reddit, but with a different UI and no direct user submissions.
- localhoat 8y agoThat’s actually the reason why I don’t by a HomePod
- Hamuko 8y agoThe HomePod is a horrible device unless you want Siri in a can. The source selection is just so locked down for whatever reason, so unless you're all in with the Apple ecosystem, you're going to be missing out something.
- sneak 8y agoThe HomePod would be a incredible bargain even if it didn't support Siri at all, and were just an AirPlay compatible speaker. Everyone who complains about Apple Music (myself included) and Siri's uselessness are mostly ignoring the fact that it is the single best compact speaker, audio-wise, shipping today. It's an order of magnitude higher audio quality than everything within 10%-1000% of its price range. It's insanely great. As a speaker. Period.
- Hamuko 8y agoAs a speaker you can't connect to.
- georgespencer 8y agoCan someone help me stop playing the world's smallest violin here? Spotify knowingly built a low margin business living in the pocket of the labels (who force Spotify towards razor thin margins) and Apple/Google (who have, since before Spotify launched, operated app stores for their platforms which are to some extent curated and which are not free market economies). Spotify feels aggrieved that Apple does not allow it to develop software for certain of their hardware lines, such as Homepod or Apple Watch. Why do I have to allow you to develop software for my proprietary hardware, just because it's technically possible? The crucial line in their argument is this: > giving up 30% was too much for us to keep our prices low for our fans. Unfortunately, the end result is that you can no longer upgrade to Premium through the app. How is this Apple's fault and not your fault? Every market place takes a cut from the vendor. Your business not being able to sustain the cost of doing business is nobody's fault except your own. Apple should not be allowed to send push notifications about products or services they prohibit other apps from sending. They shouldn't arbitrarily restrict Spotify from updating the app (virtually no information is provided about what infractions Apple saw, and history suggests that companies are great at presenting one side of the argument and then we find that Apple has a legitimate grievance). They should not be able to charge Spotify more because of their competition. But to suggest that Apple should be forced to allow Siri integration with Spotify? Homepod? Apple Watch? Ridiculous. Monopolies where prices rise are bad news. But look at UK football coverage. On top of my free-to-air channels (£150 p.a. TV licence) I need a Sky Sports subscription (minimum £25 per month) and a BT Sport subscription (which necessitates one of BT Broadband - gross - or Sky) which I think is around £5-£10 per year. The top flight football is fragmented across all three providers. Is that better for me?
- pedroaraujo 8y agoA 30% cut is something that Spotify needs to pay to Apple for every user that subscribes to Spotify through Apple devices. This cost doesn't doesn't exist for PC users, for example. They probably could live with it but I can understand why it feels like an artificial cost that Apple came up with. It would be an understandable cost if they were selling the Spotify App through the App Store and using the actual store infrastructure for supporting Spotify... but they are not. The app is nothing more than a portal to the entire Spotify infrastructure, it doesn't weight anything to Apple. And then we have the subject of the direct competition, Apple Music doesn't need to have their profits cut in 30% because they are owned by Apple itself. And it's even worse if they are using Siri, Homepad and Apple Watch to make Apple Music more appealing in comparison to Spotify.
- nerdwaller 8y agoI’ve been waiting to see Spotify follow Netflix and create their own label, instead of just curated playlists. They’ll otherwise always be at the whim of renegotiations. (Not entirely relevant to the post, but seems like it’s an avenue for them to go to break a little from other players).
- hesk 8y agoI hope this never, ever happens. I love that I can basically listen to any music I like on Spotify. (I know there are exclusivity deals in music streaming but so far it hasn't affected me.) Compare that to the fragmented video streaming marketplace where services try to distinguish themselves with exclusive and/or original content. If you want to watch N shows, you have to subscribe to N different services. And none of the services have a comprehensive movie library (at least where I live).
- bovermyer 8y agoUnpopular opinion: I will never go back to the Apple ecosystem. I like my freedom way too much.
- Doctor_Fegg 8y agoThat's not an "unpopular opinion", that's a personal preference and you're welcome to it.
- novaRom 8y agoWhy unpopular? It's a rational decision. Diversity vs centralization.
- W4ldi 8y agodiversity vs privacy. iOS is still much more secure and has much more protection for the typical user than android.
- novaRom 8y agoWhy do you think that "iOS is still much more secure"? The fact it's a closed source system means only we are not aware of many potential security risks. Apple has really bad reputation because of serious security bugs discovered in Mac OS recently. It might be similar with iOS devices.
- brootstrap 8y agoyeah good for you, many of us never even got into it to begin with. I will say my job got me a macbook pro (after decades of windows usage and hackage) and this bitch is still kicking ass 5 years later. Big ups for the laptop. iPhone, who gives a shit it's a phone. Some people are super into it, i'm like dude i dont fucking care about the screen, the camera, the unlocking your face with a picture. If think all that jazz is worth $800+ be my guest.
- Grustaf 8y agoNot unpopular, just uninteresting.
- supermatt 8y agoJust as Microsoft were stopped from shipping a browser with their OS, vendors should be prevented from shipping an App Store with their OS. You cant move to another platform without losing access to all your "purchases" - there is no free market. They have monopolies within ecosystems they created. They should be FORCED to have an open platform, with users able to access multiple 3rd party storefronts on multiple platforms. They can market themselves as official/curated/whatever they want but the user should have the choice.
- georgespencer 8y agoApple invests billions into R&D, design, manufacture, and UX design for its devices. Your logic would then see them dealing with picking up the pieces for bricked devices, hacked passwords, lost data, viruses, etc. Using an Apple devices is accepting a benevolent dictatorship, and it's a trade off tonnes of users are happy to make.
- mido22 8y agooh, I didn't know that they were giving away the devices for free.
- georgespencer 8y agoThe devices are currently costed for, presumably, a certain volume of support issues which I can only imagine is enormously minimised by the walled garden of the app store.
- iwasakabukiman 8y ago> Vendors should be prevented from shipping an App Store with their OS. So then how would a novice user get apps the first time they boot up their phone? They would have to know where to get apps from. That seems like an easy way for users to end up downloading a bunch of malware because they think it's the official Apple or Google app store when it's just a random website. Having a built in app store has huge advantages in security and usability for the end user.
- chj 8y agoKudos to Spotify! Somebody has to do this, and from the time line posted, they really suffered. Amazon's Kindle team probably should chime in too..
- bpyne 8y agoI've been with Apple Music and Pandora for years. A few months ago my teammates at work convinced me to try Spotify: I love Spotify! Both the content and the UX work for me. While this post represents Spotify's view without having Apple's to contrast it with, it seem eerily similar to the "Browser War" days leading up to Microsoft's admonishment. Apple seems to be the equivalent of a drunkard walking a fine line.
- colmvp 8y agoI would totally buy this fear if iOS was anywhere close to the marketshare that Windows was back in the 90s.
- unethical_ban 8y agoSpotify is platform neutral. All things being equal, that's enough to use them vs. Apple/Google/Amazon anything. Those three serving up things like music or movies are ancillary to their main product. Spotify has a vested interest in being the best music platform. Apple as an interest in selling more phones and computers, which may be benefited by a good in-house music app.
- bo1024 8y agoI wonder if companies like Spotify would be willing to help invest in developing FOSS devices that compete with Apple products. It would be one way to fight back and advance their own business.
- tumetab1 8y agoA more honest title would be - Spotify to Regulator: Please force Apple to be fair™
- gurpreet- 8y agoPersonally, as an app developer, I think Spotify is taking the right stance here. I believe that Apple should take some cuts but not as high as 30%. I believe for some categories like microtransaction based apps Apple should take maybe 5%. Plus, I think that if Apple has a competing service, then it should waive the tax altogether. It's only fair. If the only function of the App Store (or Play Store) is to provide hosting and some quality control then I don't see why apps can't be hosted on a secure website from the vendor - as far as I'm aware, Apple requires you have some sort of website anyway. At least Google allows installing apps without the Play Store, perhaps it's time Apple permitted something similar with its apps? This could solve this whole problem and have other positive side effects such as people being less likely to jailbreak their iPhones.
- hokumguru 8y agoThis opens up a wide host of negative side-effects including the extreme ease of malware. I'd say the #1 value proposition for the App Store, and why most iOS users prefer it, is the guarantee of virus-free programs.
- headsoup 8y agoWhy don't Apple/Google ensure AV/Malware protection is a default app? Why do we depend on Apple/Google protecting us from these big bad apps? If not Apple/Google controlling it directly, I'd imagine there would be a reasonable market for malware/AV providers on mobiles, if not solutions provided by Apple/Google.
- Gorbzel 8y agoA minority of the HN circlejerk doesn’t like the proven security and ease of Apple’s ecosystem, so let’s artificially break that down and replace with inherently flawed anti-malware systems we’re required to use in hopes our phones don’t become botnet nodes with 1hr battery life? That’s so backward it’s insane.
- scarface74 8y agoMore to the point, why do you act as if malware protection has ever been effective and not just a resource drain?
- hellopat 8y agoIs Netflix next? March 25th is right around the corner...
- eicnix 8y agoNetflix already removed iTunes payment[0] to avoid the 30% Apple tax ($256 million in 2018) [0] https://techcrunch.com/2018/12/31/netflix-stops-paying-the-apple-tax-on-its-853m-in-annual-ios-revenue/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/12/31/netflix-stops-paying-the-a...
- jordansmithnz 8y agoSomething to note: competition wise, Spotify doesn’t have a 30% App Store profit handicap compared to Apple Music, it has a 60% one. Spotify doesn’t just forfeit 30% of their App Store revenue, they pay this directly to Apple - so the relative handicap is doubled.
- Grustaf 8y agoNo, Apple doesn’t get all its money from Spotify. For Apple it’s insignificant. And of course it only applie for in app purchases, if you browse to Spotify.com on you iphone and pay there, Apple doesn’t get a penny. Most of these claims are dubious at best. Bunch of cry-babies.
- GeekyBear 8y agoThey have some valid complaints, but "if we use Apple's payment infrastructure, we have to pay them a cut for doing so" isn't one of them. The thing I find to be anticompetitive is that Spotify cannot provide a web link to their own payment processing web page within their app. Apple has long allowed content providers to opt out of using Apple's own payment system (and paying Apple a cut), but without being able to point users to your payment website, this rings hollow. As far as Apple Watch goes, the API to allow for downloading content to local storage and playing it back in the background landed in last year's Watch OS update. Pandora manages this task just fine.
- Grustaf 8y ago> The thing I find to be anticompetitive is that Spotify cannot provide a web link to their own payment processing web page within their app. Well, you probably can’t advertise your apartment on AirBnb and then Link people to your own payment service that bypasses AirBnb’s fee either. It sort of makes sense.
- AsyncAwait 8y ago> They have some valid complaints, but "if we use Apple's payment infrastructure, we have to pay them a cut for doing so" isn't one of them. But Spotify doesn't want to use Apple's infrastructure and is compelled to do so regardless. Spotify is saying that if using Apple payment infrastructure was free, then not allowing other options would not be a problem, but since it's not free, not allowing anything else is a problem, not that Apple charging for the use of its payment infrastructure is a problem in itself.
- GeekyBear 8y agoThey are not compelled to use Apple as their payment processor. They are absolutely free to handle billing their customers on their own website and to turn off the ability to pay through their iOS app altogether. This is, in fact, exactly what Netflix has chosen to do with new users. https://techcrunch.com/2018/12/31/netflix-stops-paying-the-apple-tax-on-its-853m-in-annual-ios-revenue/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/12/31/netflix-stops-paying-the-a... Nothing is stopping Spotify from doing the same thing with new and/or existing users. What they are not free to do is provide a link to their billing web page within their app.
- nubela 8y agoUpvote the fuck out of this. Google does exactly the same thing with Chrome Extensions or Android Apps.
- elagost 8y agoI'm no great fan of Google, but it's a little harder to point the finger at them. F-droid works perfectly well on any Android device, and is a viable alternative to Google Play (for some users). Android .apk files can be installed on any Android device with one switch flipped - and the first time you attempt to install an .apk file, it points you to the setting. Chrome extensions can similarly be packaged and distributed from another source (i.e. GitHub) and are treated as first-class chrome extensions alongside their store-installed counterparts. Apps installed on an iPhone via Xcode (only available for macOS, which is only available on Apple hardware) expire after 7 days and refuse to open unless they are re-deployed. They last for a year if the user pays Apple $99/year for a developer certificate. Google's platforms don't have people spending money as much as iPhone users do, but they are not nearly as locked down or restrictive.
- Zenbit_UX 8y agoI guess now I know where Spotify's priorities have been over the last few years as their Android app regressed. Your war with Apple seems to have distracted you from the one platform you are on good terms with. As a premium subscriber it's very frustrating to not be able to pause music on the lockscreen anymore. Or using the headphone controls. Or why a blocked song keeps being played in discover weekly. Get your act together or you'll lose your android customers to Apple too.
- thekyle 8y ago> As a premium subscriber it's very frustrating to not be able to pause music on the lockscreen anymore. Or using the headphone controls. I just wanted to say that I am also a Spotify Premium subscriber using the Android (Pie) app and I don't have any issues with these two features. I cannot comment on the blocked songs, since I do not use that functionality. Have you checked the forums to see if other users are experiencing the same problems? Maybe there is a specific fix for your device.
- Zenbit_UX 8y agoI'm on android pie and I'm not the only one having these issues, go to the play store listing and sort reviews by latest version, many are complaining about the lack of lock screen and headset controls. The app is extremely unstable on Bluetooth as well, I now leave my expensive wireless earbuds at home because Spotify can't handle more than 10 seconds of continuous wireless playback without cutting out.
- hobbescotch 8y agoHas anyone noticed in CarPlay that Spotify sounds much quieter (and worse) than Apple Music? I have always had a suspicion that this was Apple’s doing, but now it seems much more likely. But if I’m wrong someone please let me know! I’d really love to know what is causing it. It almost makes me want to subscribe to Apple Music just for listening in the car.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoI agree that Spotify is taking the right stance. In their position, working on whatever team is responsible for fighting Apple, I would also do anything in my power to fight. Having said this, Apple can do as they please. They control the hardware, the OS, the App Store, and the user accounts. The same was true of Twitter who effectively squeezed access to their API until one or two desktop clients remained. The only two ways out of this is to legislate a lower rate (through campaigns such as these), or to create a competing platform that lowers costs for its users. Imagine if Spotify offered a lower rate for Android users... Wouldn't that send a very clear message to Apple?
- thomascgalvin 8y ago> Imagine if Spotify offered a lower rate for Android users... Wouldn't that send a very clear message to Apple? I believe this is also against Apple's Terms of Service. IIRC, they have a "most favored nation" clause which prohibits you from offering a lower price on a competing platform.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoI was just looking for this in the App Store review guidelines and I couldn't find it. https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/
- paulgb 8y agoAnother piece of evidence: on the site, on June 2014, they mention raising the price to 13 Euro to make up for the 30% charge. I don't think they raised the price for web subscriptions at that time.
- ric2b 8y ago1. "Subscriptions must work on all of the user’s devices where the app is available. Learn more about sharing a subscription across your apps." 2. "You must not directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase, and your general communications about other purchasing methods must not discourage use of in-app purchase." I think this implies that the subscription must be the same for all devices and you can't treat iOS differently. Pretty sure having a lower price if you subscribe on Android would violate that second clause.
- su8898 8y agoSlightly off-topic: I find it intriguing that Spotify keeps on calling their users as 'fans' instead of users or customers!
- Dirlewanger 8y agoSlimy and disingenuous corporate PR speak is everywhere. They probably have something equally repulsive for their employees.
- maaaats 8y agoWhy the hate? Many communities have nicknames for the users. HNers, redditors, slashdotters, imgurians.
- coldtea 8y agoKnowing how crap Spotify app is (an Electron monstrocity on the desktop) that's for the best.
- xxpor 8y agoGiven that electron monstrosity allows them to have a Linux client, Spotify will always have my support over Apple Music
- duski 8y agoexcept its not electron and it doesnt hog half as much as itunes
- coldtea 8y agoWell, Spotify it's around 2-3% CPU at rest. iTunes is 0.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dddddaviddddd 8y agoNice title given Apple's FairPlay DRM.
- iambateman 8y agoJust because Apple can do as they please, doesn't mean they ought to be allowed to. Antitrust is a useful tool for when players end up controlling monopolies and using them in anti-competitive ways.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoAntitrust would not apply here as Apple's share of the smartphone market is less than monopolistic. There is a stronger case against Amazon for selling Amazon-branded, well-moving products like batteries and diapers, even though they don't stifle the other brands.
- jcranmer 8y ago> Antitrust would not apply here as Apple's share of the smartphone market is less than monopolistic. Having had to take antitrust training at my company in the past few weeks, I can say that you are very mistaken if you think antitrust only kicks in when the company is a monopoly.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoCan you elaborate on why I am mistaken?
- jcranmer 8y agoAntitrust covers in general anticompetitive practices, and has done so since the original Sherman Antitrust Act. So, for example, colluding with another business to fix prices is covered under antitrust, even if the sum of the businesses concerned do not constitute a monopolistic power in the industry. The other common category is the various rules around the preference of a company's other product lines over competitors--the line between "legal" and "illegal" is a little more blurry here. You can fall afoul of these conditions if you have "sufficient market power", which is a substantially broader claim than "monopoly power." I don't think there's any lawyer that would try to claim that Apple doesn't have "market power"--note that the smartphone market, from an OS perspective, is basically a duopoly.
- bad_user 8y agoJust because Apple can currently do this shit legally, doesn't mean that they should. Software platforms are marketplaces and company behind such platforms yield great power, even if technically speaking they aren't yet a monopoly. Hardware devices should not be legally allowed to be locked down in the way that Apple devices are. Not sure how many people remember, but Microsoft eventually being forced to provide choice in browsers was a great outcome and allowed Firefox and Chrome to flourish. Yes, Microsoft was at that time a monopoly, whereas Apple right now isn't, but Apple has the potential to be a monopoly. They are after all the richest software company in the world. Apple succeeded where Microsoft failed, they normalized “trusted computing”, which brought everything we feared. I very much prefer EU's consumer protectionism in these regards and I'm hoping they'll do something about walled gardens such as Apple's.
- gumby 8y agoYou can already write web apps (which can be pretty sophisticated these days) and users can even “install” them right on their home screen. This capability has been there since the original iphone though the power available to web apps has grown enormously. Unfortunately not every app can work his way, e.g. access to PII-sensitive sensors. But nothing stops Spotify from doing this — it’s how Spotify works on a laptop anyway.
- znpy 8y agoMe to Spotify: it's time to start looking closely Purism's PureOs and Librem 5. It has the potential to really be the one true alternative runtime that can get mass adoption.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sneak 8y agoIt's time to trot out Cory Doctorow's talk on DRM to Microsoft (2004): https://craphound.com/msftdrm.txt https://craphound.com/msftdrm.txt > "Sony didn't get permission. Neither should you. Go build the record player that can play everyone's records." I remember when Apple's M.O. was to build insanely great hardware, and make money selling that hardware. It was the Other Guys who would do shady things like bundle browsers with OSes and do things explicitly against users' preferences to promote their own platform and ecosystem. Apple never really started with that until the iPhone. Now they do all of this ecosystem-lock-in stuff because they're not solely interested in revenue from hardware sales now. It's lame and scummy and un-Apple. I'd love to be able to use the Google Assistant and Signal Messenger on my Apple Watch, and use Spotify on my HomePod, and use iMessage on my Pixelbook. Real shame that I pay top dollar for hardware and that I can't.
- mediocrejoker 8y agoIt's hard to have much sympathy when you know that this was written by the marketing department of a company with a $30bn market cap. This looks to me like a blatant attempt to latch on to a perceived popular sentiment that Spotify thinks they can use to to have the government give them a big advantage that they didn't have before. Call me cynical but it's hard to see this as anything but self serving.
- mcrae 8y agoSure, but if another company with a $1T mkt cap is abusing it's market position to the detriment of a $30B company, wouldn't you want to hear about it? After all, if they treat Spotify this way, how do you think they'll treat your app in the future if it happens to compete with them in someway?
- alkibiades 8y agosure but it’s 30bn vs apples almost trillion in market cap
- calcsam 8y agoIt's interesting how this appears just after Elizabeth Warren's call to break up the big tech companies. I don't agree with Warren's stance, but hats off to Spotify for nice PR campaign timing.
- lisperforlife 8y agoI think we should break the monopoly of app store and play store. Platforms should enable other stores to play well along with their stores. It is ridiculous at this day and age to go through a process like app store / play store approval after you've spent so much money building an app. The web works fine without a single party deciding what should or should not be on it. We should treat app store as a service for distributing apps and providing services to update and charge people for those services. It should be distinct from the platform itself. The platform should stick with publishing a spec for how an executable should be and standards to verify the veracity of the distribution with certificates and digital signatures. I think if there is a region that can enforce this change, it will be the EU and the rest of the world will follow.
- talkingtab 8y agoI don't think this is about Spotify versus Apple - its about Apple versus its customers. I want to be able to choose what music service I want, and I want the price to be competitive. And not just music. You just have to wonder what's up with Apple.
- mediocrejoker 8y agoWhy not switch to Android?
- coldacid 8y agoIt's about Apple and anyone they consider a (potential or active) competitor. As far as customers come into it, Apple wants to be able to milk them dry and keep them from using anyone who might provide a similar or better service than their own, as well as take over any profitable channels they don't already have support for. It's 1990s Microsoft on a mobile phone.
- paulgb 8y agoThis is why I think the "if you're not the customer you're the product" mantra is overly simplistic. In this case, you can still pay $1000 for a phone, and it only makes you a more valuable product for Apple to sell to its (developer) customers.
- nevir 8y agoApple did the same thing to Kindle for iPhone back when it launched. We submitted the original version to Apple with a fully functioning store built into it—and were then stuck in submission limbo. Two weeks later, Apple announces their intent to build in-app purchasing. The kicker: Apple wanted a 30% cut of every book sold on the store …and at the same time, had negotiated with book publishers that the publishers MUST sell all books at a 30% margin on ALL stores if they want to sell their books via Apple's own ebook store. Aka we couldn't sell books at an increased cost, even if we wanted to. We would have had to take a loss on every purchase. In the end, we had to remove all of the store functionality from the app, and weren't even allowed to link people directly to the web store for purchasing (or even instructions for purchasing).
- elagost 8y agoMy dad has had iPads since the first one, and it is still jarring for him to not be able to just click a "store" button in the Kindle app. (I believe it used to have a webview for the store built-in; I do not use the Kindle app) He was very confused when it disappeared. I imagine most users feel this way. I had to coach my mom to sign up for Pandora on the website so she saved a couple bucks a month, and it was baffling to her why it costed more in the app.
- nevir 8y agoYeah, it was supremely frustrating for us. The original store experience was fully native, and still a far better experience than what the app has today :(
- giovannibajo1 8y agoAgreed. I am very aware of Apple policies on this regard and anything discussed in this thread, but still two weeks ago I wandered around in the Amazon app looking for 10 minutes on how to buy a book in Kindle version... then I realized I had to switch to Safari for that. This is confusing for users.
- sinnoh 8y agoboy, that kind of "deep regulation" into UX design from a single arbitrary company should be illegal regardless. people bought apple hardware and the operating system, not voted them the unilateral governing body on consumer choice in that platform. one should not be taken to imply the other.
- halfjew22 8y agoThis all seems well and good. However, I'd like to point out something that doesn't sit well with me. Spotify uses this same kind of extraction mechanism on the artists that use its platform. The complaint loop is complete. We have artists complaining about artist 'hosting' companies complaining about application hosting companies. I believe the solution lies in different, non-zero sum economics, but haven't been able to think of anything for music. I do, however, have some pretty cool ideas for longer form text and video content.
- bytesmith 8y agoCustomer to Spotify: support Siri Shortcuts and I will switch immediately. https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/iOS-Siri-Shortcuts-Support/idi-p/4569462 https://community.spotify.com/t5/Live-Ideas/iOS-Siri-Shortcu...
- sascha_sl 8y agoYou had me, until the point where you turned off libspotify.
- UpperBodyEimi 8y agoWhat am I missing here? Why can Spotify not redirect users to subscribe on their own website? I'm pretty sure I signed up on Spotifys website, then logged into my iPhone. Apple definitely don't get 30% of that subscription fee.
- coldacid 8y agoBecause Apple rejects their app whenever they try something like that, or even have phrasing suggesting that users do so without actually redirecting themselves.
- alex_duf 8y ago>Why can Spotify not redirect users to subscribe on their own website? Because it's forbidden by apple to inform your user that it's cheaper on the website.
- UpperBodyEimi 8y agoIs this in their ToS or is this just hearsay?
- thekyle 8y agoAccording to the website, the debate is that Apple does not currently allow apps to do what you are describing. A few quotes from the timeline: > Apple now prohibits buttons or links to any other external ways to pay. > While we haven’t been able to include any buttons or external links to pages containing product info, discounts, promotions, etc. (even if they don’t link directly to a payment system!) since Feb. 2011
- UpperBodyEimi 8y agoThanks! URLs blocked on my network for now.
- fb03 8y agoLet's be fair then: Phones now have the same level of processing power as portable computers. We shouldn't be obligated to only run applications that are siphoned thru a third party "trusted clearinghouse", be it the smartphone or the operating system vendor. If I want more safety or I am not a Power User, I can flick a switch on the device to allow that binding behavior to happen. Heck, they are giving me the 'free service' of taking care of app security for me, I could even pay for that if I am serious about having my apps checked and stuff. Phones are computers. You own the hardware, you should be able to install whatever you want. Always. Is the argument about protecting the masses of non-tech people? Great, make it an opt-out. And still: There ought to be someone keeping tabs on that big brother (gov regulations? agencies) or else shady behavior can ensue as well.
- sneak 8y ago> Phones now have the same level of processing power as portable computers. We shouldn't be obligated to only run applications that are siphoned thru a third party "trusted clearinghouse", be it the smartphone or the operating system vendor. I pay a lot of money for iPad Pros and Google Pixelbooks for precisely this functionality. When the user can run anything they want, the result is the unsafe landscape of malware we see on common desktop OSes.
- effingwewt 8y agoAs OP mentioned, that could be enabled with a toggle. An example of this all being for the benefit of walled gardens, take rooting. Obviously if a user is going through the trouble to attain true ownership of their phone and os, they are doing so because they want to be in control. Phone carriers openly fight this at every turn because they want us to be forced to use their BS apps, known as bloatware, and prevent users from no longer seeing ads. This is all about money. Microsoft is trying hard to do the same on desktop now with all their in-os ads. Protecting users is the single most bullshit line ever and they all use it.
- 0x262d 8y agohard to feel bad for spotify, another publicly traded company maximizing profit and posing as a person, but it does highlight the downsides of rent-seeking behavior. it's almost like private markets are bad and always lead to this sort of bs in every single real world case.
- bartoszhernas 8y agohttps://freeyourmusic.com/blog/spotify-trying-to-lockin-users/ https://freeyourmusic.com/blog/spotify-trying-to-lockin-user... Spotify is not the angel here, as it's using same tricks to block free choice and lock in users heavily.
- KangLi 8y agoRegardless of Spotify or not, Apple has become a state of the art bloodsucker while delivering flat out products. Making the switch to Android has never been more convenient.
- nojvek 8y agoYes please. EU commission, please fine the shit out of Apple and give them a reality check that they infact are a bully. I have given all hope on the US govt doing anything to help the average joe. It’s a govt lobbied and paid for by corporations.
- shiven 8y agoIt’s thanks to crap like this & the total lack of original innovation on the iPhone platform, that I am seriously considering the Samsung S10, after 8 years of exclusive iPhone use. Post-Jobs Apple is over & done for. They are in “rent collection” mode now. So long & thanks for all the fun. It was good while it lasted.
- Taylor_OD 8y agoAs Apple hardware sales decline they are desperately trying to build other services to make up for that lost revenue.
- ringaroll 8y agoI really hope Apple dies and burns. They have good PR but thats it. They lie and deceit developers just like Google. Bait and Switch. There should be government regulation of Apple, Facebook and Google. These corps are just too big and control our democracy. Apple is starving innovation by deliberately not supporting many thing on the Safari iOS browser and prevents competition illegally by restricting 3rd party browser engines. Taking a 30% rent on purchases is blatant theft. More people need to speak out. #AppleRentSeeker Because Apple is unable to increase revenues, it's now trying to increase by using uncompetitive tactics and illegal restriction of competition.
- thanatos_dem 8y agoWhat does iOS Safari not support? It uses WebKit, so more or less full technical/js support, it has ad blockers, tracking prevention, a built in password manager that uses the iOS keychain... not sure what else I’d really want for web browsing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sirmike_ 8y agoIts been a super long time since I have looked into developing on the iOS side -- are there restrictions on Safari which would prevent Spotify from going to an all PWA type deployment for iOS and peacing out from the App Store? What would the API for Safari restrictions be to overcome? Thanks in advance.
- pier25 8y agoAFAIK Safari has great support for PWAs these days except for not being able to show a native banner that allows the user to install the PWA on the home screen.
- tmsh 8y agoWhat will be the real innovation if the platforms are more open? I'm looking forward to the Chrome dev tools and v8 that comes out of this. Microsoft/IE antitrust led to a retraction in unhealthy Microsoft dominance (see IE6) and a rise in Firefox and eventually Chrome. Rise in Chrome led v8, node and better dev tooling (and by extension a richer JS ecosystem and maybe things like ClojureScript tangentially). When the platforms monopolist/duopolists get retracted that will pave the way probably for more open source apps in the app stores and maybe a few other large corporations (like Google did for Chrome) dominating. Maybe better cross-platform tooling will come out of this? It's fun to think of what this will allow.
- tlogan 8y agoAll companies do this. Back in days, even Evernote started doing that (with disguise "API bandwidth limits"). Nowadays, Evernote is irrelevant, so nobody complains. The only difference here it that Apple's customers have $$, so everybody wants to be on their platform and everybody make noise. And these politicians are talking on both side of their mouth: first they say how "3rd-party apps are stealing data" so platform must to have more checks when adding an app on their store. And when platform tries to enforce the rules they complain how platform needs to be "more open".
- sbt 8y agoAbout time.
- kaelig 8y agoThis is exactly why I moved from the iPhone to an Android phone about a year ago: I couldn't use Siri to play things on Spotify – that's pretty much the only thing that really bugged me about iOS.
- ringaroll 8y agoWell I want to make a startup but dont want to to get wrecked by Facebook or Google or Apple. I guess I'll wait until lawmakers break them. Or else they dont deserve innovation.
- wut42 8y agoA bit off-topic but since this page is a call to the European Comission, it would have been nice to have a GDPR compliant cookie notice.
- headmelted 8y agoUtterly disagree. The problem isn't the amount of the Apple tax, and it buries the lead to make it about that. The contention here is that applying rules like this arbitrarily in a way that at least appears to favour your own products over your rivals is an abuse of your position. If the commission rules in Spotify's favour (which I would think is likely, given the dim view they've taken of such matters previously), then I'd be astonished if Spotify doesn't file lawsuits in the US under the Sherman Act. In any case, having this fight happen, and in public, can only be good for indie developers if it forces Apple to apply it's rules arbitrarily.
- volandovengo 8y agoFor a long time I've been confused about the rules of monopolies. Microsoft got into a lot of trouble when they bundled IE into Windows so much so that the US threatened heavily to break up the company. Fast forward a decade later and apple, google and amazon bundle a crazy amount of unrelated services into their platforms without the regulators raising an eyebrow...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Angostura 8y agoAt that time Microsoft completely dominated desktop operating systems to the extent that it was an effective monopoly. It them attempted to leverage that position to try and squash other browser makers. I agree that Apple is trying to squash Spotify, but I don't believe it doesn't have an effective monopoly on mobile phones.
- berbec 8y agoMicrosoft DID squash other browsers. Netscape died and the code lived on, but the profitable company was no more.
- number_six 8y agoIsn't their argument about the Apple Store and being able to put their product into the Apple Ecosystem? I didn't read any of it as saying they have a monopoly on phones.
- whalesalad 8y agoAnecdotally spotlight has had a hard time finding the Spotify app for me recently. (I use spotlight like an app launcher.) I chalked it off to some mojave bug with my new laptop but a tiny part of me was thinking conspiracy.
- EvagohP5 8y agomy god, so cringy, what a bunch of soyboys really.
- pier25 8y agoAs a user, I much prefer the Android model. For example I can buy and browse Kindle or Audible books directly in the app. I don't use Spotify but I imagine it's a similar experience. Apple policies do not really benefit anyone. Kindle iOS users will simply open Safari to buy their books, making their experience worse. Either Apple should really remain objective and not have horses in the App Store race, or follow the same rules on its own apps that they impose on others, or change the rules to benefit everyone (including the users).
- Mindwipe 8y agoIn all seriousness, when people say "iPads are better tablets because of software compared to Android tablets" I really do raise an eyebrow. If your use case for a tablet is to read books or comics (which I suspect it is for many people! A lot!), then the iPad is terrible because of this specific limitation, and Android tablets are much easier to use. Shame Google seems hellbent on destroying them - the Pixel C really was a very, very nice comic reading tablet when it wasn't suffering hardware failures.
- pier25 8y agoI'd say 40% of my iPad Pro use is for reading (Kindle/Google Books) or using Comixcology.
- laythea 8y agoNo. No. No. Not another website that demands I zoom and scroll just to read text. I'm not reading. Who's with me!?
- qrohlf 8y agoInteresting tidbit: "FairPlay" was the name of apple's proprietary iTunes DRM technology that was eventually mostly phased out due to the aftermath of Steve Jobs' open letter [1]. I wonder if the naming parallel is intentional? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay#Steve_Jobs'_%22Thoughts_on_Music%22_open_letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FairPlay#Steve_Jobs'_%22Though...
- mises 8y agoSomeone just posted this, about Spotify trying to lock in users: https://freeyourmusic.com/blog/spotify-trying-to-lockin-users/ https://freeyourmusic.com/blog/spotify-trying-to-lockin-user... Spotify isn't really complaining about "unfairness". Business complaining are really just them trying to mobilize customer outrage to force a better deal for them. Apple created an ecosystem, and is allowed to charge what they want for it. Other vendors charge markups: retail, a business with notoriously low profit margins, charges about 15% markup. This is because price elasticity of groceries is exceedingly high: customers have extensive choice and it's not an immediate/emergency good. Restaurants charge about 60%. Clothing can be 300%, high fashion more. But nobody complains about that. We need to stop thinking of the app store as a "tax" and more as a retail outlet, because it is just a digital retailer. The 30% effectively amounts to a markup. > [Apple] frequently decides to interpret (and re-interpret) them [App Store rules] This is a hard line for Apple to walk. Other platforms have issues with this too, and can't always come to one perfect interpretation. See some of the issues with Youtube policing pedophilia recently and having to take some drastic (and very unpopular) steps. What was okay previously isn't now. On Apple's payment system: they run a walled garden. Though there are disadvantages to this, there are also advantages to it. The case could be made that this has massive security benefits (iOS malware, anyone?) and can also keep users from having their payment details tricked out of them by forcing them through one channel. Think it wouldn't happen? An app tried to trick iPhone users into scanning their fingerprint to authorize a large Apple Pay charge to the scammer. It could be worse without the security. > Siri still won’t talk to us today Need some more technical detail here, but why is the onus on Apple to do the work to integrate with your platform the way you want to do it? Apple does provide SiriKit: https://developer.apple.com/sirikit/ https://developer.apple.com/sirikit/ > [they] won’t work with us to develop an app for it [the Apple Watch] Again, why should Apple have to work with you? What you're effectively looking for is a support contract. Pandora managed it. > Apple Music doesn’t have to pay the 30% IAP charge Yes, it's called vertical integration and there are huge benefits to it. It's been one of Apple's core business practices from day one. They control huge parts of their supply chain, even developing their own phone chips (which may well end up as desktop-grade CPUs and could provide a huge consumer benefit in terms of microarchitectural advancement). This isn't unfair. Undercutting is not unfair. App store tightening is of course designed to protect Apple's revenue stream. They've seen other developers stop using IAP, and want to ensure the App Store remains dominant. Not unfair. It's Apple's right to say what they sell and don't sell on their store. > "level playing field" See the article linked at the top of this reply. Spotify is trying to keep users in its platform by preventing playlist transfer (and even prohibiting apps that do it for them, so not an issue of just not developing the functionality). That's at least as anti-consumer. Business do this sort of stuff all the time, and Spotify is more committed to its revenue than to "fairness". Spotify is just salty because they didn't get the deal they wanted and because Apple is trying to push users toward its products over Spotifys. Not really nice of Apple, but not "unfair".
- aranw 8y agoThis reminds of the whole browser war situation with Microsoft many years ago which Microsoft was forced to allow other browsers. It, however, feels different from Apple who seem to be able to just get away with this behaviour unchallenged.
- caprese 8y agoEuropean Commission is the only antitrust regulator with teeth, I'm glad that single market area is coming into its own. The regulator for the 21st century that corporations actually listen to. Without them, we would be here debating how this doesn't satisfy antitrust laws to the American standard, which would be beyond the point but a typical discussion. Going to take another 50 years before that succumbs to regulatory capture.
- mises 8y ago> We – and our partners – use cookies to deliver our services and to show you ads based on your interests. Seriously? Y'all want to sniff/sell my data and run ads on a website that's supposed to "raise awareness" about "consumer unfairness"? Jerk move. Yeah it's all technically legal, but it's definitely tacky. You're making it rather hard to sympathize with you.
- vnorilo 8y agoIsn't it a little ironic that Spotify complains about Apple's cut while their entire business model is exactly the same? If anything, they are less fair to artists than Apple is to devs.
- simonh 8y agoFunny that Spotify fails to mention that, for app subscriptions, after a year Apple's cut drops to 15%.
- draw_down 8y agoI am not sure what is meant by "Apple's behavior" on this page, but I am sure that it's not a good sign that Spotify made this. I'm not disagreeing with them- there is plenty to question about how Apple treats companies who use its platform, even though I'm not sure what their beef is (nor do they go out of their way to tell me). But if things were going well I doubt they would resort to making something like this.
- rchaud 8y agoIt would be nice if the platform-independent music sites (Spotify, Tidal, Beatport, Bandcamp, etc) joined together to fund a web framework for music streaming that didn't require the same level of system access as a native app. That would allow them to escape the App Store tax, and the headaches related to Apple's review process, deployment issues, etc. Right now, Apple owns the moat. The fairness Spotify is asking for requires people to give up money on the table. Because of that, a well-intentioned public awareness campaign is no substitute for legal action. PS - I'd love it if more news websites were structured like the simple timeline on this site. I'd like to see how the situation developed over time, rather than seeing a stream of articles littered with links to past stories. Just give me one timeline I can scroll through, and I'll decide which of the linked stories I want to click on.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoI'm pretty sure that such a web framework exists. There's <audio> element and web audio JS API. https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Element/audio https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Element/au... https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_Audio_API https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Web_Audio_A...
- bithavoc 8y agoI forgot my Apple Music membership was active, I just canceled it.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoApple's actions are not good and will eventually discourage companies from developing anything more than marketing apps for the App Store. You don't want a big piece of your revenue stream dependent on Apple app sales and Tim Cook's whim. Maybe this is why there are so many Cr-Apps and fewer and fewer "killer apps" anymore.
- pje 8y agoThe solution here is for the US to start enforcing anti-trust laws again. I can't imagine a clearer example of uncompetitive business practices and platform monopolization than the App Store.
- humbfool2 8y agoThey also posted a Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=&v=l8SShgWqJvg https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=&v=l8SShgWqJvg
- sandov 8y agoAsking the European commission to impose regulations is morally worse than taking advantage of your market position and consumers' ignorance.
- JangoSteve 8y agoFor what it's worth, I don't think Spotify is asking the European commission to impose regulations, but rather asking them to enforce the regulations they already have.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- johnnydoe9 8y agoI hope the EU takes this seriously just like they did with Microsoft. They shouldn't charge the 30% if they have a competing product and are undercutting it.
- demuch 8y agoI just don't understand why most people think Apple don't have a monopoly market position. Of course Apple is the monopoly on the App Service market ([1] App store generated 93 more revenue than google play in Q3). We are talking about app service rather than the phone units sold. [1] https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/11/app-store-generated-93-more-revenue-than-google-play-in-q3/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/11/app-store-generated-93-mor...
- 8f7tjdsk9o8 8y agoIt's one things to compare app sales from one market to another, but the broader issue is that Apple maintains a monopoly on the store itself. There is no Google Play store on iPhone. And... listening to SCOTUS oral arguments recently, that sounds like it will be changing soon.
- joshstrange 8y agoWow... Spotify had an opportunity to make a good case and then threw it all away because they got greedy. A company not providing you and API you want does not equate to them blocking you. FULL STOP. Spotify had some decent arguments (re: 30%, IAP, payment) but it fell 100% flat when they started giving equal importance to things that were not targeted at them. The lack of music API's on homepod, watch, iPhone are not some direct slight against Spotify and to pretend they are only shows Spotify's inflated view of themselves. Put simply: NOT EVERYTHING IS ABOUT YOU. Spotify is twisting the truth to it's breaking point in this post with just enough truth sprinkled around that you might not notice the bullshit.
- writepub 8y agoThe complaint is that Apple is withholding certain APIs from public access, though nothing technical prevents it from doing so, other than anti-trust issues. There is certainly truth to that! When Apple is both an app publisher, and API publisher, these anti trust issues are bound to pop up
- joshstrange 8y ago> The complaint is that Apple is withholding certain APIs from public access, though nothing technical prevents it from doing so And once Spotify proves that then maybe we can have a discussion. There is no data to support that claim. I can think of a number of reasons why they weren't ready to provide audio API's like battery reasons. Also Apple has released audio API's both before Apple Music (iPhone) and after (Watch). Spotify is just mad they didn't get them sooner.
- writepub 8y agoI don't think this goes to trial, but it's trivial to prove unfair API advantages to the manufacturer. Either provide the same API to others, or concede to anti-competitive charges. NO ONE is willing to give Apple the benefit of doubt, after they have unilaterally, retroactively mucked with app store rules to kill competition. The most egrageous case was with Steam, whose game streaming app was found to be non compliant after apple retroactively applied change of policy.
- dman 8y agoSomeone - please commoditize mobile phone hardware. I want to be able to get a phone and assemble my on stack on it. Without any playstores / subscription services / location tracking / snooping built in.
- monsieurdoc 8y agoMeanwhile, Spotify is still a rip-off for artists http://www.timetoplayfair.art http://www.timetoplayfair.art
- jordache 8y agoApple needs to be broken up. Warren go it right.
- intellix 8y agoWhen I'm on Spotify on macOS and press play on my keyboard, it always opens up iTunes instead. Am sick of this second party support for everything especially when the Apple versions are so dire
- Ardon 8y agoI had a similar frustration where the media keys would control videos in Safari instead of my music. This little app lets you go back to the old behavior, or set a priority: http://milgra.com/mac-media-key-forwarder.html http://milgra.com/mac-media-key-forwarder.html
- dclusin 8y agoGiven the increasing importance of smart phones in our lives it seems like we would benefit by having a modern day equivalent of the Carterfone decision[1] for smartphones. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carterfone
- berbec 8y agoI hate to say this, but one of my main gripes against Apple - the unfair advantage they have in pricing by not having to "pay themselves" 30% - has lost some strength in my mind. Every grocery store takes a cut of every item sold on the store. The store owner determines the percentage. Just like Apple. Grocery stores make similar/nearly identical products to the third-party merchandise they sell. Just like Apple. Grocery stores can routinely undercut the pricing of third-parties due to not needing to "pay themselves". Just like Apple. Damn. I really wanted to hate EvilBigTech for this. The rest of Spotify's points I have no issue, but this one doesn't hold as much water for me anymore.
- miloignis 8y agoI think the fact that Apple prevented them from using payment methods that didn't go through them makes it significantly worse though - to carry the analogy (perhaps to far) the grocery store prevents the packaging of the products it carries from mentioning the website where you can order other products or something.
- y7 8y agoI'm glad that Spotify is taking this stance. Apple and Google Play together have an effective monopoly on the mobile device app market, which is worth about 70 bln USD per year. Cost of entry and network effects make it essentially impossible to have new competing app stores, so barring new regulations the market will remain as un-free as it is. It's therefore about time for regulators to step in if we want to promote innovation in the app market that doesn't necessary align with the self-interests of Apple and Google, so I'm glad a relatively well-known company such as Spotify is pushing for this.
- Timothee 8y agoSide note but talking about their users/customers as "our fans" is super strange.
- johnnycab 8y agoThis is part of a bigger war to maximise the duopoly of music and video streaming, perhaps analogous to the triple/quad play in telecoms. It seems that Spotify's latest salvo is timed to capitalise on the rumoured event[1] and maybe even influenced by previous decision by Netflix to breakaway[2] from the two main revenue generating platforms (Android & iOS). Whether or not it will be beneficial to their business model(s) long term - only time will tell. Apple needs a new goose and a contender in the ring to keep institutional investors happy, at least until a new market strategy[3] is cemented and next round of R&D, technological advancements, tooling etc. take effect and come to fruition; especially considering the recent battery recalls[4] and lower than expected demand for flagship products, So, I would assume they have carried out some due diligence to avoid any punitive measures by the EU or invite excessive regulation. Nonetheless, it might turn out to be a pyrrhic victory for Spotify, despite a ruling in favour of an app with some clout in a dominant ecosystem. For example, Amazon has decided to fight[5] Google/Apple on many occasions, with no obvious benefits. Microsoft has largely capitulated to Amazon & Google on some of their efforts e.g. Cortana v Alexa, Edge v Chrome.. [1]https://www.macworld.co.uk/news/apple/apple-streaming-service-3610603/ https://www.macworld.co.uk/news/apple/apple-streaming-servic... [2]https://bgr.com/2018/08/23/netflix-subscription-payment-change-iphone-matters/ https://bgr.com/2018/08/23/netflix-subscription-payment-chan... [3]https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-must-reverse-angela-ahrendts-luxury-brand-strategy-2019-2?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-must-reverse-angela-ah... [4]https://www.theverge.com/2019/1/2/18165866/apple-iphone-sales-cheap-battery-replacement https://www.theverge.com/2019/1/2/18165866/apple-iphone-sale... [5]https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/26/16371292/google-youtube-amazon-echo-show https://www.theverge.com/2017/9/26/16371292/google-youtube-a...
- qwerty456127 8y agoWhen I've first read about the 30% apps tax I couldn't believe my eyes. That's insane. It would be Ok if the actual devices were at least 10 times more cheap and Apple was making the actual profits relying on apps taxation only but given how much iPhones cost it's ridiculous.
- chairmanmow 8y agoSpotify is a shady company that doesn't pay artists as well as Apple, it doesn't have a sustainable business model and now that they're public they're hiring PR firms to make timetoplayfair.com and spam HN because they're accountable to investors. Spotify doesn't play fair with intellectual property, they were founded by a guy than ran an ad supported torrent company and got enough early market share to go public, but it's not sustainable. Now they expect less of a cut to gain market share because they didn't build something sustainable, unique or based upon a higher standard of ethics. No tears to be shed for this company's standard of fairness. Plus the product has other issues which I noted when I was a customer but were ignored as this company is simply interested in the bottom line; so I cancelled my account, which was not easy.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- alanz1223 8y agoAs an extension, not only is Apple guilty of the absurd 30% tax on IAP, Google does it too and I think its very unfair that you cannot choose your own payment processor. Apple and Google should be viewed as an oligarchy of some sort being that they control almost all of the mobile market. The fact that there is almost no oversight to their business practices and their ability to literally take any app off the market or charge whatever processing fee they want is ridiculous. Its not like any company can also just set out to build their own app store since Google and specially Apple would never allow them to compete. I could go on this topic for days since I just know how much mobile developers are so vulnerable and powerless against the app stores.
- adontz 8y agoCannot post link to https://www.timetoplayfair.com/ https://www.timetoplayfair.com/ on Facebook. It says: Oops Something went wrong. We're working on getting it fixed as soon as we can.
- erikig 8y agoFacebook was experiencing issues all day today. https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/13/tech/facebook-instagram-down/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/13/tech/facebook-instagram-down/...
- fedxc 8y agoI hate to be that guy, but Apple built their own platform and they can bend the rules as they see fit. Spotify should just quit said platform if they don't like the rules and ask their "fans" to follow them over to other platforms. I know this is not likely to happen but, oh boy, what a move. Let's all jump into the water and let the Apple platform be an Apple service ghost town. On the other hand I do want to see Apple slapped on the hand by the European Commission and level the ground for all developers, specially indie ones.
- jotjotzzz 8y agoNot sure why Apple didn't get hit with an anti-trust lawsuit yet. Spotify is correct.
- toasterlovin 8y agoWhenever Apple's 30% take on the App Store comes up, people on this website get all up in arms about it. Let me provide some perspective, which I think is sorely lacking: I sell physical goods on Amazon. They charge me 15% for this privilege. The only reason they don't charge more is because physical goods have lower margins than digital goods (my margins after it's all said and done are somewhere between 10-15%). And, you know what? I'm happy to pay Amazon their 15% because they're bringing me customers that I wouldn't have otherwise. Perhaps thinking about it like this is instructive: does Amazon have an obligation to let me sell on their platform simply because lots of consumers choose to buy stuff from Amazon? Does Amazon have an obligation to change their fee structure so that I can more easily compete with Amazon Basics branded products? Should Apple charge a smaller percentage to subscription services that can't afford to give up 30%? Probably. It would net Apple a percentage of something, rather than the 30% of $0 that they're getting now. And it would be a better experience for Apple's customers. But it is in no way unreasonable for Apple to expect to get paid for originating sales of software and subscriptions. And it is certainly not unreasonable for them to get paid significantly more than credit card processing fees.
- WA 8y agoThing is, unless your app is already somewhat popular, Apple won’t do anything for you. Maybe you get more customers. But maybe an app like Spotify invested enough in marketing to reach new customers without Apple‘s health. The problem is that it’s really hard to measure how many customers Apple really brings and how many would find an app through other means.
- toasterlovin 8y agoAmazon is similar. Listing your products on there does not lead to sales. So, in addition to the 15% cut, I pay Amazon roughly 5-10% more to advertise my products as sponsored listings. But I can tell you that Amazon has resulted in way more sales than advertising on Goole and sending customers directly to our site. There is tremendous value to being on Amazon. Despite the constant declarations of Amazon having a counterfeit product epidemic, customers are comfortable buying on Amazon. They know that Amazon will have their back if we rip them off. As a result, there are lots of consumers who only buy certain classes of goods from Amazon. And it is Amazon, not me, who has cultivated that relationship. It makes sense that they charge me a significant amount to participate.
- iamsaitam 8y agoOh, that title.. thought for a moment they were going to start paying more to the musicians.. but I guess it's not yet time to play fair there.
- tasubotadas 8y agoI've submitted a complaint about this requirement to use specific purchase systems against Play Store and App Store two years ago but they didn't see it as a problem because, apparently, you can switch from GPlay to Apple products or vice-versa. A sound logic.
- 49531 8y agoImagine if the entire web were subject to the arbitrary will of an individual corporation.
- badatshipping 8y agoApple owns their platform. It cost a fortune to develop, and it's theirs. Imagine it's the 1800s and you wanted to develop technology to let anyone listen to music anytime. You'd have to invent the computer, an operating system, and the internet (some means of distribution), then invent Spotify. (Or maybe not all those things in their entirety, but just enough to support the Spotify's functionality.) Since it's 2019, there are platforms that provide the operating system and means of distribution, and Spotify merely has to deliver an app that floats in high-level-land. They then complain that that platform, who did all the work Spotify didn't have to, isn't being "fair." What does that mean? What are they rightfully owed? Why doesn't Spotify create their own OS and App Store, and develop/distribute Spotify there? Because it's inconceivably hard? Surely that's why the people who did it get to set the rules.
- writepub 8y agoMaybe Intel should only allow Apple to run Intel approved apps on Intel Mac's, because it's Intel's CPU running the show? And what about the modem chip vendors? Shouldn't Qualcomm put a firewall in firmware and filter all traffic on the iPhone that it hasn't approved? What about the ISP carrying those packets? Shouldn't they lay claim to packet ownership? This platform ownership piffle Apple has sold for eons is pure horse shit, and the EU regulators will rule as such. Simply put, a fridge manufacturer cannot control what items get stored and cooled in the fridge, after the customer has paid in full for both the fridge and the item. And the fridge manufacturer certainly cannot restrict items only sold though it's own stores
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tareqak 8y agoI'm 100% behind Spotify on this issue even though I don't use the service. BUT If you're going to ask someone else to play fair, then maybe you should do the same i.e. have a revenue-sharing model that is fair to all of big labels, indie labels, and independent music producers.
- throwaway24680 8y agoIt's time for app developers to unionize. Collective action is the only way to level the playing field.
- madrox 8y agoA week before launch of an SVOD product I worked on, Apple chose to reject us in spite of months of meetings and reviews with their app teams and assurances we were in-bounds since we were working with them for launch featuring. It came down to the fact we required an email address and password for IAP so you could bring your subscription to the web or other platforms. While everyone else in the category did this, they decided that policy was going to change and we were just going to be the first people to deal with it. Since having an email-based account was core to the architecture and the UX, I went through a week of refactor hell to make emails/passwords optional to meet our launch date. Since other apps still get to do this, it's clear the policy change message was BS. I've suspected a lot has had to do with Apple's ambitions in the streaming space and their desire to be in a position to offer bundling and other over the top services. They're already trying to control the UX with the TV app and are offering companies better rev share rates to do the integration work. Cutting back from 30% is how Apple incentivizes even heavier integration into their ecosystem. Apple keeps doing this: Google and the Google Phone app, Netflix, Spotify, my product...more that we haven't even heard of, since not many are as big as the ones I've mentioned. The idea that this is somehow about protecting the consumer rings hollow.
- ChildOfChaos 8y agoEh this is just one big company trying to get more profits by complaining against another. Spotify is not the good guy here. Spotify works just fine on apple products (I use it), who cares about using Apples payment processing system (which they have a right to charge for), it's a Spotify service, so i should pay through Spotify which i do.
- dijksterhuis 8y agoJust to add to the debate - when in was working in the music industry and had a view of the data (~ 3 years ago now), the money Apple Music would pay per stream was higher than Spotify...
- abalone 8y agoThere's a lot of things I like and are consumer-friendly about the App Store, mainly around privacy and security. But the "Apple tax" is absolutely where it veers into a level of concentrated power that concerns antitrust law. Yes, I get that you can switch to Android and Apple doesn't have an actual monopoly. They still wield a lot of power to force this 30% tax down everyone's throats. Specifically it's the power of "bundling" which is a potential antitrust violation.[1] The implied reasoning behind Apple's restrictions on bypassing the tax is to ensure a positive customer experience. By selling things through Apple they take on the role of an intermediary merchant that can do things like refunds and otherwise ensure a positive, trustworthy customer experience. But we need only look at the Mac App Store to get an idea of how much consumers truly value this value-add. On that platform, vendors and consumers have the freedom to directly interact, while Apple has still enacted a pretty good level of privacy and security protections (through revokable developer certificates and sandboxing). Many simply bypass the store. And the tax there would make even less sense for strictly ongoing content subscriptions that pose no additional security or privacy threat. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_(antitrust_law) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundling_(antitrust_law)
- LaGrange 8y ago...unfair as Apple's rates may or may not be, it's a bit rich coming from Spotify.
- justfor1comment 8y agoA recent law passed in India seems like the kind of regulation that is needed to prevent this kind of behaviour https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/05/amazon-how-india-ecommerce-law-will-affect-the-retailer.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/02/05/amazon-how-india-ecommerce-l... Essentially what the law says is that if you own a platform you can't create and sell products on it. This law targets Amazon and Flipkart since Amazon also uses their own website to sell Amazon basics products. Amazon also uses internal metrics to determine which new product categories to launch which other sellers on the platform won't have access to. Apple and Google app stores should also have similar restrictions.
- sjg007 8y agoWhat if Spotify takes your phone number and sends you a text link to sign up to pay?
- erikig 8y agoThat would probably be fine...until Apple created a rule to discourage and then eventually ban all apps that used that pattern without going through their API.
- dzonga 8y agoThere should be an alternative App Store, plain and simple. As long as the sandbox for apps exist, users will be pretty safe. Apps should work the same way sandboxing works on PC browsers. Apple constricts Safari iOS because they don't want web apps to be fully competitive with native apps. E.g I prefer to use Overcast.fm over web than the native app, but most times, my podcast streams will stop abruptly in mobile safari, that i'm thinking of trading my privacy to Android for a pixel 1. Only thing that saves me, is I hardly use my phone, otherwise the limited functionality of iOS for devices you pay hundreds for is painful.
- elamje 8y ago> Uber doesn't pay the 30% like others do. This makes me curious if this is how Uber(Jump Scooters) is undercutting Lime and Bird on Scooter and Bike pricing in my city (Dallas). Uber is $0 to start a ride + $.15 a min. Bird and Lime and $1 to start + $.15 a min. Is this partially because Apple takes 30% from Bird and Lime, but not Uber?
- sumitsrivastava 8y agoInteresting to see this given Spotify doesn't play fair by locking in data in their app for developers. See: https://freeyourmusic.com https://freeyourmusic.com [not mine, but read why this exists]
- jaimex2 8y agoSo what was wrong with using Apple subscription service but jacking up the price 50%? It's a lazy tax as far as I see it, why would anyone complain?
- jasonhansel 8y agoThis will keep happening until Apple does what it should have done all along: give users control by allowing them to sideload apps.
- booleandilemma 8y agoBut Apple not only has unilaterally changed the rules themselves time and again, but also frequently decides to interpret (and re-interpret) them in ways to disadvantage rivals like us. Spotify isn’t so much a rival as it is a serf on Apple’s farm though, right? Apple could just remove Spotify from the app store altogether, for fun.
- booleandilemma 8y agoI like how Spotify uses the word fans in place of customers. Nice marketing.
- amelius 8y ago> Apple decides to open up the App Store to outside app developers and lures them in by the hundreds. They ask users – want to order a pizza, find your nearest florist, or look up how to do the Soulja Boy dance? “There’s an app for that.” We already had the web for those things ...
- amelius 8y agoThe entire platform economy is a bad idea. Because it's one thing if a government regulates a market, but yet another if a company does it.
- excalibur 8y agoArtists to Spotify: cough
- jy1 8y agoThis isn't about a 30% take rate on IAP (that's fine). This isn't about apple having apple music. The problem is that Spotify is not allowed to take credit card input directly in the app. The problem is that Spotify isn't allowed to redirect users to a webpage to collect payment.
- willart4food 8y agoApple is the new Microsoft! #FTC #MONOPOLY
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- hiven 8y agoApple seem completely unreasonable behind the scenes. As an iPhone fan boy it really puts me off. Do google do similar things I wonder?
- daveheq 8y agoIt really should be a progressive fee, which starts low for new apps and goes up as more and more sales are made per time period.
- appstorelottery 8y agoI think if you own the platform you shouldn’t be allowed to compete. E.g. You can’t write apps for your OS. You can’t sell your own products through your own market. Etc. I’m surprised this hasn’t been legislated by now... we all remember Novell & WordPerfect... it never gets better.
- countryqt30 8y agoThere are always 2 sides to it. Especially when one side makes the other look like a blithering idiot. A few points: * Without Apple, Spotify would be worthless and not reached any users at all, never grown * Apple is doing the heavy-lifting of building and distributing Apple Watch, HomePod, iPhones. Spotify is creating little additional value in comparison * Spotify repeatedly tried to cheat Apple's system and they were blocked and rejected (in my opinion) rightfully. They tweaked wordings, they even linked to a website that first looked harmless and would be MODIFIED after the app is approved. I'm not sure Spotify's behavior is ANY better.
- objektif 8y agoHow about Spotify also start paying a better cut to all creators? Are you guys not sick of corporarions pretending like they are good citizens?
- Xplosiveoctopus 8y agoIt’s their platform and they can do whatever they want. They invested, they built it, they rule it. Whiny generation and their stupid EU laws...