23 ms·
Thousands of underground gas bubbles poised to 'explode' in Arctic
- deanclatworthy 10y agoIf you find this interesting, VICE did a 15min segment on their show recently about this very issue.
- serg_chernata 10y agoThanks for the mention, love Vice. Would you mind providing a link?
- deanclatworthy 10y agoIt was shown on HBO. Season 5 episode 3
- loader 10y agoI couldn't find a youtube video of it but here's the HBO.com link http://www.hbo.com/vice/episodes/05/57-when-the-earth-melts-and-the-displaced/index.html http://www.hbo.com/vice/episodes/05/57-when-the-earth-melts-...
- LyndsySimon 10y agoWell... I guess let's hope the "Clathrate gun hypothesis" is incorrect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fjabre 10y agoIf we can't figure out an engineering solution to this problem then it's game over. It always amazes me how much people and governments focus on prevention when it comes to climate change, knowing full well it's far too late to change anything by reducing carbon emissions. If we can't sequester these 'surplus' gases from the atmosphere then I guess you could say we don't have a chance in hell, pun intended, of surviving as a species if runaway warming becomes a reality.
- philipkglass 10y agoArtificial sulfate aerosols look like they could quickly damp positive feedbacks though of course they're no permanent fix and won't do anything to counteract ocean acidification. There are more permanent fixes possible in theory (large scale accelerated silicate weathering) but their feasibility hinges, IMO, on some rather optimistic assumptions about the future trajectory of robotics. Metaphorically speaking, we now have to consider the planetary equivalent of high-risk, high-cost surgery after mostly ignoring the planetary "stop smoking" advice experts have been giving for more than a generation. Also, any large scale sequestration effort is going to be much harder if emissions continue unabated. We're past the point where prevention alone can stabilize atmospheric CO2 but we're never past the point where further anthropogenic emissions can make the problem even worse.
- bufbupa 10y agoCan you elaborate on the optimistic assumptions in robotics that may enable accelerated silicate weathering? Or could you point me to some readings on the matter?
- philipkglass 10y agoA search on Google Scholar for "accelerated silicate weathering" will be more informative than my comment. But here's the shortish version... Naturally occurring silicates of magnesium, calcium, sodium, and potassium are thermodynamically prone to weather to carbonates in ambient conditions, when water absorbs CO2 and passes over rocks. In the case of magnesium and calcium in particular, the weathering leads to stable solids that will not spontaneously release CO2 again. A schematic example with calcium silicate: CO2 + CaSiO3 -> SiO2 + CaCO3 Gaseous carbon dioxide and solid calcium silicate become solid silicon dioxide and calcium carbonate. Silicate weathering has multiple advantages over other carbon dioxide removal/sequestration schemes: • The end state is naturally stable. You don't have to worry about the leakiness of underground containment. • It restores the pH balance of the oceans as well as reducing radiative forcing (warming) effects. • It deals equally well with point and distributed sources of CO2 (coal plants, automobile tailpipes). • It can be located anywhere on Earth. It does not need to be adjacent to CO2 sources. • It does not require concentrated CO2 streams, but works with ambient atmospheric concentrations. Natural silicate weathering reactions dominate Earth's CO2 balance in the very long term. But they are strongly kinetically hindered in nature. After a freshly exposed rock surface has weathered to a depth of a few microns, the cation-depleted "rind" drastically slows the weathering of the remaining interior. Without human intervention, it'll take about 100,000 years for natural silicate weathering to restore the pre-industrial baseline of atmospheric CO2 concentrations. There are different ways to improve the kinetics: • Crush bulk rock to a fine sand texture, so full interior weathering finishes much faster (still takes years-to-decades, but no longer takes geological time scales). • Place crushed rock in near-shore ocean environments where mechanical wave erosion keeps removing rinds. • Place crushed rock in acidic tropical agricultural soils where it weathers faster due to low pH and elevated temperature. This also improves soil quality for growing crops. It's not explicitly included in the scholarly literature, but I say that advanced robotics are necessary because the required scale of intervention is staggering, bigger than any engineering endeavor in history. For example, the Columbia Plateau in the United States contains basalt whose alkali and alkaline earth content could bind about 20% of its own mass in CO2, after complete weathering: https://crustal.usgs.gov/geochemical_reference_standards/basaltbcr2.html https://crustal.usgs.gov/geochemical_reference_standards/bas... To neutralize the CO2 that humans emitted in 2015, about 36 billion tons (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_di...), would require mining and pulverizing about 180 billion tons of Columbia Plateau basalt. That's about 60 cubic kilometers. We're in no danger of running out of plateau -- it contains more than 170,000 km^3. As for energy estimates, the Bond Work Index for crushing basalt such that 80% of particles pass a 100 micron screen is in the neighborhood of 17-20 kWh per ton: https://www.911metallurgist.com/blog/table-of-bond-work-index-by-minerals https://www.911metallurgist.com/blog/table-of-bond-work-inde... I'll add a factor of 2 for overhead to estimate the whole process energy expenditure. That would mean that using Columbia Plateau basalt, you'd expend 40 kWh per ton of basalt, about 200 kWh per ton of CO2 removed from the atmosphere. That is, energetically speaking, really good compared to schemes that try to run "combustion-in-reverse" to regenerate hydrocarbons from CO2. It's efficient enough that you could actually use coal fired power to drive the whole process and it would still be a net CO2 sink. But at 200 kWh per ton-CO2-scrubbed, it would take 7.2 billion megawatt hours to neutralize humanity's 2015 CO2 emissions. That's an annualized power of 821 gigawatts -- nearly twice the average electrical power generated in the United States. The scale is so vast that I can only imagine advanced robotic manufacturing, mining, and energy generation being up to the task. However you want to modify my baseline scenario -- smaller projects scattered around the Earth instead of one mega-project, being pickier about processing only the best rocks -- I think that the scale is still daunting. But I think it may still be possible because I see automation advancing a lot in the 21st century if we don't precipitate a civilization-ending crisis first.
- cjensen 10y agoA lot of the photos in the article sure looked like pingos[1], which are common in the Arctic and subarctic, rather than something exotic. Horses before Zebras and all that. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingo
- CoffeeDregs 10y agoUnfortunately, few of the photos have anything to indicate scale and those few seem to range from 100m (small trucks on the far side) to 2-3m (the guy stepping on one). Still, those are incredible photos...
- Daishiman 10y agoWell this is pretty much the beggining of the end then.
- ivrrimum 10y agoCan you elaborate please? How is this the end?
- randyrand 10y agoThe consensus is that unchecked GW would not be a human extinction event.
- philipkglass 10y agoCorrect, I don't believe that human extinction is in the cards from unchecked GW. Though it could well still be the greatest and most prolonged disaster in recorded history. There is an enormous gulf between minimum thresholds for, respectively: - "Not a big deal" - A catastrophe, comparable to World War II - The greatest catastrophe in recorded history - The extinction of industrialized civilization - The extinction of the human species - The extinction of multicellular life - The extinction of all Earthly life - The destruction of Earth as a planet It can be tricky to push back against hyperbole comparing AGW to some of those later-stage events without being mistaken for someone who doesn't worry about AGW at all.
- tonmoy 10y agoThat being said, it makes little difference for me among the last 4/5 items in the list
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> It can be tricky to push back against hyperbole comparing AGW to some of those later-stage events without being mistaken for someone who doesn't care about AGW at all. Yeah, the thing is, that your list roughly translates to: - Not a big deal - Many of us are dead - Most of us are dead - Almost of us are dead and everything is fucked - Remaining list items aren't even worth considering Hyperbole is never good, but it's important to realize that anything above "Not a big deal" means at least a serious degradation of life quality for everyone on the planet. So maybe let's rewrite the list to show how your and mine lives will look like: - Everything is much more expensive, no more extravagant meals - European refugee crisis, except you're the refugee - Like the above, except everyone wants to shoot you - The Walking Dead, just without the zombies - Everyone dies
- sqeaky 10y agoAt first I was thinking "stupid click bait title", then I saw the pictures. Anything making those craters is properly an explosion. Anything heard 100km away is properly and explosion. If anything this article plays it down with words like eruption and venting. This seems super dangerous for people in the area. And dangerous in the climate change sense for the rest of us.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- konceptz 10y agoI imagine the literal boiling of the earth. Yes, not accurate but just interesting to picture (for me).
- yborg 10y agoI can't believe that this got 350+ comments and nobody actually recognized the clickbait here. For one thing, it's a story from that noted climatology journal "The Siberian Times". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pingo They're full of ice, not methane. And what makes those craters is the ice melting and/or drop in groundwater pressure. The issue of entrained methane trapped in permafrost is real and the pingo ice most likely also contains trapped methane, but the implication that these are domes of pressurized methane READY TO BLOW AND HURL EARTH INTO RUNAWAY GREENHOUSE AT ANY MOMENT is absurd. The melting of permafrost generally over wide areas is the actual threat.
- gph 10y agoI know it's stupid and crazy, but would carpet bombing the arctic work to burn up the methane trapped below the permafrost before it leaks out into the atmosphere and causes worse problems? Or maybe we should send out expedition crews to find and preemptively explode these methane bubbles. Perhaps the way things are going they will become too plentiful to really do anything realistic about it.
- brians 10y agoIt burns to CO2. Not enormously helpful?
- vkou 10y agoPound for pound, methane is a much stronger GHG then CO2.
- ams6110 10y agoBreaks down more quickly though I'd expect?
- philipkglass 10y agoMethane naturally breaks down to CO2. Transforming it to CO2 faster is unambiguously better.
- vkou 10y agoNot quickly enough to save us from disaster, if the CG hypothesis holds.
- maccam912 10y agoA stat I hear often is that methane is 26x "worse" of a greenhouse gas than CO2, so not ideal but still helpful.
- phkahler 10y agoHow about just spreading a bunch of methane consuming bacteria over there? Not quite suited to the environment - how about breeding some that are?
- good_vibes 10y ago[wow]
- jacquesm 10y agoIf you're on HN for all of 20 days and this is the level of your contribution to this thread I suggest you take your fart jokes elsewhere. Thank you.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- good_vibes 10y agoI've been on HN for much longer. I just decided to start over because I've changed a lot over the years.
- helloburin 10y agoThis made me think of methane powered rockets that Elon Musk has mentioned: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raptor_(rocket_engine_family) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raptor_(rocket_engine_family... Can we use the methane to get us to another planet?
- wiz21c 10y agoI don't like what I'm reading here. Is there any expert here that could at least bring in non-panic arguments ?
- cwal37 10y agoHere is an at least a somewhat optimistic take on this issue in that it's looking for mitigation techniques and IDing possible research[1]. I worked for the lead author one summer at LLNL right around when this was published, and I believe he's continued to work on aspects of this in the interim, although I must confess that I'm terrible at keeping up with people and am not entirely sure. [1] http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es204686w http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es204686w
- mikestew 10y agoThat's why I keep hitting "refresh" on this page of comments, in the hope that someone with more expertise than I have comes along and tells me it's not nearly as bad as I take this to be (i. e., "we're fucked"). Still waiting, BTW.
- kaybe 10y agoSorry, nope. The climate community pretty much agrees on this. How we will deal with the changing circumstances is wide open though, so there is some hope there. Given our history though.. edit: Here's a comment I made for released carbon due to permafrost melting (with literature): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13769896 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13769896
- dreamcompiler 10y agoThere is some hope. We could geoengineer a giant shade structure to reflect sunlight away from earth. It would cost $trillions (twelve zeros) but it could be done with current technology. And it would cool the Earth immediately. Unfortunately it would do nothing to fix ocean acidification, which threatens to starve and/or suffocate us all.
- 10y ago
- tabeth 10y agoSo, assuming we're screwed, where's the best place to move preemptively? I know Boston isn't that place. - I assume the coasts are a nonstarter. - Moving inland could be nice, but the ground would need to be pretty arable to restart civilization there. I'm guessing somewhere in Africa is a safe bet, given the lack of resource exploitation there, but then again, there's not much infrastructure at the moment.
- philfrasty 10y agoFirst-mover advantage.
- anon1253 10y agoI'm betting on the higher regions of Scandinavia or Iceland.
- Gustomaximus 10y agoCountries like Norway/Iceland could get significantly colder if the gulfstream stops from arctic melts, which seems likely. Maybe this will improve in time but in the short-term this could be a real problem. Somewhere like NZ is a better bet. Being remote with no land borders could be an advantage if there is significant global upheaval.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wamsachel 10y ago> I'm guessing somewhere in Africa is a safe bet, given the lack of resource exploitation there, ...what?
- tabeth 10y agoAFAIK Africa has a ton of natural resources still available compared to the rest of the continents (other than Antarctica)
- 10y ago
- andrewflnr 10y agoWhy do the craters have those sheer sides?
- jacquesm 10y agoI was wondering about that myself. I suspect this has to do with the violence of the explosion cutting a path to the outside that is a circle because that's the shape the underlying gas bubble would have had. Which makes me wonder what this landscape looks like during a thunderstorm with lightning hitting the occasional methane deposit.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bithive123 10y agoHere is a good video about the arctic methane emergency: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8F9ed5E54s4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8F9ed5E54s4 Some summary points: - Total amount of methane in the current atmosphere: ~5 gigatons - Amount of carbon preserved as methane in the arctic shelf: estimated at 100s-1000s of gigatons - Only 1% release would double the atmospheric burden of methane - Not much effort is needed to destabilize this 1% - The volume currently being released is estimated at 50 gigatons (it could be far more) - 50 gigatons is 10x the methane content of the current atmosphere - We are already at 2.5x pre-industrial level, there is a methane veil spreading southward from the arctic. - Methane is 150x as powerful a greenhouse gas as CO2 when it is first released. Here is a longer video for those who have the time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPdc75epOEw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPdc75epOEw
- shostack 10y agoIn layman's terms, how much are we screwed without hope of a solution, and what is the rough timeframe before the evening news starts looking like "The Day After Tomorrow?"
- alistproducer2 10y agoI'm wondering the same thing. Should I start blowing through my 401k money now or what?
- partycoder 10y agoExcellent time to defund the EPA. Natural selection at its best.
- ganfortran 10y agoLet it crash. Human need a lesson.
- jacquesm 10y agoLots of humans that have absolutely no say or any kind of influence at all will suffer, so no, let's not let it crash. The 'lesson' you are talking about could easily end the species, it's hard to learn 'lessons' when your species ceases to exist.
- cafebabbe 10y agoThis would be a "lesson" like death is a "momentary setback"
- bbcbasic 10y agoThat depends on your religion I guess.
- ganfortran 10y agoLet it crash. Human need a lesson.
- british_india 10y agoThis is precisely why Dr. Guy McPherson has predicted human extinction on earth by 2030. Methane clathrates coming from the Arctic sea floor and from Canadian and Siberian permafrost. This is the most serious threat we face now.
- derrickdirge 10y agoSo is it time to kill myself yet?
- WalterSear 10y agoWe are.
- ams6110 10y agoSo, this sort of thing must have happened in past warm periods. Yet life survived.
- chunkstuntman 10y agoLife certainly has a good chance given the existence of deep-sea bacteria, tardigrades, and cockroaches, but the human species has a relatively narrow set of conditions that must be met for any sort of longterm survival.
- xoa 10y agoI can't believe there are people willfully obtuse enough to still be putting out this strawman. No one credible is or has ever claimed "the end of life" or even "the end of multicellular life". Humanity could get wiped out entirely and "life" would be fine for a few billion years until it really would get wiped out completely without intelligence. But even a few tens of millions let alone hundreds let alone billions is something we might reasonably want to avoid don't you think? Is this really such a hard concept for you to grasp? When "life survived" previous mass extinction events you should read that as "SOME life survived, and often not the big complex types."
- xg15 10y agoHere is another article about the same event (in german) that has an aerial view supposedly showing the distribution of the craters over one of the islands: http://www.spektrum.de/news/7000-gasblasen-woelben-sich-in-sibirien-auf/1443175 http://www.spektrum.de/news/7000-gasblasen-woelben-sich-in-s... (The craters filled with water, hence the dark color. The picture doesn't say anything about the craters' depth) I don't know about the source though, so I guess it should be taken with a grain of salt.
- theseadroid 10y agoSource of the image https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=6034 https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=6034
- Keyframe 10y agoCould one pierce a bubble and syphon/concentrate the gas into a tank with a pump? Might be too late, considering how many there are and how remote they are. edit: nm, I saw that conference where they've shown Methane releasing from the submerged Siberian plane. We're fucked.
- delecti 10y agoNaively, it seems like that would be a bit like trying to pop a helium balloon and recapture the helium. Though I'm certainly not an expert, and it's possible it'd be more akin to natural gas drilling, which we have some experience in.
- Keyframe 10y agoIf you look at the video in the article, there's a dude poking a hole with his boot in one of the smaller bubble. It looks like a possibility to capture the gas, maybe drill from top on the smaller ones and from side or bottom on the large ones... but, I'm not an expert. Also, top comment here linked to a conference where they've showed a submerged Siberian plane bubbling gas from beneath sea surface - 500 to 5000G of Methane. So long, and thanks for all the fish :/
- delecti 10y agoI saw that video. It makes me think that the individual bubbles aren't big enough to be cost effective to harvest.
- Razengan 10y agoIf we can't fix, if we can't prevent, and if we cannot prepare either, then maybe we could at least preserve? • Digitize all human knowledge and as much art/literature as you can gather (books, music, movies, shows, games, even porn and random YouTube videos and discussions on online forums :) Most of that work has already been done. • Store it on the most resilient (and simple/repairable) storage media you can, • Bundle it with devices that can read that data, • Along with instructions for building/reinventing such devices, and instructions on how to interpret that data (i.e. JPEG and other file formats :) • Also include a guide for translating the instructions. Assume that a future reader may not understand any of our current languages, or even be human at all. • Put it all in a silo as physically strong as you can build. • Make copies of the silo and bury one on each continent and in each ocean. Maybe even on the Moon? • Distribute markers and maps to each silo (and instructions for opening them) all over the world. • Let fate take its course. All of this could be done by a few individuals and most of it won't even require a lot of money.
- mirimir 10y agoBuilding digital storage that lasts more than a few decades is hard. See http://longnow.org/ http://longnow.org/ and http://rosettaproject.org http://rosettaproject.org
- xtian 10y agoWe've constructed a society which is incapable of responding effectively to even ultimate crisis, and faced with that realization all we can think to do is devise a way to preserve the leavings of that dead-end paradigm. Very nice.
- lutusp 10y agoThis is a particularly dramatic methane release, but methane is being released regularly in the high latitudes. I visit Alaska in the summertime and I see methane releases in many locations -- for example (taken from my kayak): http://i.imgur.com/rRs3fQU.jpg http://i.imgur.com/rRs3fQU.jpg It's important to say the only reason you can see this outgassing is because the source is underwater. The entire landscape is releasing methane this way, but without any clear signs.
- gragas 10y agoIt's pretty amazing that that website emails you your password in plain text when you register.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoOk, so how do we unfuck this? What are the promising options, who's working on them, and how can one contribute?
- codecamper 10y agogo solar. & EV
- TeMPOraL 10y agoThis won't help clear out methane in the short term, though.
- notatoad 10y agoclearing out the methane is the problem. you really, really don't want it to clear out, you want it to stay frozen under the arctic permafrost. the problem is if the ice that's currently keeping all that methane sequestered melts, it releases the gas. We need to drastically reduce our greenhouse gas emissions from other sources to curb global warming and keep all that gas frozen away.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI used a wrong expression. What I meant is clearing it out of the atmosphere if it happens to get there, and/or making sure that the currently sequestered methane stays that way (including by locking it down harder somehow).
- wallace_f 10y ago>& EV You can have a bigger impact by bicycling, walking, carpooling or taking public transit. Better yet, work from home. Depending on the energy mix used to recharge your EV it's not a huge difference in CO2 emissions if you're coming from something fuel efficient to begin with.
- Pxtl 10y agoMinimize animal products in your diet, including dairy (not just meat), stop buying so much stuff, stop driving everywhere. Get involved in municipal politics to help get your city more transit and cycling oriented. Get involved in state/provincial politics to encourage the development of green energy and the abolition of coal and gas. Get involved in federal politics to encourage the creation of carbon pricing at a federal level.
- xutopia 10y agoThe majority of the population does not care about this one bit. They're going to carry on driving their gas guzzlers. The only change we can make is if we, who understand what is at stake, invest in renewables to bring their price down. When the backwards people will see us all in our cheap to run, fast to accelerate and cheap to maintain electric pass them on the highway will they feel dumb buying gallons of gas to keep their guzzlers going.
- dcchambers 10y agoConsumer gas vehicle make up a TINY fraction of the cause of greenhouse emissions worldwide. Everyone changing to EVs isn't going to fix anything, especially when that electrical power can come from dirty power plants. The big changes need to come from agriculture, commercial, and industrial industries. The world also needs to quickly phase out coal and gas power plants and switch to all renewable so new "green" electric vehicles are actually better for the environment.
- geoka9 10y ago> Consumer gas vehicle make up a TINY fraction According to [1], transportation is 26% of greenhouse emissions, of which over half is passenger cars and light-duty trucks. [1] https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis...
- dcchambers 10y agoThose are US emissions only. What about China? India? The EU? As you can also see from that report, 30% of emissions come from electricity generation. If we all switch to EVs, expect that % from consumer vehicles to just flip to electricity. That can't be fixed until all our electricity is 100% renewable.
- i2amsam 10y agoIt can be improved as soon as average electricity generation is cleaner than internal combustion engines, which it is today.
- maerF0x0 10y agoso arctic russia has acne?
- executive 10y agoburning off the bubbles is fun https://youtu.be/15tPaV_j0CU https://youtu.be/15tPaV_j0CU
- finid 10y agoOne thing the Russians have going for them is they're not denying climate change. That lets them sit down and think things through.
- signa11 10y agosilly question: burning it / these is not an option? it produces co2, but that is far less worse than ch4.
- warredale 10y agoWhy wouldn't we preemptively pump them out? Draw them down.
- dcgoss 10y agoThis is the first time I've heard about this issue. If this is as severe and terrifying as these comments are making it seem, why has this not been covered more?
- earthtolazlo 10y agoWhat do you think climate scientists have been screaming about for the past several decades?
- dcgoss 10y agoIt always seemed like CO2 was the biggest issue. Call me naive but I didn't hear anything about massive underground methane bubbles ready to explode and destroy humanity imminently.
- cafebabbe 10y agoI heard about that problem ten years ago, without specifically looking for it. It's probably known for decades.
- rhino369 10y agoRapid runaway global warming isn't the scientific consensus.
- agentultra 10y agoIt's strange reading about this and realizing that to be able to do something about it I would have had to have been born twenty some-odd years before I was born. That it's literally too late to do anything about it. I was raised to care about these issues, to save the rainforest, to cut down on pollution, recycle -- to do something about it. And that it would've taken a concerted effort from everyone to take the same care. Scientists have been warning about this for decades. And we've done nothing. Not even to slow down! I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness... Indeed.
- rhino369 10y agoIf drastic action is taken now we'd only see 2 degree warming. That is far from the end of the world. If we do nothing we'll see 5-8 degrees, which would change the climate pretty drastically. It's not too late at all.
- agentultra 10y agoFrom the video linked in another comment it seems like drastic is basically impossible. The speaker, Stuart Scott, had said that we'd have to just drop $28 trillion worth of fossil fuel assets on the floor and walk away today. It seems more likely that we're going to hit at least 5 degrees over the next 100 years which, if I'm not mistaken, means mass extinction events and the collapse of civilization as we know it. 2 degrees, from what I understand, is drastic enough to destabilize our current geo-political situation and threaten humanity with large-scale famine, water shortages, and mass migrations. It doesn't seem like we can even avoid 2 degrees at this point. It's just going to happen even if we do stop everything today if I'm understanding this news right.
- rhino369 10y agoThe IPCC reports don't substantiate those figure. RCP8.5 which assumes increasing co2 emmisions until 2080 results in 2.6-4.8 degrees by 2100. But Rcp8.5 is considered pretty much worst case. It is basically what happens if we just continue to use fossil fuels and have no climate policy. RCP4.5 which is a somewhat optimistic but still realistic plan would only have 1.1-2.6. RCP6 which is a realistic scenario where fossil fuels are used heavily but by 2060 we start heavily switching to carbon neutral sources. That leads to 1.4-3.1 degrees by 2100. There also isn't any scientific consensus on what level of rise would lead to collapse of civilization. But I'm pretty sure it wouldn't be 5 degrees by 2100. Even with 5 degrees the bread baskets of the world should still be producing a ton of food. There would need to be engineering solutions. GMO modified crops to survive droughts better. Better irrigation in California and the Midwest. The dooms day projections all assume we just sit around while food production drops and just starve to death. That's a bad assumption. It would cause famine in parts of the world where rising food costs means they can't afford food. But food could go up 5x in America before we'd have problems affording it.
- buzzybee 10y agoEvery time I see stories about runaway climate catastrophe, I stop and consider the scenarios and how it might affect how I lead my life, and none of them really change how I plan to do things. I'm working and training in ways I believe will contribute, and that is sufficient to calm myself. Basically, either we make all the turnarounds necessary, on every front - policy, technology, engineering, culture - to beat this stuff by a huge margin, or it's all over. I don't see a middle ground of "things kind of suck for a while and then it's okay" happening. And that guides a lot of my thoughts on other topics: I want survivability, and of a form which preserves key freedoms. I believe massive reforms to the economic and political system are needed to do it. I believe our existing social network structures and cultural norms are insufficient to address this. There's a lot of room to change in all directions.
- 1propionyl 10y agoThis sounds like the start of a Dan Brown novel...
- brogrammer2 10y agoHonest question: Why is Mainstream Media not covering this like it should be doing? Heck, this should be the breaking news every single day!! After all, this spells doomsday for the upcoming generations, so shouldn't it be the news that should be shown/covered almost everyday on the front page. The people have the right to know that their children and grandchildren will suffer because of something that is going on right now. I guess, that majority of people, all over the world, are blissfully unaware of this scenario because this doesn't get the kind of attention in the MSM that it should. All they get served is dirty politics and gossip entertainment news. Maybe people will force the policies to change if they get to know that this will happen. It seems that most people today think that Terrorism is the main threat to our society, when in fact, Global Warming seems to be the real deal. Let's say it was found that fifty years from now, an Asteroid would hit Earth. Would the people of Earth react in the same way as they are doing now?
- ianai 10y agoUntil people undeniably feel it they will not believe they are the problem. It takes a lot for someone to change their minds in the face of "criticism".
- InclinedPlane 10y agoIf the media covered everything they should have to the standard of quality they should have over the last, oh, let's say twenty years, the world would be an incredibly different place.
- balabaster 10y agoUnfortunately they're too busy exploiting human nature for their own advantage than to exploit it for the good of humanity.
- notsofastmister 10y agoRussia Today (bear with me for a second) did a documentary [0] on how the climate and geography (!) of the region is changing. They also interview the local population and how they view the change in the ecosystem on which their whole lives are build. [0] https://rtd.rt.com/films/the-permafrost-mystery/#part-1 https://rtd.rt.com/films/the-permafrost-mystery/#part-1
- sinkensabe 10y agoSo they can explode at any time from now and possible end us? Is that how I should wrap my head around it?
- porker 10y agoIt's really hard to get the scale of the domes from the photos. Are the top photos 30cm across or 100m?
- emiliobumachar 10y agoWell, the first photo has a cloud in it. I don't remember ever seeing tiny clouds that stuffy, so I think we can rule out anything below tens of meters.
- emiliobumachar 10y agoSerious question: would we be better off finding a safe way to burn all this methane before it leaks? Even detonating it in place and wasting the energy seems advantageous, since CO2 is much less greenhouse-y than unburned methane.
- kahrkunne 10y agoIs there way to harvest these? We could burn the gas for a lot of energy, and the CO2 released would be a lot less bad than the methane.
- mrlaserOO 10y agoSo here is a solution: send a drone overhead and just ignite the methane via laser. no more methane!
- perfunctory 10y agoSuppose one has already cut his own consumption as much as possible and has some free money left. What's the most efficient way to spend it to combat climate change? Buy EV; donate to environmental lobby group; invest in a vegetarian restaurant around the corner; isolate your own house? Any ideas?
- basicplus2 10y agodon't forget the termites, as it is not a one off that has a half life, but a continuous process of production. "production of CH4 by termites is probably <15% of the global yearly emissions." http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v301/n5902/abs/301700a0.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v301/n5902/abs/301700a0...
- jlebrech 10y agowho/what will this affect?
- lolive 10y agoGod is nice. God won't let that happen.
- BrailleHunting 10y agoAnother bigger problem, raised by VICE reporting, is tundra thawing, leading to ground collapsing 10-30 meters into huge sinkholes. Appearently, one of the possible solutions is replacing tundra forests with grasslands by megafauna and macrofauna grazing, including, potentially, cloned mammoths, because grassland freezes harder in the winter and keeps the permafrost froze during the summer months.
- adamtait 10y agoThe Zimov's (Russian scientists) are behind this effort. Check out their Kickstarter: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/907484977/pleistocene-park-an-ice-age-ecosystem-to-save-the https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/907484977/pleistocene-p...
- mattmanser 10y agoHonest question, if it does turn out that these have a bad effect, and they can detect the bulges, can't they start draining them before they pop?
- adamtait 10y agoThere's a team of scientists in the arctic who have an unconventional but (possibly) effective idea to reduce/slow the release of permafrost methane. The Zimov's have a Kickstarter up now - https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/907484977/pleistocene-park-an-ice-age-ecosystem-to-save-the https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/907484977/pleistocene-p...
- harwoodleon 10y agoThe news services wont report this because it's not an immediate threat. This surely is a case now for stopping flying. If everyone made a conscious decision not to fly, be a bit inconvenienced, this would lessen the chance of this and other catastrophic events taking place.
- alvern 10y agoHere is a list of articles so far about methane capture and biogas. This is lab based experiments in small quantities (~50ml) but it could be scaled up. So in a foggy smog future where we all live in domes, these methane processors could slowly grab the energy back from the atmosphere. [1] https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn18977-innovation-methane-capture-gives-more-bang-for-the-buck/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn18977-innovation-meth... [2] http://pubs.rsc.org/en/Content/ArticleLanding/2008/CC/b804405h#!divAbstract http://pubs.rsc.org/en/Content/ArticleLanding/2008/CC/b80440... [3]http://www.rsc.org/suppdata/cc/b8/b804405h/b804405h.pdf http://www.rsc.org/suppdata/cc/b8/b804405h/b804405h.pdf
- teslaberry 10y agoTHE WORLD IS GOING TO END. OMG!!!!!!!!!!!! a brainwashed generation unable to prioritize reality now, believe that 'science' has gifted them a version of the apocolypse they can believe will bring the end of times , but hey-------this isn't a religion or end times cult. ....right?
- otempomores 10y agoCould those methan bubbles be burned off with a torch drone.?
- stefek99 10y agoHighly recommended: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Pinchbeck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Pinchbeck How Soon Is Now? The book outlines the changes to our technical infrastructure - agriculture, energy, industry - and our social, political, and economic system that Pinchbeck deems necessary to avoid the worst consequences of global warming, species extinction, and so on.