20 ms·
As the U.S. fantasizes, the world builds high speed rail
- mc32 9y agoRail is not cheap. It's feasible when we have population density. It would make sense along the DC-Boston megalopolis and perhaps SF-San Diego, maybe some stretch of Texas. It makes little sense in the rest of the country. That said, where it would make sense, like DC-Boston, we definitely should build it out. Build up the cities as the countryside is absorbed (as seen in Japan, and elsewhere in Asia) and let it become viable. Its deployment would definitely affect how cities and other communities grow and also depopulate, so we'd need to anticipate that and prepare for it. Three things China has going for is vis a vis the US: -Pop density -Command economy (gov't can just move things through with little debate, displace 1MM people, if necessary.) -Costs (in labor, materials, regulation, etc.)
- naravara 9y agoThe SF to San Diego or D.C.-Boston corridors alone generate enough economic output to power most countries. It's mind-boggling people append "just" when talking about them like they afterthoughts in the grand scheme of things.
- CamperBob2 9y agoIt's deployment would definitely affect how cities and other communities grow and also depopulate, so we'd need to anticipate that and prepare for it. According to rail advocates, it's a good idea to hardwire your city's transportation infrastructure to fixed locations and routes that may or may not serve the population effectively and economically for decades to come. But only if you're building rail. Roads are right out.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 9y agoHere in Silicon Valley there's a lot of building going on near Caltrain stations. And we have no room to run another highway.
- CamperBob2 9y agoBut the Valley isn't where the "generational failure" referred to in the article is taking place.
- greglindahl 9y agoYour reply didn't look like it was restricted to discussing only inter-city travel.
- Spooky23 9y agoThat's already a busy rail corridor. But guess what? It's falling apart. Millions of people pass through the NYC rail terminals every year, and the big inter-city one is crippled by infrastructure failures and damaged tunnels that connect to NJ. It seems that the NJ government spent Federal $$ provided to fix it on something else. We're living in an age of incompetence.
- enraged_camel 9y agoWell yes, if you build infrastructure and then fail to increase maintenance funding as it ages and usage increases, it's going to get crippled.
- mc32 9y agoAcela is not really high-speed rail. They should build out bona-fide high-speed rail ala Shinkansen. New track, new rolling stock, new propulsion systems, and affordable fares. NYC-Boston should be half of what it is now and they should eliminate all the "classes". It should be simply utilitarian transport.
- Xt-6 9y agoCorruption is probably a thing too
- RobertoG 9y ago"We're living in an age of incompetence." I'm not American, but I doubt it very much. It seems to me, from the outside, so take it with a grain of salt, that the crippled infrastructure thing is politically motivated and working as planned.
- cloverich 9y agoWhat I don't understand -- how is road cheaper? I don't get it -- in Austin TX they are spending years to add a single lane to one of the main highways, along with high walls of thick concrete on either side to help with noise in neighborhood, etc. For all the talk of railway's cost and requiring disrupting existing buildings, we have paved roads criss-crossing all of our residential and commercial districts already. It certainly feels like the same way the government is promoting cars, spread out cities, and suburbia, they could be promoting more densely populated, rail-backed cities.
- calafrax 9y agoRoad is more expensive but a lot more people want to use roads then want to use railroads so it doesn't matter what the price is. It doesn't matter if something is cheaper or more efficient if people don't want to use it. This is like asking why doesn't everyone use Linux?
- jjeaff 9y agoIt's not all about what people want either. Even with a rail system, you still need all the roads. Maybe not as many lanes, but American cities are pretty spread out. You will need a ton of last mile transportation.
- WalterBright 9y ago> in Austin TX they are spending years to add a single lane to one of the main highways We gotcha beat in Seattle, where it took 30 years to build the north I5-I405 interchange. It took only 20 years to build the 8th Street I405 overpass. 25 years are projected for the light rail.
- closeparen 9y agoThe freeways were built in a time when you could realistically eminent-domain and bulldoze your way across the country. We no longer live in that time. Any project involving new rights of way is infeasible because property rights (especially property rights over land you don't own, but sits adjacent to your home) are so much stronger now. Government is promoting cars, spread-out cities, and suburbia because they work so well and people love them so much. Think about how much housing supply would go away if not for the road network. Think about the bare-minimum transportation appliance car. With a private, enclosed space, air conditioning, a comfortable seat, and a radio, it's worlds better as a subjective experience than being inside even a relatively luxurious urban train during the commute rush. Now consider how many tens of thousands of dollars people happily spend on a level of comfort and quality far beyond the bare-minimum Craigslist special. Democratic governments promote and invest in what their citizens like.
- masklinn 9y ago> Rail is not cheap. It's feasible when we have population density. It would make sense along the DC-Boston megalopolis and perhaps SF-San Diego, maybe some stretch of Texas. It makes little sense in the rest of the country. As part of its HSR strategic plan, back in '09 the Obama admin identified over half a dozen regions well within HSR densities and distances (the existing north-east corridor, nothern new england linking to canada, southeast along the coast, the chicago area, the gulf coast, south-east central though Texas, the californian coast and the pacific northwest).
- zionic 9y agoTrains less than 300mph are useless in the US. Either go big (maglev/hyperloop) and meaningfully compete with airlines or forget about it.
- hehheh 9y agoI'd be ok with investing in 200mph rail if we went ahead and bought enough ROW to add faster adjacent rail when the funds/will is there.
- masklinn 9y ago> Trains less than 300mph are useless in the US. That's complete nonsense. HSR is comfortably competitive with plane up to ~750 miles and can probably be stretched to ~900mi. That gives you a lot of interesting regions in the US. No, high-speed train is not useful for linking NYC and LA, but nobody ever suggested that.
- melling 9y agoWhat does Spain have going for it? They have more HSR than the US (2000 miles). No one said we should blanket the country with HSR, but shouldn't the US have a need for at least 2000 miles? We have basically zero. You're doing that thing where you try to explain why it won't work in the US by saying that it won't work everywhere.
- cylinder 9y agoSo it makes sense for "only" a third of the population, yeah, better to not talk about it.
- cryptonector 9y agoI wouldn't call a command economy anything like an advantage. EDIT: Also, lower labor costs are, to some degree, a function of having a command economy (China missed out on a ton of economic growth in the 50s, 60s, and 70s, that would have had it be much wealthier now, for example, and this command economy of theirs can command lower wages too, in part through financial repression, for example).
- mattfrommars 9y agoPeople keep on forgetting the immense size of the continental USA. http://francistapon.com/images/travels/europe/usa/900/TEXAS.jpg http://francistapon.com/images/travels/europe/usa/900/TEXAS....
- mozumder 9y agoThis is a discussion about high-speed rail, not US geography.
- weego 9y agoYeah OK you're super special and no one else has the same problems you do. The irony of that considering the title was not missed.
- dEnigma 9y agoChina isn't all that small either
- mc32 9y agoThey are just as large, but they have 4x the pop. That helps a lot in more ways than one.
- vorg 9y agoIf you adjust the numbers in the graph at the bottom of the article for head of pop in the countries, China's still overshadowing everyone else, but suddenly France, Spain, and Italy tower over the US, and the US is still a flat line at 0.
- naravara 9y agoWho cares about chunks of the country nobody lives in? A high speed rail line to cover the region from LA to the Bay Area or the Eastern Seabord wouldn't be any less a project than when Japan did it. If anything it would be easier since our land isn't all geologically unstable.
- lazaroclapp 9y ago
- armenarmen 9y agoWell, the fact that te government subsidized the automotive and oil industries with the Federal highway act in '56 lead to our deprioritization of rail. Had this not been the case, chances are we'd have European equivalent rail, and the small local trolley systems that dotted americas small and medium sized cities would never have been torn up.
- revelation 9y agoNo no, it's not billions spent on cars and suburbia, it's the size of the country!
- armenarmen 9y agoThe size of the country certainly factors in, no doubt. I'm with you there. I am saying, that had there not been HUGE subsidies for the auto/oil/construction industries in the form of interstate building that we would most likely have a better rails system. That's a fair thing to suppose no?
- melling 9y agoWhen you make up your facts as you're writing, do you consider that someone can simply Google it to find out that you're wrong? http://lmgtfy.com/?q=size+of+China+vs+US http://lmgtfy.com/?q=size+of+China+vs+US China has 14,000 of rail. We have about 20? That's part of the Boston/NYC route that counts as high-speed rail.
- tacoman987 9y agoSarcasm is lost on these people.
- ivan_gammel 9y agoHaha. You should try driving from Moscow to Vladivostok.
- madaxe_again 9y agoMost of that drive is actually ok - there are about 500km of unpaved road en route, and only three or so river fordings. Managed it in a 1988 Merc 190E in eight days, so if that can do it, anything can.
- serhei 9y agoFor those who think it's because of geography / hyperloop is better technology anyways / any other red herring besides Brezhnevian political stagnation: It's not completely implausible that, 30 years from now, most of Europe and Asia are connected by hyperloops while the US has built nothing and Internet commentators are arguing that hyperloop is old news compared to yet-unproven teleportation technology, and anyways the population density of the US doesn't support hyperloops.
- mozumder 9y agoWhat's good about Hyperloop? It's more expensive compared to rail. HSR is more of a more efficient airplane - spacious & can walk around & get a drink.
- serhei 9y agoI'm actually very skeptical about Hyperloop, but it seemed a good way of getting my point across. USA doesn't build stuff not because of technological viability but purely for political reasons.
- hyperbovine 9y ago"purely" is pretty strong. I give you the population density of Earth per ㎢: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_density#/media/File:World_population_density_1994_-_with_equator.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_density#/media/File... (Or if you prefer something more recent, have a look at: http://www.newgeography.com/content/002808-world-urban-areas-population-and-density-a-2012-update http://www.newgeography.com/content/002808-world-urban-areas...) Pretty obvious which areas are ripe for HSR. Except for the mid-Atlantic corridor and arguably coastal California, nothing in the US really is. It's the same thing when people go abroad then come back and complain how backwards cell phone service is here. People really don't appreciate how underpopulated the U.S. is relative to the rest of the world. (Conversely, it's also why we could accommodate practically an unlimited # of refugees compared to Europe, if we really cared to.)
- closeparen 9y agoThe US has a strong inter-city travel network in the airlines. The TSA severely limits its effectiveness, so it could be tempting to build a rail network just to bypass the TSA, but there's no reason to think the same screening procedures won't apply to HSR after the first incident (or just threat).
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- smudgymcscmudge 9y agoThis reminds me of the popularity boost various nosql databases got because it allowed devs to sidestep bureaucracy that had built up around schema changes.
- bsder 9y agoThat's the first useful justification I have ever seen for NoSQL. How in the world did I miss such an obvious thing?
- achamayou 9y agoThere is: you can't easily turn a train into a weapon able to take down any large piece of infrastructure in sight. In fact since all high speed trains are electric, you probably can't get very far before the inevitable power cut.
- cylinder 9y agoWhat does the TSA have to do with me sitting on the tarmac for an hour at even secondary city airports waiting for departure?
- closeparen 9y agoCongestion is just what happens when too many people want to use a system and you're not willing to deny travel to some of them. Congestion absolutely happens on trains. Just look at the New York or San Francisco subways during rush hour. The first and most obvious form is that you'll spend the first few train departures in "line" to get to the edge of the platform, then a couple more for a train you can physically squeeze onto. The more insidious one is that public transit operators respond to crowding by increasing frequency beyond what their signaling technology can support. Even after you make it onto the train, you'll spend most of the journey stopped on the track waiting for the train in front of you to move. You can solve congestion in any transportation system by enforcing a low enough number of simultaneous users, forcing the others to not travel, or use some other means. We seem least willing to do this with trains. Transit authorities are seriously thinking about congestion pricing for freeways, airlines raise prices at popular times, but rail systems are working to attract more ridership even as they collapse under the weight of their already-far-too-high ridership.
- bpodgursky 9y agoIMO electric and self-driving car technology is advancing rapidly enough that investment in high-speed rail is going to end up like landline telephones -- it had a time when it was useful, but countries that missed the boat will end up doing A-OK without them. Rail is convenient, but it will never ever be as convenient as having a car take you where you want to be, carry your kids, and carry your stuff around. As soon as self-driving technology eliminates the hassles of parking and clean solar-electric tech eliminates the environmental concerns, ridership is going to tank on all the fixed train lines. It might be 10-15 years out, but I would be shocked if any of the investments made today in rail ever pay off.
- mc32 9y agoHere they are not referring to intra-city transport. Self driving people movers make sense within a city. Inter-city transportation is a different problem. I think high-speed rail makes a lot of sense. It's energy efficient and land efficient and probably time efficient as well.
- afuchs 9y agoA self-driving car with 1-2 passengers takes up significantly more space than existing public transportation technologies, such as trains and buses. This isn't a problem outside of densely populated places. However, as the density of a place increases, point-to-point transportation become increasingly ineffective. Replacing public transportation with point-to-point self-driving technology in a place like Manhattan, would require building out a ridiculously massive amount of road capacity.
- zionic 9y agoYou're thinking like an engineer, where efficieny trumps all. In the real world people who can will spend money not to be packed in like sardines with people of questionable hygiene. Know what happens when the AC is out on your vehicle? You get it fixed. How about when the AC is out for the 3rd time this month on the bus/train? "Oh well, that sucks, guess I'm going into work sweaty today" Mass transit everywhere I've been in the US sucks. It's so bad only the poor us it, because even the middle-middle class finds it disgusting/inconvenient.
- notadoc 9y agoI wonder if the USA will ever build and modernize its infrastructure? We're still coasting on what was built 50, 60, 70+ years ago. Then you travel to the rest of the developed world, and wow, what a difference in infrastructure.
- protomyth 9y agoThe US picked cargo over people for rail. The US has an amazing logistics system comprising of truck, rail, barge, and air. Some people are working on adding drones. Not having passenger rail was a choice. Automated cars and the potential of Hyperloop might seriously change people's opinion of passenger rail.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- will_pseudonym 9y agoFWIW, automated cars make passenger rail less appealing.
- someguydave 9y agoYes, passenger rail and freight rail don't mix very well. Passenger trains are generally slower and more expensive than airplanes, except maybe through high population density areas.
- protomyth 9y agoScheduling is also problematic, particularly when you have a lot of local restrictions from cities and market changes that require freight rail to increase or just plain harvest.
- tptacek 9y agoHaving just spent a couple weeks driving around Germany and Austria: it's hard, if you haven't done it before, to appreciate just how strong America's road system is until you drive in Europe. German highways are excellent, of course; marginally better than our own (the worst traffic jam I've ever been in was 30 minutes outside of Munich, but, whatever). But the European highway network is sparser than the American network, and once you're off the highway, it's significantly worse (though more scenic, and much more "fun" to drive on.)
- sdiq 9y agoEvery time I hear or read something about the US I realize the country is in many ways far behind Europe. When it comes to healthcare (in terms of accessibility), education (in terms of cost), infrastructure, etc, America seems to be doing much worse than these countries. Yet, ironically, America still leads these countries (and the rest of the world) in most other spheres.
- ensiferum 9y agoKeep in mind that in US all these services that us Europeans think are for the benefit for the society such as health care of education are actually just for the benefit of the private companies who rake in the money while the society foots the bill of these bad policies. But that's what you get when you have a goverment which is for the businesses instead of for the people.
- cylinder 9y agoBut didn't you hear, salaries for programmers and bankers are much higher than in Europe. And GDP per capita!! That's all that matters of course /s
- Scarblac 9y agoThey believe in individualism much more, small government, less solidarity. Which is great for the rich and really bad for the poor. The best of the best in any subject are likely to be on the rich side of the divide, and they flock to the US.
- chroem- 9y agoUnpopular opinion, but I really don't see why we should want high speed rail in the first place. It's slower than flying on a commuter airline, but the tickets cost nearly as much, and it's also enormously expensive to build. Then there's also the issue of throughput and last mile logistics. You're limited to putting people in a few train cars, as opposed to a continuous stream of people on a freeway. Being a high speed train, stops are necessarily few and far between, so once you arrive at the station you still have to figure out how to travel tens of miles to where you really want to go. My perception is that it's a huge money pit for something that's quite frankly inferior to our current infrastructure. We would be much better off improving our current insterstate system.
- fatjokes 9y agoSome of the negatives you're listing are only true in America. In Asia and Europe, high-speed train is much cheaper than train, faster when accounting for security and check-in, and 10x more comfortable. You also don't generally get abused by TSA and airline workers.
- jacquesm 9y agoRail is superior to highways on quite a few dimensions: - faster (200 Km/h and up) - much lower accident per passenger mile - in theory it should be cheaper (it isn't for a variety of reasons, many of those are political) - it allows you to work while you're in motion (much harder in a car or a plane) - more land efficient - connects the centers of cities rather than the outskirts which in many cases removes that last mile problem because the majority of traffic is city-to-city For the United States the situation is better served anyway by comparing rail and air travel, air travel scales better as the distance increases, is (roughly) comparable in cost per ticket and tends to be faster on longer distances.
- CalChris 9y agoRail is mostly used for cargo. Rail is about 4 times more efficient than a truck is fuel wise. Labor wise, more than an order of magnitude. A 100-unit train can carry 10,000 tons whereas a truck is closer to 20 tons.
- ensiferum 9y agoFor americans a train is socialism. They need their V8s for crawling walking speed on the 4 lane highway burning a ton of fossil fuels. Actually the bigger the truck the better since it means freedom (or something). ;-)
- wizardforhire 9y agoI'd love to disagree but my experience tells me otherwise. Several of my mentors are opposed to rail for these exact reasons, although not as bluntly. Rolling coal is a real thing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- zkms 9y agoTo quote a thread about that (cultural ideas around automobiles vs rail) I saw on twitter: "Americans tend to think that there's no way everyone would use trains unless forced to by lack of alternatives. This is projection because their experience with cars is exactly that: forced to by lack of alternatives. Do you think nobody in Japan drives? The country that gave us Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Subaru, Mitsubishi, Suzuki, etc etc, isn't without a domestic market lmao" (https://twitter.com/380kmh/status/879463196284858369 https://twitter.com/380kmh/status/879463196284858369)
- taurath 9y agoGo walk up to someone in LA or Seattle and ask them if they could would they take a train into work instead if it cut the time in traffic down. I'll bet very few people would say no.
- giardini 9y agoWhat's the justification for spending on high speed rail vs roads vs air travel vs doing nothing (Google Car is coming, remember)?
- GrumpyBen 9y agoWill the Google Car drive at 200 mph ?
- modeless 9y agoNo, but it will take you door to door, departing instantly when you're ready and not before, and it won't stop in between unless you want it to.
- pikzen 9y ago*citation needed The congested road network still happens with Google cars.
- giardini 9y agoDoes it, even when cars movements are coordinated and all driving automated? How congested? Regardless I would want to see a cost-justification of high speed rail vs auto vs standard train vs buses, etc.
- thedarkproject 9y agoAnd somehow magically the continuously overcrowded streets and traffic jams don't apply to the Googlr car? Have fun waiting in traffic..
- ams6110 9y agoIn the U.S., President Obama’s initiative was met by Republican governors elected in 2010 who, for reasons that had little to do with sanity, resisted free federal money to fund the completion of intercity rail projects their (Democratic) predecessors had developed It's not insane. Federal money is never "free" it's taken from the people and always comes with strings attached.
- exabrial 9y agoLike it or, this guy speaks the truth
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoIn addition, if the rail project might potentially have a negative operating profit, then it may be rational to refuse it.
- exabrial 9y agoThis sounds like a title written by someone that's never visited anywhere but New York or LA. The USA is very large, and we don't have high population density except for the Eastern seaboard (where rail seems to work pretty well there). Roads are a much better, cheaper, faster, flexible option. We just need a 10x revolution in: storage density, fast charging, or efficiency.
- taw55 9y agoWhat about the logistics industry?
- bsaul 9y agoA big difference between europe and us is also in the fact that people in europe tend to live inside the cities, and not just go there to work. Train is considered faster than plane her in france, because you can go to the trainstation using subway, and board immediately, whereas you need to leave your place 2 hours before your flight. i have the feeling that this advantage would be lost in the us, where people live in suburbs way more, and so any trip starts at least with a 45 minutes drive ( not to mention the fact that parking in an airport is probably more convenient than in a city center).
- michaelchisari 9y ago62.7% of the US population lives in only 3.5% of the land mass. We're not as concentrated in cities as Europe, but we're not all small towners by far. And we're seeing a mass migration to city centers across the country, while rural areas are seeing a depopulation.
- hassancf 9y agoEven third world countries such as Morocco are building rail tracks for bullet trains...
- dghughes 9y agoI envy mainland Europe with its rail system. I wish my region of Canada would build a rail system. What we have is old and mainly was for transporting ore, steel, grain. Even just regular rail not even high speed any speed is preferable in a snowstorm. My region is small and would be perfect for a light rail system mainly because it's got few people scattered over a wide area with no direct route. Bombardier even makes rail cars for many countries so it's a home-grown resource we could use. I think south eastern Canada and north eastern US could have a great interconnected rail system. I'm only 800 km (~500 miles) from Boston but I may as well be on the dark side of the moon. Like NY city before its subway system people were crowded in the city but when rail was expanded people could live in the suburbs and work in the city. I think a US and Canadian rail system would open up travel and trade on the eastern coasts of each country. Day trips to cities you'd never even think of visiting now or not even capable doing so now in a day.
- cylinder 9y agoThe Anglosphere is just becoming a big joke altogether.
- cartercole 9y agoso because every other country is subsidizing the shit out of stuff so should we? Economics drives our country not pipe dreams of people who want to get the taxpayers to foot the bill for their new hotness
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ortusdux 9y agoI still resent Rick Scott's decision to reject federal funds for Florida's high speed rail. It would have been the first high speed rail in the country. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_High_Speed_Corridor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_High_Speed_Corridor
- gokhan 9y agoI'm on a vacation in Italy and just used one this morning from Florence to Bologna with Trenitalia. A lot of positive things: The ride was 35 minutes long, doesn't include any security theater, you can arrive the station 10 minutes before the departure and hop in a couple of minutes, comfortable, roomy, from city center to almost city center, and many more. And the train continued to all the way to Turin, visiting many cities including Milan in 2-3 hours. Cost was 16ish euros, I guess (deducing from a total payment for four people). Doing the same though air travel would add at least a total of 2-3 hours for the whole thing. Don't know about the cost comparison but the user satisfaction is there.
- aerovistae 9y agoFrankly the lack of security frightens me. It's only cool til someone stands up on your car and pulls out an AR. Then suddenly it's "what were they thinking." Happened in France, fortunately with no casualties...
- mvid 9y agoSo should every building have scanners and metal detectors? What makes a train different?
- aerovistae 9y agoYou can't escape a train very easily by comparison to a building.
- s0rce 9y agoYou can't escape a crowded train station, especially when underground or a skyscraper when you are on a higher floor. This type of situation can't be controlled everywhere without constantly living in fear. There just isn't any point in trying and usually the security is pointless theatre anyways.
- martinald 9y agoShould we add security for buses too then?
- rmoriz 9y agoYou can't even compare the population density of France with Germany, hence why always apply the "high speed rail" idea to the US? Image a high speed rail system between large cities but people still have to own and use a car, drive 200miles to/from the next station. Also either the train stops at every small town or it will be an express train that leaves the rural areas behind. IMHO a high speed railway network is not the start but an evolution of an existing regional rail system/public transportation system that acts as a feeder and communter infrastructure. The US lacks those public transpotation systems even in mid-size towns. That's a bigger problem IMHO.
- tptacek 9y agoThis topic comes up routinely on Hacker News, and it's no surprise why: there are a lot of Europeans interacting with a lot of Americans here, and European high speed rail is an enviable asset for the continent. But last time we talked about this, it seemed to me that if you looked into the details, it was clear why we don't have HSR in the US. Even assuming we built a network that operated at Shanghai Maglev speeds, at the distances the network would need to operate, air travel would remain significantly more economical. In a thread 3 years ago, I made a list of the top US cities by GDP, and then broke out the crow-flies ground distances between them: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8713324 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8713324 Of the 55 edges on this graph, only 6 were 700 miles apart or less. Several of those are already served by the Acela. There's a definite advantage to rail over air, in that rail can deposit you right in the middle of the city you're heading to. But that advantage can't make up for the fact that no train is going to compete with a plane for trips between the largest US cities.
- mattkrause 9y agoI'm not convinced that the numbers in your link are quite so conclusive. First, with stops factored in, the Acela makes about 75 mph. This is competitive with driving, not flying. There's a lot of room for improvement right there. Second, I'm not sure that distance between the biggest cities matters. Is there actually a ton of traffic between Philly and Los Angles, for example? You could easily imagine several unconnected networks (SF-LA-SD, for example, along with an upgraded Boston-DC route, or something between Austin, Houston, and Dallas). In a similar vein, you could imagine connecting one major city to a bunch of somewhat smaller ones. For example, Chicago to Madison, Milwaukee, or even Minneapolis. This wouldn't necessarily replace air travel, but it would integrate those cities more tightly and might replace a lot of driving. Madison to Chicago even becomes a (somewhat) reasonable commute!
- tptacek 9y agoAt European rail speeds, a train from Chicago to Minneapolis --- which, as a Chicagoan who likes Minneapolis, I wish existed! --- would take 6-7 hours. A flight from Chicago to Minneapolis takes just an hour and a half, and there are so many of them that catching one is no harder than catching a train. On the list I provided, where do you see major opportunities for us to build out rail? I know that there are some! I just don't think there are many, or that it will ever make sense for us to have a densely connected HSR network like Europe.
- graycat 9y agoHow much money does Amtrak in the US Northeast Corridor make each year, in ballpark, round numbers? $100 million? $1 million? $1?
- twblalock 9y agoThe problems affecting high-speed rail in the US are the same problems that prevent low-speed rail, streetcars, subways, and buses from being more common -- people don't see themselves using such things and so they don't want to pay for them. In the Bay Area, the Caltrain commuter train runs from San Jose to San Francisco, through the downtown areas of most major cities in between. It is currently so popular that it is significantly over capacity every day. Yet it is still a constant political battle to get funding to improve the system, even though the Bay Area is one of the most educated and politically liberal parts of the country, where support for public transit is higher than many other places. Sometimes I think we would have much more transit funding overall if we set aside part of the transit budget to send Americans to other countries on vacation, so they will return knowing how good public transit can actually be.
- tptacek 9y agoI do not think this is true. I think people have an easier time seeing themselves in an Acela car than they do in a Jetblue seat --- which is part of why the Acela is so popular. People don't drive from DC to NYC so they can signal their independence. Pretty much, they don't drive from DC to NYC at all. Where HSR is feasible and built out in the US, it gets used. The problem is, HSR isn't feasible for the most economically important routes in the US. You can get from London to Paris in 3 hours on a train, and from Paris to Frankfurt in about 5. Almost as a rule, the most economically central European cities are closer to each other by rail than the most important American cities are --- excepting the Eastern Seaboard, where we have rail --- by air.
- jamespitts 9y agoWe have a serious problem with retrogradism in this country. A large number of people are suffering from changes outside of their control, and they are disconnected from those at the forefront of social and technological progress. Many of these people have lost trust in the system, and even in progress itself (outside of progressions that are accessible and affordable such as games or phones). As a result, there is little enthusiasm for investing in major improvements to systems or building any major infrastructure enabling progress. "High speed rail? What is in it for me? I work part time and can't afford these medications. I want the life I used to have back." Perhaps a good place to start is understanding the experience of people who are voting for an imagined retrograde society. This can be difficult for those of us who have had the privilege of a better education, or better opportunities in the cities, or even all of our needs met as we build what we build. The privileged must try, and must succeed in understanding what is happening here. This is because the votes of those within what is essentially a ghetto lead to major consequences, including underfunding high speed rail. The result isn't just ridiculously under-qualified and intellectually isolated politicians that are easy to make fun of. The underprivileged will keep voting in this way until their concerns are answered (or not). We at the technological forefront know more about what needs to be done in terms of advancing progress, possibly even to the point of solving half of all social problems. However, we must also pay heed to the immediate, harsh reality of the people left behind. Our environment -- natural, political, or infrastructural -- depends on this. If the ethical demand to listen and react appropriately to the suffering of others does not convince us to strongly act, watching the destructive results of their votes should.
- laretluval 9y agoI would not have much interest in greater understanding between me and someone who calls my desires "retrograde".
- jamespitts 9y agoThat is assuming the term retrograde is a bad thing; often it is not. I might have chosen a better word, and am curious if there is one. This retrograde notion is based on a lot of evidence and personal experiences. For example, in a conversation I had with someone a few years ago I asked what is wrong with the way things are. That person told me he wants things to be like the way they were in the 1950s, referring to the sense of community, job opportunities, and social mores.
- ptr_void 9y ago'Why Trains Suck in America' : https://youtu.be/mbEfzuCLoAQ https://youtu.be/mbEfzuCLoAQ
- graycat 9y agoA guess: Now that Trump is talking about "infrastructure", the passenger train people are coming out of the woodwork again looking for big subsidies from the US Federal Government. Some years ago, for a while I was a prof in Ohio. Well, there was a group all hot on connecting all the Rust Belt cities -- Chicago, Detroit, Cleveland, Columbus, Dayton, Cincinnati, Muncie, Akron, Indianapolis, South Bend, Youngstown, Toledo, etc. with passenger trains. They were really hot. Look, guys, the US had a very good passenger rail network. Could go by train from one tiny crossroads to any other, all by train. And people did that. But soon that whole thing was killed off by, and may I have have the envelope please? Right, the Model T, etc. Private cars. A lot of the tracks grew up with weeds. After WWII, soon, for trips up to 1000 miles, say with the whole family, people would rather just take the family car. Just after WWII, the passenger trains were still running, but, no thanks, people would rather take the family car, e.g., from Florida all the way to Grandma's near Buffalo, NY. As soon as I got married, my wife and I went to her family farm for Christmas, 900 miles, by car, car packed with stuff. Plane? Train? Bus? No thanks. Gee, guys, now with the TSA, no way will I want to take a car full of luggage, toys, Christmas presents, etc. past the TSA. No way. For me, for anything like family travel, public mass transportation, no matter how fast, how roomy, how cheap, how safe, due to the TSA and all the luggage handling problems, lack of privacy, being legally under the thumb of a lot of people, rules, bureaucrats, various cases of police, being subject to being forced to wait in my seat for four hours while whatever is going on, etc., the answer is no, no way, never, don't bother to ask again. There are a lot of people and projects there in the woodwork eager to come out with lots of publicity, reasons, and excuses and eager to scarf up Federal subsidies. A LOT of people/projects. Clearly there is a whole industry of this stuff. They are always back in the woodwork, and as soon as they smell money, and they are good at smelling money, out they come, big publicity drives, etc.
- mnm1 9y agoI think it's too late for rail. Yes, we lost a generation of development in rail. We also lost a generation of development for pretty much every other transportation industry, and thus our whole infrastructure. The article briefly touches on it. Transportation in general hasn't been a priority for at least thirty years. I'm not worried about rail. Rail is dead in the US and has been for a long time. I'm worried about our highways. That's our infrastructure core, without which the US cannot survive. Not building rail projects in the US is pretty normal and on par for the downward trajectory we're on. Not building and maintaining highways and bridges shouldn't even be an option. While some upper-class, rich people can afford to live in our cities, they are a huge minority and most people rely on cars and highways. Outside of a couple of cities, good city public transportation simply doesn't exist in the US and won't exist anytime soon. I think we need to be realistic as to what is possible in the US. High speed inter-city rail isn't possible. And even if it is, can it compete with the price of plane tickets? Doubtful. Giving our cities good public transportation isn't possible. It may have been possible in the past, but not the last few decades. Having room inside a city for all who want to live there most certainly isn't possible. Building roads and bridges has now become almost impossible in many places. I have to wonder what is the plan for the US transportation infrastructure. As far as I can see, the plan is to let it deteriorate until it doesn't exist anymore. At least in that sense, it's consistent with education, social programs, and the rest of our crumbling society.
- wbl 9y agoIt's possible. We just don't wanna.
- thisrod 9y agoThere is another question here. How the hell did the French build 300km of high speed track, going through central Paris, for only 10 billion dollars? If Australia could do that, the cost benefit analysis on Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane would look very different. Melbourne to Sydney is worth doing now, though it's a close thing. But the benefits come as time savings for rich businessmen, and Australia told them that if they really wanted it they could pay for it themselves.
- wluu 9y agoThey really need to build high speed rail across the east coast of Australia. We've talked about it in this country for so long and yet nothing is happening.
- thisrod 9y agoThe problem is that it will cost 100 billion dollars (!), and it really isn't clear that it's worth that much. That's where the French seem to have some magical advantage.
- ravenstine 9y agoWhen other countries play a bigger role in securing the global economy with military might, maybe we can start building a high speed rail infrastructure. Otherwise, I don't see an actual need for it. It would be an improvement, for sure, but all I see is people looking at much smaller countries and assuming that America is stupid for not doing everything they do.
- pmurT 9y agoEven if we had high-speed rail the gov would regulate it to death like everything else - they'll make it just as painful as flying. Imagine the TSA salivating for the mission creep.
- faragon 9y agoMay be the US is doing a wiser thing. I live in Spain, where high speed train was pushed in the era of the housing bubble, and in my opinion is not that big deal, except for communicating the two bigger cities of Spain (Madrid and Barcelona). Lower capacity routes are on deficit, and I'm very skeptical about their long term viability.
- mickronome 9y agoSeveral comments in this thread almost appear to be constructed to prove the author right in how the debate derails. It's not much of my concern, but still I couldn't help to notice something that felt like an unusual occurrence here on HN, or maybe I'm simply seeing ghosts. I am rather tired to be honest! Anyway, my flawed observation: Some sort of deadlock where instead of discussing how to improve the situation, the discourse get stuck in debating which is the correct reason for not doing anything, instead of trying to come up with improvements? Several times arguments are made that a non existent technology will make current investment pointless in the future, so no investment should be made now. Isn't that the argument implied by the title of the article? Obviously, it could be true that future inventions would make it pointless, but that certainly is not something you can calculate/know off the cuff, if it's even worth speculating about. Building a high speed rail network take long enough time that all those possible avenues can probably be explored in excruciating detail before the first shovel hits the dirt a decade from now if everything moves quickly. People are sceptical towards hyperloop, which is understandable in many ways. But what if it would work? Wouldn't it be worth investing quite a lot of money simply to figure out if it could work? Obviously it could potentially only solve a very specific part of the transportation puzzle, but one that could have quite some positive effects. Positioning cars and aircraft as more-or-less the only viable ways of communication for the foreseeable future sounds like an awfully odd position to me, even for a very sparsely populated country. While, the correct solution might not be high-speed rail, some variation of it it could still be the best solution in several instances. Maybe someone would come up with something like a tethered electrical ground effect aircraft/train which could take advantage of the sparse population if they knew there were money to be made. Instead of massive resistance and cartloads of red tape ?
- scythe 9y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brightline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brightline appears to be for real in Florida and the Acela now carries a majority of traffic on some parts of the Boston-NY corridor and service to Washington. Texas has much cheaper gas and stronger car culture than anywhere in Europe or Canada. It's really just California that's lagging behind expectations; the other two projects could be better. And Florida / Texas / California / Northeast wraps up all of the locations in the US that are viable for high-speed intercity passenger rail. The only truly underserved corridor in North America is Toronto - Detroit/Windsor - Chicago, but most people don't even recognize it as a possibility because it crosses a border. So instead of "what's wrong with the US" we should ask "what went wrong with CA HSR?".
- flimflamvir 9y agoThe first one went OK, the second collapsed the Japanese rail industry. All require huge subsidies. America is smart!
- anjbe 9y agoI’m going to share my experience with commuter (not high‐speed) rail: the New Mexico Rail Runner. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trainroadrunner.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Trainroadrunner.jpg The Rail Runner was built in 2006 primarily due to Governor Bill Richardson’s efforts. It essentially covers two cities, Albuquerque (~500,000 people) and Santa Fe (the capital, ~70,000 people), which are already connected by Interstate 25. I love trains; I recently took Amtrak to LA and back. And I love the Rail Runner. It’s my favorite way to get to Santa Fe by far. Once I arrive, being without a car is not too bad: Santa Fe is a fairly walkable city, Albuquerque has a decent bus system, and a bicycle (which I can take on the train) makes things a lot easier. The big problem with the Rail Runner is its cost. Richardson originally was very vague about the cost, and initial estimates were (it turns out, a wildly optimistic) sub–$100 million in initial capital. The state took out a loan to pay for construction. The total cost is now estimated to be about $800 million. Currently the state Department of Transportation pays about $25 million a year on the loan; as currently structured, that will slowly increase to $35 million per year until 2025 and 2026, where the payments jump to $110 million (per year!). New Mexico is currently in a budget crisis (not just due to the Rail Runner). (http://fortune.com/2016/12/04/new-medico-budget-crisis/ http://fortune.com/2016/12/04/new-medico-budget-crisis/) There have been special legislative sessions called this year to sort things out, and there’s conflict between all three branches of our state government. I have no idea where the DOT will find $80 million in their budget the next ten years, at least not without serious cuts to our already underfunded highways. Then there are the operating costs. This is “not so bad.” Revenues only cover about 10% of operating expenses. But at least the rest is covered (at the moment) by county taxes, federal grants, and payments for use of the track by Amtrak and BNSF. I’ll be cynical: my personal belief is that Richardson intentionally hid the costs and pushed the Rail Runner as a short‐term publicity stunt for his 2008 Presidential run, without a care as to what it would do to the state ten years later. It is very like him. (Don’t even get me started on the spaceport.) https://www.abqjournal.com/news/state/602848nm10-16-07.htm https://www.abqjournal.com/news/state/602848nm10-16-07.htm The legislature sponsored a study to determine the feasibility of selling the Rail Runner (https://lintvkrqe.files.wordpress.com/2015/11/final-hm-127-study-final-report-november-4-2015.pdf https://lintvkrqe.files.wordpress.com/2015/11/final-hm-127-s...). It concluded that nobody would be willing to buy it due to low revenues, high operating costs, and the plethora of exclusivity agreements that would need to be renegotiated (with BNSF, Amtrak, the pueblos, the federal Department of Transportation…). And selling it wouldn’t help since it wouldn’t absolve us of the requirement to pay off the debt. At this point I don’t foresee a solution other than refinancing the loan (again) to avoid those $100 million cliff payments, at the cost of further interest payments. Like I said, I love the Rail Runner, and I really want to see it (or passenger rail of some sort) succeed in New Mexico. I do think the way the Rail Runner was handled — intentionally hiding the costs and having no concrete plan to cover operating costs — is completely unconscionable. Not that it has to operate at a profit; after all, highways lose money too. But the Rail Runner loses so much money, and we’re already a poor state. It is valuable to connect New Mexico’s capital with its largest city. I just feel like there has to have been a better way to do it. I hope the proposed train from Las Cruces, NM to El Paso, TX (http://www.lcsun-news.com/story/news/local/2017/06/28/study-proposed-rail-service-las-cruces-el-paso-would-cost-120-m-430-m/436728001/ http://www.lcsun-news.com/story/news/local/2017/06/28/study-...) will learn from the mistakes made with the Rail Runner. Whew. After all that, I’m curious: what successful rail projects have you seen, and what makes them successful?
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoHigh speed rail doesn't actually provide the eco-benefits over planes that proponents think it will. And high speed rail is only competitive against planes and cars at distances less than 500mi. Unfortunately the US is too sparsely populated and the big cities outside of the coastal corridors are too spread out for high speed rail to be economically and ecologically sensible. http://www.newsweek.com/why-high-speed-trains-dont-make-sense-74107 http://www.newsweek.com/why-high-speed-trains-dont-make-sens...
- mieses 9y agoRail is a bad idea wrapped in shiny engineering. Read Randal O’Toole http://ti.org/antiplanner/ http://ti.org/antiplanner/.
- ableton 9y agoInterestingly a private company is tying to build a high speed train from Dallas to Houston tx. The great thing is that it would be privately owned so if it's a flop taxpayers arent on the hook.
- d--b 9y agoSomething that is never debated when we talk about high speed train in the us: would it bring development the same way the iron horse brought development in the 19th century? I mean, yes the US is sparsely populated (in the middle), but isn't it also because it doesn't have fast and easy transport system? Wouldn't a high speed line between San Fran and Portland develop the very rural regions of Northern California? High speed train also means high speed cargo transport, isn't that driving some economical development? These are not rhetorical questions, i seriously have no idea of the answers, but it would be nice to see what experts think about that.
- a_imho 9y agoFrom the little data I gathered, trains/mass transit seems to be much more efficient than cars regarding greenhouse emissions. YMMV depending on your stance on climate change, but I find it sad people dismissing rails so easily in this thread.