25 ms·
We’re sorry, and we’re not rolling out the fees change
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThis is a remarkably direct and appropriate apology, along with an appropriate response, a rare thing indeed. If not for their initial response to the first round of feedback, namely to put a "we're still doing it" at the bottom of their original blog post (with completely unreasonable and unjustified explanations for why), I'd give them full credit for responding appropriately. As it is, though, at least they fixed this. They're still going to need to deal with the giant pile of patrons they drove off; many people lost a significant fraction of their support because of this change, and that won't necessarily come back. Between 1 and 2 years ago, I talked to some folks at Patreon about an unrelated topic (namely, trying to use Patreon for registered charities). They mentioned at that time that they had a change in the works to shift processing fees from creators to patrons, which they said at the time would be "better for creators" for various reasons, but that didn't want to talk about the details yet. (Since the issue is now public, I don't see any issue with saying that now.) That discussion naturally didn't include any information about fee structure or un-aggregation of charges with associated additional fees, e.g. the "$1 costs $1.37" problem, since that wasn't the topic; the impression they gave at the time was that the only change was to pass on the (presumably still aggregated) fees to the patrons, which wouldn't have been as serious a problem, and wouldn't have killed Patreon's suitability as a wildly successful microtransaction platform the way this change did. So, they've been thinking about this for a long time, and yet they sprung it on people without warning and without running the full details by anyone. Update: there's now a survey from Patreon asking for feedback: https://twitter.com/Patreon/status/941010263385374720 https://twitter.com/Patreon/status/941010263385374720
- runj__ 9y agoYeah, they could have avoided this altogether by checking with their user base but this is a good response, although radio silence for five days is a bit crazy.
- sigzero 9y agoI give them leeway on the 5 days. I guess they could have said something general like "We understand the new payment policies are not what our user base has expected of us. We are formulating an in-depth response and will have it out in the next few days. We appreciate your response and patience."
- JoshTriplett 9y agoIt'd have been dangerous to say even that if they didn't know they could fix the problem in a satisfactory way, or they'd get blasted even more. But yes, they should have handled this far, far better.
- slededit 9y agoIf you ask the user base if they are OK with a price increase you are going to get a big NO every time.
- delecti 9y agoTheir user base includes both patrons and creators. Obviously patrons would say they don't want a price increase, all other things being equal, but they might be okay with it knowing that increase goes to creators. And asking a handful of high earning creators could have given them good feedback on why it's a bad idea.
- slededit 9y agoBut the increase was going to the company Patreon not the creators. That was mostly the point - they need/want to make more money.
- firloop 9y agoIt didn’t really seem like Patreon was making significantly more money from the new model, fees were higher because they chose to no longer batch charges. The fact that this belief is so widespread is a major testament to Patreon’s failed messaging.
- minimaxir 9y agoTwitter was filled with screenshots of people removing their $1 pledges. It wouldn’t surprise me if the rollback of the new model was motivated more by economics than PR, where the forecasted revenue under the new model (accounting for loss rate of subscribers) was lower than the forecasted revenue under the old model.
- pjc50 9y agoWell, those things are inseperable in this day and age, especially for a company that depends on internet communities. It's astonishing how a company with one product could misunderstand its own market so badly, but given the troubles of Twitter and to a lesser extent Etsy perhaps it's less surprising.
- sgdread 9y agoI understand why they do it: they trying to bring down transaction costs with payment processors. These fees on small amounts is death by thousand cuts. But, I believe, there is a way: they can introduce wallets for $1-2 patrons: put $10 in a single transaction, then charge the wallet once it is a time to pay to creator. This should aggregate small transactions into larger ones and significantly cut the costs.
- ryanatallah 9y agoIt seems very likely that the change was motivated by payment processor fees. Patreon uses Stripe to process payments, which charges a flat rate of 2.9% + $0.30 per successful charge. Compare that to the proposed fee patron fee structure of 2.9% + $0.35 — where presumably the extra $0.05 per transaction is the cut Patreon takes off the top for themselves.
- conductr 9y agoDon't forget it's now 2.9% of $1.37 instead of $1.00. Reducing their piece by another 1 or 2 cents depending on how Stripe rounds
- ceejayoz 9y agoPatreon does enough volume to qualify for discounts - their Stripe rate is 1.9%, not 2.9%. (This used to be on https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-do-you-calculate-fees- https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-..., but it's gone now.)
- nojvek 9y agoLooks like they wanna be nice guys running a marketplace at 5% and claiming to be good guys. And then VC dogs biting them to make fatter profits so they find ticket master like shoddy processing fee scams.
- hutzlibu 9y ago
- PandaChi 9y agoI'm just sharing in here b/c I've always appreciated when others "peel back the curtain" to show the thinking behind decisions. At the end of the day, it was obvious that we fucked up from the immediate feedback, but internally there was already a strong camp who felt this change was wrong, which greatly helped our ability to move quickly and plan out how we'd call this off (all the code was already in production behind feature flags). On the data side, our churn ticked up, but was actually lower than we predicted and quickly returned to normal levels https://imgur.com/a/inFOE https://imgur.com/a/inFOE -- so the reversal was largely driven by the complaints of creators and patrons alike, and our own realization of how tone-deaf the decision was to begin with. Speaking of which -- in my mind there are some obvious solutions to alleviating fees that didn't require moving the entire burden onto the goodwill of supporters. We're going to tackle a more comprehensive roadmap in the coming days and weeks (and talk to creators much more during this process), but if anyone is curious or wants to offer feedback, here are my thoughts: * A big problem (that we arguably created ourselves) is a patron could pledge to a creator on the 25th of a month (granting a patron 5-6 days of access), get charged, and then get charged again on the 1st of the next month (granting the patron 30-31 days of patron-access). Pro-rating didn't seem like a right solution for the first charge since becoming a patron unlocked all the content immediately. So imo we should just (like a Netflix or any other subscription) have your first pledge grant you 30 days of access, whenever it was created -- and have this forever be your "anniversary date" of charge -- if you pledge Jan 25th, you'd be charged again Feb 25th. * The question is around how we aggregate pledges if this patron pledges to another creator. If we say the patron pledged $5 to the 1st creator on the 25th of Jan, then pledged $5 to the second creator on the 10th of February, I'd want to charge the patron $10 on Feb 25, and in the receipt call out that you're paying for the 1st creator for the period of Feb 25-March 25, and for the 2nd creator from March 10-April 10 (because you'd have already paid for Feb 10-March 10 when you pledged to the 2nd creator on Feb 10). This way you're ALWAYS getting 30 days of access for every pledge you pay. * Now that we can aggregate payments across multiple creators, I'd want to allow for the purchasing of multiple months/year at a time for a creator or creators, which further reduces fees -- additionally it allows creators to setup rewards (we're building this system out now) for when patrons have pledged a total of X amount or pledged for some time period. * Finally, once we can pledge across multiple time periods, I'd love for cryptocurrency to be able to pay for patronage. Currently it's trivial for us to accept bitcoin via our Stripe integration, but we wouldn't be able to do recurring payments, and the ultimate thing that kills it for me is that creators wouldn't actually get bitcoin, but rather we'd have to convert it to fiat immediately. I'd rather patrons be able to purchase multiple months of patronage and creators have the option to convert to fiat immediately or hold actual bitcoin and participate in the wild ride that is cryptocurrency speculation :) Ok that's all -- ideas are rough above, but that's what's on my mind lately -- happy holidays.
- fusiongyro 9y agoOff topic, but is there a good solution like Patreon for registered charities?
- tristanho 9y agoSuccessful/appropriate company apologies seem so rare these days! Anyone have examples of ones done right?
- grrowl 9y agoI don't understand why this .37 applies to every transaction. Wouldn't it make sense to charge the overhead once a month, with the actual dollar(s) being distributed as the user wishes? They should use the power of their platform (obviously nearing or having passed critical mass) to make it easier for prolific supporters while also maximising their paetron's income. I think they had good intentions, but got greedy and lost sight of their overall goal
- bionoid 9y ago> This is a remarkably direct and appropriate apology [...] many people lost a significant fraction of their support because of this change, and that won't necessarily come back They could have restored all cancelled pledges and covered their costs for a few months. That would give creators money to pay the rent, and probably go a long way towards restoring relationship with patrons. Clearly, they're not that sorry.
- smegel 9y agoThe fact you didn't engage with the community initially or ask for feedback speaks far more about your arrogance, incompetence and mendacity that the nature of the change itself. If I was using Patreon I would be looking for alternatives anyway...how long until the next "surprise"?
- minimaxir 9y agoThe issue is that there is no current alternative to Patreon’s ease of use for gathering funds from a large number of fans, and a Patreon competitor can’t be built overnight. (Kickstarter’s Drip is not public yet) Of course, being a pseudo-monopoly allows you to test the limits of monetization.
- k2xl 9y agoThat's pretty harsh. They made a mistake and then apologize. While they didn't "initially" they did "eventually" - don't they deserve some credit for that?
- Tyrek 9y agoI'm sure the deserve some credit, but that doesn't wipe away the fact that they behaved in a way that reeks of 'arrogance, incompetence and mendacity'. Bad decisions are bad, and walking them back doesn't undo the initial decision.
- PaulKeeble 9y agoNo. Allowing companies to continuously treat its customers poorly as they test out pricing structures to maximise profits is how gambling become common in computer games and makes up 50% of EAs profits. It shows their intent, to work out how to maximise their earnings and keep everyone grumbling but still using their service. Look for an exit if you are funded this way, this company is going to keep trying until it sticks.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoThey made a mistake that indicated they had a faulty understanding of their entire value proposition. And they made a mistake that had a profound negative effect on their user base (there are almost certainly many creators who were forced to scramble to be able to make rent or pay their bills during the holidays). Sweeping that under the rug of "a mistake" is silly. They hurt people, and it didn't have to be that way. They could have announced their plans with a longer timeline (6 months or a year, perhaps) with the expectation that things might change depending on feedback. Instead they rode roughshod over their user base. For a service that is supposed to be about changing people's lives for the better they did not take those lives as seriously or treat them with the gentleness they deserved.
- theandrewbailey 9y agoServer being internet-hugged. Cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:IFhxAyCJ1fMJ:https://blog.patreon.com/not-rolling-out-fees-change/+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:IFhxAy...
- quadrangle 9y agoNot surprised. There's no way this made sense, and they already freaked out tons of people who cared only partly about the fee and partly about the feeling of helplessness when you rely on a for-profit platform that can change at a seeming whim and pull the rug out from under you. Pulling back addresses the fee concerns directly and gives some feeling that the users can have some influence, although they'll stay wary. None of this changes what drove the fee issue in the first place: Patreon tries to present itself as a donation platform but is primarily a paywall service. Since most "creators" use it to easily manage restricted access to shareable perks (i.e. perks that are non-rivalrous in nature and could be shared with the world), they will continue to have to serve that freemium business model.
- TillE 9y agoAs everyone on the internet eagerly pointed out the moment this was announced, you can get a best-of-both-worlds solution by simply prorating the second month. Nothing actually eliminates piracy issues; it's easy to discreetly mirror an RSS feed, for example. You're ultimately relying on the honesty of the vast majority of your patrons, a strategy which has worked out for Patreon creators very well thus far.
- quadrangle 9y agoTotally. The point is that the Patreon folks made the stupid decisions about the new fee because they were blindly thinking about effective paywalls. If they had been thinking holistically about things, they wouldn't have been so dumb. Of course, there are better ways to handle even the paywall issue. The stupidity was clear when they wrote “if you’re a creator on the monthly plan without the benefit of charge up front, you are constantly worried that your patrons are going to delete their pledges before they’ve paid”. From that, we can see how they were just hearing irrational paywall worries from people and responding irrationally around just trying to please those requests / address those worries. Those worries should have been recognized as irrational. Patreon ought to be saying that this is about honesty and people who want to support you and that they aren't in the business to try to stop all possible freeriding, they are working to help everyone who actually wants to support the creators etc.
- WesleyLivesay 9y agoWhile I like that they are walking these back, I have a feeling that people who lost a lot of supporters won't see a 100% recovery. I only lost a few, but it already has me poking around at different options for the future.
- Symmetry 9y agoI ended up canceling all my $1 donations except for a random one which I gave all the money to, but I know that a lot of people just canceled them.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI was able to find a PayPal for all but one of mine, and sent three months worth of pledges to them.
- kbenson 9y ago> I have a feeling that people who lost a lot of supporters won't see a 100% recovery. That's probably not a bad thing overall. I'm sure people that stopped pledging money during this period will get an email, and have a chance to undo the action. That said, there's quite a few people getting a couple bucks a month from me that I don't really have any reason to support anymore, but haven't taken the time to clean out. That's not an efficient market. If I had stopped pledging to some of them because of this (I didn't as I didn't see a problem with this move), I wouldn't feel compelled to pledge again, and that's a good thing, as right now they are only getting money from me because of my laziness. I'm not talking about people that I still want to support on principle or because I think they do cool stuff even if I'm not consuming it. Those people by definition are worth my money, so I would likely sign back up.
- davidgerard 9y ago> I only lost a few, but it already has me poking around at different options for the future. Same here. Nobody is going to trust Patreon not to do something equally damaging again. It's nice they've reversed this, but I really can't think of anything that will bring back the trust they just trashed.
- misterbowfinger 9y agoIt's hard to believe that Patreon didn't ask for feedback on this model initially. I'm sure they did, but my guess is that they didn't expect the blowback from people that depended on $1-2 patrons to have such a large impact on their image. IMO, before Twitter/Facebook, this apology would've never happened. They would've continued to press on with their fee structure and it would've been yesterday's news. The real question is - is this still a good move for them? Or should they have dealt with the blowback either way?
- gcommer 9y ago> It's hard to believe that Patreon didn't ask for feedback on this model initially. From their initial blog post announcing this change: > In preparation for this change, we ran experiments and months and months of research to understand patrons’ potential reactions and we found that many patrons were happy knowing that this change will send more money to creators. Looks like a somewhat interesting user-testing glitch to me. Perhaps their sample of patrons wasn't representive, or when you sit people down and discuss a new feature 1-1 you can be more convincing than when broadcasting it to the whole world in a blog post.
- Symmetry 9y agoIt sounds like they explained the asynchronous collection to the patrons without also explaining the implications for fees?
- kbenson 9y ago> Looks like a somewhat interesting user-testing glitch to me. Perhaps their sample of patrons wasn't representive, or when you sit people down and discuss a new feature 1-1 you can be more convincing than when broadcasting it to the whole world in a blog post. Or perhaps we're all just a raving mob waiting for the right inputs, and early sentiment by influential individuals actually shapes our thoughts and actions far more than we like to admit.
- jopsen 9y ago
- megaman22 9y agoI'm not sure how patreon is supposed to work; i signed up a long time ago, and I haven't seen a red cent from them. In the meantime I've gotten hundreds of dollars from Amazon and add AdWords.
- kinkrtyavimoodh 9y agoYou are not being sarcastic right? I am finding it hard to be charitable here. Patreon is just a place for your fans to support your work in a structured manner (rather than a free-form donate button). If you are a content creator, it is up to you to market your patreon account and request your fans to support you there. Did you do that?
- egypturnash 9y agoHere's what worked for me. 1. Make a thing and post it online for free with some degree of regularity. 2. Every post had a small link: "Pssst! Wanna help crowdfund a pagerate for me? Support my comics on Patreon." 3. Every time I made a thing, I'd post it to Patreon; at the end of the month, my backers would get charged based on how many things I made. 4. Over the course of a year, my Patreon went from "paying for my drink at the weekly cartoonist meetup sometimes" to "paying most of my rent on a productive month". And I am doing this by drawing a complicated graphic novel about a lesbian robot with Philip K Dick problems. I make far more from Patreon than I ever did from ads, and I'm delighted to have been able to turn them off for good.
- megaman22 9y ago
- stagger87 9y agoIs Patreon making a profit right now?
- kuschku 9y agoNo, they’re making significant losses, and according to rumors, credit card companies are seeing too high refund rates with Patreon, and are asking them to either fund that, or unbundle the payments.
- theobon 9y agoDo you have a source for these rumors. This is the second comment I've seen on this post suggesting this but I can't find any supporting evidence. According to Patreon's blog posts the unbundling was entirely related to the "date of first subscription" problem.
- pishpash 9y agoHow does unbundling help refund rates?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ebiester 9y agoI mean, how many ways can you say "To make this viable, we need more money. That can come from you, or it can come indirectly via fees to your patrons. Which would you prefer?"
- ceejayoz 9y agoI'm fine paying a transaction fee. I'm not fine paying seventeen of them for my swarm of little $1-3 pledges that get billed as one monthly transaction.
- falcolas 9y agoAccording to the expanded initial blog post, it would not have been all at once, but over the course of a month, corresponding to when you created a pledge. Not a good model imo, but at least it wasn’t totally insane.
- ceejayoz 9y agoNo, that "not all at once" is precisely what made it insane. All at once is good. Their credit card fees have a percentage component (1.9% for Stripe) and a fixed, per-transaction component ($0.30 for Stripe). All at once means that fixed component gets charged once per month. Moving to a one-transaction-per-pledge model means that fixed component is multiplied by the number of pledges, which dramatically increased costs for users like me with a bunch of small ones.
- falcolas 9y agoWell, I would have considered "charge all at once" combined with "charge for every individual service charge" to be insane. But... semantics. Charge once and apply one service fee would make a lot more sense. Also, for online transactions, Stripe's percentage is 2.9%. Of course, there's a lot of caveats to Stripe's pricing, so I'm sure the actual charge amount changes.
- 9y ago
- ronilan 9y agoGreat move by YouTube! Edit: oops, sorry, it's Patreon. That damn dog whistle again...
- glenneroo 9y agoI don't understand why they had to make the change global. Why didn't they just do this for e.g. patrons paying more than $10 (or whichever amount makes sense)? I support a lot of projects but only the minimum of $1-2 per month/project and suddenly they were all $2-3 (multiplied by 10 projects is a huge tax).
- pilif 9y agoI wonder whether this rollback was caused by them actually listening to their users or the huge dip in revenue as people stopped donating. Well. Either way. This looks like a good thing. Until the VCs start again to pressure for more revenue. Let's see what happens then. Probably higher fees for the creators.
- nbm 9y agoThe cynical view: "We took a calculated risk, announcing the set of changes, and seeing what the fallout would be. The fallout exceeded the threshold we set, so we're now going to issue the apology we had prepared in case that situation was reached."
- kbenson 9y agoI'm not sure why that requires cynacism. It is a business, after all. I would rather them do this than blunder along blindly with policies that might cause them to fail entirely, and adversely affect all those that rely on they far more than this did.
- aylons 9y agoIt IS cynicism, by definition. If we have come to expect cynicism from business as something usual, that's sad, but it is cynic nonetheless. If they had been upfront about it from the beginning, it would still be a business decision, only less cynic.
- always_good 9y agoFWIW, cynic is a noun.
- aylons 9y agoThanks. Cynical would be the right word, I see. English is not my primary language.
- make3 9y agoThat's not cynicism. let me tell you a secret. Businesses are there to make money. It's surprising, I know. Another secret while we're at it: adults run businesses, and have strategies that they hope are rational. Again, incredible, I know; I though companies were run by impulsive 14 yo with black and white minds.
- huebnerob 9y ago
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThis is probably too late for a lot of creators, so hopefully Patreon feels the pain of this boneheaded decision for a long time to come. Several of the people and projects I sponsor have moved to alternative services, and I followed them. In the future, if a competing service is offered I will favor it over Patreon.
- gk1 9y agoWhat alternatives are there?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoOne went to LiberaPay, another set up something called SendOwl, and a third just put their product on itch.io. There are actually a lot of different ways to setup this kind of funding stream, depending on what you're looking for. If you're looking for "Patreon, but not Patreon" then it gets a little more complicated.
- myth_drannon 9y agoIt's LiberaPay not LibrePay
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoCorrected.
- spencerfry 9y agoOne alternative is Podia. We've been getting a lot of signups from Patreon users over the past few days. We don't play games with fees (no transaction fees at all, actually, only what Stripe/Paypal charges). Here's more on the differences: https://www.podia.com/patreon-alternative https://www.podia.com/patreon-alternative If anyone wants to give it a shot, feel free to reach out to me (Spencer, the founder) directly in the live chat widget :)
- 734786710934 9y agoUsers who were upset with the change need to reckon with the fact that Patreon isn't profitable and that it's likely that it's impossible for them to ever become profitable with their 5% business model (Patreon is based in San Francisco and has over 100 employees, do the math).
- padillla 9y agoMaybe they should move somewhere less elitist. SF is overrated and overpriced.
- Analemma_ 9y agoThey can just take a larger share of creators’ aggregate earnings if they need more money. Obviously the creators won’t be happy, but it wouldn’t destroy the “many individual $1-2 donations” segment, as this change would’ve done.
- ilamont 9y agoThis is what Upwork did. Freelancers weren't happy, but the anger died down and the company is still in business. Background: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11626864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11626864
- icebraining 9y agoPatreon is based in San Francisco and has over 100 employees Neither of which are immutable laws of physics. I feel for those employees, but between giving money to them or to the creators - I'm giving to the creators.
- djsumdog 9y agoHmm. I wonder if they could be profitable if they didn't live in SF. It's tough because a lot of the best engineers, minds and talents are on the west coast, either in the Bay Area or Seattle. Having moved to the other side of the country, I've noticed the difference in where companies are at architecturally. It's a tough trade-off for sure.
- dokem 9y agoThe sad part is that Patreon has to backtrack and apologize so aggressively. I read the email the other day while sitting on the toilet and thought nothing of it. Was there any actual blowback or just a couple of loud mouths on Twitter that can't afford to rub a few pennies together? You can't make everyone happy, especially in the quest to make money.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoThere was a substantial blowback from both creators and patrons. The problem wasn't really the switch to having patrons cover overhead, it was that no attempt was made at all to aggregate pledges in order to reduce that overhead. This disproportionately affected patrons who pledge small amounts to a lot of people.
- ProfessorLayton 9y agoI'm glad they're reversing these changes. But these developments scream loud and clear that no creator should ever rely too heavily on any single platform. If I was a creator I would certainly still be on the lookout for alternatives.
- minimaxir 9y agoPatreon took off because it was the alternative, as traditional YouTube/website ad revenue has high variance and has been decreasing over time.
- pvdebbe 9y agoI would urge everyone to open up a Liberapay account on the side. In the long run Patreon only has one direction to go to, thanks to moral policing and other shenanigans.
- Thetawaves 9y agoIt was my impression that patreon needs to find a profitable footing to continue existing. Generally I would see increased revenues as a good thing (it helps to ensure that a service people appreciate continues to exist). Given that - why has there been such a push back against this?
- mcintyre1994 9y ago"Many of you lost patrons, and you lost income." Because lost income is as bad as increased revenues are good, and people lost income. Patreon aren't in a field where they get to experiment like that without affecting people's income, and that's always going to lead to pushback.
- gizmo686 9y agoA lot of people viewed Patreon as a microtransaction service. They give $1 to a bunch of creators. Creators liked this because it meant they could get a bunch of low value supportors instead of a relatively few high value ones. Previously, Patreaon worked fine for this use-case. You support 10 creators at $1 each. Patreon charges you $10 each month, and credits $1 to each of your pledgies accounts. Patreon then eats $FEES from the pledgie's account and gives them the remaining money. Patreon would aggragate transfers so they only pay transaction fees on the single $10 charge to me, and on the final payment to the creator. As a result of this (and maybe other things), the fees were unpredictable to the creators, because they did not know how many other creators were splitting the transaction fees. In this example, a single creator would only see a ~$0.03 fee on my $1 donation; however, if I only had a single creator, he would see the full $0.30 on my dontation. (There are other fees at play, but this is the important one). Under the new system, every donation pays the $0.35 transaction fee. This means that even if I support 10 creators, they all pay the full $0.35 on my $1 donation. In contrast, if I instead had a single creator at $10, he would only see $0.38 in fees, or about $0.04 per dollar. This means that the new system disproportional effects people making small donations. It is also not clear that this was a pure money grab. This change coincided with a change to their payment system where they would stop aggregating charges. If they do not aggragate charges, it makes sense that they would charge smaller donations more, because those now have more overhead. The problem is that this breaks the service for small donation use cases.
- jknoepfler 9y agoIt creeps me out to no end when corporations mimic human social behavior using community relations teams. It's made worse by people thinking that anything about the content of the apology matters. It was literally crafted by an expert actor. The only thing we should care about is the reversal and whatever concrete action Patreon takes to prevent a new fiasco (which I see no mention of). The company executed a business decision with bumbling incompetence, then was forced to back it out because of their customers. That later bit is interesting, the fact that it was accompanied by something written by a trained parrot is not. I'd still be looking for alternatives, the original decision was a gross breach of trust and revealed that Patreon's business 1decisions are not coming from the authentic place we may once have hoped for. edit: to clarify, the content I'm looking for in a real apology is a plan of action so that this isn't repeated. Patreon needs to restore trust. Apology language doesn't do that. Rolling back the act of searing incompetence was step one. Making sure it doesn't happen again is the real apology.
- mlevental 9y agopeople will down vote you because anything counter corporate/capital is blasphemy and this kind of messaging has been so noticed that almost no one even considers it for a second but you're completely correct and I agree with you.
- asdjasldkjkljd 9y agoIt's probably not so black and white. Companies are ultimately comprised of people, who may or may not be trying to manipulate you. With all the hostile corporate nonsense out there, it seems strange to categorize every supposed act in good faith towards the customer as a manipulative lie.
- whatyoucantsay 9y agoThe same strategy works with people. Intentions matter because they let you reason about a person's likely future actions, but often the only way to ascertain another's intentions is to scrutinize their actions as opposed to their words.
- 9y ago
- benkarst 9y agoA blog post as an apology? I can picture the CEO in a meeting, "Hey if this doesn't work out, we can just draft a really sincere sounding letter to our creators."
- minimaxir 9y agoGranted, that is the normal strategy for startups in 2017. (except that the post was made on an official blog and not Medium)
- TheCowboy 9y agoYou should suggest the alternative response for the less imaginative of us, because what else could they do in response? It just comes across as snarky for people to hate the changes and dismiss them again when they rollback the policy everyone hated. This is an unprofitable startup here, so I don't think they can start giving out money to everyone who lost support. Businesses make mistakes, and I'd think it would be a positive when they listen to their users.
- mcqueenjordan 9y agoI doubt it was the feedback that they heard. I think it was the money. I’m willing to bet that this rollback is because Patreon leadership and Sr. Managers woke up Monday morning, took a look at their metrics and KPIs and nearly had a heart attack. It probably looks like a nice upward trend for a long time then a massive spike down after the announcement. Always follow the money.
- chipotle_coyote 9y agoMaybe, but if you poke around Graphtreon for a while and just look at the dropoffs in terms of patron counts and revenue from the time of the announcement until today, they're noticeable but they're not "OMG our world is on fire." (It's useful to click "Start on Zero" when that option is there, so you have a better visual representation of the actual drop.) Patreon could certainly have afforded to wait and see what happened after the change rolled out. This is certainly a business decision, but image is part of their business, and part of their image is, ostensibly, listening to creators.
- actualanswer 9y agoThis isn't the Enterprise. Did you take a look at the people who run Patreon? I'm sure they are more shattered that people lost patrons than the fact that Patreon themselves lost money. They had good intentions - to get the creators paid 95% but they executed it poorly.
- davidgerard 9y agoNot sure it was graphs. I think #4 creator Amanda Palmer posting in open revolt asking her patrons to sign up for email so they could follow her somewhere else might have helped: https://www.patreon.com/posts/15819420 https://www.patreon.com/posts/15819420 It turns out the whales remember when they were minnows.
- jasode 9y ago>Many of you lost patrons, and you lost income. I think Jack at Patreon fundamentally misunderstood the nature of the relationship between patron and creator. A lot of patrons feel like their payment is a donation instead of paying a subscription or water bill. Yes, some patrons+creators have a quid-pro-quo arrangement where payments unlocks content or extra services. However, many payments are just "appreciation" type of money. That is a fragile relationship and it was wrong to tamper with it by charging extra fees to the patron. Jack was/is a creator himself so he should have known this dynamic and therefore predicted the bad outcome ahead of time. Ideally, when you start a multi-sided platform, you want to get the economics correct from the very beginning so you can leave it unchanged. (E.g. Apple iTunes charges 30% since 2008 and it's stayed that way.) However, if you have to readjust the percentages, it's preferable to take it out on the sellers' side and not the buyers' side. When ebay started, the fees for sellers were ~3.25%. Over the last 10 years, it has crept up in increments to ~10%. All of those price increases were absorbed by the sellers. If Patreon needs more than 5% to make the numbers work for a sustainable business, they need to take it from the creators and not the patrons. Patreon was riding on the "good will" of patrons making voluntary payments. It was a terrible miscalculation to destroy that good will and nickel & dime patrons with extra fees.
- masklinn 9y ago> I think Jack at Patreon fundamentally misunderstood the nature of the relationship between patron and creator. A lot of patrons feel like their payment is a donation instead of a subscription or water bill. Yes, some patrons+creators have a quid-pro-quo arrangement where payments unlocks content or extra services. However, many payments are just "appreciation" type of money. And at least for serials the "quid-pro-quo" arrangement is usually earlier access to content (e.g. bonus/patron chapters), there's no exclusive/sale type arrangement.
- jasode 9y ago>And at least for serials the "quid-pro-quo" arrangement is usually earlier access to content Yes, when I typed out "quid-pro-quo", I was thinking back to the recent HN article about webcam women making money on Patreon. Patrons would pay $10 a month and for that, the women would do private chats, role play, etc. For that particular type of patron who needs to see a particular woman take her clothes off, the 2.9% fee plus 35 cents would be more of a "nuisance" fee and they'd just go ahead and pay it. Let's call this group, the SUBSCRIBERS. However, a lot of Patreon relationships are not quid-pro-quo and it's a totally different psychology when patrons pay a $1 donation to "support an artist" with no direct benefit other than some good feelings or minor things like "early access to content" like you pointed out. In this scenario, Patreon is the online version of throwing money into a hat to show appreciation for the musician at a coffee shop. Inflicting extra fees on patrons damages this type of relationship. (E.g. "Twitter was filled with screenshots of people removing their $1 pledges.") Let's call this tip jar group, the DONATORS. If SUBSCRIBERS are the majority and dominated the platform over the DONATORS, Patreon could have stayed the course to charge extra fees to patrons on December 18. However, it's telling that Patreon aborted that plan which signals to me that the DONATORS are a very large and influential part of the Patreon membership. Jack said they did a bunch of spreadsheet models and surveys before announcing the fee changes but obviously, their assumptions about their members were way off somewhere. (I'm oversimplifying with categories of SUBSCRIBERS vs DONATORS to illustrate a point. It's certainly possible for some patrons to be a blend of both psychologies based on how their pledges are split to various creators.)
- james_pm 9y agoAre there really that many patrons who feel the value they get from whatever they are supporting is a single dollar? Leave the transaction fees as they were going to be, and make the minimum amount of patronage $5 or $10.
- ceejayoz 9y agoI love the $1 price point. One of my pledges is to a favorite author. $1/month means $12/year. She puts out about a book a year, at about $12 in Kindle format, so my pledge means I'm at least doubling the amount of revenue she gets from me annually (and I'd suspect significant portions of that $12 go to Amazon, agents, publishers, etc.). I can do this casually, for a bunch of creators I like - comic artists, activists, authors, indie game devs - and it's not just me doing it, either.
- actuallyalys 9y agoSome people don't have the disposable income to support more than one or two creators at $5, let alone $10. For me, there are creators I like, but aren't very active, aren't that valuable to me, or are supported by me in other ways that I pledge $1 to.
- egypturnash 9y ago50% of my Patreon money comes from $1 pledges. Many (if not all) of those pledges are from people who are giving $1 to multiple creators. I post most of the stuff I make online for free, with no ads. All those $1s add together to make a sustainable wage for me. It's the Long Tail in action. It's pretty nice.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pishpash 9y agoOr, they could have grandfathered existing users. You know, that's usually how you appease and change at the same time.
- Bjartr 9y ago
- thriftwy 9y agoLook how good it is to be customers and not the product? You get to have apologies.
- wnevets 9y agoSaying you're sorry and not doing it is good enough for me.
- davidgerard 9y agoThey said they're sorry and they're going to do something toward whatever the hell it was they thought they were doing in the coming year.
- myth_drannon 9y agoWell at least LiberaPay got their minute of fame from this fiasco. Their stats shot through the roof. https://liberapay.com/about/stats https://liberapay.com/about/stats
- craftyguy 9y agoHopefully folks continue to migrate to them. It's pretty clear Patreon is only looking out for themselves at this point, and the "sudden" change in direction is because their bank account started to bleed.
- gkya 9y agoEvery enterprise has to earn a decent amount of money to survive, let alone succeed in a financial way. They'd just start out as a NGO otherwise. WRT dumping Patreon and the like, I'd rather see community-efforts and enterprise compete. That has lead to some very high quality products from both (e.g. clang vs. gcc, chrome vs. firefox).
- QAkICoU7IDNkpFu 9y agoMakerSupport also gained from Patreon's mistake: Their rank improved 8,324,736 positions vs Liberapay's 824,569 positions. MS is now rank 578,982 and Liberapay is 586,177 vs Patreon's 461 Data from alexa.com: https://archive.is/y3CJ9 https://archive.is/y3CJ9 https://archive.is/txACk https://archive.is/txACk https://archive.is/lkMkp https://archive.is/lkMkp
- username223 9y agoYou had one job, Patreon: aggregate payments to eliminate fixed transaction fees for the people exchanging money through your platform, replacing them with a percentage fee. You set the percentage too low and then, instead of simply raising it, you tried to stop doing the one thing that made you useful: eliminating fixed transaction fees. It's a pretty good corporate apology, but it demonstrates a surprising lack of understanding of their business.
- sleepybrett 9y agoToo late, the damage is done.
- da_chicken 9y agoI understand why they need to do something different. It's no mistake that the rule was $0.35 plus a percentage. All the credit card companies that people use to pay with Patreon charge the retailer per transaction regardless of the size, and it's usually $0.20 to $0.35 plus a percentage; debit cards can be as high as $0.50 plus a percentage. That has to be the motivation for this. So the first $1 you give is only like $0.65, and that's just the payment processing fee. It also costs money to transfer the funds to the creator's account , and then Patreon gets 5% of what's left (https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-do-you-calculate-fees- https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/204606125-How-...). Almost all the money has gone to fees. Even if you run the charges once a month, this is a fee for each Patron and another fee for each creator. If you're a patron and you're giving just $1 to just one creator, you're probably giving them like $0.10 and Patreon a big fat penny. This is why so many stores have a minimum transaction amount for credit cards. If they don't do that, they can lose money on fees because the profit margin on what they're selling doesn't even cover the service charge.
- draw_down 9y agoDid that state of affairs change recently somehow? I would imagine it has been that way since Patreon started.
- ufo 9y agoPatreon originally aggregated all payments into a monthly lump transaction to Patreon. The new fee structure is consistent with them desegregating the payments but it is not clear why they would do that. One theory going around is that having individual payments reduces their chargeback rate because the number in the credit card bill matches the individual contributions instead of the lump sum. Another theory going around is that separate payments would allow payments to be immediately sent to the creator instead of waiting until the end of the month. But Patreon hasn't been clear if one of these is the reason or if it was something else.
- da_chicken 9y ago> The new fee structure is consistent with them desegregating the payments but it is not clear why they would do that. From what I've read, the credit card companies are complaining about partial refunds, which apparently occur much more often with Patreon. If I've got 10 creators I'm supporting for $1 each, and I decide I need a refund for one of them, well, Patreon only ran one $10 transaction. Now it's kind of a pain in the ass for the credit card company because I'm telling my credit card company it should be 10 transactions @ $1 and I want to refund $1, but what they see is one $10 transaction.
- imiric 9y agoThis is an admirable response, but I feel like Patreon is just one of the first approaches towards getting rid of the advertising revenue models so prevalent on the internet today, which should definitely be our goal. We can't allow greedy advertisers to hijack online services, as is the current case for YouTube. I hope that in the future content creators won't have to depend on a single company which takes decisions purely based on their own profit. The marketing team can spin this anyway they want, but ultimately as a company that is their goal. For lack of a better term, microtransactions and some form of digital currency should solve this problem. I'm not a fan of the Brave browser, but they introduced a micropayment system last year[0]. It seems to have been launched with Bitcoin support, but maybe this has expanded (as it should) towards other currencies. Can someone share their experience with Brave Payments, or with similar systems? This seems like the only logical way to go, from a technology standpoint, and we're not that far off from reaching it. Creators have their digital wallets, payments are made in the background (with very limited user interaction, or none whatsoever) after a certain smart contract is fulfilled between creator and consumer, and the funds are transferred with very little latency. The content creation service that launches with this will be huge in the near future. Bonus points for open sourcing it and making an open system that all content creation sites can reuse. [0]: https://www.brave.com/introducing-brave-payments/ https://www.brave.com/introducing-brave-payments/
- jimmaswell 9y agoI really liked the idea of websites mining some cpu-mineable cryptocurrency in place of having ads there. I suspect that might be a more widespread solution in the future. Maybe even in the long term, the mining will be done through webGL or some other API so that the browser can take advantage of the host's GPU/GPU equivalent.
- acqq 9y agoIt seems you haven't thought about the consequences for such an approach.
- jimmaswell 9y ago
- xupybd 9y agoPatreon lost my support when they banned Lauren Southern. They have every right to do so but I don’t want to support a company that refuses to work with people based on their political leanings.
- TheCowboy 9y agoPlatforms aren't neutral parties and have to make calls like this. "Political leanings" is misdirection. Participating in attempts to block NGO (affiliated with Doctors without Borders) ships performing maritime search and rescue missions for migrants is particularly heinous. If it must be spelled out, this is acting to prevent the rescue of drowning refugees. Are you really supporting freedom of expression by allowing your platform to support people who don't support others right to exist?
- xupybd 9y agoI think the argument is to do with political leanings. Some believe that NGO boats incentivize human trafficking. If this is true more people will die via human trafficking than would if these NGO were interrupted. While that argument is not super solid it is a political one and to Ban her based on her intention to report on this seems political to me.
- TheCowboy 9y agoYou can rephrase this as much as you want, but this is not just "her intention to report on this". This is obstructing humanitarian efforts in a way that leads to loss of life. You're claiming the motivations here are to protect the lives of migrants by limiting "incentived human trafficking", but the motive is white nationalism. http://www.dw.com/en/defend-europe-identitarians-charter-a-ship-to-return-migrants-to-africa/a-39702947 http://www.dw.com/en/defend-europe-identitarians-charter-a-s...
- xupybd 9y agoMost of those quotes are from the activist group Hope not Hate. They are a group on the left saying a group on the right is bad. Can you see how this is a deeply political issue? I hear far too often that people on the right are white nationalist, yet I see no one presenting evidence they are. There are some white nationalist on the right but I don't think it's fair to tar everyone on the right with the same brush.
- gigatexal 9y agoMost things, if not everything, comes down to economics and not goodwill.
- zdkl 9y agoCitation Needed
- stcredzero 9y agoOne of the greatest victories of Human Rights in the past few hundred years came down to philosophy and goodwill, not economics. The abolition of slavery cost the British government and Navy a considerable amount in their enforcement effort. The US paid a terrible price for it. http://imperium-europa.blogspot.com/2016/06/thomas-sowell-british-war-against.html http://imperium-europa.blogspot.com/2016/06/thomas-sowell-br... Economics is one of the biggest factors deciding what people do. (I'd put it at #2 or #3) However, there are even mightier factors than money and livelihood. Otherwise, we'd be Ferengi, not humans, and the Ferengi characters in Star Trek which are written to be different would be the main characters. That economics reigns supreme is one of the false cornerstones of the original Marxian economics which experts in the field now know to be false, but which persists in zombie form in the popular consciousness.
- ageofwant 9y agoThat's a comforting fiction, however the truth has more to do with the industrial revolution, and the fact that a joule from coal is significantly cheaper than a joule from a slave. Future high primary energy cost economies will almost certainly be based on slave labour, like they have in the past.
- stcredzero 9y agoThat's a comforting fiction, however the truth has more to do with the industrial revolution, and the fact that a joule from coal is significantly cheaper than a joule from a slave. Then why not have slaves running your coal powered machinery? The truth is that the free labor of slaves was just a particular (and ultimately inefficient) pattern of organizing society, and the human capital of knowledge is the real driving force. If energy was the ruling force, then West Virginia wouldn't be so poor and rural, and Japan wouldn't be a world economic powerhouse. Future high primary energy cost economies will almost certainly be based on slave labour, like they have in the past. Even in the historical US, slaves that worked in agriculture and industries that required knowledge and attention to detail were paid. Otherwise, there is no motivation for energizing the human capital of skill and knowledge. If the way you see the world were accurate, then totalitarian societies would be the wealthy ones. Instead, those with some degree of free trade and individual freedom are the wealthy ones.
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoThe thing everyone is missing is that you CANNOT do $1 credit card payment at scale. Patreon has been taking a hit for every single dollar pledge made. They dont want your $1, it costs them too much! Patreon decided that they were SICK of supplementing all the $1 pledges, and added a new fee schedule. The internet, was too short sighted to care about this economic reality, and so they were forced to burn with fees once more.
- byuu 9y agoAnd that's why the older model worked better: a donor would pledge $1 to twenty creators, and would get charged one $20 transaction fee at the beginning of each month. The creators ate the Paypal fee (usually 4-5%), and then Patreon collected an additional 5% for simply coordinating these exchanges with their service. I doubt there were many people who only pledged $1 to one creator and that was it. But if that was truly a problem, then sure, one 35-cent charge per month would be reasonable.
- encryptThrow32 9y agoThank you for explaining. I never understood the aggregation of donations process. Maybe a majority of their customers are paying $1 to 1 person? Are there really people that give away x $1/month to multiple random internet folks? I don't get it.
- sofal 9y agoI like to listen to podcasts a lot, which is pretty common. Typically I'm going to consume a fair number of individual podcast episodes during a month, but they're all from a wide variety of podcast creators, many of whom I'd like to support on Patreon. I'm not going to pledge $10 to every single podcast I listen to, because then I'm paying hundreds of dollars a month for podcasts. I also don't want to send a bunch of money to just one among the many podcasts I like. I'd like to spread out my support across the different content creators, each of which I feel has given me something of value.
- chx 9y ago
- ksk 9y agoThey should put the executive payroll on patreon. That would prevent any future mishaps. :)
- AlanSE 9y ago> Aggregation is highly-valued, and we underestimated that. To me, at least, this is the core issue. Patreon is supposed to be the way to support creators in the internet age. If they're going to make a strong many-to-many funding model impractical, then why should anyone put money into them as opposed to conventional charities? An NPR pledge drive will sign me up for a credit card monthly auto-payment, but that just doesn't really get me excited. Sure, it's a good cause, but good causes have always been around. This is critical because of the fact that so many of the creators are actually doing bleeding-edge things. The tiny sub-categories of creators I fund didn't exist 3 years ago. A $1 donation isn't just a signal from the supporter to the creator. It's a signal to the media, it's a signal for potential book deals, all kinds of things. Those numbers have value. By making those contributions radically financially inefficient, they are risking a tipping point that undermines their core value proposition. Even worse, it hurts the frontiers of creation that we cared about in the first place.
- ksk 9y agoI think I read it somewhere else too, but why does a company setup for community contributions need to raise money through venture capital?
- throwawayyx96 9y agoI'm scratching my head wondering why they didn't just take the obvious route of offering an optional 'also pay the processing fees' option like paypal does. Phrased in a way that lets the patron know that their supported creators are getting a larger cut as a result. They might have been pleasantly surprised by how many people will go for that as long as it's voluntary and the fees are reasonable.
- nicky0 9y agoIt seems to me that patreon thinks that its customers are the creators, and so it has been focusing its effort on pleasing them. In fact it is quite clear by asking "who pays the money" that their customers are in fact the patrons.
- eric_the_read 9y agoThis seems straightforward, if only from a cash flow perspective-- customers are the people who give you money; vendors are the people you give money to.
- pornel 9y agoAt least Liberapay had a good week: https://liberapay.com/about/stats https://liberapay.com/about/stats - 50% increase in active users, 8x increase in money deposited. It's still a rounding error compared to Patreon's size, but I'm happy to see open-source non-profit grow.
- aw3c2 9y agoAnd I really like their model. You sent a fixed amount of money to your account once and then distribute it over time as you like. For a 100€ load this is 60¢ in fees. Withdrawing euros to a SEPA bank account is free. Totally awesome!
- chx 9y agoWhat is missing from the blog post and from comments here as well is something I saw on Twitter: if they unbundle and charge on the "anniversary" of the join date of everyone then anyone shipping physical is utter screwed. They used to have a single day (say, the 6th) when they shipped out to everyone who paid and that was it. Shipping every day for small creators doesn't work -- they need time to create :)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ReedJessen 9y agoExcellent apology. They are in a tough position.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nojvek 9y agoI really liked that people voted with their wallets. I funded $10/month to a couple of people and pulled everything out. I'm glad they reversed the fee. Will start funding again. I wish we could all do the same with our taxes to make a point to GOP.
- tartuffe78 9y agoYou mean the party pushing for tax cuts?
- acqq 9y ago> You mean the party pushing for tax cuts ..." for the rich and the corporations and on the costs of the public services."
- wnevets 9y ago>You mean the party pushing for tax cuts for the very rich? ftfy
- nerfhammer 9y agoThey're raising them for Californians
- losteric 9y agoThey're raising them for everyone except the rich.
- tensormoon 9y agoGood sports. I have about $50/mo going to creators on the site. I would follow wherever they went. Hopefully they managed to keep this stuff from disrupting too many people.
- behringer 9y agoThis screams like "hey we'll charge the creators rather than you". As a creator there's no way I could trust you for getting a fair deal and the competition is so fierce nobody needs to use patreon. If patreon needs help paying the bills, they should make their own account on their own system and rely on the service to provide like everyone else.
- rossdavidh 9y agoWhat's odd to me is that they don't seem to have understood that spreading this charge (basically the credit card fee) across several people the patron is sponsoring, is more or less their purpose. If a given patron is not (typically) sponsoring more than one artist (or whatever), then yes they would/will have a problem, but they also wouldn't have a reason to exist. It's not like there aren't other ways to accept a credit card online, on a repeating basis even. Enabling a "tip jar on a monthly basis" was their whole reason for existence. They may not have known this.
- fiatjaf 9y agoI don't understand why that would have impacted more $1 donors than others. Someone please explain!
- fiatjaf 9y agoI ask a question and get a downvote.
- Majestic121 9y agoBecause there is a 0.35c flat fee per donation along with the 2.9% (ignored in the sample). So giving ten euros to 1 creator actually costs 10.35 to the patron. Giving 1 euros to 10 creators costs 13.50
- fiatjaf 9y agoThank you.
- yuvalr1 9y agoThe way to prevent such future issues is to move to a decentralized platform, perhaps using a blockchain.
- Tokkemon 9y agoHah. Wait, what happened?
- fapjacks 9y agoI waited a few days before canceling my $1-2 pledges, and completed my cancellations yesterday. So now today I had to spend some time going back through and re-pledging the stupid $1-2 pledges to lessen the screw to my beloved creators. What a clusterfuck!
- reiichiroh 9y agoNo apology is enough to atone for Pomplamoose.
- nikolay 9y agoI am in the States and I am charged VAT. I emailed them, tweeted to them - no response! I can't believe this company is run so poorly!
- xchip 9y agoI cancelled my account, glad to see they got the message. It will take a while until I rejoin, if I do ever join. I might donate directly now.
- nopcode 9y agoI already deleted all my subscriptions. I'm too lazy to put it back.
- frandroid 9y agoI think a major issue that many commentators here don't touch is the idea that Patreon plainly lied to its users. They said "more money will go to creators" when the real action was "we're charging more money to users with barely any more benefit to creators". Everyone understands that $1 going to $1.37 is "more money going to Patreon" and the stated benefit was spin. It didn't make me change my pledges but I was shocked by the dishonesty.
- frandroid 9y agoPatreon have built a kind micropayments platform, but suddenly they decided they weren't happy with being a micropayments platform anymore, charging PayPal-level fees on transactions, and many more artifically inflated transactions at that. We already have PayPal, we don't need Patreon as a second one which isn't competitive.
- Jpoechill 9y agoCancelled a subscription that I had also, will have to return now. yipes
- manigandham 9y agoA patronage/donation model has no reason to worry about pledges being cancelled early since there no purchase or expectation of goods. Sure some people might have done that but it's already a community willing paying money to support people they liked so it seems that behavior filters itself. Unless they were trying to become a real commerce and subscription business, it seems rather disingenuous to claim that as a reason, and it looks like that was the core foundation because taking that away leaves little more than saying that the existing system was "confusing", which could've be solved differently. Also I'm not sure how individual payments with even more fees could be less confusing than a single payment and fee per month but this is a rather unfortunate incident for all the patrons who have to suffer from the loss.
- xlii 9y agoI wonder how long companies will be able to do stuff like this. I know Hanlon’s razor but lately I get the feeling that most of the companies try to push shitty stuff on their customers and in case of getting caught with the hand still in the cookie jar they apologize profusely and move on to another one. I refuse to believe that it was innocent accident. As other commenter pointed out this was discussed for a long time and most likely WAS an educated decision. The only thing that was underestimated here is amount of outrage that followed.
- katastic 9y agoAs usual. If you want a company to change, you have to affect their bottom dollar. Otherwise, you'll only get a "we have learned through this experience and will take it forward with us to prevent [our messed up thing we did] from [ever being noticed by you again]."
- thisacctforreal 9y agoI like the model of having the patron pay the (variable) cc fee, and having either the patron or creator pay the patreon fee. $patron_charge = $pledges_to_creators + $cc_fee + ($patreon_fee?) $creator_payout = $pledges_from_patrons - ($patreon_fee?) My beef is with aboloshing payment batching, which is the only wholesome value proposition of patreon (i.e. strictly creates or spreads wealth). Without that it's just another locked-down social graph. The goal for this change seemed to be at-cost fee payments with no loss or profit, and to prevent chargebacks from customers who didn't remember/expect a payment total or payment date. The first goal is acomplished with the patron-pays-cc-fee model, and the second one might be solveable enough with UX tweaks. Showing how the total is calculated in a big, ledgible table, perhaps after every new pledge, seems like a useful start. Maybe even showing a calendar, granting the ablility to change the monthly charge date, and sending/offering reminders or adding an export-to-calendar button. Of course those may be overwhelming to users, so maybe KISS and find out what can be improved later.
- fab1an 9y agoOne thing that bugs me about these types of 'we hear you loud and clear' statements is the stylistic use of the 'corporate first person plural'. I feel the "we" in this contexts sounds a lot less authentic than a first person singular statement from the founder / CEO. While companies certainly do have a specific and sometimes even unique culture, do we really think that _they_ have "core beliefs"?
- macspoofing 9y agoThey are a young company dealing with money and playing in a very controversial space (they will be attacked and targeted for providing a service to people like Sam Harris - who is seen as a bigot by large swaths of the left). They are going to get things wrong as they mature. It will take time.
- ashtube 9y agoYou mean they didn't look at the stats and see how low the average pledge is, and the many, many users who pledge $1-2? Whilst it's a nicely worded apology, they F'd up being greedy, and are now trying to recover by maintaining that closeness with the users. I'm not buying it.
- sontek 9y agoI wonder if this came out of the SF/Bay Area style growth after taking on investment? I haven't heard if they've been hiring a ton lately but I saw this happen with SurveyMonkey when we went from 100 employees to 1500. The first 100 understood EVERYTHING about our customers and the product. Something got lost in translation when we grew to 1500 in a few years. I wonder if they have scaled out to the point where they are hiring people who don't quite understand the product but are just a butt in a seat?