23 ms·
Investing for Geeks
- jernejpregelj 10y agoInvest in crowdfunding products ;) https://www.starterstreet.com/ https://www.starterstreet.com/
- chollida1 10y agoGreat post!! I'd add a few things that I've learned over the years: 1) Always be invested in the market. Corollary, don't time the market. This is by far the largest mistake people make. Investors typically pull money out at the bottom after they've suffered a physiologically devastating loss, like at the end of 2008 and hence they miss the rebound, like 2009-now. This isn't quite the same but it shows what missing the top 25 days in the market over the past 45 years does to your returns. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-missing-out-on-25-days-in-the-stock-market-over-45-years-costs-you-dearly-2016-01-25 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/how-missing-out-on-25-days-... If you are an investor you need to be in the market, period. 2) Accept that you will lose money some years. If you are buying index funds then you will get market performance, ex fees. Markets go down sometimes. Stay the course. 3) Don't look every day or you will go nuts. Keep in mind that the largest draw down (top to bottom) will be larger than what the returns look like if you just look year over year. Ie if you look and see the S&P lost 28% in 2008, understand that if you watched the S&P every day of 2008 then it probably lost more than 28% from its top to its bottom but rebounded slightly at the end of the year to make the year over year loss less than the maximum loss. 4) Have some exposure to outside of the US markets. Consider the scenario of investing all your money in the company you work for. In a rough time for your company you get the double whammy of losing money and possibly your job at the same time. Similarly to how you are told to not invest all your money in the company you shouldn't invest solely in the country you live in, same principle. EDIT see child comment, I mangled the English language in point 4
- wtvanhest 10y ago> 1) Always be invested in the market. Corollary, don't time the market. This is by far the largest mistake people make. The easiest way to tell if someone understands financial markets is to find out whether they believe they can time the market. If they believe they can predict the market, they don't know what they are talking about. [edited - removed ending]
- gxs 10y agoThere is something very off putting about your comment regarding how you preemptively dismiss anyone who would dare argue with you. Time in the market beats timing the market - the adage is as old as time itself. Not sure that knowing it makes you understand the markets especially well. Similarly, not sure that not knowing it says anything about you either.
- wtvanhest 10y agoPoint taken. I edited it out. And... just to go a step further. My comment included the word 'easiest' to describe how to find out someone doesn't know what they are talking about. IMO, if someone starts talking about timing the market, I know right away that they do not know what they are talking about. Other indicators are much harder to diagnose. A self proclaimed market timer is just the easiest to identify.
- enraged_camel 10y agoKnowing that adage doesn't mean you understand markets especially well, but not knowing it definitely means you don't understand markets. I had a friend in college who played World of Warcraft. When the first expansion was announced, he invested $10,000 in Blizzard stock. His reasoning? "It's going to be awesome and sell a lot of copies!" He didn't understand that the stock price at the time he made the purchase already reflected that information (that there was an expansion coming out soon).
- Xcelerate 10y ago> There will likely be people that reply to this comment with various comments saying I am wrong. You can judge those comments for yourself. This is the comment equivalent of a loaded question. Or it's like those people who dismiss those arguing against them because of who they are rather than what their argument is.
- maerF0x0 10y ago> "Open a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA. The traditional IRA contributes pre-tax money, the Roth IRA post-tax money. The upshot is that if you believe your marginal rate at retirement to be higher than your present rate, you should pick a Roth IRA, otherwise, you should pick a traditional IRA. If you don’t feel like forecasting that, take my word for it that 90% of you should have Roth IRAs." I simply cannot fathom why he would state that. I cannot imagine a scenario where my retirement income would (nor should) be as high or higher than my peak earning years. Typically in retirement you have a home and all sorts of hard goods (clothes, furniture, cars) paid off and thus need less money.
- wyldfire 10y agoThe risk that favors Roth IRAs includes the risk that the tax code will change to include higher rates than the current tax code. Also note that any increased or decreased "need" doesn't factor in to the calculation.
- hellogoodbyeeee 10y agoUS income taxes are at historically low levels too.
- lettergram 10y agoI would disagree - prior to WWI there was no income tax. Further, not every state implanted income taxes (some still don't have any)
- lloyd-christmas 10y agoundefined != 0
- lkbm 10y agoSeems like in the case of tax, it does. They weren't taking a random % of income in income tax based on what was in the memory cell from the previous call stack. They were taking 0%.
- loteck 10y agoRead Goldstein's (edit: Bernstein's!) book "If You Can". It's a whopping 16 page book of plain talk and he made it free on the internet, no strings. [1] It's the best introduction to planning for retirement, especially for those under 35, I've read so far. [1] https://www.etf.com/docs/IfYouCan.pdf https://www.etf.com/docs/IfYouCan.pdf
- cesarbs 10y agoBernstein :)
- rublev 10y agoHoly shit this is amazing. Thanks for this link. Helped tie together a bunch of scattered finance knowledge I've 'acquired' (or encountered in the wild I guess).
- etjossem 10y agoReads like a fatherly chat with his children about personal finance, it's brilliantly written.
- anotheryou 10y agoif you trust stocks and live in the US hat is, right?
- Analemma_ 10y agoInvesting for non-investors: whatever the question, if you have to ask, the answer is index funds.
- MarlonPro 10y agoTrue. Buffet said so - S&P 500 Index Funds.
- dennisgorelik 10y agoIt's a good investment guide, but I disagree with Patrick's advice on Roth IRA. Roth IRA (unlike Traditional IRA) almost never makes sense. It is very unlikely that tax rate at retirement would be higher than tax rate now, because if your income at retirement is already high (meaning high-tax rate) then you are very unlikely to get money out of your retirement fund. You are much more likely to get money from your retirement fund at your low-income years, when tax rate is quite low already.
- sgman 10y agoGains in Roth IRAs are also tax free in addition to withdrawals. This means that if you have 30 or more years until retirement, you enjoy a 30 year growth at 8% compounded tax free (based on The numbers in the article). This is why if you're young and qualify for a Roth IRA it's almost always the correct choice.
- jowiar 10y agoThat doesn't matter. Roth vs. Traditional is purely a bet on current vs. future tax rates. P = principal, T_0 = current tax rate, T_t = Tax rate at retirement (t years in the future). r = rate of return between time 0 and t Roth IRA: (P * (1-T_0)) * (1+r)^t Traditional IRA: (P * (1+r)^t) * (1-T_t) Which are identical save for the tax rates.
- khuey 10y agoIt's not quite that simple. There is other relevant weirdness in the tax code. Roths are not subject to required minimum distributions and don't count as income during retirement. That can be very useful because a lot of provisions of the tax code phase out as your income rises. Of course, Congress could also fix that oversight by the time you make it to retirement ...
- ccallebs 10y agoI think (and correct me if I'm wrong) the advantage of a Roth is that you're paying the tax on a much smaller amount at entry than you are at exit. For example: - I deposit $4000 into my Roth IRA this year. - This was post-tax income on $6000. - In 40 years, It grows to $20000. - My total tax burden is still $2000.
- k2xl 10y agoOne issue with the Roth IRA. You're contribution limit goes to zero after you make more than around 180K (depending on how you file).
- benmanns 10y agoYou can contribute to a non-deductible IRA and then after a (short) period convert it to a Roth IRA. If you don't have other traditional IRA funds (the basis is pro-rated across all traditional IRA accounts).
- loeg 10y agoGoogle "backdoor Roth" for more thorough description and discussion.
- pbreit 10y ago1. Pay off credit cards & loans 2. Max out 401k, IRA 3. Put most of your money in cheap index fund like https://investor.vanguard.com/mutual-funds/lifestrategy/#/ https://investor.vanguard.com/mutual-funds/lifestrategy/#/ Note: this is not investment advice
- loeg 10y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics
- cbr 10y agothis is not investment advice It certainly looks like investment advice!
- pbreit 10y agoThat's for the lawyerly among us.
- bbcbasic 10y agoBy loans you mean the mortgage too? Pay that off first? In Australia you could pay off your mortgage then refinance in a brand new loan to buy investments. The interest you pay on THAT loan is income tax deductible.
- h4nkoslo 10y agoMortgages are a special case because the debt is usually tax-subsidized, and depending on the state, one effectively has the option of giving the house to the bank in lieu of paying the remaining balance.
- bbcbasic 10y agoThat is a difference in the US. In UK/Australia you pay the mortgage from your post-tax salary. Encouraging some people in Australia to perversely rent their house out and go and rent a similar house (sometimes identical apartment in same block!) from someone else, in order to get the interest offset against tax. In the UK it is even worse, as you can only claim 20% of the interest cost on an investment property even if you are paying 40% tax on the rental income (!!)
- teej 10y agoIf you're healthy enough to swing a high-deductible health plan, consider maxing out a "stealth IRA" aka health savings account. With a $3,350 individual / $6,750 contribution limit, it's a great tax-advantaged account that can be treated just like a Traditional IRA. If you use it for medical costs, which you are likely to have in retirement, you get tax advantage on both ends. http://whitecoatinvestor.com/retirement-accounts/the-stealth-ira/ http://whitecoatinvestor.com/retirement-accounts/the-stealth...
- tcoppi 10y agoAgreed, if you have an HSA available it is probably the second places I would maximize contributions to, after a 401k/403b.
- mikemac 10y agoHSA contributions are arguably better considering they are not subject to FICA.
- tcoppi 10y agoYes, but only if they are deducted from your payroll by your employer, which is usually the situation when you have an HSA, but not always. You won't get a FICA refund if you contribute yourself off-payroll, but you will get an income tax refund at least.
- loeg 10y agoIt's like a traditional IRA, but the age for penalty-free non-healthcare withdrawals is higher (65 vs 59.5). Just something to keep in mind if you're older and think you might need the money sooner.
- tcoppi 10y agoThere is theoretically no time limit on taking withdrawals for medical expenses, so if you have enough medical expenses before you retire you can pay them with taxable money and withdraw in retirement those payments(save the receipts in case you get audited!). I wouldn't rely on that though, I'm sure the IRS will crack down on that if it becomes popular.
- MarlonPro 10y agoI'm on our company's 401K plan. If you know nothing about how the stock market works, then the target date retirement fund is the way to go. The worst thing you could do is not participating in your company's 401K plan, especially if the company offers you matching dollars (Read: FREE MONEY). I started with a target date retirement fund (managed by Schwab) but almost 2 years ago, I decided to re-allocate my fund into 3 mutual funds: S&P 500, US Small-Mid Cap, and International Large Cap. I'm happy that I re-allocated my fund. Ramith Seti's "I will Teach You to be Rich" book inspired me. And, another influence that made me re-allocate my fund is the "Three-Fund Portfolio" principle by Boglehead's Guide to Investing. I don't currently have access to the funds that Bogle suggested, but if I have extra money to invest, I'd open a Roth IRA account (alongside my 401K) and do the following: VTSMX 60% VGTSX 30% VBMFX 10% or ETF's VTI 60% VXUS 30% BND 10% These allocations follow the Boglehead principle of 3-Fund portfolio / Lazy portfolio
- Veratyr 10y ago> I decided to re-allocate my fund into 3 mutual funds Is there a particular reason you chose mutual funds rather than regular index funds? Everything I've heard in the past says that mutual funds generally have higher expenses without worthwhile increased returns.
- douche 10y agoVanguard funds have ridiculously low costs
- MarlonPro 10y agoYes. I surveyed blogs written about index fund. Most suggested Vanguard (inventor of Index Fund). Like you probably noticed above, my ideal 3-fund portfolio consists Index Funds/ETF's from Vanguard.
- MarlonPro 10y agoBecause our company's 401K plan has limited choices. I'd go for index funds and/or ETF's if offered. BTW, my S&P 500 is an index (SWPPX).
- orestis 10y agoWhat is a Vanguard, Betterment, WealthFront equivalent for EU-residents? Local banks usually offer a very small selection of funds and the fees are usually 2%, which has a huge impact.
- Ecio78 10y agoVanguard is available in Europe as well, event though with a subset of products. In general, take a look at etf funds with low commissions. Search on bogleheads the wiki pages for Europe (there are also few for specific countries)
- orestis 10y agoTheir products might be available, but not the company. You are responsible for finding a broker that has reasonable fees.
- Ecio78 10y agoYou are probably right and it's not so easy to find broker proposing them. But I've read few days ago they are growing and thinking about improving their presence in Europe so this may change. Still, if you want to build a simple portfolio a-la Bogleheads I think it's easier to use big étf funds (they may not be at the same fee level of vanguard but the competition pushed then low enough to be ok)
- azatris 10y agohttps://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/EU_investing https://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/EU_investing
- FabHK 10y agoJust to emphasise that (a point Noah Smith @Noahpinion has been hammering home recently): The fees look small, but are absolutely astounding. If you put in some fixed amount regularly over, say, 35 years, and the asset manager charges 2% p.a., they easily take a third of your savings overall, or more. It is imperative (particularly in this low yield environment) that you keep your fees down.
- freditup 10y agoIf your company doesn't do any 401k matching, how worth is is to put money into it vs. regular investing? In my case it's likely I may want access to the money before retirement age, so I'm not sure what the best option is.
- bretthoerner 10y ago> in my case it's likely I may want access to the money before retirement age In that case always max (currently $5,500/yr) a Roth IRA first, because you can withdraw the principal before retirement. Second, if your company 401k offers loans the typical (maybe this is a legal thing?) max I hear is 50% up to 50k total. You're making a loan to yourself that pay back into the investment. Keep in mind if you leave the employer you may have to pay off the loan... If you really might need access to your money it's probably best to stick to Roth IRA + taxable (non-retirement) investments. Another thing about 401ks is the fund choices can sometimes be shit. If they're all high expense rate funds I don't even bother. These days the companies I've worked at typically offer one or two halfway decent index funds, YMMV.
- enraged_camel 10y agoThe primary advantage of a 401k is that contributions are deducted from your taxable income. If you make $100,000 and put 10% of that into a 401k, your income tax will be based on a $90,000 income. You do pay taxes on the money you put into a 401k when you start withdrawing from it during retirement, but what matters is this: if you believe your income during retirement (i.e. the money you'll be paid regularly out of your retirement accounts) will be less than your income today, then contributing to a 401k means you will end up paying a lot less in taxes overall, over the course of your life. There are ways to take money out of your retirement accounts before retirement age, but it depends on certain scenarios[1]. If you need to access the money before retirement age outside of those scenarios, then do a regular brokerage account. Regardless though, you should definitely open a Roth IRA if you're eligible, and contribute the maximum amount every year. Contributions to your Roth IRA are after-tax, so they won't be taxed when you take them out during retirement - since they have already been taxed. This makes them very advantageous. [1]http://www.bankonyourself.com/401k-withdrawal-rules http://www.bankonyourself.com/401k-withdrawal-rules
- asciihacker 10y agoForex, Binary Options and Cryptocurrency can return in months what traditional investing takes decades to do. I know which I prefer.
- tptacek 10y agoSo can blackjack.
- douche 10y agoBack when online poker was booming, I knew some guys that paid off their college tuition grinding on FullTilt
- Tomte 10y agoBecause they could spot and enter many small markets with "fish". In finance and investment there is (to a first approximation) only one big market, and you are the "fish". Those guys wouldn't have made their tuition walking into the Bellagio and entering the Big Game.
- douche 10y agoOne of the guys actually did go pro and made a pretty good living at it for a while, besides writing some books and video series on texas hold 'em http://www.businessinsider.com/how-andrew-seidman-started-playing-poker-2013-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/how-andrew-seidman-started-pl...
- infinite8s 10y agoGo for it. Let us know when you buy that yacht.
- czbond 10y agoAgreed. They can also lose it in the same manner as a "flash crash"
- TDL 10y ago
- ozim 10y agoI think this should be opening sentece, after which a lot of people can just skip all other investment advice: "Only invest money you won’t touch for 10+ years."
- phil248 10y agoHonest question: Then what do you do with the rest of your money? Say you plan on buying a home in 5-8 years, what is one expected to do with tens of thousands of dollars over that time period? Earn 1-2% on bonds?
- conorgil145 10y agoAs some others in this thread have said (and Patrick discusses in the post), there are lots of things you can do to much more directly impact your change of becoming rich and retiring well/early than optimizing your investments: get a really good salary and don't spend a lot of money. One blog which I have read is Mr Money Mustache [1], which focuses on those same concepts. Many of the posts are good reads. [1]: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/all-the-posts-since-the-beginning-of-time/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/all-the-posts-since-the-begin...
- mholmes680 10y agoThis site was a eureka moment for me, but I've yet to convince my wife that every sacrifice is worth it - and I don't blame her. The comments/forum on the site are some good reading too, tho I think the guy did get a little lucky along the way. If nothing else, that site made me realize where i stood on the consumer/producer scale, and what i needed to do to feel better about my future.
- charlesdm 10y agoI don't really agree with that. Investing well is almost always more important than worrying about small expenses. Do you know how many people don't invest? Like, 99% of people.
- loeg 10y agoIt depends on how long you have until retirement, which is influenced by your saving rate as a percentage of income. If you can save 99% of your income, you can retire real fast and your investment choices don't impact your pre-retirement earnings very much. (That's pretty much the gist of this post: http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-simple-math-behind-early-retirement/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2012/01/13/the-shockingly-sim... ) That said, you need to be invested somewhat just to fund retirement. It can be pretty conservative, though.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoJust to play devil's advocate, what if Peter Schiff is right again? :-)
- tunesmith 10y agoright about what?
- thr0waway1239 10y agoMaybe you already know, but he is this perma-bear investor who became a YouTube meme in early 2009.[1] He was the guy who was constantly warning about the potential for a 2008 style crash starting around 2006. The longer the bubble was going up, naturally, the more and more he was mocked. Until it all came tumbling down. The point is, he is basically saying what we are seeing now in 2016 looks like the run up to the crash in 2008. Although his critics would rightly point out that he has been saying the same thing for effectively most of the last 10+ years. If you think 2008 could and should have been avoided, you might not agree with his views. If you think it was a long overdue correction, you would be more likely to agree. Finally, how this relates to the article mentioned here: while timing the market is definitely difficult, I suppose there are times when you are better off not entering the market at all lest your investing psychology gets permanently burnt. The next year or so might be one of those periods. (In other words, my personal view is - just hold on to your cash for a while and do nothing with it). [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0YTY5TWtmU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0YTY5TWtmU
- jsonmez 10y agoI'm a software developer and over my career, I've actually been doing real estate investing for about 18 years. 3 years ago, I was able to essentially "retire" by reaching full financial independence and bring in $10k per month from real estate passively. I don't mean to plug my own thing, but I created a course which is in pre-release called "Simple Real Estate Investment for Software Developers." https://simpleprogrammer.com/products/simple-real-estate/ https://simpleprogrammer.com/products/simple-real-estate/ I basically outline my strategy and how I did it. I also talked about my whole story in a chapter in my book, Soft Skills. For those who are curious about real estate investment. It's not risky at all if you do it right and you think long-term.
- virtuexru 10y agoIf you make $10,000 a month why do you need to charge $500 for this book? ;)
- jsonmez 10y agoIt's a video course. $500 is a small investment to make to see if real estate investment might be worth considering. If someone isn't going to invest $500 in learning about it, they probably shouldn't consider real estate investment.
- bbcbasic 10y agoPerhaps, because he wants to make more than $10,000 a month?
- TheBiv 10y agoI wish you had a sample chapter to review before plopping down $500.
- jsonmez 10y agoGood point. It's pre-release. So, I'll be adding much more content, including a sample video.
- 10y ago
- alejohausner 10y agoWhy don't geeks read Mark Hulbert? Every time I see people discussing investing, it's usually about index funds. Stock picking is supposedly fool's gold, so you should buy the whole market, or so goes common wisdom. But the market can be brutal. It can have decades-long stretches of terrible returns. If you had all your money in index funds, and retired in 1929, you would have made no money for 25 years. If you retired in 1967, 15 years. If 2000, 10 years. Do you have 10 years of living expenses saved up? There are good stock pickers out there, people who focus on fundamentals. And you don't have to take their word for it. Mark Hulbert has been subscribing to many stock pickers' newsletters, trying out their picks, and reporting objectively on the results since 1980. Some libraries subscribe to his monthly report, but since investing is a very long-term process, the same handful of newsletters keep showing up in the report: you only need to look at a few recent Hulbert reports to find good stock pickers.
- reddytowns 10y agoI somewhat agree, but I wonder if times are changing. Some background, I bought Hilbert's newsletter in 2003, and then bought and followed The Prudent Spectular, based off of its recommendation. I did so religiously, and even though I'm glad for it's advice which helped me ride through the collapse of 2008 without selling, the returns haven't been spectacular. I wonder now, though, if the game has changed. Has there been so much ongoing disruption due to the advancement of tech, that what worked before won't work anymore. Which is to say, the problem with stock pickers is that it takes a long time to measure their performance, and what worked in the last 20 years may not work in the next. Btw, I don't know why you are getting downvoted. What you say is interesting and certainly has merit.
- alejohausner 10y agoI don't know if you'll read this, but here is some info for you. I subscribed to Hulbert until mid 2014, and had a look at the yearly tables where he summarizes the performance of all the newsletters he tracks, with 1, 5, 10, and 15 year averages. With a bit of algebra, you can use those yearly 1, 5, 10, and 15 year averages to estimate the performance of the Prudent Speculator for single years, going back to 1992. Here's the numbers I got (percent/year): 2013 5.3 2012 17.8 2011 -2.3 2010 21.8 2009 38.4 2008 -43.0 2007 1.0 2006 14.6 2005 16.0 2004 27.1 2003 102.6 2002 -35.0 2001 11.2 2000 2.2 1999 19.1 1998 -0.1 1997 -15.5 1996 44.8 1995 56.4 1994 77.9 1993 -13.7 1992 35.6 You started in 2003, and dropped it sometime after 2008. The average for 2010 through 2013 is 10.6% per year, which is OK, but I think is in line with the broad market index. One of the recent Hulberts has a recent semilog plot of the newsletter's returns, and by I eyeballing it can see that, while it outpaced the market from 2000 to 2007, it has pretty much tracked the market since 2008. So it hasn't beaten the index lately. Hulbert also reports that the newsletter's author prior to 2002 (when he died) used margin to augment the returns. Since 2002 another person is picking the stocks, and they're not using margin, so that might account for the recent pedestrian returns. 10% is nice, but I agree it's not spectacular. Looking at recent behavior dissuaded me from following it. I wanted a bit more money from my investments. But I can see how, in 2003, the previous decade made the plan look really good to you. I would have done the same thing as you.
- infinite8s 10y agoQuestion - is it fair to use the 8% historical market average when doing these calculations (which include some of the most spectacularly productive periods in the American economy)? All the predictions I've seen going forward look like the average will be much lower (at least for the current generation), and a rate of 4-5% means you need a much larger nest egg to drawdown a livable amount each year in retirement. Edit: It's not clear from the essay, but I'm assuming Patrick's 8% rate is not adjusted for inflation (based on his 40k drawdown scenario - the other 3-4% would cover inflation).
- tcoppi 10y agoDepends on how conservative you want to be. For me personally I've been using an inflation-adjusted rate of 5% annually, but I consider that very conservative and hope to realize a much longer rate over my time horizon. But if I do realize only 5% annualized, I will be sure to have more than enough to not live in squalor. If realized rates over the next ~30 years are less than 5%, not only are we as a civilization going to have bigger problems than my retirement, but I don't think much anything will save you regardless of how much you are saving, unless you have a very frugal retirement.
- FabHK 10y agoHistorical long term real rates hover around 6%, and I'd consider real rates of 5% for the next decade quite optimistic, not conservative. Also, regarding safe withdrawal rates, consider that (depending on the jurisdiction) in retirement you might have to pay taxes on the nominal rates, but then leave enough to compensate for inflation. Say: 4% nominal, pay 25% taxes, leaves you with 3%, but 2% inflation, so you can safely withdraw only 1%. Thus, conservatively, $1m might give you only 10k a year.
- tcoppi 10y agoFrom 1871 to the end of 2015 returned 6.86% annualized in real dollars. Most 30-year periods you can pick out average either that or above, save a few odd periods. [1] I use [2] to do most of my predictions. I think you are being way conservative with assuming a 4% withdrawal rate will only give you $10k real dollars on $1m invested, but everyone has different risk tolerances and assumptions :) 1. http://www.moneychimp.com/features/market_cagr.htm http://www.moneychimp.com/features/market_cagr.htm 2. http://www.firecalc.com/ http://www.firecalc.com/
- pilingual 10y agoAlso, don't listen to one person. Do your own homework. https://medium.com/@blakeross/wealthfront-silicon-valley-tech-at-wall-street-prices-fdd2e5f54905 https://medium.com/@blakeross/wealthfront-silicon-valley-tec... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9856151 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9856151
- frinxor 10y agowealthfront is a bad idea.
- paolav 10y agoAny tips / guides for non-USA / european citizens?
- parenthesis 10y agohttp://monevator.com/ http://monevator.com/ is UK-centric.
- hackerboos 10y agoCanada: https://i.imgur.com/YcceUqa.jpg https://i.imgur.com/YcceUqa.jpg
- atmosx 10y ago> Often when I told people I was building a (toy) stock exchange they’d ask me for stock advice, which is about as well-considered as asking a WoW guild to deal with your terrorism problem. And you think that's problematic? I have relatives telling me that they'll go with X anti-thrombotic therapy because a cousin of the brother of a guy who they met in the supermarket took it 6 years ago and worked wonders for him. I'm a pharmacist and I have rather strong opinions about some drugs over others, but I can take advices from doctors, physicians, nurses or anyone with a minimum degree of knowledge on the topic. Still, many times I have to argue with with relatives, to the point where I get frustrated.
- loeg 10y agoSince you are all forum nerds, y'all might also enjoy: * https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics https://www.reddit.com/r/personalfinance/wiki/commontopics ("I have $X, what do I do with it?") (and the rest of the PF wiki is a good general resource as well) * https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence/ https://www.reddit.com/r/financialindependence/ (How do I save enough to be able to stop working?) * https://www.bogleheads.org/ https://www.bogleheads.org/
- hundt 10y ago> You should open a SEP-IRA, which is a special account type that is similar to a 401k in mechanics but has very, very generous funding limits. Actually, both account types have the same yearly limit; it's just that the employer can contribute much more than the employee, and when self-employed you can contribute as the employer. In fact, the difference between SEP IRA and 401k is not the funding limits, but the fact that the SEP IRA allows only employer contributions. You can actually open a "solo 401k" for yourself if you are self-employed, and make both employer and employee contributions. That will let you put more money away for a given income than the SEP IRA, until you make 275k or so at which point you have hit the cap for both (and the cap is the same for both). Edit: Vanguard has a calculator to show the difference: https://personal.vanguard.com/us/SbsCalculatorController https://personal.vanguard.com/us/SbsCalculatorController
- ryanwaggoner 10y agoThis is exactly right, although with solo 401k, you can hit the cap of $53k contributions with net profit of only ~$185k, not $275k, if you max both employee and employer contributions. Additionally, with a solo 401k plan, the $18k employee contributions can be Roth.
- hundt 10y agoAh, good point about the Roth contributions! I'd forgotten about that difference.
- anovikov 10y agoAny advice for non-Americans? I'd like to get to Vanguard but...
- jsonmez 10y agoSo, I thought I'd type up a bit of more detailed explanation of my story and why I think real estate is a great investment for software developers, since my previous comment was a little lacked. I bought my first house when I was 19. It's a little two bedroom shack in Boise, Idaho, which I bought in 1999 for $68,000. I still have that little shack. Today it's worth about $135,000 and the tenants I had in it essentially paid the mortgage on it and I own it free and clear. I've actually got 26 total rental units and I generate about $10k a month of almost completely passive income off of them, net. I made a ton of mistakes along the way, but I learned quite a bit--which I'm happy to share. Over the years, I tried to buy one property every year. At first I could only afford small properties and would put 10% down, so I was a bit leveraged. But, eventually I was able to afford bigger properties and put more money down. I always bought properties using 30 fixed loans and that ended up working out well. I watched in horror as many of the other investors I knew--who were really speculators--went under, during the big housing crash. I actually thrived during this time, picking up properties for cheap. All the time I was working as a software developer, I had this goal of retiring early. I kept saving as much as I could and investing real estate... little by little. Like I said, I made mistakes, but learned from them and got smarter as I got more experienced. Eventually, I had built up enough cash flow to actually "retire." This happened a few years ago. Why is real estate such a good investment? Well, I think there are two main factors: leverage and hedging against inflation. Leverage is extremely powerful. A bank will lend you a large amount of money, sometimes 90% or more, for you to invest--if you buy real estate. This isn't the case with other investments. So, you can buy a house for $100k, put $10k of your own money into it and if it goes up 10%, and is worth $110k, you make 100% return on your $10k. That's insane. I don't know other investments where that is possible with such low risk--if you mitigate the risk properly. Now, I don't depend on appreciation--and you can't count on it--but, you don't even need it. Just the cash flow alone can get you excellent returns on your money. Again, with little risk and huge upsides. Hedging against inflation is also a beautiful part of real estate investment. Most other investments are hurt by inflation, real estate isn't. In fact, if you owe money on a mortgage and inflation hits, you actually owe less. Home values go up with inflation, as do rents. I know it's a bit difficult to believe--I probably wouldn't if I hadn't done it myself--but, I have done it and I did escape the rat race. Anyway, if you'd like to know more, let me know and I'll post the link to my YouTube videos and the video course (that is in beta) that I am releasing on specifically real estate investment for software developers.
- simonista 10y agoDoes anyone have suggested reading on what the estimates of 8% (or 7% or 5% or whatever gets used) are based on? Is there any data to support that the next 30 years will see those types of returns from the total market on average?
- lutorm 10y agoData by definition can't be from the future, so unless you by data mean "extrapolations", then that can't be the case.
- 3pt14159 10y agoI'm getting really sick of hearing programmers tell me about the efficient market hypothesis as if it is some very hard rule, like big O notation. The market is not efficient. Full stop. Stop telling me that I'm not going to beat the market. I beat the market all the time. In 2007 I was telling everyone I know that the housing market was about to burst. I sold all of my family investing company's stocks (except for Apple) and I moved everything into money markets / bank accounts. Bought back in during 2009, road the wave up until about last year I started feeling a bit skiddish and sold off not everything, but many things. I routinely pick individual stocks, like Apple, Telsa, Amazon, Bitcoin; that I know are better. Apple: iPhone is better. I don't care if some analyst at Goldman knew this before me 90% of the public was still talking about how Blackberry had a keyboard. Telsa: the physics made sense, plus Elon had that Silicon Valley-ness to him. Amazon I knew would win with AWS and the whole "ecommerce is a bear" thing. Bitcoin: People like drugs and buying things online, bought in at $4 a coin, have since sold almost all of it. It is actually really easy if you are smart enough to be a programmer to beat the market. Just make sure you understand the domain you are in really well, and be cautious of overall trends in the economy. I've averaged 18% year over year returns with a diversified portfolio (yes, more than a quarter of that is bonds or and another quarter is super low risk dividend companies like consumer staples). "Survivorship bias" I hear you say. Maybe there should be this other word "suvivorship bias bias" where one is incapable of having their view of the efficient market hypothesis challenged because this is the only thing that comes to mind when they talk to someone about investing. There are ways to do better than the S&P 500. Patrick is right about one thing though, you won't pick winning stocks from reading the newspaper but you might miss a 2008/2009 if you read The Economist instead of Time Magazine. http://www.tradersnarrative.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/after%20the%20fall%20house%20prices%20economist%20magazine%202005.png http://www.tradersnarrative.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/03/a... http://img.timeinc.net/time/images/covers/pacific/2005/20050613_400.jpg http://img.timeinc.net/time/images/covers/pacific/2005/20050...
- vintageseltzer 10y ago> "Survivorship bias" I hear you say. I understand your sentiment, and have felt the same way. I made the same bets on Apple, Tesla and Amazon at around the same time and beat the market. I think the issue is — can you replicate that for the next 30+ years? I don't think I can.
- 987654321s 10y agohttps://m.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100006448920160&fref=ts#!/photo.php?fbid=1649169341974681&id=100006448920160&set=a.1588861311338818.1073741828.100006448920160&source=44&refid=17 https://m.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100006448920160&fref=t...
- 987654321s 10y agohttps://m.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100006448920160&fref=ts#!/photo.php?fbid=1649169341974681&id=100006448920160&set=a.1588861311338818.1073741828.100006448920160&source=44&refid=17 https://m.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100006448920160&fref=t...
- misnamed 10y agoSomething else I would add - if you're working in the ups-and-downs world of startups and technology, you may have meaty and lean years and during the good years find you want to save more fore retirement than 401ks, SEP IRAs and ROTH IRAs (if you're not priced out) allow. One handy way to extend your tax-advantaged space: buy Series I and Series EE bonds from Treasury Direct. Both are tax-deferred until you cash them in. You can purchase up to 10K of each type per year. They are government-backed, highly-safe fixed-income instruments. I bonds will pace inflation (like TIPS) for up to 30 years. EE bonds have low 'normal' yields but they automatically double after 20 years (so around 3.5%/year annualized, better than the rates on 20-year Treasuries). These rates are better than what you get on the open market. And unlike normal bonds, they won't kick out payments that are taxable along the way - you can save the tax bill until you have a lean year then cash them back out (in the case of I bonds at least), or save them to the end of their lifespan (or until they double in the case of EE bonds).
- torkins 10y agoBonds are a horrific investment in today's market. Rates are lower than they have been since WW2 when they were fixed by the government! The principal and interest risk for owning bonds is essentially at an all time high. You'd literally be better off in cash in rates rise even somewhat in the near future.
- tanderson92 10y agoThe post you are responding to literally explains how EE bonds are better than those you can buy on the open market. Also, you cannot reliably time the market.
- torkins 10y agowhat makes you think this wouldn't be priced into bond yields? There is trillions of paper in the market, an arbitrage is eaten by the entities who make their living doing it. There is no secret edge.
- EGreg 10y agoI want to ask something. People always ask me why I rent and "waste money" instead of getting a mortgage etc. I explain to them that I put most of the money I make into my company, and have a greater ROI than if I put the money into real estate. But, since I have to live somewhere, I rent. Yet, I am not sure this argument is correct. If I had money for a down payment, perhaps the strategy of getting a mortgage would win in the long run. So, instead of getting into the details, I usually mention I also like to be able to change apartments every year or so. What are your thoughts - those of you who have now, or have had, growing startups?
- mikemac 10y agoI'd look at it from a different angle - you spend a lot ton of time and energy on your company and don't want to have to deal with issues that come with home ownership - it's easier to just call the landlord with any problem that pops up. Plus, if you decided to relocate to a different place there is a significant cost of selling, which would wipe out any modest gains in appreciation.
- MarlonPro 10y agoWe all have our own preference when it comes to investing. One big factor in investing is diversification. Well, putting all your eggs in one basket is a risky business.
- FabHK 10y agoOne argument I found compelling: you are naturally short one property, as you have to live somewhere. Thus, you go long one to be flat.
- _audakel 10y agoGood point - on Should I Invest In Crowdfunding? "Crowdfunding has a bit of an adverse selection problem, where only companies which are insufficiently attractive to more professional angels .... go"
- vehementi 10y agoThere's a 3rd option which is to not eat robo advisor fees (0.6%-1%) and instead do the purchases yourself through a brokerage. Option #1 doesn't really dominate this.
- seangrogg 10y agoA great post on the whole, but out of curiosity does anyone know how he arrived at $40k off of $1m with present-day examples?
- dsacco 10y agoThe S&P 500 averages something like 7-8% over a 20 year timeline. Index funds tracking it will return similar performance. I would imagine Patrick is providing a conservative estimate, because regardless of the market average you can't count on seeing $80k on $1M each year.
- FabHK 10y agoSafe withdrawal rates are a whole chapter in itself. If you want to be 100% sure that your money lasts to the end, i.e. your death (in real terms), you cannot erode your principal, in real terms. Thus, if you have, say, a 5% total return nominally, but 2% inflation, you can withdraw 3% p.a. (Taxes complicate things, particularly insofar as you pay taxes on the nominal returns.) However, with this strategy you bequeath your original principal at the time of death (in real terms, i.e. grown by inflation), which might be too much. Thus, people generally argue for taking out a bit more, which might give you, say, 4% withdrawal with 5% nominal returns and 2% inflation (taking out about 1% or your principal p.a., halving it over the course of 70 years). When you erode principal like that, you run a small chance that you run out of money if your a) returns are lower than expected or b) you live longer than expected. A solution to a) is, as the name suggests, fixed income (i.e. bonds), which have no equity risk and (when you hold a bond with fixed rates to maturity) no interest risk. You are stuck, however, with credit risk (bond issuer goes bust) and inflation risk (except with inflation adjusted bonds). A solution to b) are annuities, that is an insurance product that pays you a fixed amount until you are dead, pooling the early/late mortality risk. The market for these is very different for different jurisdictions, one reason being, as usual, tax issues.
- IanCal 10y ago4% also sounds like a reference to the Trinity Study: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study
- zeveb 10y ago> I haven’t written too much recently, which was largely because I was quite busy with Starfighter. Sadly, that wound down. On a happier note, I will now have a lot more time for writing, both personally and on behalf of Stripe, which I joined earlier this week. As an aside, I'm sorry to read that Starfighter is closing down. Seemed like an interesting idea, and one that could have been good for both employers & employees. My best to tptacek — I know that he'd high hopes for it.
- tptacek 10y agoThanks! Not done yet.
- runamok 10y agoI am surprised by the 90% should invest in a Roth IRA vs. Traditional if they do not have access to a 401k. I would expect the growth of pre-tax dollars would outweigh having to pay taxes when I withdrawal. Put another way, I expect my retirement income to be 1/2 or less than my current income...
- milcron 10y agoIt hugely depends on your tax expectations. For tech workers who typically have high salaries, the 401k is a better solution since it reduces your tax burden. If your current tax bracket is rather low, or you expect to be earning lots of money through retirement, then Roth IRA can be a better solution.
- ryandrake 10y ago> If your current tax bracket is rather low, or you expect to be earning lots of money through retirement, then Roth IRA can be a better solution. I think for a typical "geek" who this article is about, rare is the scenario where you expect to be making that much more by (and throughout) retirement to justify taking the tax hit now. Maybe this works for a doctor who's doing residency and still paying for medical school, who eventually expects to be raking it in. But for tech workers our compensation tends to plateau very early and not grow a great deal throughout our careers. I know on a percentage basis, my comp grew more in my first 5 years than it has in the last 15. This scenario would appear to encourage tax-deferred investment.
- runamok 10y agoI was specifically referencing this part of advice: > No 401k Offered: > Open a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA. The traditional IRA contributes pre-tax money, the Roth IRA post-tax money. The upshot is that if you believe your marginal rate at retirement to be higher than your present rate, you should pick a Roth IRA, otherwise, you should pick a traditional IRA. If you don’t feel like forecasting that, take my word for it that 90% of you should have Roth IRAs. I don't see many people where Roth IRA makes more sense than Traditional yet they say 90% should go Roth. Assume I make 100k and I put in $5500 into traditional... I would have to earn about $8000 to have $5500 to put in my Roth IRA after taxes. Having all those years to grow that "extra" money seems much superior to me even if somehow you amass so much money that you are making more in retirement than during your working life UNLESS you suspect future tax brackets will be much higher. I suspect that is a typo and 90% of folks should choose traditional...
- lamby 10y agoAny similar articles specific to a UK resident?
- IanCal 10y agoThe UK personal finance subreddit has a lot of good content https://www.reddit.com/r/ukpersonalfinance/wiki/lumpsuminvestment https://www.reddit.com/r/ukpersonalfinance/wiki/lumpsuminves... https://www.reddit.com/r/UKPersonalFinance/wiki/isa https://www.reddit.com/r/UKPersonalFinance/wiki/isa
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- marpstar 10y agoWhen I was working at Best Buy in college I was employed part time and they offered 401k. My mother instructed me to contribute as much as would max out their match, explaining that it was essentially "free money". I don't remember what the match was. I eventually rolled the whopping $2,600 into an IRA that's grown pretty well the past 8 years. It's a ridiculously easy thing to do that pays off, literally.
- BeetleB 10y agoGood points. I'll point out that a 10 year window is too short. Look at this post to get an idea of 5 yr vs 10 yr vs 20 yr vs 30 yr windows: http://blog.nawaz.org/posts/2015/Dec/pay-down-mortgage-or-invest/ http://blog.nawaz.org/posts/2015/Dec/pay-down-mortgage-or-in... 10 years has enough volatility that you shouldn't use it to compare between funds.
- hristov 10y agoI agree with most of this, except for the stuff on robo-advisors. You should be very careful about those. First of all their fees are too high. Wealthfront's 0.25% fee seems rather small and it is smaller than what a lot of human advisers charge, but if you compute it over a lifetime of savings with the negative compounding effect it will cost you a lot. Imagine you receive some money when you are 20 from a rich uncle and invest it for 40 years using the wealthfront fee structure. After 40 years you will have paid about 10% of your savings in fees. Or, in other words, you will have about 10% more savings if you had taken a couple of hours to sit down and decide which funds to invest in. Keep in mind that the wealthfront fees are in addition of any etf or mutual fund fees you have to pay to get into investment vehicles. So yeah, compounding interest is a dangerous thing. There is another problem with roboadvisers -- people put too much trust in them. In our society there is this implicit trust of the computer, probably bred from multiple sci-fi shows with all-wise computers. Well it is a very dangerous thing when it comes to your savings. You may not be the best investor, but you should take responsibility in your investment choices. You should know what you are investing in and why. Even if the thing you are investing in is a boring simple S&P 500 fund (as it should be for most of you) you should know what it is and why you are investing in it. You shouldn't just blindly follow some algorithm programmed by god-knows who.
- chc 10y ago> Or, in other words, you will have about 10% more savings if you had taken a couple of hours to sit down and decide which funds to invest in. If and only if you would have done about as well as the robo-advisor in those couple of hours. (I'm not saying this would or wouldn't happen, but it's pretty big for an unstated assumption.)
- hristov 10y agoWell the thing is that the roboadviser is not even intended to make particular security picks. It is only supposed to decide which broad areas to invest in and what percentage for each area. Thus, the roboadviser can say that for your particular risk profile you should have 60% stocks 40% bonds and within the stocks you should have 60% sp500, 20% foreign large cap ... etc. My point is this portfolio distribution stuff is not an exact science and there really isn't a right answer. There are some broad accepted guidelines, but they are rather broad and simple and you definitely do not need computers to follow them.
- ArtDev 10y agoIf I don't know where the profits are coming from and for what cost, investing may not for me. There are a few companies with good ethics, mostly in tech, that I would invest in. I don't see myself investing in a mutual fund or index fund though.
- p8donald 10y agoI am in the EU and I am investing my money in peer-to-peer lending. You lend your money to other people through the marketplace and they pay it back with interest. The ROI is about 10% to 15% per year. I think it is low risk since you can choose the type of the loans you want to invest in (loans secured by real estate or short term loans with buy back guarantees). You can also diversify since the minimum investment is €10. I don't think you can invest hundreds of thousands or millions of euros (the market is not so big) but the market can definitely support tens of thousands of euros.
- hackerboos 10y agoWhat service do you use for this? I'm aware of Zopa in the UK.
- p8donald 10y agomintos.com and twino.eu
- loeg 10y agoAny 10-15% yield loan today is essentially junk grade as far as bonds are concerned. (That would be the opposite of "low risk" investment.)
- jbpetersen 10y agoAlternately, a lot of people around here no doubt have unique opportunities to speculate on how specific technologies will progress. If you can spot something that's genuinely original in how it blends things together, has enough expert mindshare to be a leader in its domain for the foreseeable future, stands good odds of capturing a decent amount of the value it creates for those who support it, and offers a way for you to throw money at it: throw money at it. It's a completely different game from trading in more mature markets where politics and statistics become major forces alongside original innovation in determining what happens next.
- noodle 10y agoA lot of people around here do "invest" in this type of tech by working for companies producing that tech. For the average person, you can't throw your money at a random startup. And generally, its not exactly a safe bet either. People who do throw their money at startups tend to also have lots of other very safe, diversified investments to balance out the risk of larger singular investments on specific bets/companies/tech/ideas. For example, the author is advocating and claims to invest in your basic Vanguard Retirement Target fund, but he's also an accredited investor who also does just what you suggest
- jbpetersen 10y agoYou made me realize I should've said time/money from the get go. With startups specifically, I'm hoping Title III is just the beginning of making them a lot more accessible for more casual investment, like throwing $5 at whatever cool/useful thing has caught your attention lately.
- somic 10y ago"Your company will probably extend a term saying “We will match your contributions up to N% of your salary.” You should always and under every circumstance invest enough money to max out your employer match. It is free money if you take it." This is a reasonable default option but not necessarily the best for everyone. There is a flaw in this statement - you are encouraged to save more today in order to maximize amount of money in your retirement account, with side effect of some immediate tax savings (which btw will not be in absolute figures but will be in rate - if you save more to 401k, your tax rate will be lower but amount of tax you will pay will still be higher). If you are too far from retirement and have other goals that will come before retirement that could be very important to you, it becomes a decision just like anything else, not a no-brainer. This is because of tax law - you are very constrained in your ability to take money from 401k before retirement if you need it.
- csharpminor 10y agoYes, some people cannot afford to save for retirement. As the article mentions, you shouldn't invest money that you can't live with for at least 10 years. However, the opportunity lost for every year you defer retirement contributions is huge, especially when you factor in the employer match you could be getting. If you assume a $200 a month contribution at about a 3% rate of return, the difference between 39 and 40 years of contributions is $7,600. Discounting the $2400 in contributions you would have made, that's still $5,200 lost just for waiting a year. And we're not even factoring in an employer match. Again, agree that for some this may be a tough decision. But generally speaking, if you receive a salary and have the option to participate in a retirement plan, you should do it.
- somic 10y agoParticipate in 401k plan - yes, 99% people would benefit from starting as early as possible. Max out your per-paycheck 401k contribution (including in order to maximize employer match) - not always. The farther you are from retirement age, the bigger your opportunity cost is going to be (your 401k money is locked-in into retirement account). There are also certain 401k rules that may play very hard against you. For example, take a look at mandatory withdrawals ("required minimum distribution" - RMD) for some types of retirement accounts in the US at certain age + how your retirement account suffers disproportionately if market is down when you start mandatory withdrawals. I know the math you are talking about, it does make sense conceptually and that's why it's cited in all 401k materials, real life with its rules and uncertainty is bit more complicated.
- bluetwo 10y agoIf you are self-employed and incorporated, and are really crushing it, you can open both a 401k and a Roth 401k to maximize the amount you can stuff away.
- loeg 10y agoYou can only contribute $18k as employee and $35k as employer (under 50 years old, anyway). Those totals are across both traditional and Roth 401(k) accounts. If you have 401(k)s at multiple, unrelated employers, you can get employer contributions from both to a total over $35k. But if both are Individual 401(k)s, I don't think that applies.
- bluetwo 10y agoYes. If you use both, you can work it so you hit the maximum 53k per year, or 59k per year if you are 50+, and have a big chunk in the Roth side so you won't have to pay taxes on the money later (You pay now, of course). https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/roth-ira-roth-401k-roth-solo-401k-whats-difference/ https://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/investing/roth-ira-roth-401k...
- loeg 10y agoWhy would you do that instead of just putting away 53k pre-tax, as a self-employed with Solo 401(k)?
- bluetwo 10y agoIn theory, having a chunk in the Roth is a better deal. You pay taxes on that money now, but down the road, you don't have to pay when you withdraw. Assuming it has grown multiple times, you pay much less in taxes by doing it now. And, you are not forced to take mandatory withdrawals when you are older. I understand the penalty for early withdraw, should you need to do that at some point, is more forgiving with a Roth as well. It is more paperwork and more math to setup both.
- rudyl313 10y agoI've written up my philosophy on beating the market, which is a little less conservative with respect to believing that markets are efficient and investing in the indices is the only prudent way to invest: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KXfTFYfmhb9Cy5NE0uRuf8SvqZArtLuRje6EeY5caEI/edit?usp=sharing https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KXfTFYfmhb9Cy5NE0uRuf8Sv...
- DocG 10y agoNot a bad investment plan. I do real estate. Earn around market medium and will have initalt investment to pull out or give to children at my will.
- torkins 10y agoFor an audience that might be interested in being a bit more self-directed, take a look at the approach of the guys at http://tastytrade.com http://tastytrade.com.
- pmorici 10y agoWhoa, startfighter.io is winding down? That is the first I've heard of that.
- wyclif 10y agoIt's very, very rare that I say to myself, "Self, I'm glad I read that sign-up email this morning." Thanks, Patrick.
- cloudjacker 10y ago> Crowdfunding has a bit of an adverse selection problem, where only companies which are insufficiently attractive to more professional angels They mean every idea that doesn't have a 10 billion market to disrupt and gain 1% of Its crowded at the bottom, enjoy the liquidity preference!
- tominous 10y agoFrom personal experience, before you put all your spare money in the stock market, make sure you have the basics covered. Ask yourself, "What would happen if my partner or I couldn't work for a few years?" Money: Set up life insurance, income protection insurance, and decent medical coverage. Accommodation: You don't need to own your own home, but have some money available to cover rent or mortgage if needed. Social: Don't let your social life revolve exclusively around work colleagues. Invest time in family and broader groups. Find a way to have achievements outside of work. So this happened to me. My wife and I went from a very comfortable double income to countless hospital visits and no time or energy for anything else. And this is just after we had kids. I'll be forever grateful that my wife set up the safeguards above. I was 100% invested in work, financially and socially, so it has been a huge shock and could have been much worse.
- AznHisoka 10y agoMind if I asked what exactly happened in your life that led to this?
- tominous 10y agoWe found out my wife had cancer ("of unknown primary") in May last year. We're in our early 30s so this should not be happening. Anyway, I think the same advice would still apply for more mundane situations like a recession or a failed business.
- perseusprime11 10y agorelated topic but how important is having a financial advisor?
- icedchai 10y agoI'm currently investing $1000/week into Vanguard funds. I've been doing this since 2007, started at $500/week, and gradually moved up. The key is to always be investing. Currently I am focused on international and energy. I feel these are "low" and will come back in 5 or 10 years. Maybe I'm a fool. Sometimes, it is difficult to resist trying to time things, and if the market drops 2% or 3%, I'll buy more. So far, it has worked out, but holding on through massive losses can really hurt. Throwing your money into a correction can feel really strange. In February, I was down probably 40 or 50K over a month. But I stuck it out. I even bought some individual stocks (mostly SaaS companies) that are up 40% or 50% (CRM, HUBS, etc.)
- herval 10y agowhat's your current gain % since 2007?
- icedchai 10y agoAccording to Vanguard, my annual rate of return is 10.7%. This is actually since 2008, sorry. I forgot when I opened the account. It is actually a bit higher than that, since I rolled over some funds from another account and those gains are not included in the investment return calculation. Vanguard is showing the entire roll-over amount as a "purchase", despite the true cost-basis actually being lower.
- nojvek 10y agoYou must be making crazy money to invest that much per week. That's barely my salary after tax. Sometimes reading HN makes me feel really poor
- icedchai 10y agoI do okay. What helps most is I live in an area with a low cost of living, and my house is paid off.
- eigenvalue 10y agoAnother idea that has worked very well historically: buy spin-offs. As a category, they consistently outperform for a variety of structural reasons (forced selling, lack of awareness/coverage, perverse management incentives at the time of the spin that often lead to a low share price, better management from increased focus,etc.) This free site has a list of upcoming spins: http://www.stockspinoffs.com/upcoming-spinoffs/ http://www.stockspinoffs.com/upcoming-spinoffs/
- nojvek 10y agoThere are lots of words in here that someone new to stocks wouldn't understand. From the gist I make vanguard is a good starting point. Is there someone you can call talk for a consultation to explain this in a layman's language?
- loeg 10y agoYep. https://investor.vanguard.com/financial-advisor/financial-advice https://investor.vanguard.com/financial-advisor/financial-ad...
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoYou need to invest some time to understand it before you do anything, outsourcing your decision making to a financial adviser is a poor strategy.
- YZF 10y agoI agree with some of the points but a note of caution. Stock markets today are significantly different than those of the past and the kind of low interest rate, low growth environment, we've been in over the last decade or so has no precedent. "In the 10 year period from 2006 to 2015, the average return was a little lower than 8%" From the peak of the '99 bubble till around today we have about 2% yearly return on the S&P 500 (excluding dividends). You would actually do much better if you were in bonds. Between '99 and '09 you would actually lose money. Two takeaways from these, one is that you can't just pick some period and build a theory over that, the second is that when you're invested in stocks there is a non-negligble probability of losing money over a 10 year horizon. The only reason stocks are so high these days is that their prices are supported by zero interest rates. That doesn't mean they can't go higher for various reasons but you need to be cautious. Everyone talks about buying stocks right about when things get frothy, not too many people post this sort of financial advice at the doom and gloom bottoms. Over long periods, dollar cost averaging, you'll do OK. Don't rush in at a top and obviously don't sell at a bottom, something a lot of people end up doing. Privately held tech companies, especially startups, can actually have a better return vs. public companies. The problem is not the return, the problem is getting a strong, diversified portfolio. Unless you are a VC you can't really do that. In general small caps tend to outperform large caps and startups tend to outperform small caps, in aggregate, over long durations. It's really not about out-picking stocks, it's about being able to diversify. There are a few factors affecting diversification. Different markets and asset classes tend not to be perfectly correlated. This means that some may be overvalued at the same time that some our undervalued. While it's not always easy to tell (sometimes it is easy, when no one wants to buy) I would think one should offset their weighting to areas they consider to have better value. As long as those areas are themselves well diversified (e.g. Europe or Emerging Markets) the long term risk you are taking is low. The other factor is that having multiple assets allows you to construct a better portfolio. This is known as the "Efficient Frontier". Assuming you have some information about how the different assets correlate with each other (which is a big assumption but still) you can combine those assets to create a higher returning portfolio with less risks. Personally I'm invested in a mix of stocks (worldwide), fixed income, real estate (through funds) and bonds. I keep adding to this. I make some macro bets (e.g. I've been heavier Brazil, Greece, emerging markets, junk bonds ATM) through long term weighting of my portfolio and I keep an eye on those. Out of my current bets Greece hasn't worked out (yet) but the others have. YMMV. These are not the kind of bets where I can suffer heavy losses over extended periods (IMO) but there's certainly increased risk. I don't expect US stocks to have great returns over the next decade or so but I'm still in there with some portion of my investment. My horizon is 10-20 years and I very rarely sell anything (except the stock I get from work :). I try to buy when people are panicking but it's hard to find good panic these days ;)
- dschiptsov 10y agoThis HN talking head has an advice for everything, from programming to investment, while we, mere mortals, have never seen either his code or his wealth. It is good skill to make an internet meme-brand of himself and to sell it to idiots, but there is something sick (or shall we say new normal) about the community where this grabs so much attention. I never understood how people could stand a narcissistic talking head which is broadcasting nonsense-bordering generalities for more than a few minutes.
- dang 10y agoAw, come on. We're all 'talking heads' here; Patrick's just a better writer.
- neur0tek 10y agoGreat post. Love Vanguard
- SimonPStevens 10y agoCan someone explain why he says that 90% of people should expect to have a higher marginal rate of tax at retirement and so are better saving to a Roth pension with post tax money now? I'm UK based but the principles seem the same, and I'm fairly sure I'm paying more tax now than I will be after I retire.
- tharshan09 10y agoThis is very US based. Does much of this advice change, say if I were a, UK citizen? (other than the obvious 401k etc)