12 ms·
The death of Google
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI thought Lauren does a good job here of distinguishing between the people who work at a company, and the emergent behavior of a company based on profit motive or other incentives. Larry Bossidy wrote a book on confronting reality[1] which I found interesting because it tackles some of the issues facing Google today. Basically when you compare your new businesses (Google X, Other bets) to your monster business (Search Advertising) they look puny and weak. But sometimes if you considered them on their own they would look like good things. One of the PMs I knew at Google told me (as he was leaving) that Google was the only place he knew where you could get fired after creating a $100M/year ARR business. That is only $25M/quarter which was only a .3% increase in revenue, so a loser right? But how many people would love to be in charge of a business generating $100M/yr in revenue? Lots! The reality Google is missing is that there isn't another "search advertising" business but there might be 100 other smaller businesses that they could invent/run just as profitably. But it is hard to see that. [1] Confronting Reality -- https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Reality-Master-Model-Success-ebook/dp/B000FC2JN4/ https://www.amazon.com/Confronting-Reality-Master-Model-Succ...
- fjsolwmv 8y agoWould you want to run a $100MM/yr business that costs $120MM/yr to run?
- qaq 8y agoSure if it had metrics VCs like it could easily be a Unicorn
- Jtsummers 8y agoPotentially. What's it doing and what's its value to the world and the corporation it exists within? What if you have a product that brings a great deal of value to many people, but for various reasons you can't collect much revenue on it. You could be operating at a loss, but still producing great value. In that case, if there were a way to cover that $20MM/year gap (corporation sinks profits from other divisions into it, for instance) it could be worthwhile. Or perhaps that business that's losing money brings in customers who go to the other divisions and make them profitable. That is, its return is indirect and hard to measure (though not necessarily hard to verify).
- saudioger 8y agoThere are a lot of startups that are in worse shape than that and hope to be profitable someday.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> Even if Google creates a cancer vaccine I'd be tired of seeing their brand. Gonna guess you've never had a loved one die of cancer.
- ratfaced-guy 8y agoOr maybe they should just start paying dividends.
- ardfie 8y agoMakes me think of Peter Thiel's comments here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Q26XIKtwXQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Q26XIKtwXQ
- rplst8 8y agoMan I'd like to hear more of that.
- chrisbradshaw 8y agohttps://youtu.be/PsXFwy6gG_4 https://youtu.be/PsXFwy6gG_4
- sjg007 8y agoPeter is pretty much on the money here. Google's biggest (search engine) threat is Facebook if FB can get their act together. Second is Amazon since they can be a one stop shop. But his comment came before the AI 2nd revolution hit mainstream which has changed R&D at all of the tech companies. Google does have some problems though, it can't go to far down the DoD, Darpa route since Googlers don't want to work with the military (as the article describes) and then it may miss out on innovation in China by not having a Chinese presence and offices in China to get at that talent. That ship may have sailed though as Alibaba and Baidu are giant. What Google really needs to do is unleash its human capital.
- trhway 8y ago>The reality Google is missing is that there isn't another "search advertising" business but there might be 100 other smaller businesses that they could invent/run just as profitably. But it is hard to see that. i don't think Google missing it, i think they're running a similar model to VC - better hit another one or a couple of 100B+ Unicorns than a 100 of 100M small businesses. >Google was the only place he knew where you could get fired after creating a $100M/year ARR business. That is only $25M/quarter which was only a .3% increase in revenue, so a loser right? the same like VC do - no signs of horn in 2-3 years, just cut the "losses" (i.e. take your 2-4x investment growth) and move on.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nostrademons 8y ago"i think they're running a similar model to VC - better hit another one or a couple of 100B+ Unicorns than a 100 of 100M small businesses." It occurs to me that the VC model itself makes a certain set of assumptions about where we are in the economic cycle. It only works if a.) there are industries that can be reinvented by the application of technology in a way that disrupts all the existing firms and b.) those firms are too blind, too set in their ways, or too structurally rigid to adapt that technology. This has been the case from the 1980s onwards, but was not the case from roughly 1920-1980. At some point we're going to hit the end of the current cycle, and then any firm based upon that assumption is just going to die through bad bets. I don't think we're there yet, but it's interesting to think about the assumptions underlying the model.
- kamaal 8y agoThe VC model exists largely because these people max out on investing in traditional instruments. Beyond that they have to look at some thing like a VC business. In his investment class Martin Shkreli talked about this topic in specific. Its just that after a while you realize you can't squeeze much juice out of a fruit anymore, no matter hard you try. At that point, your only options are acquiring good businesses or starting investing into new ones. I think the reason why your $100M project was shut down is may be they realized if they wanted wanted make $100M out of something they might as well buy a bond, it makes no sense to run a people team, pay them and manage them all for their scale of profits. Either way it also looks dripping with hubris if your shutting opportunities that could put $100M on the table with little effort.
- riku_iki 8y agoAlso there are possibly other search ads scale businesses inside google, like youtube ads, display ads, mobile ads, play, cloud, docs.. We just don't know what is ARR for search ads.
- dabei 8y agoWhen you compare a new initiative with established business the dollar values doesn't matter. If it's inline with the company's core mission it's worth doing even if it makes significant loss. But when the team could be working on something closer to the core mission, or much higher revenue potential projects it make sense to cut a $100M business.
- nostrademons 8y agoHeh. My first project at Google made roughly $100M/year. It was shut down by my department (Search) after 3 years because it "didn't move the needle", resurrected by Ads for another couple years because it apparently moved the needle enough to make it worthwhile for them, then shut down for good. I remember joking "Well, could I buy it off you if you don't want it? I'd love to have a $100M business", but it was a little too integrated with Google's systems & salesforce to make that feasible.
- rabidrat 8y agoToo bad they don't have Amazon's foresight to platformize their systems and salesforce.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThat is a very salient observation. Of course if they did that they would lose people who would step out, start their own business and just rent Google's infrastructure, but as AWS has shown that could become a meaningful part of their annual return anyway.
- simula67 8y agoI doubt it was lack of vision. For a long time, one of Google's most important competitive edges was it's efficient infrastructure. With AWS coming in and Google moving to become an AI company, data probably became a more serious competitive advantage and they started Google Cloud Project
- IAmGraydon 8y ago$100M in net revenue? What was the cost to start, run and maintain this project?
- nostrademons 8y ago3 engineers. I (and a teammate) carried a pager for about 6 months but then Search SRE took over ops; it shared backends with other search systems and was primarily a frontend innovation so the marginal cost was minimal. There was some ongoing AdSales cost for it - basically we built a tool to visualize related queries for your search [1] and then AdSales got a hold of it and said "Woah, we can show this to clients and tell them 'These are all the other queries you should be advertising on'", and then the clients spent a whole lot more money advertising on a whole lot more queries. [1] https://www.ducttapemarketing.com/using-google-wonder-wheel-for-visiual-seo/ https://www.ducttapemarketing.com/using-google-wonder-wheel-...
- matwood 8y agoYou have described the classic Innovators Dilemma [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Innovator%27s_Dilemma
- krn 8y ago> I thought Lauren does a good job here of distinguishing between the people who work at a company, and the emergent behavior of a company based on profit motive or other incentives. I have always found a company to be a mirror of its CEO's personality. Think of Apple under Steve Jobs, Microsoft under Satya Nadella, and Uber under Travis Kalanick. A sense of integrity - or a lack of it - plays a huge role in how we feel about the company.
- candiodari 8y agoGoogle's had a lot of CEO's. Who are we talking about ? Larry Page, Eric Schmidt or now Sundar Pichai ?
- krn 8y agoGoogle under Eric Schmidt (from 2001 to 2015) was the one people learnt to love.
- sys_64738 8y agoThis might explain why Apple hasn't released any new Mac Minis recently.
- stcredzero 8y agoI thought Lauren does a good job here of distinguishing between the people who work at a company, and the emergent behavior of a company based on profit motive or other incentives. Throughout the article, is the explicitly stated assumption that Google's enemies/critics are evil. Google has plenty of good critics with good criticisms. That's precisely the kind of substrate of viewpoint, in which Google is somehow anointed, which Lauren forwards and which underlies the very Google hubris she decries.
- ScottBurson 8y agoLauren is actually a "he". (I met him once, probably in 1981.)
- kamaal 8y ago>>One of the PMs I knew at Google told me (as he was leaving) that Google was the only place he knew where you could get fired after creating a $100M/year ARR business. I wonder how much of that is because the organization hierarchies and inner machinations of the people structures are opaque to people like Larry Page and Sergey Brin at their level. Sure these people could form a Google X and search for the next $100 billion businesses. But if you have $100M/yr opportunity products coming up all over the company and you don't even bother to look at them. You are already losing plenty of potential $10Bn/yr opportunities. It should be perfectly possible for these people to chase both moonshot and sky shot opportunities.
- komali2 8y ago>Today’s belated announcement of a security breach related to Google+, People keep calling it a breach, but I thought it was merely an unexploited vulnerability? I may have missed it, but did it come out that there was a breach as well?
- kenhwang 8y ago> merely an unexploited vulnerability The footnote there is, unexploited in the last 2 weeks they had logs for. They have no way of knowing if it was exploited earlier than that.
- foobiekr 8y agoA source would be great if there is one.
- rconti 8y agoI don't know about "2 weeks" but it was clear from Google's announcement that they had no idea. I remember this, because it was posted on an HN thread where the poster claimed it was "unexploited" so I went in expecting that, and Google's own words made it clear they had no idea.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kenhwang 8y agoStraight from their announcement https://www.blog.google/technology/safety-security/project-strobe/ https://www.blog.google/technology/safety-security/project-s... > We made Google+ with privacy in mind and therefore keep this API’s log data for only two weeks. That means we cannot confirm which users were impacted by this bug. However, we ran a detailed analysis over the two weeks prior to patching the bug, and from that analysis, the Profiles of up to 500,000 Google+ accounts were potentially affected. Our analysis showed that up to 438 applications may have used this API. > We found no evidence that any developer was aware of this bug, or abusing the API, and we found no evidence that any Profile data was misused.
- imleft 8y agolink?
- mahemm 8y agoIn case this dies: https://archive.fo/f4RHX https://archive.fo/f4RHX
- jtbayly 8y agoThat is dead, for me. Sadly. Since the original is also dead.
- y0ghur7_xxx 8y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vortex.com/2018/10/08/the-death-of-google https://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vo...
- kenhwang 8y agoGoogle's hubris is believing engineering brilliance alone can solve everything. They are consistently bogglingly bad at human interaction -- communications, PR, management, UX, customer service. There always seems to be a lack of well-roundedness at Google. It didn't really matter back when they just did search, but now that they're expanding into other fields, they're looking more and more like an expert hammerer than an master of many tools.
- crunchlibrarian 8y agoTrying to view every problem through the lens of a probability distribution seems to be Google's only way of looking at the world. Converging every answer to the same hivemind mean is not always the best solution, let's start thinking more about the edge cases and outliers which do actually still exist.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 8y agowhat is selfishness?
- cube2222 8y agoI think you should add some examples. I for one think the opposite. They're the best at giving me exactly the ad which I may like. (I'm not saying I like the idea of an ad)
- monksy 8y agoI really get the feeling that they like they sell the idea of their engineers over the idea that they're helping their customers solve a problem in a better way. That's rather frustrating thing is: they've done some creative things, but it doesn't seem to be so that they've helped anyone. My guess [from their product launches and behavior] It looks like they reward people who make publicity waves and ignore the fact that nothing comes of it. Google wave? Duo/whatever the next chat app.. etc. (Now Google+)
- amelius 8y ago
- Animats 8y agoFacebook is already "Mad Men". Google is getting there.
- 394549 8y agoThe site is down for me, but this works: https://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vortex.com/2018/10/08/the-death-of-google https://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vo...
- nwah1 8y agoI've thought this for awhile, and have seen other articles about it. While Amazon and Microsoft seem to be executing well on their respective visions, Google, Apple, and Facebook all seem asleep at the wheel. Nothing gamechanging from any of them, lots of scandals and user complaints piling up. There's nothing unusual about it. Big companies usually go this route. It is frankly amazing when they don't.
- siquick 8y agoApple is the most valuable company in history and the new focus on privacy is going to win them even more loyalty.
- lallysingh 8y agoTheir products aren't compelling anymore -- they're living off the momentum of prior greatness. As soon as someone else has a compelling, exclusive phone feature, Apple's likely to collapse. A lot (LOT) of their product demand is from fickle customers that would leave them quite easily. There's no lock in, and there's no reason to be loyal -- it's a fashion brand. As for privacy, I think you'd have to show that those customers don't have facebook accounts to take that seriously.
- mario0b1 8y agoMaybe some time will come where they go from fashion-only-brand to consumer and/or budget brand? Sure it could hurt their image, but if they keep going into that privacy direction it could possibly give them A LOT more customers, who just can't (or don't want to) afford apple right now.
- lallysingh 8y agoIf their fat margins collapse, so does their market cap.
- nielsbot 8y ago
- Doctor_Fegg 8y ago> the politically-motivated hands of the lying Google haters, who have already been screaming for Google’s blood Yikes. Maybe tone down the invective a bit? It’s possible to think Google something other than a force for unalloyed good without being “politically motivated”, a “lying hater”, or consumed by blood-lust.
- Chlorus 8y agoCan't imagine why I shouldn't give a multibillion-dollar company whose employees (well, former employee in this case) refer to critics as "evil haters" the benefit of the doubt.
- draw_down 8y agoYeah, no kidding. I had the same reaction.
- throwaway5250 8y agoYeah, caught that bit of gatekeeping: "I, Poobah of Tech, am here to say that Google might suck. However, all of the people who have said before me that Google might suck, well, they suck." As for Google, considering everything that's come out in the last year, they've gone from a company I always wanted to work at to a company I cannot imagine working at.
- stcredzero 8y agoAs for Google, considering everything that's come out in the last year, they've gone from a company I always wanted to work at to a company I cannot imagine working at. I can well imagine what it would be like, and I would be frightened to work there.
- freetime2 8y agoThe contrarian in me says now is probably a great time to work at Google. They are basically printing money at this point. Disillusioned kool-aid drinkers are making their way for the exits, which means there are probably ample opportunities for personal growth. Their mission to "organize the world's information" is still relevant. And there's no way it can be as bad as recent media coverage makes it seem... just don't get caught up in any culture wars and you should be golden.
- gaius 8y agoThe author of this is clearly deeply emotionally invested in Google and desperately struggling with the cognitive dissonance of things not being as she idealised
- dekhn 8y agoHe, not she.
- vl 8y agoDeath of Google is exaggerated. Patient is more likely alive than dead.
- noncoml 8y agoHe means the spirit of Google is dead, not the company itself: > It is indeed possible, even likely, that Google can continue onward without the kinds of changes that I and other Google supporters have advocated over the years, and still make bushels of money. > But it won’t be the same Google. It will have become the “conventional company” kind of Google, not the firm of which so many Googlers are so rightly proud, and that so many users around the globe depend upon throughout their days. > The Google that we’ve known will be dead
- freetime2 8y agoI suspect that "spirit of Google" probably means different things to different people. To declare Google "dead" just because he doesn't like some of its recent decisions seems awfully self-centered. "Google is changing" would be more accurate. And of course it is - as every living entity does in 20 years. Have you changed at all in the past 20 years? Would you describe yourself as "dead" because of it?
- metalliqaz 8y agoNetcraft confirms it?
- crave_ 8y agoIronically, the site is down.
- draw_down 8y agoI'm sorry but I can't take someone seriously who is talking about the "evil Google haters", it's just silly. There are good reasons to have issues with some of the things Google does.
- nicodjimenez 8y agoGoogle is probably the best company in the world at copying successful products. They copied AWS, Amazon Echo, Evernote, the iPhone, and the list goes on. While maybe this isn't the most sexy strategy, the truth is that it CAN work when you have really amazing engineers. As the ad margins diminish, they will fiercely compete with everyone who seems to be doing something interesting. They are definitely fighting very aggressively on many fronts and are definitely not dying _yet_.
- bitL 8y agoI think that award goes to Amazon - they are ripping off successful designs from their own marketplace; can't really beat that! Clueless 3rd party producers take all the risks; once Amazon notices them they are done within a few months as Amazon prepares their own "clones" under their own brands with prices nobody can beat.
- degenerate 8y agoI agree, Amazon is the better copycat. Remember when Google tried to buy Groupon for $6B and they declined? Both Amazon and Google subsequently created a Groupon clone, and the result: "Amazon Local"[1] was way better than "Google Offers"[2]... and interestingly both shut down in 2015. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Amazon_products_and_services#Amazon_Local https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Amazon_products_and_se... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Offers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Offers
- 908087 8y agoWhoever wrote this comes off like an angry 13 year old fanboy/girl with the "evil Google haters" BS.
- i_am_nomad 8y agoIt’s code for hating conservatives and anti-censorship people.
- kshatrea 8y agoI think idea that this blog post is conveying is overrated. People said the same thing about Microsoft under Ballmer. Then he left. Nadella came in and continued many of the things that he did, and their stock price has soared. For Apple the opposite happened - their profits and stock price have soared, yet Tim Cook can't catch a break. Every little error leads to a chorus of "It wouldn't have been like this if Steve was around". Perception isn't everything. In my humble opinion, Sundar Pichai must go. Ballmer said it best - "I am a pattern"[0]. I think Pichai has been a great manager but he, from the outside, doesn't seem to be a great leader. If he steps down, the new person gets leeway to change some things and get some social capital. [0]https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/outgoing-microsoft-ceo-steve-ballmer-tells-wsj-that-he-was-part-of-the-problem/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/11/outgo... edit: fixed language
- bluedino 8y agoCook’s successes have been....AirPods and the iPhone X? Sure, Apple has made tons of cash but their products have been lackluster. The Mac Pro bombed, keyboardgate, the stagnated phone development...
- akvadrako 8y agoThey haven’t been lackluster by objective measures. They still sell a lot with high profit margins.
- sjg007 8y agoApple sells privacy, iPhones and then the content services around them. That's a powerful combination. AR/VR are the obvious next generation things we need to get right as is the AI.
- flyinghamster 8y agoHe mentions DEC, but I'd go further and note that Google is making the same mistake Digital did with Alta Vista - namely, returning irrelevant search results because it thinks you really must be searching for Y even though you entered X. This gets especially annoying when one searches for a specific word and gets a page full of results that don't have it. Getting rid of the +word search syntax in favor of quotation marks was also a bad move - it makes it much more tedious to edit your query when you're trying to tell Google "Hey, I'm really searching for that word."
- PhantomGremlin 8y agoGetting rid of the +word search syntax in favor of quotation marks was also a bad move I also loved the +word feature. But didn't they want the '+' for something to do with Google+? That's dead so maybe they can release '+' back to the search people? Actually they won't adopt +word again. As you say, more and more "irrelevant search results". Thankfully the "verbatim" option helps me. I don't know how normal people get verbatim results, that left-hand column only appears for me because I don't allow JavaScript. Otherwise the option is missing!?
- hartator 8y ago> Actually they won't adopt +word again. As you say, more and more "irrelevant search results". Thankfully the "verbatim" option helps me. I don't know how normal people get verbatim results, that left-hand column only appears for me because I don't allow JavaScript. Otherwise the option is missing!? It's under Tools > All Results > Verbatim, or `tbs=li:1` in the url.
- lubujackson 8y agoIt's the problem of maximizing gross acceptableness vs. accuracy. If there is a term that has 1,000 results but could be a misspelling of a term that returns 100,000 results, Google will always go with mob rule. It's like when the bean counters take over and shave a nickel here, save a penny there, until everyone leaves because your product has become garbage. Optimizing for search happiness sounds good on paper but winning on edge cases SHOULD be Google's strength - instead, it is their biggest weakness. I wouldn't even mind the mob rule if Google still had a way to clarify your searches by default. Instead, they continue to assume more and more user intent and remove more and more options for clear user input.
- eam 8y agoI use to be an ardent supporter of Google. As soon as I installed a new browser or a got a new computer I would set Google as my home page without much thought. Then over the years they've lost my trust little by little. I never really tried using Chrome unless I absolutely had to because I believe in the separation of services and because I started losing my trust in Google. I didn't want to be tracked. I don't have nothing to hide, but I still appreciate my right to privacy. I thought I was already sharing enough with my Google searches and YouTube usage. I do continue to use gmail, but I've been keeping an eye open for reputable alternatives with security that matches that of Google, since it has that going for itself. I still haven't really found an alternative... yet, at least not one that is convincing enough to make the switch. Just recently I changed the default search engine on all my devices to be DuckDuckGo as they seem to be a much better alternative when it comes to privacy. It's pretty sad that greed has consumed Google and all they care is about maximizing profits instead of balancing profit and user experience/privacy. I really wish they can be that company they used to be, until then I'll keep my eyes open.
- bigger_cheese 8y agoThese days I pretty much view Google through the same lens as Microsoft they have eroded basically all my goodwill. I use their products begrudgingly and view everything they announce with a healthy cloud of suspicion.
- Zhenya 8y agoSite is down. Cache: https://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vortex.com/2018/10/08/the-death-of-google https://web.archive.org/web/20181009200058/https://lauren.vo...
- B1FF_PSUVM 8y agoOne of these days, a bright-eyed and bushy-tailed Noogler MBA will shoot down the Takeaway service, because it will be clearly intolerable to have a moat-bridge that 0.01% of the users know it's there and serves to keep them calm. (Then the volcano erupts and kills the dinos.)
- mcguire 8y ago"...legions of politically-motivated Google haters are using to further evil agendas." "...played directly into the politically-motivated hands of the lying Google haters, who have already been screaming for Google’s blood and for its executives to be figuratively drawn and quartered..." "...giving the evil haters even more ammunition to use for false accusations of political user censorship, they give the EU additional excuses to try fine Google billions extra to enrich EU coffers, and they give massive energy to the forces who want to break up Google into smaller units to be micromanaged for political gain by politicians and those politicians’ minions and toadies..." Wow.
- 908087 8y agoIt's almost like listening to a captive cult member decry the "evil that lies outside of these walls". The idea that people who criticize an advertising/surveillance corporation worth several hundred billion dollars are "evil" is delusional. I always knew the kool-aid was potent at Google, but not that potent. I have pretty low expectations of HN in general, but seeing this on the front page is still kind of confusing to me.
- echevil 8y agoEven with recent criticisms there're really no sign that Google's business is anywhere close to dying (or shrunk at all). Their core products, the search engine, Google Map, Youtube, etc. are still best of its kind and no where close to be replaced. Yes some people are pissed off, but Google's user base is way beyond the tiny community that cares about HN, and many would continue to love Google's products.
- MarkMc 8y agoCompanies exist to make money, and by that metric Google is a long, long way from dying, as the author admits: "It is indeed possible, even likely, that Google can continue onward without the kinds of changes that I and other Google supporters have advocated over the years, and still make bushels of money" Google's revenue today is six times as large as it was a decade ago. And I expect its revenue in a decade to be at least 3 times as large as it is today. The reason is that many of the causes of past growth will continue for the foreseeable future: 1. The people who are connected to the internet will continue to become richer - in particular booming poor countries like India and Indonesia 2. The amount of time people spend on the internet will continue to grow 3. The amount of advertising Google can show people per hour will continue to grow. For example, Google can show many more ads on YouTube and still be less saturated than the old network TV model. Another example: The Economist app currently shows untargeted ads copied from their print magazine - but in 10 years these ads will probably come from Google. 4. Google can continue to improve its algorithm for placing of ads. Google knows so much about me yet I'm amazed how stupidly untargeted its ads sometimes are. Eg. if my photo stream doesn't include pictures of cats, don't show me ads for cat food! 5. Google can continue to collect more personal data. Right now it doesn't know when I last purchased toothpaste, but it might in 10 years from now. 6. The number of people connected to the internet will continue to grow (although of course at a slower rate than in the past) [Note: I am a Google shareholder]
- candiodari 8y agoWhat is it with the systematic anti-Google messaging these days ? The G+ breach, for example, did not justify the titles it was given. Second ... Google is still the champion of good on the internet. There is no other way to put it. Google's ads, on Google itself and on youtube ... are still absolute champions of reasonableness compared to all of their competitors, even the ones that are sponsored, like Bing. Google's moral stance ... still far exceeds the moral stances from their competitors on nearly all fronts. Bing, Yahoo, Yandex, Baidu, ... there is just no comparison. Go to their pages and compare their attitudes towards, say, drug ads. Ad blockers. There is just no comparison. And as for Amazon. I used to joke: 'Google's motto is "Do no evil". Amazon's motto is the other thing'. And yes Google works with the military (well, not really, it was planning to at some point, but that's it), so does Microsoft with Bing. So does Yahoo's parent, Verizon. So does Amazon (hell Amazon's EC2 has a CIA-only cluster [1]). There is just no comparison. Google's products have no comparison anywhere. From Google Docs, Gmail, Search, Youtube, Android, Blogger, Flights, Translate, Scholar, Cache, Chrome, Hangouts, Play, Tensorflow, Drive ... all are really great products compared to their competition. Really, really great products, most of which are entirely free as well. Ad-supported, but not obnoxiously so. Does nobody other than me remember how other companies treated the web in the late 90s, early 2000s ? How about the cell phone maddness of the early 90s and how obnoxious the telcos were with their "sms services", "ringtones", ... and so forth. That's what you should compare to Google. Is there anyone here that seriously doubts the web would be incredibly poorer if Google either relented on the above stances or disappears ? Because I don't. Google would be an incredible loss. Google is growing like crazy ... and to some extent that probably means turning into a more normal company. But ... it's still VERY far removed from being one. This post ... well the guy initially said this in 2006 ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGoSpmv9ZVc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PGoSpmv9ZVc ). I mean at some point he'll be right of course, but 10 years seems a long time to wait. Google is still a very early stage business. Look at it's valuation, and it's STILL not paying dividends ? I mean how much more proof do you need ? And Google is absurdly amazing: it makes almost 12% of it's market cap in profit. What do you suppose would happen to Google's stock if it paid a 5% dividend ? We all know it could easily cover a 15% dividend for a century or two. Google is here to stay. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DEc6kVAXSs8&feature=youtu.be&list=PLhr1KZpdzukePsKIUofhgp50b63-5yr1V https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DEc6kVAXSs8&feature=youtu.be...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sonnyblarney 8y agoIt's interesting how in tech people talk about such specific cultural issues as though they're inexorably related to outcomes. Sometimes it is, more often it's not. 'Culture' is always a lynchpin of success, but Google has classical company 'good culture' in droves. The things mentioned in the article aren't as important as we might instinctively think. Google is a de-facto monopoly on search (ok, that's debatable, but there's no debate they 'own it' for now) with massive moats like Chrome and Android, vast datacentres, literal ownership of the brand i.e. 'to Google' is a colloquial verb in many languages. They are going nowhere - not for a very long time. They are 'dying' about as much as MS is dying ... meaning they are not really, they're just losing their lustre to 'us' types. The only way Google will hurt, is the same way MS has hurt - meaning a fundamental shift in users behaviour or market architecture. MS started to hurt when the world went to the internet, and went mobile. That hurt their OS and Office solutions somewhat, but they've adapted and in $$$ terms, they're just fine. So Google will hurt when people stop searching (!) meaning, not anytime soon. Now - the change to mobile which is partly dominated by Apps presents a pretty big threat, but they seem to be managing it. That's the 'kind of change' that will hurt them. Facebook on the other hands, has some existential trouble, but even they will likely be ok. Twitter has a hardcore userbase in the press etc. and might wane, but likely aren't going anywhere for a while. Snapchat ... could be in trouble. Google is maturing into 'regular company' phase. They still have amazing momentum, massive cash, 'everyone' wants to work there, it's still a solid resume placeholder, they have talented Engineers - and the culture as far as doing stuff still works. FYI - they were never good at UI, and their products have always been a little bit of a gaggle. But search, their ads, maps, chrome, android, youtube ... those are formidable assets. So yes, the 'Do No Evil' Google is gone, and we're now into the next phase. They could possibly be overvalued as are many tech stocks, but they're going to be around for a very long while.
- whateveryou381 8y ago"The death of Intel..."
- utopcell 8y agoThe TL;DR of the article is "Google is dying because ..Google+". Funny argument. If that were the case, then Google would be on life support since Orkut, Wave and many other bets that just didn't pan out. The fact of the matter is: Google is by far the best search engine. Google is the only company I'd actually trust to drive me around in a self driving car. Its cloud services are 2X more cost-effective compared to AWS. Google's Android is by far the most popular mobile OS in the US. Google is growing like crazy both in terms of employees and in terms of stock. Who even cares about Google+ ?
- dgudkov 8y agoI don't think Google is dying. Sony is probably dying. IBM probably too. Google is in its "productivity plateau" which is not a bad thing. It's just not the Google we used to know, the one where "don't be evil" meant something and that could make radically new, awesome things. Now it's just another powerful, profit-oriented corporation.
- krschultz 8y agoYou can't cite AT&T without mentioning that AT&T was broken up by the government. It's entirely possible that the government will come and split Alphabet into several companies. That has been suggested by several knowledgable tech pundit. But until that happens I just don't see Google faltering.
- caro_douglos 8y agoLove the joke at the beginning of the Internet & Empires talk where he says he was scared google would take him out with the hardwired mic.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> they give the EU additional excuses to try fine Google billions extra to enrich EU coffers From wikipedia: The European Union provides more foreign aid than any other economic union.[20] Covering 7.3% of the world population,[21] the EU in 2017 generated a nominal gross domestic product (GDP) of 19.670 trillion US dollars, constituting approximately 24.6% of global nominal GDP[22] and 16.5% when measured in terms of purchasing power parity.[23] Additionally, all 28 EU countries have a very high Human Development Index, according to the United Nations Development Programme. The EU is one of the most prosperous, more wealthy regions of the world with some of the most robust legislation to protect citizens' rights, including consumer rights. Arguing that it's going after Google's (and Facebook's, etc) violations of its users' privacy is meant to "fill its coffers" is just clueless.
- laichzeit0 8y agoGoogle is crap until you set your default search engine on your mobile and desktop to something non-google. Bing is a good example. It looks almost exactly the same as Google and you probably won’t even realize it. Until you actually use it for a few weeks. And go like “wait a minute why am I not seeing this so and so result.. I remember Googling this exact search term a few weeks back and.. oh wait..” or you click on the News tab in the search results and it, well, sucks. I really want to move off Google but they are just so. damn. good. right now it’s actually scary. It feels almost like search is a “winner takes all” game. Even if the runner up is really good, it’s still not good enough.
- phs318u 8y agoWhat they definitely don't do well is corporate marketing and sales. I've been involved in two RFP's in which Google were invited, and in both instances Google lost out to other vendors. Two significant factors in their losing out were: 1) the naked arrogance and almost-disinterest of their people when in the room with the client's business people i.e. the people signing off on the vendor selection. 2) non-trivial examples of products that were terminated at short notice, in some cases with no clear migration path. While 2 can be mitigated, it was 1 that stuck with me. I've been in the room with quite a few big vendors and Google were BY FAR the most arrogant. Quite appallingly so actually. SAP, Microsoft, Oracle, IBM - however crap some of their products and services may be (as are some of Google's), they at least have the common sales sense to make the prospective client feel listened to. In my experience, SAP were masters at this.
- feri339 8y agoI still believe that Google leadership (maybe different for middle management) really has altruistic aspirations. Or rather, they think it's better they grab the power because they won't abuse it. People complain about the monopolistic market power of Google. But in reality this is the only way big tech works at this time. You either grab the market or you'll loose out. Anyway. Alphabet has to get cloud and Waymo right because long term they can't keep relying on advertising. In the end it's all about who gets to "real" AI first. Out of all the serious contenders I'd rather it be Alphabet than Amazon or worse, Baidu or Tencent. Because whoever gets that will probably dominate on whole new level. And that believe is really based around the ideals of the founders. Bezos for example seems much more like a typical business person with profit motivation. Page and Brin seem like they're just using the financial success of Alphabet as a means to an end. Because when you're that rich your world view and ideas for the future seem much more relevant than simply getting more money.
- glenrivard 8y agoLast quarter Google grew YoY for the quarter at 26%. Same with the quarter earlier which is actually accelerated growth. So as the numbers get bigger growth rate increasing. But have not yet rolled out the robot taxi service in Arizona which they say is coming this year. Transportation and shipping is over a trillion dollar opportunity. Take some time to get there is true. So the headline of this article seems void of reality?