18 ms·
A lawsuit over Costco golf balls
- xupybd 10y agoThis shows everything wrong with IP today. There should be no place for legal bullying. Especially when it's as simple as crushing competitors under litigation costs.
- saidajigumi 10y agoEspecially the cynical practice of filing known-baseless patent suits as described in the article. That behavior should get the company heavily fined, and land the responsible corporate actors in prison.
- an_account 10y agoPrison seems fairly harsh. There are legitimate disagreements about what a patent covers, and to throw someone in prison over that would be ridiculous.
- xupybd 10y agoI'd agree with this. But maybe some kind of restriction on asserting patent claims when organisations repetitively make claims that don't stand up. Something to penalise this behaviour.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- _jal 10y agoAgreed. Penalties should be in the same form as the motivation: money, and lots of it. Sufficient to make people think twice about asserting a bogus patent again; the amount they claim in damages would be a good starting point. Lose a suit claiming $100m in damages, pay that amount to the winner. Yes, that's arbitrary, but less so than East Texas patent awards.
- mcguire 10y agoWe only have the defendant's word that it was baseless.
- astrodust 10y agoLoser pays makes filing these absurd cases a lot more expensive. If it's destined to lose and it's guaranteed to be paid, finding a lawyer is going to take it on is going to be really easy.
- intrasight 10y agoI think you mean to say "plaintiff loser pays". If the defendant loses, they shouldn't pay. Only then would finding a lawyer get easy.
- astrodust 10y agoNope. Loser pays. This is the English system and it's generally up to the court to decide if this is the case, and if so, what amount is appropriate. Example: http://www.sotosllp.com/2016/01/litigation-costs-in-ontario-where-the-loser-pays-and-the-winner-also-pays/ http://www.sotosllp.com/2016/01/litigation-costs-in-ontario-...
- orionblastar 10y agoI used to work for a law firm as a programmer/analyst, after that DMCA and changes to patent and copyright laws, it is easy to just sue a small company until their court costs and attorney fees exceed their income and they have to settle out of court or reach an out of court settlement. Disney and other companies like DC and Marvel wanted the Trademark law to keep getting modified so they still owned the rights to their characters and they would not go into public domain as our founding fathers wanted. Yeah, this is legal bullying, sort of like taking the competitor and roll them in a rug and start beating them with bats until they give up.
- badestrand 10y agoFor me this only shows the flaws of the law system, doesn't it? The real problem is that defending costs are so high for businesses. If this would be covered by the government or some insurance until the case is resolved, the small companies that got sued could have fought this to the end and only go down if they actually infringed the copyright.
- PatentTroll 10y agoWell what if the balls performance is due to patented innovations that the company wants to protect? We don't know the facts here, just some blogs opinion.
- finaliteration 10y agoIronically, anti-competitive moves like this are only going to accelerate the game of golf's steady decline[0]. I get needing to protect your market as a large player, but when you are the main player and your product is too expensive to buy and the perception is growing that the sport you specialize in is a waste of time and money, what good does it do to push out someone making a cheaper product that may allow beginning players with smaller budgets to enter the game? [0]http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/the-death-of-golf-20150625 http://www.mensjournal.com/magazine/the-death-of-golf-201506...
- tbabb 10y agoWhether that's true or not, I don't think it's enough to rely on the invisible hand to squelch this practice. The truth is, as long as it is advantageous to sue frivolously, companies will do it. And this is bad for the free market, the economy, and consumers. Policy change should make it much more costly to launch a frivolous lawsuit (as distinct from a claim made in good faith), e.g. by making it much easier for a bullied defendant to counter-sue and win significant damages.
- ethbro 10y agoSimilar to the email spam proposals, charge a modest fee for each motion filed. Set it at a point that isn't a barrier for anyone filing a "normal" amount of motions, but where it increases to real money if your main business is filing large amounts of know-it-will-fail paperwork.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sirclueless 10y agoFiling motions is not their main business. Their main business is putting down competitors. In fact the only reason it works is that they have enough revenue that they can retain lawyers (expensive) to do these things without affecting their bottom line much. Lawyers aren't cheap for Acushnet either, they just have the cash to throw around. Adding fees just hurts small players more. This sounds like a "solution" that makes the problem worse.
- cissou 10y agoI don't understand how "“We laughed when we got the lawsuit. We knew we made it.”" and "his company settled the 2015 claims with Acushnet by agreeing to get out of the golf-ball business altogether; it received no payment from Acushnet, nor did it pay." are compatible statements.
- err4nt 10y agoI feel like there was a smile that turned into a frown between those two statements as they realized what it meant
- exabrial 10y agoI think at some point in your life, if you're creating or performing, you'll reach a point where your critics have a significant audience. At that point, you can give yourself a small pat on the back, you've managed to make a splash in the status quo.
- astrodust 10y agoThere's such a thing as funny-sad.
- munchbunny 10y agoYou celebrate the small victories even when you know you're about to hit a big setback. They're not mutually exclusive. In fact being able to appreciate the wins despite the losses is partly how you stay resilient.
- tedunangst 10y agoI would have appreciated some more information about these patents. Like instead of telling me the lawsuit is all hot air, show me? I feel they deliberately omitted any facts which might allow me to form any opinion other than the one I'm supposed to have. (I'm happy to believe the lawsuit is bullshit, but not based on nothing but say so.)
- metaphor 10y agoThe following patent numbers cited in this[1]: 6994638 8123632 8444507 9320944 8025593 8257201 7331878 6358161 7887439 7641572 7163472 [1] http://golf-patents.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/20170317-Complaint-Costco-v-Acushnet.pdf http://golf-patents.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/20170317-...
- tedunangst 10y ago> because, at the least, dimples on the KS golf ball do not cover more than 80% of the outer surface. Haha. Do I believe that? Even the legal filing is short on facts, just assertions. Like who counted the dimples and how many are there in reality? Thanks for the link. I think I fall somewhere between "willing to believe what I'm told" and "willing to do extensive research". "Willing to not particularly care" is about right.
- setr 10y ago>Like who counted the dimples and how many are there in reality? Assuming the dimples and placement of them is uniform across the ball, and across all manufactured balls, Then it shouls be pretty simple to get the size of a ball, the size of a dimple, and the spacing between two dimples, and then extrapolate the actual coverage
- tedunangst 10y agoYeah, sure, it's pretty simple. But why won't anybody tell me what those numbers are? I'm not going out to Costco to buy a set of balls they no longer sell to find out. It seems so obvious that the easiest way to convince me X != Y is to tell me X and Y. Is that weird?
- sergiotapia 10y ago> David Dawsey, a golf intellectual-property expert Talk about carving a niche for yourself.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoprobably a pretty lucrative niche, too. golfers spend a FORTUNE on that game.
- gthtjtkt 10y ago> Companies with deep pockets lock down the market by making it too expensive for competitors to operate and to offer lower-priced yet quality products. It is a legitimate tactic; even those who succumb to it don’t really begrudge the approach. Who the hell wrote this article, the CEO of Acushnet? "Don't get the wrong idea, small businesses love being sued over frivolous patents they never infringed upon!"
- sk5t 10y ago"Ho hum, we've been driven out of business by legal maneuvering, but it's all in good sport." You don't often see such a laissez-faire attitude towards one's livelihood amongst small businesses.
- sirclueless 10y agoOne reason to be so nonchalant would be that the guy did in fact copy someone's patents wholesale, and was just waiting for the day someone would notice. If you know the lawsuit is unwinnable and not frivolous, no point complaining about it.
- sk5t 10y agoA plausible response in the software field, perhaps, but golf balls? Surely it's some effort to design a ball (or several), set up manufacturing, logistics, distribution, sales channels, marketing... I can't speak for the buy-side of driving ranges and miniature golf, but most regular golfers have at least some brand loyalty--a Slazenger, Maxfli, and Callaway are not perfect substitutes.
- annnnd 10y agoAccording to article this is not the case here: > “We weren’t infringing. But we couldn’t afford to fight the case,” he says. Instead, his company settled the 2015 claims with Acushnet by agreeing to get out of the golf-ball business altogether; it received no payment from Acushnet, nor did it pay.
- aluminussoma 10y agoCostco sued J&J Vision Care a few years ago over anti-consumer behavior in the contact lenses industry (I characterize it as anti-consumer. The Vision Care industry characterizes it as pro-consumer). They dropped the lawsuit in 2016, probably because Johnson and Johnson discontinued the practice: https://www.law360.com/articles/800034/costco-drops-antitrust-suit-against-j-j-over-contact-lenses https://www.law360.com/articles/800034/costco-drops-antitrus... Costco did support a different lawsuit by state of Utah against Contact Lens Manufacturers. The Manufacturers lost their first appeal in December 2016: http://www.sltrib.com/news/4731439-155/contact-lens-makers-lose-one-in http://www.sltrib.com/news/4731439-155/contact-lens-makers-l... Hopefully this will begin reducing the prices of contact lenses. Kudos to Costco for sticking up for its customers. Here is one manufacturer's opinion on this matter: https://www.alcon.com/content/unilateral-pricing-policy https://www.alcon.com/content/unilateral-pricing-policy
- yourapostasy 10y agoWRT prices of contact lenses, I use an ultrasonic contact lens cleaner with plain saline (Ringer's will also work if that is cheaper in your area), then storing the contact lenses in my lens solution to disinfect. Far better comfort profile, for far longer, than I ever obtained following the manufacturer instructions of 20 seconds rubbing on each side, and 5 seconds rinsing on each side. The saline is half as much as the normal lens solution, I use it liberally to rinse the ultrasonic cleaner, I get more use out of my contacts, and I use far less normal lens solution. So far I haven't encountered any drawbacks, YMMV.
- hkmurakami 10y agoThis article is very sparse on details. For one, the factory that makes the Costco balls primarily makes Taylor Made balls. The manufacturer is a Korean company that used its excess capacity to make Costco's balls. Taylor Made sells premium balls so they're pressuring the manufacturer to not do this in the future. Also i haven't seen any details about Costco having a golf ball design team. Where did this design come from? Did they contract it out to one of the small manufacturers that he article refers to? That's mainly the thing I want to know, since if it's truly their design that they own, then they'll be able to find someone to make it for them. Also Aschunet isn't that deep pocketed. Their annual revenues are $1.5B with ~$70M shares outstanding and an EPS of about 6, so about $400M in profit, and operating income is in the range of $150M. https://forum.mygolfspy.com/topic/14841-acushnet-losing-sales-profits-market-share/ https://forum.mygolfspy.com/topic/14841-acushnet-losing-sale... Unlike the small ball companies they sued, Costco is a much bigger company than Acushnet and can afford to fight them off, especially since Costco has the distribution scale, hype, and demographic fit perfectly suited to really move the needle with this product (The upper middle class family with disposable income that is budget conscious, which is Costco's main market, is perfect for a budget high performance golf ball, which is a perishable sporting good that you need to buy hundreds of if you play regularly). (Fwiw it is very common in the sport to have small upstart club makers. Basically all you need is a milling machine to make a perfectly reasonable iron or putter, and every now and then you'll see a random small manufacturers club in a tour player's bag - ex: the Yes! Golf putter when Retief Goosen won both his US Opens)
- finaliteration 10y ago> Unlike the small ball companies they sued Maybe I'm mis-reading, but I think the article said that Acushnet was the first one to send a threatening letter claiming IP infringement.
- hkmurakami 10y agoAcushnet has sued small ball companies into oblivion in the past. Acushnet took the initiative in suing Costco this time. Costco, unlike the small ball companies, have the funds to fight back, Acushnet isn't that big of a company. It's defeinitly a small cap company whereas Costco is definitely a large cap. Apologies if my post structure was not clear.
- bmcusick 10y agoAmerican courts should have a "Loser pays" rule, and stricter standards for determining what is a frivolous lawsuit warranting additional penalties for the filer. American jurisprudence has always favored making sure "everyone gets their day in Court" to the point where trolls and professional litigants are ruining things.
- korzun 10y agoThat sounds great on paper, but in reality, all that does is prevent legitimate cases from advancing. It's already expensive as it is to take legal action against an offending party. You are assuming that every lawsuit is a money grab; it's quite the opposite.
- bmcusick 10y agoAnd … this is why we get strategic lawsuits. I'm not assuming any such thing. I'm an attorney and understand the tradeoffs and I think society would be better off if these sorts of cases didn't waste everyone's time.
- hackuser 10y agoWhat happens if your small business sues Google? Right or wrong, you are betting the business on that case. If you lose, Google's legal costs will consume your entire business. That said, it's hard for your small business to sue Google anyway.
- bambax 10y agoIt shouldn't be based on actual costs but on an averaged estimation; and it shouldn't be automatic but left at the discretion of the court, specifically to punish frivolous litigation.
- fgonzag 10y agoI've always had an idea that whoever loses a civil suit pays the other party the lower of the legal costs of both parties. So if small company A fights big company B, small company A would only have to pay twice it's legal costs, even if megacorp decides to spend smallcorp's yearly sales in the defense. If megacorp sues a small company, then small company can decide to fight it if they think they have a case and have enough reserves (which are easy to estimate since they will be based on 2xs your legal costs if you lose, 0 if you win).
- dbg31415 10y agoI love Costco. They pay good wages (with benefits), have good quality products, and great prices. They have a kick ass return policy. And they stick it to patent trolls. Fuck yeah, Costco. Keep it up.
- gesman 10y agoFirst decent reply. Upvoted.
- albeebe1 10y agoI was half expecting to read an article about counterfeit golf balls, or a factory side selling its customers product. Not even close, this is interesting.
- aryehof 10y agoIf parties generally cannot afford to defend claims such as this, surely this reflects poorly on access to justice. Justice only available to the rich? How can one claim a state based on the rule of law, if it is not accessible to all in a timely manner?
- BEEdwards 10y ago> It is a legitimate tactic; even those who succumb to it don’t really begrudge the approach. Maybe I just haven't given up yet, but what the f*ck? This is not a legitimate tactic, this is LITERALLY everything wrong with our present system.
- BoysenberryPi 10y agoShe isn't wrong about it being a legitimate tactic. You might not like it, it might make you a piece of shit for doing it, but it is a completely legitimate tactic.
- gmac 10y ago'Legitimate' is too broad. Google defines it as: 1. conforming to the law or to rules. 2. able to be defended with logic or justification; valid. Definition 1: maybe, although even that may be borderline, since these unsubstantiated suits sound pretty vexatious (IANAL). Definition 2: no way that this is justifiable, or that this peculiarly broken aspect of the US legal system — where you pay your own costs even if you win — can be defended with logic.
- loco5niner 10y agoIt's legitimately a tactic, but not a legitimate tactic.
- the_cat_kittles 10y agolegitimate, to my mind, connotes at least some moral rightness. so i disagree. maybe the literal definition is "legal", but i think it would be more clear to say "legal" than "legitimate"
- sluggg 10y agothe tactic is legitimate, sure. But do ALL those people who succumb to the tactic really not begrudge the approach? I highly doubt it. QZ found one guy who was not upset and uses that to justify the prior claim... booo qz booo
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoWhy not just make a $1 ball using all of the expired 1990's era patents from the top manufacturers. You'd make a mint. Name it the Patentless.
- zanny 10y agoThe article goes into why. It doesn't matter if you actually infringe the patents, they will sue you for their entire patent portfolio and bankrupt you trying to dismiss all the frivolous charges.
- jdhawk 10y agoProbably because 1990's balls sucked, and were expensive to manufacture (wound cores?) There are plenty of cheap golf balls using modern materials, designs, and manufacturing techniques out there. People just want to play what they see the pro's playing - because its one less thing they can blame their shitty performance on. Club technology has not significantly changed in the past 10 years, but Golfers are always looking for an edge that does not require more practice...thus the constant new products.
- bodyloss 10y agoWhy is it that the patent holder doesn't have to make a case with proof of infringment? Would it not make sense that if you want to defend a patent, you should show you've made the effort of documenting how someone is infringing?
- dmritard96 10y agoSamsung and Apple fought over rectangles. Nest and Honeywell fought over circles. Next up, spheres... But in all seriousness, this is just rent seeking via the patent system.
- duncan_bayne 10y agoJust get rid of patents altogether, already: http://praxeology.net/anticopyright.htm http://praxeology.net/anticopyright.htm (Titled "Anti-Copyright Resources", but in fact contains a lot of material relevant to patents, too.)
- xroche 10y agoThis is why most patents should be eradicated. They only allow established companies to stay in business despite lack of innovation and price competition. The whole patent system is abused by parasites.
- praptak 10y agoWhy don't consumers boycott the trolls out of existence? It's not like there is a huge cost of switching golf balls, right? And the consumer base isn't companies whose deciders spend someone else's money.
- scott_karana 10y agoThe feedback loop is poor, even if you ignore biases. How do consumers know their favourite brand is filing lawsuits, much less know if they're frivolous?
- bitmapbrother 10y agoCompanies that knowingly waste the courts time by filing frivolous lawsuits should be heavily punished. Acushnet is not defending their patents, they're just trying to prevent competition. They're fully aware that no patents were violated because they've already examined the KS balls extensively for infringement. This case will never make it court for the simple reason that their hand has been thoroughly exposed.
- tomohawk 10y agoReminds me of the time we almost got inexpensive milk, until some pet congresscritters intervened to keep the milk trust intact. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12/09/AR2006120900925.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/12...
- golergka 10y agoEverybody's quick to call this "bullying". How are all of you so sure that Costco didn't indeed steal intellectual property? Or the fact that small companies got sued before means that it were frivolous lawsuits - because, being small, they couldn't have possibly done anything bad like stealing IP? I don't know anything about this issue, but at least I know I don't know it. What I don't understand is whether all the HN commentators get the idea that they know the situation good enough to jump to conclusions here.
- barking 10y agoThe law is there to protect us but this is an example of how the high cost of going to law facilitates oppression. The same goes when it comes to dealing with the government. A government official has no personal liability with respect to any decision they make and has essentially bottomless pockets if it goes to court. It means for example that a revenue officers decision is final when it comes to the interpretation of tax law in your case, unless you're very rich.
- talha123 10y agoI went from glasses and astigmatism to LASIK and halos.
- chmike 10y agoCould this be a tactic to chose the trial location and avoid Texas ?
- Skylled 10y agoI'm sorry, but shouldn't it be the responsibility of the party making the claim to provide evidence of patent infringement before the defendant is ever even affected? What a sad state of affairs our court system is in if even a known false lawsuit can be devastating.
- ALee 10y agoTwo things to keep in mind: 1) Acushnet is trying to keep Costco from entering the market, but once Costco sells a significant number of its golf balls, Acushnet will have to deal with the economic ramifications. 2) Streisand effect - this lawsuit plays really well for Costco, namely that it gives them a lot of free publicity and hype around their supposedly amazing golf balls.
- pkolaczk 10y ago"But we couldn’t afford to fight the case" I think there must be something very wrong with the court system in USA. This is the one who claims their patents have been infringed that should prove at the court and pay the price for filing the lawsuit, including the cost of the experts hired by the court. Why are the costs of defense so high in this case?