29 ms·
Lawsuit: Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer led illegal purge of male workers
- grawlinson 10y agoWith all the hubbub surrounding Mayer/Yahoo, why hasn't the board or shareholders fired her?
- matt4077 10y agoMostly because there are people with opinions that differ from the hn/reddit echo chamber. Nobody denies that yahoo failed, but most people also believe that it's fate was sealed the day it refused to buy google, and that she did about as well as anybody would have. ...but also: she'd get a 60$ million bonus if fired, and considering that yahoo has already lost 90% of its former value and is being sold of, people probably stopped caring.
- CalChris 10y agoYahoo refused to buy Google? I don't remember that. In 2000, when Yahoo signed the deal to use Google search results, they also made an investment as well. IIRC, they sold that when Google went public. Obviously, Yahoo made a ton on that.
- josephg 10y agoLarry and Sergey tried selling their pagerank engine to Yahoo back in 1998, before they formed Google. Yahoo wasn't interested. They founded google as a fallback plan after being turned down.
- rgbrenner 10y agohttps://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-Yahoo-turned-down-an-offer-to-buy-Google-for-around-1-million-in-1998 https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-Yahoo-turned-down-an-o... there was also a time a few years later, when yahoo offered 3b for google: https://www.wired.com/2007/02/yahoo-3/ https://www.wired.com/2007/02/yahoo-3/
- throwaway_exer 10y ago1. The Google founders initially tried to sell Pagerank to Yahoo for $1 billion when Google was just a search research company. 2. Later, Yahoo bought goto.com before Adwords came out. Adwords infringed on goto's patents. Google ended up giving a few hundred million to Yahoo.
- merpnderp 10y agoIsn't that bonus peanuts to the incredibly bad deal she signed with Mozilla? I love Mozilla so was happy when Yahoo got outmaneuvered on that deal, but she certainly didn't "[do] about as well as anybody would have" on that deal.
- protomyth 10y agoI would think the the board of Yahoo believes that since it is selling the company anyway they should let the new buyer pay the golden parachute instead of the existing stock holders.
- meddlepal 10y agoYahoo is in full self-destruct mode this week.
- baby 10y agoSomeone could wonder if all this is being triggered by people with an agenda.
- meddlepal 10y agoTo what end? Yahoo is dead and being purchased by Verizon already for an agreed upon price. I guess they could back out, but that seems unlikely.
- sytse 10y agoNot totally unlikely https://techcrunch.com/2016/10/06/report-verizon-wants-1-billion-discount-after-yahoo-privacy-concerns/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/10/06/report-verizon-wants-1-bil...
- DiabloD3 10y agoAnother version of the story made it to the HN frontpage: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12657576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12657576
- Pyxl101 10y agoThe threat of impending or active litigation will make Verizon reluctant to close a deal with Yahoo. It's new downside risk for Verizon that they have no desire to take on. Verizon may ask that Yahoo settle the lawsuit before closing the sale. So, it may be that the lawsuit was timed to put maximum pressure on Yahoo to settle, by creating risk of jeopardizing their sale.
- simonh 10y agoManagement is responsible for every aspect of how an organization functions and operates. When management fails this comprehensively, it's not unusual for the organization to fail in multiple different ways. But Yahoo has been on this trajectory since long before Mayer joined them. They are to internet services what Blackberry was to mobile devices. They were a transitional platform, just advanced enough from the old platforms (CompuServe, AOL) to succeed when they failed, but too like them to succeed once the industry transitioned to the new paradigm.
- Moshe_Silnorin 10y agoThis seems to be a self-policing crime.
- argonaut 10y agoI'm extra-suspicious of this lawsuit because of the opportunistic timing. He was fired in January 2015, more than 1.5 years ago. And yet the lawsuit is only filed now during Verizon's process of closing its acquisition of Yahoo. Whether or not he has a case, his motives now have an antagonistic taint because he no doubt timed this to maximize the PR damage and his chances of getting a quick settlement.
- matt4077 10y agoIf the article is a good preview of the case, it does seem to be bullshit... The mechanism by which this discrimination supposedly happen was the stack ranking feedback system. Now I believe stack ranking is stupid and somewhat cruel. But I don't see how it allows more discrimination than other grading systems. The lawsuit also doesn't claim intent and it'd be quite a stretch to assign liability to the CEO for hard-to-prove unintentional side effect.
- apr 10y agoNow, once the lawsuit is filed, he gets to do discovery. And if some exec at Yahoo has ever said something over email to the effect of aggressively promoting women, and, given the current set of beliefs in the Valley, it is hard to believe nothing would turn up, the guy might have struck gold here.
- joeax 10y agoBecause performance reviews are highly subjective to begin with, you can easily hide discrimination behind the guise of stack ranking. It's easy to prove liability, she is CEO she has all this performance data at her fingertips.
- int_19h 10y agoIf the lawsuit is to be believed, it's a stack ranking system with some unusual twists - most notably, the part where higher ranking managers can arbitrarily change ranking scores of anyone under them, bypassing their direct managers. He gives a specific example where scores of several people were decreased from above with no explanation, and seemingly no clear basis other than gender.
- rdtsc 10y ago> “We believe this process allows our team to develop and do their best work. Our performance-review process also allows for high performers to engage in increasingly larger opportunities at our company" Ok so has that worked out well for Yahoo? Clearly it's been enough time by now to do an evaluation of Yahoo practices looking back and say something like: "Yeah thanks to these great management practices we have reconquered market share / are the new exciting place where everyone wants to work / or we lead this revolutionary research"? It ended up being owned by a phone company in the end. So if Yahoo is a failing company, what they did there, will be associated with failure. It seems they effectively moved the cause of promoting women in technology fields backwards. When someone will say "we should find a way to promote women more" ... "Oh, right, Yahoo was heavily into that, yeah that was ugly, the lawsuit and all...". It is a bit like the crazy person advocating for your favorite language or framework, it's nice to have a fan, but because they are crazy, they are pushing everyone away with their behavior. > as well as for low performers to be transitioned out.” "Transitioned out" ... there is an almost a positive ring to it. "We've reached out to them, found their pain points and helped them transition out to a new stage". Is that how everyone talks now? Or is it just me who finds it grating.
- kevinastone 10y agoI'm more used to "managed out", but same euphemism.
- matt4077 10y agoYou remind me of that old joke: When a girl fails in math class, it's "women are bad at math". When a guy fails, it's "John is really stupid".
- taneq 10y agoBut when someone says "diversity is automatically good so we'll form a maths class with mostly women" and that maths class gets poor grades, it doesn't help further the notion that "more women equals better performance".
- 10y ago
- melindajb 10y agoAnyone who was unkind to Ellen Pao should really be rethinking themselves about now. Edit: Hn thread: why is diversity so important? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12576806 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12576806 Me: if diversity is not important than this lawsuit is a joke and HN should be laughing at this lawsuit.
- grawlinson 10y agoWhat's this in reference to? I don't really follow the manglement part of tech as close as I probably should.
- melindajb 10y agoYes, we know how hacker news feels about women.
- sctb 10y agoPlease don't post deliberately inflammatory generalizations about the community. It only serves to make the discussions predictably worse and ruins the threads for everyone.
- matt4077 10y agoFunny you should mention her. I'm 100% sure that it can't be coincidence that the only "really bad CEOs" I keep hearing about on social media are Pao, Meyers and Elizabeth Holmes. But people really don't react kindly to accusations of sexism without proof. I wonder how unlikely it is that the 90% of male CEOs in high tech are all exemplary.
- protomyth 10y agoYou must be reading different social media then me since there are plenty examples of bad male CEOs. Isn't there a Twitter article on the main page? HP is a special case as they have had a run of awful CEOs (the SAP guy being one of the worst) and most damaging a criminal board. I think the jury is still out on Meyers. Holmes is basically a criminal. Not one has approached SCO or Enron bad. There are plenty of sucky male CEOs out there. [edit: seems the male Backpack CEO made the front page doing something far worse]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- pcurve 10y ago“..less than 20 percent female. Within a year and a half those top managers were more than 80 percent female,” Even if they were not deliberate about it, they must have talked about how this might be perceived by employees. As bad as this issue is, I think hiring friend/referral/former colleague, especially en mass is much bigger issue that's rarely talked about because it's not necessarily illegal. However, I cannot overemphasize how demoralizing it is, especially when they aren't proven to be any better.
- blazespin 10y agoI am OK with this. What annoys me is the discrimination against non asians happening in the valley these days. I mean, gee wilikers.
- orly_bookz 10y agoSurely you mean non-whites and non-asians. Caucasians are still a huge portion of the Silicon Valley work force. It's women, hispanics, and african americans who make up some tiny percentage...
- ralusek 10y agoAre you so sure that there are fewer women, hispanics, and African Americans in Silicon Valley because of discrimination, specifically?
- Buge 10y agoDo you have a source for the discrimination? Palantir was recently accused of discrimination against Asians because they hire them at a much lower rate. https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/26/regulators-accuse-palantir-of-discriminating-against-asian-applicants/ https://www.mercurynews.com/2016/09/26/regulators-accuse-pal...
- dgudkov 10y ago>hiring friend/referral/former colleague, especially en mass is much bigger issue that's rarely talked about because it's not necessarily illegal. And it's not necessarily wrong.
- GirlsCanCode 10y agoIt won't be illegal anymore if Hillary gets her platform implemented. The first thing she said during the first debate was she wants the Law to make sure that if you take the average woman's salary, ignoring all factors, it should be the same as the average men's salary. Given that women major in "Gender Studies" and men major in Engineering, the only way to achieve that is have significant numbers of men unemployed.
- aq3cn 10y agoWow, so many different news about the same tech company within a month and now this one too. They could not have pulled a better stunt to compete with what Apple and Google is doing in their keynote. http://gizmodo.com/7-of-yahoos-biggest-fuck-ups-1745729341 http://gizmodo.com/7-of-yahoos-biggest-fuck-ups-1745729341 http://gizmodo.com/how-yahoo-totally-blew-it-on-security-1787177844 http://gizmodo.com/how-yahoo-totally-blew-it-on-security-178... http://gizmodo.com/heres-what-happened-to-all-of-marissa-mayers-yahoo-acqu-1781980352 http://gizmodo.com/heres-what-happened-to-all-of-marissa-may... http://gizmodo.com/yahoo-secretly-scanned-users-emails-for-the-nsa-and-fbi-1787401845 http://gizmodo.com/yahoo-secretly-scanned-users-emails-for-t... http://gizmodo.com/state-sponsored-hackers-stole-personal-information-from-1786958663 http://gizmodo.com/state-sponsored-hackers-stole-personal-in... http://gizmodo.com/sad-yahoo-sale-confirms-that-marissa-mayer-failed-1784155301 http://gizmodo.com/sad-yahoo-sale-confirms-that-marissa-maye... http://gizmodo.com/the-internet-is-targeting-yahoo-for-fostering-an-illega-1755162398 http://gizmodo.com/the-internet-is-targeting-yahoo-for-foste... I almost felt sorry for them when I read articles like that it's the saddest deal in history as they could got more much money earlier. Now, I feel good that they are gone. fuff .. gone .. I need to take care of my Flickr account now.
- spydum 10y agoYou have to wonder if there is some sort of campaign to smear yahoo? The timing does seem strange, but perhaps it's simply because they are under so much scrutiny because of the eventual sale?
- TheDrizzle43 10y agoYahoo and Twitter have been getting torn apart the past few weeks, coincidentally when they are selling. Probably a little bit of column A and column B.
- talmand 10y agoPossibly an effort to reduce the price.
- aq3cn 10y agoI have these speculations: 1. Tech giants are making room for themselves. 2. Their employees (male ones especially) are unhappy with deal, so they are attacking it. 3. Verizon is doing this to get discount. 4. CEO does not care about hiding lies anymore, she wants to be fired to get her money and may be she has lost control over her employees. 5. (highly improbable) They want users to delete their accounts due this kind of bad press.
- joeax 10y agoI was once a fan of Mayer when she first took over Yahoo, until she led a crusade against remote workers. As a remote worker myself I can tell you this crusade sent ripples throughout the industry. A lot of tech companies (especially outside the bay area) want to emulate the cool kids like Yahoo, Google, and Apple, and even the company I work for started questioning its WFH policies. So no, I don't feel sorry for her one bit.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoDude, Yahoo stopped being a "cool kid" a decade ago. That's really messed up if your company actually thinks it should emulate Yahoo because it's a cool company.
- joeax 10y agoI never said my company emulates Yahoo. But "cool kid" or not their influence cannot be understated. Right after the Yahoo/WFH hoopla companies like Best Buy and HP followed suit. Remember this was back when she first took over CEO and everyone believed she was the "one" to turnaround the company.
- IndianAstronaut 10y agoI know someone at HP who suddenly had to go in to work. This put him in a situation where he had to pay thousands for day care and he threatened to leave until they finally let him work from home again.
- doublescoop 10y agoSo, an employee was doubling as a full time care giver for his children while remote working? That sounds like exactly the kind of practice that gives remote work policies a bad name in the first place. If I found out one of my employees was taking care of his kids while working at home, you better believe it would result in a conversation and a possible revocation of his use of the remote work policy.
- Steeeve 10y agoThere's a bizarre amount of negative Yahoo news lately, and a lot of it references Mayer directly. I wonder if Verizon isn't trying to shed her and her departure bonus.
- smegel 10y agoThose Jews have been accruing money and power for so long now, it's about time they were cut down to size. Men, I mean men.
- png_hero 10y agoI guess this is where someone gets shadow banned for using the word "cuck" ??
- bajsejohannes 10y agoBetter title: "Lawsuit: Yahoo CEO Marissa Mayer accused of illegal purge of male workers". An accusation is very different from a verdict.
- dschuetz 10y agoDoes anyone here even use Yahoo's products or services? I wonder why Yahoo is still significant and why there are stockholders dumb enough to stay. Yahoo is a sinking ship, imho.
- grawlinson 10y agoYes. I used Flickr before Yahoo purchased it, and have watched Yahoo ruin it. I've tried alternatives (Instagram, 500px) but keep coming back to Flickr because I just prefer it to the rest. Over the last couple of months, I have started migrating my photos/contacts to other photo sharing networks in anticipation of the eventual straw that broke the camels back.
- dschuetz 10y agoSo did I. Same goes for Tumblr.
- fenomas 10y agoYahoo services (like the core branded stuff, not Flickr etc.) are still really popular here in Japan. News/entertainment content, and yahoo shopping all seem to be well-liked. I don't know any numbers but I wouldn't be surprised if it leads gmail as an email provider.
- gaius 10y agoYahoo Japan is a separate entity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- NovaS1X 10y agoI used Flickr for a long time but moved to 500px as the whole site is just significantly better than Flickr. So no not anymore I guess. Why would I use Yahoo for anything?
- iamleppert 10y agoJust reading this brought back memories of working at LinkedIn, and why I'll never again work for a company who has institutional performance review processes. That pretty much excludes all big tech companies and I'm perfectly fine with that. The cookie-cutter performance review process is impersonal and has absolutely nothing to do with helping people do their best work. In my case, I had a manager who simply didn't like me because I'm gay and used the performance review process, and eventually put me on an action plan and forced me to quit. Most of the big tech companies will put you on something called a PIP, which is a "Performance Improvement Plan". It basically means they are preparing to fire you, but they give you an option: quit now, and you can have some severance, or you could try and stay and complete the PIP, but still run the risk of being fired for any reason, and in that case, you get no severance. It's exactly what happened to me, and I decided it wasn't worth the stress to try and stay and fight it so I just quit. It was the most demoralizing experience ever, and really showed me that these processes are in place so managers can just get rid of people they don't want or like.
- tomerv 10y agoWhat's the alternative? I assume that you expect companies to promote/fire based on performance. How can you do that without a performance review process? My experience has been that the biggest factor is your direct manager. If your manager hates you, then you have a serious problem, because no matter what kind of process (or lack of process) your company has, they can get you fired. On the other hand, a good manager can help you do your best despite any existing "cookie-cutter" process.
- awesomerobot 10y agoFrom what I've seen the performance review process in large companies allows you to mask a personal vendetta as a performance issue (and you'll get away with it). Your manager can say "based on feedback everyone says you suck" and you can't really do a whole lot to look into it. You don't know where the feedback is coming from, or if it's even valid. At a smaller company a manager seems more responsible to look at performance democratically. So if they have a personal vendetta and they fired someone for it, it's much easier for other employees and other managers to see what's going on and call it out (so they might not act on it to begin with). Of course that's not universal, sometimes at a small company you might have one person with consolidated power so it doesn't really matter (and can be much worse). And of course, at a smaller company peer pressure can keep issues under wraps because you're worried about everyone knowing that you're the one bringing it up. So yeah, a performance review process needs to exist at larger companies because it makes sense logistically... but criticism of that process doesn't mean it should be thrown out entirely, it just welcomes the discussion about how it can be improved. There are middle grounds between strict performance reviews and small-company democracy.
- leaveyou 10y agoI'm deeply offended by this and personally I will cease to use Yahoo Mail. I urge any self-respecting males to stop using any of Yahoo services as a form of protest for this despicable act of discrimination. And I'm serious; too much is too much.
- petre 10y agoYahoo services are pretty much low quality anyway. Flickr is okay but it doesn't really work on mobile w/o installing their app. So why use them anyway? You don't need this as a reason when there are already better services out there. Plus Mayer will probably be pretty much gone soon, since instead of saving what was left of Yahoo, she made it even less relevant than before. It will be probably bought by Verizon.
- ComodoHacker 10y agoSo you judge mere on the fact that some lawsuit was filed? Without hearing, without proofs presented, without looking into other party's version? Perhaps this is exactly what someone is expecting from you now.
- leaveyou 10y agoI don't deny that the situation must be analyzed carefully but going from "less than 20 percent female" to "more than 80 percent female" in less than 2 years leaves little room for doubt. Also this adds up to the undisclosed security breach and the fact that Yahoo secretly scanned emails for US Intel.. Not a very defensible behavior.
- geofft 10y agoGoing from less than 20 percent female to more than 80 percent female is being exactly as discriminatory, though. You should have been offended all along, right?
- yolesaber 10y agoNo you don't get it. When men get their jobs its because of their hard work and abilities. When women get jobs its because of mass discrimination against males! /s
- hueving 10y agoThis is ultimately the result of things like 'implicit biases' training that tell you to accept that you are unfairly subconsciously advantaging majorities and that you should explicitly disadvantage them to make up for your biases. Disgusting.
- dankohn1 10y agoImplicit bias is a real phenomenon backed up by good studies: http://www.vox.com/2014/12/26/7443979/racism-implicit-racial-bias http://www.vox.com/2014/12/26/7443979/racism-implicit-racial... Whether or not reverse discrimination was taking place at Yahoo, it is worthwhile to try to reduce the implicit bias we practice in our own lives.
- Veen 10y agoIt's not reverse discrimination; it's just discrimination.
- dankohn1 10y agoYes, reverse discrimination[0] is an example of discrimination. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_discrimination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reverse_discrimination
- Veen 10y agoI object to the term because of this, from the article you linked to: > In a narrower sense, it refers to the specific negative impacts Whites or males may experience because of affirmative action policies. The two meanings are often conflated, which leads to confusion and misinformation. As companies try to fight historical biases, there will be some from the dominant group that suffer — those that might have been promoted under the old biased system won't be under a new less biased system. Advantages that the dominant group had will naturally be eroded. That's all well and good; an inevitable and desirable consequence of progress in the right direction. However, if the Yahoo! figures from the article are right, this seems to be a case of active discrimination against male employees, which isn't the same thing at all. Calling them both "reverse discrimination" elides the difference between those two possible meanings. So I prefer to think of what we're discussing here as active discrimination of no substantive difference to the usual historical discrimination. In Yahoo! some female managers were the dominant group — they had the power — and they used that power to discriminate against male employees to fill the ranks with other women. That's straight-up discrimination. Of course, the whole thing might be nonsense, but we'll have to wait and see.
- drawkbox 10y agoWe live in a "free" and democratic society but when you work at mid-large companies they are all basically idealistic dictatorships with brown shirts running the ranks. It really is a conundrum in some places.
- dreta 10y agoThere’s a reason why people make tons of money playing the stock market against companies that artificially force gender, or racial equality. Practices like these are going to ruin your business the same way being sexist, or racist will. Either you hire the best person for the job, or you’ll be beaten by companies that do.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoPractices like firing all your men and replacing them with women will ruin your business "the same way" that being sexist will? Perhaps we need to examine the popular conception of what constitutes "sexism". This is right up there with the idea "more blacks = more diverse".
- to3m 10y agoMore black people.
- Klibarchu 10y agoGive it a rest. Trumpeting your PC nonsense won't help you. You understood what he meant. Communication successful, despite your protest!
- yolesaber 10y agoIt's not about successful communication, it's about how you present an entire group of people. Using the term "the blacks" or "Blacks" makes you sound like Archie Bunker, dude. Negative social signal.
- kolbe 10y agoMaybe the goal is to send a specific type of social signal so people like you can self-select themselves out of his life? The term isn't pejorative. So, chill out.
- phyzome 10y agoAs a man in technology... this seems fine. The playing field is already tilted against women in tech, so if someone intentionally levels it, that's great! And I don't really care if they tilt it the other direction. Those men will find work elsewhere, no problem. (I am not taking a stance here on Mayer's other management practices, to be clear.) Discrimination against an otherwise unoppressed majority really fails to make me care. (Caveat: That's along a single axis of oppression; I recognize that intersectionality is a thing, etc.)
- williamgb 10y agoAs a man in tech from an underprivileged background, I couldn't disagree more. I worked as a cleaner for three years while educating myself, at the same time slowly winning freelance work. I know and worked with other men who went through similar situations. That we might be considered ripe for purging due to our genitalia is some somewhat remarkable. That people seem to support it with apparent glee is disheartening. If you recognise intersectionality is "a thing", how can you justify supporting any measure which discriminates based on an arbitrary attribute such as gender? Surely the concept is one which demands a little more nuance in matters like this?
- refurb 10y agoMaybe you don't understand. White men are all the same. They all grew up with a silver spoon in their mouths and no hurdles to overcome. Life is just easy for them. /s
- abestic9 10y agoWould it be safe to assume, then, that you're in favour of massive cookie-cutter layoffs of female nurses to level out the gender imbalance there?
- EJTH 10y agoHow can you be fine with laying off persons based on their sex? You come out as someone who has chucked the whole keg of coolaid. "Discrimination against an otherwise unoppressed majority really fails to make me care." - You don't think that leads to oppression? When will you care? When white males are rounded up in death camps and ridden by BLM deathsquads, will you care then? You don't think it is comparable to saying "Discrimination against islam - a religious majority really fails to make me care" ?
- staticelf 10y agoMarissa Meyer seems like a really bad CEO.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoShe's basically in the spot Fiorina was in - the ship is slowly taking on water for Schumpeterian life cycle reasons.
- PedroBatista 10y agoShe sure put some holes in it too.
- staticelf 10y agoI don't really understand the reference, but despite the spot she was in when she started she obviously have done some bad shit right from the get go. Like banning remote work and now this. Then there is no seeming investment in the stuff Yahoo! is good at which is simply weird.
- gspetr 10y agoI'm not sure why you wish to remove agency and assign victimhood here. She knew the job was difficult when she took it. Speaking of Fiorina, there was a guy who was a CEO of a company taking tons of water too. He turned it around. And then he won the primary in which Fiorina also ran.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoI wasn't assigning victimhood that I know of - Yahoo is just an older company. My read is that they'd have had to have pivoted pretty sharply. We tend to assign praise or blame on people who pivot depending on how it works out, but it's just not clear that anyone ( except perhaps a very select few ) is simply better at that than anyone else. It's as much gambling as it is playing a game. I am not 100% sure which primary you refer to, but McCain never turned any company around and Trump has just pivoted to being a floating brand. He's left a trail of wreckage in his wake but still gets to claim otherwise. I don't hold bankruptcy against anyone but you don't then get to construct an "I'm a winner" narrative from that. At least his communications style is that of a con man. Now, in America, the phenomenon of Perfesser Harold Hill is really a thing - a "jasper" who does good without being good - but the narrative there doesn't work, either.
- zhai88 10y agoWorked for a high tech company in the US that hired mostly ethnic Asian people especially immigrants from China, Japan, Korea because most were single or came over alone and would work 12 hours, weekends, etc. THey did not protest, maybe could not protest because of whatever visa they were on. CEO was from China, family members in senior positions at the company etc.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoThis whole thread is deeply disturbing. The bald statement in the headline is deeply disturbing. The fundamental assumption that women can't possibly be deserving of management positions. That any objective measure of performance would certainly favor men. That any man that loses his job to a woman has been treated unfairly.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoIt's not just any man...it was a lot of men. This kind of discrimination could be excused if it brought a tangible value to the company, but this reshuffling did nothing to help this ailing company. Meyer's actions were discriminatory at worst; at best, it was merely gross incompetence.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoLots of companies fail to survive Silicon Valley forever. Yahoo!'s future aside, the conversation was about promotion, not ailing companies. A lot of women are routinely overlooked in management promotions. Since its 80% (or usually much more) men in every other company in Silicon Valley, we'll have to call discrimination and incompetence at all of them? The assumption that women can't possibly belong in management is galling. No mystery why Silicon Valley has the reputation it does.
- wfo 10y agoYes -- because people go to tech websites and spam entire comment sections with hundreds of comments saying exactly the same thing and telling everyone that they are sexist while intentionally missing the point.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y ago>The assumption that women can't possibly belong in management is galling. No mystery why Silicon Valley has the reputation it does. You're putting a lot of words in other people's mouths in this thread, and I believe you are equating skepticism and discomfort from the lawsuit's allegations with willful ignorance or even sincere sexism. If a CEO wishes to fire half the company and hire new people, sure. If the CEO wants to fire half the company (who happen to be men) and replace them with new people (who happen to be women), again, sure. If a CEO implements a review system designed to illegitimize honest work by a cohort of people and have them demoted and/or fired to minimize severance costs while bringing on or promoting people of a different cohort, then we have a discrimination problem. Honestly I am a little surprised at the accusations of sexism towards people that are expressing discomfort with what appears to be a primarily sexist act.
- inmemory_net 10y agoAs an example of the rot in Yahoo, the Yahoo Finance Message Boards don't work in IE 11.
- cmdrfred 10y agoI have been told the feminism is truly about egalitarianism, I will patiently await the feminist outcry.
- acaciapalm 10y agoFeminism is not about egalitarianism. Saying that is the equivalent of responding "All Lives Matter!" to BLM. I'm not saying that Yahoo did something right or wrong (maybe qualified women started to flock to yahoo because of its female CEO? Who knows! I will let the justice system sort that one out). But I really dislike feminism constantly being watered down to mean anything other than "the advancement of women." Like, women have a lot of issues across the globe. Women get acid thrown in their faces, get denied education, etc. etc. Feminism is about stopping all of that, NOT about egalitarianism. There's already a word for egalitarianism, why the need to make feminism mean that, too?
- sageabilly 10y agoWoman here: If it turns out to be true, then yeah, that is absolutely sexist and is absolutely 100% bullshit. That's the point of wanting equity for everyone: being a woman or being a man should have no bearing on whether or not you can do the WORK, so if that starts to be a point of consideration then yeah, that's kinda inherently sexist. Just like men getting the side eye when they want to be elementary teachers or women in stockrooms getting asked if they need help carrying something.
- jtedward 10y ago>Yahoo’s diversity reports indicate that the percentage of women in leadership positions at the company rose slightly to 24 percent in 2015 from 23 percent in 2014. This is buried in the very last line of the article.
- roflchoppa 10y agodoes anyone have links to go to court documents that have been filed?