17 ms·
U.S. Bans Trans Fat
- nsxwolf 11y agoThe food police were wrong and killed a lot of people with trans fats. Can we have our lard back now? Oreo cookies taste like crap with whatever they've replaced the trans fats with.
- mhurron 11y ago> “I don’t know how many lives will be saved, but probably in the thousands per year when all the companies are in compliance,” I doubt it. People are going to continue to eat way to much of things they shouldn't, or too much of things that should be only eaten in moderation. It's not like Trans-Fats are the only thing people are eating too much of that is killing them.
- mason55 11y agoVery few things in food are categorically bad for you. Even stuff like fat & sodium, which people generally think of as "not good for you" are required for your body. If you tried to make a list of foods that actively harm you or that cannot be made a part of a healthy diet then your list would be very small. Transfats are one of the few things that the above does not apply to. They are actively bad for you and there are no known redeeming qualities.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoDepends on what the substitute foods are. If people start eating 100 percent less trans fat but 300% more sugar to compensate, then even though sugar has redeeming qualities, it will be a bad thing, right?
- meursault334 11y agoThe argument that we could end artificial trans fat with tons of sugar is a straw man. The most sensible replacement which in most cases only affects the cost and shelf-life of food is either healthy or less-damaging fats. Banning trans fat may be bad for orangutans but it's good for consumers' health.
- VLM 11y agoWhat possible corporation out there would intentionally increase direct and indirect financial costs, lowering profits, merely to not increase sugar/hfcs use to lure people into buying their product? Highly processed foods are now going to be much less greasy/oily and much more sugary to attract consumers. You need to do "something" get people to eat junk food, and if its not going to be the oily/greasy axis of evil it will be the HFCS/sugar axis of evil. Maybe 1% of the market, the green/organic or at least greenwashing segment, will increase prices and switch to saturated fats and dramatically lower shelf life, but on a population wide scale that is a rounding error. Higher carbs means more fat people and more diabetes and fat related illness including heart issues. So we're trading large number of heart disease related deaths for rather optimistically a slightly smaller number of obesity related deaths. Its probably a net win, but this is not the technological singularity where we'll all live forever...
- maxerickson 11y agoHighly processed foods already switched over to using better packaging that keeps oxygen and moisture out (trans fats don't particularly taste better than other oils, they have better shelf life, improved packaging makes up for much of the difference). Proof that I am not rambling incoherently: http://www.pffc-online.com/technical-reports/5213-paper-product-protection http://www.pffc-online.com/technical-reports/5213-paper-prod... So no worries there.
- venomsnake 11y agoMargarine was developed as a replacement for butter. Just bring butter back (or any other saturated fat. coconut oil is also awesome)
- cactusface 11y agoWell, if it was categorically bad for you, it probably wouldn't be considered food.
- mhurron 11y agoWay to focus on that and not the much more real problem with people's diets, eating way too much. Yes, you need sodium in your diet to live, you do not need 3400 mg of it a day (twice recommended level). Can you show that Trans-Fats would be killing people if they stuck to properly portioned meals? Removing Trans-Fats is just going to be replaced with other fats, and probably some sugar for 'taste' that people will continue to eat far too much of. I expect the effect of removing Trans-Fats to be negligible to none because of that.
- venomsnake 11y agoTrans fats taste terrible. Butter, ghee and lard have all flavor.
- marcosdumay 11y ago> Can you show that Trans-Fats would be killing people if they stuck to properly portioned meals? People, no, I can't. If you wanted mice, monkeys, pigs, or any other mammal, I'm sure there's a study for you, but people not. What do you think about the prohibition of adding arsenic to the food? If people eat it in moderated quantities, it won't kill them either.
- Someone1234 11y agoIt is quite disturbing how big the anti-fat (in food) sentiment got in the 1980s and 1990s. And even though it has been heavily debunked, people still look at fat quantity in food to decide what is "healthy." Ignoring the fact that fat (not transfats, regular dietary fat) is extremely good for you, and won't cause you to gain weight. There are even still "low fat" foods on the shelf which intentionally remove dietary fat and replace it with complex carbohydrates (mostly sugars), which are bad for you. Remember the whole "red meat will kill you!" thing? Yeah, utter nonsense. There's a small amount of cancer risk from the cooking process (and glazing/smoking) but broadly speaking raw meats are one of the healthiest non-vegetables you can eat. Much healthier than processed foods. The more fat the better. When you order a burger, the bun is by far the most unhealthy part. Then the sugared sauce (e.g. ketchup, mayo, etc), then the american "cheese," and last of all the meat. But most modern burgers are just "sugar delivery devices" in the sense that the % of meat is tiny and % of sugar (from bun, cheese, and sauce) is getting higher and higher.
- mcintyre1994 11y agoSorry to comment without adding anything beyond my upvote, but I think this may be a typo :) > broadly speaking raw meats are one of the healthiest non-vegetables you can eat.
- Someone1234 11y agoI'm not sure I follow? I am trying to say (maybe unclearly) that vegetables are healthiest and then [unprocessed] meats. So meats are the healthiest non-vegetable. Vegetables, raw meats, everything else. Fruits are a tough category as some are extremely healthy (e.g. Blueberries) while others are barely better than candy (e.g. Figs, Grapes, etc).
- Balgair 11y agoTo clarify here: You mean eating, for instance, bacon that is less processed (not injected with tenderizers, salt, msg, etc) is 'healthier' for you than bacon that is processed (all that stuff injected). You do NOT mean that eating less heated and cooked meat is 'healthier' than eating cooked meats. That the cooking process is independent (mostly) from the 'healthiness' of the meat. Am I correct here?
- tomjen3 11y ago>Transfats are one of the few things that the above does not apply to. They are actively bad for you and there are no known redeeming qualities. Yeah eggs, salt, fat in general - all of these used to be considered dangerous too. Why should I believe that trans-fats are dangerous?
- baldfat 11y agoAlthough trans fats are edible, consumption of trans fats has shown to increase the risk of coronary heart diseasein part by raising levels of the lipoprotein LDL (so-called "bad cholesterol"), lowering levels of the lipoprotein HDL ("good cholesterol"), increasing triglycerides in the bloodstream and promoting systemic inflammation. [http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/high-blood-cholesterol/in-depth/trans-fat/art-20046114 http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/high-blood-cho...]
- tomjen3 11y agoI am not sure - years ago trans-fat were banned in Europe and now our chips are so greasy that I can't stand to eat them.
- Vraxx 11y agoThank goodness. This will finally put an end to companies including trans fat in their products but labeling 0 grams of trans fat due to serving size and other stupid tricks. I think consumers as a whole can get over pie crust not feeling the same for a little bit, as well as a slightly different texture for frosting.
- venomsnake 11y agoLeaf lard
- nsxwolf 11y agoThis already happened several years ago. There was about a year where all snack foods were utterly disgusting - Cheetos were like fried glass, potato chips were limp and off tasting, Oreo cookies were brittle and the filling tasted like chemicals. They slowly figured out replacements for the trans fats that improved the quality. We'll never know quite what they are because of trade secrets. But it's probably far less natural than hydrogenated oils. Oreo cookies, by the way, never recovered. They are terrible.
- Vraxx 11y agoI still go to stores and see products proudly labeled with 0 grams of trans fat that actually contain trans fat after consulting the ingredients list. This did not stop years ago.
- nsxwolf 11y agoThe wholesale frying/baking of foods in vegetable shortening did in fact stop. There are still small amounts of trans fats in many foods per the FDAs allowance.
- Vraxx 11y ago"Small amounts" is certainly a very relative term given that the serving size can be arbitrarily small to misrepresent the amount of trans fat actually present as 0 grams. For example, say I'm selling a product with the ingredients list "Partially hydrogenated soybean oil". If I label the serving size as .49 grams I could label the amount of trans fat as 0 grams per serving. Now this is obviously an exaggerated example, but it's easy to see from this example that a product could contain a non-trivial amount of trans fat with a specifically chosen serving size to label the amount of that trans fat as 0 grams (trivial). Therein lies the issue.
- azdle 11y ago> “I don’t know how many lives will be saved, but probably in the thousands per year when all the companies are in compliance,” said Michael Jacobson, executive director of the Center for Science in the Public Interest. Ironic since CSPI is one of the major reasons that we are using trans-fats today.
- talmand 11y agoOne of them? From what I've read and documentaries watched, they are the major reason. Typically example of people going out of their way to order people how to live their lives for the "better" but ends up being worse. Plus it seems they are being revisionist about trying to act as if their pro trans-fat stance never happened.
- LordKano 11y agoThey are the primary reason.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bamie9l 11y ago"As for frying, palm oil is expected to be a go-to..." uhoh
- leonardicus 11y agoThat's nice, but I think will be ineffectual in practice. As soon as you start cooking with any unsaturated fats, a portion will isomerize to trans fats. I doubt major food manufacturers are using only trans-fat sources in today's climate of health conscious (or hypervigilant) practices.
- cko 11y agoI thought it required heat plus a metal catalyst to convert unsaturated fats to trans fats.
- hga 11y agoYou'd also need a hydrogen source; catalysts might be available, but you need bulk hydrogen to get anywhere.
- nate_meurer 11y agoAs far as I can tell, merely heating cooking oils does not create significant quantities of trans fats: http://blogs.longwood.edu/incite/2012/01/30/heat-induced-cistrans-isomerization-in-vegetable-oils-and-oleic-acid/ http://blogs.longwood.edu/incite/2012/01/30/heat-induced-cis... From the above paper: > "The results indicate that heating canola, corn, and premium and generic olive oil to their smoke point for at least 15 minutes does not quantifiably increase their respective concentration of trans fatty acids."
- jwally 11y agoBy these standards, how is alcohol still legal? Alcohol-Related Deaths: Nearly 88,000 people (approximately 62,000 men and 26,000 women) die from alcohol-related causes annually, making it the third leading preventable cause of death in the United States. -http://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-consumption/alcohol-facts-and-statistics http://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohol-health/overview-alcohol-con... EDIT: I'm not advocating that alcohol be illegal. I couldn't care less to be honest. I guess my comment was more of a question of how can you ban substance "A" because "Its bad for you"; but not ban substance "B" which kills 90k people in the U.S. annually? It just seems cherry picked is all. If the gov't is going to ban bad things, how does substance "B" get a pass?
- ahallock 11y agoThe gov just cherry picks/jumps on the bandwagon for certain things and calls that progress, while at the same time subsidizing industries promoting bad health and the obesity epidemic. Real change won't come from authoritarian bans but from a cultural shift and people caring more about their health.
- tertius 11y agoAnd when people don't do that, the government has a reason to get bigger... And that's what we have, a complacent populace.
- lbotos 11y agoI don't think mobsters in America right now are gonna start a trans-fat ring to get people their trans-fat needs.
- shaneofalltrad 11y agoThis is a good point, but still shows how our laws and the reasoning is never transparent. I wonder what they really are up to? It obviously opens the door for other regulated products (as in more profitable) will now have a higher demand. The FDA is the mobsters in America by the way.
- cowpig 11y ago> The U.S. market size for palm oil is 2.6 billion pounds (1.2 billion kilograms) annually, he said. He expects that to increase by half a billion pounds a year once trans fats are eliminated. This is really, really bad news. http://www.saynotopalmoil.com/Whats_the_issue.php http://www.saynotopalmoil.com/Whats_the_issue.php
- arbitrage 11y agoDo you have any impartial sources on the subject? www.saynotopalmoil.com doesn't seem entirely objective in the matter.
- baldfat 11y agoWWF? http://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/footprint/agriculture/palm_oil/environmental_impacts/ http://wwf.panda.org/what_we_do/footprint/agriculture/palm_o...
- kylecesmat 11y agoA quick google search on the matter will reveal many sources. Though not the most professional news syndicate, VICE ran a great story a few months ago on the environmental impacts of palm oil in Indonesia. https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-planet-for-palm-oil https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-plane...
- uptown 11y agoSeconded this. VICE's episode is well worth watching.
- ptx 11y agoNational Geographic: http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/10/141009-orangutans-palm-oil-malaysia-indonesia-tigers-rhinos/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/10/141009-orang...
- bottled_poe 11y agoThe difference being that this transfers the cost outside of the US economy.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoHuh, so apparently processed foods will be harder to make. What a shame.
- tswartz 11y agoPros and cons to everything. Replacing trans fat with palm oil will likely increase the negative impact some of that industry has on the environment. https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-planet-for-palm-oil https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-plane...
- Omni5cience 11y agoI'll just leave this here: https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-planet-for-palm-oil https://news.vice.com/article/indonesia-is-killing-the-plane...
- notNow 11y ago"As for frying, palm oil is expected to be a go-to alternative" That's like jumping out of the frying pan into the fire, pun intended!
- niuzeta 11y agoI still don't quite get it; couldn't they have just mandated the usage/inclusion of trans-fat in product, and let the consumers avoid it? By the same standards, we're still letting people smoke and drink.
- Vraxx 11y agoIt's already required for them to label it, but there's several problems with that solution that we've been dealing with since that was mandated. For one, if you have less than 0.5 grams per serving in your product you can label it as 0 grams of trans fat. This is a problem because serving size is arbitrarily determined by the producer of the product, which with a small enough portion size can still leave trans fat in significant portions while labeling it at zero grams. Other tricks exist like using different types of oils (trans and regular oils) in different manufacturing plants and calculating the average amount over all locations the product is produced. The other issue with this is that even relatively small amounts (relative to how much food we consume) can be very detrimental to your health. The other issue is related to the first and that even consumers that want to avoid trans fats can have trouble doing so if they don't realize the first point I made, and the only way to avoid that is to scan every ingredients list for partially hydrogenated oils.
- dagw 11y agoFor one, if you have less than 0.5 grams per serving in your product you can label it as 0 grams of trans fat. Simple fix. Require transfats to be reported in milligrams instead of grams
- Vraxx 11y agoOh I agree that would definitely have a good effect for increasing knowledge of what one is actually consuming, but I think uncertainty comes into play at some point. In any event I don't think that banning trans fat was the only way to solve the problems I listed. Though I do detest trans fat and it annoys me when I can't consume or purchase a product because I noticed there is a non-trivial amount of trans fat in it. In this way, banning trans fats is definitely a convenient solution for me and I don't see many downsides to supporting it.
- protomyth 11y agoSince this is by regulation and not statue, what's to stop the next administration from simply changing its mind?
- adventured 11y agoThe practical context of it all. Once most of the food industry moves away from it, the cost of reintroduction and the well known health dangers (terrible PR headlines), are what act to prevent companies from bothering to lobby about it. The companies spend large amounts of money to move on to alternatives, and that's that.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y ago> “I don’t know how many lives will be saved, but probably in the thousands per year when all the companies are in compliance,” said Michael Jacobson, executive director of the Center for Science in the Public Interest. "Saved" in this context means what, living 3 months longer because your heart disease is slightly milder than it would otherwise have been?
- hasenj 11y agoShouldn't there be some kind of regulation on products that use a lot of sugar? Specially those sold in large quantities ..
- logicallee 11y agowow - that is amazing. An outright ban. No, "strict labelling laws", no "strict regulation" in the amount or limitation on the kinds of foods that can still have it. Ban. I'm surprised!
- maxerickson 11y agoIt is not an outright ban. As the fine article says: Food companies will be able to petition the FDA to gain approval of specific uses of partially hydrogenated oils if they have data proving the use isn’t harmful. Companies will have until June 2018 to comply with the FDA’s determination either by removing trans fat or gaining a waiver.
- tjr 11y agoI wouldn't be surprised if every company that wants to is able to produce "data" which "proves" that their use isn't harmful...
- logicallee 11y agoI went on the title - I'm a busy guy! (Okay, I did skim.) Still, what you quoted is quite different from how I thought something like this would go down. In particular the standard of proving it isn't harmful is quite high! I would have thought consumers would be allowed to choose it in certain cases, despite its being harmful. (As they can in other cases.) Or, a small amount might have been allowed even though it is obviously deleterious, e.g. in foods consumed in small amounts and which are obviously exception and not considered healthy.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe only real consumer benefit is that trans fats have properties that keep costs down. I don't have a great characterization of how much they do that, but I guess it is swamped by other costs, so it is probably better described as trans fats being slightly more profitable for producers, not in terms of them costing consumers less.
- LordKano 11y agoDoes anyone else remember when the Center for Science in The Public Interest pressured everyone to move away from saturated fats to trans fats? The people leading the charge on this are the primary reason why we went to trans fats in the first place!
- redblacktree 11y agoWhoops.
- ams6110 11y agoExactly. I have really lost faith in the FDA. Saturated fat bad. Trans fat good. Trans fat now VERY bad. Saturated fat actually OK. Eggs bad. Eggs good. Coffeee bad. Coffee good. Sacharrine causes cancer. Sacharrine OK. Meat bad (especially red meat). Meat good. I now just eat what I want, and don't worry about it unless I start vomiting.
- tkyjonathan 11y agoBe safe and go low-fat whole plant vegan. Statistically, the healthiest option for you.
- drcube 11y agoStatistically, eh? Got a cite?
- pjonesdotca 11y agohere are several http://www.veganhealth.org/articles/dxrates http://www.veganhealth.org/articles/dxrates
- nostrebored 11y agoMost of which are terrible. Population studies are generally awful, especially when you're using the population of people on a restrictive diet vs. people eating whatever the hell they want to. Especially when you consider the number of vegans who are actually active vs. the rest of the population, which is quite substantial in my anecdotal experience. I think what you can see from these studies is that avoiding processed foods, being a healthy weight, and being active are good for you. Also, what about the studies showing the children of vegan (it might even be vegetarian, can't recall) mothers have lower birth weights, IQs, and are shorter than the general population? What about the rates of B-Vitamin anemia? I think that the benefits of being a vegan are the benefits of being concerned with your health. I'd be interested to see a comparison between an equally fastidious group of meat eaters.
- anon3_ 11y agoI thought this stuff was already banned in the 90's.
- jokoon 11y agoI live in france and apparently there is no law to force manufacturers to indicate those. I often see "hydrogenated oil", but I don't know if it's possible to get away with those tricks mentioned in the article. Got coronary disease in my family...
- ageofwant 11y agoAnd so dies the last of Indonesia's remaining natural forests. Covered by cultivated palm trees.
- neosavvy 11y agoBut what about biscuits!!! Fried Chicken!!! Alton Brown recommends using Crisco, he's like a scientist.
- buckbova 11y agoI use white lily self rising flour, buttermilk, and butter flavored crisco in my biscuits and they are phenomenal. I add a little cornstarch for extra crispiness. But I bet they would be better with original crisco before all the changes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisco#Changes_in_fat_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crisco#Changes_in_fat_content I've tried with butter and low-fat milk and it just wasn't the same. I use peanut oil for fried chicken. Not sure if it's healthy or not, I just know it's good for frying.
- moron4hire 11y agoThis issue is the most important health and safety issue in the country right now. Add up all of the deaths due to obesity-related diseases and it's an obvious low-hanging fruit for improvement. For all the yellow-jacket journalism surrounding cars or drugs or strangers or vaccines or guns, they are all drops in the bucket compared to heart disease. But that said, I don't think the FDA or CDC are doing anything functionally significant towards improving the issue. There is a greater underlying question that still needs to be answered: why has the problem continued to get worse, despite ALL efforts otherwise? There is a gun against the head of 2/3rds of Americans and nobody is asking how it got there and why it's still there. I'm afraid it's because we keep arguing about the shape and color of the bullets and how you should really be better at dodging bullets of you want to stay alive.
- hga 11y agoNot necessarily; another "unnatural" recommendation by our betters, to shift from fats and meats to carbohydrates, could easily be worse, and maybe synergistic. "Unnatural" in that we were advised to shift from natural saturated fats, and from something resembling the more balanced pre-agriculture diet. And I'm suspicious of mass quantities of unsaturated cis-fats, which I gather weren't quite so common prior to cultivation of oil seeds.
- moron4hire 11y agoHuh? You mustn't have read my post very closely.
- hga 11y agoAh, yes, I too narrowly focused on this particular issue of trans vs. cis and saturated fats and incorrectly inferred what you meant by the "this issue". Taking a step back, yep, the postulated (and being tested by Taubes and company) carbohydrate hypothesis is a part of what your comment is addressing.
- buckbova 11y agoI don't want to tell people how to eat. I'd prefer to let it shake out like smoking tobacco. Over a few generations many wised up and there will be many less smoking related deaths in the future. But everyone dies of something and who am I to tell you how to live while you're still here?
- cheshire137 11y agoMaybe I'll finally be able to find snack cakes and biscuits without partially hydrogenated oil. That stuff is everywhere, even when the label proudly claims '0 trans fat!'. Such a crock.
- criley2 11y agoThe label currently can say 0 trans fat per serving, and what they actually mean is less than 0.5g per serving. From the prev FDA rule: >Trans fatty acids should be listed as "Trans fat" or "Trans" on a separate line under the listing of saturated fat in the nutrition label. Trans fat content must be expressed as grams per serving to the nearest 0.5-gram increment below 5 grams and to the nearest gram above 5 grams. If a serving contains less than 0.5 gram, the content, when declared, must be expressed as "0 g." http://www.fda.gov/Food/GuidanceRegulation/GuidanceDocumentsRegulatoryInformation/LabelingNutrition/ucm053479.htm http://www.fda.gov/Food/GuidanceRegulation/GuidanceDocuments...
- danso 11y agoThis story is a great reminder that there's a lot of potential for studying Regulations.gov API and writing an interface (and heuristic) for surfacing interesting rules and regulations...the trans-fat rule has been up for comment for long while now: http://www.regulations.gov/#!docketDetail;D=FDA-2013-N-1317 http://www.regulations.gov/#!docketDetail;D=FDA-2013-N-1317 Maybe I'm in the minority of people who hadn't heard that this transfat regulation was soon to be implemented (as a former New Yorker, it caught me by surprise)...but there are probably many upcoming rules that are worth knowing about before they get published.
- kdamken 11y agoIt's strange that they're putting these measures in place when sugar is significantly more damaging to people. High fructose corn syrup would have been a much better target.
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoDoes this mean the end of no-stir peanut butter? I hate that stuff you have to mix all the time.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI've always used peanut butter that comes separated. It's never reseparated after being mixed, though. Do you keep your peanut butter refrigerated?
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoOnly communist peanut butter need be refrigerated.
- Nadya 11y agoPeople refrigerate peanut butter?
- thaumasiotes 11y agoYes, because otherwise it separates. :p
- Nadya 11y agoNever had that problem. Heretics.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Does this mean the end of no-stir peanut butter? Isn't no-stir peanut butter usually peanut butter with added palm oil? Other than the fact that this phase out will likely increase the demand for (and cost of) palm oil, it shouldn't have much effect on that.
- a8da6b0c91d 11y agoThe permanently stable peanut butter absolutely requires a small amount of added trans fats. It is not added saturated fat such as from palm oil.
- geoffbrown 11y agoADM, you are going to have to pry the coconut oil out of my cold, dead, greasy hands!
- TorKlingberg 11y agoThere is something about nutrition that always sparks a 500 comment thread on HN. I am not sure why.
- coldtea 11y agoEverybody eats? Not everybody uses Go/Haskell/Lisp/JS/etc?
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoBut vegetable shortening necessarily contains large amounts of trans fat. Does this mean that currently vegetarian foodstuffs will switch back to lard?
- jessaustin 11y agoBaked goods that require flakiness, and can't use trans fats, probably have to include some lard. Butter alone just doesn't seem to get the job done. Of course the chemists might come up with some other bizarre substance they can add to food, but I won't be the first to eat it.
- reamworks 11y agoYou know how to be healthy? Don't _be_ fat. Eating the correct number of calories each day is probably much more important than your particular source of fat. The U.S. Government probably killed at least a million people during the "low fat" craze, where fat was replaced with sugar in many foods, increasing the amount of obesity and type-2 diabetes. It's disgusting that people who are responsible with what they eat can't enjoy trans-fats in their biscuits and donuts.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]