25 ms·
Please Make Google AMP Optional
- JeremyBanks 9y agoGoogle search doesn't really have many options like this, and I'd be shocked if they added this one. But given the URL format, it should be trivial for a browser extensions to rewrite links or requests from AMP pages to the original. I bet it already exists.
- limeblack 9y agoAnd how do you plan to do this when no mobile browsers suppport extensions?
- krrrh 9y agohttps://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Mindwipe 9y agoSamsung's browser does, and has reasonable marketshare. With a few tweaks iOS content blockers could achieve this, and I have to wonder if Apple are considering it.
- omot 9y agoI never really understood why google amp is bad. Can anyone explain the reason why people think its ethically bad?
- zakk 9y agoNot really an expert, but I don't see any good in strengthening Google's monoculture.
- rak00n 9y agoIf that's the argument everyone should boycott all Google products.
- tajen 9y agoPlus pageviews are done on Google's servers, so Bing doesn't know which website has many views and which doesn't.
- esrauch 9y agoHow does Bing know it for non-AMP views?
- tajen 9y agoYou're right - Bing can't. Google knows a website's pageviews because it can cleverly cross information between the search engine, Google Analytics and Google Map's by-foot frequentation of shops (for shops and customers with tracking allowed). I'm just underlining that not owning a good share of all 3 of those may make it much harder for future competitors to enter the market.
- epistasis 9y agoI'm trying to imagine the uproar if Apple had done AMP instead of Google. Somehow AMP has some staunch defenders, but everything, and I mean everything about how it's been approached has felt very anti-web and pro-Google. The overall concept may be sound, but the implementation, and the inability to escape it, has significantly hurt my opinion of Google. In fact, I no longer use Google's search because of it.
- endorphone 9y agoDo you think there would be an uproar? Apple introduced reading mode, built-in content/ad blocking, etc. AMP actually fits in the profile of Apple -- prioritizing a fast, usable solution. This author notes that they "feel bad" about consuming AMP content. Which is extremely weird given that content creators intentionally volunteer their content to AMP (aside from this user who got famous claiming that Google was stealing their content because they had enabled a Wordpress plug-in haphazardly). If Google blacklisted non-AMP content, or even just deranked it, sure there's an argument, but as of yet this notion that it's some content theft is quite strange. Google's intention with AMP is obvious, and obviously not anti-web: Facebook is becoming a primary medium where users are accessing a lot of content. I personally read all news via Facebook now, where they've integrated it heavily with a built-in browser and now instant articles (Facebook's AMP). Compared to this, the traditional web is just an obnoxious mess, not because of the web but because of the abuse that AMP restricts.
- bo1024 9y ago> If Google blacklisted non-AMP content, sure there's an argument, but as of yet this notion that it's some content theft is quite strange. Doesn't Google already admit to prioritising AMP pages in search results?
- endorphone 9y agoThus far it is purportedly not a ranking factor. https://moz.com/blog/google-amp-search-results https://moz.com/blog/google-amp-search-results https://searchenginewatch.com/2016/07/06/is-google-amp-a-ranking-signal/ https://searchenginewatch.com/2016/07/06/is-google-amp-a-ran... [just to be clear, just because you read it in some HN thread doesn't make it true. Let's see a single citation that it actually influences ranking]
- limeblack 9y agoSo another article was posted a couple weeks ago about AMP. One advantage I have seen is that you can get around intranet blocking sites if they support AMP. Besides obviously speed this is the only advantage I have found.
- sintaxi 9y agoI suggest stop using google search altogether. https://duckduckgo.com/ https://duckduckgo.com/ is an excellent search engine and its trivial to make a google search via `!g` prefix when you are not finding what you are looking for.
- 65827 9y agoI moved off of gmail a few months ago, pretty happy about that but man duckduckgo fucking suuuucks. Really wish there was a nonprofit (with a strong privacy policy) wikipedia like .org solution that provided good results.
- Twirrim 9y agoWhat problems are you running in to? I've been using duckduckgo at work for just over a year now (took a change of job as an ideal time to try a complete switch in search engine too), and it has been excellent. I've been getting almost as good results as I do from google on even from some fairly vague terms, and comparable to Google when I give it explicit text to search for. Unlike Google it also seems to pay a lot more attention to searching for what I'm asking for, instead of trying to play guessing games.
- floatboth 9y agoDDG does kinda suck at finding specific programming things sometimes. The results are just not as good for the more obscure and rare stuff.
- takeda 9y agoThis is because Google also tries to build a profile for you and serves different results based on that, while DDG will return the same thing for the same keywords to different people. For searches in specific domains it is better to use bangs. For example prefixing with !py shows results from python manual. Here's more about it: https://duckduckgo.com/bang https://duckduckgo.com/bang
- 9y ago
- 0x0 9y agoAMP is bad and anyone who's invested in it should feel shameful for making the internet a worse place.
- PunchTornado 9y agoOn mobile I click only on AMP because it is fast.
- adventurer 9y agoI'm not sure I would go that far but I've given up on Google personally, though. Yahoo search is ok. Firefox's mobile UI isn't as good but I'm sticking with it. Email and Photos is pretty hard to get away from. Hopefully I'll be fully out some day in the near future.
- lukejduncan 9y agoIsn't yahoo search just bing repackaged?
- adventurer 9y agoIt's powered by Bing
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- izacus 9y agoInternet being turned into a shitty place by bad developers and advertisers is why AMP exists in the first place.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoYou just said "Jimmy pissed in the pool, so who cares if Timmy shits in it?"
- 9y ago
- wbc 9y agoanyone from the project? wanted to test out but it looks like the create link is dead: https://www.ampproject.org/docs/create/ https://www.ampproject.org/docs/create/
- godot 9y agoI went through the ampproject.org homepage and reached this docs/tutorial link: https://www.ampproject.org/docs/tutorials/create https://www.ampproject.org/docs/tutorials/create Seems like the link you found is outdated.
- plasma 9y agoLike the article, I often dismiss AMP and visit the original, because I want the latest content - AMP is cached and so for sites like reddit the content is out of date.
- wmf 9y agoThe author's argument against AMP comes down to "I don’t know why I do it, but for some reason it just doesn’t feel “right” to me to consume the content through the AMP. It feels slightly off". This is... not a strong argument. The AMP saga has pretty clearly shown that users care about content while Web developers only care about URLs and what goes over the wire. This is a huge disconnect. It doesn't help that many Web developers show no empathy for the users' viewpoint. Ultimately it probably is easier for Google to add an opt-out to appease a very small, very vocal minority than to educate them that the URL doesn't matter.
- emodendroket 9y agoThat's neither here nor there. Wanting the ability to turn it off is reasonable.
- ehsankia 9y agoYou're being downvoted but you're absolutely right, this article is just weak and it's only popular because it voices a popular opinion, but does a very bad job at justifying it. I fully agree that it should be optional and people who dislike it should be allowed to disable it. But as you mention, the author provide absolutely no real argument other than "it feels wrong". All user studies so far show that it's a net positive, and I'd rather stick to real data than feelings or anectodes. I personally love it, but I also agree that those who don't should be allowed to disable it.
- akras14 9y agoThank you for valid criticism. I've added the following to the post. Hope it clears up my point of view a bit better. Some people expressed a valid criticism that just saying “doesn’t feel right” is not good enough. While I agree, I don’t have any solid data to back up my argument. I believe AMP (to some extent) is a hack on top of existing browsers and the Web, to create a faster in-browser “browser”. As a result a number of small things (scrolling etc) don’t work on my iPhone as I would normally expect. Considering that this post received over 1000 up-votes on Hacker News, making it one of the top 300 posts of all time, leads me to believe that I am not alone.
- vultour 9y ago> AMP took off. Over two billion pages are using AMP I don't think I've ever seen an AMP-enabled website, I certainly never noticed any buttons suggesting I visit the original website.
- mattmanser 9y agoOnly works on Chrome.
- vultour 9y agoOh that makes sense, I've always had iPhones and never had a need to switch from Safari.
- Viper007Bond 9y agoThat's simply not true. I get it all the time in Safari on iOS.
- Shorel 9y agoAlso on Opera.
- timdorr 9y agoIt targets mobile browsers (the M stands for Mobile in AMP), so you won't see them on desktop. But if you search on a mobile device, you'll get this for the OP: https://www.alexkras.com/please-make-google-amp-optional/amp/ https://www.alexkras.com/please-make-google-amp-optional/amp...
- frankydp 9y agoIsn't AMP just an RSS reader for the entire internet? If they solved the URL issue somehow(even if faking the address bar), and had original and AMP links in search; it would probably reduce the antiAMP argument quite a bit. Which both seem to be just UI issues.
- tyingq 9y agoHijacking right and left swipe and the back button are also issues. Google's attitude that it's "your page" despite the URL and header is complete BS. They clearly hijack it for their own benefit.
- MBCook 9y agoI CANT STAND sites that do that. At a minimum it's frustrating because I tend to hit it accidentally. Then there's the infuriating fact that it messes with the system back/forward gestures on iOS. Of course every website does something different so it's not really something you can actually learn to use. Worst of all I was on the website the other day where I couldn't use pinch to zoom without it moving me to a different page. It was literally impossible to zoom into the content. I can't stand all these things where websites seem to try to invente the features that are already built into mobile phones. "Will make a bar that makes it easy to share this!" I can ALREADY share things easily on my phone. And it doesn't waste 10% of my screen at all times. Also, I can configure at the way I want.
- Aaargh20318 9y ago> Isn't AMP just an RSS reader for the entire internet? No, AMP is basically WAP 3.0. A crippled, baby version of the internet invented because most Android devices are too slow to offer a decent browsing experience otherwise. Which is fine for the people who need it, but Google has to stop forcing it down everyone else's throat.
- quadrangle 9y ago> this jeannie is firmly out of the bottle It's "genie"
- abrowne 9y agoI've never actually seen AMP "in the wild". Is it because my only mobile browsing is with Firefox on Android?
- floatboth 9y agoYeah, same. Firefox Nightly Android + DuckDuckGo, but sometimes I do use Google, still haven't found an AMP page.
- abrowne 9y agoI do use Google, although I don't search for news much. I usually find NYT, Guardian etc articles from their homepages.
- callahad 9y agoThat's because Google sniffs Firefox's user agent and serves it an older, less featureful version of Google Search. One that doesn't support AMP. Spoofing Firefox's ua-string to appear as Chrome will get you the full Search experience, including AMP.
- johnsmith21006 9y agoBut according to some on here a no AMP response with FF is better as no AMP. Which is it? Personally prefer the faster speed with AMP.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kuschku 9y agoGoogle intentionally serves to Firefox a massively limited version of Google search. Most search features are completely removed, and this also includes AMP. Others are search filters, for example.
- chinathrow 9y ago
- niftich 9y agoGoogle Search on Mobile is no longer a web search engine that hyperlinks to the resulting page, but rather an search-integrated newsreader that loads itself when you click on a result that's marked with AMP. This is understandably a big change from how things used to be, but it isn't going to get better anytime soon. After all, most people on mobile spend their time inside apps, probably from some Google competitor like Facebook. Within these apps, they click on links, which increasingly load inside webviews; the framing app collects info on where people go, and uses this to sell targeted advertising. Facebook is a king in this space, and is now the second largest server of internet display ads, after Google. Google's assault on Facebook's encroachment is twofold: drive people to Google's apps like the Google Now Launcher (now the default launcher on Android) or the Google app present in older versions of Android and available for iOS, and deploy the same content-framing techniques from their own search engine webpage on mobile user-agents, where the competition is most fierce, and they can also position it as legitimate UX improvement -- which, to their credit, is largely true, as bigpub content sites on mobile were usually usability nightmares and cesspits of ads. I understand that the author and quite a few others are peeved at this behavior and that there's no way of turning it off. But it's really not in Google's best interest to even offer the option, because then many people will just turn it off, encouraged by articles like the author's own last year where he was caught off-guard and before he gained a more nuanced appreciation for what's really going on. The bottom line is this: Google is inseparable from its ad-serving and adtech business -- it is after all how they make most of their money -- so if you are bothered by their attempts to safeguard their income stream from competitors who have a much easier time curating their own walled garden, you should cease using Google Search on Mobile. There are other alternatives, who may not be as thorough at search, but that's the cost of the tradeoff.
- bitmapbrother 9y ago>Google Now Launcher (now the default launcher on Android) This is not the default launcher on Android. Each OEM has their own launcher. It's also not even the default launcher in AOSP for obvious reasons.
- ShellGh0st 9y ago"on mobile" these days is a device with a quad core, 3GB of RAM, and a 1080p + screen. I don't want your stupid "mobile" website that doesn't work, your cut-down "optimized" walled-garden product. I just want the normal web, in all its glory.
- learntofly 9y agoI use an older iPhone as my primary internet device when at home. From google news, the top hits are served through amp and I lose about 1/10 of my screen area to a pointless blue "bar" underneath safari's address bar. This loss of screen space is the only reason I object to amp.
- andars 9y agoI also use a iPhone that is a few years old. My experience has been that Google sends me to AMP pages in Safari and scrolling literally doesn't work. It just does that springy thing (as if there is no more content) on both top and bottom.
- j1vms 9y agoWhat some may fail to see is that the Web's success in the smartphone/mobile era is not yet secure. Both Facebook and Apple, among others, have vested interest in treating the Web as competitive threat. I believe AMP was Google's response to Facebook's Instant Articles. Although there is much to be concerned about Google's ever-expanding reach into the daily life of a good portion of the planet, I think web proponents have more to fear from the likes of FB, Apple, and others appearing on the horizon. These companies are mostly succeeding at meeting current UX expectations (performance, standardization, ease-of-use), and in doing so they are capturing eyeballs away from the web. It's possible some of those who have left for these walled gardens may not return.
- makecheck 9y agoBe sure to structure your Google searches as "g!" searches to DuckDuckGo and AMP effectively disappears with the same set of search results.
- ShellGh0st 9y agoI switched to DDG and I couldn't be happier. I !g maybe 5% of the time.
- robin_reala 9y agoOnly because Google haven’t turned on AMP results for encrypted.google.com. It’s presumably only a matter of time until they do.
- terrestrial 9y ago!g has been my exclusive portal to Google for years (also on mobile). I never understood what all the rage was about until I went to try it in the "normal" Google. This is the first time I've seen that "lightning" icon. Wow. So that's how it feels like to be a "lucky 10 000". crawls back under stone
- robin_reala 9y agoAbsolutely, my !g usage will drop right off when Google decide to add in their other SERP ‘functionality’.
- grizzles 9y agoI posted an alternative solution. https://github.com/electron/electron/issues/8534 https://github.com/electron/electron/issues/8534 The ticket was closed a few days ago. People dislike stuff like AMP, but we are probably stuck with it, there just isn't much interest in alternatives.
- andy_ppp 9y agoI mean, if you take AMP to it's logical conclusion why should Google allow anyone to host their own webpages when Google can host them all better and faster.
- dragonwriter 9y agoThe point of AMP is everyone can host their own pages, and anyone who wants to can host their own AMP cache. So, no, your description isn't taking AMP to it's logical conclusion, it's extrapolating a distortion of AMP.
- tangue 9y agoAMP has been created for product managers. Everybody in a project knows that slow and bloated pages hurt users, but business requirements are making it impossible to do otherwise. Google AMP solves this problem, in an authoritarian way (hence the outrage), by defining what's good and bad for the Internet. Marketing has taken the lead in corporate websites projects to the detriment of the end-users, AMP puts the user in the center.
- epistasis 9y agoAs user, AMP makes my life hell. It made me change nearly two decades of search engine loyalty because Google decided to embrace extend and extinguish. Screw those assholes for breaking the back button, accidentally scrolling to the side, and URLs. I mean, I hate outlook and office with a passion, but the AMP team has somehow produced something even worse: take a monopoly and forced a terrible UI and experience in a huge number of users. Every memeber of the team should be thinking of how they can spin their time at Google as being not related to AMP. Such crap, and such a bad direction for the Google experience.
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoExactly. I read a good article where Google is basically admitting to being "bad cop", in other words product managers and devs often try to push back against "please just add my one more shitty ad and pixel tracking library" from marketing and business teams, but AMP gives them the power to just say "sorry, that's not technically possible with AMP".
- dabber 9y agoI haven't read through the comments here yet but my initial impression of the article is 'ha, I was literally thinking this today'; because I was. AMP is a little heavy handed for my tasteS. Another instance of HN being on the same wave length I guess.
- PaulHoule 9y agoUse bing?
- dabber 9y agoI think you meant DuckDuckGo ;)
- godot 9y agoThere's a lot of complaint about Google AMP and Facebook Instant Articles, e.g. walled garden, anti-open-web and whatnot. Here's something simpler from a non-developer, average-consumer point of view. I recently began taking BART to work daily (new job). For those who don't know, BART is Bay Area's subway system, and (at least on the east bay side) cell reception is notoriously spotty. When I'm on the train, which includes 2 hours of my day everyday (unfortunately), I'd be browsing on say Facebook, and look at links that my friends post. Instant articles almost always load successfully (and quickly) and external links to actual sites almost always fails to load or loads insanely slowly. Yes, when you're at home or in the city with good mobile reception, these things make no sense and you'd rather hit the original site directly. Give them their ad revenue, etc. to support them, right. But for the average consumers who actually have problems like slow internet (like the average joe who rides public transportation and wants to read on their phone), things like AMP and Instant Articles actually help. I can only imagine outside of silicon valley (where I live), how much more significant of a problem slow internet/slow mobile data actually is. P.S. I don't work at Google or Facebook, and I know this sounds like propaganda, not to mention this is exactly what they would like to tell you as the "selling points" of these features, in order to continue building their walled garden empires. Fully aware of it, but I did want to bring up why they exist and why I even actually like them.
- themodelplumber 9y agoYeah, but maybe there's a better way to get you your nice BART outcome, you know? I think that's really part of the pushback here. We haven't really given social permission for Google to convert the web to AMP by force.
- imchillyb 9y ago> ...convert the web to AMP by force. @themodelplumber Complete hyperbole. Google's not forcing anyone to use AMP. They're not forcing developers or users to use AMP. There is no force. There is only usability. Users prefer usability. Developers prefer people use their products. If a user does not, or cannot, connect to the developer's product the developer loses. If a user cannot connect easily and speedily to a page, they will not consider the product. I rock an LG V20 and I use Chrome mobile. AMP lets me connect to the content I wish to consume speedily and easily. I connect at a significantly faster rate than without AMP. Thus... I <3 AMP. I don't care who controls it. As long as I can connect to the content I want, I'm good.
- cmac2992 9y agoI love AMP as a user. So many sites have brutal load time and jumpy pages, popups and sometimes crashes. As a developer I'm not a fan. It's another thing to manage and maintain. And the last time I checked once you can't leave without some serious consequences. As a marketer I like the increased CTR but dislike the higher bounce rate and limited features.
- bradgessler 9y agoGoogle could accomplish the same objective by penalizing pages that abuse users with ads or load slow.
- ender7 9y agoUsers: I like AMP pages, they're fast! HN: But the open Internet! Users: What's that? HN: Normal websites! Users: Like...the really slow ones? With all the annoying popovers? And pages that take forever to load? And for some reason cause my fancy new phone to slow to a crawl? HN: Well, those websites should rewrite their entire codebase to be faster. Users: That doesn't help me, though. HN: Trust in the free market! The problem is you, the user, who just needs to exert more pressure on website purveyors so they'll make performant web sites. Users: You mean, like, preferring websites that offer faster experiences? Okay. Continues to use AMP.
- akras14 9y agoHence the request to make it optional, with it being on by default. >It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it.
- cgag 9y agoI hate them because they suck not because open internet.
- cgag 9y agoI hate them because they suck not because open internet.
- baconner 9y agoYour hypothetical there assumes that AMP actually works well. My experience is it's got painful usability issues at least on android chrome. The worst one I see all the time is scrolling down to actually read the AMP page frequently results in the page closing, returning you to results. Fast is good, but at least it ought to be a good user experience. I used to use google news a lot, but i totally abandoned it after constant frustrating experiences with AMP. Plus most of the amp-ified pages don't seem significantly faster than the original page. I'm not seeing the utility for users, just for google.
- imchillyb 9y agoPerhaps it's your device @baconner? I'm using an LG V20 device, with Chrome mobile, and I see a significant improvement with AMP'd pages over normal sites. So-much-so that I dread going to non-amped pages as they are slow and the ads are horrifically annoying. I guess this is why anecdotal evidence is not as heavily weighed as a thoroughly tested and evidenced study. YMMV I <3 AMP
- 801699 9y ago"... Google's AMP team even invited me to have lunch with them." Reminds me of this: http://blackhat.com/media/bh-usa-97/blackhat-eetimes.html http://blackhat.com/media/bh-usa-97/blackhat-eetimes.html As far as I can tell, in order to be "forced" on a user, AMP must rely on javascript, the browser used or maybe the OS (I trust they are not rewriting search results to point to AMP but that could be another one). A no javascript command line tcp client will retrieve the page without automatically following the amphtml link. Users thus have a choice. And if choosing the amphtml link it is easy to filter out everything but the text of the page (the content). In that sense AMP is quite nice. The "forced" nature of AMP should make users think about these points of control for advertisers and Google: javascript, browser, OS. Maybe website owners will think about them too the next time they "recommend" or "require" certain browsers. Web should be javascript, browser and OS neutral.
- tomphoolery 9y agoWhy doesn't AMP change the URL bar itself? I don't see a reason why it can't utilize the browser history API and attribute the correct URL page view, considering Google is probably doing your analytics too.
- saurik 9y agoBecause the ability to have one website claim to be another site entirely in the URL bar seems like a phisher's wet dream?
- jayflux 9y agoThe history API can only change the path, you can't change the entire hostname with it, that would open too many doors to phishing if that was possible.
- reaperducer 9y agoAs someone who used to make WAP web sites for mobile phones, I find AMP's limitations comforting and its goal laudable. Much better than the throw-another-javascript-framework-on-the-pile ethos that they teach kids coming out of school these days.
- codazoda 9y agoSo, funny thing. I have been ignoring amp results by accident. I didn't realize what they were and they look like sponsored ads, so I had complete "banner blindness" to them. Odd, now I'll try a few.
- sorenstoutner 9y agoMy experience is that all the advantages of AMP can be had by disabling JavaScript while browsing. And this comes with none of the disadvantages of ceding even more control to companies like Google and Facebook. In my opinion, JavaScript should be disabled by default and only enabled for specific tasks or websites. Not finding exactly what I was looking for in any other browser, I eventually created Privacy Browser on Android. https://www.stoutner.com/privacy-browser/ https://www.stoutner.com/privacy-browser/ There are extensions like No Script that can give similar results for other browsers. https://noscript.net/ https://noscript.net/
- theWatcher37 9y agoNoScript rocks!!!
- akras14 9y agoNice
- jorvi 9y agouMatrix or uBlock (in advanced mode) can largely accomplish the same in a simpler way. However, in my experience, if you go the 'default deny' route against scripts, the spread is about 33/33/33, with 33% of the pages working perfectly, 33% breaking in small ways, and 33% completely borking up. Yes, you can then add the necessary scripts to a whitelist, but it gets tiresome to constantly have to 'fix' sites.
- qb45 9y agoWhitelisting is indeed troublesome, especially in the age of CDNs, and not really worth it for sites visited only once. I discovered that some instances of breakage can be fixed by enabling Firefox "reader view", for others I just start chromium --incognito and paste the link.
- ciconia 9y agoAt 43yo I probably belong to the older folks on HN, but those modern devices all of us carry in our pockets to me seem just absolutely incredible and magical. They probably can run around machines that took up whole rooms just a few decades ago. At the risk of sounding like an old fart (I probably do), I fail to understand this frustration of normal mobile users with the so-called slowness of their mobile experience. To quote CK Lewis: "Give it a second! It’s going to space! Can you give it a second to get back from space!??"
- bsder 9y agoIt's the ads. It's always the ads. The basic stuff loads lightning fast. And then the Javascript ad garbage starts loading. 20 seconds later and 15 domain lookups later, your page finally becomes responsive. So, what is happening is that AMP is removing everything except Google served ads and that makes everything nice and fast.
- theWatcher37 9y agoMaybe the problem is javascript
- bsder 9y agoExcept that some popular websites have javascript "plugins" that strip the ads out and aggregate/serve only the content. Funnily enough, those are almost always blazingly fast.
- narrator 9y agoMaybe the problem is content creators can't monetize easily and, in desperation, go overboard with the ads.
- Spivak 9y agoIt's true of client side rendering in general. If you're targeting mobile and get most of your traffic from search results then you should be looking at aggressively lightweight sites. * Top bar with a damn small company logo and navigation links. Top bar does not follow the user down the page. Your logo isn't that cool and nobody is using your navigation links half way though an article. * No fancy or dynamic layouts. No scrolling effects. No bars that follow them down the page. No floating buttons. No animations. No 'expandable' content. No hamburger menus (they're lazy design anyway). * Minimal CSS. Sane font settings focusing on readability. No web fonts. Use the system default sans serif for the article content. * Email solicitation exists as an in-band static form at the end of the page (or the beginning if you really can't help yourself). * Use text placeholders for images and use JS to load them at the request of the user. Or more generally, only use JS to reduce the traffic over the wire. * (If you must) Use a tracking pixel rather than something like GA or Piwik.
- zhuzhu 9y agoThis guy earning with Google adsense
- gub09 9y agoYes, why does a private website needs 10 trackers/data-miners? For the ad revenue?
- naasking 9y agoI'm starting to hate AMP for one simple reason: it breaks the back button on my Android phone. Like, what the hell? Didn't we do this dance over 10 years ago? Do we really have to keep circling the same drain over and over and over again?
- hn_throwaway_99 9y agoCan you say how? Works fine for me: If I'm on Google search results, tap on an AMP article, and then hit back, I'm back on search results. If I'm on an AMP article, and I tap through to the host site, and then hit back, I'm back on the AMP article (and hitting back again takes me to my original search results page). Works exactly as expected for me.
- naasking 9y agoI would if I knew the precise steps. The past few weeks I've been googling all kinds of DIY projects, and I can't count the number of times I'd google something, get an AMP article, hit back once and end up on a previous google search and not the page that linked this article.
- radicaldreamer 9y agoI can’t help but think that Google considers more and more posts like this a success metric for taking over this part of the web (like Facebook does with its walled garden).
- geekme 9y agoThe publishers should stop supporting AMP collectively. I own a couple of websites and I have not enabled AMP in either of them.
- matthberg 9y ago"What I realized today, however, is that while I don’t so much mind AMP as a publisher, I really hate it as a user. I realized that EVERY TIME I would land on AMP page on my phone, I would click on the button to view the original URL, and would click again on the URL to be taken to the real website. I don’t know why I do it, but for some reason it just doesn’t feel “right” to me to consume the content through the AMP. It feels slightly off, and I want the real deal even if it takes a few seconds extra to load." I have subconsciously been doing the exact same thing for a while now, and I think this quote covers a good deal of public sentiment. It's weird to use AMP, yet slower without it. Another main issue I have with AMP is that there is no speedy way to check the url, something I do quite frequently. Instead it's just Google's hosting for the site, with the source being only available by clicking on the link icon.
- falcodream 9y agoIf my regular page loads as fast as the AMP page, to within some margin, could Google drop the AMP version and link directly to me? It would make AMP a tool for improving the web rather than replacing it.
- corobo 9y agoYou could just not enable AMP if your site loads faster without it
- millisecond 9y agoProblem is that Google is boosting amp in search pages, making it 'required' for sites that live on SEO.
- whyagaindavid 9y agoHere in 3rd world with flaky 2/3G and just 100-300mb data, AMP is welcome. We still use 1G ram phones!
- drawkbox 9y agoTowards the end of AOL (early 2000s), they used to take all content that you visited through their browsers and re-compress and sometimes remove things from the sites. This sometimes really ruined image color, layouts, style etc. The agency I worked at it was a huge problem because back then clients and business people still used AOL and would see the jacked up versions of their site. There was literally nothing you could do, they did it to small and large sites without abandon. AMP reminds me a bit of that type of setup with AOL re-compressing and crunching down sites through their network. I agree with Google on doing this for email for security but not necessarily websites. AMP to me is quite annoying and in general a bad move.
- andy_ppp 9y agoWhat really gets me about the AMP Cache (AMP itself is fine by me) is that it doesn't actually make anything faster. If you time the difference in download speed between the real website AMPd page and AMP Cache URL the difference is almost nothing in 99% of cases. And neither page load gives you that magical instant hit you get on Google's SERPs. The speed difference on SERPs is the background downloading and (possibly) pre rendering of AMP pages. This functionality could easily be added to browsers, keeping people on their own websites and Google not having control over the content. We already have <link rel="preload/prefetch"> but how about adding <link rel="prerender" href="http://amp.newswebsite.com/article/etc." http://amp.newswebsite.com/article/etc." />. This would absolutely give all of the benefits of AMP Cache without Google embracing and extending the web. It's also much simpler to integrate, every single site can choose to benefit from this (not just SERPs) and I don't end up accidentally sending AMP Cache urls to my friends on mobile.
- patrickaljord 9y ago> We already have <link rel="preload/prefetch"> but how about adding <link rel="prerender" href="http://amp.newswebsite.com/article/etc." http://amp.newswebsite.com/article/etc." />. The goal of AMP is to improve the experience on mobile, making the client prerender instead of Google would be bad for your mobile device battery.
- andy_ppp 9y agoI’m just suggesting a way to improve the mobile experience without breaking the web. There are a multitude of ways to do this and while I see your point about everyone using prerender everywhere (browsers should probably have energy usage by domain and warn against bad actors) it’s surely better than this mess where one company completely controls the mobile web.
- wmf 9y agoThe browser does the rendering in all cases; it's not like AMP is downloading a bitmap of the page.
- codedokode 9y ago
- tobyhinloopen 9y agoI must be stupid but I never seen an AMP page anywhere. Link?
- lokedhs 9y agoHonest question. How do I see an AMP page? Perhaps my use of a browser is different that most others (I don't use Facebook, for example) but I can only recall seeing an AMP link once or twice. Do you only see them when doing a Google search?
- homero 9y agoAt least they give you the link now, before was horrific
- BinaryIdiot 9y agoHonestly AMP should have been a set of tools / a framework. Think about it. Currently with AMP Google gets not only your traffic but they get your content on their own domains (which makes all content look like the same trustworthiness) and, at the same time, they mark sites that have AMP available in their search results thusly weighting those results differently because it can train users to click on those more. Ultimately this is bad for everyone but Google. However, if it was a framework / set of tools we could create our own AMP pages and simply put them on our own DNS. Google's cache is really the only unique thing going on here and we wouldn't have to worry about sharing trust.
- bsaul 9y agoThis is crazy, i never noticed those amp links until i read this article. I never clicked on it because my brain somehow classified them as "weird google stuff looking like a new kind of ads". It looks so much like the "external content" ads you find on some website, plus it provides less room for the first sentences of the article, so it made it look even more like clickbait. What did happen though, is that i found google results a lot worse on mobile, and ended up not searching for stuff on my mobile. Google results really look like a mess on mobile now... They really went from minimalist zen to baroque indian arabesque over the year...
- b0rsuk 9y agoThe article displays his autocomplete hints: google amp pages google amp annoying google amp sucks google amp conference My equivalents in google.com are: test cache disable maps Both bing.com and duckduckgo.com (which doesn't track) don't recognize "amp", even when I put both first words in quotes, and assume I made a typo in "maps". This simple test is therefore inconclusive, but my hypothesis is that his search autocomplete hints are, ironically, colored by his search history. The only negative word I got (disabled) is much more neutral. Now that I think about it, duckduckgo's "no tracking" isn't just valuable for privacy. It's also valuable for consistent search results across computers without yielding even more information (logging in etc). A few times I made a query and found something useful and surprising, and then I wasn't able to replicate the query on another computer to show someone else. In any case I'd hate to miss a rare interesting page because Google thought that extra 10 pages about Linux might interest me more.
- freyr 9y agoTry going into Incognito Mode and searching from google.com. When I do that, I get pages, annoying, sucks, and conference. Actually, I get those same results in or out of Incognito Mode, but it's possible your search history is coloring your results.
- blazespin 9y agoI get google amp .. pages, annoying, disable on mobile safari. I've never searched for google amp before and generally don't search for anything that would encourage that. An option to disable would be good. Don't see what the big deal is. Doubt many people would use it, but technical folks would probably like it. Why this was voted up to top on HN is weird. Even if enabled by Google, won't have any impact.
- tempodox 9y agoIf we need Google to tell us to do something that could just as well be achieved by applying reason and sane engineering, without capitulation to a monopoly, then something is deeply wrong with our industry.
- jbg_ 9y agoI started using a self-hosted searx[1] instance recently, and I highly recommend it if you'd prefer to not have to care about this nonsense. It's the first time I've found an alternative to google.com that is actually usable (i.e. I find what I'm looking for near the top of the first results page every time I make a search). You can use Google as one of the results providers, but you won't see any AMP results, and since searx can mix in results from Stack Overflow etc, you might find that a different search engine than Google still gets you good results. I think Google would pull fewer of these monopolistic tricks if people would realise they have genuine alternatives. [1] https://github.com/asciimoo/searx https://github.com/asciimoo/searx
- skmanish 9y agoNot able to view AMP pages in my Google chrome right now, neither on my friends' phones
- unlmtd 9y agoIPFS.
- jeshwanth 9y agoAMP should be optional, I was getting irritated yesterday as many pages are not getting loaded.
- cubano 9y ago> To be honest, I don’t even know what Facebook Instant Articles are. Amen, brother.
- daveheq 9y agoGoogle AMP: 1. Obscures the web page's URL. 2. Makes manual zoom in/out impossible. 3. Sometimes hides content mentioned in the article, with no ability to scroll horizontally to see it. 4. Confuses Chrome on Amdroid into over-hiding its top address/menu bar (forcing two swipes down all the way to the top to show) or forces it to show (won't hide on scroll down). This is just coming from a user's perspective, fortunately it doesn't impact my work, but may in future websites I build due to it being almost 100% of the news articles I read.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 9y agoGoing back to the old days' BBS does not seem like a bad idea.
- baxtr 9y ago...and changes the native scroll behavior iOS (which is much slower). Google has no respect for the native behavior
- askafriend 9y agoThe native behavior changed in iOS 11 so that Safari scrolling on any page is just like the accelerated scrolling on AMP. Check out this response from a Google AMP engineer about scrolling: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384938 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14384938
- baxtr 9y agoThanks for pointing this out. I am looking forward to a homogeneous scrolling experience. Still, I don't understand why google's AMP team they would change scrolling behavior in iOS 10 and lower.
- scottmf 9y agoIt's slower for a reason. I'm not sure why they'd switch after a decade simply because Google asked them to.
- 9y ago
- Artlav 9y agoAs someone who just heard of AMP today, i still can't find any site where it's used, nor have i ever encountered it in the wild. Is it an american thing, not enabled for other countries? Just what am i supposed to look for?
- floatboth 9y agoSearch for some hot news topic on Google with Chrome on Android, you'll see a ton of AMP pages. I haven't encountered it in the wild either because I do not do that pretty much ever.
- gub09 9y agoPlease, web developers, as a minimum, set up your websites so that they do not depend on Google, Facebook, Microsoft, Amazon or Apple for their functionality. That means, for example, use DoubleClick or AdSense or GoogleAnalytics if you like, but please do not use jquery from Google's CDNs. If you do that, and the site is dependent on that functionality to work (i.e. for text to be displayed), those of us who don't allow Google CDNs will not be able to use the site. The same for WebAssembly: use it if you like, but please don't make your actual content unnecessarily dependent on the use of services from these multinationals. It makes the Web less free.
- chrisan 9y ago> That means, for example, use DoubleClick or AdSense or GoogleAnalytics if you like, but please do not use jquery from Google's CDNs. Why is Google Analytics ok and not their CDN?
- codefined 9y agoA website still functions without Google Analytics. 99% of websites won't function if they lose a key library.
- bryanrasmussen 9y agomaybe this means Google Analytics isn't a key library?
- colordrops 9y agoThat's what the person you are responding to is saying.
- tree_of_item 9y agoYes that's what people in this thread have been saying. I'm not sure what your point is.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ccommsxx 9y agoI've been waiting for a comment on why re-hosting verbatim copies of the original content by google is not considered copyright infringement? How come there seems to be no discussion on this at all?
- tertius 9y agoStart by showing how proxying is copyright infringement. Or even search results...
- JoshMnem 9y agoRepublishing copyrighted content on another domain without permission is copyright infringement. I don't know if Google's terms allow their republishing of copyrighted content via AMP, but most people in charge of those decisions at their companies probably aren't paying attention to the domain name or the implications of what they are allowing. At the very least, companies are being coerced to allow the republication of the content.
- Dayshine 9y agoBecause the authors opt-in?
- ccommsxx 9y agoBut how? Where is the opt-in? Is including the javascript from ampproject.org considered an opt-in to give gogole a license to republish your copyrighted content? There is no notice or terms and conditions/license or any kind of other legal agreement that I found on the amp website. [EDIT: actually the code on github is licensed as Apache 2: https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml https://github.com/ampproject/amphtml] So I don't understand how this works legally. You surely don't automatically sign over your copyright to somebody else by including their javascript library in your page?
- Shorel 9y agoJust make your blog in Jekyll instead of WordPress. Much faster everywhere, in all browsers and platforms.
- dreamcompiler 9y agoMaybe if we all start adding Pragma: no-AMP to our HTTP requests Google and publishers will start noticing we care.
- alenros 9y agoWrote down this Tampermonkey\Greasemonkey script that would do the job of automatically redirecting you to the original content. can also be obtained from [0] // ==UserScript== // @name Un-AMP // @namespace http://tampermonkey.net/ http://tampermonkey.net/ // @version 0.1 // @description avoids google AMP links and navigates to the original content // @author Alenros // @match https://www.google.co.il/amp/* https://www.google.co.il/amp/* // @match https://www.google.com/amp/* https://www.google.com/amp/* // @grant none // ==/UserScript== window.location.href=document.getElementsByClassName("amp-canurl")[0].textContent; --------------- [0]https://github.com/alenros/Un-AMP https://github.com/alenros/Un-AMP
- burgerdev 9y ago> My issue with AMP being used inside Google the Search engine I'd suggest trying an alternative, maybe https://duckduckgo.com https://duckduckgo.com.
- johneke 9y agoEven if people are for/against AMP, I think it does make sense to have AMP optional. For instance Google searches will often show the "Ad"-ified link at the top, but with the regular link somewhere below in the search results. Google could just as easily have the AMP and non AMP links in the search results if they aren't really the evil corp everyone thinks they are :)
- bradezone 9y agoGoogle AMP is the devil and I've long since switched to DuckDuckGo as my search engine on mobile. The thing I hate most about ANY technology is when they think they know what I want more than I do.