17 ms·
Tech Giants Set to Face 3% Tax on Revenue Under New EU Plan
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cryptoz 9y agoWe are all in this world together. It is insane that corporations have been able to reap untold profits while hardly being taxed at all. These companies could not exist without the societies of the people who buy their products. They should pay taxes wherever they do business, even if fiat currency isn't changing hands (i.e., Facebook and Twitter free users) as specified here. Good move EU. Higher taxes on megacorps will improve quality of life globally and will ensure stronger societies that are more resilient to disaster (like the 2008 crash, or even a natural disaster). Higher taxes on megacorps will increase the probabilities of stable societies with healthy middle classes. Higher taxes on megacorps will enable more people to be entrepreneurs themselves, as more people will grow up with the resources and skills to start something of their own. It's win-win-win all around. If the megacorps want to earn more money, they should pay more tax. They'll earn more money in the long run that way. Edit: I'd love to reply to the comments below, but all you downvoters made that impossible. I'm now banned from commenting and replying on HN presumably from some automatic downvote ban switch. Thanks for silencing the debate downvoters and HN filters. Goodbye.
- cromwellian 9y agoWell, tax them on the money they make from EU sales then. I hardly see why the EU has a claim on revenues made by overseas companies on non-EU citizens. How about the US levy a tax on global BMW and Benz revenues?
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> I hardly see why the EU has a claim on revenues made by overseas companies on non-EU citizens. For the same reason the US government has claim on all global income of both its citizens and corporations. [1] [2] Corporations brought this on themselves by using accounting cleverness to "hide" billions in profits [3]. This is simply a regulatory response. Tech companies can choose not to operate in the EU as well. This gets to the crux of the problem: taxing where the use takes place, not where the corporation is located. [1] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/income-from-abroad-is-taxable https://www.irs.gov/businesses/income-from-abroad-is-taxable [2] https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/people-with-foreign-income-or-foreign-assets-have-us-tax-obligations https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/people-with-foreign-income-or-f... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_Irish_arrangement
- cromwellian 9y ago>For the same reason the US government has claim on all global income of both its citizens and corporations. Keyword "IT'S CITIZENS AND CORPORATIONS". The US government doesn't have a claim on all global income of companies that aren't US corporations. e.g. Alibaba. I can't wait to see your reaction when the Chinese government asks for 3% of global revenues of Siemens.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoLet's address that when Siemens is evading taxes like US tech companies are. I can understand employees of US based tech companies might have strong feelings about this stance. I'd encourage reflection on taxes and how they pay for societal infrastructure.
- cromwellian 9y agoThe Panama Papers revealed Siemens dodging taxes, that's why I chose that example. http://www.dw.com/en/paradise-papers-expose-tax-schemes-of-global-elite/a-41246087 http://www.dw.com/en/paradise-papers-expose-tax-schemes-of-g... If the EU wants to pay for social infrastructure, they need to tax money made within their borders and encourage the development of their own economy. I support Google, Facebook, Apple, and other companies paying taxes on the business they do in your borders, and harmonization of tax rates and laws across the Atlantic, but not some kind of unilateral "Marshall Plan" of taxation without representation. This kind of tax scheme is just going to lead to retaliation, just like tariff trade wars. Do you really think the US Congress and Administration will sit idly by and let the EU slap, in effect, a global 3% tariff on US corporations and not retaliate? I fear a real storm on the horizon with all of this growing nationalism. You've got right wing movements cropping up in the EU, you've got nationalism in the US, EU, and China growing. I don't think trying to claim extra-territorial extra-jurisdictional revenues is a legitimate tactic. And I'm pretty sure you've lose your mind if the CCCP imposed a 3% global tax on your local companies for money they made that was unrelated to exports to China.
- 9y ago
- cryptoz 9y ago> How about the US levy a tax on global BMW and Benz revenues? As long as those companies are pumping out gasoline cars that pollute the air and the environment around the US, that sounds like a great idea! Those companies are unfairly creating pollutants and encouraging their customers to raise the global temperature, dirty American's air, and everyone else's, etc. I would be pleased to see the US pose taxes on businesses that are actively harming Americans.
- Dwolb 9y agoThis is akin to a franchaise tax. I'm pretty sure the thinking of the legislators is taxing net income is too easily manipulated. Therefore by taxing a 'small' (up for debate) amount of revenues there's less gamesmanship that can take place when determining tax liability. For reference, Texas charges a 1% tax on taxable margin over $1M with three options for determining taxable margin. This gives companies less wiggle room when determining tax liability
- SamReidHughes 9y agoWhat about the huge surplus value that Google's search engine provides society? I say we should confiscate money from everybody and give it to Google as a subsidy, because they're underpaid for what they do.
- sintaxi 9y agoCorporations pay +20% tax on profits, then provide jobs to people which are then taxed 30-50%. Corporations are providing loads of value to society. How on earth is this not enough? Honestly, if this is not enough money for the government to operate there are serious spending and accountability problems. A governments primary purpose is to protect rights of individuals. Its job is not to run the world. If we really want to help the middle class lets just let them keep more of the money they earn.
- vidarh 9y agoThis is specifically targeting companies that are shifting profits around to avoid those 20%+ on profits by setting rules that are harder to work around.
- esarbe 9y agoThere's a problem when these companies use international treaties and agreements to pay less tax than your local carpenter or grocery store or their own cleaning staff. It's a government's primary purpose to protect the rights of individuals. What these multinationals are doing is theft on all the other players.
- cromwellian 9y agoWhat right does the EU have to tax revenue (not even earnings) from money made on non-EU citizens? I could understand an argument that they have a right to levy a tax on money created by selling services to EU citizens, but global revenues? They mention Twitter as an example in the article, but Twitter's revenues for 2017 was $3.83 billion, and their net-earnings is mostly negative, or barely positive. So they'd be asking Twitter for money they don't even have. This seems too crazy to pass, like the Trump tariffs, it just seems to be a footgun.
- cryptoz 9y ago> What right does the EU have to tax revenue (not even earnings) from money made on non-EU citizens? Every right. Their government, their citizens, their laws. > but global revenues? These companies exist globally. They would be vastly smaller and have far less impact if they did not have EU citizens. Network effects matter and ignoring them is choosing to not understand the big picture. > So they'd be asking Twitter for money they don't even have. It doesn't strike me they would try to collect this retroactively! Also, I would argue that clearly Twitter should not exist at all if it cannot pay a reasonable tax in the areas where it operates. Edit: What right does Twitter have coming into the EU, collecting data on its citizens, earning revenues from that, and not paying tax? Seems insane to me. Edit 2: I guess all the downvotes trigger a switch, I'm not allowed to post any more on HN I guess. Bye all. Edit 3: To the replies below, I'm not "boxed in" by some silly argument. I'm just banned from replying.
- cromwellian 9y ago> Every right. Their government, their citizens, their laws. If a company doesn't have offices in your country, it's not yours. >These companies exist globally Well, maybe the net result is to get out of the EU then, if the costs of 3% of global revenues exceed profits. If you don't think a company that is mostly non-profit (Twitter) shouldn't exist, I feel that's a pretty pathetic position. So you're either a very greedy, high margin profit company,or the EU says you shouldn't exist?
- 9y ago
- sgroppino 9y agoAs an answer big techs will likely break these companies into 100 smaller ones to avoid the thresholds? "The levy would cover companies that have annual worldwide total revenue exceeding 750 million euros ($920 million) and total taxable annual revenue from offering digital services in the EU above 50 million euros."
- jiaweihli 9y agoFrom that angle, the transition from Google to Alphabet was prescient.
- mtgx 9y agoNot prescient. It was exactly one of the primary reason for doing it: not being considered a "monopoly" or to make people not think so much that "Google" owns everything.
- crispyporkbites 9y agoThe law doesn’t work like that, if the taxman sees you as one company, you are one company
- awalton 9y ago> As an answer big techs will likely break these companies into 100 smaller ones to avoid the thresholds? That sounds like a huge win to me. More competition is better for the market at a whole, and these 100 smaller companies will not be able to stop from competing with each other (or maybe we'll learn they just were better off as separate companies in the first place...)
- themihai 9y ago>> More competition is better for the market at a whole, Hold on...they will be different companies just on the paper...more like Google1, Google2 and Google3.. instead of one big Google.
- 9y ago
- Zenst 9y agoMany comments seem to of missed this key aspect: "Tax on tech companies to be based on where users are located" So this is money made from EU based users and revenue they make from them.
- jimmywanger 9y ago>So this is money made from EU based users and revenue they make from them. That's a gross oversimplification. Especially with the internet, it's not clear anymore. Let's say that I live in Thailand, have US citizenship, sell products on Amazon in England, ship to France, and then advertise on Google. Who do I pay taxes to and at what rate? Provenance of profit is not easy. You're paying Amazon a cut for shipping/fulfillment, and Google for the ad revenue, but your customer is a French national and you're a US citizen but currently residing in Thailand.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sjg007 9y agoIt's pretty clear. You are selling in the UK so the revenue would be taxed there. Post-brexit the French customer will pay customs duty. The Google ad revenue will be paid by Google based on the market. So the ad run in France generates EU revenue. Doesn't matter if the payor was an American or anyone else. If you are US citizen then you pay world wide income tax. You can deduct foreign taxes paid up to a limit. Better to actually incorporate though so you can pay less tax.
- jimmywanger 9y ago> It's pretty clear. You are selling in the UK so the revenue would be taxed there. It's not clear at all. Your warehouse is in the states (or where ever) and the goods are never in the UK. For all cross-border shipments you have to pay customs tax. Just because somebody saw your product on a co.uk website you have to pay the UK for what exactly? And as you brought up, there are customs taxes as well as income taxes. Why are these artificial delineations good for business?
- ryanworl 9y agoRevenue taxes on businesses that are effectively monopolies in their markets are... not smart. They will raise prices by exactly the amount of the tax and the only ones suffering are their customers who now pay 3% more for everything. I bet it would even be added as line item to every invoice “EU Revenue Tax, 3%” I’m sure everyone will love it!
- dannyw 9y agoGoogle has already passed on Australia’s 10% “overseas digital goods and services tax” as a line item on G Suite. My bill is 10% higher.
- crispyporkbites 9y agoOr it’s now 10% cheaper to start an Australian gsuite competitor ;-)
- discoursism 9y ago90% of billions and billions of dollars is still billions and billions of dollars.
- ganeshkrishnan 9y agoHow so? You still have to pay the gst regardless of if you are Google or if you are in Australia
- JeanMarcS 9y agoIsn’t “overseas digital goods and services tax” for overseas companies only ? Serious question here. On the island I live, we have a tax roughly translatable as « Sea tax » which is added even on locally produced good (sounds stupid? It is...)
- dogma1138 9y agoNo, local services have normal GST.
- spectrum1234 9y agoIf you are gonna have a form of corporate tax, a tax on revenue is the best way to do it. This will raise prices of goods the least and directly target the largest companies.
- Shivetya 9y agowell many people unfortunately do not understand that taxes like this get past on to everyone. most only see the tax on their receipt. embedded taxes are the greatest tool of the tax collector
- bluecalm 9y agoAnd where do you think money for corporate tax on profits come from?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoRolled into the "price" of the item on the receipt, rather than being itemized like the sales tax is.
- throwaway2048 9y agothis is something that gets thrown around a lot, but its manifestly untrue, if corporations could easily charge more, they would, and they would pocket the difference as profit. Taxes in general reduce profit, they do not increase prices.
- conanbatt 9y agoThe nuance of passing down taxes is that it depends on the elasticity, which generally is about the capacity for the consumer to substitute the goods. If you put a tax on tobacco or alcohol, it definitely gets to the consumer. If you put a tax on pork, then people switch to chicken and the producer gets hit.
- harryh 9y agoThis is 100% wrong. Walmart buys[1] goods for 97 cents and sells them for a dollar. Google produces technology for 50 cents and sells it for a dollar. A 5% tax on revenue would make Walmart a money losing enterprise while being a minor annoyance for Google. This is why we tax profit and not revenue. Different industries have radically different cost structures.
- Jyaif 9y agoOut of curiosity, is there any European tech company that has 750m in taxable annual revenues?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nopriorarrests 9y agoSpotify? Booking?
- disgruntledphd2 9y agoI think Booking are safe, as they actually sell access to a physical product. Spotify definitely though (and given that the records labels will take any extra profit they make, this might actually be OK for them). It's not going to pass though, these things never do, as unanimity is required.
- TomK32 9y agoSAP had 22.1 billion in 2016, freenet 3.3 billion, United Internet 3.9 billion, Software AG 879 million. And that's just a few from DAX and TecDAX. What Europe doesn't have is a Uber, running a few billions of loss per quarter.
- alkonaut 9y agoWhat counts as “tech”? Media? Electronics? Tech consulting? Software? Games? I can think of at least Spotify, King, Rovio to name 3
- hartator 9y agoIs that just another form of tariff?
- Eridrus 9y agoHow is this different to a tarriff? The EU has basically no companies that fit this description.
- disgruntledphd2 9y agoSpotify? King? Ubisoft? Probably a whole bunch more that I'm missing.
- Eridrus 9y agoThis original article doesn't say this, but there are reports that subscription companies like Netflix (& Spotify) would not be affected: https://phys.org/news/2018-03-eu-tech-titans-tax-riles.html https://phys.org/news/2018-03-eu-tech-titans-tax-riles.html We'll see exactly how they define digital companies, but expect it to be highly political.
- themihai 9y agoI think the tax should be on profit based on where the users are located not on gross revenue. This looks more like a capitulation in the fight against various tax evading schemes employed by these companies. Isn't possible to just give a broader EU law that criminalises this kind of schemes?(i.e. draining the profit by various means). I'm sure that as soon as a bunch of executives along with their lawyers are put in jail this madness would stop.
- al_chemist 9y agoProfit is very easy to alter. Gross revenue is not.
- ganeshkrishnan 9y agoMost companies have negative profit. All the revenue is offset against r&d and expansion
- themihai 9y agoyeah...they are non-profit right? :)) Let's take Amazon for example, or Google or Facebook...how much do they invest in R&D? Last time I've checked they reported billions in profit every quarter.
- laurencerowe 9y agoAmazon is notorious for reporting approximately zero profit.
- themihai 9y agoyou are right.. I got it wrong with Amazon but I don't think it's the case with FB and many others
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoThe problem they are trying to resolve is companies shifting the profit to another country with lower corporation tax.
- condiment 9y agoI think taxes based on users or revenue are misguided. This sort of tax ought to be based on a relative share of megawatts of compute power, and should be progressive in a way that prevents any single entity from controlling more than N% of all computational capacity.
- mankash666 9y agoIncorporate your business outside the EU. It will protect you from unreasonable taxes and regulations. The internet has no boundaries or residency or citizenship. Especially if you are a software-as-a-service business, ignore everything about the EU and domicile outside it.
- adventured 9y agoThe EU will block your service's access into the EU market. That's their only possible next recourse if you simply ignore them and stay out of their jurisdiction physically (in a scenario where you continue to sell to EU customers, but refuse to abide by their policies such as this tax). They'll also go after the payments side, they'll try to shut off your ability to get the payments from EU customers. Going down the roads that the EU is toward further centralized bureaucratic control over the Internet, they have to build their own version of the Chinese firewall to control EU Internet access eventually. There can be no other possibility if they plan to see this path through to its logical conclusion.
- cinquemb 9y ago>There can be no other possibility if they plan to see this path through to its logical conclusion. I foresee a future, where EU users (and users "behind" the Chinese firewall) acquire crypto currency facilitated through p2p dapps and acquire tokens to be able to advertise their products/services over other dapps to other users in the EU. I look forward to this game of increasingly expensive wack-a-mole that will enable the next generation of economic activity with technology. The facebook's and alphabet's may not adapt to something like this (hard to change the course of these giant behemoths), but increasingly more, newer enterprises will be incentivized to go down this path (and users within these jurisdiction who don't really care for these rules and will have increasingly easier technical access to these services). Though of course reactionaries will be totally blind to this (their heads are in the sand) because they will be happy to see their respective local diktats pander to their world view, rather than explore the realm of possibilities that all sorts of actors may pursue.
- ocdtrekkie 9y ago
- lovich 9y agoWhy are a large amount of people treaing access to other nations markets as a human right? I can see the argument behind saying you should have access to your local market be realtively free, you have to live somewhere, and you and your local societies interests are relatively aligned. However,when it comes to foreign markets many people here seems to want the best of both worlds. It's a paraphrase but it seems like saying "let me work however I want in your home, but don't limit me at all", seems to be the rallying cry. How is this not hypocritical?
- pdelgallego 9y agoI am ok with free trade, as long as it also apply to freedom of movement of capital, goods, and people, and we have a common set of rules, and a common court that applies them.
- zavi 9y agoThe argument against protectionism is that it hinders growth of all parties involved.
- andosa 9y agoIt certainly didn't hinder Baidu, Alibaba et al
- volgo 9y agoThis is essentially Trump's argument against free trade. Your companies makes so much money in America and you don't have any rights here, why shouldn't we restrict you? Free trade isn't some right, it's just better for everyone involved
- oliwarner 9y ago> Free trade [.. is] just better for everyone involved How are zero-rate imports better for everyone? The consumer saves money. The government loses sales tax revenue, loses income tax revenue from the people that could have made it locally, has lower employment rates. Buying locally doesn't always make sense, but often you can make an economic argument that paying slightly more for something made and sold locally is better for the consumer too.
- Buge 9y agoLet's say a company has their headquarters in country A. A user from country B uploads a video filmed in country C. Someone from country D buys an ad to be placed on that video, and the purchase is processed in country E, while the sales agent is based in country F. A different user in country G watches the video and clicks on the ad. The video was served from a server in country H, and the ad from a server in country I. Where does the company pay taxes?
- pimmen 9y agoCountry D, I think. That's where the sale was made.
- sumedh 9y ago> Country D, I think. That's where the sale was made How can the company determine if a user is from Country D, ip address or what the user enters in the address box?
- ben_w 9y agoBilling address, given a sale is involved. Bank accounts tend to be attached to an address, and they can be traced if any silly loopholes get exploited.
- reacharavindh 9y agoIsn't that an available information from the user's credit card/bank account? Now, of course there will be people who are residents of a different country or have cards from multiple countries, but I'd expect that to be a negligible fraction.
- tonfa 9y agoAre you talking about sales tax, or corporate taxes? Out of curiosity, what makes you think it should be D, assuming you were talking about corporate tax? With a much simpler example, if a merchant in e.g. France sells a product to a consumer in e.g. USA, the VAT/import/sales tax should go to the US but the corporate tax on profit for the merchant is taxed in France.
- pleasecalllater 9y agoSo if I work for US companies, and I live in Europe, I suppose I will also need to pay additional 3%, right?
- Proven 9y agoThe EU cretins... The EU more and more looks like a cattle farming operation. Captive populace has no choice but to pay tax (because it’s ultimately always paid by the customer) simply because they use the Internet. Can’t wait for that hellhole to fall apart. FB/Google/Apple/MS need just 1 dissenter. That could be the Irish, although they’ve acquired the slave mentality since joining the EU...
- zhyder 9y agoThe EU's proposal isn't the best, but it'll hopefully spur more debate and shake us out of our current local optima, where corporate taxes for multi-national corporations are just odd. How about this proposal: tax company on a fraction of global profits, where the fraction is the fraction of revenue that was attributable [1] to the EU? [1] - Different ways of determining attribution, but simplest is based on billing address of the customer making purchases, including purchasing ads
- patall 9y agoBut it goes even further. In Germany, due to the former divide of the country, lots of big companies like Siemens or Osram have left the state where they were founded and moved to somewhere else. Because corporate tax is paid on a federal state level this means to now many more of companies pay their taxes for example in Bavaria and less so in for example Berlin. So in theory you would also need to have companies pay money on a federal state level (or be distributed somehow "equally" by a central government). In Germany we have whats called a "Länderfinanzausgleich" that redistributes some of the money between states even though that is highly controversial.
- throwaway77384 9y agoThis is fantastic and I am all for it. Even if this gets passed on to the customer, it ends up in infrastructure and the kind of things the EU does well. I'd love to see more of this. If the international conglomerates had wanted to avoid this, maybe they wouldn't have dodged taxes like they did in the first place. Brilliant and long overdue. My main worry is that countries which capitalise on enabling the tax dodgers (cough, Ireland, cough) will vote against this.
- shady-lady 9y agoWhat was the point of the European Single Market then? Or was that just meant to benefit the larger industrial nations(cough, Germany, cough)? It would seem to be sour grapes on the parts of France & Germany that they weren't chosen to the main entrypoint to the EU for some US companies.
- throwaway77384 9y agoWell, I think you are making a very valid point. Germany and France sure like throwing their weight around and have earned plenty of appropriate criticism for their actions. They will most likely continue to do so. Just like with the US on a global level, large, influential economies will often bully smaller ones into situations favourable to their own goals. I do not know what the point of the European Single Market was. In fact, I'd be interested to hear someone with the know-how tell me. Was it to create a trading zone where the same rules applied to everyone? Or was it just supposed to ease trade across borders by creating some kind of customs framework and abolishing tariffs, etc.? Now the point I was making wasn't specifically about Ireland. I could have said Italy as well. I just wanted to point out that paying taxes is a huge deal. Not just for filling the coffers of the European Union, but as a symbol of everyone paying into the social contract. If people see nothing but giant corporations exploiting the legal systems of countries to dodge taxes, people think they could do so, too. It disenfranchises the populace and just ends up giving more rise to populism, which is possibly the biggest scourge on society at this moment in time. Populism leads to fascism. The whole tax malarkey plays into this. It's not the root cause of populism (not sure there is one) and it's certainly not Ireland's fault that they managed to attract business through favourable business tax rates, but something needs to be done about the blatant tax avoidance by these international players and I think this is a good first step, which will surely see some refinement down the line. So, again, I think you make a valid point, but I also believe that my original point stands also. By the way, there's one country that was afraid enough of tax regulation that they fooled a sufficiently large proportion of their populace into voting for one of the most insane political decisions of the last decades. In a non-binding referendum, which is somehow, miraculously, being implemented with a kind of fervour and passion not seen since the Apollo program. (While actually important societal issues would never be put up to a referendum and even then, if people voted the wrong way (aka, against short term financial gain, or archaic doctrine), would simply go ignored. Hmmmm....)
- gaius 9y agoGoogle et al: (smugly) we comply strictly with the letter of the law, if you want us to pay more change the law Government: hold my beer Google: it’s not fair!!! (fx: bitter tears) Let’s charge them the back taxes for all their evading years too
- adventured 9y agoAvoidance is not evasion, so your back tax / theft premise will fall apart there. It would never survive a legal challenge. This EU fake tax is actually a new tariff. The EU has a $100 billion net trade surplus with the US. Germany - by far the largest economy in the EU - in particular has an extreme trade imbalance with the US in relation to the size of the trade between the two countries. The German trade deficit is so extreme, it's larger than the total sum of all exports from the US to Germany in fact. The US is the least trade dependent developed nation on earth: https://i.imgur.com/q7TrEZF.jpg https://i.imgur.com/q7TrEZF.jpg Every nation that has a large surplus with the US, that decides to pick a trade fight, will be guaranteed to lose a lot more than the US does accordingly. The US for example imports three times from China, what China does from the US. A trade war with China is ideal for the same reason it's going to be ideal with Germany and the EU broadly. In a perfect world, the US will import dramatically fewer consumer goods from China, Germany and overall in general. Instead the US should consume less from abroad and shift those resources to domestic capital formation and investment toward greater US production. That's further ideal at a time when automation gains will make it easier to reshore ever greater manufacturing. The vast US capabilities around manufacturing and energy, make the US uniquely positioned among major economies to not need very many outside nations.
- esarbe 9y agoIt's pretty much obvious that the tax avoidance perpetuated by Google, Apple, Amazon and Microsoft is against the spirit of the (tax) law, even if it is not against the letter. But you are right; it would never stand a legal challenge. That's why there is this new tax. When you consider that companies like Apple, Amazon and Google - using these tax loopholes and sandwiches - get to pay a much lower tax rates that your local carpenter or grocery store, I don't see this as a new tariff, but as enforcement of an existing one. About the 'trade fights'; I think you really do underestimate the straits the U.S. is currently in. The only reason the U.S. can import as much as it is currently doing is because of the strength of the U.S. Dollar. The median inflation adjusted income in the U.S. has been sinking for three decades. Even more automated production will not produce purchase power, especially if the value of the Dollar suffers because of a trade conflict. Interested to hear your thoughts!
- gonvaled 9y agoTariffs should also be imposed.
- juskrey 9y agoWhich proves EU bureaucracy is in the livestock business and can do absolutely nothing to boost entrepreneurship.
- jfasi 9y agoPersonally, I like this proposal. I like that it's simple: any overly complex system will almost inevitably result in distortion and loopholes. A few points of my favorite points: * It's done on revenues and not profits. This avoids the impossible question of where profits are realized: if you make money in one country but displace that earning by costs somewhere else, it's practically impossible to determine where the tax should go. * It's uniform across the EU and so it doesn't incentivize companies to base themselves in any member over another. This avoids the distortion we have now with Ireland's permissive tax system siphoning up all the company headquarters and with it the (scanty) tax revenue. * Each member receives money based on the number of users they have in their own country, meaning they have a strong incentive to increase usage of digital services and a disincentive to put in place regulatory measures that would decrease adoption and harm growth. One of the problems of the current situation is that it sets tech companies up as these parasitic monsters that creep into a country, make huge profits, alter the society as they see fit, and give nothing in return. The best thing about this proposal is that it sets up a harmonious relationship: governments get to make money while companies get to have their access to citizens legitimized. With that legitimacy comes better PR and a seat at the table as legal systems everywhere catch up to the world tech companies have created. Plus it might finally put that ridiculous "tech companies are tax evaders" meme to rest.
- adventured 9y ago> The best thing about this proposal is that it sets up a harmonious relationship It does the exact opposite. It spurs a further acrimonious relationship between the major economies of the EU and the US. Particularly France and Germany, which are a combined outsized share of the EU economy and represent ~80% of the trade deficit that the US has with the EU. This new tariff exists solely because the EU can't compete on technology and needs to raise barriers. It's the same reason any country chooses to implement lopsided tariffs, as a shield from competition. It encourages the US to figure out how to retaliate for a new tariff that was designed to almost exclusively target US tech companies. The US will have no choice but to respond with something equally punitive on EU imports. That'll just make relations between the EU and US worse.
- 9y ago
- zerostar07 9y agoCan't tech giants just split their EU operations in 2, and thus split the revenue, and thus dodge the tax
- riffraff 9y agoThe parent company will have the revenue of both. If there is no parent company they have effectively spun off a separate business.
- zerostar07 9y agoeach could ship their profits to separate companies (parented by google) outside the EU,
- DenisM 9y agoThe state of Washington has a very similar concept: Business and Occupation tax. If you have nexus you pay taxes on local revenue. That’s in addition to the sales tax. The tax rates vary by industry, mostly a fraction of a percent. I don’t know how successful the giants are in dodging taxes though. Perhaps they are trying to setup “independent” out of state entities that handle all of the sales. There is also a trend afoot that pushes all businesses to pay sales tax across the entire US, nexus or not. The idea is that modern software makes compliance easy across all local tax regimes, so the old excuse of unmanageable complexity is losing its power. I don’t know the details though. So We might end up with the idea of nexus being deprecated too.
- 3pt14159 9y agoWhat is "nexus" in this context? The frequent traveler program?
- DenisM 9y agoNo, sorry. [...] Nexus, also called “sufficient physical presence,” is a legal term that refers to the requirement for companies doing business in a state to collect and pay tax on sales in that state. [....] https://quickbooks.intuit.com/r/taxes/what-is-nexus-and-how-does-it-affect-your-small-business/ https://quickbooks.intuit.com/r/taxes/what-is-nexus-and-how-...
- dollar 9y agoIt sure would be fun if Google, Facebook, Twitter collectively shut off EU users on the day this tax went into effect.
- zygimantasdev 9y agoAs EU citizen I wouldn't mind. If these corps decide its not profitable for them - for sure an alternative will pop. (Currently using two of those services)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]