48 ms·
Theranos, CEO Holmes, and Former President Balwani Charged with Fraud
- nathanaldensr 9y agoTheranos and Holmes have agreed to settle the fraud charges levied against them. Holmes agreed to pay a $500,000 penalty, be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for 10 years, return the remaining 18.9 million shares that she obtained during the fraud, and relinquish her voting control of Theranos by converting her super-majority Theranos Class B Common shares to Class A Common shares. Due to the company’s liquidation preference, if Theranos is acquired or is otherwise liquidated, Holmes would not profit from her ownership until – assuming redemption of certain warrants – over $750 million is returned to defrauded investors and other preferred shareholders. The settlements with Theranos and Holmes are subject to court approval. Someone help me out: Does this settlement really make the affected parties feel the pain? Does it discourage other companies from attempting the same thing? Given the scale of the fraud, shouldn't these two simply be in prison right now?
- daxorid 9y ago> shouldn't these two simply be in prison right now? Compare and contrast with Shkreli sentencing. Some animals are more equal than others.
- leggomylibro 9y agoWell, Holmes and Balwani didn't actively and loudly antagonize most of the country. Most rich criminals know that when you scoff at the law, you should do it quietly.
- jessaustin 9y agoIt also helps to have lots of family and friends who have given lots of money to lots of politicians. For nonviolent crime like this, the law really is different for different people.
- username223 9y agoMost poor criminals know that, too. Shkreli openly taunted the criminal justice system, and that doesn't end well for anyone.
- charlesdm 9y agoSome animals at least are likeable as people. Others are not.
- hourislate 9y agoRemember who was on the Board of Theranos. These upstanding Americans will never serve a day in Prison including Holmes and Balwani. Shkreli on the other hand was thrown in prison for raising the price of a drug, making money for his investors and offering a reward for one hair. Justice has been served. Junk away....
- matthewmacleod 9y agoShkreli was actually thrown in jail for comprehensively defrauding investors.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hourislate 9y agoYeah...hehehe....sure he was... And Elizabeth thought her technology actually worked. A honest mistake... Junk away....
- aje403 9y agoI'm not really sure that's fair. In fact, IANAL and have zero knowledge of law, but the two had seemingly nearly opposite intent of their crimes. Who knows what was going on in the girl's head, but it sounds more like a bunch of idiot investors gave a lot of money to a dreamer who wanted to make an impact and didn't know when to quit and fold her hand rather than an elaborate con. That gets taken into consideration before pitchforks come out. At a certain point you have to wonder why did a 21 year old get paid 700 million dollars on good faith to start a pharmaceutical company with little oversight? I remember reading about the board a few years ago and just looked it up again. Several generals, Henry Kissinger...huh? This is all seems pretty obvious in hindsight.
- alehul 9y ago> sounds more like a bunch of idiot investors gave a lot of money to a dreamer who wanted to make an impact and didn't know when to quit and fold her hand rather than an elaborate con Until you said 'her', I actually thought you were referring to Shkreli. He ran a hedge fund starting at 23, and when he lost a lot of the money, he made bigger bets and tried to earn the money back rather than admitting his losses. > I remember reading about the board a few years ago and just looked it up again. Several generals, Henry Kissinger...huh? Shkreli raised money from Steven Cohen's SAC Capital, the family of Fred Hassan (former CEO of Schering-Plough), and Brent Saunders, the current CEO of Allergan. Their stories, though they differ in industry, seem quite similar when compared in detail.
- aje403 9y agoWhile I don't know either of them so it is an unfair judgment to make, I would guess there's a big difference in thoughts in the back of their head: "These idiots aren't getting their money back, wait for my next play..." "If I can hold them off for another year, we'll have a big breakthrough..." Making larger bets to cover for an hide losses is a very common story for traders on wall street. Buying an AIDS drug to price gouge is not. In contrast, it seems like Holmes had an earnest desire to improve medical tech. Again, I'm speculating, we'll see if this unfolds any further. Fun story to follow.
- vasilipupkin 9y agoSEC doesn't put people in prison, it can refer to Justice Department for prosecution. Whether it does or not, depends on the circumstances of the case. They prefer quick resolution rather than years of litigation.
- georgeecollins 9y agoMany people are in jail today because they can't post bail. You can discourage ever facing incarceration by being able to afford a good legal defense. You can be forced to accept incarceration without conviction because you are poor.
- TremendousJudge 9y ago"In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread" - Anatole France
- georgeecollins 9y agoMy mom was a judge, and I learned that saying because she had it posted in her chambers.
- mevile 9y agoI doubt Holmes can afford much of anything anymore.
- enlightenedfool 9y ago
- desireco42 9y agoI wish we could do this to politicians, once caught in lie and fraud, bar them from taking any public office for 10 yrs :). I agree she got away lightly.
- diggan 9y agoFunny fact, in 2013, Italy actually banned Silvio Berlusconi from holding public office for 6 years. But, that doesn't stop him from participating and trying to win elections anyways...
- danmaz74 9y agoHe's not participating personally: he can't be elected. But his party wasn't barred.
- icebraining 9y agoRight, they find someone else to sign the paperwork.
- cmurf 9y agoImpeachment provides for this. At the federal level, you are bared from public office for life upon conviction. And it doesn't apply only to elected officials, but all public officials. Even some low person on the totem pole could be impeached, removed from their office, and bared from holding any public office ever again. Pardons do not apply to impeachment convictions. States vary in their impeachment proceedings and what burdens must be met.
- georgeecollins 9y agoIf you are convicted for drug trafficking or plead guilty to it, any asset that you can't prove you received through other legal means is likely to be subject to seizure.
- SilasX 9y agoIsn't that also true without your if-clause?
- throwawayjava 9y agoThe "is likely to be" part is not true in general. Changing that "likely to be" into a "may be" would make the statement true(r) without the if-clause. Also if the if-clause stated "suspected of" rather than "convicted of", then the "is likely to be" part would be true in general.
- georgeecollins 9y agoLet me show why I believe what I said. I'm no expert, and I would like it if you could clarify my understanding of why you think seizure of assets is not likely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United...
- debacle 9y agoThe civil forfeiture epidemic is more localized.
- throwawayjava 9y agoYes, I know exactly what you were referring to. I think this sentence is accurate: If you are suspected of drug dealing, any asset that you can't prove you received through other legal means is likely to be subject to seizure. I think this sentence is accurate: any asset that you can't prove you received through other legal means MAY be subject to seizure. I think this one isn't accurate, though: any asset that you can't prove you received through other legal means is likely to be subject to seizure. Maybe I'm just surrounded by extremely lucky people, but none of the people around me (all of whom aren't partaking in illegal behavior / have never been suspected of illegal behavior) have had the police show up and randomly take their stuff.
- briandear 9y agoSo she can’t be a director of a public company? Other than Yahoo, who would even consider hiring her? This “punishment” doesn’t seem like one. She should be in jail.
- hluska 9y agoI don't know if I agree with you. Personally, I can't imagine the humiliation of carrying this around with me...
- mikepurvis 9y agoLots of people currently in prison would happily choose "carrying around humiliation" as an alternative, I expect.
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoEveryone loves a comeback story, though. In a few years she'll take the circuit of podcasts / news outlets. "I thought we could do it. It started with a single, tiny lie and then it snowballed. I get out of control. I took some time off and now I'm starting my own company. We will be the most transparent company in the world and we're innovating X!" Something along those lines. It's not a life or career ender IMO.
- gaius 9y agoEven Tonya Harding is the subject of a flattering movie now
- fiblye 9y agoShe got to live a few years as a billionaire. She could easily get a normal, non-executive job like 99% of Americans after this. I think most people would take a lifetime of "humiliation" if they got to live an unreasonably extravagant life for a while then return to an upper middle class lifestyle, occasionally having news articles written about them until it all fades away completely after 5-10 years. A sentence of "humiliation" would only make scams like Theranos a more appealing idea to many people. And frankly, if someone could go so deep with a scam like Theranos, I don't think they/Holmes have much of a sense of shame to begin with. They'll justify their fraud to the very end.
- saas_co_de 9y agoSettlement is probably best for investors because they immediately get control of the company and Holmes basically gets nothing. The job of the SEC is to protect investors so they are probably doing the right thing here.
- gjem97 9y agoYeah, I don't think she gets nothing. She was paid a salary for many years, I would't be surprised if it was a pretty hefty one. There were probably other perks, too (wasn't she known to fly private for business trips?). It looks like she simply relinquished some equity that probably wasn't worth very much anyway. This settlement doesn't look like much of a deterrent to future would-be fraudsters.
- Nanite 9y agoTrue, and besides having lost money, their investors also continue to lose credibility, considering the poor if not complete lack of due diligence on their part, as long as this fiasco is in the spotlights.
- mathattack 9y agoThis will wipe her out, and likely kill her career. Remember, this is just the SEC. The pain they inflict is commensurate to investor pain. The government still should go after them for endangering people’s lives. There should be long jail terms for that.
- Kalium 9y ago> The government still should go after them for endangering people’s lives. There should be long jail terms for that. But the SEC won't, because that's not what they do. And this is, I think, as it should be.
- mathattack 9y agoExactly - separate group.
- spaceflunky 9y ago>This will wipe her out Will it though? Surely Holmes still has a few million stashed away somewhere that she can live comfortably off of? This settlement isn't going to leave her destitute. Either that or I'm sure she set up some clever offshore accounting structure that has $10M stashed in the cook islands or some shit. As soon as you get some cash, I think "rich person 101" is you set up some complicated structure to hide rainy day money for this very reason. I would venture to guess she took home at least $50MM in all those rounds of investment (maybe more? i have no idea how that works.), I doubt she blew it all or was stupid enough to leave it in plain sight.
- ericd 9y agoDid she take money off the table? Not everyone does/can, even when they raise a lot.
- spaceflunky 9y agoI often wonder about this. I know founders that have instantly taken $100k off the table on a $1M angel investment. but such is silicon valley life i suppose?
- icantdrive55 9y agoNot in my opinion. I remember those interviews, with the black turtle necks. She was playing the part of genius, but looked full of it, especially with all the secrets. She is basically being fined $500,000. This is pocket change. I imagine so much money is hidden. This hidden money just might be the next fraud charge? "Bared from hiring as an officer, or director for 10 years." She will get hired on somewhere under Something of Something, even though she's a complete fraud? She didn't even finish her degree? Hell--most people don't know anything about blood testing. In a few months, the victim will be on stage somewhere. "If a was a ---, I wouldn't be treated this way!" She got off very light. She's pretty enough to be scooped up by a Valley Boy. We have not heard the end of her. She will be fine. I can't imagine any retirement money went into the company, so I really don't care about the 1 percenter's who lost some pocket change. The only thing I'm glad about is no one is going to sport the black turtle neck, for awhile at least--that look belongs to Steve anyways. Any maybe, when the genius card is thrown around, people might do a little homework? She did enter the market, with the right look, pedigree, though. The Lookers were looking for the next Zuck. Oh well, and the band plays on. (I have a feeling under Trump's reign, the SEC, federal courts will go very easy on these types. So--if your planning on doing something fraudulent, white, and have family money; go to work.)
- joering2 9y agoPharma Bro was just sentenced to 7 years in jail for misrepresenting facts to investors, despite said investors did not lose any money but actually made some [1] Here Holmes not only doctored power point presentations to baloon numbers to investors, but put thousands of lives in danger (if some were lost, we will eventually find out) by providing wrong results for tests to many patients that lives relied on it, and she gets jail-free card and slap on the wrist. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/09/pharma-bro-martin-shkreli-sentenced-to-7-years-in-prison.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/03/09/pharma-bro-martin-shkreli-se...
- AcerbicZero 9y agoYeah, he was kind of a douche, but it's pretty obvious he only got slammed with that kind of time because he didn't play the game right.
- danso 9y agoShkreli received 7 years in prison because he was found guilty by a jury for securities fraud. What you refer to as "Here Holmes..." was were SEC civil charges. A criminal investigation was opened in mid-2016 and, as far as we all know, is still underway: https://www.npr.org/2016/04/19/474868428/innovative-blood-testing-company-theranos-under-criminal-investigation https://www.npr.org/2016/04/19/474868428/innovative-blood-te...
- kqr2 9y agoMost likely she also has Directors and Officer's Liability Insurance: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directors_and_officers_liability_insurance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directors_and_officers_liabili... As part of the settlement, there was no actual admission of wrongdoing or fraud, so it's quite possible that the insurance would pay the fine.
- sk5t 9y agoMaybe, maybe, if the insurer had the option to direct any defense, but it's still mighty hard to insure against willful acts.
- eggpy 9y agoWell, according to Forbes, Holmes is worth _nothing_[0], so $500,000 is probably fairly painful. Plus, relinquishing ~19 million shares regardless of their value has to hurt. Also she no longer has the majority of votes in her own company. And as a CEO who can't be an officer of a public company for 10 years, yeah that probably really hurts too. Not to mention her name is effectively toxic pretty much forever now. So she's not going to jail, but those penalties certainly look painful to me. [0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2016/06/01/from-4-5-billion-to-nothing-forbes-revises-estimated-net-worth-of-theranos-founder-elizabeth-holmes/#56ac4b833633 https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2016/06/01/from-4...
- kristianov 9y agoHer family is rich and connected. I don't see the punishment is too harsh without her going to jail.
- perl4ever 9y agoIt seems like a much larger fraud than Shkreli's, who got 7 years. Also, as someone pointed out, they didn't just deceive investors, they deceived the people who were getting blood tests and that seems much worse. So one might suspect there's some sort of privilege going on. Or maybe the story just isn't complete yet.
- Clubber 9y agoPoliticians needed the prosecutors to make an example of Shkrelli because they needed to distract people from the fact that cornering a drug market and hiking the prices is still perfectly legal and practiced by much larger companies.
- briandear 9y ago19 million shares of a company worth nothing?
- AndyMcConachie 9y agoIt's a slap on the wrist compared to the crime.
- mieseratte 9y agoThere's often a thin line between "startup founder" and "confidence man".
- edanm 9y agoNo, there isn't often a thin line. Most founders are not out there committing massive fraud. They may be doing a lot of marketing, and are probably promising things that still have to be built, but they're not out there lying that they have millions in revenue from contracts that don't exist, or falsifying demos.
- mieseratte 9y ago> Most founders Often does not imply most nor does it mean that there must be massive levels of fraud such that the SEC has to be involved.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoRight. "We had $50 million in bookings this year" - Misleading because it seems like that should mean $50 million in revenue but all of the bookings were for 10 year contracts so it is really only $5 million in revenue, but it is not fraudulent because it isn't factually untrue. "We will be able to raise prices enough to be profitable" - Often optimistic to the point of delusion, but without a time machine it is not a statement of fact so it isn't fraud.
- marcosdumay 9y agoEvery founder is optimistic to the point of delusion. It's a requisite. Investors know how to deal with that. What they don't know how to do is deciding if "those complicated papers that use words you never even heard before say we can do X" is a lie or not.
- icebraining 9y agoHow so? Isn't that what due diligence is? You get a third-party expert (be that in accounting or biology) with a signed NDA, and have them verify those results. What they probably can't handle is outright fabrication.
- hkmurakami 9y ago>Theranos and Holmes have agreed to settle the fraud charges levied against them. Holmes agreed to pay a $500,000 penalty, be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for 10 years, return the remaining 18.9 million shares that she obtained during the fraud, and relinquish her voting control of Theranos by converting her super-majority Theranos Class B Common shares to Class A Common shares. Due to the company’s liquidation preference, if Theranos is acquired or is otherwise liquidated, Holmes would not profit from her ownership until – assuming redemption of certain warrants – over $750 million is returned to defrauded investors and other preferred shareholders. 3 years ago, I never would have thought that such an outcome would actually happen.
- ithinkinstereo 9y agoPretty good outcome, especially if she avoids criminal charges. Presumably she's still pretty wealthy, enough not to have to work again or to lie-low for the next decade before staging a comeback.
- i_am_nomad 9y agoIf I recall, she hasn’t gained any liquid wealth from Theranos - her net worth was recently reported to be zero. https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2016/06/01/from-4-5-billion-to-nothing-forbes-revises-estimated-net-worth-of-theranos-founder-elizabeth-holmes/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/matthewherper/2016/06/01/from-4...
- draw_down 9y agoPeople like her have a way of failing upward, she will be fine.
- dhbanes 9y agoAre Meredith Perry and uBeam next?
- bhouston 9y agoDidn't she sort of demonstrate that it worked? Or least that is the headline I read.
- raesene9 9y agoMy (limited) understanding is that they've demonstrated a level of wireless power transmission, but nothing approaching some of the early hype that had things like mobile phones recharging in people's pockets whilst they were in a coffee shop. The controversy there isn't whether you can transfer wireless power or not, but whether you can transfer enough in an easy enough way to make a practical consumer product. If you want (alot) more detail this is a good thread to read http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/the-ubeam-faq/1175/ http://www.eevblog.com/forum/projects/the-ubeam-faq/1175/
- chime 9y ago> mobile phones recharging in people's pockets whilst they were in a coffee shop. While not using the same Qi-like charging mechanism, the physics has been proven: https://www.disneyresearch.com/publication/quasistatic-cavity-resonance-for-ubiquitous-wireless-power-transfer/ https://www.disneyresearch.com/publication/quasistatic-cavit...
- harryh 9y agoWithout commenting on the viability of the method in that link one way or another, I will point out that the physics is described are completely different than what uBeam has said they are working on. uBeam has said they are wirelessly transmitting power via high frequency sound. This link describes a method that uses magnetic fields.
- pdq 9y agoAnd Energous.
- GoRudy 9y agoWhy don't they have to serve jail time for this?
- Whomee 9y agoPussy Pass. Ask Skillrelli.
- jljljl 9y agoTwo major differences: The SEC can only bring civil charges, not criminal ones. So SEC investigations won’t bring jail time by themselves, although if the FBI or other agencies get involved that could happen Also, Holmes and Theranos settled, which probably had some impact that on the penalties they faced
- megadeth 9y agoWon’t see a day of jail time while Shkrelli gets 7 years.
- sseveran 9y agoWell he did mouth off to congress. Once that happened they were always IMHO going to dig until they got him on something.
- charlesdm 9y agoMartin Shkreli was, honest to god, an idiot. He got several chances to "kiss the ring" and show remorse, and what did he do? He put some extra oil on the fire and kept acting like an idiot until the very last moment. Sometimes you need to realise when to fold and suck it up.
- newnewpdro 9y agoWas?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- daxorid 9y agoAlternative take: it's disgusting and offensive to the foundational concept of blind justice that punishment is more highly correlated with charisma and obsequiousness to judges than it is to actual crimes committed.
- charlesdm 9y agoIt comes down to basic human decency. Of which he has none. And that does not make him very likeable. You can raise drug prices like he did and do it in a moral way. He was basically laughing in people's faces about what he did. I agree courts, juries and judges are to be neutral, but a person like him just ends up getting under most people's skin. Even if there was no rational decision to go hard on him, I wouldn't be surprised if people subconsciously make that decision.
- ss2003 9y agoHere's the danger of "Fake it till you make it."
- twosheep 9y agoHere's the complaint: https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2018/comp-pr2018-41-theranos-holmes.pdf https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2018/comp-pr2018-4...
- ebbv 9y agoTake a TV from a truck that's left open behind a warehouse; get months if not years in jail. Deliberately commit fraud for years and steal millions and millions of dollars; slap on the wrist. Our system is so ridiculous.
- jonwachob91 9y agoThe SEC is a civil agency and can not jail anyone for anything, they can only levy penalties. Justice has to take over the case for an offender to go to prison.
- ebbv 9y agoDo you think they will? Do you think Holmes and the others at Theranos responsible for the fraud will get any jail time? Maybe that's coming but it doesn't seem like it, and that's the point of my comment. I didn't say "The SEC sucks", I said the system sucks.
- FireBeyond 9y agoIs there any kind of requirement (or general process) that says that Justice typically defers until the SEC has issues findings and sanctions before beginning (or stepping up) criminal proceedings?
- Boxxed 9y agoHow does that make the above statement any less ridiculous? Isn't that exactly what he or she is pointing out? That the system is explicitly preventing these people from serving jailtime?
- mikeyouse 9y agoNo. The system doesn't do any such thing. Since the SEC only deals with civil penalties, they can act quickly and without the certainty required for criminal convinctions. They can also refer cases to the Justice Department, who can (and do) levy criminal charges. Just because the SEC is the only body to publicly announce a resolution doesn't mean that Holmes or Theranos are off the hook criminally. The Obama DOJ initiated a criminal investigation in 2016 that is apparently still active and could absolutely result in jail time: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/19/business/theranos-sec-justice-department-investigation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/19/business/theranos-sec-jus...
- ChuckMcM 9y agoOk, this is the money line in that press release for me: “The charges against Theranos, Holmes, and Balwani make clear that there is no exemption from the anti-fraud provisions of the federal securities laws simply because a company is non-public, development-stage, or the subject of exuberant media attention.” For all those entrepreneurs are trying to "fake it until you make it" be aware that the SEC considers your strategy both fraudulent and they feel they have the jurisdiction to prosecute you. And while I doubt the SEC is going to go after every CEO that raised a Series A on a pitch deck that was pure fantasy, the people who participated in the round might bring them in if it served their purposes.
- minimaxir 9y agoIt's worth nothing that one of Theranos's VC funders, Tim Draper, did defend Holmes despite the fraud allegations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973102 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973102 https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/theranos-investor-claims-theres-a-conspiracy-to-take-down-elizabeth-holmes https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/01/theranos-investor-cl...
- devy 9y agoSomeone called Tim Draper the Trump of Venture Capital[1] :) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11973420
- Coding_Cat 9y agoTim Draper also stands to gain from Theranos being reviewed positively, valid product or not, being an investor.
- minimaxir 9y agoThat's true, which just compounds the problem of newbie investors thinking "fake it until you make it" is OK because they get positive reinforcement from their investors.
- Waterluvian 9y agoIs Holmes still rich after this? I can't tell just how much of her wealth she's being forced to return in form of shares.
- swarnie_ 9y agoShe's half a million poorer from the fine. Any proceed from the sale of the (worthless) shares will need to be returned to defrauded investors amounting to 750 mil before she gets anything. So i think unless her entire position is sold for more then $36 a share she has lost everything from the company. No idea what her personal finances were going in to this event.
- jartelt 9y agoDo we know if she was rich before? Maybe she was able to cash out a lot of her shares during some of the financing rounds, but she also could have just been "rich" on paper by owning many Theranos shares. If she was rich by virtue of holding Theranos shares, her wealth has decreased a ton in the last couple years since the value of the company has surely plummeted.
- detaro 9y agoThe SEC document says that she never sold any of her shares, and says > Holmes was paid a salary of approximately $200,000 to $390,000 per year between 2013 and 2015
- seanieb 9y agoHey, I've no idea how to PM you, but you flagged my submission about the SEC charging another company... Equifax. This story is about Theranos. > https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16586011 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16586011 > "on the front page, please check for duplicates before submitting"
- detaro 9y agooops, embarassing... there's been discussion about equifax too, but I guess that was the criminal part and not SEC: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16584980 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16584980
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aphextron 9y agoSo... the punishment for getting caught in massive fraud is that you just have to give back the stuff you got through fraud? Sign me up.
- FussyZeus 9y agoUnless of course you steal Holmes' car. Then you'll probably be killed, or at best, incarcerated for 10 years. Remember kids, the rich are not playing the same game the rest of us are.
- oculusthrift 9y agoIt helps when you’re the opposite of a black male.
- fwdpropaganda 9y agoMy opinion: if you think this is about race and gender (as opposed to about wealth and power) you're being played.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoI think it plays into it quite a bit. Odds are, of the two crimes listed, stealing a car is more likely to be done by a black male. Hence, it's punished harder, despite Theranos objectively doing more harm.
- FussyZeus 9y agoWell the thing is, due to the redlining practices of yore, black people have a significant disadvantage when compared to even the meager wealth of poor whites. And that's not even getting into the cultural issues surrounding "ghetto" culture (which is also predominantly traceable to redlining.)
- chefandy 9y agoNot to mention schools being funded by property taxes, so people living in high-density, lower-value areas (depressed urban, almost always nonwhite) always have underfunded schools while those who live in relatively low-density, higher-value (wealthy suburbs, almost always white) areas have extremely well funded schools. Also, rampant employment discrimination based on name alone (Are Greg and Emily More Employable Than Lakisha And Jamal, 2003, pdf: https://tinyurl.com/ydghdzuc https://tinyurl.com/ydghdzuc) Also, higher police scrutiny than whites, and even higher conviction and incarceration rates than whites for the same crimes. etc. etc. etc. While there are economically depressed whites who have some of the same problems as economically depressed non-whites simply because they're economically depressed, their situations are not equivalent. Saying that they are is nothing more than a way for white people to distance themselves from the fact that we are in fact privileged because of our race, and that our relative success isn't solely attributed to our hard work, smarts and persistence.
- plouffy 9y ago700 million dollar fraud, 500.000 dollar penalty. That's an impressive RoI for the fraudsters.
- swarnie_ 9y agoNo one is lining up to buy Theranos shares, where is the ROI here?
- plouffy 9y agoIn salaries, perks etc ... I can imagine that a large part of the 700 million dollars would have been spent on salaries, perks etc ... 500,000 dollar fine seems paltry when you've essentially been able to con people out of 700 million.
- tabeth 9y agoWhat exactly needs to happen for white collar criminals to be punished commensurate with their crime and consistent with the magnitude of "regular" criminals' punishment? Holmes' punishment is effectively nil. Meanwhile: [1] A man sells $40 with of cocaine and eventually 5.9g of weed lands him 20 years in prison. [2] "Illegal" voting lands a woman 8 years and deportation. [3] Possession of a few shotgun shells gets a man 15 years. Meanwhile, defrauding investors hundreds of millions results in... nothing, really? There's a word for this. Unacceptable. [1] http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/crime/bs-md-ci-twenty-years-marijuana-case-20150507-story.html http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/crime/bs-md-ci-twe... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/10/us/illegal-voting-gets-texas-woman-8-years-in-prison-and-certain-deportation.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/10/us/illegal-voting-gets-te... [3] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/11/opinion/sunday/kristof-help-thy-neighbor-and-go-straight-to-prison.html?hp&_r=1& http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/11/opinion/sunday/kristof-hel...
- DannyBee 9y agoThe SEC can't jail people, they only have civil authority. They can only refer criminal cases to the us attorneys and DOJ and offer assistance (and i assume they did)
- Nokinside 9y ago> There's a word for this. Unacceptable. Expressing emotion and anger can be healthy. But let's discuss this and find out why this is and can and what should be done? * US justice system is designed for settlement. In US 97% of civil cases are settled or dismissed without a trial. 90% of federal criminal cases resolve without trial. 94% of state cases end via plea bargain. * Normal criminals accept harder sentences when they plead guilty. Is it because it's easier to find them guilty or because they don't have access to better lawyers? * Criminals can be put into prison only if they can be convicted. Many financial crimes are very hard to prosecute and end result is uncertain. Proving intent can be very hard. Concrete proof even harder. Getting something is better than getting nothing. When federal prosecutors go ahead, it's not uncommon that the result is acquittal. sources and backround The Difficulty of Proving Financial Crimes https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2010/12/13/the-difficulty-of-proving-financial-crimes/ https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2010/12/13/the-difficulty-of-pr... What prosecutors have to prove in order for you to be charged with a financial crime http://www.businessinsider.com/what-proof-for-financial-crime-prosecution-2017-1?r=US&IR=T&IR=T http://www.businessinsider.com/what-proof-for-financial-crim... So what do we want? Do we want to relax the the burden of proof in financial crimes? More regulation and paper work that leads easier to prosecute trail (called bureaucracy that increases the cost of enterprise).
- OscarTheGrinch 9y agoFake it 'til you break it...
- mbesto 9y agoThis is why due diligence is important folks.
- oculusthrift 9y agoI wonder if Holmes was male if she would be treated like Martin Shkreli and attacked in every horrible way possible. Don’t see much rhetoric against her.
- hammock 9y agoYou must be new to Hacker News.
- whafro 9y agoTheranos was a punch line in my office just this morning, and she'll forever be associated with that. But Shkreli has brought on himself another order of magnitude of personal criticism because of his statements and actions beyond the price fixing. In my experience from the days after his sentencing, people who know nothing about tech or healthcare know his name and react to it with scorn, while quite few of them know the name of his funds or companies.
- fhood 9y agoHoo boy, you are right, the world sure is hard for us white males. Discrimination lurks around every corner. I can't believe nobody realizes that ol Martin wasn't punished because he made a public ass of himself and openly mocked the justice department. It was because he was a white male.
- danso 9y agoMaybe it's because you weren't paying attention to it at the time. Or wasn't* reading HN when the investigations were coming out: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12053721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12053721 Less than a year later, before punishments really started to be officially levied against her and Theranos, a movie project with Jennifer Lawrence drew a frenzy of bidding. https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2016/06/jennifer-lawrence-theranos-elizabeth-holmes https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/2016/06/jennifer-lawren... edit: added "wasn't"
- DannyBee 9y agoPeople keep complaining about lack of jail time. As has been repeated in a number of subcomments: The SEC cannot send people to jail. Full stop. They have only civil authority. They refer criminal cases to the US attorneys/DOJ, and offer assistance. All evidence suggests they did so here. The decision to criminally prosecute or not is out of their hands.
- tabeth 9y agoWhy can't the SEC send people to jail? I don't understand the point you're making. If people believe something is an injustice should they just shut up? Even if they can't send people to jail people should complain if they feel that shouldn't be the case -- it's a signal that perhaps the current process is wrong. After all, all restrictions and rules were created by us to begin with. Complaining can be useful feedback.
- bllguo 9y agothey don't have the authority to do that... yes, people should inform themselves before talking. Jail time and other penalties will depend on the Justice Department
- Bud 9y agoBecause it does not have the authority to do so. https://www.sec.gov/oiea/investor-alerts-bulletins/ib_investigations.html https://www.sec.gov/oiea/investor-alerts-bulletins/ib_invest...
- tabeth 9y agoI've already read that -- it does not explain why. It simply states that it cannot. What law restricted it? Why was that law put into place? How often are recommendations for prosecution followed up on successfully? EDIT: Thanks everyone for the information -- very interesting.
- Bud 9y ago
- joshsabol46 9y agoTheranos is a case study about the consequences of Wizard of Oz Experiments.
- chrisper 9y agoThe SEC title says Massive Fraud. I think the title here should reflect that.
- nraynaud 9y agois the "Massive" part just grand standing, or does it correspond to a legal qualification of the alleged offense? Interestingly I can't google that because I get drowned under Theranos results.
- briandear 9y agoSo do those of us accused of sexism for not supporting Holmes a few years ago now get vindicated? Attacking her competence and questioning the Theranos Kool-Aid was seen as sexist and unfair, but it turns out we were right — she is a criminal — or at least a civil violator of securities law.
- matt4077 9y agoThe accusations (at least the ones I made) were never about her guilt or innocence. From what I remember, HN and similar just had dozens and dozens articles each week on this case, far more than for other, comparable cases. MtGox was around the same time, I believe. My subjective impression was also that Holmes featured far more prominently in the articles and discussions than male CEOs in other cases. Here is one commentator in this thread comitting all sorts of crimes against grammar to accentuate her gender: “The FBI should recommend charges for this Holmes lady.” Edit: I just noticed the comment I cited was by the same user I was replying to :) I guess my sexism-radar is well-tuned today.
- perl4ever 9y agoI think some perspective is needed. The idea that medical services you may get could be a fraud and nobody who matters really cares is much more threatening to the average person than some cryptocurrency exchange losing money or other cases of wealthy speculators being defrauded. Lots of news articles were written about the LIBOR scandal too, but even if I read them, I don't believe deep down that it affected me meaningfully.
- EpicEng 9y agoAnd if he had said >The FBI should recommend charges for this Holmes guy. No one would think twice. Stop looking for reasons to be outraged, you'll be better off for it.
- danso 9y agoCan you link to threads/places where people ripping on Holmes (post-WSJ investigation) were under heavy fire? Investor Tim Draper continued to call critics sexist/malicious but I wouldn't call him status quo by any stretch of the imagination: https://www.axios.com/tim-draper-keeps-defending-theranos-1513299953-eadf43f6-1803-422c-8869-f55d86844d6b.html https://www.axios.com/tim-draper-keeps-defending-theranos-15...
- spodek 9y agoFor those interested in learning about the United States government moving from prosecuting white-collar criminals to settling, the difference between the SEC and Justice Department misses the point. The book The Chickenshit Club https://www.amazon.com/Chickenshit-Club-Department-Prosecute-Executives/dp/1501121367 https://www.amazon.com/Chickenshit-Club-Department-Prosecute... by a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist tells a more thorough and comprehensive, though infuriating and tragic, story.
- unquietcode 9y agoYou can commit most crimes in this world with relative impunity, but the number one rule is never steal from the rich.
- driven20 9y agoI have seen this idea from time to time. I don't think it's right. The problem is they are stealing from people with abilities, smarts, and resources. Of course, there are going to be backlashes.
- neveroffensive 9y ago> The problem is they are stealing from people with abilities, smarts, and resources. To be fair, these sorts of people tend to be wealthy. I think the real lesson is don't steal in the public eye. Theranos had so much press surrounding their rise, and fall. It was inevitable the SEC would get involved.
- Bartweiss 9y ago"Lying about deals with the same government that will eventually prosecute you" seems like another pretty obvious rule. Claiming you have contracts signed when you don't is fraud, but claiming you have $100M in DoD revenue when you don't is elaborate corporate suicide.
- briandear 9y agoThat's ridiculous. She would have gotten thrown in jail if she carried an ounce of cocaine. "Stealing from the rich" resulted in a "civil" violation. Big deal. When the Department of Justice charges, convicts and throws her in prision -- then we can talk about the "number one rule."
- jeffdavis 9y agoWhat does "charged" mean here? Is this criminal or civil?
- bane 9y agoUgh Finally. More than just the financial fraud, these folks engaged in behavior that actively endangered the public. I hope this isn't the end of the government actions against them. Her public behavior was exceptionally bizarre and almost none of what's been revealed comes as any real surprise. For timeline purposes: Dec 24, 2017 - They get $100m lifeline investment https://www.wsj.com/articles/blood-testing-firm-theranos-gets-100-million-lifeline-from-fortress-1514057523 https://www.wsj.com/articles/blood-testing-firm-theranos-get... June 21, 2017 - Walgreens settlement https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-walgreens-reach-deal-to-settle-lawsuit-1498037580 https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-walgreens-reach-deal-t... May 30, 2017 - Crisis on the Board https://www.wsj.com/articles/court-documents-shed-light-on-theranos-boards-response-to-crisis-1496136600 https://www.wsj.com/articles/court-documents-shed-light-on-t... April 21, 2017 - Caught using outside lab gear to fake tests https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-secretly-bought-outside-lab-gear-ran-fake-tests-court-filings-1492794470 https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-secretly-bought-outsid... April 5, 2017 - Holmes found to owe $25m to her own startup https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14047457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14047457 Jan 19, 2017 - Closes last lab after failing inspection https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13433840 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13433840 Jan 17, 2017 - second lab fails inspection https://www.wsj.com/articles/second-theranos-lab-failed-u-s-inspection-1484708428 https://www.wsj.com/articles/second-theranos-lab-failed-u-s-... Jan 6, 2017 - Lays off 41% of workforce https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13338996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13338996 Nov 17, 2016 - Whistleblower comes out https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/283681/theranos-whistleblower-was-george-shultz-grandson-wsj https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/283681/theranos-whistleblow... July 8, 2016 - Banned from operating a lab for 2 years https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12053721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12053721 Jan 27, 2016 - Letter from the feds https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10983747 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10983747 Dec 20, 2015 - Some skepticism https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10765562 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10765562 Oct 16, 2015 - Struggles with tech https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-has-struggled-with-blood-tests-1444881901 https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-has-struggled-with-blo...
- swyx 9y agogreat list. thank you
- cat199 9y agocall me back when the ex board members get hit for this.. IMHO the fraud wasn't the investors getting fleeced, it was the US public through obamacare payments made for pharmacy blood screening.. and given the players this will never, ever, ever see the light of day.. for now, it sounds like they are taking the fall to cover the higher ups to me.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theranos https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theranos Since its incorporation in 2003, Holmes has been the company's chief executive officer. She recruited Channing Robertson, a chemical-engineering professor at Stanford, to be a technical advisor and the company's first board member during its early years. Sunny Balwani, a software engineer Holmes had met during high school, joined the company as its president and chief operating officer in 2009.[54] In July 2011, Holmes was introduced to former Secretary of State George Shultz, who joined the Theranos board of directors that same month.[55] Over the next three years, Shultz helped to introduce almost all the outside directors on the "all-star board," which included William Perry (former Secretary of Defense), Henry Kissinger (former Secretary of State), Sam Nunn (former U.S. Senator), Bill Frist (former U.S. Senator and heart-transplant surgeon), Gary Roughead (Admiral, USN, retired), James Mattis (General, USMC), Richard Kovacevich (former Wells Fargo Chairman and CEO) and Riley Bechtel (chairman of the board and former CEO at Bechtel Group).[55][56][57] The board was criticized for consisting "mainly of directors with diplomatic or military backgrounds."[11] As of May 2016, the Theranos board of directors were:[64] Elizabeth Holmes, Founder and CEO Riley Bechtel, former Bechtel Group CEO David Boies, a founder and the chairman of Boies Schiller & Flexner William Foege, former director U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Richard Kovacevich, former Wells Fargo CEO and chairman James Mattis, retired USMC General Fabrizio Bonanni, former executive vice president of Amgen
- ilamont 9y agoBoard members may have been incompetent, guilty of a dereliction of duty, or were tricked themselves. Meeting minutes would shed light on this.
- i_am_nomad 9y agoIt’s noteworthy that none of the board members had experience in the medical device industry. They were most likely just in over their heads.
- ejlangev 9y agoIt's about time. Blatantly lying to investors is fraud and should be prosecuted as such. People who defraud others should face consequences for doing so.
- mbesto 9y agoAside from everything else rightfully pointed out in this thread - the other interesting bit is that it's likely that their investment in commercial real estate will net a pretty massive return. I can't think of many places in the Bay that are better for a large office that can hold 100's of employees. For reference, the HQ they built in PA: https://www.google.com/maps/place/1701+Page+Mill+Rd,+Palo+Alto,+CA+94304/@37.4088252,-122.1537814,3a,75y,145.99h,83.72t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sSa9Do8oPZ7jhSbrBHYOkEw!2e0!6s%2F%2Fgeo3.ggpht.com%2Fcbk%3Fpanoid%3DSa9Do8oPZ7jhSbrBHYOkEw%26output%3Dthumbnail%26cb_client%3Dsearch.TACTILE.gps%26thumb%3D2%26w%3D392%26h%3D106%26yaw%3D126.308975%26pitch%3D0%26thumbfov%3D100!7i16384!8i8192!4m5!3m4!1s0x808fbabdef9cac33:0xf011ccf019f54d02!8m2!3d37.408248!4d-122.152764 https://www.google.com/maps/place/1701+Page+Mill+Rd,+Palo+Al...
- 2YwaZHXV 9y agoThey didn't actually build it. Stanford owned the land and building (and built most of it) while Theranos paid for internal improvements. Stanford also recently sold the property (maybe a year or so ago) and 1701 is available for lease now.
- mbesto 9y agoOh wow, TIL. I thought they had bought it from HP.
- 2YwaZHXV 9y agoIt was actually a Wall Street Journal building before it was torn down to build the building Theranos moved into. Theranos was previously in 1601 California Ave (the old Facebook building), which was previously HP/Agilent.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoI think there is a fair distinction between "fake it until you make it" and actually willfully defrauding your investors and customers. Sure this may work at the beginning but you have to do some kind of magic or goal at the end of "faking it" and have results.
- kolbe 9y agoHeadline is misleading. Securities Fraud is not fraud fraud.
- Kliment 9y agoUnfortunately pricks.com, by Blake Ross, is no longer online. However, the CDN that hosted it is still up so here is the direct link - it's a script for a comedy show based on theranos, and painfully close to reality https://web.archive.org/web/20160604083644/http://static1.squarespace.com/static/56345cc7e4b017e2546ad875/t/563aaac5e4b025f66b293ec8/1446685381777/pricks.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20160604083644/http://static1.sq...
- the-dude 9y agoLink does not work : the website expired.
- jaclaz 9y agoCourtesy Wayback Machine: https://web.archive.org/web/20160604083644/http://static1.squarespace.com/static/56345cc7e4b017e2546ad875/t/563aaac5e4b025f66b293ec8/1446685381777/pricks.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20160604083644/http://static1.sq...
- Kliment 9y agoHah, I actually got the same message about the website being expired but it also served me a PDF. Link updated.
- blakeross 9y agoHah good memory! I guess I'll resurrect it for the trial :)
- Kliment 9y agoI passed it on to everyone I knew that was in any way related to the comedy/entertainment industry. And a lot of other people besides. It's excellent writing, even though it's for a medium I generally don't enjoy. Thank you for putting it out there! And that was an excellent use of that domain name.
- misiti3780 9y agoSo this was complete bullshit too?:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGfaJZAdfNE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGfaJZAdfNE
- starpilot 9y agoTimes like this when I appreciate big government and bureaucracy. This is exactly what they should be doing. This is in the interest of the public.
- mathattack 9y agoCould the SEC litigation be whybthe VCs has to keep quiet?
- joering2 9y ago> Holmes — a Steve Jobs wannabe who dressed exclusively in black turtlenecks — settled with the regulators for $500,000 while neither admitting nor denying the accusations. What Holmes did is most likely a fraud... but what the regulators did in this part above is pure and simple blackmail and extortion... the only problem is that who's gonna prosecute the persecutors.... This is really not far from wild wild west hundred years ago, where everyone was wearing guns at their belts. Truly mind boggling!!
- UncleEntity 9y ago> but what the regulators did in this part above is pure and simple blackmail and extortion Settling out of court is blackmail and extortion? If they thought they were innocent they could have had their day in court but instead they basically pleaded "no contest" and took their lumps.
- joering2 9y agoNeither part admit or deny accusations. What the heck?? So why does DOJ even exist in the first place when such dipsy doodle can occur?
- danso 9y ago"No contest" pleas are a policy of the U.S. judicial branch, and are handled on a case-by-case basis [0]. The DOJ is an agency within the U.S. executive branch. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolo_contendere#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nolo_contendere#United_States
- nodesocket 9y agoI'll be very curious to see how and if her charges compare to Martin Shkreli who got the book thrown at him (7 years and $7.4m). Shkreli was a scapegoat mostly because of his public/social media persona, cockiness, and arrogance. Meanwhile the crooks that caused the financial meltdown have not been charged with anything. Bene vixit, qui bene latuit— "He lives well who conceals himself well."
- williamscales 9y agoI don't think he was a scapegoat per se, he did actually do illegal things. But I imagine that things would have gone a lot better for him if he had not jacked up the price of Daraprim to the extent he did. It seems that drew attention to his previous activities.
- nodesocket 9y ago> jacked up the price of Daraprim Which by the way is completely legal and common in the pharmaceutical market, but the media outrage and SJW backlash made it seem illegal.
- danso 9y agoDidn't realize President Trump is/was a SJW http://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trump-martin-shkreli-daraprim-drug-cost-2015-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trump-martin-shkreli-d...
- DoreenMichele 9y agoYou learn something new everyday.;)
- freejulian 9y agoHe didn’t hide from what he was doing - he embraced it. Make no mistake, big pharma is doing the exact same things. I for one am appreciative that he called attention to the power monopolies have over the pricing of medicine. He had the book thrown at him because he drew attention to what modern capitalism is.
- RoyTyrell 9y agoGood. While they had a good idea, it's run by unethical and terrible people who really have no regard for the safety of the public. It seems like every time they were forced to show any level of proof they lied until they were caught. If a pharmaceutical company operated like they do, I doubt anyone would be praising them for any reason.
- EpicEng 9y agoWhat was the good idea exactly? As far as I'm aware the details of their (non-existent) tech have never been shared, not even with investors. Anyone can think up some pie in the sky idea.
- RoyTyrell 9y ago> What was the good idea exactly? Using tiny amounts of blood to do a whole entire blood workup. > their (non-existent) tech Some of it existed. It just required them lying about using other companies' products with a standard volume of blood. The rest of course was entirely made up. > Anyone can think up some pie in the sky idea. I agree. I just said the idea was good but unfortunately for her, even being a mega-uber-disrupter-genius like Elizabeth Homes, our level of technology isn't there yet and maybe never will be.
- jbduler 9y agoFirst, Kuddos to John Carreyrou from the WSJ for great investigative journalism. I’m too tired of all these “fake it till you make it” lines of thought, and it is not only a YC issue, it is pervasive across the valley. Cloning flappy birds, "uber" for pet grooming, etc I don't care. But when things get serious and your life and money is at stake, there is no room for BS "disruptors" with 20 hours of training on subjects such as insurance, medical care, banking, or your lifetime investments. The list of "pseudo disruptors" is pretty long: Remember Zenefits' Parker Conrad fraud: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/18/technology/zenefits-scandal-highlights-perils-of-hypergrowth-at-start-ups.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/18/technology/zenefits-scand... or that 3D printer for makeup: https://techcrunch.com/2014/05/05/mink-is-a-3d-printer-for-makeup/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/05/05/mink-is-a-3d-printer-for-m... There are a lot of very comments here, at least that is reassuring. Folks get it.
- digitalantfarm 9y agoGuys, we're talking about some serious meme potential here.
- supernova87a 9y agoAgain, I will just state that the reason we (maybe secretly) take so much satisfaction / schadenfreude at this story is that someone who was so hyped and the darling of Silicon Valley got so much funding and attention. While others who toil away on good ideas, without nearly so many connections and silver spoons, struggle to even get 1 minute of air time with the kind of funders and backers that she got. Separately, I hope that they absolutely nail and jail Sunny Balwani, who threatened and intimidated whistleblowing employees with their careers for exposing the massive fraud that Theranos was. Finally, we should be thankful that the SEC and agencies like DHHS and CMMS actually still have some teeth and reputability to follow through on issues like this and have not been totally gutted. Imagine 100 years ago when hucksters like this were touting every fake medicine under the sun and people were actually grateful for public-serving regulation. The order from CMMS to Theranos actually essentially said, "You are in immediate jeopardy of violating the law and must provide proof that you're reversing the harm caused by your inaccurate / fraudulent medical test results. Simply closing your lab will not remove this jeopardy." Thank god for rules.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoSchadenfreude is a word commonly used in discussion of the Theranos debacle and it really aggravates me because it presumes that anyone not throwing a pity party for these pathological liars defrauding people of money and potentially putting lives at stake with their bullshit tests that don't work are somehow bad people with negative personality traits. No, Holmes and her people are bad people with negative personality traits. The folks going "Fuck yeah, this bullshit never made sense to me and I am glad to learn I am not crazy" aren't suffering some personality disorder. They just are glad to find reality aligns with their understanding of reality. Also: Justice is a thing. Righteous anger over bad behavior is not schadenfreude.
- googlryas 9y agoWhy do you think schadenfreude is a negative personality trait or a personality disorder? It is just a name for a specific emotional state. It seems perfectly apt here.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Balgair 9y agoHis name is Tyler Shultz. He is the main reason we know know what Theranos was doing. He had his life destroyed, he knew it would happen, what Theranos would do to him, and he did the right thing all the same. Tyler Shultz is a hero. Never let someone tell you that you don't matter. Try hard to do what is right. We need more people like him, be one of them too. Be like Tyler Shultz. https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2016/11/explosive-new-details-emerge-in-lawsuit-against-theranos https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2016/11/explosive-new-detail... Edit: Pic: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3944392/Theranos-whistleblower-revealed-George-Shultz-s-grandson-Tyler-exposed-flaws-Elizabeth-Holmes-technology.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3944392/Theranos-whi...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- roymurdock 9y agoHe has started his own company Flux Biosciences in 2017 after learning some important lessons... "With Theranos I learned that entrepreneurs have to sell their vision," he said. "But you have to have some line between having a vision and seeing something that’s just not there." "[Flux Biosciences] is developing point-of-care medical tests on blood, urine or saliva. Right now the company is working on a test for testosterone in saliva which could give a consumer health information but wouldn't serve as a diagnostic test that would affect medical care, as Theranos' tests aimed to." https://www.forbes.com/sites/elliekincaid/2017/10/03/after-blowing-the-whistle-on-theranos-tyler-shultz-is-going-back-into-diagnostic-testing/2/#656bc540fd5f https://www.forbes.com/sites/elliekincaid/2017/10/03/after-b...
- Balgair 9y agoIt seems that there is justice in this world, then. By going public Tyler Schultz very likely saved lives. I can only wish him the best in his new endeavors. For certain, anyone doing business with him knows his handshake is worth something real.
- pinewurst 9y agoI had a similar thought when this story appeared this morning. https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-whistleblower-shook-the-companyand-his-family-1479335963 https://www.wsj.com/articles/theranos-whistleblower-shook-th...
- CrankyBear 9y agoIt took them long enough!
- non_sequitur 9y agoI still find it crazy that her response to a question on how the tech worked was: "A chemistry is performed so that a chemical reaction occurs and generates a signal from the chemical interaction with the sample, which is translated into a result, which is then reviewed by certified laboratory personnel."
- samgranieri 9y agoExactly. "A Chemistry is performed"... yeah, that's a phrase I'd expect out of a second grader, not a Stanford dropout...
- petsormeat 9y agoLawdy. Was Sarah Palin her speechwriter?
- jdoliner 9y agoThis sounds like Vincent Adultman from Bojack Horseman.
- danso 9y agoI hadn't seen this before, or if I had, I've forgotten, but Theranos created an account on HN to post to the "Who is hiring?" threads https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=Theranos https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=Theranos First message was May 5, 2014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7701095 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7701095 > Visit a lab for a Doctors appointment recently? Two vials of blood is a lot isn't it? Theranos is looking to completely redefine healthcare by solving speed and accuracy issues of current lab testing by combining SW engineering and life sciences using 1/1000 less blood than what is typically drawn today; our process have results in Doctors’ hands in as little as 2 hours allowing them to provide significantly more accurate treatments in a timely manner. The first time someone replied: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8401792 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8401792 > I was rather disappointed that the site doesn't say much about the underlying assay technologies you're using.
- txsh 9y agoGood. Now lets put everyone who they paid to hype them in prison as well, every journalist, blogger, hacker news poster who received money in exchange for writing a favorable comment.
- xwvvvvwx 9y agoThis should terrify pretty much anybody who did an ICO last year.
- yalogin 9y agoSo how are they able to still operate? It was revealed to be a scam a couple of years ago now? How are they still running? Even if no one is jailed right away, I would expect everyone to leave and them not be able to hire anyone again.
- paul7986 9y agoStill slightly amused that my uncle thru marriage..his brother was the CEO of a very well known national store who invested in Holmes. My uncle in 2014 mentioned how excited his brother was to help Holmes out and her mission. Which seems like there was no mission just a spoiled brat telling lies for her ego's sake all the while leading all her parents rich friends to be defrauded. I tried so many times to get investment from his brother yet his brother just played along/followed his rich friends vs. helping out a distance family member. I even had a startup in which I met with Google per their invitation to talk about buying us and every huge tech name knocked on our door. We only received 25k of investment from a Baltimore incubator, yet tried to get additional but I'm not a cool kid or a kid with rich friends or parents with rich friends.
- rdlecler1 9y agoI’m guessing she wasn’t renting a small studio in Palo Alto. Wonder if they’ll claw back any of these ill gotten gains.
- fungiblecog 9y agoSo if you commit massive fraud you get a slap on the wrists. Meanwhile people committing minor crimes (in comparison) are incarcerated.
- Ice_cream_suit 9y agoFrom the Financial Times: Here's the nuance of her formula: Commit fraud as an attractive, well-connected WASP woman who happened to be neighbors with well-connected VC Draper family. Tell a great story: Stanford drop-out who studied Chinese, afraid of needles, wants to help the world. Leverage Silicon Valley connections to pull in other really big fish, such as Kissinger, et al, who would be really, really embarrassed that they were so hoodwinked by an ingenue. Use that cognitive dissonance to raise more and more money, while having no technology whatsoever. Get even more and bigger fish such as Biden to vouch for you. Wrap your company in total mysterious secrecy. Declare anyone against you as against women in business. Works like a charm and will happen again in the future.
- jedberg 9y ago> Works like a charm I dunno, I'd say it kinda failed here.
- tenpies 9y agoI'd say it worked fantastically. For the sake of timing lets compare Shkreli and Holmes. She committed a much larger fraud and lost people huge amounts of money. She is spending exactly zero days in prison. She is getting a $500,000 fine - which Theranos is probably paying for - and a slap in the wrist[1]. Meanwhile Shkreli - who's "victims" lost zero money - is going to spend 7 years in jail and has lost at least $10 million because the government decided to take it over. I would love to see people complaining about gender gaps addressing the huge gender gap in our justice system, because cases like this are a slap in the face. --- [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-theranos-sec/theranos-and-its-founder-settle-u-s-fraud-charges-sec-idUSKCN1GQ2HC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-theranos-sec/theranos-and...
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIt would be hard to punish Holmes worse than Shrkeli at this point. 7 years in a male prison has much more potential to destroy a life than 7 years in a female one.
- hahahaha23 9y agoVCs seem to care a Stanford/google background more than anything else. They should be punished by watching “moneyball” non-stop for a week.
- Ice_cream_suit 9y agoMartin Shkreli = 7 years, $7.5M fine Investor capital lost = ~$0 Elizabeth Holmes = $500k fine, D&O bar Company value lost = ~$8 billion
- yters 9y agoWhy is there such a culture of fake it till you make it in SV? If the tech is good, no need for faking. If the tech is bad, figure it out, don't fake it. Otherwise, if it doesn't work and it is faked, things will get really bad and at worst lives could be lost. It seems like there is a lot of stupid money around and a lot of scam artists trying to suck the supply dry.
- tomtimtall 9y ago> Why is there such a culture of fake it till you make it in SV? If the tech is good, no need for faking. Nothing happens in a vacuum. If you don’t work hard to hype and oversell your cure for cancer, investors will be passing you by to invest in this nonexistant blood analysis product hyped to the skies. In VC it doesn’t matter what’s you have. The game is to attract enough captital to the point where you can hopefully crate what you sold investors on already having before he house of cards collapses. It’s like one big hype/investment ponzi skeam after another, however companies can openly loose money for years after years without anyone calling bullshit as long as the prospect of gains are hyped enough. Though importantly, you have to work the right line between outright lying and hyping. Prefix everything with “might be” and “could potentially” dumb investors will still be fooled but you might survive the legal fallout more gracefully.
- yters 9y agoBelieving your own hype does not make it any less a scam.
- pg_bot 9y agoIt may be the case that Theranos could not "figure it out" as it may be impossible to do what they claim they could. In that case there is no reason for Theranos to exist as the real fix would be to do what existing labs already do (draw more blood) and they would not have any competitive advantage in their field. The correct move is to always be honest with results and to pursue one of two strategies. Spend the rest of the money they have attempting to perfect a machine that is likely to never work, or return the rest of your investors money and close up shop. The healthcare market does not tolerate fuck ups. If you are working in this space you have to be tough and competent. Things need to work as advertised or you will be sued out of existence.
- throwaway84742 9y agoIsn’t she a pretty close relative of some congressman? If so, this could be a good test of how much justice there is left in the justice system. It’s pretty hard to deny she caused a significant amount of damage.
- jotjotzzz 9y agoWhy no jail time? We should start sending CEOs to jail.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoIt still baffles me how this ever got started. How does a 19 year old sophomore dropout have sufficient expertise in microfluidics plus clinical testing to garner hundreds of millions in investment with pure vapor? Nevermind the learning curve of running the business and developing a real saleable product.
- artur_makly 9y ago"Holmes subsequently raised $6 million in funding, the first of almost $700 million that would follow. Money often comes with strings attached in Silicon Valley, but even by its byzantine terms, Holmes’s were unusual. She took the money on the condition that she would not divulge to investors how her technology actually worked, and that she had final say and control over every aspect of her company. This surreptitiousness scared off some investors. When Google Ventures, which focuses more than 40 percent of its investments on medical technology, tried to perform due diligence on Theranos to weigh an investment, Theranos never responded. Eventually, Google Ventures sent a venture capitalist to a Theranos Walgreens Wellness Center to take the revolutionary pinprick blood test. As the V.C. sat in a chair and had several large vials of blood drawn from his arm, far more than a pinprick, it became apparent that something was amiss with Theranos’s promise."
- FlyingSideKick 9y agoIt seems the settlement of a $500k for Holmes was rather weak justice and sends the wrong message. With the kind of fraud she perpetuated to investors jail time would be more appropriate.
- sidcool 9y agoWhile we enjoy the fruits of capitalism we should also accept its Dark Side. There will always be people who abuse a Goodwill system. I'm not completely satisfied with the outcome, but I hope this serves as a warning to the abusers of capitalism. Thank you SEC and the Justice Department.
- TravelTechGuy 9y agoPeople have been talking for a while about the SEC moving towards some sort of regulation/legislation of ICOs. I believe the following paragraph in their announcement is telling (emphasis mine): “Investors are entitled to nothing less than complete truth and candor from companies and their executives,” said Steven Peikin, Co-Director of the SEC’s Enforcement Division. “The charges against Theranos, Holmes, and Balwani make clear that there is no exemption from the anti-fraud provisions of the federal securities laws simply because a company is __ non-public, development-stage, or the subject of exuberant media attention __.”
- make3 9y agoWouldn't she be going to prison for this? Did I read incorrectly, or are they not trying to send her to prison
- redsummer 9y agoWhat could have attracted all these senile old men to this young blonde woman’s company? It’s a mystery wrapped in an enigma.
- fnord77 9y agothe more these stories come out, the more that Holmes is coming off as sociopathic, to me at least.
- Moorcountry 9y agoMost of the wealthy did similar things but were not prosecuted. Behind Every Great Fortune There Is a Crime. Very few super wealthy made their money honestly.
- ossdev 9y agohttp://www.paulgraham.com/founders.html http://www.paulgraham.com/founders.html > 4. Naughtiness > Though the most successful founders are usually good people, they tend to have a piratical gleam in their eye. They're not Goody Two-Shoes type good. Morally, they care about getting the big questions right, but not about observing proprieties. That's why I'd use the word naughty rather than evil. They delight in breaking rules, but not rules that matter. This quality may be redundant though; it may be implied by imagination. > Sam Altman of Loopt is one of the most successful alumni, so we asked him what question we could put on the Y Combinator application that would help us discover more people like him. He said to ask about a time when they'd hacked something to their advantage—hacked in the sense of beating the system, not breaking into computers. It has become one of the questions we pay most attention to when judging applications. Too naughty, Sam? I suppose it all depends on whether or not you pull it off. If her oversold, semi-vaporwear tech ultimately panned out, and she ultimately got the Defense Department deals she lied to her investors about having, I could easily see her being held up as another celebrated example of "fake it 'till you make it." (Or until the SEC shuts you down for fraud).
- k1lly 9y agoAgain, what have you expected? https://medium.com/multiple-personalities-order/how-to-be-the-best-investor-in-the-world-ed31163fe965 https://medium.com/multiple-personalities-order/how-to-be-th...
- dangle 9y agoFake it till you make it?