11 ms·
But energy efficiency has been increasing at a fairly steady rate for much longer than the last 10 years. Jevons paradox(1) has previously ensured that increas
by bryanlarsen 9y ago
But energy efficiency has been increasing at a fairly steady rate for much longer than the last 10 years.
Jevons paradox(1) has previously ensured that increased efficiency resulted in increased demand. What has changed now?
1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- toomuchtodo 9y agoPeople are getting older, and use less resources overall as they age. Drive less as well.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoThis is interesting, especially in the areas TVA covers. Would be cool to correlate this usage by average age of the customer base.
- amluto 9y agoI would guess that Jevon's paradox doesn't exist for many domestic applications. Most people have all the lights, washing machines, etc that they need. Making lights more efficient won't make people buy more of them.
- moccachino 9y agoI would argue LED lighting does increase the demand for all sorts of lights rather a lot. It is due to increased efficiency, but that is not directly what creates the demand. The increased efficiency means light bulbs are no longer a fire hazard, allowing lights to be strewn just about anywhere and left on indefinitely.
- wickawic 9y agoAgeeed. Also seeing as LED bulbs are ~10x more efficient per lumen than incandescent, people are not installing 10x as much brightness in their homes
- pouetpouet 9y agoPerception of brightness is not linear. The human eye response is not linear. So x10 the luminous flux (power output) will be perceived as brighter but far from x10.
- Dylan16807 9y agok. People are still not installing 10x as much light.
- pouetpouet 9y agonot in their home, but I can see many more historical and institutionnal buildings being illuminated, commercial use also. It may still not amount to 10x though.
- lozenge 9y agoStreets, offices and shops are now better lit.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- user5994461 9y agoOffices and shops used neon lights. It lits as well as LED or better, but consumes a lot of power.
- pfdietz 9y agoDo you mean fluorescent bulbs? They do not use neon, but rather use mercury vapor. The UV light from the mercury excites a fluorescent layer on the inside of the tube, causing broadband emission of visible light.
- manyxcxi 9y agoJust because it’s LED doesn’t mean it doesn’t use any power at all, so it’s still a waste of energy. Every light in our house is LED and I still teach my kids about not wasting energy and turning things off when not in use. Maybe it’s because I grew up with incandescent bulbs, but I can’t stand the thought of random lights being left on for no good reason, even if it costs 40 cents a year to keep lit. EDIT- ADDITIONAL THOUGHT I was going to add that it’s not like I went around my house adding lights that didn’t exist, but as I think about it... The house I grew up in was built in the early 70’s and every room had a single ceiling light that had two bulbs in it. The hallways had 1 or two ceiling lights. My current house, built two years ago has 8 can lights in the living room, 6 cans in the kitchen and 3 pendants over the island, 8 in the dining room, etc... So maybe you’re on to something with the thought of putting in a lot more lights than we used to.
- eadmund 9y ago> Every light in our house is LED and I still teach my kids about not wasting energy and turning things off when not in use. Are you certain that it's wasting energy, though? You have to account for the time spent actually turning the light off, as well as for the psychic cost of having to think about whether to turn it off or on. I'm reminded of one of my old offices, where some office busybody turned off the lights in the bathroom. They were fluorescent and took awhile to brighten up, so of course this meant that one would enter a darkened room, turn them on, and then slowly get some light. Was it a huge deal? No. Did it make our lives worse than just leaving the lights on? Yes. > Maybe it’s because I grew up with incandescent bulbs, but I can’t stand the thought of random lights being left on for no good reason, even if it costs 40 cents a year to keep lit. At 40¢/year, leaving it lit costs .11¢/day, or .0046¢/hour. At any reasonable rate for your time & mental energy, it makes sense to just leave it lit.
- rsynnott 9y ago> They were fluorescent and took awhile to brighten up, so of course this meant that one would enter a darkened room, turn them on, and then slowly get some light. Was it a huge deal? No. Did it make our lives worse than just leaving the lights on? Yes. LEDs don't do this. At absolute worst, you'll have a fraction of a second before they light up at all, but once they light up, they light up immediately.
- CJefferson 9y agoElectricity is not the only cost -- LED light bulbs are quite expensive, which puts a natural limit on how many I want to fit in my house.
- matwood 9y agoMy local utility has an online store for customers with amazing deals on LED lightbulbs (not as cheap as normal bulbs, but not as high as you see at a Home Depot). I've replaced every bulb in my house.
- mark-r 9y agoI've seen utility subsidized bulbs at Costco.
- skrap 9y agoI'm gonna have to call you on that one. Even high-end brand LED bulbs are so much more cost efficient than incandescent bulbs, it's the rational act to immediately replace nearly every single incandescent. Whether you're interested in saving energy or saving money, you should remove and smash your incandescents. Here's a blog entry I wrote with some of the simple math: https://blog.sense.com/articles/smash-incandescent-bulb-switch-led/ https://blog.sense.com/articles/smash-incandescent-bulb-swit...
- azeotropic 9y agoWhere do you find 100 watt equivalent LED bulbs in 2700K for $1/bulb?
- lodi 9y agoYou won't find LED's for $1/bulb, but the total cost of ownership over X years is massively in favor of the LED. Also I simply find it convenient that LED's just. don't. die. I haven't had to change a single bulb since I upgraded ~4 years ago.
- rsynnott 9y agoThat's true to an extent, but if you had 16000 lumens previously, using about 1000W, you probably don't _want_ ~100,000 lumens now, just because it uses the same amount of power. That's far too much light.
- gascan 9y agoIn support of your argument, just about every damn device these days is covered in LEDs that run 24/7. Look around your house at night. Microwave, electric kettle, stove, phone chargers, smoke detectors, routers, modems, electric toothbrushes, and that's just what I remember off the top of my head. Yes, not exactly the same as LED light bulbs, but illustrates the point. LED's are cheap and the power is a rounding error, so they go in everywhere. (This is infuriating to me because I would like my house to be dark at night)
- ars 9y ago> Making lights more efficient won't make people buy more of them. Yes it does. I personally added a bunch of lights I would never have added if they were inefficient. But because lights are so cheap (it's barely worth my time to turn it off, although I still do it), I added a bunch of them. I'm still spending less on lighting power than before though.
- nopriorarrests 9y agoAs I commented in other thread, your argument about people having all they need could be re-phrased as a "lack of innovation". Last thing we have invented which consume electricity is home PC. And it was 40 years ago. Without this invention we probably observed the declining demand much sooner, but hey, large monitor and good graphic card and latest 3D shooter, this stuff rocks. But before we invented home PC, people "had everything they need", they were just unaware of 3D shooters, and your argument was as valid as today. For the last 20-30 years we had no other inventions which can convert electricity into value. And older inventions, such as fridges, got more efficient.
- georgeecollins 9y ago>> Most people have all the lights, washing machines, etc that they need. If you think that you need to visit an American suburb two weeks before Christmas.
- martinald 9y agoGood point; perhaps it is not efficiency then but outsourcing of light/heavy industry (simply meaning while TVA et al demand is falling, Chinese power demand is growing even more rapidly), and the fact there is more supply in the form of unmetered local solar/wind generation which looks like a fall in demand on the grid but actually isn't. Interesting.
- SerLava 9y agoIntuitively, that only applies when there's actually some pent up demand. At some point, availability of teacups really won't drive more demand.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoEnergy is the principal or a major secondary input into food, transportation, housing, consumer and industrial goods, et cetera. In other words, just about everything we spend money on. So unless we start seeing a major drop in the demand for currency, I don't buy this argument.
- hrie282 9y agoEverything we spend money on is being manufactured more power efficiently, is more power efficient on its own, and grid demand drops as adoption of new efficient gadgets and individual solar expands? At home we went all LED lights. My office followed suit. Even my city swapped the night time street lights Sadly we had almost every appliance in the house die in the first 4 yrs we owned it. But they’re all new efficient models now Fewer desktops, more tablets and phones. Our big TV is only on 3-4 hrs a week (but it too is a more power efficient model) A lot of effort has gone into battery storage and efficiency this last decade. Little numbers add up to big ones real fast
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- crdoconnor 9y agoFinance consuming ever greater proportions of our GDP probably helped keep that in check https://www.bis.org/img/speeches/sp081119_g3.gif https://www.bis.org/img/speeches/sp081119_g3.gif (if your rent doubles and home insurance goes up, your electricity consumption does not go up). Similarly, offshoring of manufacturing likely muted the demand for electricity too.
- gowld 9y agoEconomic inequality means that the average person can't afford to keep consuming as much energy as in the past, meanwhile the wealthiest people have saturated demand, they have everything they can imagine wishing for.
- lawlessone 9y ago>Jevons paradox(1) has previously ensured that increased efficiency resulted in increased demand. you can only have so many devices and appliances.
- marcosdumay 9y ago> What has changed now? Jevons Paradox is not an immutable natural law. It's does not even have any predictive power. It's just a notice of an interesting thing that can happen but the naivest interpretation of microeconomics assumes it's impossible.
- jtuente 9y agoJust like Moore's law, which is also hitting a wall.
- ctdonath 9y agoMoore's Law has been hitting - and going through - walls for the last 30 years.
- delecti 9y agoTrue, but you can only handwave away the size of atoms for so long.
- fooker 9y agoWe are somewhat far away from being restricted by the size of single atoms. A silicon atom is 0.2 nanometers and the smallest single transistors used in recent chips is in the order of 5-10 nanometers. Also, using photons instead of electrons does allow you, almost literally to handwave away he size of atoms. How exactly, is unknown today.
- madengr 9y agoThat leaves about 13 years left until Moore’s Law hits that 0.2 nm feature. Will be interesting to see how it pans out.
- marcosdumay 9y agoSilicon lithography has to hit a wall way before single atom sizes. For a start, silicon semiconducting is a probabilistic effect and only happen on populations. Photons at usable frequencies are much larger than atoms. Just notice that lithography is currently moving into what they call "extreme UV" (and most people call X-rays) because the UV photons are much larger than the features of current top of line chips.
- mattnewton 9y agoMaybe the new things that people would spend electricity on now that it’s cheaper haven’t reached the mass market yet. I’m thinking mostly electric cars, because I live near Tesla, but I am sure there are other opporunities for greater electricity usage around the corner.
- sremani 9y agoThe Great Recession. The current demand flatness is only temporary, esp. when we are ushering into the world of Electric Cars and 3D printers. There is a hungry beast lurking its called "The Data Center". As the Data Center count increases over the future, we will also see raise in demand. Over all, my bet is Jevons paradox will stand the test of time.
- Analemma_ 9y ago- Data centers are ridiculously efficient. The latest generation of data centers from the big cloud providers have PUE in 1.07 territory, which would've seemed like pie-in-the-sky ludicrousness even 10 years ago. Every CPU cycle that's done in a data center instead of on someone's client machine or on-prem server is a decrease in power consumption. - 3D printers don't use very much power, and in any case, while 3D printing is going to be an ever-bigger deal in manufacturing, the 3D printing at home fad has already crested and is fading away, like 3D televisions. There's not going to be one in every home. - Electric cars will indeed increase power consumption, but mainly when they are plugged in for the night, where there is already a lot of wasted power from e.g. nuclear plants that can't scale down at night. The total increase in necessary generating capacity and infrastructure upgrades won't be as big as you think.
- sremani 9y ago>> Data centers are ridiculously efficient. The latest generation of data centers from the big cloud providers have PUE in 1.07 territory, which would've seemed like pie-in-the-sky ludicrousness even 10 years ago. Every CPU cycle that's done in a data center instead of on someone's client machine or on-prem server is a decrease in power consumption. << Do you know what is the global consumption of energy of data centers in 2016 ? It is same as consumption of energy of global aviation. Think about it, the energy consumed by Data Centers is equal to all commerical planes world wide flying. (source: realclearnergy podcast) They may very well be efficient, that is shit load of energy and that is point.
- neuromantik8086 9y ago
- rsynnott 9y agoI'm not sure that's entirely true, especially for domestic energy consumption. 10 years ago, I had a CRT TV, incandescent bulbs, and a washing machine that was probably about an F on the EC's ratings. At work, I used a computer with a big CRT screen (actually, maybe just an LCD by then) and a processor that used about 40W just sitting there. And 20 years before that, my parents also had a CRT TV, incandescent bulbs, and a similarly inefficient washing machine. These were likely a LITTLE more inefficient, but nothing much. Now I have an LCD TV that uses well under half the power of a CRT, LED bulbs which use about 5% the power of incandescents, and an A-rated washing machine that uses about a half the power of the old-fashioned ones. At work I use a computer with an LED-backlit LCD monitor and a modern processor that idles at practically nothing. For most people who had "all mod cons" 20 years ago, they're using less electricity today than they were then. Electric cars are the one wrinkle, and I think they will drive electricity usage upwards. Other than that, though, domestic use is declining for the middle class, and commercial and industrial use are too in many cases. An awful lot of electricity usage 20 years ago was essentially waste, and we're getting quite good at eliminating that.
- adventured 9y agoJust the switch to smartphones alone is incredibly impressive on efficiency. For average users + average US electricity rates, you're looking at $0.05 to $0.10 per month in cost. Nationally, every hour people are using their phones, instead of watching TV, playing a gaming console, or using a traditional computer, is a big savings.
- gowld 9y agoElectric cars create synthetic electrical demand, since they displace oil demand. It's still energy demand. (The switch from oil to coal vs solar vs hydro vs wind is interesting, but the top-line "electricity demand" number means very little.)
- floatrock 9y agoYou're right that it is still energy demand, and you're right that it's substituting oil for electricity. But I don't know what you mean by "synthetic" since charging an EV is very much a real load, which is exactly why utilities should be the biggest fans of EV's. It's a no-brainer... "hey utilities, you know how demand for your product has been stagnant or falling? Well here's a product that can steal gasoline's market share, makes up about a third of your consumers' consumption, AND is cheaper to operate for your consumers." Utilities should be the biggest champions of EV's.
- saas_co_de 9y agoThe efficiency of the devices people use has been increasing but the prices of electricity have been rising during the same period so efficiency from the perspective of the consumer is not increasing. The mechanism by which increasing efficiency would increase consumption is lower prices and if that is missing then consumption won't increase.
- Shivetya 9y agoAre we doing less though? Because of efficiency gains we may be doing more work with less electricity so while the outward demand numbers are less that amount of work being done is increased. I do know on a personal scale that LED lighting lets me have far more light hours for an incredibly lower bill. If anything I leave lights on more now. I even ran over a thousand feet of Christmas lights because their cost was so much less than before (like 12/15 to 1)
- nkoren 9y agoSimple explanation: Jevons paradox is an observed correlation that has held true for certain notable industries at certain periods of history, but is not a law of nature. Demand for anything is neither infinite nor infinitely elastic. But more specifically in the case of electricity: there is no demand for electricity, and never has been. The actual demand is for what electricity can do. If the slope of the energy efficiency gains of electrical goods is steeper than the slope of the induced demand for those goods, there's no reason why more goods demand (in accordance with Jevons) shuldn't result in less electrical demand (seemingly contrary to Jevons).
- SilasX 9y agoBut (manifestations of easily usable) energy should be the most vulnerable to Jevons effects, because it has so many potential uses that that any increase in efficiency will flip some marginal case into profitability. Ditto for lower prices.
- nkoren 9y agoThe problem is that energy as energy gets cheaper, it becomes an increasingly marginal part of cost of what uses energy. Eg., let's say you've got some good/service, of which energy is 10% of its lifetime operating cost. If you drop the cost of energy by 50%, then that's only a 5% cost decrease for the good. In order to generate a Jevons rebound from the perspective of the energy supplier, that 5% decrease in price would have to increase demand by more than 100%. Seems unlikely. It was a different story back in Jevons' day, when energy was a genuinely significant component of the overall cost structure of a LOT of things. But in how many goods and services is that still the case? As the cost of energy decreases relative to other cost components (like labour), you'd expect the Jevons effect to produce diminishing and eventually negative returns, no?
- roenxi 9y agoYou might want to reflect a bit more closely on what Jevron's paradox actually is. It is not related to the cost of the final product. Take air; it is essentially infinite and free. We use vast quantities of air in every aspect of our life. We use it in cars, in households, in computing, we breath it, we rely on their being a few km of the stuff above us to maintain pressure, etc. It is so abundant it gets a bit silly to talk about how essential it is to our way of life. Use of the stuff is almost certainly growing exponentially with population. Believe it or not, but raw electricity is more useful than air. Humans would happily use vast amounts of electricity 24x7x365 our entire lives if it is available. As price goes down, usage should be spiking. Rather than Jevron's paradox being broken it is much more likely that some combination of * Supply is tightening * Real prices rising * Something is badly wrong with the economy is affoot.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Jevons paradox(1) has previously ensured that increased efficiency resulted in increased demand. I've always been confused with the labelling of the observation that the common shape of demand curves means lower price (all else being equal) leads to greater market clearing quantity as a “paradox”; what else would you expect? That being said, all else has not been equal over time. Note that what has dropped is consumption of utility-supplied electricity; part of this may be drop in demand for electricity (use efficiency would seem to spur demand with more utility for each unit consumed, but it may suppress it if it means that the point where you hit steeply diminishing returns is hit faster), but an important part is the deployment of customer-owned generation capacity that is a direct substitute for utility-supplied electricity can be expected to hit consumption of utility-supplied electricity hard. And no one has ever labelled the effect “new perfect substitutes reduce consumption of the substituted good” a paradox.
- graeme 9y agoThe article only refers to electricity demand in the US. World demand is stil growing, and I think the energy system is most properly viewed as a global one. I would be interested to know whether the embedded energy consumed by the US has been growing or shrinking. (To calculate this you would add in the energy used to make American imports.)
- andylei 9y agoJevon's paradox isn't really a paradox, its just a description of differing results for differently shaped demand curves. If you have a relatively flat demand curve, then a small shift in price yields a lot change in quantity demanded. I think price has gone down far enough that the shape of the demand curve has steepened. As consumers, there just isn't much we can do with a lot of extra electricity, so even if the price drops a lot, we're not going to consume that much more.
- nitwit005 9y agoJevon's paradox probably only applies to some types of power usage. Industrial consumers will certainly consume more if its cheap, but a more efficient toaster doesn't mean I'll get two toasters, or toast more often. I already have more toaster capacity than I'd ever need.