13 ms·
The issue with pay was always a thorny one for me at Google. Not what they paid me, I thought that was fine, but that there was so much enforced secrecy around
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
The issue with pay was always a thorny one for me at Google. Not what they paid me, I thought that was fine, but that there was so much enforced secrecy around it.
The entire goal, as far as I could ascertain, of that secrecy was to keep people who had been mislead about how they were being paid, from being able to prove or disprove that Google was actually paying people what it said they were paying people.
And what had been presented as a really performance driven, no discrimination, reward metrics, was perceived to be yet another 'management beauty contest' where managers could swing bonus dollars toward people they liked (regardless of their performance) and away from people they didn't care about.
And to be clear, I was ok with that, it's how a lot of bonus systems are set up, but it bothered me that it was presented as something else. And while I didn't start a spreadsheet, I did get advised by HR that my questions were not helpful :-).
It was suggested that if it bothered me that much maybe I didn't really want to be working there, I thought about that and agreed with that conclusion.
- nullrouted 11y agoI'm not disagreeing with the other things you said. But there are a few reasons I believe companies want to keep salary information private: 1. They want to get top talent at a cheap price, this is understandable because lets face it all of us want to get the best deal they can. 2. They want to avoid a hostile work environment where people are pissed off because they don't feel Jeff in sales should earn so much. Those are the only two reasons I can think of that can be legitimate.
- RodericDay 11y agoI can't put my finger on it, but the way you parse this situation seems like you're trying as hard as possible to underplay its importance. "Lets face it all of us want to get the best deal"- it's like you're trying to empathize with "the company", and not think too hard about the people it's screwing over. Promoting salary secrecy at the expense of your workers' justified welfare is called exploitation.
- nostrademons 11y agoNothing wrong with empathizing with the company, just as long as you can also empathize with the worker and understand why they might feel like they were screwed over when everybody else is getting paid more for the same work.
- nullrouted 11y agoNot really...and I apologize if you think that is my meaning. I guess I look at it from a truly business standpoint and any business wants to acquire an "asset" at the lowest possible cost. Whether that be property, IP, other businesses or employees. It would be kind of foolish for a business to go in an say "sure, we will pay the highest cost" in every transaction they do and will likely lead them to bankruptcy. As a normal worker of course I hope they all pay us great salaries and equal pay for equal work but part of my "job" in the negotiating process is to make sure that happens.
- stormbrew 11y ago> As a normal worker of course I hope they all pay us great salaries and equal pay for equal work but part of my "job" in the negotiating process is to make sure that happens. So why are you arguing for making your own job harder? In what kind of negotiation does one side insist the other keep all the cards so they can play a shitty hand? Not a fair one.
- enraged_camel 11y ago>>Not really...and I apologize if you think that is my meaning. I guess I look at it from a truly business standpoint and any business wants to acquire an "asset" at the lowest possible cost. Whether that be property, IP, other businesses or employees. This is the same type of logic that makes people view Human Resources departments with disdain: viewing people as "resources" as opposed to, you know, people. The fact that you are comparing and equating employees with other types of assets is especially disturbing. A chair doesn't have dreams, feelings, or a family to feed. So it makes sense to get the "best deal" when you're buying one. But humans have those things, and treating them as fairly and humanly as possible should be the priority. This may seem like bad business sense to the uninitiated, but companies who follow this practice tend to have a lot of competitive advantage in the sense of fierce employee loyalty. If people know you're treating them fairly and with respect, they will return the favor.
- Retra 11y agoThose are understandable reasons, but I wouldn't call them legitimate. Like I can understand why "being angry" sounds like a good justification for punching someone in the face, but I wouldn't call it a legitimate reason. If your employees feel Jeff is making too much money, maybe he is? Or maybe your company is doing a poor job of making it clear what it is that he brings to the table. Besides, you already have a hostile environment when you force employees to keep secrets from each other. (They're certainly not going to be loyal when they are being exploited as a matter of policy. It breed cynicism.)
- nullrouted 11y agoI guess you and I just disagree which is okay :) I guess it depends on why you are angry and punched that person in the face, did they spit on you, hit your wife, etc? Your analogy here isn't very good. It isn't an employees job to understand what every other employee does and honestly management trying to justify every salary to every other employee would be a bit ridiculous. Maybe Jeff (or lets say Sarah) has a good salary because they bring in 10x the business as the next best sales person. That is easily quantifiable but lets say Jeff/Sarah brings in only the average income but you can see the growth with their customers. That isn't easily quantifiable and honestly doesn't need to be broadcasted to the whole employee base (especially since employees leave and go to other competitors and would then have a good list to work off of). Employees routinely keep information confidential from each other because it makes sense to do so. This isn't a bad thing like you make it out to be, companies shouldn't be some open society where everyone gets to know each others business.
- ectoplasm 11y agoWell, if it's legitimacy you're after, it's illegal to prevent salary sharing in the US.
- fleitz 11y agoHahah no one would trade on the stock market if you didn't have an idea of the order book, it's essential that pricing is disclosed so that FMV can be reached. Negotiating your salary with out knowing what everyone else was making is stupid. If you're a star performer the goal is to get everyone making what you're making so you can ask for a raise on top of that. (In companies with huge amounts of cash on hand).
- bjourne 11y ago> 2. They want to avoid a hostile work environment where people are pissed off because they don't feel Jeff in sales should earn so much. I've been in workplaces where everyone know each others salaries. Development shared sql database with the hr department so the "information leakage" was obvious. But nobody cared and it didn't lead to a hostile work environment. I cant say knowing what your coworkers make never leads to hostile work environments. I can only say that I find it illogical that it would (why would it piss you off if someone negotiated a good deal?), have never heard of any work environment becoming hostile because of it or experienced it myself.
- LoSboccacc 11y agomeh I worked at places with super strict 'hushing' policies and everyone knew everyone else salary anyway anyway I always treated policies more as suggestion than binding contracts, since I never sign on those.
- jjohn2 11y agoI can provide a real-life (tongue-in-cheek) example in which knowing what your coworkers make may lead to a 'hostile' work environment. I work for a state agency in which all our salaries are public record (and made quite available to be searched for on the local newspaper's website). There's two developers in our mixed group, of which I am one. The other makes a moderate amount more than me. However, he is much more senior than me, and to be honest, a better coder too, so it's understandable. My gripe is that I think we're both underpayed and I think we both deserve a healthy raise. I wish he was motivated to ask for one instead of just taking the yearly cost-of-living increases so that I might ask for one myself. And that annoys me greatly sometimes. I have yet to be hostile though. :)
- polymatter 11y agoI'm not sure why you feel you can't push both of you for a raise. Surely having the public record is in your favour because you can point to similar jobs that pay more.
- incepted 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vladimirralev 11y ago1. Actually most people just want a "fair respectful share" as opposed to "the best deal they can get". The race to get the best deal emerges from the need not to fall behind the few peers who decided to be greedy (or business-savvy as some like to call it). It goes viral. There are many interesting insights around that in sociology and game theory. Like the playouts of the pirate game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_game https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_game. 2. Well, yes. And whoever is pissed off just go find another job. This way everybody gets to see who is right and who is wrong and learn to respect each others jobs more. It should be noted that a mismatch in the understanding of ethics is just as bad as salary mismatch. Tech workers are encouraged to share all their knowledge while sales/business keep their knowledge and connections private, which naturally makes them more valuable. For example, there is no such thing as open-source business development or open-source sales leads database. Tech workers kind of made the leap, but in terms of sharing the business people are essentially assholes. There is no right or wrong here, it's just an ethics mismatch.
- prof_hobart 11y agoIf it were 2 that was driving it, companies would be equally quiet about grades. If you're annoyed that Jeff in sales is earning so much, you'll probably be equally annoyed that he's two levels higher than you. However, in my experience most companies like to make a big deal about your grade. I know the level of pretty much every person in my office, and whenever anyone gets promoted, they get announced in front of the entire company. The real driver is around option 1. The company doesn't really care whether you know that there's people in other departments or at more senior grades getting better paid than you. They'll just tell you that those people are doing more valuable jobs for the company. What they don't want you to find out is how much that they are prepared to pay other people for doing your job. If you find out that the person they've just hired to do the same job as you is on £10K more because that's what the market is paying now, the company has suddenly got a pretty annoyed member of staff with a pretty good bargaining position.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI think it is a simpler problem than that. Taking away all emotion, a company has an idea of what they want to pay for what level of performance. The problem is, people come into the company with vary variable amounts of pay. The solution that Google came up with was this, hire people at a rate that would get them into the company, observe their performance for a bit (8 - 12 months), decide where they were on the scale, and then plot an intercept course for them for "Google pay". They have always had two ways to control that, one was your "slotting" if you were over paid relative to your performance they could "down slot" you which effectively froze you out of getting a pay raise over two promotion cycles, and two they could "discount" your calibration value which would decrease your potential bonus and even your RSUs[1]. All had the effect of being able to "dial in" your compensation, post hire, into something they considered appropriate. The only problem with that scheme is getting people to accept it right? Who would take a job at a company where your offer letter didn't accurately reflect how much they were actually going to pay you? It established a minimum amount they were going to pay you (your base salary) which, people whom I knew took pay cuts because hey, 20% bonus target (and everyone told you that "most everyone get all their bonus") and gee that was actually a pay raise right? In the Bay Area when your HR "business partner" started reminding you that California was an "At Will" work state (which means you can quit any time, they can fire you any time), if you were paying attention you got the message to stop pursuing your current line of questioning/activity/what ever. But hey, it's there pool and their rules, that is the way of things. And while you might think it was Wrong, other than some of the stuff that came out in Brian Reed's case I don't think they did anything regularly that was illegal. Just optimizing to the a different set of constraints than you might expect. [1] "Restricted Stock Units" or RSUs would vest based on your 'score' with a max of 1.0 Google Shares to RSUs and a minimum of 0 Google Shares to an RSU.
- obrero 11y ago> enforced secrecy Not that the US government enforces labor law (for the workers creating the wealth any how), but it is illegal under the Fair Labor Standards Act for an employer to tell employees they can't share what their salary is.
- prof_hobart 11y agoOne of the reasons that these kinds of things aren't often enforced is that they are very hard to prove. Companies are rarely stupid enough to openly say that you've been fired or given a low performance rating because of this specific act, but do something like this and you'll quickly find that you've got a non-specific "troublemaker/not a team player" reputation starting to be attached to you and once that happens, it's almost impossible to shake.
- snarfy 11y agoInstead of retaliating directly, here is what they do: 1. Create an alternate project 2. Move trouble makers to the alternate project 3. Cancel the project I've seen this happen on more than one occasion.
- fenomas 11y ago> I've seen this happen on more than one occasion. OTOH, just because it happens doesn't necessarily mean someone meant it to. That is, for most companies it's hard to imagine creating a project just to fire someone. But it's very, very easy to picture a natural progression like: "new project starts and needs internal transfers -> several managers see an opportunity to get rid of bad/disruptive team members -> project fails because half its team was bad/disruptive". Never attribute to, etc.
- snarfy 11y agoI agree with the sentiment, but unfortunately, on one instance I was actually told by the project director why the new project was created (I was on the other project).
- higherpurpose 11y agoI know there are sites that ask "how much you're earning as a software developer" or whatever, to get an idea about how much people are getting paid for a type of job. But is there a website where it basically gives asks you to choose the company name, then whether you're male or female, white or black, etc? I think such a site could give us a much better idea of how companies treat their employees.
- ricardobeat 11y agoGlassdoor has done that: http://www.glassdoor.com/blog/tech-salaries-glassdoor-diversity-hiring-survey/ http://www.glassdoor.com/blog/tech-salaries-glassdoor-divers...
- cpncrunch 11y agoIt's only in their "diversity report". If you do a salary search on glassdoor there is no option to list by gender or ethnicity.
- vilmosi 11y ago>>> If you do a salary search on glassdoor there is no option to list by gender or ethnicity. Isn't that a good thing?
- aileron 11y ago...no? How are you supposed to figure out whether pay is biased by gender or ethnicity then?
- vilmosi 11y agoPay shouldn't be biased by gender or ethnicity. Which is why I'm confused on why you want to see the salary based on these factors. What about reports of single vs married people? Or based on height? Or ugly people? What's the point on playing with these numbers? Seriously, do you plan to negotiate your salary based on some factors that have less than nothing to do with the job itself?
- cookiecaper 11y ago>And what had been presented as a really performance driven, no discrimination, reward metrics, was perceived to be yet another 'management beauty contest' where managers could swing bonus dollars toward people they liked (regardless of their performance) and away from people they didn't care about. No matter what it is, people are going to favor other people they like over people they don't like. When it comes down to an individual making a decision against two people, this will always come into play, subconsciously or not. You have to be incredibly naive to believe that you'll still get favored for bonuses if everyone hates you, no matter how good your performance is. This is why being likeable/liked is part of good performance. If we're talking aggregate bonuses, may not apply, but anytime it's a 1v1 thing, yes, of course the amount the manager likes you is going to matter, even if it can't swing the decision in your favor in that particular instance.
- kmonad 11y agoI don't have it ready at the moment but I do believe there is a study from London School of Economics (around 2006?) showing that unhappiness about salaries arises through comparison and not through absolute values. Just playing devil's advocate, could the strict secrecy you experienced not perhaps be an academically informed attempt to maintain happiness despite differential pay instead of an exploitation plot (exaggerating here)?
- Udo_Schmitz 11y agoSo, are people in Sweden, Norway and Finland–where you have access to your fellow citizens salary–more unhappy?
- quonn 11y agoNo, but they are, as far as I know, societies with much smaller income differences than other countries. So that might make up for the fact that the information is public.
- danellis 11y agoIn keeping with the topic, I don't think developers are unionized in those countries either.
- e12e 11y agoSome are, some are not -- at least in Norway. Unions are particularly strong in the government sector, and generally even developers will be unionised there -- in the private sector there's a general feel that a software engineer is in such a strong position that they don't need a union. Like for most types of work -- that's probably wrong. But people only ever figure it out when it's too late. At my previous workplace (a research institute) I believe pretty much 100% were organized, both researchers, developers, sys.admins and other staff.
- kybernetikos 11y agoIt's probably not unconnected. I heard an interview recently with a company that shares salary data with all employees, and he said it provided a downward pressure on the salaries for top jobs as the people making those decisions knew that any employee could ask them to justify themselves.
- justwannasing 11y agoIn all my decades of working, I always thought my employer would fire me if he knew I was discussing my pay with others. I know I was told that could happen more than once in my early years so I don't know why Google would be any different and I perfectly understand why such discussions should not take place.
- frostmatthew 11y ago> I know I was told that could happen more than once in my early years It's illegal for employers to prohibit employees from discussing compensation[1]. [1] http://www.govdocs.com/can-employees-discuss-pay-salaries/ http://www.govdocs.com/can-employees-discuss-pay-salaries/
- justwannasing 11y agoAt a glance, it looks like that changed just in April, 2014.
- frostmatthew 11y ago2014 is when (by executive order) it was extended to employees of Federal contractors that weren't covered by the NLRA. For those covered by the NLRA (nearly all private companies) the law has been on the books for well over half a century[1] (discussing pay is considered a "concerted activity"[2]). [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157 [2] http://www.govdocs.com/can-employees-discuss-pay-salaries/ http://www.govdocs.com/can-employees-discuss-pay-salaries/
- aaronchall 11y agoThe US Labor Relations Act has been around since 1935. It's nothing new: 29 U.S. Code § 157 - Right of employees as to organization, collective bargaining, etc. - https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/29/157
- 11y ago
- grecy 11y agoTelling employees to keep salaries a secret is exactly like giving candy to a child and telling them not to tell anyone else. In both cases, the giver is being manipulative and trying to hide something, and it's messed up. I'm shocked how many people are OK with keeping their salary a secret.
- engi_nerd 11y agoIn principle, I wish I could freely share my salary with others. But in practice, I keep it a close secret. Why? Because I have to work with people very closely. This is not intended as a humblebrag. So for the year 2014 my performance review was excellent. Pretty much firewalled. I've taken on a lot of technical responsibility above my pay level (because I want to raise my pay level!). I was rewarded with a substantial raise. But several of my coworkers were very upset with their raises (which were very minimal) and vented openly about them. Should they find out that I received a raise higher than them, how would they react? Given their open whining, probably not well. Their anger would be directed toward me. I'd rather avoid that silliness.
- nwmcsween 11y agoThey need to be rational and look at what the issues were (if any) and try to solve them. This has to be looked at from a social perspective too, a more social and leading person will get a raise as it's perceived as knowledge.
- grecy 11y agoYou raise a good point - which I why I think the exact specifics of salaries can be a little blurry. I.e. "Your peers make between $x and $y. They received performances bonuses of between $z and $q this year", etc. etc. But it's still important to have the open discussion and get it out in the open.
- engi_nerd 11y agoThat sort of information gets out anyway. We all know what the salary range is for the various engineering levels. Example, I'm a level 3 engineer, so the salary band is (off the top of my head) somewhere from 85k to 103k/year. The raises given this year ranged from 1% to 6%. So we all know roughly how people are doing, but only our manager knows exactly who got what % raise.
- justin66 11y agomanagers could swing bonus dollars toward people they liked (regardless of their performance) and away from people they didn't care about. And to be clear, I was ok with that, Why?
- coliveira 11y agoThe most interesting is that hiding salary information does not work. If you don't receive a raise similar to the average of your firm, sooner or later you will find out and search for another job that will pay average or better salary. And if you receive above average, then you will either be promoted to a level where you're average again, or have your future raises decreased. Basically, the only thing that works is a promotion, which is clearly a public event. So, it would be much better if everyone had their salaries made public, with salaries clearly tied to promotion levels.