13 ms·
Filmmakers fighting “Happy Birthday” copyright find their “smoking gun”
- amelius 11y ago> even if the work had been published in 1922 with proper notice, and even if that copyright had been renewed in 1949 (which the plaintiffs say it wasn't), the song still would have become public domain at midnight on December 31, 1997. 75 years of copyright protection is ridiculous; imho, this should have been 10 or maybe 15 years.
- pavlov 11y agoToday copyright protection is in fact much longer than 75 years in the US. For personal works, it's life of author + 70 years. So if you write a poem today and live another 60 years, your poem will enter public domain in the year 2145. For "works made for hire" (which includes most commercial works), the term of copyright is either 95 years from publication or 120 years from creation, whichever is shorter. So the movie "Ant Man" will enter public domain in 2110... Assuming that the US Congress doesn't extend the deadline indefinitely (which the Supreme Court has permitted). Law text: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/302 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/302
- danieltillett 11y agoNothing will ever enter the public domain while Winnie the poo is bringing in the billions.
- pavlov 11y agoSince long copyright term exists solely to protect media companies' IP brand families, there could be an exponential tax on copyright extension. The first nine years of copyright are free. After that, you pay $100 to renew for the tenth year. At year 20, the price is $1000 / year. At year 30, the price is $10,000 / year, which is still perfectly reasonable for profit-generating IP. The 70th year of copyright will cost a billion each year. At that price, it becomes a major board room decision whether to keep milking the same IP or rather come up with something new. The profits from this tax could go to culture and education, similar to what is done with gambling profits in many European countries that have a state-owned gambling monopoly.
- ChuckFrank 11y agoIdeas like this is what we need.
- richmarr 11y agoI'd like to upvote this twice.
- sireat 11y agoI am generally very anti-copyright ( I hold that ten- to twenty years should be enough for the creator/their family) but I really like this exponential tax proposal.
- phaemon 11y agoThat's an odd shifting of the Overton Window. I would generally think that someone who was anti-copyright would start from the position that copyright shouldn't exist at all. And that someone who was very anti-copyright would be actively protesting against the law.
- mcv 11y agoIt's a compromise. If copyright really is so important to your business model, then you can afford to pay for the extension. Once it stops bringing in money, it becomes public domain within a decade. As it is now, all art that does not generate money is forgotten and remains inaccessible forever.
- TillE 11y agoIn particular, there's a ton of interesting non-fiction (eg, niche history books containing original research) that's out of print but not out of copyright. Nobody benefits from this. If we had a reasonable "orphaned works" law, the internet could contain much much more useful information.
- nmrm2 11y ago
- mattlutze 11y agoPatents I can understand needing often to be shorter than they end up being, but personal copyright I'm not so disturbed by. When should people be able to publish derivative copies of For Whom the Bell Tolls on self-published Amazon accounts without royalties going to Hemingway's estate? Works made for hire, 100 years feels like a really long time.
- XorNot 11y agoBecause the idea that one individual - who is now long dead - can create a work that then should be protected for several generations of descendants is a wealth stratifier. What implicit societal value are it's modern beneficiaries creating that entitles them to that revenue?
- mattlutze 11y agoIt's social status and worth are that value. At creator's life + 75 years, the existing law is the lifetime, sort of, of the creator's offspring, not several generations. Should I be able to take his bibliography, self-pub it on Amazon with flashy covers and take the profits from it? I'm not sure.
- jo909 11y agoIf you are able to figure out how to make a profit with a public domain text, you are very entitled to them.
- mattlutze 11y agoIf he wrote the books half a lifetime ago? What's a reasonable time, then? 10 years? 20? From when it was published, or when it was written? It can take years for a manuscript to move through editing, and many of our beloved classics did terribly their first run or two. Is it anymore fair should a publishing house go all 90's Star Wars on works their stable of authors wrote a few decades after first publication, with the authors not seeing a penny from them? 75 to, what, 150 years may indeed be too much, but the answer is not so clear as to what the alternative should be.
- RexRollman 11y agoI am an ardent supporter of copyright laws but there needs to be some kind of middleground. Copyright lasts way too long.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 11y agoOne cannot discuss long-term copyright without mentioning the mickey mouse graph. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20090811/0123105835.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20090811/0123105835.shtml Copyrights have been extended so many time that the legal system has forgotten how to deal with expiration. The concept of profitable works "falling" into public domain is strangely foreign to most IP lawyers.
- icebraining 11y agoIt's not exactly "forgetting": "Actually, Sonny [Bono, Congressman who pushed the Copyright Extension Act] wanted the term of copyright protection to last forever. I am informed by staff that such a change would violate the Constitution. ... As you know, there is also [then-MPAA president] Jack Valenti's proposal for term to last forever less one day. Perhaps the Committee may look at that next Congress." -- Mary Bono, speaking on the floor of the United States House of Representatives
- nmrm2 11y ago> It's not exactly "forgetting" Unless you count forgetting high school math :-) > "Sonny wanted the term of copyright protection to last forever. I am informed by staff that such a change would violate the Constitution. ... As you know, there is also [then-MPAA president] Jack Valenti's proposal for term to last forever less one day." http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=infinity+-+1 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=infinity+-+1
- nmrm2 11y ago> It's not exactly "forgetting" Unless you count forgetting high school math. http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=infinity+-+1 http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=infinity+-+1
- mathattack 11y agoStrange that a recording artist would do this. :-) Makes one very cynical about his reasons for running for congress. And also very cynical about Mary following her father's footsteps.
- madaxe_again 11y agoWarner will win and keep the copyright. Evidence has little bearing on this sort of thing - all that matters is money. The lawyers will want to spin it out for more billable hours, the judge will too, as having that he found in favour of Warner on his cv will help him get more lucrative work from corporations.
- halviti 11y agoBy your logic there is no justice system, and I'm not sure that everyone agrees with that.
- blackhole 11y agoWe have a justice system, it's just hopelessly corrupt and biased in favor of those in power.
- bostik 11y agoSo you could say that you have the best justice system money can buy?
- kuschku 11y agoDo you by any chance read the blog of the German blogger fefe? xD He does make this joke "the best XYZ money can buy" about governments, judges and police in europe and the US quite often.
- bostik 11y agoSorry, but no. The joke is old. I first heard in the early 90's, applied to government. It was old then. I honestly would not be surprised if it could be traced to the early days of the Renaissance :)
- elektromekatron 11y ago
- kisstheblade 11y agoEven if the copyright expires wouldn't you be forbidden to use eg. the "Mickey Mouse" name for your own mouse-stories? Because of trademarks, which don't expire?
- mcv 11y agoYes. Copyright does not stop you from using the name "Mickey Mouse" for anything. Trademark does.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoWell, kind of a gray area. If I wanted to write a story or song about Mickey Mouse and sell it, that would be okay. If I wanted to start a line of T-Shirts based on that story or song, that would be an issue. If enough people got together and started making public domain art featuring Mickey Mouse - so much so that it became generic - that could potentially render the Trademark no longer valid, from what I've seen of the law/intent. Very large curve to overcome, but possible in theory.
- spiralpolitik 11y agoI think you could only depict Mickey Mouse as drawn in 'Steamboat Willy' as later depictions would still be under copyright. Trademark law would prevent you calling it Mickey Mouse and my guess is that if you ever tried to use the public domain Mikey Mouse, Disney's lawyers would bury you in so much legal paperwork that you'd give up before you got smothered.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoInteresting perspective, I can follow the line of reasoning for sure. Part of the reason I mentioned song or story (vs. visual format e.g. a comic) is because it allows the consumer to fill in the visualization themselves. Thus, while using the 'Steamboat Willy' version as a creator, the audience is free to substitute their conception as they please. No doubt I'm working a fine line here, but a catchy song about "Mikey Mouse on the River" could pretty much hit the factors to ground it in public domain...well, I'd like to think so at least haha. I guess we'll have a whole new set of legal knots to work through. I mean as in Trademark vs. Public Domain Copyright. This does bring me to recall Southpark has frequently used Mickey Mouse in a parody fashion (as an evil, iron-fisted empire chief) and apparently did a good enough job of sticking to Fair Use that I can't find evidence Disney ever sued. What I'm getting at is I do agree Disney is highly motivated to protect every bit of their IP to the fullest extent possible - no doubt their lawyers like this very much - but in a changing landscape, there may be certain workarounds that clever artists will use.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoAn interesting insight into (I assume) US culture in the comments that I've certainly never come across before. Do restaurants really have their own proprietary versions of the "happy birthday" song over there? I've only ever heard the "proper" version in restaurants and other social gatherings here in the UK.
- austenallred 11y agoYes, generally along the theme of the restaurant. I've actually never heard the traditional song in a restaurant.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoWow, you learn something new every day. I didn't come across it the couple of times I've been over there. I suppose in TV and the movies we always hear the "correct" version (even in a public setting) because they've paid the money to Warner to be able to use it.
- phlyingpenguin 11y agoGenerally true, but I've actually been hearing more and more of the actual song lately.
- Miner49er 11y agoChains seem to never do the original, but small, locally owned restaurants often do, at least in my experience.
- mark-r 11y agoI've heard the Happy Birthday song in a Hard Rock Cafe. I suppose they paid for the right to do so.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoFrankie & Benny's do this too, in the UK.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>The 1927 songbook referenced above was found in a batch of 500 documents provided by Warner/Chappell earlier this month. That cache included "approximately 200 pages of documents [Warner/Chappell] claim were 'mistakenly' not produced during discovery, which ended on July 11, 2014, more than one year earlier," Nelson's lawyers write. >The new filing comes as US District Judge George King was just two days away from holding a hearing >That important line of text published underneath the song's lyrics was "blurred almost beyond legibility" in the copy that Warner/Chappell handed over in discovery. Plaintiffs' lawyers note that it's "the only line of the entire PDF that is blurred in that manner." Hide the needle (and then obscure it too) in a big stack and dump it at the last possible moment. Can the judge hold them in contempt for this sort of thing? OTOH, I'm amazed they handed it over at all.
- joesmo 11y ago"Hide the needle (and then obscure it too) in a big stack and dump it at the last possible moment. Can the judge hold them in contempt for this sort of thing? OTOH, I'm amazed they handed it over at all." Sounds like business as usual to me.
- etler 11y agoConsidering it was the only blurred page, I wonder if that made it stand out more...
- sitkack 11y agoI would say it could be a potential disbarment of their attorneys.
- Mimu 11y agoCopyrights are so stupid sometimes. In France there was this class (children) that sing a song to their teacher retiring. Guess what? There fuckers came and ask for money, what a world we live in. Source (in french of course, sorry): http://www.maitre-eolas.fr/post/2006/07/21/403-adieu-monsieur-le-professeur-bonjour-madame-la-sacem http://www.maitre-eolas.fr/post/2006/07/21/403-adieu-monsieu...
- xd1936 11y agoWhy is this in the Apple News section of Ars?
- xxs 11y agoCEO of Disney sits on Apple's board (probably related to the infamous Micky Mouse law)
- ximeng 11y agoThe Hollywood Reporter had the scoop apparently and has a few more details. http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/happy-birthday-lawsuit-smoking-gun-811144 http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/happy-birthday-laws...
- wmeredith 11y ago> Warner/Chappell has built a licensing empire based on "Happy Birthday," which in 1996 was pulling in more than $2 million per year. Leeches on society. Good riddance.
- brianhempel 11y agoWarner/Chappell has submitted a response arguing that it's not quite a smoking gun. Copyright divestment by failing to put a proper copyright notice must happen with the "consent of the copyright owner". The song in the 1922 songbook said, "Special permission through courtesy of The Clayton F. Summy Co." without the appropriate copyright notice. The lack of proper copyright notice would have released it to the public domain (proper notice was included on other songs in the songbook). However, Warner/Chappell claims that Summy didn't own the copyright in 1922: the songbook asked the wrong people for permission. "There is no evidence that the Hill Sisters (Jessica or Patty) granted anyone the right to publish the Happy Birthday to You! lyrics until 1935. The evidence instead shows that Summy sought and obtained a license to publish the Happy Birthday to You! lyrics from Jessica Hill in 1935." As circumstantial evidence, Warner/Chappell also points out that in earlier court battles in the 30s and 40s the copyright holders never indicated that there was any authorized publication before 1935. Warner/Chappell doesn't address the filmmaker's claim that a 1922 publication would put the song into the public domain in 1997. I'm confused here: Would the publication have to be authorized for the 1997 date to hold? Filmmaker's request for summary judgement: http://www.scribd.com/doc/272751583/Birthday-Evidence http://www.scribd.com/doc/272751583/Birthday-Evidence Warner/Chappell's response: http://www.scribd.com/doc/272870978/Warner-Chappell http://www.scribd.com/doc/272870978/Warner-Chappell