21 ms·
Ray Kurzweil: AI is still on course to outpace human intelligence
- pseudolus 8y agoThe singularity is nigh! This trope might make for great fiction but the on the ground reality is far different. Intelligence is multi-dimensional. No machine intelligence has yet shown an ability to match humans in multifaceted intelligence and the day when such intelligences can outpace humans is as far off as it was when the singularity was first posited.
- chrisco255 8y agoWhat does multi-dimensional even mean, in the context of intelligence? Sounds like a buzz word.
- burlesona 8y agoIn the field this is the idea of General Intilligence versus narrow intelligence. Alexa, for example, is an Artificial Narrow Intelligence. It can process speech and then follow different scripts with instructions derived from that speech, but it often fails comically so you as the human have to talk to it just right for it to work. Not too different from a verbal command line. Meanwhile a human personal assistant has general intelligence. You can just tell them what you want and they can understand and figure it out.
- zimpenfish 8y ago> Alexa, for example, is an Artificial Narrow Intelligence [...] often fails comically I'd venture that your coda nullifies the "Intelligence" part thoroughly and completely. She's an "Artificial Smart Assistant", at best.
- seiferteric 8y agoThe problem is we have no useful definition for intelligence and therefore no way useful metric to measure.
- maratd 8y ago> What does multi-dimensional even mean, in the context of intelligence? Emotional Logical Intuitive Social Computational Instinctive Sexual Experiential and I can keep going, but you should get the point.
- chrisco255 8y agoThese are just skills. No one has proven they take some special kind of intelligence or that such intelligences exist, including oft-quoted emotional intelligence.
- maratd 8y ago> No one has proven they take some special kind of intelligence This isn't true. We have overwhelming evidence that these "skills" originate in different parts of the brain in all humans and if we disable those parts, those "skills" disappear. Those parts of the brain are unique and have their own structures. There is strong evidence that they require unique "hardware" and as such, are a "special kind of intelligence".
- chrisco255 8y agoNo we don't. Right-left brain thinking has been completely debunked, for example. If you've got links to overwhelming evidence (studies) I would appreciate it.
- gfodor 8y agoThe idea of the singularity is based upon the idea of recursive self improvement. I'm not sure how your claims are relevant.
- leesec 8y agoI think (human)intelligence almost guarantees recursive self improvement; thus, if AGI = human intelligence or greater, it would also guarantee recursive self improvement.
- gfodor 8y agoThe inverse case seems more likely, where non-human equivalent intelligence becomes sufficient to recursively self improve to superintelligence. Both the before and after states seem relatively unrelated to human intelligence, which is one arbitrary (and, likely uninteresting) point in what I would assume is a many dimensional space to quantify intelligence.
- coldtea 8y ago>I think (human)intelligence almost guarantees recursive self improvement That's quite a wide claim, seeing that we haven't seen much "recursive self improvement".
- drb91 8y agoIt’d be a lot easier to believe not coming from a company selling ads. Google would be far more of a self improvement tool if it were not incentivized to sell you things you don’t want.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoI mean Kurzweil has found a home at Google but he has been talking about the singularity for far longer afaik.
- drb91 8y agoHe’s also been wrong his entire life. There’s a reason Google hired him: to make AI look good, despite being a near meaningless term. Edit: diction.
- arcticfox 8y ago> No machine intelligence has yet shown an ability to match humans in multifaceted intelligence This is pretty absurd to point to as an intermediate goalpost; that's basically game over when it happens.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoIt's game over when machine intelligence controls all the resources needed to ensure their continuation. As long as they are trapped and subject to our control of the power switch and reproduction they can't do much that we don't want them to.
- ethbro 8y ago> It's game over when machine intelligence controls all the resources needed to ensure their continuation. One might have said the same thing about corporations in 1900...
- mortenjorck 8y agoThis brings me back to the short essay from a few years ago about the corporation as human-powered AI: http://omniorthogonal.blogspot.com/2013/02/hostile-ai-youre-soaking-in-it.html http://omniorthogonal.blogspot.com/2013/02/hostile-ai-youre-...
- ethbro 8y agoOr as Neal Stephenson put it in 1992, "The franchise and the virus work on the same principle: what thrives in one place will thrive in another. You just have to find a sufficiently virulent business plan, condense it into a three-ring binder ― its DNA ― xerox it, and embed it in the fertile lining of a well-traveled highway, preferably one with a left-turn lane."
- aaroninsf 8y agoOne would arguably have been right. All that is necessary to make this argument compelling is to take a longer view than the human attention span. The current population explosion is evidence for, not against, this, IMO... stars also enjoy boom times, even as they consume the last of their resources, in ever more exotic formulations...
- candiodari 8y agoAren't you a little bit worried ? I mean there has been a long history of "you can't do this with computers". It started with carrying out list of simple instructions, then doing anything with images, then recognizing images, then drawing images, then simple games chess, recognize audio (though people realized this was stupid in the 60s with IBM speech synthesizers and so today people don't remember), and then Go (and less well known: backgammon, video games, ...). For most of those we now roll our eyes and go "how could they have been so stupid ?". As for practical applications: robots run something between 3/4ths and 5/6ths of the stock market. Maybe you're unaware of this but that's the thing that decides how and where humans work (not just the ones also doing stocks, anyone working at any public company is partially directed by it, which in practice is nearly everyone). AIs talk to humans more than humans do. AIs produce more writing than humans do. AIs judge more humans (for insurances, or creditworthiness) than humans do. Despite what you think AIs actually drive just a little under 1 millionth of total miles driven in the US today, going up exponentially. AIs currently drive a little more than a 1000 person city does. In experimental settings, AIs have beat humans at convincing other people that they're human. At "chatting up" humans. Seriously. Not that it seems to take much at all to convince humans you're sentient: iRobots have convinced soldiers to threaten army technicians with guns into repairing them. There wasn't even that much AI involved, but that's got to count for something. In research, I would argue there are already multifaceted artificial intelligences in reinforcement learning. There is nothing in those atari game playing AIs about the games. There used to be the score of the game, but the modern ones don't even have that. They can play any atari game, from Montezuma's revenge to pacman, which I'd argue are very different indeed. There must be some measure of "multifaceted" in there, surely ? But let's keep it simple: could you make this problem a bit more accurate ? For example, which animals would you say exhibit an acceptable level of "multifaceted" intelligence ? Why do those animals qualify ? What would a good test be ? I'd love to find an interesting test for this.
- foldr 8y ago>I mean there has been a long history of "you can't do this with computers". Historically, people have both grossly overestimated and grossly underestimated future technological progress. Some people thought computers would never be able to play chess; others thought we'd have superhuman AGI in 2001. The bottom line is that people's past and current ignorance tells us nothing about what the future is actually going to be like.
- tim333 8y agoIn Kurzweil's book 'The Singularity it Near' written in 2005 he predicted it for 2045 and has never changed the predicted date so we're still 26 years off. We've recently had AlphaZero beating us at games and Waymo cars kind of driving so there's some progress on the ground. Give it time.
- mimixco 8y agoI love Ray Kurzweil and he's an undisputed genius, but like many other believers in The Singularity, he's convinced of something that has never been proven to be true. No computer will ever demonstrate actual intelligence, which is the ability to bring a new and unforeseen solution to an existing problem. I need only a cite a few examples to show this is true: Uber cars run over people. Facial recognition claims black people are criminals just for being black. Facebook's AI software lets in fake news. These are all errors that could be avoided by actual human intelligence. The fact of the matter is that we don't really know where intelligence or creativity comes from. It's unlikely that we ever will. (See "Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle" for one reason.) While machines are great at doing things faster than people can do them, they're not good at inventing new solutions or doing something that humans couldn't do, given enough time.
- fabiospampinato 8y ago> No computer will ever demonstrate actual intelligence Such statements are impossible to be proven right, as, assuming you consider yourself actually intelligent, that implies we are not inside a computer ourselves, which I'd argue is impossible to prove.
- AnimalMuppet 8y ago> that implies we are not inside a computer ourselves, which I'd argue is impossible to prove. Perhaps not. But some statements cannot be disproven and yet still should not be taken seriously. But I think you are right that, while correct in claiming that the Singularity has never been proven, mimixco is also making statements that cannot be proven.
- Scene_Cast2 8y agoIf we're running in a simulation, the host computation hardware may be different from what you imagine a computer to be. For example, we could be an experiment of "is life possible in a euclidean universe".
- mimixco 8y ago
- Novashi 8y agoBrave claim: we won’t actually invent good AI until two-way brain-computer interfaces become useful. We need to augment human intelligence to handle systems vastly more complex than we can do today. Specifically memory creation and recall, and information assimilation rates.
- rytill 8y agoSo brave.
- lsc 8y agoHow do you define 'useful'? My keyboard and monitor are brain-computer interfaces. I'd argue that they are pretty useful. I can imagine a way to consume information that is dramatically faster than the 500 or some odd words per minute I get reading. But for input to the computer? I mean, I'm not saying that a keyboard can't be improved upon, but I think there are some hard limits to how quickly I can compose my thoughts; I think that it's fairly rare that the fingers are the limit. (Of course, making it so I think less about the fingers would be great) What I'm saying is that there might be human processing speed issues that limit how much value we can get out of faster I/O. On the other hand, maybe it's like reading was for me; before I could read at a certain speed and certain ease, I couldn't enjoy books, because I'd forget the beginning of the paragraph before I got to the end. Like I needed to load enough words at once to see the picture. It's totally possible that output would be the same way; if I could somehow output the equivalent of five hundred plus words per minute, maybe that would change my writing the same way passing that speed changed my reading?
- Novashi 8y agoI think most of the bandwidth would be computer -> brain, not the other way around, assuming it can teach your brain to retain knowledge and show it images/movies. The only exception would be if we could significantly alter the perception of time, but I'm not really betting on that despite how useful it'd be. Even if I could only accurately sample 1-8 bits/second from the brain, that would be world-changing. There are a lot of clever people who could stuff a lot of utility through 8 bits/second given you are paired with a powerful smartphone and a proper "UX". Clever encoding schemes and signals could be developed. Especially if you go for sequences/chords that are executed over 1-4 seconds. Plus the brain would likely just act as an index to fetch info that is then replayed to you. I really don't need a terabyte in the form of neuron connections when storage and computing would be ubiquitous.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoRay Kurzweil is still on pace to die before the Singularity arrives.
- Mediterraneo10 8y agoI always felt that Kurzweil’s timelines were too optimistic not only because technology may not evolve so fast, but also because it fails to account for the delays that government regulation imposes. So many of the vaunted leaps in medical technology, for example, are going to require years and years of testing before they get approval for use. Other whizbang technology of the future might be prohibited from the consumer market because governments see it as too dangerous.
- xiphias2 8y agoThis may be the case for many technologies, but clear wins that save lives get fast tracked. It just happened to CTX001. Also older researchers are doing self testing all the time, as they know that they don't have the time to go through regulations. https://www.investors.com/news/technology/crispr-vertex-gene-editing-fast-track/ https://www.investors.com/news/technology/crispr-vertex-gene...
- bytematic 8y agoNot if he eats any more pills
- TimTheTinker 8y agoI don't think anything like the singularity will ever be possible, because the ability to speak language for oneself and invent complex reasoning is spiritual, not merely physical. Humans can do it because we are inherently spiritual beings, a union of body and spirit. (I know most folks here don't subscribe to that assertion... I'm not here to argue it anyway.) But even if that isn't true, humans are not merely the product of our biology. Each of us has undergone an $age-year period of training, 18 years of which was on someone else's effort and time. I doubt someone is willing to put in that much personal investment to raise a neural net like his/her own child.
- YaxelPerez 8y agoRaising a kid without having to change diapers sounds pretty cool.
- Koshkin 8y agoBut a fan will be there for sure.
- singularify 8y agoNeural nets don’t vote Trump, so guess again.
- Agebor 8y agoBut if something is spiritual, there must be some way for it to interact with the physical world, otherwise you would not know about it. Then that way can be measured, which makes it physical... Unless you are calling spiritual those things that can't be measured, yet?
- naringas 8y ago> there must be some way for it to interact with the physical world that's the body
- mrob 8y agoFor the sake of argument, "spiritual" could be a class of physical objects that can only be produced by other spiritual objects. This is the old "vitalism" argument, which is generally considered discredited, but as the "hard problem of consciousness" is still unanswered, this is a small loophole that proponents can use to hang on to it.
- dwighttk 8y agoAnd if you don’t agree you just don’t understand exponential growth.
- dwighttk 8y agocant tell if downvotes are people who don't understand exponential growth or people who think I don't understand exponential growth
- scottlocklin 8y agoI didn't vote either way, but long term exponential growth in anything is basically impossible. Think about it for a minute. At some point lithography gave us Moore's "law" (which, FWIIW has arguably already failed). Do you think that can continue forever? Pretty sure you exceed computational capacity of the universe pretty quickly. Exponential growth in cell phone sales happened at some point as well. As did exponential growth in transportation speed. The idea that we've had exponential growth in anything but lithography technology in recent years is also laughably insane. Do you think programming languages are exponentially better than they were 30 years ago? Do people live exponentially longer? Cars, autos exponentially cheaper or better in some way? Are machine learning algos exponentially better? No, no, no, and no.
- wetpaws 8y agoYou are talking about s-curves, if I understand it correctly. Few notes: first, exponential growth does not necessary mean fast growth, some of the technologies can still be in early phase or depend on some future advances (compare time for tv to capture the world vs smartphones) Second, the decline of exponential growth of a technology does not mean it can't be replaced with a nother technology with better prospects (i.e gas cars vs electric cars, etc). I would argue if that you zoom out for a bigger picture, technology as a whole does show traces of exponential growth.
- scottlocklin 8y agoRe: technology showing "traces of exponential growth" citations needed; everything slowing down from where I'm sitting.
- chrisco255 8y agoRay Kurzweil's brain has already been backed up in the Google Cloud Platform. Everyone claiming he's running out of time is just wrong!
- fitzroy 8y agoCounterpoint: "Hey Siri, lock my phone." "Playing 'Locked Out of Heaven' by Bruno Mars..."
- magnamerc 8y agoI suspect human intelligence is more than just computations in the brain. A lot of computation I assume most occur 'outside' of the brain in the gut via hormones and protein signalling. I have doubts that you can replicate human intelligence without replicating human biology.
- kowdermeister 8y ago> hormones and protein signalling They are control utilities, regulators for the brain, whose generation is initiated by the brain. However I think you are right with the need for human body. Without sensory input its state would collapse, I think it needs a world with constant stimuli to live in.
- pessimizer 8y agohttps://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/a-brief-guide-to-embodied-cognition-why-you-are-not-your-brain/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/a-brief-guid...
- jstewartmobile 8y agoOr even if it were all in the brain, accurately modeling neurons and interactions of neurons, on bajillions of cudas and threadrippers, will probably still take much longer than it takes for the real-life system to do its thing: https://newatlas.com/spinnaker-neuromorphic-supercomputer-mouse-brain-simulation/57101/ https://newatlas.com/spinnaker-neuromorphic-supercomputer-mo...
- Koshkin 8y agoModeling the human brain is just one of the directions of the AI research, possibly not the most important one, even, at this point. On the other hand, the "super-intelligence" everyone is thinking about will be nothing like the human mind.
- jstewartmobile 8y ago
- nyrulez 8y agoDespite the cynicism and his black and white predictions, I think his rhetoric still has valuable contributions. It forces others to take a true account of what intelligence is and what kind of intelligence is AI capable of in the medium term (evidence: this thread). For some reason, this doesn't get enough attention and we have people like Elon and Stephen Hawking making dire predictions all over the place.
- ForHackernews 8y agoI can't believe there are people genuinely afraid of a hypothetical powerful malevolent AI, yet seemingly not that concerned by actual climate change.
- lern_too_spel 8y agoWho says you can only worry about one thing?
- coldtea 8y agoAnybody who understands opportunity costs...
- lern_too_spel 8y agoThat's reductionist to the point of absurdity. You might be able to only focus on one thing at a time, but a day is long, and you need to worry about multiple things in a day to merely survive. In your free time, it is possible to worry about poverty, climate change, superintelligence, and many other things. The reason that rich people worry about superintelligence is that it could bring the same uncaring devastation to the rich as climate change brings to the poor.
- coldtea 8y ago>The reason that rich people worry about superintelligence is that it could bring the same uncaring devastation to the rich as climate change brings to the poor. The problem with this is that I believe one is a genuine threat, the other is a fad.
- throwaway13337 8y agoIt's much easier to make a plane that can fly than to emulate the particular way a bird flies. They'll both solve the flight problem, so it doesn't really matter. Flight is something extremely comparible to ai development. When it was developed, many companies were trying, and a lot of people said it was impossible. The problem space is also similar. We're not sure how to get there exactly but we may be close. It was, in the end made to happen by an unlikely pair - not a large company with a lot of investment. I believe this might be that fate, too.
- grouseway 8y agoQuestion is, are the current approaches at AI the equivalent of the early flappy wing planes we were building to emulate birds?
- twtw 8y ago> in the end made to happen by an unlikely pair Who spent years studying birds... No, the wings of the wright flyer don't flap, but that doesn't mean it wasn't designed based on birds. One key piece (controllability) came as a result of the wright brothers studying how birds adjusted the shape of their wings.
- seiferteric 8y agoThe difference is we knew what flight was and had an easily visible and verifiable goal that was obvious to all when it was achieved. What is intelligence? How do you measure it? How will we know once we have created? We haven't even defined the problem yet, how can we know when we have achieved it?
- rafiki6 8y agoIt matters tremendously. Think about the economics of bird flight vs. plane flight. Why is it that flight has been around for almost 100 years now and yet we still aren't flying everywhere? The reality is we can always come up with subpar ways of doing things, but there's a reason birds have evolved as they are today that we just can't replicate ourselves. We mastered long haul rapid flights, but bird flight generalizes much better. They might be slower in long haul, but they are much better and short haul and medium haul and have evolved to work in groups to make long haul possible. So yes, analogously we can create intelligence in a different way, which we are, but it likely won't generalize as well.
- simplecomplex 8y agoDefine AI. Define intelligence. Kurzwiel's prediction are nonscientific and unfalsifiable. AGI is unscientific. He really likes making predictions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzweil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzwe...
- jimbokun 8y agoI don't think this one happened: 2019: "The computational capacity of a $4,000 computing device (in 1999 dollars) is approximately equal to the computational capability of the human brain (20 quadrillion calculations per second)."
- zozbot123 8y ago$4,000 in 1999 would be about $6,000 today. A midrange Deep Learning workstation is in the ballpark, and while it can't "match the computational capacity of the human brain", it can do plenty of nifty things - including beat the current Go world champion in a match.
- slacka 8y agoNo, not even close. 20 quadrillion calculations per second= 20 petaFLOPS. A Nvidia DGX-2 is only 2 petaFLOPS and that "AI" supercomputer costs $399,000. Far cry from $6,000. You are just hand waving to try to defend a definitively failed prediction.
- tim333 8y agoHe predicted Turing test by 2029 which is fairly definite, falsifiable and quite likely to be falsified. For me proper AGI is when you could say to a robot go build some better robots and then have them build even better ones and they can do so without needing us. There will be some year before which if humans disappeared, computers and robots would grind to a halt and after which they could carry on. That's also a definite falsifiable thing, harder than the Turning test and is kind of what I think of as corresponding to the singularity which tends to be rather wooly in it's definition.
- jstewartmobile 8y agoCounterpoint: https://engineering.purdue.edu/kak/RobotsWillNeverHaveSex.pdf https://engineering.purdue.edu/kak/RobotsWillNeverHaveSex.pd...
- jobigoud 8y agoGave up at page five of "this is what this presentation is about", can you summarize his main argument on why robots will never have sex?
- jpindar 8y agoIt's clickbait. The last page is: >But What About the Title of this Presentation .... While obviously a cheap hook, it is nevertheless intended to convey the possibility that it is our emotions, our passions, our innate desires — all ingredients of our sexuality — that are the defining elements of our consciousness and, through consciousness, our intelligence. The End
- tim333 8y agoThanks for the time saver. Incidentally I note sex robots are a thing apparently https://www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/8204874/sex-robots-machines-alexa-relationships-investigation/ https://www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/8204874/sex-robots-machine...
- ada1981 8y agoI had a chance to interview Ray and spend some time with him before he joined Google. The way we met was very serendipitous -- I asked a question during a movie premiere about the nature of reality. He must have enjoyed it because later someone from his team sought me out to invite me to a VIP after party. His publicist at the time said this was the best interview he ever gave (It's possible she says that to all the girls, but, I'll take it!) https://www.huffingtonpost.com/anthony-adams/ray-kurzweil-interview_b_921015.html https://www.huffingtonpost.com/anthony-adams/ray-kurzweil-in...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ForHackernews 8y agoThe Singularity is just millennialism [0] for secular technolgists. We still have a pretty paltry understanding of human intelligence. It seems unlikely to me that more and more iterations of AlphaGo will spontaneously produce strong general AI. My bet is no AGI within my lifetime. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Millennialism
- mirceal 8y agoit depends on how old you are, but I think you may be right that AGI still needs on the order of hundreds of years to happen.
- iheartpotatoes 8y agoAlpha zero is a generalized AlphaGo, so they are headed in the right direction! AlphaGo -> win this boardgame AlphaZero -> win any boardgame (well, three right now) AlphaMinus1 -> win any game AlphaMinus2 -> win anything AlphaMinus3 -> win winning. so much winning. But you get my drift, I'm extrapolating hugely off one abstraction step.
- ForHackernews 8y agoYeah maybe. How do you define "win" in terms of general intelligence? Outsmart all top human experts at their field?
- wetpaws 8y agoWhatever the reward function dictates would be a win :)
- ForHackernews 8y agoRight. So we've just successfully moved the goalposts to "write a reward function that objectively evaluates g"
- iheartpotatoes 8y ago
- davidw 8y agoIDK, Google's voice assistant thing still can't figure out my wife's name because it's not an English name and I pronounce it as it should be pronounced.
- Scene_Cast2 8y agoHere's my shorter-term thinking. Current ML can't generalize well [0], can't do arbitrary & conceptual thinking, and has trouble with language. [0] by that, I mean that it does not easily pick up higher-level patterns unless explicitly forced to (through either model architecture, data & task setup, etc). Meaning - it has a much lower success rate outside of the training data distribution compared to "flesh" intelligence. Kind of reminds me of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHRvF0m3yuo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHRvF0m3yuo
- jobigoud 8y agoHmm, current ML has only been worked on for a few years, we have barely scratched the surface. No signs of slowing down afaict. It has wiped the state of the art against algorithms we took decades to think up. What happens after decades of that? It feels more like there is too many new directions to explore and we don't have enough time/creativity/insights/ideas to fully take advantage of it.
- ttlei 8y agoCurrent ML algorithms have been worked on for decades earlier. They are gaining momentum again due to big data and computing power.
- jobigoud 8y agoTo me "current ML" in the parent comment meant deep learning. Open a computer vision paper from this month and the prior art section almost only contains references from between 2014 to 2018. Yes the NN layer architecture might be based on ideas from the previous era, but the way the algo actually solve the problem is completely different. And that's just because it's the only way we can do it right now. When we can apply deep learning to itself it, to select better architectures and hyperparameters, will find strategies we didn't think about or didn't consider worth trying.
- rjf72 8y ago1957 - First ever man-made object launched into space. 1957 - First ever animal launched into space. 1960 - First ever animal launched into space that survives the trip. 1961 - First man goes into space. 1965 - First man goes on a space walk. 1966 - First spacecraft lands on the moon. 1967 - A probe is landed on Venus (!) which collects and sends back video and audio recordings among other data. 1968 - First spacecraft to orbit the moon and then return to Earth. 1969 - We put men on the moon who then safely return. We've done all of this in just 12 years! We literally went from nothing to men on the moon in 12 years! We've barely scratched the surface of what's possible and there's no sign of things slowing down at all! Can you imagine where we'll be after decades of this. Where will we be in 50 years? I can't even begin to imagine what 2019 will be like. I don't say this to be snarky, but to point out the issue. Exponential growth doesn't mean continued exponential growth, and it's always very difficult to predict the future. While thoughts such as the above were common place, there would have been hardly a person to predict that the room-sized government "computing machines" would one day be a few inches large, millions of times more powerful, and cost as little as a week or so of minimum wage work. In some cases, those exponents did keep churning for a while. On AI, I used to be a futurist in terms of it - until I got to work with it. Now I'd be extremely surprised if we have have fully capable self driving vehicle within the next decade that's not constrained to white-listed routes. And that is an extremely softball problem since it fits perfectly into the small domain of problems that current ML/AI systems are really great at making progress on. The thing is getting to a testable model is absolutely trivial. Going that remaining 10% from model to product is many orders of magnitude more challenging.
- aj7 8y agoI don’t find this any different than a steam shovel outpacing a human digger. It’s still necessary to prevent both from destroying things and harming people.
- pcstl 8y agoBetting on technology evolving faster than expected is usually a safe bet, but it feels like Ray has been working on flawed premises and refuses to revise them.
- jimbokun 8y agoWhat, specifically, has he gotten wrong?
- Slartie 8y agoThis one (especially HN commentary) is a good read: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18806315 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18806315 After reading it all, I don't really see him as being any more successful in predicting than you and me. You get some right, you get some kind-of-in-the-right-direction, you get some wrong, and some are just laughably wrong.
- jcoffland 8y agoA better question is what has he gotten right?
- tompetry 8y agoThe brain and "mind" is insanely complex. There is so much we still don't understand, so of course there is so much we cannot replicate. But is it possible? If there is an incredible breakthrough in understanding, then yes of course. Personally I see little value in people saying it can or can't be done (of course it can!), it's just a matter of if and when. We shall see...
- dmead 8y agoare people still listening to this guy?
- tim333 8y agoSeems so.
- bartcobain 8y agoWhy not?
- root_axis 8y agoComputers that are capable of analyzing and understanding their environment with a level of fidelity comparable to a human, without being preprogrammed with information about the nature or structure of the environment, are out of reach for the foreseeable future. I don't see any fundamental reason why such a computer should be impossible, but there's not even a realistic roadmap towards such a thing. That is to say, if it ever does happen, nobody alive today can predict when it will happen.
- nradov 8y agoIt would be foolish to claim we've made any meaningful progress toward a true AGI that can pass the Turing Test until someone demonstrates a computer as smart as a mouse across the full spectrum of activities.
- pgodzin 8y agoWhat does it mean to be as smart as a mouse? If you specify a handful of tasks that demonstrate it, someone will be able to purpose-build an "AI" to do those things well.
- ThomPete 8y agoI am seriously interested in understanding why a lot of people have no issue accepting the idea of humans evolving from simple immaterial matter into biological beings and all the way up to our current reality but have a hard time believing that can be done via computers. I would at least put it in the very likely box that computers can learn to be the same kind of pattern recognizing feedback loops that we are even without humans understanding the brain completely just as we became conscious and self aware without any "programmer". "Computers" don't need to be like us to become intelligent, they don't actually need to reproduce the lungs and the intestine as we have it, they are in many ways free of those restrictions. They might be "concerned" with very different things than we are and might even not really care about nature to survive. All they need is energy.
- rafiki6 8y agoBut let's not forget evolution of the magnitude you speak of took hundreds of millions of years. I'm not sure why humans think we can beat that record.
- ThomPete 8y agoI don't think humans can beat the record, but technology? That's another matter all together. Again our own consciousness wasn't created it emerged which means that we are a product of this emergence.
- rafiki6 8y agoTechnology at this time is nothing but an extension of human will. There is no indication or path that it has yet left our grasp. Therefore we are the limiting factor. Just as nature or the divine might have been the will that allowed us to emerge.
- baq 8y agobut if it ever leaves our grasp, you won't notice when it outpaces us, it's going to be so quick.
- danielam 8y ago“Kurzweil’s Phantasms”: https://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/04/kurzweils-phantasms https://www.firstthings.com/article/2013/04/kurzweils-phanta...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- peterwwillis 8y agoThe more you learn about Kurzweil and what he bases his predictions on, the more you realize he's a one-trick pony. They only work on things governed by Moore's law (advancing transistor density) and that in turn depends on a variety of things. Moore's law is expected to wind down around 2025. Also, a lot of what he bases his claims on are unexamined junk science (like his nutty health books, but also extending into specific technologies). Let's not swallow everything he says just because he helped invent OCR. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Kurzweil#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ray_Kurzweil#Criticism
- WaltPurvis 8y agoYou are much too kind. Kurzweil is a loon, full stop. The fact he once made brilliant contributions to computer science is quite irrelevant to the essential craziness of his more recent delusions. In 2005, Kurzweil published The Singularity Is Near and predicted this would be the state of the world in the year 2030: "Nanobot technology will provide fully immersive, totally convincing virtual reality. Nanobots will take up positions in close physical proximity to every interneuronal connection coming from our senses. If we want to experience real reality, the nanobots just stay in position (in the capillaries) and do nothing. If we want to enter virtual reality, they suppress all of the inputs coming from our actual senses and replace them with the signals that would be appropriate for the virtual environment. Your brain experiences these signals as if they came from your physical body." That is not happening by the year 2030. It is so starkly delusional that anyone who seriously affirms a belief that it will happen probably needs psychiatric help. It is akin to Eric Drexler's loony visions back in the 1980s that nanobots would cure all diseases and continually restore our bodies to perfect health. We were supposed to all be immortal by now. None of this is happening, probably not ever, and certainly not in the lifetime of any human being currently living. Kurzweil is going to die, Drexler is going to die, everybody is going to die. Adopting a pseudo-scientific religion to avoid facing mortality is kind of sad.
- tim333 8y agoYou can differentiate the Moore's law / AI stuff which seems fairly sensible to me and the nanobots and vitamin pill stuff which I've always thought a little nuts. Hans Moravec did a much more down to earth analysis on the Moores/AI stuff if you'd rather avoid Kurzweil.
- slacka 8y agoHis predictions are hit and miss. From his 1999 predictions: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzweil#Late_20th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzwe... By 2009: Y: The majority of reading is done on displays rather than paper N: Most text will be created using speech recognition technology. N: Intelligent roads and driverless cars are in use N: People use personal computers the size of rings, pins, credit cards Y/N (premature): Though desktop PCs are still common for data storage, individuals primarily use portable devices for their computer-related tasks. Y/N (premature): Personal worn computers provide monitoring of body functions, automated identity and directions for navigation. N: A $1,000 computer can perform a trillion calculations per second. ... seemed a total mixed bag, many 2009 predictions just beginning to coming true today By 2019: N: The computational capacity of a $6,000 computing device is approximately equal to the computational capability of the human brain (claims that is ~20 petaFLOPS. Nvidia DGX-2 is 2 petaFLOPS "AI" supercomputer for $399,000). [ N: Computers are embedded everywhere in the environment (inside of furniture, jewelry, walls, clothing, etc.). Y(easy win): Most people own more than one PC N: Cables connecting computers and peripherals have almost completely disappeared. Y/N: People communicate with their computers via two-way speech and gestures instead of with keyboards. (can but in my home and my office most words entered are not) N: Most business transactions or information inquiries involve dealing with a simulated person N: Rotating computer hard drives are no longer used. N: Three-dimensional nanotube lattices are the dominant computing substrate. N: The algorithms that allow the relatively small genetic code of the brain to construct a much more complex organ are being transferred into computer neural nets.(Could be decades off. Need several breakthroughs to even put this on the horizon) N: Most roads now have automated driving systems—networks that allow computer-controlled automobiles to safely navigate. N: Most decisions made by humans involve consultation with machine intelligence. For example, a doctor may seek the advice of a digital assistant. ... few hit but we're mostly heading that way. To me seems 5-15 years premature [1] https://www.popsci.com/intel-teraflop-chip#page-2 https://www.popsci.com/intel-teraflop-chip#page-2
- rafiki6 8y agoAs with most technologists and futurists, he fails to grasp that things take time, lots of time, to make meaningful progress and adoption.
- Koshkin 8y agoAs we do not possess a clear (or, at least, a generally accepted) definition of what constitutes the "true AI," it seems very likely that we will cross this "even horizon" without realizing it; we may have done it already, for all we know (or, rather, don't know - due to the fact that much of the progress is being done in secrecy).
- jimmytucson 8y agoWhat if human beings were physically connected to a growing network of perfectly organized facts and information? What if that network could even assist with basic logical reasoning tasks? Would that be enough to say we’ve reached the singularity? It doesn’t seem like it now because our phones aren’t quite physically connected to our brains, and the internet is far from organized, but I’d venture to say we’re already pretty close. A more interesting question to me is whether this is really anything we want. If human machines were infinitely intelligent then they would all agree. So you wouldn’t need more than one. Sure, the ultimate human might need 7 billion pairs of eyes but those eyes wouldn’t need any more brains than to fuel up and locomote. Furthermore any human-like tendency to doubt oneself or fall in love or “rock out” would be deemed useless and therefore overridden. Understanding that the purpose of a human is to pass on genes, and that there’s little human or genes left in her, the ultimate human might therefore conclude that her sustenance only disrupts the purposes of organic life forms. Her next and final act would be to destroy herself. This is how I see the end of humanity. Not in a violent clash between artificial and organic intellects, not in a symphony of mushroom clouds, but with the final flip of a switch, in cold, calculated resignation.
- zackmorris 8y agoThe most important part of the talk was when Kurzweil mentioned running partially-trained AIs in simulation to generate more training data than exists in the real world. That was the first clear description of imagination that I've seen, although others have hinted at it, for example the running stick figures (that I think Google's DeepMind) trained to run an obstacle course several times before they actually did it. I might be remembering that wrong, but there have been a few similar examples. Anyway, the reason why the imagination part is important is that nobody today is talking about parallelization when it comes to AI. A few "rules" of AI computing and their limits: * Processing power doubles every year or two for the same cost -> processing power will someday be approximately infinite (for certain classes of computation) * The search space for even the simplest problems is effectively infinite if we don't know the hidden models -> if we know all the hidden models, then large search spaces become tractable * The sequential portion of intelligent decision making is less complex than the parallel portion (computers have been beating us at all sequential operations since perhaps the mid 60s or 70s) -> when the parallel portions are solved, then computers will beat us at all intelligent decision making That last point is really important and exciting, because most of us simply aren't accustomed to thinking in terms of solving problems in parallel. We're thinking "how do we train a self-driving AI to recognize pedestrians and swerve to avoid them" instead of "how do we optimize the solution to the series of equations to drive to the store and back without hitting anything, in a single pass". AIs will soon be looking forward from their current model of the world, running some number of simulations (potentially billions) and choosing the best outcomes, then feeding back those solutions to improve their hidden models of the world. All in parallel, with virtually unlimited computing power. At that point we'll be training AIs like children and will start to see emergent behavior that mimics life. Personally, I don't see how this can possibly be any more than 10 years away, 20 at most (even for rank amateurs like me), given the number of people tinkering on these evolutionary patterns, and the amount of open source research being generated. It kind of haunts me actually. Like, we just started investing in our 401k at work, but I don't have the heart to tell everyone that the singularity will probably arrive before their investments mature. Like, how does one have a child when it's looking like the 20th century reality we're living in isn't going to be around much longer? Do we suffer through the daily grind, the 40 hour weeks of converting our time to money, when AGI will overshoot that within weeks of surpassing our definition of sentience? It literally might make more sense to become a beach bum, or travel the world, go to Amsterdam and spend a few years in a drug-induced haze. Or is the correct answer to keep going through the motions of running the rat race, knowing that it's all a waste of time but constructing some kind of inner monologue to distract us from the depression induced by the real world's unfolding existential nightmare? Is there a way to un-take the red pill and go back to the blue pill? I guess I digress, but this is literally all I think about anymore. The futility of work/culture/technology in a world of ever-increasing human subterfuge. Why can't we admit that the dystopia is playing out before our eyes and begin to escape the yoke? I guess the one thing that keeps me going is that we might be able to break down a single day into its component parts and automate away anything that's beneath human potential so that we can do the stuff we'd like to do (like nothing). The Roomba can vacuum (done). The self-driving Uber can take us to work and back (almost done). The rooftop solar panels can pay our electric bill (effectively done). And so on, until there is no minutia left. The last step will be to spin up a partial (of oneself) to go to work and earn the paycheck, or literally grow the food to feed us so we no longer have any external dependencies. This is the part that I think is roughly 10 years away.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yters 8y agoAI is mechanical turks all the way down and always will be.
- tux1968 8y agoThen humans are as well, yes? What exactly is the magic in human cognition that is impossible to replicate in silicon?
- imtringued 8y agoThe brain is denser, more efficient and 3 dimensional. Compared to the current limitations of silicon the combination of those three aspects is downright magical.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoYawn. Of course he has to say this, he makes his living saying stuff like this. He is, after all, a ”futurist”. It just seems rather trite at this point.
- narrator 8y agoI think we will find limited use for general AI since we won't be able to properly regulate or understand the behavior of machines that are smarter than us. Alpha Go Zero can't explain why it plays chess the way it does except for showing how it evaluates the board, but the reasoning is buried in millions of mathematical calculations accreted via millions of games of self play that we can't understand the intuition of. Of course, many smart players can't really tell you systematically how they make the moves they do either. AI will be like a dictator who makes his decisions by intuition only.
- jobigoud 8y agoAn intelligent black box can still be "useful". It could help cure diseases or get original insights in many fields for example. Even if we don't understand how it thinks.
- narrator 8y agoSure, but these are narrow AI applications. The great and powerful Oz general AI will be of limited utility unless there is a man behind the curtain.
- jobigoud 8y agoIf narrow AI can be useful despite being a black box, AGI can also be useful even if it's a black box. All the human scientists in the world are black boxes. An AGI could be another researcher, just maybe more productive. We don't need to understand how it thinks to understand the paper it writes.
- md224 8y agoI've felt for a long time that Singularitarians are looking in the wrong place. They see accelerated technological development and assume that the endpoint will be an artificial brain in a box. What they fail to see is that these inventions and breakthroughs haven't been about increasing the intelligence of a machine... they've been about increasing the intelligence and efficiency of human systems. The singularity isn't a brain in a box... it's us, the collective, a metasystem transition that's been underway for millennia. A movement toward a whole that transcends the parts.
- corysama 8y agoCan we please as least try to steer it towards https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/As_We_May_Think https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/As_We_May_Think ?
- goatlover 8y agoThat's what seems apparent to me, so far anyway. AI is more about augmenting human intelligence than it is about smart machines. All that impressive DL stuff is ultimately providing more tools for humans to be more productive.
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoRay Kurtzweil is certainly super smart, but I find his views about the Singularity disturbingly myopic. It's as if he has been living in a bubble for decades, and doesn't realize how the world works for real. I still have a lot of sympathy for him, as I'm sure he means good. Still, these views distort our reality for many people.
- manigandham 8y agoOf course it will happen. We humans are an outcome that took billions of years and yet here we are. It might take a billion more to get sentient AI but as long there is progress then the end is inevitable. The only debate is when it'll happen, but we probably need an advanced sentient AI to help figure that out.
- vkou 8y agoOn pace to do what? Add numbers really fast? Play chess? Make a best guess of which news story I want to see? (Hint: not sports) Perform automatic gear shifting? Follow the vehicle in front of it? Kurzweil has long been preaching that there will be a qualitative revolution in what AI will achieve - and it has been 15 years away, for the past three decades.
- tim333 8y agoNot actually true, the always 15 years away bit. Three decades ago (1990) his prediction was Turing test and AGI in 2020–2050. More recently he's predicted Turning test 2029. He may be wrong but doesn't keep shifting the dates 15 years away. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzweil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predictions_made_by_Ray_Kurzwe... )
- tim333 8y agoI think Moravec's arguments on the same subject "When will computer hardware match the human brain?" are a little less cranky than Kurzweil's and his prediction from 1998 "it is predicted that the required hardware will be available in cheap machines in the 2020s" seems to be panning out. https://jetpress.org/volume1/moravec.htm https://jetpress.org/volume1/moravec.htm
- crappy-doo 8y agooh Ray... how about you stop waving your hands, sit down and shut up...
- gaussdiditfirst 8y agoCheck out Rodney Brooks' blog to see some predictions from somebody who actually has at least some idea of what they're talking about: https://rodneybrooks.com/predictions-scorecard-2019-january-01/ https://rodneybrooks.com/predictions-scorecard-2019-january-... However as the ML researcher Michael Jordan (one of the most important in the field) has previously stated, these sort of long-term technology predictions are just fun science fiction and there is essentially no academic rigor in this stuff: https://medium.com/@mijordan3/artificial-intelligence-the-revolution-hasnt-happened-yet-5e1d5812e1e7 https://medium.com/@mijordan3/artificial-intelligence-the-re...