16 ms·
For first time since 1880s, more young Americans live with parents than partner
- erbo 10y agoI'll echo what Bill Quick said[0]: "Yep. Just the sort of thing you'd expect to see from a healthy, booming Obama economy. But #NeverTrump. Because we need more great news like this." [0] http://www.dailypundit.com/?p=122315 http://www.dailypundit.com/?p=122315
- thesimon 10y agoAnd Trump would solve this how? It's not like the US would be better off with cheaper housing prices but higher percentage of people without a job due to recession. Not in the US at the moment, so maybe Trump announced a plan for solving that issue, but the economy is far from the issue.
- mwfunk 10y agoHe doesn't announce plans to fix things, he just says how bad something is, says something insulting about whoever tried to fix it before, then says that if he gets elected he'll somehow magically take care of it because he's the kinda guy who "fixes things", or something. Although, there have been frequent instances where he claims to have a plan for something, but doesn't want to say what his plan is because he doesn't want to give anything away to his enemies. It would be kind of endearing if it was someone asking a little kid how he's going to prank someone, not so much when it's a grown man responding to questions about the potential use of nuclear weapons.
- dragonwriter 10y agoDid I miss the point where Trump offered something that looks like a vaguely plausible solution to the problem that in recent periods of aggregate growth, that growth has largely been captured at the top end of the income distribution?
- clevernickname 10y agoHe has promised to bring manufacturing jobs back by ending "free trade" (i.e. imposing tariffs on the countries that have been imposing tariffs on our exports for decades) and punishing American manufacturers that move factories abroad, significantly lowering taxes for lower income brackets (including no taxes for the nearly 50% of the population in his lowest bracket), and encouraging domestic investment by reducing corporate tax rates to extremely competitive rates while imposing a repatriation fee on offshore corporate accounts and ending the tax exemption on corporate income earned abroad. The "automation is going to put 99.9% of humans out of a job" dystopian futurist crowd may see this as punting the ball down the field, but I'd much rather pump some wealth back into our lower classes today and wait until everyone else is contemplating post-scarcity economics, than commit economic suicide while China snickers.
- jotux 10y ago>I'll echo I think parrot is the word you're looking for. Had you read the article you'd have seen this is a trend that started in the 60s and started accelerating in the late 90s.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shams93 10y agoEntering the post capitalist era where there is "no money" for anything not even continuing the species.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Grishnakh 10y agoI'm not sure what to say about this other than it doesn't bode well. I really wonder what American society will look like in 50 years at this rate. People living with their parents until their 30s, a sky-high divorce rate, high rents, massive student loan debts, these are not signs of a healthy society, and as someone else pointed out, it isn't good for the birthrate either. We better get to work on extending lifespans to mitigate this I guess.
- AdmiralAsshat 10y agoWell at this stage in the game, it seems like everyone right now who owns a house is someone who owned a house 30 years ago, i.e. the only way anyone from my generation gets a house is to inherit it from my parents when they pass on. Fortunately, my parents fully intend to do that. There's a rise, however, in the number of seniors who reverse-mortgage their house and sign away the title to it in exchange for a monthly income until they die. If that continues, I imagine the banks and private companies will own all houses in about 50 years, because the previous generation decided to further screw their offspring in the name of having a slightly cushier final days.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dionidium 10y agoi.e. the only way anyone from my generation gets a house is to inherit it from my parents when they pass on This statement can only be made with a straight face by someone who has never been off the coasts. There are 65 million people in the midwest and another 119 million in the South. A majority of those are in areas where cheap housing is the norm.
- logfromblammo 10y agoYes, homes in the interior of the continent are more affordable. But in my experience, none of the inland cities have a tech-job market robust enough to warrant buying a house with a mortgage, except maybe Chicago. And I wouldn't want to live there again, because of the corruption. So you can easily afford to buy a house, but when you have to move for a new job 3 years later, your equity may just be eaten up by closing costs and market fluctuations, and you might as well have been renting the whole time. There's just nowhere in the US where I feel like I might still be in the same spot 10 years from now. And even if I did inherit a house from my parents, I'd just have to sell it, because their city--my hometown--is absolute crap for tech jobs.
- bluedino 10y agoIn other countries it's common to live with your parents until you're married, or even a little bit past that. In America it's looked down upon. Nothing wrong with staying home, saving money (even if you pay rent to your parents, it's cheaper than living on your own). You can save money, pay for school, or not be forced to work a job by staying at home longer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shams93 10y agoThat's true, in Italy this is definitely the norm, but this kind of screwed up economy that only functions for the oligarchy has also been the norm in Italy for hundreds of years so there would seem to be a correlation between not having families and people being stuck under systems of oligarchy.
- sotojuan 10y agoLiving at home while working at even a decent paying tech job is a great way to save tons of money or pay loans. Definitely something I've considered doing. Also works great with remote jobs.
- joe_the_user 10y agoSure but of course most people who live with their parent do so because they can't afford to do otherwise regardless of the clever few who aim to save even more money.
- branchless 10y agoThis is true, but now you are saving for a meager deposit so you can take on a mountain of debt so that the rentiers can keep all your labour. This is not a good development, even if they used to do it in England in the 18th century.
- morgante 10y ago
- aeharding 10y agoThis isn't necessarily a bad thing -- the last sentence brings this up: "What all of these shifting dynamics mean for the future of housing, families, and work has yet to fully emerge." Just look at other developed countries where living with parents is normal. Could this just be the US lifestyle evolving? It looks like a pretty regular trend over the last ~50 years.
- actionwords 10y agodevolving
- searine 10y agoDepression era children created the reforms that ushered in an era of plenty, which was then slowly eroded until we are back where we started. We can only hope that the Great Recession created another generation that will fight for the economic reforms necessary to regain our dignity.
- Pica_soO 10y agoSurely the horn of plenty constantly refills.. Would really be depressing if all we ever where is too late to a one time party. Here to clean up and to be looked down upon for not getting that high.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> We can only hope that the Great Recession created another generation that will fight for the economic reforms necessary to regain our dignity. Not so far, it hasn't.
- searine 10y agoThe units of history are large. It hasn't even been a decade since the crash, and people don't easily forget.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoHow long after the crash of 1929 were the reforms? Well, there was the Securities Act of 1933, the start of the SEC in 1934, the FDIC in 1933, and Glass-Steagall in 1933. So, most of it was four to five years after. We are now eight years after 2008. What's happened? Not very much, from my view. > people don't easily forget. I think that 2008 wasn't nearly as bad as 1929, and people therefore forget much more easily.
- hackbinary 10y agoGordon Brown saved what was left of the world economy by bailing out RBS, Lloyds, and BoS, and forced the US to similarly bail out several of the US banks and auto manufacturers. It could have been a lot worse.
- k__ 10y agoStrange. Living alone is expensive, yes, but living with your partner shouldn't be much more expensive than living with your parents.
- shams93 10y agoThe thing the article doesn't examine is how many single people live alone and are unable to partner even if they have above average income, we're seeing a shift into an asexual society made up of people only connected to their immediate family with no other connection to community or non-familial relationships.
- xirdstl 10y agoOr not necessarily unable to partner, but don't care to.
- Jemmeh 10y agoIf you're an only kid it's still 3 people splitting rent instead of 2. If you have a large family and they're all pitching in, it could be even lower. Deposits to move out, needing a bigger emergency fund, you have to go grocery shopping/chores all on your own instead of splitting them with others. Time is money. On top of all this, most people I know in the early 20's are shit at money management, so they can't save up.
- brbsix 10y agoPresumably if you're living with your partner, you're paying 50% of the rent. I assume most people living with their parents are not paying any rent. At least in high-rent areas like the Bay Area, that's a significant savings in the order of $1000-1500/mo. Not to mention saving on parking, utilities, etc. Plus depending on the family there's likely additional time and cost savings with cooking and household items. Who knows, maybe some people even have their family or house-cleaner to do their laundry.
- mikeyouse 10y agoOn the coasts this isn't true since long time home owners (like parents) have been in their houses for decades and are insulated from the crazy property value increases. If you are a 30-year old in San Francisco, the difference between living with your parents and paying 1/3 of the mortgage in a house they've owned for 20 years and living with a partner and paying 1/2 the rent of a new apartment would literally be somewhere on the order of $1,500/month.
- excalibur 10y agoSo does "other living arrangement" include prison?
- ghaff 10y agoyes. And group situations such as dorms.
- shanemhansen 10y agoI think that in the future we will look back at current US living customs as a fad. The nuclear family will pass away and living in a big household with an extended family will be more common. I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.
- fullshark 10y agoThis trend in America is largely driven by weaker economic factors though. I think that's bad.
- hasenj 10y agoThere's an opposite trend: the "single mother" family. I haven't heard of anything resembling an extended family house occurring in North America.
- nilkn 10y agoI don't think you can call it a fad because that implies that it's a purely social phenomenon, but in reality it appears to be tightly intertwined with economic factors. In particular, it seems to be mostly financial issues that are encouraging the shift in the US towards multi-generational households.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoMobility in the US is high compared to many other countries. It's hard to pull off multi-generation housing when you live 2000 miles away.
- jotux 10y agoYes, it's higher than other countries, but the majority of Americans still live near their parents. http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/12/24/upshot/24up-family.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2015/12/24/upshot/24up-fa...
- Grishnakh 10y agoConsidering I've never see a family with more than 2 people that wasn't dysfunctional in some way, this doesn't sound like a great thing to me. I'd rather see a society where polyamory became normal, so people could put together their own families by choice, rather than having it forced on them by genetics. There's very few of my family members that I could stand living with.
- xirdstl 10y agoPerhaps the peak romantic-cohabitation in the 1960s is the anomaly, and we're now retreating back towards something more sustainable. Consider that it is normal to live with parents in many other countries.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoWhy not retreat back towards subsistence farming then? I can't believe I see these things on HN!
- pluma 10y agoIn Germany there have actually been serious discussions (both amongst social democrats and conservatives) about "multi-generation living" as a model to improve the well-being of families with children and the elderly. The rationale goes that grandparents can look after the children while the parents are out earning money and in turn the parents can eventually take care of the aging grandparents as long as they don't need intensive care. The argument being that this arrangement was historically the norm and worked out favourably for everyone compared to the modern "everyone for themselves" model where overworked parents neglect their children and the elderly can't age in grace because nobody has the time to look after them. I'm not saying whether this argument is valid or realistic, but "let's rethink best practices" certainly isn't as exotic as you may think, even if this proposal seemingly runs counter to the individualism that is presently the cultural norm. EDIT: The model projects in Germany also aren't cases of economic desperation either. These are middle-class families who think doing this is beneficial for their children. Maybe one should point out that "living together" in this case doesn't mean the same thing as "sharing an apartment" -- it's more of a "close neighbour" thing. So you could argue it's a bit hypocritical.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThe proposals about multi-generation living are worth considering, but they can't be used as an excuse to bone the younger generation and call it "the norm". And that's what I observe happening. I don't think this arrangement was "historically the norm" for city dwellers. There, you had either nuclear families, or singles, or wealthy families complete with servants and maids. In countryside, where you live is not important as long as you have land to grow food on and there's no drought. But surely everybody in your family have their own idea what city they want to live in. It's sufficiently hard to negotiate this with your partner in nuclear family! Good look doing it with all those grandparents.
- louisswiss 10y agoI wonder how the average amount of free space per dwelling has changed over the last 50 or so years... Perhaps this trend could be explained to some extent by the fact(?) that mommy & daddy have a lot more space at home nowadays than daddy's parents did when he turned 18, making living with the parents more attractive to today's young adults than it was to prior generations. Not at all suggesting this would be the only likely factor, of course.
- slg 10y agoHouses today are much bigger. This is one of those things that people often forget when comparing current economic markers or generations to the past. Our standard of living is simply much higher today. The average house had approximately 500 sqft per person in 1973 but had increased by roughly 65% by 2010. Sources: - https://www.census.gov/const/C25Ann/sftotalmedavgsqft.pdf https://www.census.gov/const/C25Ann/sftotalmedavgsqft.pdf - http://www.statista.com/statistics/183648/average-size-of-households-in-the-us/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/183648/average-size-of-ho...
- joe_the_user 10y agoYou probably need to look at the median house size as well as the average house size. Also, I strong suspect this varies by region and suburb versus city.
- derekp7 10y agoI would also add in the usable space (number of usable rooms). Many houses come with a formal dining room combined with a formal living room (often called the great room); they then have a family room that flows into the kitchen. Add in an oversized master bedroom, and you have quite a bit of square footage but not really anything you can do with it that you couldn't do with smaller houses.
- slg 10y agoThe census data linked does break it down by region (Northeast, Midwest, South, and West) and by city versus rural (Inside MSA and Outside MSA). It also lists both average and median. The exact rate of increase obviously varies depending on these facts, but the pattern is the same, American houses today are just bigger.
- hristov 10y agoThis is the result of our society screwing over the middle class and working people in general for many generations. It used to be the average joe could get a factory job after graduating highschool and be able to afford a modest home and start a family on a single person's income. But now jobs pay badly and housing is expensive. And in the few places with high paying jobs, housing is so expensive that it makes up for it easily.
- nostrebored 10y agoWe have a dearth of skilled workers. Everyone has known that wages for unskilled labor would go down over time for decades. What people were predicting re: shifts in the labor market hasn't happened, and I do think that a large part of this has to do with culture (blue collar workers are looked down upon) and another part has to do with the U.S. not doing enough to encourage people to go into these fields. For instance, Germany's programs to train their unemployed population in skilled labor is ridiculously effective.
- dionidium 10y agoNo, there's something different happening. Cheap housing is the norm in the Midwest (as has been covered elsewhere in this thread), yet kids there are still choosing to stay at home longer.
- dforrestwilson 10y agoMy wife, myself, and my baby are all moving back in with the parents in a few months time. They have a McMansion, so from a cost and space efficiency standpoint it makes great sense. Plus, free baby sitting. It has always weirded me out how easily people discount the benefits of learning from their elders in the states. We feel lucky to give our daughter a lot of exposure to decades of life experience and wisdom.
- kilroy123 10y agoI think there is more family dysfunction than other cultures. This is purely speculative, and based on my own experience. I could NOT live with my family. It would be non-stop fighting and absolute dysfunction.
- jupiter90000 10y agoThis is always interesting to think about. In the US, living with parents after adult age seems to equate to enmeshment and codependency between parent and child. I think codependency is particularly definable in cultures like America's where individualism is valued. An Asian family doing the same thing may be seen as not-codependent due to a culture of not going against your family and collectivism rather than individualism. I would go insane living with my family or at least have a reduced sense of freedom, but I'm American so I've got the freedom and individualism values deeply embedded.
- whatever_dude 10y agoI believe other cultures have just as much of a sense of freedom and individualism, but the family dynamics are different in a way that parents themselves understand that freedom. If you moved back with your parents, I assume the problems would be as much yours as theirs. As if they would expect to still be treating you as a child. I've seen that with all my American friends and relatives and that's the reason all of them hate being home: they cannot stand their parents treating them as kids. It's a really weird thing. In other cultures I have experience with (South America), the kids' individualism and freedom grow as they grow, even if they're under the same roof. In other words, their identity comes from their own growth, not from being sent away. It's common for people to still live with their parents well into their 30s -- normally, until they get married, although it's common to just move your partner in. And when that happens, they normally share (and gradually take over) the costs and burden of living in the house.
- morgante 10y agoOne thing which jumps out to me is that "other living arrangement" was higher back at the turn of the 20th century. Does anyone have any insight into why it was so high then but has declined since? The reason this surprises me is that college attendance (and, thus, living in dorms) was much lower then. What were these other living arrangements that so many people were living in?
- wavefunction 10y agoProbably renting a room or bed in a boarding house.
- ghaff 10y agoPer the original research, other includes living with relatives other than parents (but not "roommates") or group quarters (including dorm or prison). I expect that the former of those used to be higher than today. ADDED: Maybe boarding houses. Not sure how those are counted.
- poulsbohemian 10y agoIf I had to guess, boarding houses / rented rooms. If you look at census records for my neighborhood from a 100 years ago, nearly every household had non-family boarders.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoBoarding houses?
- tluyben2 10y agoIt's been a long time since uni and my first company but at that time (90s) it was definitely not normal in my circles to live with your parents. You were considered rather 'sad' if you did. But that's only perception/peer pressure; there are reasons to live with your parents (financial is one). However another thing is that I know almost no one who could live with their parents; that is not about liking or not liking, but more about that you seriously want your own space when you get to a certain age and my parents would be driving me bonkers and vice versa.
- slantyyz 10y ago>> It's been a long time since uni and my first company but at that time (90s) it was definitely not normal in my circles to live with your parents (financial mostly I guess). I don't have any numbers to back it up, but my experience (I think we're of a similar age) was that this was true mainly for "white people with an English speaking background". Most of my friends with an ethnic background did not have any stigmas related to living with their parents prior to marriage. This includes people who might otherwise be considered white but whose parents spoke a different language at home (Italian, Greek, Portuguese), etc. Granted, I live in Canada - there seems to be much less pressure for immigrants to assimilate vs in the US.
- tluyben2 10y agoThat might be very true; this was in the Netherlands in a 'prestigious' math/cs major; there were no (0) people with an ethnic background there. Come to think of it, we had no people with ethnic backgrounds in the electronics minor I did either. I live in Spain now and it's normal here to stay with your parents until, what is in US tv shows referred to as, far beyond serial killer age.
- triangleman 10y agoTitle needs to be updated: "... for the first time since 1880"
- return0 10y agoSince the percentage of people living alone hasn't changed for the same period, it seems there is a direct shift from Spouse -> back to Parents, or not making the step from Parents->Spouse. The percentages seem to exactly cancel each other. I 'm not sure if there is an economic argument to make here. It seems like a shift away from long-term commitments and relationships. Or that relationships cost too much.
- xirdstl 10y agoI don't think that's right. The percentage of living alone has also grown a lot recently, according to the graphs in the article.
- return0 10y agoIt has grown decades ago and stayed high. In this graph, the vertical gray line is 2006 (peak). The same rate seems to be going back to the 80s http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/files/2016/05/ST_2016.05.24_young-adults-living-05.png http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/files/2016/05/ST_2016.05.24_y... wish they had better graphs.
- ghaff 10y agoI'm looking at the original research [1] and it looks as if the percentage of people living alone or as single parents has increased significantly (like 3-5x). Which doesn't invalidate your point. The headline here should be that married or cohabitating has dropped and all the other categories have increased. [1]http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2016/05/24/for-first-time-in-modern-era-living-with-parents-edges-out-other-living-arrangements-for-18-to-34-year-olds/st_2016-05-24_young-adults-living-01/ http://www.pewsocialtrends.org/2016/05/24/for-first-time-in-...
- return0 10y agoLooking at the other graphs, the increase in living alone happened decades ago, while the shift to living with parents is very recent.
- 10y ago
- rwhitman 10y agoSo much of the most comfortable housing stock in America is single-family "McMansion" type homes. The type of suburban detached house that likely the majority of middle-class American millennials grew up in. For a young adult in the current economic climate, the only way you're living in one of these cushy homes is if you're living with your parents. You can't rent one very easily, since they can't be divided up into multiple units or rented at all due to zoning and HOAs. Not to mention it's not typical to be a renter in these neighborhoods to begin with, so even finding a rental is nearly impossible in some areas. Then of course, after the housing bubble crashed and the subsidies went away, a mortgage for one of these became a big challenge to achieve, and who has the savings sitting around for upkeep and emergency maintenance? Boomer parents, and a handful of lucky gen-xers are pretty much the only people who could comfortably acquire and hold onto these houses, so it only makes sense that sticking to them like glue is the best strategy if you wanted one. And there's also the fact that it's just not cool to live in the 'burbs, where you grew up, in the first place. The mental justification has to be "well I'm saving money at least". Saving money, means crashing with the parents. After all, it's "just temporary". Those are at least my very subjective observations that might be overlooked in that study...
- Kluny 10y agoIt's more than uncool. It means giving up a huge portion of your life to commute to work, to your kid's school, and to the grocery store. It's definitely not coolness that keeps me living in a neighborhood where I can walk to the grocery store and to work. It massively increases the hours of my life.
- hackbinary 10y agoI blame the baby-boomers and their "It is all mine attitude". The baby-boomers have systematically dismantled all of the social advances since WWI. This is yet another indictment of their greed.
- prewett 10y agoI'd like to see some sources for that, and less unsubstantiated inflamatory rhetoric. Trump is giving us more than enough of that. Also, baby-boomers didn't happen until after WWII, and there are a lot more social services [welfare, social security, medicare, Obamacare, more trust in banks thanks to FDIC] and regarding social advances, women are freer, the civil rights movement happened, the sexual revolution happened, and homosexuality is socially accepted [I, personally, don't think the latter two are positive developments, but I mention them because I am in the minority]. You have baby-boomers to thank for a lot of that. Social advances since WWI? Yep, lots! "Dismantled" is hardly the word to use for the 20th century.
- hackbinary 10y agoAll of the social advances happened despite the Babyboomers, and largely because of the 'Greatest Generation.' The Babyboomers have engaged in a systematic reduction in taxes since the 1980's when they took over the economy, and therefore government's abilties to fund things like education. The babyboomers had free and lowcost education across most western countries, yet now most young people now graduating from university now leave with crippling levels of (student) debt. Our infrastructure is crumbling, our young are getting poorer and poorer education and we are told we can not afford these public services as tax receipts go down. The babyboomers have been at the wheel for the last 30 years, and they have left us a mess to clean up from their greed. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/10171591/10-Baby-Boomer-entitlements-todays-youth-wont-have.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/10171591/10-Bab... http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/10/who-destroyed-the-economy-the-case-against-the-baby-boomers/263291/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2012/10/who-dest... https://www.ced.org/blog/entry/are-we-about-to-let-all-of-the-baby-boomers-off-the-hook-please-no https://www.ced.org/blog/entry/are-we-about-to-let-all-of-th...
- ThomPete 10y agoThe number one elephant in the room is that the cost of living is increasing while most salaries are not. It was supposed to be the other way around but urbanization seems to be a major factor for why that doesn't happen mostly because of the increasing value of real-estate that comes with urbanization.
- eru 10y agoNot the first time this happened. Check out "Progress and Poverty: An Inquiry into the Cause of Industrial Depressions and of Increase of Want with Increase of Wealth: The Remedy" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_and_Poverty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Progress_and_Poverty), the book that kicked off the Progressive Era.
- ThomPete 10y agoAhh yes, Geoism. I have a lot of sympathy for some of the thinking there.
- eru 10y agoWikipedia also has https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geolibertarianism which is essetially the same thing but might appeal more to the traditional libertarian hacker demographic. In German we have Silvio Gesell and his Freiwirtschaft.
- cwbrandsma 10y agoI'm planning on this happening to me right now. Basically, I'm not ruling out the possibility of my kids living with us until they are about 25. Too many things are working against them. College is too expensive, housing will be insane, and there is really no chance of their first jobs to be enough to pay for anything other than rent. I can't even rule out them getting married and still having to live with us.
- ghaff 10y agoThe headline is one specific framing of the research. The more obvious takeaway for me is that "married or cohabitating in own household" has dropped significantly while living with parents, living alone/single parents/roommates, living with other relatives/group living situations have all gone up. (The study doesn't seem to break out just living alone.) So I'm not sure the degree to which I'm inclined to read this study as "young people moving in with parents" so much as "young people not moving in with partners."
- arca_vorago 10y agoThis is simply the result of class-warfare, and the rich are winning. Nobody wants to hear it though. Every time I rail against the supranational oligarchical bankers on hn I get downvoted into oblivion, and almost always without any response or discussion. My estimation is that the oligarchs have already exploited the third world as much as they can, and now the only place left to exploit is to turn inwards an cannibalize their own populace. This is primarily happening in the banking center countries, Germany, USA, and the UK. Personally, I have been expecting a crash that is used to push a globalist currency move, my guess with cybercrime as the scapegoat. Globalism is the enemy. I am so tired of hearing about how globalism is just here to stay and Americans are just going to have to get used to a lower standard of living. It's just a talking point for collectivists who want to push the global government model, but I think that a return to protectionism is what is called for. Tax imports, subsidize exports, lower or abolish income taxes, reduce corporate tax rate but make less loopholes so they actually have to pay something. Do not misconstrue protectionism for isolationism, which is a common but false retort. Inflation is much higher than measured, because they have figured out how to manipulate the numbers. The same with wages... and unemployment,.. and all the other things we supposedly use to measure the macro-economy. We need to stop speaking of the branches of the evil and get to the root, and I am convinced that the central banks are the root that is rotting this country. The fiat, fractional reserve system is farcicle enough, but decoupling it from gold and turning it into the petrodollar has forced us into realpolitik geostrategic moves that are going to do nothing but bite us in the ass. Andrew Jackson may have been a son of bitch, but he was right in how he attacked the banks. "It is maintained by some that the bank is a means of executing the constitutional power “to coin money and regulate the value thereof.” Congress have established a mint to coin money and passed laws to regulate the value thereof. The money so coined, with its value so regulated, and such foreign coins as Congress may adopt are the only currency known to the Constitution. But if they have other power to regulate the currency, it was conferred to be exercised by themselves, and not to be transferred to a corporation. If the bank be established for that purpose, with a charter unalterable without its consent, Congress have parted with their power for a term of years, during which the Constitution is a dead letter. It is neither necessary nor proper to transfer its legislative power to such a bank, and therefore unconstitutional." http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/ajveto01.asp http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/ajveto01.asp In other words, congress should abolish the sneakily passed Aldrich bill... cough Federal Reserve Bill, and reclaim it's constitutional authority to regulate money. (Please note, I do understand that too drastic a change away from a fiat fractional reserve system would cause too much instability, which is why I think at first the structure should be maintained, but instead of an unaccountable board of governors and open market committee, it would be congress. The real danger is that congress is bought and paid for, so we need a simultaneous movement to kick out all the incumbents.)
- jupiter90000 10y agoI think this is due to economics for sure, but also I think this generation, of which I'm barely part of by the age range, has much less balls and guts than the recent previous generations. Yes the quality of life is better, but now we have generation that just wants to coast along and ride off the successes of parents and forefathers/mothers. "I don't care if I have a shitty job and live in my parents basement, I have a smart phone and a car my parents gave me. I won't fight for better wages a better world, or my country because I'll miss watching survivor tonight. Hopefully someone gets elected to fix everything because I am too busy on facebook to vote and refuse to fight to have a life I want and can respect since it brings up uncomfortable feelings and takes effort." I know I'm generalizing, but I'm disgusted in general with the lack of effort and spirit people in my generation seem to be putting into doing something about changing this shit. Let's just go back to our comfort cave at mom's and chill instead of giving a fuck.
- llamaz 10y agoIt is typical of a hamburger eating American to generalize an entire generation.
- rbritton 10y agoI photographed students just prior to going into their senior year of high school for the last 10 years, and I don't feel it's getting any better. In this area there were two trends that stood out sharply: 1. A rise in the number of grandparents raising the kids rather than their own parents. 2. A decrease in the number of students that had any kind of plans or ambitions for post-high school life.
- pconner 10y agoDo you have any real, hard data to back your statements up, or just your own personal observations?
- jupiter90000 10y agoHow would you expect this to be quantified? Just curious, I'm not planning to go researching for you. I admit it was a rant, and I'm allowed to have one from time to time.
- leepowers 10y agoReading the article what's striking is that while living with parents has now surpassed it's 1880 level of 30%, it has otherwise remained mostly stable, peaking at 35% in 1940. The big change is in the the decline in married/cohabiting households, which as nearly halved since 1960 (from 62% to 32%) A couple buying a house during our current period of declining wages is hard enough. Doing it yourself is even more difficult, especially without a college degree or other marketable skills.
- whybroke 10y agoCreate a society that does it's best to drive housing prices up faster than wages and this is the necessary result. This and homelessness and the strangulation of nascent innovative cities like Portland (and Vancouver). Of course no politician is going to advocate driving down housing prices because, in lieu of an adequate retirement system, vast swathes of the populace are entirely dependent on that housing Ponzi scheme for their old age. Its disruption is unthinkable to them. That and the inordinate influence of the mortgage industry. So loudly blaming rent control and zoning is the prefect way to do absolutely nothing about the problem as neither of these have any but the most minimal impact on the situation. If you wanted to guarantee the next generation has it even harder, limiting the conversation to these essentially irrelevant points would be the perfect way.
- tn13 10y agoA lot of people are seeing this as a problem. I think there are many positives to it. 1. Over years American cities have built their specialties. It is much easier for children to find job in same field as their parents and settle in the same city as their parents. 2. More Americans now own housing makes sense to stay with parents. 3. Millennials have invested more in education and other things than spending money on rent. Very likely these millennials would end up saving more and form the backbone of american middle class over next 20 years.
- jhallenworld 10y agoThere are interesting possibilities if you can compromise on the city. For example, take Worcester MA (2nd largest city in New England, still close to the high-tech areas). In Worcester you can buy a "triple-decker" (three three-bedroom apartments) for $400K or less. Rent is ~$1100 / unit, so this can easily pay for the mortgage. http://www.zillow.com/homes/18-Ferdinand-ST-Worcester-MA-01603_rb/ http://www.zillow.com/homes/18-Ferdinand-ST-Worcester-MA-016... Companies no longer offer pensions, so better start your rental empire now.
- trgn 10y agoyep. but if you have the leftover income and time to invest and maintain rental property, you also have the leftover income and time to research and invest in stock market. or study for a professional degree with higher salary, or seduce and mary a rich heiress, etc... all those will get you more money in the end. I'm not being dismissive though, I agree with you. In a handful of affluent metros, directing some of your disposal income in the rental market is just a non-starter. In the majority of the country, you at least have that option.
- ignu 10y agoIt's really a shame that our culture ascribes living on your own to status. A new living space to heat, cool, light and manage just to live up to our culture's view of success is incredibly wasteful.
- phil248 10y agoThe size of my apartment, which houses one person, is a tiny fraction of the size of the house I grew up in, which housed 3 people. Living on my own is dramatically less wasteful than even 6 or 7 people living in that big house. So it depends on the spaces in question. Urban living is typically compact and economical. Suburban living is expansive, what with the yards, cars and multi-mile trips to the store.
- godgod 10y agoGlobalism. College gets you in debt and when you get out of college, you have no jobs because they've all been pushed off shore.
- momchil 10y ago> In 2014, 28% of young men were living with a spouse or partner in their own home, while 35% were living in the home of their parent(s). Young women, meanwhile, are actually still more likely to be living with a spouse or partner (35 percent) than they are to be living with their parents (29 percent). Can someone please explain to me how this works -- if there is an approx equal number of women and men, then at least (35%-28%) = 7% of women are living with a spouse or partner who is NOT a man. If we account for gay couples, assuming there are the same number of female and male gay couples (and in reality there are more gay men couples than lesbian couples), then this difference is still 7% (or greater). So 7% of women are living with a partner who is not a man nor a woman? Not sure I follow this research.
- known 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hikikomori
- CM30 10y agoBut how does this compare to in other countries? I suspect the percentage is significantly higher in Europe (especially smaller countries like the UK), and higher still in parts of Asia like Japan. If this is so common in the US (where cheap housing is apparently the norm), it makes you wonder how it compares in other places where space is more limited...
- Chos89 10y agoI wonder how much it's connected with risk aversion and if it does, does it have any correlation with future economic growth?
- _xzu 10y agoUnited States seems to be following Italy's way. As US is much bigger transition takes more time and tolerances for inequalities are higher but trend is obvious. In case of doubt check if these are growing: Regional inequality, Wealth inequality, Bureaucracy, Tax system complexity, Corruption, Importance of social networks in business, Education inequality, Youth unemployment, Living with parents longer You could continue the list forever...
- jgalt212 10y agoThis happens because the Fed is content to expand the money supply by directly giving money to Ray Dalio instead of Ray Smith. I just don't get how the central banks think they can spur inflation with prolonged periods of 0 or negative interest rates. Have you seen what's in the CPI basket? It ain't stuff HF managers are gonna buy more of if they make $50MM instead of $10MM a year.
- epalmer 10y agoSo I am one of these statistics. I have an 18 year old that will graduate high school in June. She will take a gap year and live at home working for Americorps Vista help disadvantaged schools with STEM programs. She will then attend the Olin College of Engineering [0] My oldest is 23 and graduated in May of 2015 from a 4 year liberal arts university. She is working part time in our local library system. She wants to be a librarian which requires a Master's of Library Science (MLS). So she will attend an online program at Florida State for an MLS next fall. In the library system she works in, library associates are expected to give 2 to 5 years of part time work before they can go full time. The pay is okay, not great. None of her peers live on their own. At 20 to 24 hours a week they just can't pay for a place of their own (renting or buying). Full time work comes with a MLS. We think the library system is taking advantage of minimal benefits for part timers and are taking advantage of these youths. But the passion of people that want to work in libraries have them working part time and making the sacrifice of living at home. My daughter pays minimal rent to us, her auto insurance, gas, and medical co-pays. She saves everything else and when she starts graduate school her savings will start to evaporate. We have a few friends that have children living at home. The reasons are varied. One is because of some mental health challenges. Some for living at home and attending a local college full time to save money on room and board. Some because they work part time and go to school like our child. Her mom and I are 100% comfortable with this. We have some pseudo empty nester rules in place to help us have more freedom from our children and the same for them. However we still try to eat dinner together most nights. This is the together time that binds us as a family. Ten years ago I would not have imagined this situation but it is what it is. For the record we live in a coastal state in the US (Virginia) but in the center of the state (Richmond). [0] http://olin.edu/ http://olin.edu/ Edit: fixed typo
- mizchief2 10y agoHow many young people now are willing to work at a crappy job and live with 4-5 roommates in a crappy house just to be independent? How many are deep in debt with college degrees in a useless field? How many of their parents now allow their GF/BF sleep over, tolerate drinking and drug use etc.? How many require their adult children to pay rent or other expenses? I think there are many more factors than just the economy causing this trend.