21 ms·
AMD Ryzen Threadripper 1920X and 1950X CPUs Announced
- drewg123 9y agoIt is great that they're announced for an August release, but when I can actually BUY one? Given that Naples (aka Epyc) was "released" in June, I went looking to actually buy one, and I could not find a single place selling them. Not Newegg, nothing local, nothing in Google shopping, etc.
- lettergram 9y agoApparently, it's only available via one OEM: http://www.amd.com/en/where-to-buy/epyc-platforms http://www.amd.com/en/where-to-buy/epyc-platforms
- drewg123 9y agoWho isn't even selling the single-socket config that I want.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoOn July 27, you'll be able to buy an Alienware Area-51 with Threadripper.
- IanCutress 9y agoYou'll be able to pre-order. Still no official word on when it'll ship.
- drewg123 9y agoI just googled that. They apparently have an exclusive among major brands. Yuck. To be honest, for me, the last time I built a pre-made tower was 1994 or so. I'm really waiting for boards and CPUs to show up on Newegg/Amazon, at Fry's etc.
- IanCutress 9y agoAMD stated that the full EPYC stack will be available for top-tier OEMs end of July. You're unlikely to see them being sold at retail directly until the tier 1/2 OEMs have had the opportunity to take their fill for their customers. That will take a few quarters. Compare it to Intel - their top-tier partners had the hardware last November, but Intel announced 8 months after that. AMD launched its parts at the start of that 8 months, rather than the end. That's where some of the confusion about EPYC's availability lies. No-one complained they couldn't get SKL-SP back in November because no-one said anything: I'm guessing that AMD had had to make some announcement, given the delays, the projects, and to drive up OEM cooperation/customer anticipation (and show something to investors).
- shmerl 9y agoI'm still waiting for this bug to be fixed: https://community.amd.com/message/2796982 https://community.amd.com/message/2796982 Note: this isn't a bug in gcc, but looks like hardware bug related to hyperthreading.
- Laforet 9y agoI am still waiting the official errata for Family 17h
- InTheArena 9y agoJust a question (this is how out of touch I am). I thought most linux compilation moved over to a lvvm toolchain?
- shmerl 9y agoNot really, but it's generally up to individual projects. Many support both gcc and clang.
- unmole 9y agoNot even remotely close. No major distribution uses the LLVM toolchain.
- shmerl 9y agoIf you are talking about the kernel itself, I think Debian did some work to support building Linux with clang. But last time I checked, it wasn't ready. See also: https://wiki.debian.org/llvm-clang https://wiki.debian.org/llvm-clang
- cyphar 9y agoDistributions compile more than just a kernel. That's just one of several thousand packages we build. Usually the problem (even with something as simple as PIC/ASLR) is that old projects might have problems compiling. We just switched openSUSE Tumbleweed to GCC7 a few months ago, and it was a very large amount of work. I can't imagine how much work it would take to switch to LLVM.
- eemax 9y agoThe comparisons in this article are mostly against the high-end Intel core line, but these CPUs support server / enterprise type features like ECC memory, lots of PCI-E lanes, and virtualization features (I think?). Shouldn't Threadripper be compared to Xeons? EDIT: Or rather, what I'm really wondering is what these CPUs lack that AMD's server line (EPYC) have.
- IanCutress 9y agoEPYC has double the PCIe lanes, double the DRAM channels, and will have enterprise level support. Threadripper is classified by AMD as a Ryzen family product, and is consumer focused (or super high-end desktop focused) rather than enterprise focused. TR will be on shelves, EPYC will not. AMD's 16-core EPYC part (the 1P 7351P) is around $750, but supports 2TB/socket and 128 PCIe lanes in exchange for a good chunk of frequency (2.4G base, 2.9G Turbo). Threadripper is also single socket only - most of EPYC is 2P. Though given Intel's pricing, if AMD has the ecosystem, then the mid-range of the Xeon line might migrate to TR/EPYC.
- InTheArena 9y agoWhat I am going to be interested in is this versus EPYC parts. I think the higher clocks are mainly to achieve some of the more insane (and useless) FPS counts for games. If you are willing to ramp down the FPS to a number that your monitor can actually display, it may be better to find a general purpose EPYC MB and chipset, and use that. Especially if homelab / big data / compiling linux/ occasional gaming is you cup of tea.
- minikites 9y agoThere's still plenty of room to grow into VR and/or 120Hz/240Hz monitors at 4k/5k.
- InTheArena 9y agoSure, and PCIe lanes will be key to making that work, not CPU. EPYC has insane capabilities there.
- onli 9y agoResolutions has nothing to do with it. To the contrary: You need less cpu power since you will get your FPS limit from the gpu, not the cpu. Similar for VR: Current cpus are strong enough to get the 90FPS current VR headsets want. 240Hz maybe, but those processors won't be faster in games than a Intel Core i7-7700K, as games don't use that many cores.
- minikites 9y agoSo then what is the original comment referring to?
- onli 9y agoI think that is is comparing Threadripper to other workstation cpus, or it rather explicitly does compare to EPYC. Since Threadripper has a high clock, it might work better in games as well. Parent is right in saying that when adapting expectations, that additional gaming performance is unlikely to be necessary. Reminds me of using one of the Xeon E5-2670 for gaming, as in https://www.techspot.com/review/1155-affordable-dual-xeon-pc/ https://www.techspot.com/review/1155-affordable-dual-xeon-pc....
- jokoon 9y agoA CPU that large reminds me of the famous remark made by Grace Hopper about how light can move 30cm in one nano second, I guess theoretically meaning that CPU could have some kind of maximum size. Of course since current CPU contains cores, it doesn't apply.
- wybiral 9y agoWith all the cores it would still apply to inter-core communication and memory sharing.
- digi_owl 9y agoThere more i read about computer internals, the more i am reminded of the hermetic saying "as above, so below". The layout of a CPU, the layout of a computer internally, and the layout of a network of computers seems to be more and more the same.
- simcop2387 9y agoIt goes even deeper than that. They layout of the circuits at the transister/component level have to deal with this too. Take a look at a motherboard between the cpu and the memory slots, you'll see traces that make weird turns and then back onto them selves. All to make sure the signals end up arriving at the same time (well, as close as is manageable).
- jokoon 9y agoYes, but you can buffer inter core communication, cores don't need to be in sync. I think. I'm not a CPU designer.
- nabla9 9y agoClock distribution is already quite complex in big circuits. It should arrive at the same time everywhere but it does not. You need to add extra components to de-skew them.
- Aardwolf 9y ago
- thoughtexprmnt 9y agoSince the article does refer to these as desktop CPUs, I'm curious what kind of desktop workloads people are running that could benefit from / justify them?
- castratikron 9y agoThis could make a good build machine.
- IanCutress 9y agoIntel likes to market these CPUs to people who 'mega-task'. Video Editing while Gaming while Streaming while Hosting a server while Dealing with encrypted data while Multi-monitor while Contributing to science while while while etc AMD hasn't really declared which market they are after yet. It's likely going to be a big part of the launch event.
- Theodores 9y agoMega task - as in have a hundred tabs open, a dozen Excel spreadsheets plus Outlook. Maybe there will be lots of cores since there is no more Moore's law, 32 core computing will be the new core i5 with 64 core computing being the new i7. Some software might run albeit slowly on older computers that only have 16 cores. In this future the choice of 64 core computing is one of those things like car choice. Obviously we need cars electronically restricted to 155, we would not consider a car that only did 120 or so. There is a theoretical scenario where that vital power is needed but it is not a rational decision based on cost benefit analysis. Therefore you can expect a change over time to where core total becomes marketing.
- floatboth 9y agoHeh, IIRC the "mega-task" thing is very very recent, likely in direct response to AMD upping the core counts with Ryzen. (well, technically FX was 8 core but let's not go there)
- IntelMiner 9y agoI've been debating moving to one for a Gentoo build box Beyond that, I could see highly scaled workloads like video editing that could take advantage of that much raw CPU power
- walkingolof 9y agoBest thing about this is that competition is back (in the high end x86 market) and the winner is the consumer, CPU market have been stale for a while.
- antome 9y agoWhat's even better (for AMD) is that they can now design a single processor, and scale it across their entire lineup from R3(?) to EPYC. This suggests that they could incrementally improve their entire lineup annually, or deliver huge boosts every couple years.
- dis-sys 9y agoAs long as AMD can not match Intel on IPC, such one design fits all approach will always attract attacks from Intel. see the latest example here: http://www.techradar.com/news/intel-disses-amds-new-processors-in-what-could-be-an-epyc-fail http://www.techradar.com/news/intel-disses-amds-new-processo...
- mtanski 9y agoCompetitors will always find ways of attacking each other. In reality in any kind of engineering in the real world there's always trade offs of different approaches. These choices are often made with cost being one of the factors. AMD's trade of is a one size fits all die that can be used in a lot of products quite effectively. And on a relative basis, IPC wise it's really not that far. As a result it can offer this at an attractive price. Intel on the other hand is making a lot of different dies which comes with lower cross core communication latencies. Also, their more expensive / mature process allows for higher Mhz clocks. This comes with a higher premium MSPR for products in the same class. People can figure out what is more important to their use cases and we can all argue about the benefits/downsides of each approach. I would say the market segmentation with AVX512 (different chips supporting different features) is somewhat maddening. Plus a limited use case of HPC software make effective use of that. Most does not.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y ago
- SCdF 9y agoHow do people with many CPU cores find it helps their day to day, excluding people who run VMs, or do highly parallelisable things as their 80% core job loop (ie you run some form of data.paralellMap(awesomeness) all day)? Does it help with general responsiveness? Do many apps / processes parallalise nicely? Or is it more "Everything is 99% idle until I need to run that Photoshop filter, and then it does it really fast"?
- nicktelford 9y agoAs a programmer, being able to run non-trvial parallel builds (e.g. compiling large Scala projects), whilst keeping the machine quite usable for other things is pretty awesome. 5 years ago I'd have struggled to get that out of a desktop. Today, my laptop handles that, barely breaking a sweat.
- daveguy 9y agoBeing able to do big jobs in the background and still use your computer effectively. Run 3 VMs for different platforms and still have a functioning computer. There is a lot of task level parallelization that many cores helps with regardless if any one is optimized. That said, a lot of software is multithreaded these days.
- metalliqaz 9y agoRunning 4 OSes at once (host + 3 VMs) I would hope you have a very quick SSD and lots of RAM, otherwise that CPU isn't going to help much.
- Retric 9y ago64GB of ram is surprisingly affordable assuming you want to run a few VM's on one box. You can also give each VM it's own SSD without spending crazy money. AKA it's far less than the cost of 3 mid range PC's.
- colanderman 9y agoFor me, it's both the "really fast Photoshop filter" (or, in my case, static analyzer run), and responsiveness when I do e.g. a build that I've restricted to use all but one core. Otherwise yes, the cores just sit there idle.
- arcaster 9y agoI'm still waiting for a more diverse set of synthetic and real-world benchmarks. It'll be interesting to see how IPC performance holds up with Threadripper, however I think the most interesting debate will be whether the 1920x or lowest end Epyc CPU are a better buy. Unfortunately, even as an enthusiast $799 is more than I'm willing to spend on a CPU. I'm also still hard pressed to build a Ryzen 1700 System since I can purchase an i7 7700 from MicroCenter for about $10 less than the Ryzen part (and have equal or better general performance with notable better IPC).
- tothepixel 9y agoCinebench scores are fantastic for speculating on how these CPUs will work in the context of 3D rendering/simulations. That personally has me very excited.
- arcaster 9y agoMy only qualm is that purchasing an i7 7700 system in comparison to a Ryzen 1700 system is almost the same price (since I'm buying my CPU from MircoCenter). The use of my desktop is maybe 5% gaming, the rest is software dev and browsing, isn't there still a reason to prefer an IPC advantage for compilers and other system tasks? I mentioned this, because I don't think a 12 core CPU would really give me that much more productivity or value gain than an i7 7700 or Ryzen 1700. I only really need a single linux compatible nVidia GPU, enough cores and ram to comfortably handle 20 browser tabs, an IDE and a relatively hefty docker dev flow.
- opencl 9y agoUnfortunately you don't see a whole lot of benchmarks of dev stuff on CPU review sites. Phoronix at least does Linux compile time. Not sure how representative that is of your "relatively hefty docker dev flow" but it shows the 1700 as 10% faster than the 7700K, which itself has a 17% higher base clock and 7% higher boost clock than the 7700. http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-ryzen-1700&num=4 http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=amd-ryzen...
- jhoutromundo 9y agoOpteron feels o//
- crb002 9y agoAMD needs to come out with a few AVX-1024 instructions for vector ops. Essentially make one core into a GPU that doesn't suck at branching.
- sqeaky 9y agoI think there are some really hard limits on this now. I think the better at branching a chip is the worse it will be at SIMD and vice versa. Barring some crazy breakthrough I don't see what you want coming soon. Which is sad, because I want it too.
- vvanders 9y agoThere's a reason that GPUs suck at branching. Hint: It's because they're good at the vector stuff.
- opencl 9y agoA "GPU that doesn't suck at branching" is basically what the Xeon Phi is intended to be, with 72 AVX512-enabled Atom cores per chip. However it costs over $6000.
- pandaman 9y agoThe reason you think GPUs suck at branching is that they cannot branch on different lanes of an SIMD data (the 'SI' part guaranteed that). GPUs branch just fine between different instructions. There is nothing inherent to GPU making SIMD instructions to behave this way so SIMD instructions in any other PU will do the same.
- balls187 9y agoQuad channel, so you have to install RAM with 4 match sticks at a time?
- jhasse 9y agoIf you don't want to run in Dual or Single channel mode - yes.
- blattimwind 9y agoKinda. Modern (newer than ~10 years) modern controllers are quite flexible, so you can pretty much populate any number of DIMMs in any slots (apart from wrong ordering, though this is not a IMC restriction, rather firmware, for stability). However. Disregarding the recommended populations usually means that the MC can't interleave the channels properly and also must choose other settings in a lowest-common denominator way. This severely reduces the performance of the memory subsystem, which includes cache coherency and all core communication in Zen.
- jhasse 9y agoInteresting, thanks :)
- johnbellone 9y agoIts been awhile since I've built a computer with my own two hands, but either that man's hands are really small or hot damn AMD Ryzen CPU are huge.
- blattimwind 9y agoThis is a HEDT processor that comes in the package of their server processors (up to four dice and eight memory channels, over 4000 pins total). These are large, because there's a lot in them ;) The desktop series has a more usual size.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThis announcement is essentially two Zen CPUs mounted on the same microchip module (MCM) so yes, the package is "huge" relative to previous CPUs.
- NateyJay 9y agoMCM is multi chip module
- losvedir 9y agoFor what it's worth, I interpreted that image to be a still from the announcement video, which from the article: > Today’s announcements, accompanied by a video from the CEO of AMD Dr. Lisa Su So, given that she's an Asian woman, it might be a smaller hand than you were thinking. Nevertheless, it does seem to be a very large component (hence the joke image at the bottom of the article).
- floatboth 9y agoOf course it's her, no one else publicly showed a Threadripper yet :) It is large — 4094 pin socket!
- floatboth 9y ago
- sergiotapia 9y agoI'm waiting for these to launch so I can build a great multi-threaded computer. My Elixir apps are waiting for all these threads! :) Does anyone know if Plex is going to see much benefit transcoding video files on the fly?
- bhouston 9y ago> Does anyone know if Plex is going to see much benefit transcoding video files on the fly? Does the underlying avcodec / ffmpeg support huge thread counts?
- Veratyr 9y agoIt's not ffmpeg that matters here but libx264, which does support multithreading. I ran a quick test on my PC (workstation class Xeon with 6c/12t) and found that with 1/2/4/8/12t it took (wall time) 28.5/14.7/9.7/7.2/6 seconds to encode 10s of video at 1080p. So it is able to take advantage of multiple cores but there are diminishing returns. For Plex I'd really focus on using hardware encoders rather more than anything. NVENC and QuickSync are both widely available and able to do decent H.264/HEVC encodes far faster than any CPU and on a home network you're not really bandwidth constrained so the degree of compression doesn't matter too much. On a mobile network I'd go for Plex's offline optimization.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI really hope the ECC carries through. It irritates me to have to buy a "server" CPU if I want ECC on my desktop (which I do) and it isn't that many gates! Its not like folks are tight on transistors or anything. And on my 48GB desktop (currently using a Xeon CPU) I'll see anywhere from 1 to 4 corrected single bit errors a month. For things like large CAD drawings which are essentially one giant data structure, flipping a bit in the middle of them somewhere silently can leave the file unable to be opened. So I certainly prefer not to have those bits flip.
- xiconfjs 9y ago1-4 corrected errors per month?! This sounds quite bad - which manufactor?
- kpil 9y agoIsn't that more or less in the range expected from background radiation bitflips when having 48 GiB?
- vel0city 9y agoI manage many servers with >=384GB RAM. They maybe detect an error once a year, with several never reporting an error in its life. If I noticed a server reporting errors more than twice a year I'd probably swap its memory, and if that didn't fix the problem I'd probably replace the server.
- StillBored 9y agoDepends on what you mean by "reporting an error". The default configuration for most machines I've used is to silently correct single bit failures unless they hit some threshold. So you actively have to run an EDAC (or similar) driver and poll the error counters. Its only with uncorrectable errors does it generally rise to the level of a full MCE.
- 9y ago
- dis-sys 9y ago$999 list price translates to $1100-$1150 retail price in countries where you have a GST style tax, then you factor in an expensive motherboard plus heat sink, 64GB of RAM, the upgrade is like $2k. the problem is with this confirmed return of competition between Intel vs AMD, I am no longer sure whether it is a good idea to upgrade now as it is basically the first iteration between those two. Are they going to release something even better in 6-12 months time?
- microcolonel 9y ago> Are they going to release something even better in 6-12 months time? In this segment? Almost certainly not. Intel doesn't even pretend to have a competitive product in this category ready for launch in the next 12 months. AMD is releasing one now, so will be delayed about that long.
- musha68k 9y agoWell, the new iMac Pro (8/10/18 core) will start at $5000 - I also feel ever slower development experiences on my MBP and it will be pretty much a solved problem on a 16 core Threadripper workstation. I feel like I can't wait for another iteration (actually don't need to) or the planned December release date for the new iMac Pro... https://www.macrumors.com/roundup/imac-pro/ https://www.macrumors.com/roundup/imac-pro/
- dis-sys 9y agoWow, that 18 core iMac Pro with 4T SSD and 128G ECC RAM could shot up to $15k. I can buy an army of Ryzen at that price.
- wmf 9y agoYes, I would expect new CPUs every year, specifically Cascade Lake-X and Threadripper 2 in 2018 then Cannonlake-X and maybe Threadripper 3 in 2019.
- api 9y agoI did a lot of work with artificial life and evolutionary computation in the early 2000s. Wish we had these chips back then.
- gigatexal 9y agosoon as i have some funds i will be getting one but only if ECC is supported -- what would be even better is if one could do a mild OC on the part but also have ECC
- DonHopkins 9y agoHow long does it take to drip a threa?
- strong-minded 9y agoA simple formula: The 1920X beats the 7920X by a few hundred in Cinebench and a couple of hundred in the pocket. I wonder if the 'Number Copy War' (started with the X299 vs. X399 Chipset) will continue throughout the year.
- mrilhan 9y agoI recently tried to go the AMD/Ryzen route. I like an underdog comeback story as much as the next guy. But be warned: Motherboards that "support" Ryzen do not in fact support Ryzen out of the box. You have to update the BIOS to support Ryzen. How do you POST without a CPU you ask? Who knows? Magic, possibly. I still don't understand how AMD expects their customers to have more than one CPU (and possibly DDR4-2133 sticks) to be able to POST and update the BIOS. I returned everything AMD and went back to safe, good ole Intel. Worked on first try. I'm never getting sucked into AMD hype again. Also, when I went back to return the AMD components to Fry's, the manager said they were aware/used to getting Ryzen returns because of this.
- floatboth 9y agoWhat?! That sounds totally bogus. You don't have to update the BIOS to support Ryzen. Ryzen is the first CPU on AM4. You don't need "DDR4-2133 sticks". Ever. Any DDR4 sticks can run at 2133, that's literally the DDR4 standard, everything above is overclocking. 2133 rated sticks are the cheapest (and worst). I got my R7 1700 and mainboard yesterday. Everything worked on first try. Speaking of DDR4, my 2400 rated (Hynix) sticks overclocked to 3200, with decent timings, even :) (Well, decent for Hynix.) My previous system (overclocked non-K Skylake) couldn't run these sticks above 2450.
- mrilhan 9y agoWhy... why would I lie? What could I possibly have to gain from lying about this? I only have HN karma to lose, which I don't have much to begin with. You can, before simply defending AMD, research and see for yourself that required BIOS updates are indeed an issue. I tried it with an MSI Tomahawk, and an Asus B350 Prime. Had a Ryzen-5-1600 and a Ryzen-7-1700, as well as a pair of DDR4-2133, and DDR4-3000 modules each, and tried every combination, and was never able to post. Switched to Intel CPU and Asus Intel-supporting MB with the same DDR4-3000 RAM and POST'd on the first try. I'm saying that to 'prove' that the other components were fine. I'm glad that it worked out for you, and I wish it had gone smooth for me too. http://www.tomshardware.com/answers/id-3387164/am4-motherboard-ship-ryzen-support.html http://www.tomshardware.com/answers/id-3387164/am4-motherboa... https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/66b7vu/to_all_ryzen_5_owners_did_you_have_to_flash_bios/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Amd/comments/66b7vu/to_all_ryzen_5_... ... so many of these.