45 ms·
US Senate Report on CIA Detention and Interrogation Program
- malloreon 12y agoIt is incredibly depressing how many war criminals in/formerly in the US government will get away with what they've done.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sbierwagen 12y agoI didn't know this was actually going to get declassified! Apparently it's a legit release, not a leak: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2014/12/08/why-the-upcoming-battle-over-the-senate-torture-report-is-such-a-big-deal/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2014/12/08/...
- lotharbot 12y agothe first paragraph makes it clear: "On April 3, 2014, the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence voted to send the Findings and Conclusions and the Executive Summary of its final Study on the CIA's Detention and Interrogation Program to the President for declassification and subsequent public release"... EDIT: also the fact that it's stamped "Unclassified" everywhere. If it was stamped as still classified and had been leaked, anyone with a clearance would risk losing it by reading the file.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- phkahler 12y agoWait what? >>EDIT: also the fact that it's stamped "Unclassified" everywhere. If it was stamped as still classified and had been leaked, anyone with a clearance would risk losing it by reading the file. So a person with clearance can't read a leaked classified document? I'm confused, more explanation please ;-) This IS sounding vaguely familiar in some way, but I don't get it. EDIT: Thanks for all the replies. Also, I find it interesting how many people here on HN are up to snuff on security clearance issues and ready to answer this question. 5 informative answers in 30 minutes!
- bennyg 12y agoYeah, a security clearance prohibits viewing anything like this. Even if you have Top Secret you can't look at things that weren't meant for you to read.
- ceejayoz 12y ago> So a person with clearance can't read a leaked classified document? http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/01/us-military-blocks-guardian-troops http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jul/01/us-military-blo... > “Additionally, classified information is not automatically declassified simply because of unauthorized disclosure,” Wollman continued. > “Classified information is prohibited from specific unclassified networks, even if the information has already been published in unclassified media that are available to the general public, such as online news organizations.”
- spoonman1 12y agoIn order to legally view a classified document you must possess two things: 1) the appropriate classification level (or above) and 2) a need to know
- simoncion 12y agoThe only people who are restricted from reading classified documents are those who hold government security clearances. Folks who haven't bound themselves to that particular machine cannot be told what they can and cannot read.
- lotharbot 12y agoIf you have a clearance you're expected to follow proper protocols in accessing classified information. Reading something via a leak is not the proper protocol. Think of it as analogous to being given a "gift" that you know is stolen. Even though you didn't steal it, you know it actually belongs to someone else, so you shouldn't accept it.
- gknoy 12y agoIf it's leaked, you're not allowed to read it. If it's re-classified as Unclassified, you're allowed to read it, as it's no longer classified material.
- kyleblarson 12y agoI'm pleasantly surprised too. Next on my wish list is for the Nobel Committee to rescind their Obama peace prize. Fingers crossed...
- nraynaud 12y agohe stopped it.
- higherpurpose 12y agoAnd protected every single criminal who was part of it.
- misnome 12y agoYeah, it's much easier just to assassinate anyone you want from the other side of the planet with a remote bomb. Or send in a team of assassins when you want to be extra sure that nobody can survive to a right to trial.
- nraynaud 12y agoI completely agree.
- ProAm 12y agoThis is horrific. Just reading the findings and conclusions section is astounding. Embarrassing and shameful day for the USA.
- addicted 12y agoI am pretty sure today isn't the shameful day.
- ProAm 12y agoI'm pretty ashamed today as a US citizen, but I get what you are saying. Sad thing is I bet we are still doing this.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoToday we should be embarrassed. Next week when the news moves on to the next celebrity breakup, and nearly everyone forgets about this, that is the real shame.
- andyjohnson0 12y ago(Page 56) Specifically, the interrogation techniques that went unreported in CIA cables included standing sleep deprivation in which a detainee's arms were shackled above his head, nudity, dietary manipulation, exposure to cold temperatures, cold showers, "rough takedowns," and, in at least two instances, the use of mock executions Mock executions...
- ep103 12y agoI don't see any section called findings and conclusions
- lotharbot 12y agopage 9 of the pdf.
- nraynaud 12y ago
- theandrewbailey 12y agoIf anyone has senators on the Intelligence Committee (like Feinstein D-CA), write or call your senator and tell them that they made the right choice. Members: http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/memberscurrent.html http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/memberscurrent.html
- mikeyouse 12y agoNot all members of the committee deserve your appreciation.. > The 6,000-page report was researched and written by Democratic staff members of the Senate Intelligence Committee between 2009 and 2013 after committee Republicans chose not to participate. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/10/us/politics/q-and-a-about-the-torture-report.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/10/us/politics/q-and-a-about-...
- ad_hominem 12y agoFeinstein has chaired the Senate Intelligence Committee since 2009. Her job over the past 5 years in this role was supposed to be oversight of these intelligence agencies. Fact is until this release she has been a staunch defender of the existing intelligence programs and the status quo among NSA, White House, and CIA. She's exactly the type of person you do not want chairing this committee. Unfortunately when Edward Snowden stepped up and did her job for her (without the privilege of legislative immunity), she called it "an act of treason."[1] In my opinion if the CIA hadn't been caught spying on her committee's computers she wouldn't have released this report at all. It's an act of retribution in my cynical opinion. That said, props to her for releasing the executive summary[2] of the report. [1]: http://thehill.com/policy/defense/304573-sen-feinstein-snowdens-leaks-are-treason http://thehill.com/policy/defense/304573-sen-feinstein-snowd... [2]: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/02/x-things-keep-mind-ever-get-read-torture-report/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/02/x-things-keep-...
- wmeredith 12y ago"The enemy of my enemy is my friend."
- 12y ago
- Loughla 12y agoWhy do they insist on saying 'enhanced interrogation technique' instead of torture? Even when it obviously means torture: "Another senior CIA officer stated that COBALT was itself an enhanced interrogation technique." When talking about a physical place. That is so blatant word replacement that I find it hard to take it seriously.
- mladenkovacevic 12y agoI think one of the conditions for the release of this report was to erase any mention of the word "torture".
- lotharbot 12y agoThe word "torture" is in the document. I happened to just read it in the middle of page 12 (conclusion #5).
- fit2rule 12y ago>Why do they insist on saying 'enhanced interrogation technique' instead of torture? Because there is an 'unenhanced interrogation technique' that is almost but not quite torture. Never forget that beneath the violation of human rights is a desire to destroy. Calling something 'enhanced' is just another way of saying 'we forked you'.
- colinbartlett 12y agoI think you already know the answer to this. They do this for the same reason that when cops shoot civilians they don't say "Then Officer Smith shot the assailant". They say "Then there was an officer-involved shooting.": To use language as a tool to manipulate the viewpoint of the public.
- rqebmm 12y agoexcept, "Officer Smith shot the assailant" is more manipulative of the listener's viewpoint than the actor-neutral phrasing "there was a shooting and Officer Smith was involved"
- binarymax 12y ago"enhanced interrogation techniques" I hate this bullshit language. Just use the real word: Torture.
- icpmacdo 12y agoFrom the section "The Committee makes the following findings and conclusions:" on page 9 number 10 is interesting "#10: The CIA coordinated the release of classified information to the media, including inaccurate information concerning the effectiveness of the CIA's enhanced interrogation techniques." I have assumed that's the case with many of their operations, are there more public accounts of them doing this?
- secfirstmd 12y agoGlad that it's released but years too late. The idea that policy-makers did not know what was going on is ridiculous. The reality is many did not want to know and where more concerned about the post 9/11 political environment instead of standing up for what was right.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoLocal and national news TV programs have been going on for days about how all of our embassies are on "High Alert" in anticipation of violence directed at them/us on the basis of what's in the report. I take that by itself as an admission that the government's conduct has been what should be considered unacceptable, and is probably only "lawful" in the most meaningless sense of the word (if at all).
- exelius 12y agoRightfully so. People should be upset. We let a sense of urgency take over our moral compass. Which was the completely wrong way to look at this conflict anyway: we had no need to be that urgent given that our resources were (and still are) effectively inexhaustible. We got bad intelligence, we made a lot of enemies, and we lost the moral high ground that the US had worked hard to rebuild after Vietnam. The failure happened at the top: Bush (presumably guided by Cheney and the neo-con "long war" doctrine) chose to ignore decades of intelligence research showing that torture leads to bad intel. Because the failure happened at the top, nobody will pay for it. Had we done things the right (slow) way, we would have a lot more friends in the region. Because the long, slow way of intelligence gathering involves building trust and developing friendship with people. But the American public doesn't have the patience for long peacekeeping missions like that, and the international community doesn't either. There are so many layers of secret courts and classified legal opinions that it's hard to say the US has much rule of law anymore. People have lost faith in the legal system much the same as they have lost faith in our legislative system. All that's left is the executive branch, which leaves us dangerously at risk of a dictator taking over if we elect the wrong person, because the other two branches of government are too weak to stop him. I hate to get all tinfoil-hat, but it doesn't seem too far-fetched anymore.
- cyorir 12y ago"we would have more friends in the region" This seems to be thrown around a lot. You hear things like, "if we didn't go into Iraq/Afghanistan, we would have more friends in the region," "if we didn't prop up Mubarak or the Saudis or someone else, we would have more friends in the region," "if we gave more support to the Palestinians, we would have more friends in the region." I think this is the wrong way to think about our policy. We currently have a set of "friends" in the region; Israel, Saudi, etc. The things we do will always upset a portion of the population, but you will also have some who support those actions (foreign policy has not all been a shambles, which is why we retain regional allies in spite of the things that have happened over the past two decades). Changing your actions will never guarantee that you will make more friends, because in making some friends we would lose others. By catering to the progressive populations in the Middle East, you isolate the conservative populations, and vice versa. Rapprochement with Iran, as an example, may seem like a fine idea, but the mere prospect has Israel and the Saudis concerned. So changing policy cannot achieve "more friends." What we can do is choose who we want to be friends with carefully, and let that guide our policy.
- revelation 12y agoBest part is page 403: "most of them [CIA personnel] do not know that when the wpost/ny times quotes 'senior intel official,' it's us... authorized and directed by opa [Office of Public Affairs]." Of course everyone with half a brain knows this, it's funny 1) CIA personnel don't and 2) the WPost and NYT continue this practice of citing anonymous sources that are in reality public speakers, giving a carefully designed statement.
- fit2rule 12y agoThis is long overdue, and pardon my jade, but there is nothing in here that is at all a surprise. The only news in this release is that the government itself is finally recognizing what civil society has known for years: as soon as you put government and psychologists together, you have trouble.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoWell, medical personnel in general-when you add them to the apparatus of interrogation, bad things happen.
- rdtsc 12y ago> Interrogation techniques such as slaps and "wallings" (slamming detainees against a wall) were used in combination, frequently concurrent with sleep deprivation and nudity. Records do not support CIA representations that the CIA initially used an "an open, non-threatening approach," or that interrogations began with the "least coercive technique possible" and escalated to more coercive techniques only as necessary. > The waterboarding technique was physically harmful, inducing convulsions and vomiting. Abu Zubaydah, for example, became "completely unresponsive, with bubbles rising through his open, full mouth." Internal CIA records describe the waterboarding of Khalid Shaykh Mohammad as evolving into a "series of near drownings. > Sleep deprivation involved keeping detainees awake for up to 180 hours, usually standing or in stress positions, at times with their hands shackled above their heads. At least five detainees experienced disturbing hallucinations during prolonged sleep deprivation and, in at least two of those cases, the CIA nonetheless continued the sleep deprivation. > Contrary to CIA representations to the Department of Justice, the CIA instructed personnel that the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah would take "precedence" over his medical care, resulting in the deterioration of a bullet wound Abu Zubaydah incurred during his capture. > CIA officers also threatened at least three detainees with harm to their families— to include threats to harm the children of a detainee, threats to sexually abuse the mother of a detainee, and a threat to "cut [a detainee's] mother's throat." The list goes on. I have no words. This stuff would make Gestapo, KGB and Stasi proud. I can only hope more people read this report. Worse imaginable crimes are committed in the heat of passion or because of madness. Those are scary. What is more scary to me is cold institutionalized, calculated, torture, which is what this is. Not sure who said, maybe it was Slavoj Zizek, about how if we are even debating "is torture right or what advantages it might have" we have already lost. Torture should be like rape. Anyone suggesting debating if rape is acceptable should be slapped on the head and considered an idiot. Torture should be the same in any civilized country. We are not only debating it, we have also done it, we have institutionalized it, and make no mistake, Fox and the like will also be debating its "benefits and how it saved Americans' lives".
- quizotic 12y agoI'm in total agreement with your sentiment and those (so far) in this thread. But I want to question the pretext of the interrogations: the assumption that Americans will support any action that keeps America safe, the "safety first" assumption. While the importance of safety is reflected in bulk of our public discretionary expenditures, Americans have other values. Americans value liberty. Americans value humanity. Many value these above safety (e.g. N.H. state motto). Sadly most people I know choose safety first and close their eyes to the corollaries, which leads us to where we are now.
- pwnna 12y agoIn the foreword: > Reading them, it is easy to forget the context in which the program began - not that the context should serve as an excuse, but rather as a warning for the future. Well said.
- tormeh 12y agoOoh, that's good. Here, have a comment so your citation stands out more.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoToo bad this only covers the CIA and not the military. I was a 97E (interrogator) in the Army during both Bush administrations, who was lucky to never be deployed. I bet the military also has lots and lots of sins that need to be uncovered.
- Someone1234 12y agoIf I may ask, were you trained in the stuff discussed in this report?
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoNope. But then again, what goes on downrange can be very different than what goes on in the schoolhouse.
- andy_ppp 12y agoAn incredibly thoughtful and non provoking introduction to the document from Dianne Feinstein. This is a good thing and anything that can help America step back from her actions in future and take pause rather than extreme and counter productive measures is a good thing. I hope some day that just like the well tested evidence that torture doesn't work it'll be shown that mass surveillance also gives next to nothing that targeted data gathering wouldn't.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoJust to clarify are you using the word "her" in this section: "America step back from her actions in future" To mean: "America step back from the actions of the US government in future" ?
- andy_ppp 12y agoJust to play devils advocate, so please don't take this personally... There are varying levels of culpability that we all share right. It's difficult to see that we are all part of the problem if we aren't engaged in trying to change it. Your statement suggests that the American government operate in a vacuum and certainly every day people aren't engaged it does seem more and more that they can do as they wish. I'm going to go donate something to http://www.rootstrikers.org/ http://www.rootstrikers.org/ now.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoYou've mistaken my question as holding some kind of opinion. Reading your reply I can see why. I'm sorry I didn't word it better. ps: I'm not American. pps: I believe that American's, like anyone living in a democracy, are ultimately responsible for the actions of their Government.
- DanBC 12y agoYes, sometimes people use "her" to talk about a country. It is an unusual use though.
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoSome other coverage of the same report: http://www.amnestyusa.org/news/press-releases/release-of-torture-report-underscores-need-for-accountability http://www.amnestyusa.org/news/press-releases/release-of-tor... https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/09/live-coverage-release-senate-torture-report/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/09/live-coverage-...
- JumpCrisscross 12y ago> Moreover, CIA officers told U.S. ambassadors not to discuss the CIA program with State Department officials, preventing the ambassadors from seeking guidance on the policy implications of establishing CIA detention facilities in the countries in which they served. (#8) I was not aware the CIA could order an ambassador from seeking the guidance of its superiors...
- koops 12y agoFalsehood right in the forward: "the largest attack against the American homeland in our history". War of 1812?
- ceejayoz 12y agoAccording to Wikipedia, the entire War of 1812 caused 2,200 American deaths total, let alone in a single attack.
- api 12y agoPer capita relative to population size it was much larger.
- kiiski 12y agoI was under the impression that in the War of 1812, USA was the agressor. Wikipedia seems to also support this view. Is that not correct, or do americans just have their own differing viewpoint?
- ceejayoz 12y agoIt's rarely that simple, and I'm not sure what Wikipedia article you're reading. Impressment - kidnapping of American sailors into British naval service - was a pretty big issue. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origins_of_the_War_of_1812 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origins_of_the_War_of_1812
- kiiski 12y agoI didn't mean to comment on whether the war was justified or not, but simply that it was USA that attacked (and so the war doesn't quite qualify as an attack against America).
- jstrate 12y agoRead almost half of it today and nothing really surprising. Still waiting for the Taliban, Al Qaida, and IS interrogation program reports though.
- Omniusaspirer 12y agoIf we can't hold ourselves to a higher standard than religious terrorist groups then something is very wrong with this country.
- jstrate 12y agoCan you really not make a distinction between cold shower and televised beheading/castration. I agree there is something very wrong with this country if that is the case. I've spent enough Karma today.
- Omniusaspirer 12y ago"Cold shower" is a joke of an understatement. These men were kept awake for over 7 days at a time, subjected to sustained waterboarding, slapped and thrown around, left to suffer with festering bullet wounds, etc etc. All that while being told that their families were going to be raped, tortured, and killed. I know if I was personally subjected to those things I might not be so averse to having my head cut off.
- DanBC 12y agoI ask you the same thing I asked Rayiner above: try it for yourself. Take a letter size piece of paper and put it on the floor. Strip naked. Have a "cold shower", then stand on that piece of paper for just two hours. Bonus points if you manage to stay standing with a wet cloth bag on your head. Extra points if you manage this after having been on reduced calories and no sleep for 48 hours. In your case nothing happens if you step off the paper.
- thret 12y agoI don't know that you should really suggest this. I've had hypothermia, it is quite unpleasant. And you don't know the state of his health, a myriad of bad things could happen.
- debacle 12y agoFellow parents, how do you teach or plan to teach your kids about this? I was discussing this with my son last night, but I really couldn't explain to him the prejudice and fear that people use to justify these types of acts, or the "otherness" that the perpetrators try to construct around the victims in the media. It's just not something he's experienced yet. There's no way to put it into context.
- ep103 12y agoThat's because there wasn't any prejudice or fear that warranted this, ever. IIRC, in Dick Cheney's autobiography, he states that he was a driving force behind pushing the intelligence community to torture their detainees. And he states that he did so "because if we started torturing people, no one would call the republican party weak on terrorism." He didn't have to go that extra mile. That was it, that was the justification. Once reports and pictures started coming out, the Murdoch press ran stories that "enhanced investigation techniques" were responsible for foiling various terror threats, despite official proclamations and studies at the time saying otherwise. And then the press claimed it was a partisan issue, because that's what they always do, without any regard to what the issue actually was. So I'm going to go out on a limb here, and say that in my personal opinion, the only story to be heard here is that in the real world, evil is defined as actions actions taken in self-interest that harm others (Dick Cheney's actions in this story, as well as the people who obeyed those directives). That while the press made it seem like 50% of people were pro-torture, the press never, never, accurately shows the actual viewpoints of the people, not to mention how morally bankrupt and unreliable this shows the national press to be. And one last point about how many people were convinced by news reports that since these things were only being used against bad people, it was okay, and how that should be a lesson to others and the future... and how many times this has happened this exact same way in the past.
- pessimist 12y agoDianne Feinstein deserves enormous credit. Fox News and Republicans are bashing her and by extension her party as traitorous as we speak. The argument that this report should be kept in secret because it endangers Americans' lives is abominable. As an American living abroad, I'm happy to see this released. Still, I wonder about some of the side-effects of this. Instead of arresting and interrogating terrorists we kill them with drones as its less messy.
- tormeh 12y agoI would rather be killed than tortured, obviously depending on the type of torture.
- scott_karana 12y agoIt's really disappointing that she does support the NSA's extrajudicial activities, though, to the point of calling Snowden a traitor. C'est la vie :P
- sigzero 12y agoThis does nothing to help my view of her.
- discardorama 12y agoThe report didn't endanger American lives; their actions did.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Still, I wonder about some of the side-effects of this. Instead of arresting and interrogating terrorists we kill them with drones as its less messy. We were killing plenty of people in the War on Terror while the detentions and torture were going on (heck, the torture was sold in part on the basis that it was helping us find and kill people that needed killing in that war.) And some of those tortured also died as a result. Torture and killing aren't mutually exclusive alternatives.
- spacefight 12y ago
- user24 12y agoHmm, page 291 of pdf "Collected Communications". I bet that's something to do with prism.
- Amorymeltzer 12y agoThe document has > TOP SECRET [blackbox] NOFORN on it. That's crossed out and UNCLASSIFIED is inserted, but what's that black box covering up? Is it another level of secret access so secret we can't know the name?
- andyjohnson0 12y agoOn the basis of googling "top secret noforn filetype:pdf", it seems that the convention is for the redacted text to be some kind of source classification (eg. "SI" for Signals Intelligence or "COMINT" for Communication Interception. I have no idea what it would be in the case of this report, but my guess would be that it was redacted to avoid ambiguity given that "Unclassified" is stamped next to it, rather than because the classification is itself secret.
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe classification is not secret, but the intelligence sources themselves likely remain classified, including the identification of the kind of sources supporting the information in the now-declassified executive summary. Even vague descriptions of intelligence sources are often treated as more sensitive than the information derived from those sources.
- hayesbh 12y agoIt's likely this was classified top secret and SCI (sensitive compartmentalized information). SCI compartments are classified, which is probably what was blacked out. Otherwise, it may indicate a classified partner knowledge sharing program that is classified.
- throwaway-gst 12y agoPerhaps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greystone_%28CIA_operation%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greystone_%28CIA_operation%29
- AlyssaRowan 12y agoSort of. Conventionally, it's the cover name of the information compartment. If we knew what that was, since we now know what it refers to because that's unclassified, it wouldn't provide an effective cover anymore. Of course, that's still a bit silly. The CIA insisted they redact even the initials of the countries involved. Ridiculous. Well, country R is Romania, country P is Poland. There are two others, I think Country J may well be Jordan. I think I would probably be completely OK with this report being leaked in its unredacted form, including names: I sadly doubt there's any other way justice will ever be done and these people will answer for their crimes against humanity.
- epicurus123 12y agoThe Committee makes the following findings and conclusions: #1: The CIA’s use of its enhanced interrogation techniques was not an effective means of acquiring intelligence or gaining cooperation from detainees. #2: The CIA’s justification for the use of its enhanced interrogation techniques rested on inaccurate claims of their effectiveness. #3: The interrogations of CIA detainees were brutal and far worse than the CIA represented to policymakers and others. #4: The conditions of confinement for CIA detainees were harsher than the CIA had represented to policymakers and others. #5: The CIA repeatedly provided inaccurate information to the Department of Justice, impeding a proper legal analysis of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation techniques. #6: The CIA has actively avoided or impeded congressional oversight of the program. #7: The CIA impeded effective White House oversight and decision-making. #8: The CIA’s operation and management of the program complicated, and in some cases impeded, the national security missions of other Executive Branch agencies. #9: The CIA impeded oversight of the CIA’s Office of the Inspector General. #10: The CIA coordinated the release of classified information to the media, including inaccurate information concerning the effectiveness of the CIA’s enhanced interrogation techniques. #11: The CIA was unprepared as it began operating its Detention and Interrogation Program more than six months after being granted detention authorities. #12: The CIA’s management and operation of its Detention and Interrogation Program was deeply flawed throughout the program’s duration, particularly so in 2002 and early 2003. #13: Two contract psychologists devised the CIA’s enhanced interrogation techniques and played a central role in the operation, assessments, and management of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program. By 2005, the CIA had overwhelmingly outsourced operations related to the program. #14: CIA detainees were subjected to coercive interrogation techniques that had not been approved by the Department of Justice or had not been authorized by CIA Headquarters. #15: The CIA did not conduct a comprehensive or accurate accounting of the number of individuals it detained, and held individuals who did not meet the legal standard for detention. The CIA’s claims about the number of detainees held and subjected to its enhanced interrogation techniques were inaccurate. #16: The CIA failed to adequately evaluate the effectiveness of its enhanced interrogation techniques. #17: The CIA rarely reprimanded or held personnel accountable for serious and significant violations, inappropriate activities, and systemic and individual management failures. #18: The CIA marginalized and ignored numerous internal critiques, criticism, and objections concerning the operation and management of the CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program. #19: The CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program was inherently unsustainable and had effectively ended by 2006 due to unauthorized press disclosures, reduced cooperation from other nations, and legal and oversight concerns. #20: The CIA’s Detention and Interrogation Program damaged the United States’ standing in the world, and resulted in other significant monetary and non-monetary costs.
- ad_hominem 12y agoKeep in mind this is just an executive summary, not the full report, and the CIA and White House were able to heavily redact it: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/02/x-things-keep-mind-ever-get-read-torture-report/ https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/12/02/x-things-keep-...
- jgrowl 12y agoWell, when do the trials begin? Remember, 'Just following orders' is not a defense.
- sharkweek 12y agoI do not understand how torture can be an effective tool for extracting accurate information. If I am being tortured, I would likely be so quick to tell my captors whatever they wanted to hear to make the pain stop.
- mercurial 12y agoThe French 10e division parachutiste arrested and interrogated around 24,000 suspects during the battle of Algiers, often using electrical torture, rape, etc., of which an estimated 3,000 were summarily executed. This effectively put an end to the FLN presence in Algiers. Which, I suppose, gets to show that it can be effective in some circumstances, if you are willing to show the appropriate degree of ruthlessness.
- rasz_pl 12y agoFrench are all around great guys https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warrior https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warrior
- mercurial 12y agoAs the sinking of a boat and the accidental death of a crew member have little to do with the effectiveness of torture, I can only conclude that you wish to partake in a bout of gratuitous French bashing. In this case, I suggest that you start by getting some better material. The Rainbow Warrior is just a blip on the radar. You will find better attack angles in our post-WWII colonial behaviour (for instance, the repression in Algeria and Madagascar), our colonial wars or our African policy. Godspeed.
- ryanmarsh 12y agoThere's a table at the end with Hayden's testimony adjacent its factual refutation. This guy will never face charges for lying to Congress.
- snarfy 12y agoYou'll get more accurate information through tricks and false friendships than torture. There is no justification for torture. None. It's not even a good tool regardless of the morality.
- stefantalpalaru 12y ago>There is no justification for torture. None. - revenge - increasing the torturer's loyalty for the organization (how many torturers are whistleblowers?) - showing your superiors how far you are willing to go in pursuit of information - terrorizing the enemies you haven't captured yet - strengthening the connections with subordinate countries (Romania hosted secret torture prisons and bribes where given to officials. Who there dares to challenge the imposed economical partners or foreign policies? Or the visa requirements still in place in a country that hosts US military bases on its territory for that matter.)
- jimktrains2 12y agoNone of those are justifications.
- zghst 12y agoI don't think torture has to be justified to those looking to employ it. It is the most brutal method to rock someone's core, to break them as a person. Because of the current technological progress, we cannot just hack into someone's brain. The availability of methods for information extraction today are slim, you have a lot of officers who lost people, had their own tortured, and are looking demonstrate tenacious resolve in the face of an enemy. I disagree with the use torture, it is sadistic. However in some context it is not inconceivable to why some would use it.
- lotharbot 12y agoIt seems to me like there are four key findings here: (1) the CIA did some truly horrific stuff to detainees -- wallings, waterboardings, sleep deprivation, threatening their families, etc. (Specific quotes are in rdtsc's comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8723834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8723834 ). (2) the CIA systematically lied about and hid information about what they were doing from other parts of the government -- from the Senate Intelligence Committee, the FBI, the State Department, the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, US ambassadors in countries that housed detention facilities, etc. (3) the CIA didn't provide its operatives with training in interrogation until months after the program started, didn't have facilities in place until just shortly before they took custody of their first prisoner, had very little oversight even within the CIA itself (see finding #12, page 17 of the pdf), and otherwise seemed to be flying by the seat of their pants. So they weren't even making decisions in a coherent, systematic fashion. (4) all of this horrific, lied-about stuff... didn't even work. They weren't saving lives, and they had plenty of reason to know (before, during, and after) that the techniques wouldn't/weren't/didn't accomplish anything of value. So even firm believers in "the ends justify the means" don't have a leg to stand on here.
- gcb0 12y agoand even when it is public, there is still not repercussion to the people that made the bad decision.
- codezero 12y agoAs an exercise visit as many news outlets as you can and count how many times they use the word torture in their articles.
- jonlucc 12y agoI just quickly went to a few and the results are below with the sources below that CNN 3 BBC 2 Al Jazeera 5 FoxNews 2 NBC News 3 ABC News 1 http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/09/politics/cia-torture-report/index.html?hpt=hp_t1 http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/09/politics/cia-torture-report/in... http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-30401100 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-30401100 http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/12/9/senate-torture-report.html http://america.aljazeera.com/articles/2014/12/9/senate-tortu... http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/12/09/senate-panel-releases-scathing-report-on-cia-interrogation-amid-warnings/ http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/12/09/senate-panel-rele... http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/cia-torture-report/doj-stands-no-charges-ruling-after-torture-report-n264711 http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/cia-torture-report/doj-stan... http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/torture-report-reveals-cias-brutal-interrogation-tactics/story?id=27457494 http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/torture-report-reveals-cias-b...
- codezero 12y agobonus points for headlines :)
- secfirstmd 12y agoAre Jim Mitchell & Bruce Jessen and their company "Mitchell Jessen & Associates" those redacted but mentioned in the Torture Report? http://ow.ly/FClBo http://ow.ly/FClBo
- higherpurpose 12y agoJust remember folks - this is the agency Amazon chooses to provide its services to. Vote with your wallet.
- cryoshon 12y agoA few things: The Republicans have issued a rebuttal. I assume this means they support torture. I hope this dissuades some of their remaining voter base from continuing to support them. Clapper has issued a rebuttal, claiming that the report isn't neutral. I assume he also supports torture. Not sure that he has any credibility left after being caught on the record lying to congress, but whatever. The White House attempted to keep this report from coming out. Obama's admission that "we tortured some folks" was hollow, and his promises regarding torture transparency have been refuted as lies. I assume that the White House supports torture, via its resistance to exposing torture. I hope this dissuades some of their voter base from continuing to support them. Feinstein, though extremely undesirable due to her support of the NSA, has showed some balls here. In the months leading up to the release of this report, she claimed that the CIA was threatening her, so we'll see what happens. I would like it if the next big stink she makes is about the CIA's surveillance of the Senate committee. The CIA itself has just been pinned on the record as having intentionally misled Congress (its only real oversight) for a period of nearly a decade. Additionally, the CIA has been pinned on the record as having attempted to cover up evidence that it tortured people, and then also spied on the people investigating the torture within the US government. I hope that this agency is drastically reduced by some sort of chemotherapy now that some of its crimes have come to light. Just remember that this isn't over. Keep paying attention to who defends the CIA, and which media outlets place torture as a choice on the same level as other options. Keep paying attention to the way that the government tries to deny, scapegoat, and minimize this, and make sure to point it out wherever you see it. Finally, don't let them re-focus on the inevitable violent reprisals that will soon come. Releasing the report isn't the ultimate cause of violence against the US or its proxies, torturing people is. Edit: It appears as though in one of the footnotes of the report there is an admission that one of the people who was tortured to death was an innocent man who was wrongly abducted.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThe White House attempted to keep this report from coming out. That's inaccurate. Kerry asked for a delay in its release; as Secretary of State, responsible for US embassies around the world, it's his job to draw attention to the risk factors. All reports I've read prior to the release said that both the President and Vice President were strongly in favor of publication. Ultimately the choice to classify or declassify rests with the President.
- pknerd 12y agoHope the report will help Americans to find the answer of Why they hate us?
- zghst 12y agoThis response is asinine. What do you say to the organizations that massacre entire villages and towns in their own county, make regular suicide and car bombs to blow up crowded and high traffic places (in M.E., Russia, China), dismember their young for stealing bread or disobeying, killing colleagues for not being Muslim enough? They have plenty of reasons to hate us, we are not like them, but it looks like they do fine in spreading destruction and agony in their home as well.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoReposted foreword: http://pastebin.com/ZJSBptaj http://pastebin.com/ZJSBptaj Because gross pdf.
- szierk 12y agoHow can the average person combat this? Does anyone have recommendations for organizations to support? I'm honestly at a complete loss for where to start. edit: removed a comment on this article getting flagged.
- twoodfin 12y agoWonder who we have to thank for that. As we're not supposed to comment as to why we flagged a particular article, it's probably not productive to complain about flagging in the comments.
- szierk 12y agoYou're right. I've edited the comment to reflect that.
- lotharbot 12y agoThere are probably two factors at play here: (1) somewhat counterintuitively, HN penalizes stories that have a large number of comments compared to votes. It's typical for a post with ~300 upvotes to have under 100 comments; you can see several examples on the front page right now. This thread has nearly 200 comments. Having significantly more than the expected number of comments, and especially deep comment threads, is often an indicator of a flamewar, so the algorithm penalizes stories that meet that pattern. (2) flags. Not "omg I support torture" flags, but "this isn't hacker news, it's mainstream media" flags. This story is very much on the bubble for me -- it's obviously something being covered in mainstream news, but this is a link to the actual report and people are discussing the findings in detail. (I have not flagged it, but I understand why others would.) [EDIT: this comment was posted in response to a since-removed question about this story's position on the front page. I have left it because I believe the information is helpful.]
- karmartyr 12y agoTwo-thousand nine hundred and seventy seven. That's how many people were burned alive, crushed to death, forced to jump off the towers. They deserve justice. And if that means pushing a terrorist against a wall or depriving sleep then so be it. I mean lighten up people, the hazing at my frat 30 years ago was almost worse than half this stuff.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MisterMashable 12y agoIn 2004 a whole layer of top CIA officials were forced out. Defense Secretary Colin Powell resigned. Dick Cheney purged the CIA of personnel who might have served as some counterbalancing force. Once the good and reasonable people were gone (fired, forced to resign etc.), the CIA ran amok. If we look honestly at what went wrong, it's pretty clear how to fix it. Fire all the people that lied to Congress and broke the law by employing prohibited techniques. Prosecute them to the fullest extent possible. Simultaneously, conduct an internal review of all the former CIA fired for political reasons and hire them back. These are the people America desperately needs to repair our broken system. The CIA is desperately in need of reform. The world is too dangerous and complicated a place to have the wrong people running our foreign policy. If they lied about torture, what else are they lying to Congress about? Clearly it isn't the solution to every problem but it would be the best possible, immediately actionable step. Bring back the good patriot Americans who were fired from their job with the intelligence agencies for political reasons. Get rid of and prosecute the bad apples.
- dragonwriter 12y agoColin Powell was never Defense Secretary, he was Secretary of State. In any case, as the report notes, the CIA was already running amok before 2004, so any purge then was not a necessary prerequisite for the CIA to run amok, though it might have removed a constraint that would have reigned things in sooner.
- eslaught 12y agoI think we should be a little more amazed that this report is available at all---an through internal channels at that. While we're all bashing the CIA for what they've done (and are right to do so), we should also appreciate that this is also at some level an instance of government working "properly": one branch of government audited another branch, found that there had been misconduct, and was able to publish a report showing what had been done wrong. This is not the end of the road---we still need to fix the problems and prevent them from happening again---but publicly acknowledging the problems is a massive first step. Before we all jump on the bandwagon to paint the USA as the next major authoritarian regime, ask yourselves the question: would this report ever get published in North Korea, China, or the former USSR? Frankly, I can't imagine it. This report proves that the USA might not be better than any of those countries with regard to these events... but at least it appears that the USA has the guts to acknowledge publicly its mistakes.
- lhc- 12y agoWell, that's assuming that the people who did this actually consider these mistakes (they don't) and that they will be held even a little bit accountable (which looks unlikely). As it is, it's as much bragging as it is auditing: nothing bad will come to those who committed these heinous acts, and it will provide no discouragement for those who come after and have to make the decision about whether or not to torture.
- shit_parade 12y agoa steam valve to relieve pressure keeps the great death machine running smoothly.
- javajosh 12y agoThis is a really good point, and shouldn't be lost in the outrage. Of course, the outrage shouldn't be lost either, but you're right: some of our morality is salvaged by the publication of this report.
- baconner 12y agoIts something yes, but considering no one will be charged at all for well documented and extremely grave crimes well... Its hard to take solace in being a little better than a full on totalitarian regime.
- pknerd 12y agoI am sure CIA torture report has definitely shaken average Americans.
- zghst 12y agoThe average American reads "torture" and moves on. America is no longer a society whose government is afraid of it, instead we prefer to be 'managed' for the sake of convenience.
- arh68 12y agoClassification has become a tool to protect careers, not the nation. These people all acted individually towards whatever incentives they saw desirable. Money, power over helpless detainees, I don't know. Specific people did exactly what they wanted to do. And it's not like the whole CIA was on board, but the people who disagreed can get the fuck out of the room and let the adults play torture games. CIA attorneys, discussing aspects of the campaign involving off-the-record disclosures, cautioned against attributing the information to the CIA itself. One senior attorney stated that the proposed press briefing was "minimally acceptable, but only if not attributed to a CIA official." The CIA attorney continued: "This should be attributed to an 'official knowledgeable' about the program (or some similar obfuscation), but should not be attributed to a CIA or intelligence official. Another CIA attorney noted that the draft "makes the [legal] declaration I just wrote about the secrecy of the interrogation program a work of fiction.." CTC Legal urged that CIA leadership needed to "confront the inconsistency" between CIA court declarations "about how critical it is to keep this information secret" and the CIA "planning to reveal darn near the entire program.
- auston 12y agoIs there a difference in these documents? http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy1.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy1.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy2.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy2.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy3.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy3.pdf
- ilyanep 12y agoThe first is the executive summary of the official study. The second appears to be additional views added by individual senators on the committee. The third is a rebuttal from the Republicans on the committee.
- random_rr 12y agoThis is shameful... I found this website trawling around http://rectalrehydration.com/ http://rectalrehydration.com/
- junto 12y agolet's assume a group like Occupy started to gain enough traction that they became a serious threat to the status quo. that is to say, that the current power base started to shift to a form of politics outside the current two party flip flop system the USA has today. How long do you think it would be before those 'subversive' groups, even as non-violent, would start to receive the same treatment? There are few of us prepared to stick our heads above the parapet. Those that do, end up fucked. I.e. Snowden, Assange and Manning. Sometimes I dream about a people's takeover, Fight Club style, where each man on the street reminds those in power who cooks their food, who washes their clothes, who takes care of their children. A subtle collective threat en-mass to fight the power. Then I drift back off to sleep. I am the People, the Mob Carl Sandburg, 1878 - 1967 I am the people—the mob—the crowd—the mass. Do you know that all the great work of the world is done through me? I am the workingman, the inventor, the maker of the world’s food and clothes. I am the audience that witnesses history. The Napoleons come from me and the Lincolns. They die. And then I send forth more Napoleons and Lincolns. I am the seed ground. I am a prairie that will stand for much plowing. Terrible storms pass over me. I forget. The best of me is sucked out and wasted. I forget. Everything but Death comes to me and makes me work and give up what I have. And I forget. Sometimes I growl, shake myself and spatter a few red drops for history to remember. Then—I forget. When I, the People, learn to remember, when I, the People, use the lessons of yesterday and no longer forget who robbed me last year, who played me for a fool—then there will be no speaker in all the world say the name: “The People," with any fleck of a sneer in his voice or any far-off smile of derision. The mob—the crowd—the mass—will arrive then.
- sabfdkjwab 12y agoActually, there were already leaked plans from the FBI to assassinate Occupy members if the movement became too influential. http://whowhatwhy.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/FloridaFBISniperMemo.jpg http://whowhatwhy.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/FloridaFBIS... http://www.democracynow.org/2014/3/25/why_did_fbi_monitor_occupy_houston http://www.democracynow.org/2014/3/25/why_did_fbi_monitor_oc... I guess we can't let those plebeians have their way, now, can we?
- rjohnk 12y agoI'm surprised no one has brought up Homeland's past two episodes. It's fiction to be sure, but I think the raw emotions can be seen in the episodes. I have issues with people here being armchair ethics police. Also, I have just skimmed the report, so may be in error, but is there any context to those tortured? If they did not share with the CIA when they asked nicely, why? Did the tortured gun down innocent civilians? Are they known to have plans for a large attack? What would you do in that situation? I refuse to make the jump to "America the Gestapo" I refuse to make black and white "torture is wrong, always" OR "they got what's coming to them". There is evil. There is good. We get into theological and moral implications if I go any further so I'll stop there lest I get downvoted because I believe in some old white guy with a beard.
- GordonS 12y ago> If they did not share with the CIA when they asked nicely, why? Maybe because they were innocent? Maybe because they just didn't know the answers? But let's brutally torture them for years anyway... just in case? > Did the tortured gun down innocent civilians? According to the report, some of the detainees, including a mentally disabled man, were known to be innocent themselves. Presumably there isn't any real evidence that any of them have actually done anything. Otherwise they would surely be tried in a court, rather than being brutally tortured in secret camps for years on end, with no legal counsel or so much as a shred of humanity? If I was tortured using the utterly disgusting methods in this report, I would quickly claim to have gunned down civilians, eaten babies, or indeed whatever else I though they wanted me to say... Honestly, reading parts of this report left me feeling nauseated. I don't understand how anyone can even consider agreeing with what these sub-human monsters have done, regardless of context. That they will get away with this, and some even profit greatly from it, further sickens me.
- patrickg_zill 12y agoTwo thoughts: 1. The CIA hacked the Senate's computers and performed other surveillance on them. Since they were caught, it is likely that this did not shall we say, endear the CIA to the Senate. 2. Unless and until the people in the CIA that did these things, and the bosses who approved these things, face jail time, loss of government pensions, etc. I predict that nothing will change.
- rsanek 12y agoCheck out the comparison between the Hayden testimony and what this report found -- from pg. 462 onward (~37 pages total) it's a point-by-point refutation. Language in almost all of the examples includes "This testimony is incongruent with CIA records" and even "This testimony is inaccurate".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jdimov 12y agoWhat is scarier: that US gov has been lying about this or that US gov genuinely doesn't know what's going on within its agencies?
- delecti 12y agoIn all likelihood there's plenty of both going on.
- raquo 12y agoI hope we can all agree now that a country' ideology doesn't matter, what matters is how the power is structured. And that's not pretty.
- chroma 12y agoIt's a shame the report is so partisan. The democrat and republican sides disagree on basic facts, such as whether torture worked in extracting information, and whether that information helped to save lives. Both sides accuse the other of cherry-picking to bolster their cause. Since the primary records are unavailable to us, there's no way to get a more trustworthy opinion on the program. The CIA's behavior is probably pretty horrible, but it's unwise to be very confident in that assessment. Another interesting fact is that torture may work, or it may not, yet many people don't want torture to work. But think about it for a second: If torture worked, it would be an opportunity to save lives. Torturing one known criminal to extract information that could save dozens (or hundreds) of innocents is unsavory to say the least, but it's better than the alternative. (To reverse the situation, one wouldn't kill dozens of innocents to prevent the torture of a known criminal.) Simply ignoring the issue and saying, "Torture is always wrong," can lead to more death and suffering than thoughtfully considering the issue. I'm not talking about some hypothetical ticking time bomb scenario. This can actually apply to real life. Consider collateral damage. In war, it is acceptable to accidentally kill innocent people. It is also acceptable to intentionally kill combatants. But torturing combatants to extract information that would reduce collateral damage is unacceptable. It's such a strange instance of moral blindness. Note that this doesn't mean I would want torture to be legal even if it worked. It seems like there's a good case to be made for keeping torture illegal, since doing so would force a would-be torturer to be sure about the circumstances; so sure that they'd willingly to go to prison to save innocent people. Edit: So far, both replies are attacking positions I do not endorse. I'm saying make torture illegal even if it works. I'm saying ticking time bomb scenarios are poor justifications for torture. But I'm also saying that torture may save lives in some circumstances. If we're willing to accept the horror of collateral damage, we should also be willing to reduce it using methods as horrific as torture.
- Synaesthesia 12y agoFirstly, torture doesn't work, but it's not about that. Violence simply isn't morally legitimate ever, whether it's aggression or as a response to violence (possibly even greater violence). Whether it's torture, murder, whatever, it doesn't matter. Doing it in the name of war or national security doesn't make a moral difference. The ticking time bomb thing is just an excuse for this behaviour.
- aaronbrethorst 12y agoThe Republican rebuttal: http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy3.pdf http://www.intelligence.senate.gov/study2014/sscistudy3.pdf and some commentary about it: http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/republicans-dismiss-senate-torture-report-ahead-release http://www.msnbc.com/msnbc/republicans-dismiss-senate-tortur...
- brianstorms 12y agoMeanwhile, legendary Silicon Valley angel Ron Conway appears to support the CIA and its torture program. http://www.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2014/12/09/ron-conway-tweets-support-of-cia-torture http://www.sfweekly.com/thesnitch/2014/12/09/ron-conway-twee... https://twitter.com/RonConway/status/542404171865927681 https://twitter.com/RonConway/status/542404171865927681
- patronagezero 12y ago"Should any American soldier be so base and infamous as to injure any [prisoner] I do most earnestly enjoin you to bring him to such severe and exemplary punishment as the enormity of the crime may require. Should it extend to death itself, it will not be disproportional to its guilt at such a time and in such a cause, for by such conduct they bring shame, disgrace and ruin to themselves and their country." George Washington (1775) I hope someone burns this carcass of the "United States of America" soon, I'm weary of the stink from it's rotting flesh.
- rasz_pl 12y agoLeszek Miller, prime minister of Poland at the time of US concentration camps and architect of CIA-PL deal, was interviewed couple of times since 2005 on TV. Every time he urged to "shut the fuck up about it already", to not upset "our allies", and to stop directing "terrorist" attention at our country. Thats pretty much current state of TV coverage in Poland. "Funny coincidence": We had Andrzej Lepper, opposition leader in government of Leszek Miller, commit "suicide" in 2011. Whats so weird about that? Lepper was famous for announcing TALIBAN presence in village Klewki at the end of 2001. Klewki is 50km from Stare Kiejkuty and Szymany - locations of US concentration camp.
- arca_vorago 12y agoFirst, I would like to comment on the fact that given the current state of surveillance, I think a re-evaluation of oversight processes needs to be done. If the CIA isn't properly reporting to the White House, the NSC, and is avoiding oversight by congress, then who the fuck is managing these things? On that same note, what kind of NSC would allow that kind of movement? One that really knows whats going on and approves but doesn't want to be seen as complicit is my guess. Otherwise, the director, or more precisely, the AD, would be the main guy "in the know", but what kind of skeletons does he have and who knows them? What is the real power structure here beyond the official chain of command? How rogue does the Company have to get before someone reigns it in? And with the current state of surveillance, how could any congressmember practically seek to do it? Between the Agency and the Company, they have dirt on them all. My second comment is on torture itself. I'm guessing the main scapegoat is going to be the contractors pulled in post 9/11. Class 11: My Story Inside the CIA's First Post-9/11 Spy Class, is a must read for anyone interested in this factor. That being said though, as I have posited about the GOT in more general terms, I have doubts about the actual intentions of these kinds of programs in the first place. I'll forget the pragmatic and philosophical discussion about torture effectiveness for information extraction for a moment, and just come out and say it. This is how you create terrorists... on purpose. Need a war? You need someone to fight. Don't have someone? Create them. There's also the side ancillary benefit of the possibility of turning some of the radicals into doubles, who then can be used for all kinds of fun stuff. The leader of ISIS spent much time in camp Bucca. The guy responsible for the Benghazi attack also spent time in one of these kinds of facilities. Is this really the goal? Looking for good people to turn so they can be manipulated from afar (and then probably killed so they don't talk). Really and truly, I don't think we can have this discussion properly without bringing JFK into this picture. I've spent a long time trying to understand these big picture things, and my conclusion is not one that you want to hear. Namely, that there was a slow, silent coup against the American government that was fully completed at JFKs assassination. Also, please don't forget that it was the JFK incident that led the Agency to develop the anti conspiracy plan to make the phrase "conspiracy theory" anathema to public debate and discourse.
- pdkl95 12y agoEven if you ignore JFK, a good case can be made that the security agencies (probably FVEY?) currently seem to have at least de facto control basically anywhere they want. Exercising that control got a lot easier - and less obvious - as technology became available. Traditional informants and enforcers sometimes get noticed, but JOIN...WHERE user.id=foo across phone location data is very hard to discover. The key part, I think, is that COINTELPRO ended in name only. Worse, as the use of the internet increased, the number of times I've had to consider "JTRIG-style disruption, paid corporate shill, or useful idiot" has increased dramatically. While a "silent coup" is one possibility, I have been liking how Dan Geer's described[1] the high-level picture of our situation as a Cold Civil War. Cold wars are fought by proxy, and there has been a lot of pointer-chasing to trace in the modern political situation. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT-TGvYOBpI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nT-TGvYOBpI ( http://geer.tinho.net/geer.blackhat.6viii14.txt http://geer.tinho.net/geer.blackhat.6viii14.txt )
- shit_parade 12y agoOf related interest is the Op-Ed in the NY Times by ACLU executive director Anthony D. Romero: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/09/opinion/pardon-bush-and-those-who-tortured.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/09/opinion/pardon-bush-and-th... It's saddening to read such a two-faced argument by the head of an organization I supported with both time and money. When even the ACLU would rather call for pardons instead of prosecution because they no longer believe it politically viable I feel there is little left to say on the matters of justice and law in my country. I can only hope Romero is soon fired so the ACLU can return to it's core mandate as written by them: The ACLU is our nation's guardian of liberty, working daily in courts, legislatures and communities to defend and preserve the individual rights and liberties that the Constitution and laws of the United States guarantee everyone in this country. ~ Once a country abandons it's laws it is soon then abandoned by it's people.
- nickbauman 12y agoReading the report leaves me slack-jawed considering my own history. My great uncle was an officer of the Geheime Feldpolizei, a secret state security organization developed to combat native resistance against Nazi occupation during WWII. His job was to infiltrate and destroy Maquis French and their supporters (the resistance). The means they used were mass betrayal, example executions, torture, even the wholesale destruction of entire villages. In 1946 he was charged with Crimes Against Humanity and sentenced as a war criminal by an allied tribunal consisting mostly of official American personnel. He deserved exactly what he got. What he did was utterly unconscionable even in a time of war. I cannot, however, imagine representatives of today's America having the same kind of tribunal against war criminals with the same kind of standing. It is now simply unimaginable in anything but lurid, obscene terms. Dark days indeed.
- rhino369 12y agoAmerica did a hell of a lot worse than this stuff during WWII. In fact, this stuff is child's play. We loaded up air planes with incendiary bombs and flew over Toyko purposely igniting their wooden homes to purposely cause a firestorm that killed .1 million people in a single night. Pretty fucking brutal. Pooring ensure up a guys ass is pretty bad, but we instead of letting our B-52's bomb Taliban villages into nothing, we use drones. Progress is slow, but it's happening.
- nickbauman 12y agoI won't argue with you on this. I think if we're at the point of comparing effects against intent in the discussion, nobody proves anything much anymore. Shades of darkness are less important now than working together to change the direction towards light, peace.
- EdSharkey 12y agoI hear some modest outrage in people's comments, but I sincerely doubt most of you want to actually confront the leadership simply because they're aligned with you politically on most other things. Other than tossing out some words, I fear most of you are going to do nothing and continue voting for the same ol' status quo crooks and cronies.
- argumentum 12y agoThis release is a great development, and despite the overwhelming angst and disgust that many here are (rightly) feeling about these actions, it affirms that we aren't a totalitarian state. That our system of checks and balances does work, imperfectly for sure, but what system is perfect? If you aim for perfection, you will always fall short, but surely this means you should correct your aim and do better, not give up. And better we will do. Those comparing these actions to the KGB, or Gestapo, are wrong on two counts: scale and intention. There is a difference between the mistreatment of few hundred and that of a few million. There's a difference between the goal of fighting nihilistic terrorists and the goal of exterminating undesirable ethnicities and dissidents. That we are better than the worst may seem small consolation, but it is something that needs pointing out, if only to protect against moral relativism. To be able to reach towards righteousness, we must be able to distinguish not only right from wrong, but more right from right and more wrong from wrong. Moral relativism is seductive, but it's a crutch that prevents us from building a better society. The United States of America has unique responsibilities in the world, perhaps in world history, we are the stewards of liberal civilization. As such, we should certainly aim for the highest standards and chastise and correct ourselves when we fail. But only fools could think that if we go away, or withdraw unto ourselves, the world will suddenly be a better place (as many is this thread seem to suggest). Those who deny the reality of power can never fight it's ill-effects.
- hawleyal 12y agoITT: Shock, awe, denial, scapegoating, buck-passing, et al.
- fny 12y ago"Of the 119 individuals found to have been detained by the CIA during the life of the program, the committee found that at least 26 were wrongfully held."[0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lm3Cr1dAnco https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lm3Cr1dAnco