12 ms·
NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Test Flight
- wglb 12y agoWas very cool to watch the descent and splashdown.
- skywhopper 12y agoAgreed. Watching the descent and the parachutes opening was mesmerizing.
- robodale 12y agoWatching the little capsule barrel in toward the water before the parachutes opened - all I could think of was HOLY CRAP POP THOSE CHUTES!
- Shivetya 12y agoI am both amazed and disappointed at the cost to do one launch of this machine. How much of that cost is going to occur each launch?
- Fuzzwah 12y agoThis test cost $370 million. An SLS launch is projected to cost $500 million. A single Saturn V launch cost up to $375 million in 1969 — or, in today’s money, a few billion dollars. http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/186600-apollo-11-moon-landing-45-years-looking-back-at-mankinds-giant-leap http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/186600-apollo-11-moon-lan...
- deadfall 12y agoWow, almost $2.5B at today's cost. There is no way that they would allow that much today.
- ceejayoz 12y agoShuttle launches cost $1-2B, and carried significantly less to orbit.
- kllrnohj 12y agoThe cost of a Shuttle launch was $450M and carried 24,400 kg & 7 people to LEO. The only thing that can compete with that short of the Saturn V is the Delta IV-Heavy, which is $340M per launch and can carry 28,790 kg to LEO.
- lukeschlather 12y agoWhere does that $450M figure come from? I'm looking at Wikipedia where I presume you took that from, and it says the total cost adjusted for inflation was $196 billion, with 135 launches, that (with straight division) averages out to 1.5 billion adjusted for inflation over the life of the shuttle.
- mikeash 12y agoThere's some accounting fun in that, though. The marginal cost of a Shuttle launch was considerably lower. $1-2 billion is what you get by dividing the budget by the number of launches. Much of the cost went into maintaining the fleet and would have had to be paid whether or not they launched. That's substantially different than with an expendable launcher.
- Lambdanaut 12y agoLmfao isn't that extremely ironic? The purpose of the shuttle was to have a semi-reusable rocket to save a little money. Instead we end up blowing billions just maintaining and refurbishing the fleet. The shuttle very obviously wasn't the way to go. I think SpaceX's grasshopper setup is more promising. It doesn't need to withstand the same pressures that the shuttle had to because of the altitude at which it returns to Earth, so there's not so much to refurbish. That, and it also comes down like a pencil rather than like a rock.
- moskie 12y agoHow much would you like it to cost?
- api 12y agoThat's why reusability is so important.
- smackfu 12y agoJust the Delta IV Heavy cost $375 million. Rockets are expensive.
- amorphid 12y agoI did a Google search for a breakdown of the costs related to launching rocket. Found this => http://home.earthlink.net/~peter.a.taylor/launch.htm http://home.earthlink.net/~peter.a.taylor/launch.htm.
- mapt 12y agoThey are, but they're not quite this expensive. This isn't just a rocket, it's a rocket with paperwork certifying USAF involvement and EELV contracting and various oversight instruments, and manufactured by ULA, the consortium we allowed to become a monopoly, which will offer jobs to everyone involved in this process after they retire from government service. Private telecom satellites, which are in fact an open market, go for any of the Russian, Chinese, or European launchers, and recently for SpaceX, because ULA's products are too expensive unless you're the US Government. ULA in this view is effectively a branch of the US space program, which is allowed to guarantee its shareholders a profit, and is protected from allegations of waste because we have NASA to use as a punching bag, they're just a 'private sector contractor'.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoThe SLS is designed for a 500m cost per launch. This was a test flight using the very expensive Delta IV rocket, not the SLS rocket, currently in development. For reference, the Saturn V cost (fixed for 2014 inflation) is 3b per launch. The Space Shuttle cost 1.5b per flight. So this system is fairly cheap historically, especially considering how much lifting power the Block II configuration will provide. Interesting that we went from 3b to 1.5b from the Saturn V to the STS, half, but this time are going from 1.5b to 500m, a third. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System For those interested, the new Gerard R. Ford class aircraft carrier costs 14b in R&D and 9b in construction and costs 2.5b a year to run (including other ships in carrier group). If I'm doing my math right, something like the SLS, and its lifetime of missions (excluding Mars), is comparable to having another carrier in the US military. Currently we have ten carriers and two under construction. http://www.navy.mil/navydata/ships/carriers/cv-list.asp http://www.navy.mil/navydata/ships/carriers/cv-list.asp
- melling 12y agoYes, you are making the classic "we spend X for the defense project and that would buy Y." You aren't adding anything to the conversation because it never changes anything. Can we try some non-classic thinking? Maybe we can add something new to the discussion .
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoI don't think I am. I'm just trying to put that cost into some perspective. Its comparable to a aircraft carrier in some ways. I'm not necessarily advocating for cutting the military spending. If people are comfortable with taxation for one of those carriers then they should, arguably, be comfortable for taxation for the SLS. I think people have distorted ideas of what space travel really costs. Describing it as a 13th carrier puts thing into perspective.
- melling 12y agoAn aircraft carrier is a mobile city with a nuclear reactor, and hundreds of warplanes that serves a purpose for decades. I think it's a big stretch to make any kind of comparison. It really only confuses the issue.
- efuquen 12y agoA Falcon 9, which from my understanding has similar capabilities as the Delta IV, costs 60 million per launch. SpaceX is targeting 5-7 million per launch, but that depends on them getting the full reusabily they want. We'll have to wait and see if they actually achieve that price point.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoYou need a Falcon Heavy for today's launch, but the problem here is that there is no such thing as a Falcon Heavy. It doesn't exist yet, or ever. Not to mention there's risk in NASA putting its Orion dreams on something thats currently unproven. If the publish saw Orion blow up today then that could prove disastrous for the SLS program.
- chrisMn 12y agoDelta IV Heavy (which EFT-1 flew on) is currently the world's most powerful rocket, capable of putting 30 tons into LEO, about twice the payload of the Falcon 9. The Falcon Heavy which is supposed to make its first flight sometime next year is supposed to carry about twice the payload of a Delta IV Heavy[1]. However, NASA could not choose it for a few very good reasons: A) it isn't ready to fly yet and B) NASA really really needed this mission to go perfectly, and so being on the first flight of a brand new, less tested rocket created too high a risk of program cancellation. NASA was very concerned that if there were problems with this launch it would lead to program termination in the current budget environment. Especially given the fiasco of the Constellation program, and the fiasco of every program save two (ISS and STS) dating back to Apollo Applications and the Space Task Group, I can understand NASA's concern. [1]: Note that when Musk originally announced this rocket as the Falcon 9 Heavy back in 2011, it was supposed to first fly in 2013, and all their website sas now is "Expected in 2015". Rocketry and space is HARD. Even for SpaceX.
- efuquen 12y agoThanks for the response, did a bit more research and realized my mistake of not comparing the heavy versions of both rockets. I did find this article (http://www.nss.org/articles/falconheavy.html http://www.nss.org/articles/falconheavy.html) that talks about the Falcon Heavy and it's projected cost of 100 million per launch, almost 1/4 of the price, and can carry more then double the payload. However it's a bit old (2011) and I'm not sure if that projected price point might have changed, with the delays and all.
- JeffL 12y agoHow does this compare to what SpaceX is doing? Does it make sense for NASA to be doing this in parallel with Dragon?
- trhway 12y ago>Does it make sense for NASA to be doing this in parallel with Dragon? it is called competition - a best known way to get 2 of something at the total cost of 2X when otherwise it would be only 1 inferior version of that something at the cost of 10X
- mmanfrin 12y agoSpaceX is building a shuttle to get people to orbit and back -- Orion is meant to get people to Mars. I think the scale is different.
- shmerl 12y agoAren't SpaceX also working on the Mars mission long term? How are they addressing the interplanetary flight?
- guardian5x 12y agoMaybe in the very longterm. SpaceX is at the moment in orbit where NASA was in the 60s. Going to the moon is a much greater distance than most people imagine. Not even speaking of Mars.
- DavidSJ 12y ago> SpaceX is at the moment in orbit Not for long: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Space_Climate_Observatory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Space_Climate_Observatory
- sriram_sun 12y agoTrue. NASA is now where NASA would have been in the 70s or 80s if the initial momentum of going to the moon was maintained.
- stumpf 12y ago11 parachutes split into 3 separate stages, very cool to watch descend.
- iamcreasy 12y agoFor me it was the free fall. Without any parachute.
- lisper 12y agoThe [non-]money quote: "The next test flight is not expected until 2018 because of limited NASA budgets, and Orion will not carry astronauts until 2021 at the earliest." So while I don't want to downplay the technical achievement, it is politics, not technology, that remains the limiting factor at NASA. :-(
- smackfu 12y agoIt's also technology. "But the project suffered a series of technical issues last year that pushed the service module preliminary design review back by about 10 months." http://aviationweek.com/blog/nasa-slips-orion-em1-flight-2018-0 http://aviationweek.com/blog/nasa-slips-orion-em1-flight-201... It's someone doing good PR that gets it boiled down to "limited NASA budgets."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kbenson 12y agoI can't help but think part of the technology problem is also caused by budget constraints. Less budget means less actual testing and experimentation and more theoretical planning, work and design. I imagine more real world experience with tests and experiments for those involved would help these problems get solved sooner, possibly before they even come about.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoIt is not clear that more budget would make things go faster. 9 women can't make a baby in 9 months, for example. It really depends on how well the project could utilize the extra funding (they probably could do with more, but at some point progress/dollar would have to fall). It is just like software, actually.
- DigitalJack 12y agoWell in this case it would have. The sub contractors went through multiple stop-work start-work iterations and there is always a loss of efficiency with that as the engineers get shuffled. The ones on the program when it starts frequently aren't the same people as when it was stopped.
- chriskanan 12y agoA related article makes a point about the very low morale from astronauts for going to an asteroid using Orion and SLS, which is the major first use for Orion: http://gizmodo.com/orions-a-triumph-lets-not-waste-it-1666564091 http://gizmodo.com/orions-a-triumph-lets-not-waste-it-166656... I suspect public opinion about such a quest is just as low for this milestone.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- thret 12y ago'While the capsule did not carry any people, some artifacts were on board, including a sample of lunar soil, part of a dinosaur fossil and a recording of the Mars movement from Gustav Holst’s “The Planets.”' Wait, what? Does anyone know why? Is this a tradition of some kind?
- geerlingguy 12y agoSome of it, at least, is likely to test the effect of passing through the Van Allen belts a couple times.
- amckenna 12y agoFor those who saw the launch but are looking for a video of the splashdown: Longer NASA coverage (5:23) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdmZAvwznOU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdmZAvwznOU More concise coverage by the AP (0:54) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCF4dkGqV78 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aCF4dkGqV78
- harshreality 12y ago"...there's your new spacecraft, America." (1m15s: [1]) That's ignoring Dragon and Dragon v2, among others. This isn't the 60's or the 80's, when there was only one game in town, and sports-commentator-like narration propaganda for spaceflight was understandable. Cut the BS narration please, NASA/ULA (who does the narrator work for?), you're embarrassing yourselves. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdmZAvwznOU#t=1m12s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tdmZAvwznOU#t=1m12s
- issa 12y agoI really enjoy all the comments to these types of articles. Obviously, a whole lot of us are armchair rocket scientists. It's nice that there are clearly a few actual factual rocket scientists here as well. Here's to lots more to discuss in the coming years...
- swatkat 12y agoI could relate with the excitement! Indian space agency ISRO is launching its own crew module prototype[1] aboard a next gen launch vehicle[2] in an experimental mission. Crew module will perform a controlled re-entry and splashdown in Indian ocean. ISRO is aiming to be ready with all subsystems and infrastructure required for human spaceflight by 2020 (Government hasn't yet approved the human spaceflight program). [1] http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/To-put-man-in-space-Isro-to-test-crew-module-in-December/articleshow/45321894.cms http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/To-put-man-in-space... [2] http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-sci-tech-and-agri/gslv-mark-iii-faces-its-first-experimental-flight/article6660089.ece http://www.thehindu.com/todays-paper/tp-features/tp-sci-tech...
- Trollerder 12y agoThis isn't the 60s. What an embarrassing display of technology. We could have the Space Shuttle 2.0 but we get this rehashed waste of money instead. So disappointing.