11 ms·
Money Really Does Lead to a More Satisfying Life
- bcaulfield 8y agoWell, now they tell me.
- massysett 8y ago"This research is able to reliably disentangle causation and correlation because a lottery effectively provides a randomized control trial." False. The sample size is limited to those who buy lottery tickets. Of course people who buy lottery tickets think they will be happier if they have more money; otherwise they would not be buying lottery tickets.
- nrb 8y ago> (Free) Money (Awarded To Lottery Winners) Really Does Lead to a More Satisfying Life
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yters 8y agoI grew up without much money in a third world country. My memories from that time are much more vivid and meaningful than once I moved to the US and lived a well educated, middle class life. Money and comfort are good, but I seem to have lost something amidst the greater control and predictability of things here.
- adventured 8y agoYouth produces vivid, seemingly magical memories. The time relativity of having had fewer experiences and how that amplifies every experience you do have. When you're 10, every year seems like a small lifetime. Small or simple things seem extraordinary. On top of that, we usually end up over-glorifying the past because most negatives and how they made us feel fade with time. Not to mention having a lot fewer responsibilities and knowing a lot less about the world. I grew up relatively poor in the US. My childhood seems magical compared to this bullshit. Now each day vaporizes in a blur, feeling not very memorable compared to any other. I love what I do work-wise as an adult, and it still just doesn't remotely compare to spending all day roaring down a snowy hill on a sled at ten years old. I'd probably struggle to recall something memorable from ~100 days ago, but I can recall a hundred memorable things from my childhood. I don't think it was money that made the primary difference, it was the nature of every new or semi-new experience and what it means to a younger brain.
- yters 8y agoIt is something also about the lack of control. I have vivid adult memories of Afghanistan and trekking through the Tibetan plateau. I also have vivid memories of deep discussions during college that I have failed to reproduce under my own control.
- themagician 8y agoI suspect your memories are about people and places, and not necessarily things—which is what money gets you.
- taneq 8y agoMoney gets you plenty of experiences. My happy memories from last time I went snowboarding were certainly acquired with money.
- alexgmcm 8y agoI think while technically true its not really the spirit of the saying. Of course free money (from lottery winnings) is better than no money. But for most people it's a choice between more money or a less stressful job, or a shorter commute, or less hours etc. And then it's a much more complicated equation.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSurvey is of Swedish lottery winners. Results may not generalize. By some estimates, two-thirds of lottery winners are broke within seven years. https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/lottery-curse-claims-another-victim-with-ontario-man-broke-and-in-jail-after-5m-win https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/lottery-curse-claims-an... Nearly One-Third of U.S. Lottery Winners Declare Bankruptcy https://wolfstreet.com/2018/04/17/nearly-one-third-of-u-s-lottery-winners-declare-bankruptcy/ https://wolfstreet.com/2018/04/17/nearly-one-third-of-u-s-lo...
- greenhatman 8y agoI suspect the reason why many lottery winners end up broke soon is because most rational well adjusted people don't play lottery. So it's not so much the winning that make people go crazy. It's just what happens when people who don't understand money get lots of it.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI know rational people that play the lottery. I don't think it works to suggest that only crazy people play. Professional athletes who come into sudden wealth due to becoming professional athletes are also infamous for their financial struggles. However, I will suggest that many poor people think coming into money would solve all their problems because money is very often the most obvious sticking point in their own life. In reality, they trade poor people problems for rich people problems and it doesn't come with some built-in education on how to handle rich people problems. (I mean a la The Matrix: "Download this to my brain." A lot of the advice they get falls on deaf ears and they are ill-equipped to sort good advice from bad.) In fact, many poor people are incredibly dismissive of the idea that rich people have any problems. They often mock the problems that rich people have. So no surprise they aren't psychologically prepared to deal with the reality of sudden wealth in cases where they think "rich people don't have real problems."
- bdhess 8y ago> Professional athletes who come into sudden wealth due to becoming professional athletes are also infamous for their financial struggles. I think this group has similar characteristics to the lottery winners. They become rich suddenly, after having beaten long odds. You can make the same sorts of arguments about the rationality of professional athletes too. Most people who aspire to become professional athletes don't make it. Continuing to pursue the dream is largely an irrational decision.
- D-Coder 8y agoIntuitively, this sounds correct. The class "Problems that can be solved by throwing money at them" is larger.
- astrodev 8y agoI think denial is the only reason why one might find this result surprising. Everything else being equal, almost any life path will be enriched by extra money up to a certain point. That point is field-dependent, but it’s rarely low.
- sixstringbudha 8y ago> Everything else being equal, almost any life path will be enriched by extra money... I don't think so. If you have a lot of money, there will be constant pressure upon you about ways to spend it or invest it "wisely". And you ll always will have the fear of "ruining everything". If you choose to do nothing with it, you ll be blamed for not investing it or making it grow. Not to mention that you will have a hard time differentiating associates who are just there for a piece of the cake.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI have a lot of money and none of what you mention afflicts me. I don't feel "constant pressure" to spend or invest it wisely, and I don't recall ever fearing "ruining everything." I doubt I would be blamed (by who?) for not investing it; even if I was I don't think I'd care. This might come across as condescending, but everything you're saying sounds like the typical cliches about what it's like to have wealth from people who don't actually have it. It comes with its own challenges but I would not include the ones you've mentioned. Clearly some people with money do struggle with some of what you've said, but in my experience it's rare for it to be a dominating focus in their lives, and it's rarer still for it to cause the wealth to become a net negative on their health and well-being. The reason why I'm saying this is because frankly I find it frustrating when speculation like this is promulgated so confidently despite its disconnect with reality. Of the people I personally know earning over seven figures in annual income, none of them struggle with what you've said. Your generalization has a very brittle foundation. Unfortunately there are two obstacles in combatting generalizations like this: 1) most wealthy people don't talk about what their life, aspirations and challenges are actually like, 2) hearing wealthy people say they in fact are mostly happy and fulfilled makes for a boring story without a lot of draw.
- tsomctl 8y agoTo quote my grandpa, who started out with nothing and retired as a millionaire, money doesn't buy happiness, but it sure makes it easier.
- derekp7 8y agoOr to quote Weird Al, money can't buy happiness but it can rent it.
- seibelj 8y agoTo quote Daniel Tosh, jet skis are proof that money can buy happiness. No one has a frown on a jet ski.
- omgbananas 8y agoEdit: My original post was irrelevant and not enough karma to delete. Sorry.
- falcor84 8y agoHow is death by accident related to happiness? Seriously, I know many people who got injured doing a sport they enjoy and then immediately went back to it, without being particularly unhappy. I don't personally know anyone who died from an accident like this, but I imagine that someone can absolutely die while doing something that makes them happy. I'm not sure what I feel about this. On the one hand, it's definitely a kind of a Darwin award, but on the other hand, I see this as exemplifying living life to the fullest.
- pronoiac 8y agoAs a counterpoint, I offer Jay-Z: http://www.thefader.com/2018/07/05/jay-z-riding-a-jet-ski-meme http://www.thefader.com/2018/07/05/jay-z-riding-a-jet-ski-me...
- GoMonad 8y agoI think of it in the reverse. If money isn't buying you happiness, you should reconsider what you using it for.
- phaedryx 8y agoI think it depends entirely on how you spend your money. For example, if you buy a nice bed and get good sleep you are going to be happier. If you can afford healthier, higher quality food you will be happier. If money helps you spend more time with friends and family you will be happier.
- ghthor 8y agoIt isn't money. Its agency over your own life. Money is how we currently regulate and monitor the agency our citizens have over there lives and those around them. Finding better ways to grant and assert agency over one's own life is the key to happiness AFAICT.
- zhoujianfu 8y agoUBI FTW!
- rayiner 8y agoWe don't use money to "regulate and monitor the agency" people have over their own lives. We use money as a medium of exchange enabling people to get other people to do things for them. Money doesn't make you happy. Being able to pay a doctor to take care of you when you're sick, pay a private school teacher to heap attention on your kid, pay a chef to prepare nice meals for you at a restaurant--those things make you happy. If all people wanted was agency over themselves most people could do it--living off the land in the middle of nowhere is still pretty cheap here in the U.S.
- ghthor 8y agoBeing unable to pay for something you need to live your life is bvb the same as having no agency over ones life. I see no difference. Sure, if you found that no one was willing to provide you with the money you required to make decisions and live your life you could move somewhere else. That act in and of itself is an act of agency with the likely goal of improving one's situation. As far as I can tell you're supporting my argument, all in saying is that money doesn't equal agency, it's the provider of agency in our current civilization. There are either ways we could provide individual agency to our citizens with getting it all muddled up in the medium of exchange for bartering and resource allotment.
- logicchains 8y ago>Being unable to pay for something you need to live your life is bvb the same as having no agency over ones life. Requiring someone else to provide something you need without compensating them with something they want in return (money or barter) is removing their agency over their life.
- awocs 8y agoIt makes a lot of sense in today's Sweden. Sweden is still a functioning welfare state, but egalitarianism is decreasing. A couple of hundred thousand dollars will be a major difference to your success rate in getting a good quality of life. Or to put it another way there is a lot of people in Sweden today who are denied opportunities because they don't have that kind of money. Which can be seen by the large amount of private debt.
- sytelus 8y agoMoney can’t solve all your problem, but it will solve most of them.
- sebringj 8y agoOur biological instinct when freedom is restricted is to resist the force binding us. Try having a young child watch a long movie or trap a moth in a jar. We all panic or bolt or wig out. Give a thing maximum freedom and the very opposite happens. That's what a ton of money does to humans...although those that are perverse or have extreme addiction or simply have odd personalities, are able to amplify those traits extremely so. This says nothing for those that lose all their money later as that is a separate concept which has nothing to do with financial literacy and conflates negativity with having large sums of money, which is idiotic IMO, like the sour grapes allegory.
- syndacks 8y agoWho plays the lotto? Idiots, that's who. Idiots who want to get rich. So I'd say this is a flawed study with tremendous selection bias, we all know money can't buy happiness :)
- bbcbasic 8y agoIt is not idiotic to play the lotto. Its not a smart investment, but as entertainment and gambling small sums it is fine.
- wetpaws 8y agoI found personally the best factor contributing to my satisfaction is to maintain a usual modest lifestyle with combined knowledge of being financially secure and not worrying about money.
- dredmorbius 8y agoWorks great until it doesn't.
- loco5niner 8y agoa "modest lifestyle" is one of the most likely ways to continue to be financially secure.
- siruncledrew 8y agoGiven how often studies like this float around, here's what I've learned from past comments I've read: - Those who don't have money, and are therefore forced to be more self-reliant, generally would like the opportunity to have more money because they envision how it would make their lives easier. - Those who have a lot of money tend to downplay the importance of having money, generally because it's more about what the money gets you than the money itself - having options to not deal with things you don't have to. - Money is the vehicle to providing life-enhancing value for yourself in the sense that it can be exchanged for what you want/need. This is what provides happiness. I could have 1 trillion Zimbabwe dollars, but if I can't gain anything meaningful I want with it, then just the number alone isn't going to make me happy (aside from a blip of an ego boost).
- menzoic 8y ago"This research is able to reliably disentangle causation and correlation because a lottery effectively provides a randomized control trial" This doesn't sound true. Many high earning workers never play the lottery, yet have the same economic power as those who only win hundreds of thousands like in the study. I imagine their lifestyle choices are different. Lottery winners are an extremely small percentage of the population. They don't have the same responsibilities, anixities, or "golden handcuffs" that the majority of high earners have because they didn't need to go through that to achieve their economic level and don't need to maintain it.
- akeck 8y ago"Money can't buy happiness but it solves 95% of the problems that make you unhappy." ~ GSElevator
- hnaccy 8y agoPeople are often reproached because their desires are directed mainly to money and they are fonder of it than of anything else. Yet it is natural and even inevitable for them to love that which, as an untiring Proteus, is ready at any moment to convert itself into the particular object of our fickle desires and manifold needs. Thus every other blessing can satisfy only one desire and one need; for instance, food is good only to the hungry, wine only for the healthy, medicine for the sick, a fur coat for winter, women for youth, and so on. Consequently, all these are only relatively good. Money alone is the absolutely good thing because it meets not merely one need in concreto, but needs generally in abstracto.
- zakum1 8y agoA sample of lottery players is hardly a representative sample. I think people who don’t enter lotteries, besides understanding statistics better, are more likely to believe money is not the source of their success and fulfilment.
- ja66awockeez 8y agoMoney is just another tool, we need to know how to use it as well.
- jaclaz 8y agoLottery wealth is a (tiny) subset of wealth. It is possible that besides the material part there is some form of psychological effect, "I have won in a 1 to a zilion chance, I am better (or the fate, or God preferred me), I am special". Inherited wealth or hard worked for wealth may well produce different happyness levels. And of course whar happens in Sweden may (or may not) be "universal".
- mbroncano 8y ago“Lottery: A tax on people who are bad at math.” https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/240944-lottery-a-tax-on-people-who-are-bad-at-math https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/240944-lottery-a-tax-on-peo...