12 ms·
The Tyranny of the Rocket Equation (2012)
- ytturbed 12y ago>Currently, all our human rated rocket engines use chemical reactions (combustion of a fuel and oxidizer) to produce the energy. Yes, however, for completeness: an explanation of why we must limit designs to chemical rockets ought to include an explanation of why the dozen or so fusion projects underway around the world will all fail, i.e. let's inject some rational optimism. Note that the Apollo programme began before its tech was ready.
- pjc50 12y agoThe fusion projects have been running for a long time with little success. Apollo was built on scaling tech that already worked (1940s rocketry could reach space although not achieve orbit)
- DennisP 12y agoIf you consider exponential progress since 1970 or so to be "little success," you're right. Fusion has a very high threshold before it becomes useful, but we've come a long way, and we're not that far from the breakeven point now. NASA is currently working with John Slough's company on a fusion rocket for interplanetary travel. http://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2012_phaseII_fellows_slough.html http://www.nasa.gov/directorates/spacetech/niac/2012_phaseII... http://www.washington.edu/news/2013/04/04/rocket-powered-by-nuclear-fusion-could-send-humans-to-mars/ http://www.washington.edu/news/2013/04/04/rocket-powered-by-...
- ytturbed 12y agoTo address my claim you would need an explanation of why that trend will continue, including for the several new projects. Btw, Apollo used a novel alloy.
- shalmanese 12y agoFusion devices aren't rockets and are thus, not subject to the Tyranny of the rocket equation.
- Sharlin 12y agoAnything that pushes stuff out from a small hole in order to accelerate in the opposite direction is a rocket, by definition, and subject to the rocket equation. If a chemical reaction is used to create the energy to push the stuff out, it's a chemical rocket. If a nuclear reactor is used to heat the stuff so it's pushed out, it's a nuclear thermal rocket. If a nuclear reactor or solar panels are used to generate electricity that's used to push the stuff out, it's a nuclear electric or solar electric rocket respectively.
- jordanthoms 12y agoHow about http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsi... ?
- dalke 12y agoThe rocket equation applies to all momentum machines which carry its own "fuel", that is, the mass to eject. Orion gets its momentum transfer from the plasma debris of the nuclear explosion, and the plasma speed comes from the explosion itself. Orion carries the source of the plasma, hence it is limited by the rocket equation.
- chii 12y agois there a form of transport that is _not_ limited by the rocket equation?
- shalmanese 12y agoSolar sails, bussard ramjets, space elevators.
- mcguire 12y agoHow much does your fusion plant weigh?
- ytturbed 12y agoWe ought to design for a range of masses.
- tempestn 12y ago> In the 1970’s, an experimental nuclear thermal rocket engine gave an energy equivalent of 8.3 km/s. This engine used a nuclear reactor as the source of energy and hydrogen as the propellant. That was intriguing, but didn't go into detail on why a nuclear thermal rocket hasn't been tried since. The obvious explanation is that there could be serious consequences if such a rocket exploded, spreading radioactive material, etc. And rockets tend to explode sometimes. However, it sounds like while that is certainly a concern, it is not as great of one as it might seem: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_thermal_rocket#Risks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_thermal_rocket#Risks And indeed there is still work ongoing on such designs.
- daeken 12y ago> And rockets tend to explode sometimes. Chemical rockets -- the only ones we've ever actually used -- explode because that's what they're intended to do. The only difference between a successful rocket firing and a catastrophic rocket failure is the speed at which the explosion happens. A nuclear rocket engine has basically no risk of explosion; tearing itself apart at speed maybe, if the aerodynamics aren't done properly or there's a structural weakness. But that's about it.
- pjc50 12y agoNormal rocket operation is a burn, not a detonation, and there's a clear difference between those that's not just about speed.
- tempestn 12y agoNormally at least the first stage of the rocket will still be chemical, so the risk of explosion is still there. Fortunately the risk of spreading radioactive material appears limited regardless.
- snowwrestler 12y agoPretty much any large rocket today has an explosive self-destruct mechanism to cover failure modes where the rocket goes in an unintended direction. So that's one reason a nuclear rocket might explode at low altitude.
- Pxtl 12y agoThe soda can analogy is horrifyingly informative. I wonder what kind of efficiencies could be obtained with semi-science-fiction fuels like the Orion nuclear-explosion propulsion system (which is different from a nuclear rocket) or even straight-up antimatter. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_a(nuclear_propulsion)
- agopinath 12y agoFascinating read. Are there more blog-type posts like this from NASA? I'd be interested in reading more but I can't seem to find them from the main page and can't find links to these posts...
- ars 12y agoLest you despair of ever making space flight routine, a rocket is not the only way to get into orbit. Virtually all of the needed velocity is tangent to the surface, not away from it. So you can accelerate the vehicle along the ground at least part of the way, and only then turn heavenward and burn fuel to get into orbit. With this boost you significantly reduce the amount of fuel needed. There are many way of doing this. You can have magnetic propulsion (very futuristic and powerful), you can have a simple motor on the vehicle, powered by contact with rails on the ground (but motors have a limit of how fast they can work). You could have fuel "guns" fired into the back of the vehicle as it passes them, which would then capture the container and burn them as a normal rocket would. This has the benefit of not requiring a large rail, just fuel stations that the rocket would pass over. These are just some basic ideas, there are many more.
- has2k1 12y agoGiven that earth is a ball, aren't you always pointed heavenward if you are between 0-180 degrees. So you might as well start of by pointing directly heavenward, i.e 90 degrees. Plus, turning requires acceleration you cannot just capitalise on the velocity you have built up otherwise you would violate the 1st law of thermodynamics.
- ars 12y agoYou don't want to turn. To orbit you need to have velocity tangent to the earth (i.e. along the ground), not directly up. You only turn ever so slightly heavenward, mainly to avoid air resistance.
- has2k1 12y agoI'm still lost. Isn't being tangential along the equator less advantageous than being perpendicular at the poles. When you start tangential, as soon as you cover a distance equivalent to the radius of the earth, you are then perpendicular (maybe not directly so but there is no practical difference as far as the gravity well is concerned).
- 001sky 12y ago"If our planet was 50% larger in diameter, we would not be able to venture into space, at least using rockets for transport." Don't tell hollywood.
- trhway 12y agothe rocket equation with fusion engine expelling alpha-particles at 0.05c doesn't look that bad, and at least it is good enough for Solar system colonization and for sending a probe to the closest star.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nraynaud 12y agojust a noob question: why transport all the fuel, and not start from a cannon/catapult, something that make you start with some speed? edit: it's not clear, I was talking about partially using a cannon, not about a complete ballistic launch.
- venomsnake 12y agoThe moon is a harsh mistress. So it the amount of G the human and most cargo can withstand.
- MPSimmons 12y agoIf you were in a vacuum, that could be a wonderfully efficient way of converting mechanical movement into kinetic energy. We have to deal with atmospheric friction, though, and the places where the cannon would launch from (the surface) has the thickest part of the atmosphere, so the most friction.
- nraynaud 12y agowhat about vacuuming the cannon? like those ping pong ball cannons?
- SideburnsOfDoom 12y agoWhat happens when you leave the cannon? Either the cannon exit is near ground level, in which case you still have the air resistance problems; or it's not, in which case you have the problems of building very a tall cannon.
- nraynaud 12y agoyou don't have to exit the cannon at high speed, the v^2 drag will kill you. You're just trying to put some kinetic energy in the rocket in a way that doesn't make you carry it. you don't have to put all the energy in it that way, the current system works, it's just a tentative improvement. But your answer makes me feel you've not seen the ping pong ball cannons, because they have very good results with a very low mass.
- morearguments 12y agoThis might be interesting for those that haven't come across it yet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_elevator
- shahar2k 12y agowhat about the feasibility of injecting energy on the ground (say a maglev rail based launch) such input wouldnt be contributing to the rocket's weight and therefore would reduce the needed fuel consumption quite a bit I would imagine.
- lordnacho 12y ago"If our planet was 50% larger in diameter, we would not be able to venture into space, at least using rockets for transport." I thought this was quite though-provoking from a Drake Equation standpoint. From what I've gleaned, the earth-like planets we know of seem to be a big bigger than Earth. Perhaps if there's civilization out there, they are hampered by the misfortune of being on a planet that's practically impossible to escape from. If they find it hard to put up a Hubble Telescope, perhaps they'll just not be as likely to bother. My other remark is to the engineering. There's a quip that you have to be an engineer to make something that only just satisfies the requirements. Plenty of people build houses without much in the way of calculation. Even cars can be built by enthusiasts without degrees. This is what makes the space stuff such amazing engineering.
- Sharlin 12y ago> From what I've gleaned, the earth-like planets we know of seem to be a big bigger than Earth. This is entirely a selection effect. Big planets are easier to find, that's why we have mostly found big planets.
- throwawayaway 12y agodegrees are overrated. does john carmack have a degree?
- Animats 12y agoRight. This has been known for a long time. It's why rockets aren't much better than they were 40 years ago. Chemical fuels are as good as they can get. Space travel with chemical fuels is just barely feasible. In the 1960s, it was assumed that nuclear power would be necessary for space flight. Everybody involved knew the rocket equation. The original plan for Apollo included a nuclear upper stage. The engine (NERVA) was built and tested. A Nuclear Assembly Building at Canaveral was planned. But, because the goal was so narrow ("man, moon, decade"), the solution chosen was a disposable rocket the size of a 50-story building to send an RV-sized payload to the moon. The crash of a nuclear rocket would produce a radioactive mess. Not Chernobyl or Fukishima sized, but at least small-town sized. Launching from an isolated island would help. Various schemes have been tried or proposed to beat the rocket equation. Launching from a balloon was tried early. Launching from an aircraft is still used by Virgin Aerospace. It helps a little. A space vehicle that's an air-breather while it's in the atmosphere and transitions to rocket mode once out has been proposed many times, but making something that's both a rocket and an airplane is hard and adds a lot of weight. As an airplane, it has to go hypersonic to get up enough speed that it's worth doing this. Building a hypersonic aircraft is very hard; so far, only a few small demo craft have done it. The National Space Plane (hypersonic single-stage-to-orbit) was proposed in the 1980s. Ben Rich, head of the Lockheed Skunk Works and the designer of the SR-71's propulsion system, declined to let Lockheed bid on it. (His comment: "We used titanium (on the SR-71). You know anything stronger?") Remember, it has to be strong at a few thousand degrees. The same problems apply to launch track systems. Going hypersonic near the ground is possible; the Holloman AFB test track, 50,000 feet of very straight railroad track, has been used to reach Mach 8.6. The required acceleration is about 14g. Far too much for humans. The "space elevator" requires not only unreasonable strong materials but the ability to put so much mass in space that you wouldn't need a space elevator if you had that kind of launch capacity.
- wolf550e 12y agoA better example of air launch is Pegasus [0]. An example of an air breather that has passed the physics plausibility test is Skylon [1]. 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(rocket) 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skylon_(spacecraft)
- AndrewDucker 12y agoWhy not assemble some rockets in space? Get the pieces up there as efficiently as possible, and then assemble a more efficient rocket that's not designed to leave the gravity well.
- danielweber 12y agoIf you skip the middle step, that's called staging. It's really expensive to try and keep a permanent base in space.
- bainsfather 12y agoThis rocket equation is not shown, just it's consequences. Try: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tsiolkovsky_rocket_equation for the equation (ignoring gravity), and: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delta-v_budget for a diagram of the consequences.
- jwilliams 12y agoPeople that have played different versions of Civilization will remember the Triremes. They couldn't end a term in the ocean, only the coast. However, you could take a punt and travel over the ocean - with only the hope there was land on the other side. Horribly expensive, but discovering new land or another civilization early could be transformative for the same.
- mrfusion 12y agoSo this is something I've always wondered about. Can anyone explain the equation for getting to an earth sun Lagrange point? Since were already on earth orbiting the sun it would seem we already have the correct orbital velocity to hang out at a Lagrange point. So we could really approach these points at any speed no? Is there potential to use less fuel than you'd need to reach an earth orbit?
- gizmo686 12y agoBy "orbital velocity", I assume you mean orbital velocity relative to the sun. The need for this clarification should be the first indication that we do not already have the necessary orbital velocity (as there is no particular reason to use the sun as the reference other than the fact that it is the more massive body). This diagram [0] shows the Earth-Sun Lagrange points. As you can see, they all have a slightly different orbital radius around the sun, and therefore will have different orbital velocities (larger radius=slow velocity). Additionally, (most) of these points have a different direction, which would means a different velocity. (However, we can change direction for free simply by orbiting, and as long as our orbit is different from Earth's we will change our direction relative to Earth as well). The bigger issue is 'escaping' Earth's gravity well[1]. The most efficient way to do this is through an orbit. To see this, consider the effect of gravitational drag. That is to say, the speed lost due to the force of gravity. If you are in orbit, the net gravitational drag is 0 [2]. Suppose you are at point P of an orbit, travelling at speed V. If you accelerate with X delta-V at this point in the orbit, your new orbit will still contain point P, and you will pass through P with velocity (V+X), indicating that there was 0 gravitational drag. Intuitively, this is because you are accelerating perpendicular to the force of gravity. Another way to look at this is to remember that there is no particular reason to prefer using the Sun as a reference point, in which case we can see that Lagrange points are also in Earth orbit. However, your idea does point to a (theoretical) way to reduce fuel usage. When calculating the fuel needed to establish an orbit, we assume that Earth is the only massive body. However, we can (in theory) use the gravitational force of the sun to reduce the needed fuel to reach Earth orbit (in a way that has nothing to do with Lagrange points). However, the effect is not significant enough to be worth talking about. [0] http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ee/Lagrange_points2.svg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ee/Lagrange_... [1] Of course, by definition of Lagrange points, we are not actually escaping [2] Unless the orbit is circular, gravity will change your speed, but the acceleration/deceleration will balance out.
- im2w1l 12y agoWhat about firing the rocket from Jules Verne's space gun[0]? Now, I don't mean an actual gun what with the high g-forces and so, but only some machinery that gives the rocket high initial speed. Maybe a super sonic evacuated tube maglev that ends with a ramp? Put it on Mt. Everest for less air resistance. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_gun
- danielweber 12y agoYou still get a massive hit from the atmosphere when you exit the tunnel if you've built up any significant speed. Air pressure up there is still a third of air pressure at sea level.
- mcguire 12y ago"If a vehicle is less than 10% propellant, [c]hanges to its structure are readily done without engineering analysis; you simple weld on another hunk of steel to reinforce the frame according to what your intuition might say." This is why you don't let cabinet makers build ships.
- Mvandenbergh 12y agoThe point is that they can actually. A cabinet maker could build a fairly large boat at least (maybe not a ship...) entirely by hand and mostly using very simple rules of thumb. It probably wouldn't perform very well but it would float and be able to sail around. Amateurs build small boats that cross the Atlantic and even the Pacific all the time, precisely because ship building is easier than building rockets. When I say it's easier, that doesn't mean that naval architects aren't as smart as rocket engineers, but the ratio of engineering effort to performance is much more favourable.
- mcguire 12y agoI read this story[1] once, although I don't remember where: Someone somewhere needed a large number of cargo vessels built quickly (think WWII liberty ships, but those weren't made of wood), so they brought in a bunch of cabinet makers to bolster their shipwrights. It worked great, until the ships built by normal woodworkers saw significant wave action, at which time they broke up and sank. The punchline being that, on land, rigidity is the primary constraint; if you build it not to be floppy, it will be plenty strong. At sea (and especially in aerospace), strength is primary; if you build it to be rigid, it will be too heavy and if you build it to be not-heavy, it will probably fall apart. An amateur can build a fairly large boat (although usually to plans by an actual naval architect), and a small boat can make it across an ocean, but if you're serious about schlepping things around, the design constraints for ships aren't much looser than those in aerospace. [1] Maybe this, although that's not the cover I remember: http://www.amazon.com/Structures-Things-Dont-Fall-Down/dp/0306812835/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1414781193&sr=1-1&keywords=structures http://www.amazon.com/Structures-Things-Dont-Fall-Down/dp/03...
- edraferi 12y agoThe common soda can, a marvel of mass production, is 94% soda and 6% can by mass. Compare that to the external tank for the Space Shuttle at 96% propellant and thus, 4% structure. The external tank, big enough inside to hold a barn dance, contains cryogenic fluids at 20 degrees above absolute zero (0 Kelvin), pressurized to 60 pounds per square inch, (for a tank this size, such pressure represents a huge amount of stored energy) and can withstand 3gs while pumping out propellant at 1.5 metric tons per second. The level of engineering knowledge behind such a device in our time is every bit as amazing and cutting-edge as the construction of the pyramids was for their time. That's awesome, I had no idea.
- robertfw 12y agoI found the Slingatron to be a particularly novel approach for launching small amounts of unmanned mass to LEO - I am curious to know what came of their concept. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/391496725/the-slingatron-building-a-railroad-to-space https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/391496725/the-slingatro...
- clumsysmurf 12y agoIf anyone is interested, these researchers from Russia have proposed a way to accelerate a spaceship while in flight – firing a ground-based laser up its backside http://www.osa.org/en-us/about_osa/newsroom/news_releases/2014/supersonic_laser-propelled_rockets/ http://www.osa.org/en-us/about_osa/newsroom/news_releases/20...
- neurobro 12y agoWell that seems less preposterous than my own idea of using lasers to accelerate a ring of air, generating a plasma circuit that would pull the craft up magnetically. (Version 2 would have a series of plasma rings that the craft would fly through like a coil gun.)
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI really enjoyed this. It lays out in some very accessible ways, the challenges of getting into space. The recoverability of the Falcon9 will cut its costs dramatically as it reduces the cost of the launch by several tens of millions of $. I'll mention on-orbit refueling as well since you don't need recoverability per-se if you can refuel in orbit. Then your Mars lander / Crew Module can launch with enough fuel to get to Low Earth orbit, refuel, and then head out to Mars. Air launched (Skylon, Pegasus, Et alia) are also interesting, laser boosting (using lasers to add energy during the initial launch) would also help. As Elon points out though, a multi-gigawatt laser for boost to orbit is impractical both from a construction standpoint and a diplomatic stability standpoint. If the quantity of water on the moon is accurate, then it should be possible to create a 'refinery' on the Moon which could more easily get material into Earth orbit. We'll see though if we can get a group established there. I had hoped to visit the Moon at some point (I was assured by NASA in my youth that would be able to :-)) but I don't expect that to come to pass unless something amazing changes.
- nickff 12y agoIf you do the math, air-launch does not save much in fuel costs, while it adds a great deal of complexity to the launch system, and you do not save much in terms of reduced energy requirements. Most of the rocket fuel and oxidizer are used to increase velocity; comparatively little is used to gain (the first 30k') altitude or lost to atmospheric drag. The main benefit to air-launch is reduced range safety costs, and ease of scheduling, as the launch vehicle can be taken out over an unoccupied stretch of ocean, and range rental/lease costs are basically eliminated.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAn interesting paper that is doing that math : http://mae.engr.ucdavis.edu/faculty/sarigul/aiaa2001-4619.pdf http://mae.engr.ucdavis.edu/faculty/sarigul/aiaa2001-4619.pd...
- scotty79 12y agoHow hard would be building small size space fouintain model?
- Lambdanaut 12y agoIf you've got a poor mind for Math but want to understand rocket science on a more intuitive level, check out Kerbal Space Program. It's the most educational game I've ever played that still retains being fun. I usually avoid video games because I feel like I'm wasting time, but I make an exception for KSP.