21 ms·
China has built the world’s largest bullet-train network
- bainsfather 10y ago"Less than a decade ago China had yet to connect any of its cities by bullet train. Today, it has 20,000km (12,500 miles) of high-speed rail lines, more than the rest of the world combined. It is planning to lay another 15,000km by 2025" The contrast to the UK, where we might someday build the HS2 line London-Birmingham-Manchester, is massive. I am left with a feeling of awe at China's development, and frustration at the UK's stagnancy.
- ealexhudson 10y agoChina is huge, though, and the UK is not. HS2 is dragging in the UK because it's a massive amount of money to spend in order to shave 45m off a trip to Scotland. The cost/benefit ratio is totally different - and with the Hitachi training they're bringing in, the saving goes further down. HS2 is a large waste of money.
- digi_owl 10y agoHuge, and authoritarian. They move whole cities worth of people when it comes time to build a hydroelectric dam, by force if need be. The west in comparison gets bogged down in NIMBYism and haggling over land value pr CM of track/road. Never mind multiple rounds in court if one of the would be contractors can find any reason to claim the government was biased...
- hneans 10y agolol, figure out where the railway line passes, please. And How the railway was laid, with BRIDGE, ok? In the process of laying railways, engineers try to avoid residential areas or farmland. if it comes to the pinch, then build a bridge.
- sjg007 10y agothe USA moved towns to dam rivers too.
- jerf 10y agoAnd the UK used to do things too. Your past tense is correct. Whether this is a good or bad thing, well, see debates in other comments.
- crdoconnor 10y agoRail is typically never profitable unless the increase in land value around stations is captured. In the UK they typically leave those spoils to private land owners. Japanese rail companies manage this: they run the trains at cost - or even a loss - and make profits back from (for example), building malls around the stations and leasing space to retailers. The UK could really use high speed rail around the London commuter belt. If land value increases are captured it would probably pay for itself, in fact.
- mafribe 10y agoRail is typically never profitable unless the increase in land value around stations is captured. This is really interesting. Have you got a pointer for me where I can read more on the economics of railways along those lines? I wonder if the same is also true with public transport in cities, in particular rail-based underground system like London's tube.
- claudius 10y agoRoad-building is also not profitable unless you capture the increase in land value around roads. Curiously, most people are okay with tax-funded roads and streets but strongly oppose spending public funds on trains. Of course, ideally both would be run exactly at cost via user fees (i.e. train tickets, tolls etc.), but this is not an often-shared opinion.
- crdoconnor 10y ago>Curiously, most people are okay with tax-funded roads and streets but strongly oppose spending public funds on trains. Actually the public is strongly in favor of spending public funds on trains, but the British oligarchy (reflected by the media's default opinion - which some people confuse for the public's), is vehemently against it: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11867259/What-Jeremy-Corbyn-doesnt-get-is-that-the-government-causes-most-of-the-problems.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/11867259/What-J... Note the Telegraph accusing the general public of being communists: "the majority of the electorate who have no love for bankers and are positively Trotskyist when it comes to trains and utilities" "A recent YouGov poll showed that the majority of people support the renationalisation of railways, including those who identified themselves as Conservative or UKIP voters." >Of course, ideally both would be run exactly at cost via user fees Why are you against capturing the increased land value like Japan does?
- davepav 10y agoSmaller countries in Asia have also implemented HS railway really well. I visited Taiwan last year and was in awe at how good their rail network was.
- robin_reala 10y agoWe’ve invited them to bid though: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/118bn-hs2-bidding-process-opens https://www.gov.uk/government/news/118bn-hs2-bidding-process...
- pjc50 10y agoHS2 is not so much about speed as capacity. It does not replace the existing lines, it adds to them. That's why it's been so controversial - it puts railway where there was none. It turns Coventry and Birmingham into London commuter suburbs.
- grw_ 10y agoCapacity is only needed for short periods at peak times, which could be achieved by e.g running more standard-class carriages instead of first class. [0] Since you mentioned Coventry, it's intercity capacity to London will actually be reduced if HS2 comes to be due to extra trains to Birmingham occupying the track. Same for many other towns and cities in the Midlands. [1] [0] https://beleben.wordpress.com/2016/04/05/friday-capacity-to-spare/ https://beleben.wordpress.com/2016/04/05/friday-capacity-to-... [1] http://stophs2.org/news/13115-13115 http://stophs2.org/news/13115-13115
- new299 10y agoForget high speed rail. It would be great if the trains weren't 30+ years old. On the lines I most often use the carriages don't have automatic doors. I'm constantly embarrassed when I have to show visitors how to open the window, stick their hand out and use the handle on the outside to open the door (which is how it's done).
- flukus 10y agoAt least they've still got windows. Around here you have to put up with aircon that doesn't work in summer and a heater that's turned up way to high in winter. I find the older ones with windows provided much better temperature control.
- kriro 10y agoOn the plus side this is actually an example in the usability classic "The Design of Everyday Things". Iirc Norman concludes that he doesn't have a clue as to why they were designed that way and offers some hypotheses which he dismisses right away (book is at home so I can't check) :D
- huxley 10y agoA little off topic, but anyone interested in picking up "The Design of Everyday Things" be aware it was previously published as "The Psychology of Everyday Things". There was an expanded and updated edition in 2013 so you should probably look for that one.
- pjc50 10y agoIs that the Intercity 125 trains? Modern ones have generally fixed this.
- aninhumer 10y agoOf course, but the point is that these old ones haven't been replaced yet.
- pyb 10y ago
- mseebach 10y ago> I am left with a feeling of awe at China's development, and frustration at the UK's stagnancy. While the UK does feel particularly stagnated on several fronts, I'm not sure abandoning the rule of law, protection of private property, labour protections, at least an attempt at the appearance of corruption-free tenders, high safety standards and the principle that people who are affected should be consulted is worthy of much awe.
- peteretep 10y agoI don't see why getting HS2 built quickly needs any of those abandoning, other than perhaps land seized through eminent domain?
- pjc50 10y agoThe consultations took a long time, and inevitably involved demolishing minor historic buildings. The UK devotes a lot of effort to preservation where China devotes almost none. The price of cities popping up like desert flowers is the sweeping away of entire villages of traditional buildings. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/15/hs2-rail-archaeologists-english-heritage-environment https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/mar/15/hs2-rail-arc...
- peteretep 10y agoI've been to a lot of National Trust and English Heritage houses. The country is lousy with them. I feel sure one or two can be parted with. This isn't America where anything over 100 years is automatically some kind of national monument. We sold them London Bridge, can't we offload a Little Pifflington Stately Home or two?
- pjc50 10y agoThis is unlikely to be popular with the voters. Not an issue in China, of course.
- bainsfather 10y ago
- hacker_9 10y agoDeveloping anything outside London is often not a priority for the government.
- lmm 10y agoHS2 goes to London so that's a dubious explanation.
- schuke 10y agoThere's also, I guess, a diminishing return for infrastructure investments in a highly-developed country like the UK, especially when it's much smaller than China. That said though, it's a shame Heathrow still can't get the extra runway it desperately needs...
- Symbiote 10y agoIt's a shame Heathrow's terminal buildings have been rebuilt in the last 15 years, rather than shut down with an airport in a sensible place constructed to replace it. The noise of flights landing over London for 17 hours a day, pretty much every 90-120 seconds, is miserable.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Markoff 10y agoit's easy to grow from rock bottom
- djsumdog 10y agoI've only briefly been in the UK, but I really liked the rail system. It's far better than that of other countries I've lived in. I've gone London-Manchester and back and found it a delightful experience.
- gred 10y ago> I am left with a feeling of awe at China's development, and frustration at the UK's stagnancy. To be fair, the UK was overspending on railway long before it was cool :-) From Edward Chancellor's "Devil Take the Hindmost" [1]: > In January 1845, sixteen new railway schemes were projected. By April, with rail receipts continuing to grow rapidly, over fifty new companies had been registered... > By June 1845, plans for over eight thousand miles of new railway -- four times the size of the existing railway system and nearly twenty times the length of England -- were under consideration by the Board of Trade. In the following month, new schemes appeared at the rate of over a dozen a week. > At the end of October [...] over twelve hundred railways were being projected at an estimated cost of over £560 million. The total amount of outstanding railway liabilities was nearly £600 million. This figure exceeded the national income, estimated at around £550 million, of which perhaps £20 million a year could be spent safely on the railways without starving the rest of the economy of capital. > In Britain, [...] the spirit of laissez-faire dictated that the development of the railways should be left entirely to private enterprise. The uncontrolled expansion of the railway system, in the hands of semi-criminal entrepreneurs, produced a haphazard network. For instance, by the 1850s there were three independent routes from Liverpool to Leeds and three alternative routes from London to Peterborough. > The results of the mania, however, were not entirely negative. With over 8,000 miles of track in operation by 1855, Britain possessed the highest density of railways in the world, seven times greater than that of France or Germany. [1] https://www.amazon.com/Devil-Take-Hindmost-Financial-Speculation/dp/0452281806 https://www.amazon.com/Devil-Take-Hindmost-Financial-Specula...
- b6 10y agoIs the article a bit strange? They say Liu Zhijun was "removed for corruption", which, of course, in China, does not mean anything. They mention the crash in 2011 but not that the government wrapped up rescue efforts the next day and buried the trains.
- bluedino 10y agoWhenever I hear talk of bullet trains coming to the US, I hear people say things like "Americans could easily build better trains than the Chinese." Then I remind people that they have 20,000km of track, 150 trains and how much operating experience? That's a huge head start.
- kalleboo 10y agoEven for US high speed rail, I don't think any of those trains will be designed by an American company. From Wikipedia: In February 2015 nine companies formally expressed interest in producing trainsets for the system: Alstom, AnsaldoBreda (now known as Hitachi Rail Italy), Bombardier Transportation, CSR [China South Rail], Hyundai Rotem, Kawasaki Rail Car, Siemens, Sun Group U.S.A. partnered with CNR Tangshan, and Talgo.[24] All Canadian, European, or Asian.
- bluedino 10y agoChina was going to build the Los Angeles to Las Vegas but the deal fell apart.
- djsumdog 10y agoEven though they might be foreign companies, they do tend to be built in the US. IIRC Alstom in California made all the cars for the new Florida high speed line that starts running this year. It takes a while before you can start building rolling stock domestically. Melbourne just started making their class E trams a few years back, which they tout as being "made entirely in Victoria" and yet they've had the largest tram network in the work for decades.
- jerf 10y agoActually, that existing track is part of the problem, not the solution. A new high-speed train is much easier to justify economically when you're looking at (total benefit of high-speed rail) - (cost of high speed rail) than when you're looking at ((total benefit of high-speed rail) - (total benefit of current rail)) - ((cost of high-speed rail) + (cost of removing current rail if necessary)). There's a name for this effect, but I can't remember it. Another example in the real world is the effectiveness of putting up cell towers in developing countries rather than running wires for landlines.
- Rezo 10y agoSaw this amazing photo of Chinese high-speed trains just the other day: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/chinese-head-home-in-worlds-biggest-annual-human-migration/2017/01/13/fbbaaf24-d968-11e6-a0e6-d502d6751bc8_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/chinese-he... Now that's some serious infrastructure investment!
- idm 10y agoWow. I can hardly believe what I'm looking at. We're so used to seeing one "bullet train" at a time, and even that is held as a lofty aspiration. Some day, maybe, my country might have one too. That Chinese train yard picture is so serious. Once upon a time, the Dow Jones industrial average was a composite metric designed to roughly characterize the rail industry, including steel production, machining and manufacture, real estate, and use. The health of that industry was found to be predictive of the health of the entire country, and although the DJIA shifted from rail, it is still predictive of nationwide economic health. China, in my eyes, just proved how far ahead they are - and my jaw is on the floor. Those trains represent so much. It's not merely that they exist - and all of the economic activity inherent in making them exist - but now that they exist, they are an engine of productivity. All the people who can move now...
- tuna-piano 10y agoThe picture (https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_1484w/2010-2019/Wires/Online/2017-01-13/AP/Images/APTOPIX_China_New_Year_Travel_95231.jpg-ebec7.jpg?uuid=Zant8tl2Eeag5tUC1nUbyA https://img.washingtonpost.com/rf/image_1484w/2010-2019/Wire...) was taken in Wuhan, China of more than 20 high speed trains. How many people have even heard of Wuhan before? It has a population of over 10M.
- wluu 10y agoI've heard of Wuhan before, mostly because of the Chinese tennis player Li Na [1], who was born there. She did quite well at the Australian Open for several years (including winning it once) and became quite popular with the local crowd. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Na https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Li_Na
- known 10y agoSounds like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iridium_satellite_constellatio... fiasco
- hn_news 10y agoIf USA cuts the military budget just in half (~$500bil/2=$250bil/year) then using those funds in 5 years we could connect Washington to Philadelphia to New York to Boston to Portland. In another 5 years the rail could reach Chicago or Carolinas. Traveling at 186mph on passenger speed train i could easily work in New York City (dirty city, median home price $750,000) and live in the burbs near the ocean near New Heaven CT (25min commute, beautiful nature and median home price 161,000$). Teachers could finally afford homes... while working in the expensive cities. But this is not going to happen. Instead we are going to build more sophisticated weapon systems... enrich military contractors, financial sector and pharmaceutical industries.
- 010001001010 10y ago"High-speed rail (HSR) is best suited for journeys of 1 to 4½ hours (about 150–900 km or 93–559 mi)" https://www.travelstatsman.com/08082016/high-speed-rail-train-plane/ https://www.travelstatsman.com/08082016/high-speed-rail-trai... ... perfectly suited to link China's smaller cities, but not direct connections to it's major cities. Maybe driven more by environmental reasons (arguably fewer emissions than plane travel) rather than economic reasons (besides job creation, etc).
- Symmetry 10y agoFor even half full inter-city trains I don't think there's any doubt about which is more energy efficient. Trains will tend to win by about an order of magnitude. Planes aren't any worse than cars containing a single person, though. https://www.withouthotair.com/c20/page_128.shtml https://www.withouthotair.com/c20/page_128.shtml
- transfire 10y agoWhat a pathetic Debbie Downer article -- quintessential modern America. Most of the article just keeps beating the cost drum -- trains don't generate enough ticket revenue to cover their cost. Meanwhile the U.S. taxpayer givers $41.0 billion a year to the Federal Highway Administration, and most roads don't generate a single dime of revenue.
- drawkbox 10y agoRoads, originally an Eisenhower idea [1] as car culture was 'railroaded' in so to speak to win over trains, generate tons of indirect revenue. People and businesses on either side and up and down every road generate revenue because of it. Same with the internet, trains etc. You don't have to generate revenue directly from the thing for it to be a great idea. Bean counting away from indirect benefits seems to be overly-existent in our short-term planning modern US culture (not focusing on true investments enough like infrastructure, i.e. broadband etc). Our interstate systems have been huge benefits even though trains would be nice as well, Amtrak is not competitive. The interstate system is probably the best thing Ike ever did, good infrastructure projects leave a great legacy and are overlooked. It fueled economic growth across the nation as well as served as helping with defense. [1] https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/finalmap.cfm https://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/finalmap.cfm
- ascotan 10y agoUnless it's a private highway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_highways_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_highways_in_the_United... However, I'm not a big fan of toll roads myself.
- phairoh 10y agoThe Economist is headquartered in London and as the publication's name implies it commonly focusses on the economical impact of any story it reports. They also don't hide the fact that their editorial positions are rooted in classical liberal economics.
- jsudhams 10y agoNot sure all countries have to follow this, china must have done this to compensate the growth hence the infra projects with in countries help. I think other countries rather than spending money on this can develop meaning full telecom infrastructure to villages (connecting all of them) and ensure population is spread out and people continue to there where they are than flocking to cities.
- jarboot 10y agoCurrently in China and frequently using the train system here. I really wish something like this could happen in a country as big as the US. What's stopping them? Politicians? Land rights? Lack of resources?
- vkou 10y agoThe United States would rather let an oil company build a pipeline on your land, then a rail company build a high speed train track on it. Oil is prioritized over rail because it immediately creates jobs, tax dollars, and the government doesn't have to pay up front for it. If you're a politician, which one would you want to support?
- jdpedrie 10y ago> oil company build a pipeline This happens. > rail company build a high speed train track This doesn't. There are actually companies that want to build oil pipelines. How many privately funded companies are there that want to (and have the means to) build a high-speed rail line?
- jungturk 10y agoThere's one in Texas attempting to do so: http://www.texascentral.com/project/ http://www.texascentral.com/project/ Serious hyperloop contenders may well emerge soon, too.
- jdpedrie 10y agoI'd love to see that rail happen. Nowhere near Texas, but it would be cool. That said, Texas isn't really representative of the rest of the country.
- vkou 10y agoHow many privately funded companies would even consider doing so in the current regulatory climate? There's a bit of survivourship bias at play, here! Likewise, if the oil were extracted by the state, rather then a private firm, it would also not have any problems with piping it over private property.
- nacc 10y agoAs someone who grew in China, I just want to point out that besides the engineering, it is a political wonder as well. Before the bullet train network was built, China already has an extensive railway network. The first step is to run the bullet train on traditional railways, with a peak speed of 180km/h. People think it's great. No objections. But to raise the speed further, a new network has to be built, almost side-by-side to traditional railways. This idea horrored almost everybody: new railways for 10s of thousands kms, new train stations (yes for most of the place it needs a separate station), just to be a bit faster? Of course it got a constant concensual blaze from both the citizens and all the official and unofficial media. This state maintains from the beginning of the project all the way a couple years into it operates (which spans many years). The head of the project, Liu Zhijun had to be in jail of course. Then everything changes, 180 degree. People took the trains and realize it's great. What I (and probably many people too) didn't know before was with the speed increase, the perception of distance changes. The trains run like buses: between major cities, the train runs across in every several minutes. You can just get a ticket, go to the station, an hour later you are on the subway of another city. Many times when we were holding a meeting, people from other cities actually took less time to arrive than someone driving from suburbs. Then the new railway network gets praise from both national and overseas. The official media shut up about Liu. People start to think Liu as a fanatically great engineer. I cannot imagine how this project can even get started, and what Liu had to do to get this to work. There must have been a great story, but we may never know.
- sandworm101 10y agoBut what percentage of the population actually uses a bullet train in a given week/month/year? (Not trips/population, the percentage of people who take one or more journies in a given timeframe.) Is this just a service for the urban elite? Or do farmers also use them? The 747 and like jets made air travel affordable and now air travel is cheaper than by boat/rail over long distances (for people, taking into account food and lodging). If you need to attend a wedding more than a few hundred km away, you are going to consider flying. But high speed rail networks in many countries (uk, france) are either extreemly expensive or massively subsidized. All i see are suited office workers heading to jobs in downtown cores. The carbon footprint of high speed rail, while not as bad as air, also remains much higher than other ground options. Speed always comes at some price.
- brohee 10y agoI love how the Economist map misses a 50M people municipality (Chongqing). Shows how little the world knows about China...
- ajmurmann 10y agoHaving been there I think it's hugely inflated. Chongqing isn't really a giant city but a large city with a huge rural area around it that has been declared to be part of the city now. Not sure why that even happened. Maybe so that it can become a special trade zone without much political work?
- brohee 10y ago30M of the 50M people of the municipality are urban, but yes it's more a large conurbation than a city proper.
- ajmurmann 10y agoOh wow, according to wiki you are right and it's larger than Shanghai which I would have never thought. I guess the city feels smaller because of the central peninsula.
- brilliantcode 10y agochabuduo is the tradition of cutting corners long formed as the basis for china's fast economic growth. you can build the largest and the biggest infrastructures in the world as fast as possible but it won't be the longest lasting structure which NOT what current day china is about.
- FabHK 10y ago"good enough", if you don't want to google
- Markoff 10y agoas someone who lived better half of decade in China I don't find it that amazing 1. growth of HSR meant less and less slower trains = higher prices of tickets, less available to poorer people 2. prices of these train tickets are actually higher than LCC airways in Europe which will transport me much faster anywhere than HSR 3. buying ticket during peak periods is very difficult 4. train station procedures take probably more time than airport procedures (even within China, much longer compared to Schengen) 5. many of not most of the HSR stations are outside of the cities, so there is no benefit between reaching HSR station and airport
- djsumdog 10y agoWait, so you have full security screenings for the high speed rail? (Most of Europe's high speed rail goes through the same train stations and standard commuter rail, so there's no additional screening .. although if you're crossing from Belgium to Germany they do often search trains for marijuana) at border stations.
- IshKebab 10y agoThere's additional screening in Spain too. Though I recall it was a token effort.
- Markoff 10y agoyes, there is first check to get even inside train station, you must have ticket, then right after that is security check, then in some stations there is another check to enter boarding room, then to leave boarding room to platform there is another check and then in the train they check your ticket again, also when leaving station in destination they will again check your ticket to let you go it's HSR with communist characteristics no thanks, i will rather use show train in Europe where i can walk straight from my room to train with ticket in my mobile instead of Chinese harassment with thousands of people pushing you all around, it's just one disgusting experience, even Chinese airports are faster and more pleasant
- NotUsingLinux 10y agoWhile I applaud the effort. It's almost obsolete now. When they have a Hyperloop Network then I will be impressed, but given how things look, they will have it before the US..
- joshiej 10y agoReminds me of the board game Ticket To Ride haha
- BurningFrog 10y agoMeanwhile, San Francisco spent 13 years on an Environmental Impact Report for one bus line: http://www.sfexaminer.com/transit-officials-approve-final-eir-geary-bus-project/ http://www.sfexaminer.com/transit-officials-approve-final-ei...
- xbeta 10y ago(Being a Chinese grew up in Canada, and now working/living in the Bay) In my opinion, most people in the valley or in North America still refuse to give up their lifestyle. They look for something like self-driving cars, all electric-powered "personal" vehicle to invest. And those still drive on the same road/interstates/highway infrastructure and don't give you the benefits compare with high-speed rails. They don't recognize the real priorities - how to transport millions people everyday efficiently, cost-effectively, and most environmentally friendlies. They also don't recognize local economy, local businesses thrive with these connected network. It is proven to be the case in China and Japan. High-speed rail network is what people want - to get from point A to point B quickly. It's not something even the most efficient self-driving car with the best MPG electric-powered vehicle can scale for millions of people everyday. Instead of investing into some new technologies, they seem like they refuse to take decades of proven technology and just use it in US (high-speed trains were first invented in Japan in the 60s) But as I understand very well in the culture here, the politics, the corruption, and the oil/automative conglomerate will never make this happen for the actual good for the people. I would without a doubt to say the US is in its downfall as it didn't pick the priorities to fix the root of the problem.
- adventured 10y agoThe US is in fact ascendant, not in decline. You're using the rail example to imply downfall, and yet the US economy has embarrassed the Japanese economy the last 25 years. In the mid 1980s, the US and Japan nearly had the same GDP per capita; very soon the US will have twice the GDP per capita of Japan. You're implying rail is so beneficial to economic growth, and let's say I agree with that: and yet the US has been embarrassing most of Europe on economic growth for the last 20 years (Germany's economy hasn't expanded in ten years for example). If you were right, US GDP per capita should be far lower than the EU or Eurozone, when the exact opposite is the case. Germany has a GDP per capita of the poorest US states (it's nearly on par with West Virginia currently). France nearly has the GDP per capita of Puerto Rico. I don't believe your premise has any legs to stand on based on the facts. The real implication here is that the US would be staggeringly far ahead if it corrected some of its obvious flaws.
- 10y ago
- joering2 10y agoThis looks great but I honestly wonder - if China is under heavy communism oppression and noone can make enough fuzz about their lifestyle before eventually disappearing... why would Chinese government care about spending money and time building such vast (and beautiful!) network? Serious question...
- _jgdh 10y ago> This looks great but I honestly wonder - if China is under heavy communism oppression and noone can make enough fuzz about their lifestyle before eventually disappearing... why would Chinese government care about spending money and time building such vast (and beautiful!) network? Serious question... China isn't under heavy communist oppression, not the kind that you're thinking. Their style of oppression is different. The Social Contract that the Party offers the People is this - you will not get political choice, you will always be ruled by us; in return you will not have to worry about money because this economy will grow at 7.5%pa. That rising tide will lift all boats, including yours. When all your material needs are taken care of, do you really care who is in charge? Projects such as high speed rail help the Party deliver on its promise. The Economist points out the ways in which this boosts economic growth, as well as other bonus effects, like allowing people to buy affordable housing in smaller cities that are short commutes away from Beijing/Shaghai and other major cities. If the Party doesn't hold its end of the Contract up, it risks mass unrest, similar to the Tiananmen Square protests. That ought to answer your question. The interesting question is whether their Social Contract will survive. So far, the people are generally satisfied with the Party's performance but in the years to come growth will inevitably slow, if only because their economy is so massive that compounded growth is difficult. I think the strategy is that by then the Party will have a much more efficient way of enforcing control over individuals than they did in 1989 when the Tiananmen protests took place Rather than crude measures like locking people up or beating them, the Party will use the social score [1] to subtly control the People. If you know that your house payments will rise, or your medical care will be deprioritized, or your friends will ostracize you, or you'll face harassment from strangers or you won't be able to apply to good schools for your children, or all of the above... will you still have the courage to show up to protest, much less stand in front of a column of tanks? [2] [1] - http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21711904-worrying-experiments-new-form-social-control-chinas-digital-dictatorship http://www.economist.com/news/leaders/21711904-worrying-expe... [2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_Man
- MarkMc 10y agoThese days when I travel on a train I can work efficiently, play computer games, Skype my family or watch a movie - the personal cost of a slow train compared to a fast train isn't as high as it used to be. So maybe technology has reduced the economic benefit of a bullet-train network.
- bigger_cheese 10y agoI'd love it if we could do something like this on the east coast of Australia. I doubt it will ever happen. I fly between Sydney and Melbourne fairly regularly and it can be a real pain. Sydney -> Melbourne route is one of the busiest air corridors in the world so demand would probably be there.
- dfguo 10y agoThe article merely touches the economic benefits. There is also another elephant in the room which wasn't mentioned - fast way to transport army. All the bullet-train rail are capable of transporting tanks. This will allow overnight transfer of army to any city in China.