12 ms·
Deep learning pioneer Yoshua Bengio is worried about AI’s future
- joe_the_user 8y agoHe's talking mostly about military technology. I'd agree that killer-robots would be horrible - for the potential to make military action easier, to make it even easier for a single mad man launch a war and so-forth. I don't think "real" military AI is that close because things on the battle-field have to be robust and current AI seems to be inherently fragile - not always reliable and less reliable in chaotic situations. But semi-military applications like deciding who a drone will kill have potential ... to do even more harm than drones have already done.
- atupis 8y agoThat semi-military approach is already happening https://www.theguardian.com/science/the-lay-scientist/2016/feb/18/has-a-rampaging-ai-algorithm-really-killed-thousands-in-pakistan https://www.theguardian.com/science/the-lay-scientist/2016/f...
- EGreg 8y agoIs that drone carrying out kills w no humans in the loop?
- wnkrshm 8y agoNo but if the humans in the loop trust the algorithm so much, they're more like executive agents of the algorithm than the ones making the decisions. Just because you don't automate the step of actually launching the missile doesn't mean a machine can't be the originator of the order.
- KineticLensman 8y agoNo. Predator / Reaper drones are remotely piloted via satcoms link by a crew of two or three, typically pilot / sensor/ weapon operator. They are not autonomous with the exception of auto-pilot functions. The crew are typically embedded in a larger HQ where there may be political / legal cells to advise. If the target list is wrong it won’t help the targets but the human in the loop may help to avoid blowing up a school accidentally, depending on the amount of collateral damage that can be accepted for a given target.
- mtgx 8y ago> I don't think "real" military AI is that close because things on the battle-field have to be robust and current AI seems to be inherently fragile - not always reliable and less reliable in chaotic situations. Do you think the military contractors pushing their military AI solutions care about that? Do the people approving those solutions (usually those in Congress that assign the budgets) know enough to make the distinction between "highly effective AI" and "poor/broken AI that won't achieve its promised objectives during battle"? Do they even care, or do they care more about their campaign donations? The CIA and NSA have already used awfully inaccurate algorithms to send drones to kill "targets" (like people who they thought used a certain phone number). Why do you think it will be any different with AI killer robots? The algorithms will likely be just as inaccurate based on the biased/flawed data the AI will be fed, but the damage (civilian casualties) will be multiplied 10-100x due to how much easier/cheaper it will be to create and operate AI killer robots.
- deepnotderp 8y agoI don't understand the argument against military robots and AI. Why is it more moral to send men to die instead of machines? Edit: About asymmetry in the battlefield, yes, but then you should say the same of all advanced weaponry, right? Each side is aspiring for asymmetry in war technology. About the army refusing to carry out orders. That's a good point that I hadn't thought of. I'm not super sure that current humans are really that great, but it's a fair point. About the cost of war. High end military technology is very expensive and something this sophisticated probably won't be cheap. But even disregarding that, I would prefer thousands of machines being destroyed to humans dying.
- beojan 8y agoThe problem is AI taking the decision to kill people.
- wetpaws 8y agoGet your own AI, problem solved.
- drb91 8y agoOne robot vs state violence?
- wetpaws 8y agoI should've probably elaborate on my comment cause of course people will reflexively downvote it, but proxy wars, smaller armies, and now AI driven conflicts are the natural evolution of warfare. We went from slaughter of millions to hanful of extremely professional soldiers to, eventually fight of machines. (MGS4 depicted it in striking details years ago).
- simion314 8y agoDo you think that a country would surrender because your robots won a robot fight? There will still be an army and an occupation resistance movement that will fight your robots and lives will still be lost. The attackers would continue to destroy the roads,train station, food reserves, energy production facilities ... maybe AI is the future but is not better and we should try to make killer robots usage illegal.
- killjoywashere 8y ago> I don’t completely trust military organizations, because they tend to put duty before morality Ah, first, a duty flows from a moral position, so perhaps the master misspoke. Second, I submit you can strongly trust military organizations to do their duty. They will stop at nothing to kill their enemies with extreme prejudice. And the people who lead military organizations, in most cases, have thought quite long and hard about their moral positions. It is the nature of the business, when sending people to die, to question everything about yourself. Now, that doesn't mean war is a civilized affair. It is awful, insane. And I frankly don't know a lot of senior military leaders who have ever been eager to go to war, except in cases where they believed the operation truly met the standards of jus ad bellum. What you often find in histories are senior officers getting replaced when their advice to not enter war is not in line with the positions of their civilian leadership.
- Joe-Z 8y agoHey! It sounds like you know what you're talking about. Could you maybe point me to some sources on where one could read up on how military leaders decide to go to war, what set of morals they need to come up with to be able to send people to war or this "jus ad bellum"-concept (never heard of that before). I would really appreciate it!
- baxtr 8y agoNot quite what you looking for, but I found this source insightful regarding how the military think about leadership. Very progressive I’d say, see for example the Gardener’s approach http://leadership.au.af.mil/sls-skil.htm http://leadership.au.af.mil/sls-skil.htm
- killjoywashere 8y agoMilitary leaders don't decide to go to war. That's for elected leaders. Waging war and studying how to wage war are the proper roles of the military. That said, any civilian leader with a clue should ask their military commanders what a war would entail, those critical "how much" questions. And if the numbers don't add up, probably take a pass, look for a diplomatic solution. This is where honest warriors like Shinseki lose their jobs and people like McNamara, Taylor, and Westmoreland end up in charge. As for reading up on the general principles upon which the Western world built its world order, how to know when a war would be just, the collected works of Plato, starting with The Republic, and the stoics would be a good start. I would advise Irvine's Guide to the Good Life as an introduction to the stoics. I would also add Errol Morris's The Fog of War, including McNamara's separate 10 lessons (1), and, as counterpoint, Ken Burns' Vietnam series. The two together are an unparalleled view of the entry into war, and its consequences. (1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fog_of_War#Ten_additional_lessons_from_R.S._McNamara https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fog_of_War#Ten_additional_...
- eksemplar 8y agoOne of the first cyberpunk books I read opens with a drone hit on some European business man at a company resort. It seems like we’re hell bent on making this reality. I mean, military AI is basically an inevitable future for us at this point, and while it’ll probably take a few years to leak into private hands, it eventually will, and the world will be a little more shitty for it. Aside from that I’d rue the day the Americans get AI murder drones, especially if I was living in one of the 7 or 9 countries they are currently assassinating people in with the use of the current drone fleet. As terrible as a murder assassin drone is, it’s at least controlled by a supposedly moral being.
- Joe-Z 8y agoMeh, maybe it's not that bad. Sure, you'll get the occasional psycho trying to kill his pop-star stalker-victim. But for many high profile people - politicians, mega-corp CEOs, media tycoons - it might be a good way keeping them in line, knowing 'the people' can finally strike back again. For most normal/low-profile people this won't be a profile... since most of us don't have arch-enemies. (Playing devil's advocate here, so please take this with a grain of salt ;))
- bendoernberg 8y agoSounds like the "Assassination Market" theory of decentralizing power from the 1990s.
- chobeat 8y agoNo future is inevitable. That's what the californian ideology convinced you of.
- colechristensen 8y agoMy first thoughts were on the failure of logic of just being opposed to the military doing things without proposing how they should reasonably behave but... Well it seems like the author of the article had the headline in mind before even talking to YB. The responses don't seem like well thought ideas on a complex topic, they seem like random off-the-cuff answers to a journalist's leading questions, and it isn't fair to criticize them.
- break_the_bank 8y agoWith the AI soldier/killer drones the second amendment becomes fairly useless. The government cannot bleed.
- jahewson 8y agoUnfortunately the Supreme Court already ruled that the second amendment applies to self defence irrespective of the “militia” part (DC vs Heller, 2008).
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoThe ruling specifically focused on the militia aspect militia. Quoting that ruling: The prefatory clause comports with the Court’s interpretation of the operative clause. The "militia" comprised all males physically capable of acting in concert for the common defense. The Antifederalists feared that the Federal Government would disarm the people in order to disable this citizens’ militia, enabling a politicized standing army or a select militia to rule. The response was to deny Congress power to abridge the ancient right of individuals to keep and bear arms, so that the ideal of a citizens’ militia would be preserved. People conflate militia now a days with military, but they are not the same. The "militia" are the armed citizens of a state. And similarly the security of a free state is talking explicitly about security against government itself - not foreign invaders, which was the domain of the federal government. An armed population can prevent the imposition of tyrannical rule, an unarmed population cannot. In verbose modern text the amendment might read something like, "A well regulated and armed population being necessary for the protection of a state against tyranny, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed."
- arminiusreturns 8y agoUnfortunately people tend to forget or were never taught that the people have natural rights they still retain even if they aren't referenced in the bill of rights, and that indeed that was one of the main arguments against the bill of rights in the first place (that the government would see the incomplete list and think those were all we had, which is a repudiation of the foundations of the American system). Only one of such rights is the right of self defense, being independent from the right of a militia to keep and bear arms in defense against tyranny. In other words, you could remove the second amendment and the people would still have the right to bear arms.
- dnprock 8y agoAI researchers over romanticize their robot AI technology. They don't know enough about wars. Morality is something we talk about outside of the battlefield. It is not going to be your robot army fighting a human army. Instead, it will be your robot army fighting another robot army, perhaps less sophisticated. They'll supplement their disadvantage with humans. You want to be the army with more advanced robots. Otherwise you'll need to put humans on the line. Always better to equip yourself with better fighting capability.
- onion2k 8y agoIt is not going to be your robot army fighting a human army. Instead, it will be your robot army fighting another robot army, perhaps less sophisticated. I don't think there are any current conflicts[1] that could reasonably be described as being between two armies. It's more often between one group of armies from several countries working together and several groups of [terrorists|freedom fighters|"unlawful combatants" ] using guerrilla tactics to attack them. The exception are the ongoing civil wars, but they tend to be an army fighting rebel groups in that country - would rebels ever get their own robots? How would that happen? It's obviously possible that we'll see two armies of robots fighting in the future, but that's not really what war is right now. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflicts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_confli...
- dnprock 8y agoThe Syrian government got Russian weapons, air support. They even have chemical weapons. One side or many sides. You can be sure that the other sides are not fighting with their bare hands.
- discoball 8y agoThe right to bear arms was given to humans who happen to live in this so-called freedom loving country. It was never given to autonomous non-human entities. So while the military may develop robotic kill squads their non-military use is illegal. Unless the treasonous Supreme Court doubles down on their treason and give the right to bear arms to AI, by considering AI to be a digital person with rights. It could happen. The Supreme Court judges have already shown that they're fully capable of making decisions that favor big corporations over us the people. Why not autonomous bots? After all, big enough corporations are pretty much autonomous (as they follow profit above all and do so regardless of who is in charge of them).
- shard972 8y agoSeems like it could go either way, its not like the bots themselves need the rights or become legal entities beyond a weapon. Now maybe this weapon fires by you telling it to shoot that guy over there, or it's programmed to shoot anyone who enters through that door over there, but in the end it's still a weapon under control and responsibility of the owner.
- discoball 8y agoWhat you describe is not Autonomous AI that is driven by a dynamic mission, as the military AI will be. An AI killer bot can be developed that not only tries to achieve the goal specified by the mission but also alter the mission as needed to achieve a higher level goal, and the higher you go up in the goal specification the more autonomy you're giving to the machine.
- dev_north_east 8y ago> treasonous Supreme Court How is it treasonous?
- discoball 8y agoThey allowed corporations to vote with their money and buy candidates. Undermined our ”By the People. For the People” fantasy.
- clintsim 8y agoUu
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wiz21c 8y agoFTA : >>> The best students want to go to the best companies. If you're a parent, maybe it's time to teach your kids that "going to the best company" may not be the best outcome for a citizen of the world.
- TangoTrotFox 8y agoPeople too often come to one side or another of an issue without considering context and alternatives. War unfortunately drags everybody down to the lowest common denominator. The reason for this is that the lowest common denominator, the nation that would act with the greatest disregard for anything other than their own victory, is the nation that wins wars and gets to set the rules for the rest of the world. In 1945 the United States became the only nation to ever launch a nuclear strike on another country. In a two moment's flashes we killed hundreds of thousands of individuals - the vast majority being innocent civilians playing no direct role in the war whatsoever. But that act of arguable amorality not only immediately ended a world war, but has since led to a great fear of war among any nation with these weapons which has led to an unprecedented period of relative world peace. This [1] great video shows the borders of Europe throughout time. The sudden lapse in that constant warfare and transition, the one we now still live in, that occurs just shortly after the more widespread development of nuclear weapons is striking. But nuclear weapons will not remain the ultimate weapon and deterrent forever. And whichever nation is able to develop appropriate defenses against nuclear weapons and offenses beyond nuclear, will be the same nation that decides the direction of our species moving onward into the future. Again, it's a lowest common denominator problem - but it's one that's ultimately unavoidable by any means other than by ensuring that you yourself are always the most militarily capable nation. And ideally multiple nations will develop these weapons in unison. I'm not particularly fond of e.g. China having unopposed reign throughout the world, but neither am I fond of the idea of an unopposed reign of e.g. the United States. I think we find the best outcomes when we have multiple balanced powers, and in this regard it is our responsibility to never fall behind. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9YnYRk8_kE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P9YnYRk8_kE
- pietroppeter 8y ago> we need to be able to extend it to do things like reasoning, learning causality, and exploring the world in order to learn and acquire information. Having recently read the Book of Why by Judea Pearl, I found particularly interesting his remarks on causality. Pearl’s approach is based on causality being a testable assumption that requires domain expertise to be expressed. Having done that, it provides powerful techiques to address causal questions from data. Any efforts towards a general AI capable of causal reasoning should instead be able to create causal assumption from experience and “reasoning”. I have not seen around (have not looked much) discussion on how to combine general purpose AI approaches such as DL with domain specific approaches such as the Causal Inference techniques described by Pearl. Anyone has references to share?
- gaius 8y agodon’t completely trust military organizations, because they tend to put duty before morality The rockets go up, who cares where they come down / That’s not my department says Werner von Braun
- rademacher 8y agoSo he's saying that concentration of "wealth" is bad, and war is bad. A quick glance at the definition of moral gives, "a person's standards of behavior or beliefs concerning what is and is not acceptable for them to do" which suggests that they may be fluid. Are killer robots necessarily any less moral than killer humans? We seek to replace humans with "robots" in many cases under the assumption that they perform better. I suppose in the case of killer robots this could mean more effective killing, or perhaps it could mean more accurate strikes and less civilian casualties? (I'm not saying I am an advocate for military AI, just posing some questions). Finally, suggesting that we need to focus less on incremental progress when DL still isn't completely understood seems premature. I'm not sure another great leap in AI is on the horizon until a leap in computational power or a new framework is discovered.
- indigochill 8y agoMy take on the "robots mean more accurate/less risky warfare" is that that's precisely the problem, actually (at least if we start from the assumption that war is bad). By "industrializing" warfare and reducing the cost in lives, we make it more politically palatable. Risk assessment is a massive part of waging war. If the risk to one side is reduced by using robots (or other weapons-of-cheap-destruction) instead of humans, then the likelihood that side will favor war as a conflict resolution mechanism is (all other things being equal) increased. On the other hand, if the risk is too high, then alternative options are more likely to be favored. This seems to be the thinking around things like nuclear disarmament and why proliferation is generally seen as a bad thing despite nukes being hands-down the most cost-effective way to end a war (at least against an enemy not similarly equipped - see the Cold War). The reason given for the US bombing of Japan was to save lives by shortening the war - though I'm not about to get into whether that decision was justified. And that's before we introduce AI, which has had notorious bugs like failing to identify dark-skinned faces relative to light-skinned faces (https://www.bostonmagazine.com/news/2018/02/23/artificial-intelligence-race-dark-skin-bias/ https://www.bostonmagazine.com/news/2018/02/23/artificial-in...) or driverless car crashes. As uncomfortable as I am with proliferation of killer tech in general, introducing AI actually makes my skin crawl. Even without the unpredictability of AI, "precision strikes" are not necessarily as precise as their name implies: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2014/nov/24/-sp-us-drone-strikes-kill-1147 https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2014/nov/24/-sp-us-drone...
- noir-york 8y ago"“Some rogue country will develop these things.” My answer is that one, we want to make them feel guilty for doing it" Feel guilty?! The man may have contributed greatly to the field of AI, but that kind of comment just comes across as very naive about how the world works. "Shouldn’t AI experts work with the military to ensure this happens? If they had the right moral values, fine." The military adheres to the laws of war and is lead by a civilian politician, not a pope. A nation's military carries out the policies of the civilian leadership. If you want a moral military, get moral politicians. I don't understand why the distate at one's own military forces. These people are not aliens, they're fellow Americans, or French or Japanese or wherever you're from. At least for the major democracies, these men and women are volunteering to defend your ass. They don't get to start wars, the politicans you vote for do. I very much want the military forces of my country to kick the ass of any threat, and if some tech such as AI could help eliminate that threat faster and with less blood than brilliant.
- PavlovsCat 8y ago> These people are not aliens, they're fellow Americans, or French or Japanese or wherever you're from. Unless they're a threat that needs its "ass kicked", of course. Which is an euphemism for killing them dead. But that's somehow not worse than simply critizing people, wanting them to be more alive, by connecting their deeds and the consequences of those deeds? Any teenager can realize this: Militaries only positive use is to defend against other militaries, it's like a debugger that can only debug bugs in itself, but it can also be used to slaughter civilians, and does that quite a bit too much already. > They don't get to start wars, the politicans you vote for do. Then how come George Bush wasn't booed of that aircraft carrier when he declared mission accomplished? If you want respect, if you don't want to be ashamed, don't get caught in situations like that. If you want respect, instead of shame, by the time something like Abu Ghraib reaches the public it should include details about the ruckus that caused in the military, and how people got beaten up by their comrades for partaking in the torture of people, long before the police could get to them. And so on. Instead, we get these uncanny valley stories about honor and duty and whatnot, by people who don't quite remember what being human is, but also can't quite leave humans alone so they can find a solution for this mess. When I opted against military service I didn't just say no, I wrote them a kinda fiery letter. If 19 year old me can do that, others can do it, too. But now I don't even get to criticize the military because I'm not in it, because they "volunteered to defend me"? Nah. I see the ads for the Bundeswehr, they volunteered because they're not right in the head if they responded to any of that. They want power, importance, comraderie. Anything BUT personal deep responsibility, which is why all the promotional material is about how joining the army is "stepping up", just like you repeat the old chestnut of the military protecting us, rather than leeching off and killing us. By "us" I mean humans, not $country, since as I said out that country stuff cancels itself out. If people want respect, let them be respectable. If they do shameful shit, they get shamed. If you are for the swift elimination of threats you should welcome that. And yes, I do feel for soldiers, I just hide it very well. The thought of kids getting sent off to be made murderers for the protection of the wealth of people who couldn't give a shit about them, that doesn't make me think "serves them right", it breaks my heart. But that doesn't mean I buy into all those rationalizions that always get trotted out. They don't hold up, and at at this level of technology we simply cannot allow that level of foolishness anymore.
- plaidfuji 8y ago>> and it has proved incredibly powerful and effective for all sorts of practical tasks, from voice recognition and image classification to controlling self-driving cars and automating business decisions. > and it has proved incredibly powerful and effective for all sorts of practical tasks, from signal processing and signal processing to signal processing and a dubious application of deep learning
- nabla9 8y ago"It should be noted that no ethically-trained software engineer would ever consent to write a `DestroyBaghdad' procedure. Basic professional ethics would instead require him to write a `DestroyCity' procedure, to which `Baghdad' could be given as a parameter." -- Nathaniel S. Borenstein, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathaniel_Borenstein https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nathaniel_Borenstein
- Dirlewanger 8y agodeleted
- tim333 8y agoI think Borenstein's thing was a joke about people not being very ethical.
- Dirlewanger 8y agoRight over my head...
- netcan 8y agoSeems like the interviewer focuses a lot on juicy questions where Bengio does not have highly developed answers. (Q: AI for War? A: Bad) Where his opinions are more interesting is the last questions, outside of the articles agenda of "stuff to freak out about." Asked what new progress areas he's excited about, Bengio (charmingly) responds with slow progress areas he's frustrated with. Anyone know (or can guess) if he's refering to anything specific when he (I'm connecting dots) using deep learning to "learn causality?"
- haskellandchill 8y agoDeep learning has failed to develop symbolic learning, things like model building and causal reasoning using a model, hypothesis generation and model selection, etc have not seen much of that. This is something Judea Pearl has been pointing at lately.
- Voloskaya 8y agoOne of the related project he mentioned being very interested in is Baby AI, which is trying to improve grounded language learning, so incorporating world knowledge into NLP: * https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.08272 https://arxiv.org/abs/1810.08272 * https://github.com/mila-udem/babyai https://github.com/mila-udem/babyai
- tim333 8y agoAs a devils advocate for military AI, it might be better in some ways - after all if you are lunching military action do you want it to be unintelligent? The trend has been from blanket bombing killing mostly civilians to precision strikes taking out some bad guys and some wedding parties and in the future AI robots might be able to do things like disable vehicles without killing the soldiers.
- hummingurban 8y agoHow much sleep would he lose when you realize the very educational institutions which he attended were designed by large to benefit the military's R&D? Anything we invent or discover can and will be used by the military or intelligence agencies and even law enforcement agencies who are doing real human right violations. Hell, there are graduates that go work for the government because it's stable, or even unwittingly be writing RAT or researching zero days. The truth is, as researchers, engineers, our guesses are as good as touching a part of the elephant. Everyone thinks the part they hold are the whole, and make the claim, this is what an elephant should be. When in fact, if you follow the authors logic, we are all complicit. Every walk of life is influenced by the military and for the military. Internet? Designed for resilient military comm against nuclear attacks. Microwave? TV? Radio? So the genie is out of the bag and now is going to work for the military. Should we feel outraged? Should we stop all AI research because of the authors view that the military kills people so its automatically evil? What about the people who are ready to give their lives so these researchers can continue living and doing great work? It seems to me that beggars can't be choosers. It's good to have a strong sense of morality so you don't end up writing a RAT tool for a corrupt government that ends up torturing dissidents. But rarely will you even know who is using it and where it's being applied. It's simply designed so you don't have to be burdened with the moral dillemma of how a state should think and behave. By large, a state is not a person, no conscious, no morals only national interests dictated by the few in power. This skewed power dynamics will remove the decision makers from the burden of making immoral decisions to further "national" agenda. ex) Do we torture an alleged terrorist to extract information that can stop an imminent attack on hundreds? It's certainly not the call of the people who wrote the software to manage torture and it's not the call of those who follow orders. We are ruled by ideology, the one that sells to us constantly of an unknown, unpredictable threat. If the author has anything to blame, it is that people by far and large have already voted with their money and hearts-ignorance is bliss, gathering material wealth is priority.
- FakeComments 8y agoThere’s also a cohort who simply believe that working for the government is a good thing. That the violence they inflict — particularly if it means RATs-not-missiles — is justified. For two reasons: If we look at human history, we’ve collectively tried a lot of things — and short of getting rid of technology and going back to tribes that can’t broadly interact, I’m not sure there’s really a better solution than something akin to Western style democracies and the world order built around them. That’s not to say they’re infallible or perfect, just that empirically they lead to a human and cultural flourishing that’s hard to compete with. There are many real dangers out there, and many people feel it’s worth defending — classmates who become soldiers, classmates who became politicians, etc. Is it really so surprising some programmers or other STEM people feel the same way? Secondly, many of us have friends in the military. It’s a hard sell to imply that we shouldn’t help them maintain military dominance, for a number of reasons.
- nuguy 8y agoThis shocks me. Here is this man who is clearly a complete novice in international politics, economics and history. He says that we should make rogue countries “feel guilty” for developing malicious ai implementations. He hand-waves away the military as simpletons who “act on duty” like a f*king high school student. When confronted with the existential threats of ai he launches into an analysis of African visa process and “inclusivity.” This is complete and utter garbage. Worst of all he talks about reaching general, human-like ai without ever mentioning that it is basically an automatic extinction level event for human kind. If you disagree then check out my comment history and change my mind. Preventing general ai is extremely important and anyone who wants to form some kind of group to encourage regulation and legislation around ai please get in touch with me.
- eli_gottlieb 8y ago>Right now, we don’t really have good algorithms for this, but I think if enough people work at it and consider it important, we will make advances. Yeah, I think there's a lot of space for advances, if we can combine different backgrounds and intuitions. I'm working on a project where I try to combine some programming-language semantics and Bayesian learning to learn structures.
- gdrift 8y agoAdditional read: "Autonomous Military Robotics: Risk, Ethics, and Design" By Ethics + Emerging Sciences Group at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, sponsored by the Department of the Navy In this report, we will present: the presumptive case for the use of autonomous military robotics; the need to address risk and ethics in the field; the current and predicted state of military robotics; programming approaches as well as relevant ethical theories and considerations (including the Laws of War, Rules of Engagement); a framework for technology risk assessment; ethical and social issues, both near- and far-term; and recommendations for future work. http://ethics.calpoly.edu/ONR_report.pdf http://ethics.calpoly.edu/ONR_report.pdf and "Malak" by Peter Watts Inside the mind of an autonomous drone with a conscience, but as usual with Watts it all goes wrong. https://rifters.com/real/shorts/PeterWatts_Malak.pdf https://rifters.com/real/shorts/PeterWatts_Malak.pdf
- chooga 8y agoThis is not worth reading. I worked with Bengio for a couple of years, and he's a classic example of a not-particularly-talented mid-level prof who's been elevated by the bubble of hype in his field, attracted some talented students who publish papers on which he ends up as a coauthor... and now thinks he is a voice of authority in AI (and many other fields). Those who disagree with me -- can you name a single important contribution to the field he has made, that wasn't in fact done by one of his students? Hinton did backprop, leCun did convnets, Schmidhuber did LSTMs, and Bengio did ... ?
- patio131 8y agoI think we should all remember that being a pioneer in AI does not give you any experience or authority in international politics...