52 ms·
Amazon is stuffing its search results pages with ads
- iamgopal 8y agoI think amazon is winning solely based on their physical infrastructure which they keep investing in, and hence the share growth. It has nothing to do with how good their website or customer support is, or how many ads they show or not show. All are this ideas they just trying without anything to loose.
- village-idiot 8y agoTheir website is garbage for how popular it is. It’s really hard to navigate the sections for controlling your kindle, digital purchases, or settings.
- zinckiwi 8y agoThat's true. I still can't quite believe that although family sharing is a thing, and collections are a thing, I can't share a collection. I want to add books to a "Kids" collection and have that collection shared with them in Kindle for Kids. Can't be done. Need to share each book with each kid, one click at a time.
- rjsw 8y agoOr just be able to buy a book for a relative and have it added to their Kindle. Maybe it is possible but it isn't obvious how to do it.
- ceejayoz 8y agoIt's possible, and fairly easy. You should see a "Buy for others" section on most Kindle book pages, right below the main purchase options. https://smile.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=201964280 https://smile.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeI...
- beojan 8y agoAnd why does the UI language depend on which country's version you're visiting? It makes sense for the descriptions, but the UI is the same in all versions.
- slivym 8y agoWhilst their website is terrible, I actually think the specifics of what Amazon does makes it very difficult for the website to be good. They sell a million versions of a million products in a million sectors. What is useful for me to know when buying a hard disk is not the same thing that is useful for me to know when buying a bottle of wine. So they either have 1 size fits all, or a huge cost in building almost custom websites for every different sector. I'm not sure it's actually possible to do that well.
- Retric 8y agoHaving a 100 or so skins for each major section could go a long way without costing Amazon that much. They already do some customization for example showing different sizes for clothing. The problem is they don't face much direct head to head competition. Where online can you buy a digital movie to watch right now, lawn ornaments, an out of print book from 1970, etc without ordering from several websites.
- village-idiot 8y agoIf it’s possible, Amazon has the resources to do it, they just clearly have decided not to spend them. Fwiw I knew a guy who claimed that the templating language for the main website was written in C headers. I can’t verify that, but if true it’d go a long way to explain why it’s so bad.
- dingaling 8y agoEven fixing the infamous 'Choose a Department to enable sorting' problem would be a start. How am I meant to know Amazon's taxonomy? Somehow eBay can sort products across all categories and present them in one list. Wicked majick!
- pergadad 8y agoI like how it's very selectively showing filters. I can filter by price on my laptop, but not using the store on my Kindle. Alright Amazon, I guess you know who are the captive customers, but I'll not buy another Kindle...
- elorant 8y agoEbay is also crap and yet it attracts millions. We may preach good practices all day long but the truth is that if your site is useful users will find a way to navigate it. Even if you keep moving things around like Amazon.
- GFischer 8y agoTime for disruption again, I guess... but it'll be very hard to beat Amazon/Ebay. I have an idea for some niches, it'll probably be implemented by the major players after it's been validated though.
- snaky 8y agoThere is no place for disruption wrt Amazon actually (eBay is different matter, trying to became the retail marketplace instead of worldwide used goods auction site is the same way Blackberry adopt trying to be an iPhone - with only possible sad outcome). American consumer is not changing - he still prefer 'easy' (especially easy return), 'one-click', everything in one place, delivered fast and all that convenience to all other features (including quality and price).
- matthewaveryusa 8y agoAnother example is the Bloomberg terminal. It looks terrible but gets the job done and that's all that matters.
- jspash 8y agoFrom my window (if there wasn't a house in the way) I could see an Amazon Locker. THAT is why Amazon is winning - for me at least. They've solved a problem that makes up for the increased prices. The fact that I don't have to take a day off work to pick up a package. Or worry that my dodgy neighbours are going to steal it. That single feature has changed online shopping for me forever.
- m-p-3 8y agoIs there an addon of some kind that exists to make those ads more obvious (some kind of highlights) without outright removing them?
- chanandler_bong 8y agoI am not a developer, but something like AdBlock or uBlock Origin should be able to at least highlight the "Sponsored" text to make it more prominent?
- bootlooped 8y agouBlock Origin appears to remove a lot of the sponsored results. Some sections like "our brands" or "expertly reviewed" may still appear above organic results.
- Splines 8y agoI used the element picker, "##.acs-private-brands-container-background" seems to block the "Our brands" element.
- Shaddox 8y agoWell, the advertised content seems to have an ad___slot and an AdHolder class so I can probably whip you up something in stylish I guess whenever I get off work (posting as a reminder) .
- Kagerjay 8y agoProbably using stylus to update stylesheets on those specific ad's classes. But, amazon changes things so frequently that someone needs to constantly always update these scripts/stylesheets
- skinnerp 8y agoSponsored products can be removed by using any of the major ad-blockers. When I worked at Amazon we actually worked with the add-on authors to make this easier. Previously sponsored products were present but looked kind of broken when using ad-blockers, so we added some hooks and contributed rules to the plugins.
- sk5t 8y agoIt's not hard to imagine that Amazon has created a situation where groups within the company are incented to drive up this high-margin ad income (no annoying logistics! no inventory!), divorced from the "external" fallout of ever-so-slowly turning the site into garbage. eBay, have you anything to say about this? Or how about you, Hewlett Packard?
- cle 8y agoAd revenue is easy to measure. Long term erosion of the trust of your users isn’t. Metric-driven decision making is not a silver bullet.
- ryanwaggoner 8y agoI really doubt that it’s difficult to measure proxies for user trust. Return rates, conversion rates, search funnels, customer feedback ratings, basket size, prime churn rate, etc.
- etatoby 8y ago"When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." —Goodhart's law
- wikwocket 8y agoI'm sure lots of e-commerce companies feel this pressure. Where I work, an Additional Revenue team was created for this kind of thing - sponsored results, ads, cross-sells, etc. It's viewed as free money on the table, since it is relatively easy to estimate the income and the dev work required, but much harder to measure user experience and customer loyalty.
- justinph 8y agoThis is one of the reasons I've let my Prime subscription lapse and started doing more shopping at Target. In addition to fewer (or no) ads, I can often pick an item up in an hour instead of waiting two days, and the prices are better.
- dharmon 8y agoTarget will also price-match.
- thieving_magpie 8y agoAmazon (and prime as well) is a godsend for those of us that don't live within a 90 minute drive of a Target or Wal Mart.
- dgacmu 8y agoTarget and Walmart both have pretty reasonable delivery. I shop them together through Google Express (to be able to price compare), and the delivery prices still often beat Amazon. Particularly for heavy stuff.
- thieving_magpie 8y agoI should clarify I'm not locked into Amazon. I'm just happy to have it as an option for shopping. I have used Wal Mart and Target when the prices made sense.
- falcolas 8y agoFWIW, Target and WalMart offer online shopping and competitive shipping prices as well.
- billysielu 8y agoIn the UK, getting to a town center to do some shopping is so horrific that Amazon is the only remaining option.
- 8y ago
- phobosdeimos 8y agoSo do physical stores. Is it really so different from Heineken paying for prominent shelf space in the supermarket?
- slededit 8y agoWhen you ask for help finding Corona the staff doesn’t ask if you’d like Heineken instead. No it’s not the same.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- thecatspaw 8y agoSure, but if you ask for a beer, you usually get the sponsors beer without question, even if they have different beers. edit: talking about bars here
- slededit 8y agoGeneric searches this is less of an issue. But see the search for Kellogg Corn Flakes in the article.
- Talyen42 8y agoIn Amazon's case, it's more like you walk in for Heineken and see three advertisements: * Best Heineken (a Chinese no-name brand with 1,551 fake reviews) * Top Rated Heinekan (a Chinese no-name brand with 6,731 fake reviews) * Genuine Official Heienekan 16oz Can Beer Great Tasting Best Loved By Users Drink Up (a Chinese no-name brand with 5,532 fake reviews)
- tomatotomato37 8y agoCan confirm, both sponsered links for "iphone charger" score an F on fakespot. Disappointing, considering I was hoping this could be a way to filter through knockoff products.
- 8y ago
- maaaats 8y agoUnless you know exctly brand/make/model you wan't to buy on Amazon, the search is useless. Hundreds of similar results from dozens of vendors of varying quality. I liked it better when they sold things themselves, now they're just an eBay clone selling cheap knockoffs trying to hide the fact.
- Loughla 8y ago>now they're just an eBay clone selling cheap knockoffs trying to hide the fact. I've moved almost all of my online purchases BACK to ebay actually because of this. At least ebay's trust system is easy to understand and harder to game than what amazon has in terms of reviews. I'm interested to see if this is a trend, or if my circle of friends is an outlier.
- maxxxxx 8y agoSame here. I either go to eBay or B&H. In eBay I can see at least quickly the seller rating. Amazon has just turned into a big mess.
- jasonkostempski 8y agoWhat's B&H?
- jtuente 8y agobhphotovideo.com
- BugsJustFindMe 8y agoAn electronics store in NYC that delivers nationally and has a strong reputation for reliability and competitive pricing.
- maxxxxx 8y agoElectronics and photography mainly. https://www.bhphotovideo.com https://www.bhphotovideo.com.
- hardwaresofton 8y agoThis seems like a huge chance for some company more thoroughly obsessed with item quality to wade through the muck and offer some value in terms of product reviews, since reviews are being gamed. Seems like lots of free time to buy and try products in various niches, an easy to use browser extension and an extensive set of affiliate links, and a coupled website (probably not youtube since negatively reviewed companies might just copyright-strike) are all it would take...
- karkisuni 8y agoyou're describing Wirecutter and its many clones
- hardwaresofton 8y agoA little late, but this just means that it's a good idea and people are doing it and making a living off of it... But I don't frequent sites like Wirecutter because there's too much editorializing for my taste. I feel like the model could be tightened up so much more.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoMonopolizing one part of the value chain, enables you to leverage that monopoly into controlling the next. Owning the railroads enabled standard oil to price it's competitors more, put them straits, and buy them up cheaply. Owning the OS, Microsoft can make sure they own the Office Product productivity. It's why the electrical grid needs to be separate from the energy makers (and regulated). Amazon and Google as the 'front of the internet' can just suck the surpluses out of every other business; sure, you can still sell 'cereal and gadgets' - but all of your surplus / profit margin will be sucked up by them. ... but I have a sneaking suspicion that something disruptive will come along before they entirely take over.
- moate 8y agoRegulations and oversight? Or anti-trust lawsuits? I have a feeling the only way to disrupt companies this large is with the force of a government busting up the monopolies. A scrappy start-up will just be pounded into submission and/or bought up.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoRegulations where it's clean. But 'net neutrality' for example plays right into the hands of the FANGs. Networks can't make you 'pay per email' thereby allowing more of the surpluses to go to the FANGS. If there is 'network neutrality' - one might wonder if we also need 'search neutrality' i.e. if you're in the search business, you can't look at that data to infer anything about that person to sell them other kinds of services. The Office Suite monopoly seemed overwhelming just 15 years ago, but cloud services just got so much better it seems a lot less relevant these days. I haven't used 'MS Word' in forever. It's probably start time to think about maybe some regulations (specifically with regard to neutrality) in search, but beyond that I don't think there's quite a need to intervene yet.
- moate 8y agoWell that's why I'm more in favor of big, ugly "bust them up" type moves and force them to split. It's probably harder now due to globalization but it's still got to be possible right? Amazon (and Alphabet and all that) would be easy enough to carve up into smaller businesses cut off from the large central cash reserves. They would still come together to fund lobbying efforts that benefit all of them, but that's a whole other issue that needs to be addressed separately. It's too bad Trump has made it so obvious that it's personal with Bezos, or he would be in the perfect position to take that sort of action. Obviously if he did that at this point, it would be worse than Nixon's "Enemies List".
- arbuge 8y agoTheir basic underlying assumption appears to be that they're no longer in danger of losing customers and can now act accordingly. Now that they've captured 50%+ of US ecommerce, they've also raised many prices, to the point where they're far from the cheapest price in many cases. A random example... the cat litter I just purchased is $17.89 at Amazon, $13.49 at Walmart. Last week I bought a chair mat for $21.95 on Ebay - identical item on Amazon was $33.95 (both including free shipping but Amazon came with an additional 8.25% sales tax). They can do that because so many people don't price compare anymore before going to Amazon. Not to mention the issues of buying an expensive brand item and getting a fake instead, as well as the large numbers of fake reviews. Indeed, it is pretty hard to get started in Amazon FBA these days when your competitors all have hundreds of glowing reviews for similar products and you have none. They've also moved many items to the add-on category (no more free shipping unless you have $25+ in the cart, even with Prime). My Prime membership expires in a couple months time, and this time I'm not renewing it, after being a member for several years.
- hef19898 8y agoSame impression here. Could turn out to be a worrying trend for Amazon in the Long run. And with the growing fix costs coming with an ever increasing logistics food print and brick and mortar stores, Amazon might end up in tight spot, still an e-commerce leader but not dominating any more.
- mtgx 8y agoAmazon hasn't had the cheapest prices for a few good years now. They're taking advantage of the fact that they have what I like to call "brand inertia". The problem is brand inertia is not infinite. If you no longer do the things that have given you that inertia to begin with, eventually you'll run out of it. When a worthy competitor appears, your customers, who by then will have little loyalty to you, will switch.
- hef19898 8y agoOne could almost come to the conclusion that Amazon running a global experiment on price elasticity on their complete customer base.
- paradite 8y ago> Nearly 8 percent of views on Amazon product pages came from sponsored links in May, more than double what it was a year earlier, according to data from analytics firm Jumpshot, which collects URL data from a panel of 100 million people. It is fitting that an article talking about increased number of ads is using statistics from a company that collects data for ads targeting. Guess why the ads are working so well?
- sairahul82 8y agoIn the details page of the product, they used to show people brought this product also brought this list. Now that is replaced with sponsored products in most of the pages. They moved that list to bottom of page. IHMO this is deceiving users. There used to be lot of product recommendations and I find it useful. Now most of these recommendations are gone and they are replaced with sponsored ads. Not good for users.
- adrianmonk 8y agoThe worst part is that they are visually similar. There's text at the top of the section that tells you whether it's sponsored or organic, but the layout and format is otherwise identical. If you recognize things more by shape and color and such as you're scanning the page (as I do), it's easy to not notice sometimes. While nobody loves ads, I'm OK with them if it's always very obvious which you're looking at. This skirts that line. Which is an unfortunate trend. Even Google's web search results page is making ads less visually distinctive. If I remember right, they used to have a different background color, and now they just have a small box that says "[Ad]".
- sct202 8y agoAmazon's original strengths to me were fast shipping, low prices, and trustworthy reviews to sort items. I'm not looking forward to what they're turning into as they continue to get away from that old strategy.
- jrockway 8y agoI might actually be done with Amazon. Every few months, I spend some time searching for the perfect LED light bulbs for my apartment; the built-in fixture requires 6 candelabra-base bulbs. These are hard to find, but there are a few products catering to this market, so I randomly buy stuff to see if I ever get anything good. I found some LEDs that claimed to have a high CRI and were brighter than normal, so I took a chance on them. There were a couple legitimate reviews and 5 or more obviously-fake 5 star reviews. The LEDs turned out to be not that good. They were bright, the dimmability was good, and the layout of the internal LEDs was quite unique (corncob style but with some on the top, which is great). But they emitted a very greenish light, which makes them unusable. I have a spectrophotometer so I took a reading of the spectrum and, as you'd expect from the visual appearance, they emit very little red light (and no cyan light, as is the typical emission pattern of low-CRI LEDs). I wrote a review covering these points, the positives and the negatives, and included the plot of the emission profile. This review was immediately taken down because: 1) Your review should focus on specific features of the product and your experience with it. 2) We do not allow profane or obscene content. 3) Advertisements, promotional material or repeated posts that make the same point excessively are considered spam. 4) Please do not include URLs external to Amazon or personally identifiable content in your review. In other words: please do not include actual data in your reviews. What Amazon prefers is that the seller buys their own product under a fake name, and then says "5 stars: Great!" This is probably my last Amazon purchase. I might do a proper write-up and spam it around the Internets and see if I can attract the attention of some higher-ups... but probably not. Instead, I will just shop elsewhere. B&H is way better for electronics anyway, and if you just want shitty LED lights eBay beats Amazon there. Maybe I will also start buying every LED light I can find and doing proper reviews... but there is no business model there to make my time worthwhile. Reviews only work if you can actually find a product that's good and get people to buy it through your referral link. If every review says "you will hate this product, save your money", there is no way to get funding. So the fake 5 star reviews will continue, and everyone will continue to hate LEDs.
- Terretta 8y agoFor your particular case at hand, I prefer the Amazon of LEDs: https://www.superbrightleds.com/cat/led-light-bulbs-universal-finder/ https://www.superbrightleds.com/cat/led-light-bulbs-universa...
- m3kw9 8y agoThe uptick could be temporary because it is catching people off guard with rhemused to seeing most relevant result in top. But the allure of the exposure will always be there even after people smartens up
- startupdiscuss 8y agoThey should get rid of ads for Prime members. OR else, create Prime Plus for $0.5/month that shows no ads Or else, raise prime by $6 and remove ads for prime members. I know some of you are mad that I am suggesting they raise the cost of prime. But if you're willing to cancel prime over this, then you should be okay with that.
- Zelphyr 8y agoHas anyone compiled a list of alternatives to Amazon? I’m not expecting a one-stop-shop where I can buy everything like at Amazon. But a list of online retailers who are better than Amazon at specific categories of products. Because I’m at the point where I would rather pay a little extra and get quality products from a not evil company than continue shopping with Amazon.
- y-c-o-m-b 8y agoSome people are suggesting stop paying for Prime and just use eBay. My biggest concern if I ditch Amazon is losing out on some of the cheap Chinese merchandise that I actually don't mind; flashlights is one example. It never occurred to me that eBay is probably selling the same junk though, so I think i'll start doing comparisons between Amazon and eBay.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoYou don't have to completely stop using Amazon if you dump Prime though. I still place occasional orders, but I just have to get to $25 for the standard free shipping. In my area, things take about 4 days without Prime - 2 extra "processing" days and 2 days to ship.
- astura 8y agoOr you can pay for two day shipping if you really need it rather than paying up front all at once.
- scrooched_moose 8y agoIt's painful though, and seems to heavily incentivize "I guess I'll just pay the $12.99/month for Prime again". I just tried 5 different sub-$25 items. 2 day shipping was only offered on 3 of them, and varied between $7.99 and $11.44. One day shipping was offered on all of them, but was between $9.99 and $18.89. There are some weird stacking effects on the 2 day shipping option as well - it's not a flat rate or per item rate, but falls somewhere in the middle. It's definitely more expensive the more items you have though.
- dkrich 8y agoI don't understand the "Amazon is eating into Facebook's and Google's business" argument, and I've seen it now over and over. Is there really a lot of overlap there? It seems to me that the brands that advertise most heavily on Facebook and Google are the brands that don't sell much, if at all on Amazon. It seems that the overlap would be those products that are sold on Amazon and advertised via Google or Facebook, which I don't think I've seen much of. To me this seems like it would only make selling on Amazon less of a meritocracy and more of a competition for the deepest pockets. But even if it's true that there is overlap, then suppose a company cuts its Google ad budget to focus on Amazon. Then all searchers who still use Google will now go to their competitors instead. So why would they do that? If Amazon's ad business is growing it seems likely that it's coming at the expense of the sellers more than the other ad platforms.
- yubiox 8y agoGoogle trained me long ago that anything sponsored at the top is a scam. I now skip below the ads without a second thought.
- CodeSheikh 8y agoGone are the days when you go to Amazon.com for bargain shopping or in search for better deals. I look at Amazon's Prime service as a shipping company. I like 1-2 days shipping service and sometimes I would pay a buck or two more for a product of Amazon Prime can ship it.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoThe ads have been there for a long time (I know because I've either spent or managed spending on millions of dollars in clicks). It's not even the first time that it's been written about in the tech press. The share of voice provided to ads on Amazon's search results is not particularly greater than what you see on Google or FB. The headline ads are a little newer, but they're still more than a couple years old. On many Google searches you have to scroll past the fold to get past the sponsored results. With search, unless you provide some avenue for sponsored results, you will get a winners-win-more effect in which the top 3 results for any given search will capture the entire market. You will get people complaining about 'discoverability' when they are not complaining about advertising. You can't stop people complaining about stuff: you can only trade around what people are complaining about today. I will say that as Google has generally subtracted or crippled features that are useful to advertisers over the last several years, Amazon has generally kept things simple and effective. Also, virtually no customer information is exposed to advertisers through use of the platform. Everything about a customer is essentially exposed if you are the seller, however, but that isn't different from running a print catalog.
- Marsymars 8y ago> With search, unless you provide some avenue for sponsored results, you will get a winners-win-more effect in which the top 3 results for any given search will capture the entire market. If a seller really cared about this, they could implement something like a Robson Rotation for search results of relatively equivalent quality for the search criteria.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoThere are millions of SKUs. On any popular search result there are hundreds if not thousands of SKUs, not all of which are of equal quality. The organic search results (and partially the paid ones) already rank things and will often swap spots frequently during any 24 hour period if they're otherwise close to even in relevance.
- nraynaud 8y agoThat's very interesting, it looks like there is a natural tendency in private market to go to corruption. We see it where retailers ask money from the factories to put the product in some height on the shelf. Online we see it with "search result" placement. We see it in facebook where if you don't pay, they reduce the number of people who will see your post.
- Analoganalog 8y agoDestroy them - all of them, by whatever means necessary. Get arrested, go to prison. Get threatened, beaten up, publicly shamed, financially ruined, digitally mauled. Become an online and offline pariah - whatever, it doesn't matter at this point what happens to your precious self. Destroy Amazon, Google, Facebook, Twitter, etc. They will be the downfall of us all, if they haven't already succeeded in accomplishing this work already. Actively fight back against these new governments
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- TACIXAT 8y agoI went on the other day to buy a specific brand of pants. I was in the app. I searched, clicked the first link, seemed like it was coming from a third party seller. Selected the size I wanted and ordered. It arrived and was a completely different brand. Went back and looked at the search and it was an ad. What I thought was a third party seller's store name was the brand name. From this experience I learned that I can't trust their search results. The mechanism for finding what I want will also now give me things I don't want.
- nautilus12 8y agoAt what point does this become semantics. Isn't a sponsored ad with strong context (including the context of the search) simply a paid search result? The issue is that there are competing masters, one that the ad wants to get served and two that the person wants to find the search results most relevant to their context, but amazon is attempting to provide a paid option that meets that context first, and if it meets that context slightly less and is paid, then thats a sacrifice they are willing to make.
- dwild 8y agoIt's so weird, supermarket always sold better placement to some product and it was never an issue. Amazon is clear in their doing too, is that the issue? You don't notice it thus it's alright?
- kolderman 8y agoBecause it is deceptive. People think they are getting search results when they are getting back ads. There is nothing implied in product shelf placement - no-one thinks the items within easy reach are the best/cheapest, quite the opposite in fact - most people know it is the shiniest, most expensive, branded items which get the best placement. Both Google and Amazon try and deceive users into thinking their ads are genuine, ranked search results. Deceptive, misleading conduct in order to make $$$ is not far away from criminal fraud.
- josefresco 8y agoSooo, just like Google? If these ads become commonplace, savvy users will start to ignore the "first x results" and Amazon will make click/ad money on the the same people that click Google Ads. While we all wish a competitor (just a click away! /s) would arise to compete, we all know from our experience with Google that lock-in is real.
- ric2b 8y ago> While we all wish a competitor (just a click away! /s) would arise to compete, we all know from our experience with Google that lock-in is real. In the case of Google search, it is. Duck duck go is good enough to be my daily driver.
- nkrisc 8y agoI chuckled a bit when I realized the only thing I buy from Amazon anymore these days is... books! Everything else I no longer trust Amazon for. Hell, even the books might be counterfeit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13924546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13924546
- conjecTech 8y agoSame here, which is why I cancelled my prime membership. You can get almost any book you want slightly cheaper on abebooks.com (also owned by amazon).
- dgemm 8y agoRegular supermarkets have been doing this forever, they just aren't upfront about it. https://www.vox.com/2016/11/22/13707022/grocery-store-slotting-fees-slotting-allowances https://www.vox.com/2016/11/22/13707022/grocery-store-slotti...
- ashelmire 8y ago>“Nobody is scrolling beyond the first page when they do a search,” Jason Goldberg, SVP of commerce at SapientRazorfish, a digital marketing agency, told Recode. “If you want to be discoverable, you have to find a way to show up in search results.” Bullshit. Amazon search is sketchy and reviews (both number and quality) are often unreliable, so I spend far longer than I want to looking through reviews to spot the fakes and try to find products that are actually of good quality. I've actually started buying important things from elsewhere again. Many companies on Amazon are in a race to the bottom in both price and quality. That's fine for some products, but not for anything that's going to get regular use.
- fertel 8y agoThe article made it seem as though sponsored product search results unique to just amazon and the other big players. Walmart does it - although not as well. Criteo has a product thats used by a lot of large online retailers that offers this as a service.
- jhabdas 8y agoCombat adware by stuffing your pages with crypto note miners duh https://git.habd.as/comfusion/webminerpool https://git.habd.as/comfusion/webminerpool
- tomc1985 8y agoDamn it people, stop messing with organic search...
- yborg 8y agoThe HN crowd are probably 5x more savvy to this sort of thing than the average user. Amazon is the Wal-Mart of e-commerce, it now has generic brand association with a large majority of consumers. So it's working for them, and it's going to keep working for them even if every HN reader shops elsewhere. It will take some serious competition to get them to change their behavior, and I don't think Jet is going to get there, unfortunately.
- blairanderson 8y agoIf someone needs a project, please develop an "Amazon Advertising AdBlocker". Their class names are fairly consistent.
- eswat 8y agoIf they are consistent you can probably use your ad blocker's element picker to selectively remove them.
- juris 8y agoI wonder if it would be cheaper for small-time sellers to cozy up to brick and mortar store representatives than it would be to fight for space on Amazon. Does Amazon lose market share... back to brick and mortar?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThis is of course not the least bit surprising. The search box on Amazon is a pretty high value place, when someone types something into it they have already indicated they are looking to buy something so commercial intent is well established. Amazon has more third party sellers on their site now than Amazon, so there is a viper pit of competitive selling seething down there. The next step? Let those vendors give up margin over to Amazon by bidding to be in search results. More money for Amazon both in ad revenue and additional sales (for all its evilness advertising exists because it works). Interesting question to see how Walmart responds.
- nicodjimenez 8y agoAs Amazon's ad revenues increase, I expect them to gradually drop their prices, making it EVEN more impossible for other online retailers to compete. Amazon retail's profit margin is 3.8 percent, on more than $51 billion in sales in 2016. They're probably thinking they can shrink this all the way down to 0, and make up the difference in ads. The big question for me is when they will get into the search space. The growth of their ads business and Alexa's success is a massive threat to Google long term.
- bootsz 8y agoIn some sense it feels like Amazon is progressing along a similar trajectory as Facebook: 1. Start company with a minimally viable product 2. Hire smart people to iteratively optimize the usefulness of the product to attract as many users as possible. Incentive structure rewards maximizing new users 3. Product reaches "peak usefulness"; seemingly everyone uses it / loves it 4. Re-focus business efforts to maximize revenue (e.g. stuff ads everywhere). Incentive structure now puts greater emphasis on rewarding short-term revenue increases 5. Revenue climbs as usefulness declines; users begin to abandon the product 6. Company continues revenue-maximization strategy because data on user dissatisfaction / abandonment significantly lags behind data showing correlation of "ad-stuffing" with more revenue 7. User abandonment is finally apparent enough that management realizes it should do something; commence back-pedaling efforts to try to "win users back" Seems like Amazon is approaching step #5 right now. Will be interesting to see how this plays out over another year or so.
- aglavine 8y agoThe thing is that in 3) the company still doesn't make money.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 8y agoOh, going some of the way into 4 is a requirement. The problem is when the company goes into "we did more of X, clients complained but we got paid more in the end, therefore we must do even more of X!" mode.
- goda90 8y agoIs that a hard rule though? Is it possible for a company to stay at 3 and make a profit? Is it pressure from investors that pushes them on to step 4, or the forces of competition?
- bootsz 8y ago
- bordercases 8y agoI don't think it's simply the lack of consumer price comparison that is making it easy for Amazon to front ads without consequence. I think it's also that for many different consumer products, consumers don't know precisely what they want, or more particularly, how to model their requirements. If they knew their precise requirements, they would easily be able to judge whether or not a given ad was fronting a product actually is the right one for the job (that sometimes happens), as well as whether or not the products were a good deal. It would be interesting if there was a repository of the performance specs for different common household products. Right now it's the job for critics and reviewers to be the experts here, but how difficult would it be to simply read a five minute primer on the theory of detergents or the theory of headphones and then go out shopping with impunity?
- levosmetalo 8y agoI came to the point that I am actively avoiding Amazon for any purchase. It happened multiple times that they give better price to someone coming to Amazon from the search engine in incognito window than to their logged in Prime member searching for a product directly on Amazon. Now I always use günstiger.de or idealo.de or some other meta search engine to find what I need, as well as many other people. The same way internet search engines killed big portals back in the time, Amazon is going to be killed by specialized search engines, though it may take a while.
- mattferderer 8y agoPhysical stores have done this for years with shelf space and displays. Can someone explain why this is a big deal?
- jarjoura 8y agoSorry, but all this hate, how is this any different than your local grocery store charging brands for higher placement on the shelves?
- durpleDrank 8y agoHonestly, they are screwed once people start using ali express instead. I know shipping times is a bit long, but I'm sure there will be some solution to this in the future. I wouldn't be surprised they built their own fulfillment centers on the continent.
- cam3ham 8y agolol
- IB885588 8y ago"Amazon is stuffing its search results pages with ads " Like Google, you mean?
- mr_kitty 8y agoFirst comment, but god damn do I live this site. Learning new shit everyday. First I end up switching back to firefox, now I get to hear stuff like this! :D
- kolderman 8y agoGoogle has been doing this for years. I installed an ad blocker specifically to clean up Google search results, they look much better now.
- AltCtrl 8y agowow, revealing how the internet works
- nblgbg 8y agoAmazon doing some questionable things off late like 1. Removing prime subscription renewal notifications. 2. Injecting ads into search and not differentiating them much with results. 3. Replacing different recommendations in the details page with ads. Unfortunately you won't notice them if you are not keen. I recently contacted their CS about a fake product. The reviews clearly says it is some cosmetic product the product itself is a dashcam. They did not do any thing about it. They said they get back to me about it and never did. Not sure why they are turning their back on these things. Its definitely not customer obsession !!
- jimjimjim 8y agoI remember when they used to be a great bookstore.
- bashallah 8y agoAnd here I was wondering why Google or another search engine was required to find what I want on Amazon.
- trevor-e 8y agoI was amazed the other day at how difficult it is to find products on Amazon now. I knew exactly which product I wanted to buy beforehand too. I was trying to buy "BSN Syntha-6 Edge Protein Powder". I dare anyone reading this comment to find a 2-pound jug of cookies and cream flavored whey protein (not Micellar Casein or Hydrolyzed). I found it on GNC's website very quickly and bought it there.
- zanny 8y agoAmazon is the first trillion dollar company at the same time I went out of my way to order shirts and guac mix from walmart.com because I have way more faith in products I find in the page or two of results I get there than from the thousands on Amazon, 99% of which are buried in fake reviews for fake products. And I do it substantially cheaper. I even checked this week when I was in a physical store to compare prices and I was paying the same for the freely shipped stuff on the website as I would have going into a location. Competitive Amazon products had at least a 30-40% markup, even for the same brand. And thats all on top of knowing how reprehensible a company Walmart is, but its not like Amazon is any better nowadays. At all.
- tomcam 8y agoI consult for some of Amazon's biggest sellers. They absolutely have to pay for these ads to compete. Amazon fees all in can easily reach 25% of the retail price, and that's assuming you're paying very close attention. They skyrocket if you decide to take a pee and leave your analytics dashboard closed for a few minutes!
- StreamBright 8y agoFor me Amazon became the cloud & entertainment provider, I have stopped using the store in the US after a while. Said to see this degradation of service that Jeff Bezos was so proud of once.
- Discombulator 8y agoMaybe also due to Amazon’s tightlipped PR policy, it is not uncommon to read in comments about some article related to amazon such as this one accusations about systematically increasing and even user-specific “dynamically adjusting” prices supposedly to maximize profits. I don’t work there anymore since a bit, but I am somewhat annoyed by the unsubstantiated confidence with which these claims are made so I’d like to add my anec-data. First of all, when I left the pricing system had in fact strong incentives in place to _lower_ prices as much as possible (for Amazon sold items. Third party sellers set their own prices.) Amazon would often make (small) losses on many items, especially the ones shown on the home page. Moreover, there is definitely only a single price for each offer listing (which equals more or less an ASIN and merchant combination). This is evidently the case for 3P sold items, since as a seller you definitely do not have that infamous “auto-gauging” tick box the last time I checked. (And let’s not forget, most of the growth of Amazon comes through third party sellers). As for Amazon sold items, I invite anyone to actually show evidence that the same offer listing has at the same time a different price for different users/devices, otherwise it is just empty talk.
- tareqak 8y agoWhat tools (if any) do people here use for price comparison across many sources when looking for the cheapest option for a given item/SKU? What about when you are looking for quality?
- taurath 8y ago> “At Amazon we work hard to continually invent new ways for customers to find the right products to meet their needs. We take the same approach with sponsored products and sponsored brands. We are focused on creating value for customers by helping them discover new brands and products.” I hope everyone else see's whats happening with this statement - that famous "customer obsession" of Amazon's is now turned towards advertising buyers, who are now more the customer than you, the person purchasing the product. Now you are just a data point.
- anonymous5133 8y agoAnother factor I've seen helping amazon is the fact that their amazon gift cards are basically being used as a form of currency. I often trade stuff online and everyone often uses amazon gift cards. The reason is because you can redeem an amazon gift card immediately to your account to make sure you don't get scammed. With most other gift cards, even after the trade the other person can still use the gift card. I'm surprised other companies haven't realized this. If people are able to use your gift cards as a form of currency then it really helps the overall brand because eventually people are going to buy stuff with the gift cards.
- siavosh 8y agoAnyone else having the experience on the iOS app when trying to tap on a search results keeps taking you to the Echo product page?
- homero 8y agoI can't find anything anymore. I was looking for Fitbit straps and the genuine ones were many pages in.
- 8note 8y agois it better than the search without ads?
- beenBoutIT 8y agoCan someone explain why Amazon works so hard to direct searches into searches within its product categories? An example would be a search for 'Baking Soda' leading you to the 'Grocery & Gourmet Food' or 'Industrial & Scientific' categories. I'd much rather search for 'Baking Soda' and have it return every kind of 'Baking Soda' Amazon carries, as I want the best price and don't care how it's been categorized by the retailer. It's almost always faster to search for anything sold Amazon via a Google search outside of Amazon's own search engine.
- rubyn00bie 8y agoThis is THE example of why any website that has “relevant” or “best” as a filter type is absolutely shit... I have really loved Amazon but their practices lately to drive growth are driving me away. My Prime membership is coming up soon and this may be the last year I renew if I do at all. Ads are half the problem, counterfeit goods are the other... I actually could careless about things being counterfeit but it’s a risky proposition with electronics and often risky... As long as they got Gran Tour I’ll probably subscribe... because Clakrson, Hammond, and May are worth the $99 a year alone. Everything else... not so much.
- emmanuel_1234 8y agoWhat really kills me with Amazon is that, leaving outside of the US, I always tick the box for "Deliver in $COUNTRY", and regularly (95% of the time) find out at checkout time that no, in fact, this seller does not deliver in $COUNTRY. To be fair, I gave up on Amazon after that, except for Kindle's books.
- lawrenceyan 8y agoArrogance and stagnation make for a bad combination. I hope Amazon can shape up soon.
- penguin2016 8y agoDo you guys realise that Amazon just acts as a marketplace now, and the products being sold are from third parties? Now that they've captured 50%+ of US ecommerce, they've also raised many prices, to the point where they're far from the cheapest price in many cases. A random example... the cat litter I just purchased is $17.89 at Amazon, $13.49 at Walmart. Last week I bought a chair mat for $21.95 on Ebay - identical item on Amazon was $33.95 (both including free shipping but Amazon came with an additional 8.25% sales tax). Amazon is NOT raising prices, its the merchants who sell on Amazon who are raising prices. The main value that Amazon provides is fulfillment, and driving users to these product pages from third parties.
- zimmer688 8y agoI wonder if there is a way we can block these. This is getting really irritating especially in the electronics category where there is a ton of Chinese off market brands which take up a lot of space and then you get to the ones you need
- beezischillin 8y agoI live in Europe, in a country without Amazon, however I often travel to the UK so I've had a few opportunities to use their services. My experiences have been very mixed. The website, in my opinion, is a mess. It's extremely hard to find things unless you know specifically what brand and model you're looking for. Even then you might find that someone decided to sell that item for an inflated price. Generally when you're browsing for something you want but haven't decided on an exact brand and model yet then discoverability is terrible and listings become irrelevant pretty soon after scrolling down. Even trying to find a gaming laptop for a friend to buy is a useless endeavour. Shipping within the UK also seems to be terribly implemented: more often than not your packages are going to get lost, misdelivered, forcing you to fight for the goods you've already paid for and potentially get them way too late if you want them by a specific date. In August, when I was visiting, they managed to misdeliver 4 items I ordered and it's always Amazon's delivery team that messes up. The only reason I really like them is the book market and second-hand book market. It's great to be able to buy so many books at such great prices. In my own country, however, e-retail seems way more sophisticated: discovery, delivery and reliability are king. They optimise the listings for you to be able to browse and find things efficiently, to discover stuff you want quickly. And it's very rare for the shipping to take more than 1 day, unless there's a seasonal event like Christmas/New Year's. So I buy with confidence and I browse knowing that I'll usually find what I'm looking for. When it comes to buying from Amazon while I'm visiting the UK - I always expect issues. And they always happen.
- throwawayperson 8y agoIf You're Not Paying for It; You're the Product.
- thinkingemote 8y agoThe early adopters (e.g. us techies) are leaving. Do companies have metrics for who are these people are, do they care that we form such very small numbers?