31 ms·
Fired Google Engineer Loses Diversity Memo Challenge
- tptacek 9y agoThe first thing everyone needs to know about this is what the case was about, because it implicates one of the most powerful and least known rights tech company employees have. According to Section 8(a)(1) of the NLRA, employees can't generally be disciplined for exercising the rights provided under Section 7 of the NLRA. These rights are commonly understood to be about unionizing (ie, you can't be fired for trying reasonably to organize a union), but are actually broader: the NLRA protects an employee right to almost arbitrary "concerted action" to improve working conditions. Damore was terminated by Google for authoring his anti-diversity memo. During the time he was authoring and distributing internal copies of the memo, he worked with (apparently) a bunch of other engineers at Google that shared many of his viewpoints (the memo covers a lot of ground). He was terminated after the memo, an artifact of his concerted effort to change aspects of how Google was managed, was published. He and his lawyer mounted an 8(a)(1) complaint. As a starting point --- people with real-world experience or understanding of the NLRA should correct me where I'm wrong --- NLRA complaints get filed with the National Labor Relations Board. The NLRB adjudicates claims internally. If a complaint is found valid, the NLRB will try to convince the employer to settle with the employee; if that goes nowhere, the NLRB will itself effectively sue the company. If the complaint is found invalid, the NLRB will inform the complainant that NLRB is done with the case. Most of these cases (there are tens of thousands annually as you'd expect) are handled by grunts in DC. Novel or high-profile cases are escalated to a special department in the NLRB called the Advice Division. This particular case was not only escalated but apparently handled personally by the director of the division, an NLRB lawyer who'd been with the board since 1988. The NLRB turned down Damore's complaint. I think he could theoretically still sue in civil court? I don't think that's commonly done? Either way, his complaint was denied. The basis for the complaint is super simple and kind of obvious in retrospect: employers in the US are required by federal and usually state law to avoid discrimination against protected classes. To the extent that Damore's memo was about organizing against discrimination of conservative viewpoints --- a phenomenon that is almost certainly real in SFBA tech! --- it was protected. But to the extent that it attempted to organize around changes to Google management that might (might) themselves violate EEO laws (for instance, any kind of official recognition that men are better suited to software development at Google than women), they were not. You can't use the NLRA to organize in opposition to federal employment law. Wa-waa. As it turns out, this was apparently super-apparent to Google legal and Google HR, who fired Damore precisely by the book, exclusively for promoting stereotypes about women and advocating for the inclusion of those stereotypes into Google's management processes. I think an important thing to consider --- I'm no lawyer and am probably wrong about lots of this stuff --- is that if the memo had been exclusively about how SFBA tech discriminates against conservatives and could in a number of ways be made more accommodating to them, Damore would had been protected from retaliation. The Advice Memo says as much! So for someone like me, who believes very strongly in both the importance of employee organizing rights (I think tech should organize into professional associations; "unions lite") and who believes strongly in the absolute innate equivalence in aptitude for our profession between men and women, this is the best possible outcome. There's a lot to take heart in here; we do in fact have the right to organize that we've been saying we have.
- ghaff 9y ago>The NLRB turned down Damore's complaint. I think he could theoretically still sue in civil court? I don't think that's commonly done? Either way, his complaint was denied. There's still a civil lawsuit going ahead as the article notes.
- tptacek 9y agoRight, but it's on a different set of claims, isn't it? I thought it was not a case brought under the NLRA.
- ghaff 9y agoI assume so. I read the civil complaint (I actually know his lawyer pretty well) but 1.) I'm not a lawyer myself and 2.) I haven't really studied the legal case in any depth.
- dragonwriter 9y agoIt's a different set of claims but they have (in regards to the specifics of Damore’s claims; it's a class action charging a broader pattern, though) substantial overlap despite the differing legal basis. Particularly, if, as NLRB found, Damore was fired solely for statements violating a legitimate anti-harassment policy, this would be quite problematic for the claims in his lawsuit. Of course, the court in that case is not bound by the NLRBs fact findings.
- b4lancesh33t 9y agoOne does wonder how much damage this memo does to that case. It will be interesting to see.
- nindalf 9y agoProbably even less of a lawyer than you are, so thanks for that summary :)
- dk1138 9y agoThanks for taking the time to write this out and give some background.
- orionblastar 9y agoPolitical views and opinions are not protected from discrimination. Sad but true, you can be fired for your beliefs.
- tptacek 9y agoNo, that is the opposite of what the NLRB found. It's not quite as simple as political affiliation being protected (although in California it might be), but rather that under the NLRA, you can't be fired for the act of organizing to improve workplace conditions. The Advice Memo explicitly states in several places that had the Damore memo not advocated in favor of stereotypes against women --- something that is itself covered by federal and state employment law, requiring the NLRB to give deference to employers working to comply with those laws --- he would have enjoyed substantial protections. Much of the memo, according to the Advice Division, was protected.
- orblivion 9y agoI suppose he could have ignored the question of the distribution of men and the distribution of women, and just focused on his suggestions on how to make a more productive and enjoyable situation for more "agreeable" (that's a technical term) personality types. But this is all in context of Google's focus on trying to improve the gender disparity, and his memo is directly in reference to that, if one would only accept his claims about the different genders' distributions. But merely making these claims is deemed unacceptable. Google can make whatever claims they want, but his hands are tied if he wants to make these suggestions. All of this is basically to imply that a set of beliefs that a lot of people have (conservatives, mainstream psychologists(!!!)) is basically beyond the pale, and it seems like a troubling situation to me. Please let me know if I misunderstood something here.
- d1zzy 9y agoContext matters. The workplace is a place where certain discussions are simply not allowed. For example discussing an ongoing lawsuit against the employer. It's not about intention, your intention may be in the right place, it's about potential outcome, when things are taken out of context or simply interpreted by others in ways that result in creating a hostile work environment (or in the lawsuit case, taken out of context in a court of law).
- notconservative 9y ago> “Much of" Damore’s memo was probably protected under the law. ... But ... Google discharged Damore only for his "discriminatory statements," which aren’t shielded by labor law. Given how significantly many people have misunderstood Damore's claims, this seems to open up a hole for companies to mischaracterize someone as a racist/sexist/etc and then fire them over it.
- izacus 9y agoIsn't employment in places where these companies operate at-will? Meaning they can fire you because you waved your hair funny in the morning?
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoIn an at-will state, I can fire you because I don't like how you did your hair, but I can't fire you because you belong to a protected class.
- BookmarkSaver 9y agoYes, but (IANAL) if the employee suspects that there was an illegal reason behind it, they can probably sue and subpoena documents revealing management motivations. Like, sure, a manager could wake up and just fire you because they were grumpy. But if it is discovered that there was internal communications about their political opinions leading up to it, then there would be a case.
- jxdxbx 9y agoYou can be fired for your political opinions.
- notconservative 9y agoYes, but not if you're trying to organize to improve working conditions, because this is protected by the NRLA. If the NRLA believes only parts of Damore's memo were working towards improving working conditions and other parts were working to discriminate against women, which part is which. To someone that agrees with Damore, it looks like everyone mischaracterized his effort to improve working conditions as sexism. Then Google was able to use that as cover to fire him for protected organizing.
- bjourne 9y agoI don't agree with Damore's message. But Google cultivated an environment were open discussion were encouraged. So firing him for stating his opinion is truly, hypocritical bullshit. People should get fired for not doing their jobs -- not for writing what they think. And I also want to say that before you blame "the Left" for Google's behavior... Had he been fired in "Socialist Europe," the firing would have been declared against the law and Google would have had to pay a hefty fine. I can add why I'm so sure he wouldn't have been fired. In most (many?) European countries, you can be fired for only(!) two reasons; misconduct and labor shortage. Misconduct must be specifically related to your job performance. Like, a train conductor that always oversleeps or a cock who can't boil eggs. Something quite a bit more obvious than claiming gender differences between men and women. Labor shortage is if there is not enough work to do and then the company can let go of the surplus personnel. The walkthrough of the US laws, that tptacek provides, shows that they are completely different and much less employee friendly.
- ionforce 9y ago> So firing him for stating his opinion Do you think it's possible for his stating of his opinion to have side effects like creating a toxic work environment, which would be the antithesis of doing his job well?
- oceanghost 9y agoGoogle is a toxic work environment. He was fired for pointing that out.
- ditonal 9y agoDownvoted but true, look at direct physical threats to Damore in the lawsuit by people Google still employs. Yet he got fired for violating code of conduct...are threats not violations? It's a double standard, if you threaten people deemed conservative there are no repercussions, even though I consider that far more hostile than a doc.
- 9y ago
- myf01d 9y agoImagine if he was black btw I am not even white, but this politically correct tyranny in the west is getting ridiculous
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Buldak 9y agoIt's not at all obvious to me that that would have saved him from being fired.
- flash42 9y agoAnd being a woman?
- iamdave 9y agoI am not white either. What I am is tired of the phenomenon of using black people and the experience of being black as a stand in, du jur, for when people want to illustrate the objectionable nature of certain arguments. If a point is objectionable, argue it on the merits of its inherent validity or lack there of. Black whataboutism doesn't serve this purpose, it unfairly weaponizes the color of my skin.
- jrcii 9y agoOnly liberals are allowed to work at Google, and only liberals are allowed to express their political opinions on HN. The liberal-tech crowd groupthink enforcement is real.
- harlanji 9y agoUpvoted gray. I’ve observed at least one of my comments removed from HN. I was a liberal when I came to SF, but people shut me down constantly since coming here... I determined I am being bullied for the first time; as a 30+ yo man it is an interesting thing to learn to combat. Talking to homeless guys, I’ve no doubt what happened to some of them. Today I put out a substantial demo to address this in the way I know how, tweeted on same twitter handle.
- rbanffy 9y agoThat's why the far right invented Gab. Go, be happy there.
- defertoreptar 9y agoHis cardinal sin was saying that men and women are biologically different. He could've said a lot, but as soon as he tried to give a biological explanation for why girls prefer Barbies and boys prefer toy cars, he entered taboo territory. It's a thought crime because it implies that cultural influences aren't 100% responsible for why more men are interested in STEM than women.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoNo, he tried to use unrelated data on the biological differences between men and women to justify why Google shouldn't try to reach out more to women to diversify their workforce.
- neveroffensive 9y agoThis is also a bit of a miss-characterization. He tried to use data on the biological difference between men and women which _may_ be unrelated to justify why Google shouldn't forcefully diversify their workforce if it dose so at the cost of hiring the best people. Edit: I don't think that either side in this debate has actually met the burden of proof necessary to conclusively say that biological differences do/don't correlate on any level.
- rendall 9y agoDid the NLRB memo specify exactly which statements in Damore's memo were discriminatory and hostile? Is there a copy available?
- on_and_off 9y agoyes : https://www.nlrb.gov/case/32-CA-205351 https://www.nlrb.gov/case/32-CA-205351 you can also find the full damore memo online.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rendall 9y agoThanks. I checked Damore's Twitter account, and he has not yet made a statement on this, perhaps wisely following his lawyer's advice. from the NLRB Memo: "[Damore's] statements about immutable traits linked to sex—such as women’s heightened neuroticism and men’s prevalence at the top of the IQ distribution—were discriminatory and constituted sexual harassment, notwithstanding [his] effort to cloak comments with “scientific” references and analysis, and notwithstanding “not all women” disclaimers." Interesting. The Board completely dismissed the scientific arguments, even going so far as to put quotes around "scientific". They didn't accept that he was making scientific statements at all! It's not clear whether they understood that Damore used "neuroticism" as a specific and uncontroversial psychological term, and not in the folk meaning of "crazy". I'm going to suppose no, since their qualifiers "heightened neuroticism" and "more prone to neuroticism" don't come from Damore's memo, and imply the "crazy" connotation.
- on_and_off 9y agoI was also surprised that this was the part of memo quoted by the NLRB. There are others that made me frown way more. The neuroticism quote is not beyond reproach though. The big five model has been heavily critiqued, it is not exactly an ironclad scientific caution for Damore's argument.
- 9y ago
- ggm 9y agoWhat I think of his views (I disagree) is not germaine to the question: was it sensible to write and publish? It was not. That I disagree with his premise and polemic makes it easier for me to align desire and reality, but the reality of the situation doesn't change because of my desires: he was stupid to publish and Google were within their rights to fire him. All the other observed comments about liberal/conservative/libertarian views are frankly not very interesting. The bottom line to me is that he didn't have a strong enough claim to unfair dismissal. Court did its job. Move on.
- yjftsjthsd-h 9y ago> he was stupid to publish Only in the way that union organizers and whistle blowers are stupid.
- ggm 9y agoIn choosing to publish at risk of jobloss? Surely not: they both go into the situation expecting adversity and seeking a wider oucome. He did no such thing, either by intent or not. But I already stated I don't agree with his world view and contextually I do agree with union organisation and whistleblowing, neither of which this was. What's your point? Trolling.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- azurezyq 9y agoI think the problem is not if you should predict if Google will fire you because of this. It is "are you doing harm to anybody else?" Saying these words already embarrassed his female colleagues and is he still expecting Google withhold free speech within massive anger from females? Google's firing may be inevitable after a tipping point. He's stupid. Something like liberal/conservative is totally unrelated, indeed.
- leereeves 9y agoThere was no court involved in this yet. This was the opinion of a lawyer at the National Labor Relations Board that they should not take up Damore's case.
- curtis 9y agoThis sounds like the federal government concluded that Damore's firing did not violate federal employment law. I think (but I'm no expert) that the issue of whether Damore's firing violated California employment law is still an open question.
- berberous 9y agoThis is correct. The National Labor Relations Board issued an Advice Memo, declining to prosecute a case under the federal National Labor Relations Act. Damore's California lawsuit, which per the first page of the complaint, lists the below causes of action under various California laws, is unaffected. CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT: 1. Violation of Cal. Labor Code § 1101 2. Violation of Cal. Labor Code § 1102 3. Workplace Discrimination on the basis of Gender and/or Race in Violation of FEHA 4.Workplace Harassment in Violation of FEHA 5.Retaliation in Violation of FEHA 6.Retaliation in Violation of Public Policy 7.Retaliation in Violation of Cal. Lab. Code § 1102.5 8.Failure To Prevent Harassment, Discrimination, and Retaliation 9.Unfair Business Practices, Bus. & Prof. Code Section 17200 et seq 10.Declaratory Relief
- notconservative 9y agoI looked up the Advice Memo [0] written by the NRLB (thanks tptacek for mentioning that document) so that I could try to see what exactly they found discriminatory about Damore's paper. This is the relevant section: > The Charging Party’s use of stereotypes based on purported biological differences between women and men should not be treated differently than the types of conduct the Board found unprotected in these cases. statements about immutable traits linked to sex—such as women’s heightened neuroticism and men’s prevalence at the top of the IQ distribution—were discriminatory and constituted sexual harassment, notwithstanding effort to cloak comments with “scientific” references and analysis, and notwithstanding “not all women” disclaimers. The "these cases" reference is talking about a KKK member and someone who "made debasing and sexually abusive remarks to a female employee who had crossed a picket line months earlier". I don't see how Damore's memo is at all relatable to these. And more importantly, the content they found to be discriminatory were the studies on differences in IQ and psycological traits by gender? How can presenting science be discriminatory? If you disagree with some study, you explain why the methodology it used is bad or find other studies that try to explain it. You don't just claim that it's findings are discriminatory. That makes it impossible to discover why it's wrong (if it is). [0] (PDF) http://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d45826e6391 http://apps.nlrb.gov/link/document.aspx/09031d45826e6391
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 9y agoYou've lost the context of the Advice Memo. The NLRB isn't saying Damore himself violated EEO laws by writing the memo. The NLRB didn't fire Damore; Google did. The NLRB is saying that although the NLRA protects concerted action to improve working conditions, those protections do not extend to action that might discriminate against protected classes, and, crucially, that because employers are required by state and federal law to comply with EEO laws, the NLRB will tend not to second-guess them about how they do that. The important thing to remember is that in most of the US, there's a presumption that employers can fire you for any reason. Employment is at-will. Damore was appealing to a specific exception to that rule.
- hateHackerNews 9y agoITT Bunch of people pretending to know the law
- ABCLAW 9y agoWould it be possible to rename the thread "Fired Google Engineer Who Authored Diversity Memo Withdraws NLRA Challenge."? I think that's quite a bit more accurate.
- awesomepantsm 9y agoIt's not though, because it wasn't withdrawn it was rejected.
- ABCLAW 9y agoI think the official case record is not in agreement with your understanding: https://www.nlrb.gov/case/32-CA-205351 https://www.nlrb.gov/case/32-CA-205351
- dejawu 9y agoThe way this whole thing played out makes me sad, because the guy did bring up a good point - current-day social justice leaves little avenue for well-meaning but unaware (perhaps through privilege) people to start conversations and learn about the reasons and motivations for certain efforts such as affirmative action and changes in vocabulary. Damore was indeed punished for speaking out, just as he feared. Then he started retweeting Breitbart articles and selling "Goolag" t-shirts and threw his credibility out the window, and solving the problem of "how do we bring people on-board with the diversity thing without scaring them off" is again put off to another day.
- awesomepantsm 9y agoI got the feeling there was more stuff he said that never leaked but who knows
- oh_sigh 9y agoThere wasn't. There are extensive leakers in google on both sides of the fence who would have leaked the fuller doc if one existed.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI feel like the progressive left THRUST Damore and anyone who might have similar thoughts/questions into the welcoming arms of the alt-right. I'm disappointed with the "Goolag" t-shirts, but he did lose his livelihood, had his professional reputation destroyed, and only a limited time to cash out. So this socially awkward nerd did what any sensible person would do, rode the wave that was sent his way the best he could. Consider his professional options compared to a standard "former Googler." They destroyed him, it was terrible.
- tclancy 9y agoHe has no agency? He chose to speak up and then he chose to go down the path he did. It is an impressive feat of mental gymnastics to both kinda sorta acknowledge the alt-right might not be a great group of guys but then also claim Damore had no choice but to pull into that port in a storm of his own making. Allow me to pour out a beaker of Soylent for the poor, downtrodden white man.
- air7 9y agoI've recently encounter Jordan Peterson. He speaks very eloquently about topics such as gender differences from (IMO) a rational and scientific point of view. I'm linking an interview with him which I find fascinating: Both for the information he conveys and for the manner in which he manages to remain cool and clear-headed against a very aggressive interviewer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54&t=4m55s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMcjxSThD54&t=4m55s
- _dps 9y agoCould a lawyer educate me on a technical matter here? They say that "discriminatory statements are not protected". Is "discriminatory statement" a matter of law or a matter of fact? Naively I'd expect a jury to decide if a statement is discriminatory.
- pukerz 9y agoSearch for 'Rekieta Law' on YouTube, he is a lawyer analysing the case in depth
- ThomPete 9y agoReading the comments in this thread is disheartening. It mostly consists of either false claims of what Damore actually said or pre-conceived interpretations of his memo as being anti-diversity without a single, not a single reference to his memo.
- stormbeta 9y agoI think you have it backwards - this thread is full of people making excuses for Damore. And yes, I've read it. Just because he wrote some sentences that claimed he's in favor of diversity doesn't magically change the content of the rest of the memo. If he was truly arguing in good faith, he should've stuck to actual, demonstrable examples of issues or problems caused by the existing diversity practices. There was no need to go on long rambling tangents about population statistics that even he acknowledges aren't really relevant to the topic: > "Many of these differences are small and there’s significant overlap between men and women, so you can’t say anything about an individual given these population level distributions." You'll note that most of the memo seems to be implying the opposite.
- ThomPete 9y agoI would also urge you to be more specific. Give me a specific example so we can discuss it. Just handwavy claims without any specifics is useless.
- stcredzero 9y agoIt's quite strange, but if you read James Damore's memo at face value, you'll find Google and YouTube execs saying essentially the same thing in public: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VrOp8ewzJDc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VrOp8ewzJDc There was no need to go on long rambling tangents about population statistics that even he acknowledges aren't really relevant to the topic It's certainly relevant. The "jury is still out" in terms of biology and gender preferences and how those are modulated by culture: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YKmyO3hbOz8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YKmyO3hbOz8 (Seriously, watch that, and tell me which side is intellectually open and honest, and which side comes across as ideologues.) > "Many of these differences are small and there’s significant overlap between men and women, so you can’t say anything about an individual given these population level distributions." You'll note that most of the memo seems to be implying the opposite. "Seems to be implying." You are essentially admitting to an ideologically skewed, imputational reading.
- omot 9y agoCan someone remind me, what was he trying to accomplish with this memo?
- Clanan 9y ago> The Charging Party’s use of stereotypes based on purported biological differences between women and men should not be treated differently than the types of conduct the Board found unprotected in these cases. This Advice Memo establishes the precedent that discussing biological differences between men and women constitutes sexual harassment, even if those differences are supported by scientific research.
- mirimir 9y agoOh, so now men can wear short dresses to work? Or at least, shorts? When it's hot, it sucks to wear long pants. Sleeveless tees would be cool, too.
- fareesh 9y agoThis is one of the few subjects where much of the HN crowd is either experiencing some shared hallucination, or is relying heavily on poor journalism. There are many comments that classify his memo as anti-diversity (it is pro diversity), and there are many that seem to suggest that the memo claimed women are less suited for these jobs, which again is patently false to anyone who gives it a reasonable and full read. The injustice here is that this employee was taken to a workshop/seminar, was asked for feedback, which he submitted, and was ignored. His firing only came when his memo was leaked to the public and it became the subject of a media witch hunt. Had the memo not been public, he would still be working there. This was not a planned firing and there was nothing normal about it. The CEO cancelled his vacation to return to HQ and address the situation caused by the media outcry. This is a cancerous cultural problem that manifests the worst forms of censorious and authoritarian practices of dictatorial regimes of the past. Diversity at this cost is not worth it. Nothing is worth this kind of environment that is openly hostile and punitive to "wrongthink". People of various backgrounds are not tokens to be planted into various positions to fulfill some fetish or misguided sense of justice. Under-representation by a specific group or sub group is not sufficient evidence of discrimination or a conspiracy. Deeming programs and opportunities unavailable to people because they don't have the correct biological trait is disgusting, and the ends do not justify the means. To argue that favoring someone because they belong to a special genetic group is rooted in the very "essentialist" thinking that is claimed to be chastised. There is a better solution to these issues, and at this rate it will never be found. Ironic that some of the world's most innovative people who have no problem bouncing from one design pattern to another, are perfectly content with an approach to a point that criticism of it will get you fired.
- rexpop 9y agoWitch-hunts were authoritarian campaigns of gendercide. A gross, systematic slaughtering of thousands upon thousands of women. It's egregiously callous for you to misuse the term in this way. Perhaps you men "snark-hunt".
- fareesh 9y agoIt's not misuse, it's intentional. Men were not the target of witch hunts because they were the "incorrect" sex. Today, in cases where merit seemingly takes a backseat to diversity, men are the "incorrect" sex for some opportunities, like say if you want to speak at a node.js conference, or attend some special mentoring workshop. The opposite is not true, if you are not a man, there are no instances that I am aware of where you are openly denied or discouraged from pursuing an opportunity for that reason alone.
- droopybuns 9y agoIf we are all honest with ourselves, we acknowledge that we have our opinions about how most men think and how most women think. The difference between being cast out and being celebrated is that the latter keeps their opinions to themselves. This guy self-immolated for foolishness.
- fzeroracer 9y agoThe problem with Damore's theory he posited (that the difference in traits and abilities between men and women is why you see a certain imbalance in tech) ignores the history of computer science, where in the early days of CS you had a large amount of women entering into software followed by a sharp dropoff in the 80s [1]. The 'biological differences' argument falls flat because it implies that somehow women changed on a biological level between 1984 and today. I also take umbrage with his civil suit against Google because it amounts to no more than a document meant to doxx google employees by revealing their names and political positions ranging from benign to the more 'punch nazis' level of discourse. There was selective censorship applied such that people he agreed with were protected, while people he disagreed with were brought out in front of the crowd. I have seen pictures floating around designed to make it easy to effectively target said employees facebook, twitter etc accounts. [1] https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when-women-stopped-coding https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/21/357629765/when...
- rayiner 9y agoIt's not just the history of computer science. Damore's essay was based on time-tested pseudo-scientific reasoning, the sort that has been invoked to exclude women in many different fields. When law firms offered Sandra Day O'Connor a secretarial job after she graduated third in her class at Stanford, do you think they said "we just don't like women?" Of course not. They couched their bias in appeals to the differences between men and women, and how those differences supposedly were relevant to the practice of law. Damore is more of the same. Take, for example, his invocation of studies showing that women are more prone to be "neurotic." Aside from the fact that "neurotic" covers an immense range of personality traits--Damore leaves it as an exercise for the reader why that would be a bad thing. Among other things, "neurotic" encompasses "obsessive compulsive" or "anxious." Why isn't that a good trait in a programmer--someone who needs to be constantly on the lookout for the errant buffer overflow? He also invokes the idea that women are less able to handle "stressful" situations. Which explains why nurses--who are literally dealing with life and death every day--are mostly women? It's not that there isn't evidence of differences in personality traits between men and women, it's that all the inferences after "infant boys prefer trucks" is complete handwaving. Back in the day, people would, with the pretense of science, invoke differences in cranial measurements to explain the economic plight of African Americans. Damore's is just the latest in a long line of pseudo-scientific gibberish. And it blows my mind that so many in the tech community are falling for it. You actually have to be bad at logical reasoning to find Damore's points compelling.
- throwestawayer 9y agoReal question: having seen that many good engineers are hesitant to work at a company with very limited diversity, we have endeavored to increase diversity by hiring qualified junior engineers from less represented groups. Is this acceptable? These are completely qualified folks, for the job of junior engineer. We purposely, from the category of all qualified junior applicants, hired those that also were from less represented groups. Is this perceived (by “you”, I suppose) as “acceptable”?
- ralusek 9y agoIf they are completely qualified, they should and would be hired by a system that completely ignores gender and race. While the morality of your system is up for debate, what is not up for debate is that your system is mathematically disadvantaged in terms of hiring the best engineers...because your system ignores the vast majority of the hiring pool (presumably white/Indian/east asian [straight?] men). A blind system favors/ignores nobody.
- PricelessValue 9y ago> If they are completely qualified, they should and would be hired by a system that completely ignores gender and race. I can't believe you were downvoted for expressing that merit rather than race and gender should be use for hiring decisions.
- Caveman_Coder 9y ago> I can't believe you were downvoted for expressing that merit rather than race and gender should be use for hiring decisions. This is the new world we unfortunately live in. Words and their meanings are transformed to fit within the ideology ("it isn't discrimination if it favors women over men, or minorities over whites...")...
- ianal123 9y ago> We purposely, from the category of all qualified junior applicants, hired those that also were from less represented groups. IANAL, but from my understanding making hiring decisions based on race, gender or religion is a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. But I really don't know what I am talking about and would be interested in hearing a lawyer's opinion.
- ianamartin 9y agoI strongly disagree with what the guy said. But I also find it problematic that he was fired for saying it. That's crossing a line I'm not comfortable with. There were other legitimate points in his claim that should be addressed too. You simply can't discriminate on the basis of race or ethnicity. And if people are outright saying that, that's a problem. Is he a jackass? Yes. Did he do something obnoxious with that memo? Yes. Fire him for that. Which they did. Totally fine with that. But if the real culture at google is as described, that's something that needs to come to light in discovery. I would have preferred for this to move forward so we can see some light on things. The problem here isn't with Damore's "theory." It's whether or not there is a pervasive, race-based bias. My suspicion is that there isn't really anything in practice. Yeah, maybe some dude does some virtue signalling every once in a while. But in reality, I can't actually believe a competent HR team would let that happen on a systematic level. The chances are he would've been shown to be wrong. So it's too bad this didn't go past this stage.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AHZHKPA 9y agoThe way we are talking to each other here is just toxic. Most of it isn’t even a conversation at all and I see very few attempts at understanding or empathy. It all just stinks of tribalism. Every time the memo is brought up I see this same shit, and feel someone needs to call it out. I don’t care what side you are on; how we are going about this conversation is clearly not working. I wish I had a solution for this. I don’t. But understanding that there is a problem may be a good first step. We must be better than this
- Chris2048 9y agoWhat use is calling it out when you "don't care what side you are on"? You are ready to assign equal blame, when there are unequal incentives.
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoThis is the ultimate HN bikeshedding topic. It's a proxy for the nature / nurture debate. I put my vote token in the nature side. Women can do what ever men can and persisting the ideas that they can't sucks. That is my opinion and I am unwilling to change it.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoI agree it is bikeshedding. But I think it is bikeshedding with a constructive purpose of serving as a safe sandbox in which people can practice talking about difficult subjects without it blowing up in their face. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16399006 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16399006
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoI'm not convinced that is the case. Members seems to be expressing views that are intrinsic to their identities. To that end, no one has an open mind on the subject. Even I genuinely don't have an open mind on the subject! These discussions and disagreements will only serve to cement the existing views of members.
- DoreenMichele 9y agoPracticing the basics of diplomatic discussion is not about changing minds.
- iovrthoughtthis 9y agoWhat is the intended outcome?
- DoreenMichele 9y agoEmergent patterns don't begin with a stated goal. They begin with seeds and fertile ground and existing need. You look back on it later and see from whence it arose.
- swat535 9y agoWhen this discussion was initially ignited a while back, I had wondered whether I should seek the opinion of my girlfriend regarding this topic. She is a brilliant software engineer who switched out of CS into another major, despite having top grades. I finally caved and asked her to read the original memo. Whilst she found the memo interesting, she mentioned this is the view of a single person and found it ridiculous that it caused such an outcry. She is all for diversity in tech (and for all industries for that matter) and pointed out that the hypersensitivity nature of CS causes much harm than good. While we are busy doing roundabout discussions regarding a memo, personal data of millions of people are being leaked, privacy and security of people are in jeopardy because we fail to make high quality software. It truly sadden both of us that the brilliant minds in our Industry are focused on what should/should not be written in a personal memo, than actually pushing the boundaries of software. When a thought provoking community such as HN calls for arms every time this topic comes up and turns into a battlefield, I do wonder whether we have already lost the fight for TRUE diversity.