13 ms·
> Final lets you give a unique credit card number to every merchant, or a disposable one-time use number for one-off purchases. This is something I have been a
by Someone1234 12y ago
> Final lets you give a unique credit card number to every merchant, or a disposable one-time use number for one-off purchases.
This is something I have been asking for since forever! People on here claimed it was "impossible" because of how credit cards work, I guess not...
> Tired of your monthly yoga pants subscription? Or a two-week "free" trial that lasted four months? Just deactivate that card number. It's that easy.
They need to be careful what they advise. That advice could (and likely WILL) result in people getting taken to collections.
Don't like your ISP? Just cancel the CC number, then 12 months later get a bailiff turn up and seize your stuff...
- pbreit 12y agoDisposable credit card numbers have been around for decades. The user experience has historically been miserable. Maybe this will be better. Doubt it.
- andrewdietrich 12y agoAbsolutely, virtual cards have been around for years. But we've researched the space extensively and did not find a product we like or could use consistently. So we built Final. Some of the better products out there exist for customers outside of the US.
- otoburb 12y ago>Some of the better products out there exist for customers outside of the US. Would appreciate if you could give some examples for non-US customers, at least for another point of comparison.
- bobcostas55 12y agoIn Sweden I can do this...you launch a desktop or phone app, tell it what limit you want on the card and when you want it to expire, and it gives you a number w/ CVC code that you can use instantly.
- negrit 12y agoSame in France. The US is just behind.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoPortugal has MBnet, with a web interface and an Android app, as I recall. It works as advertised.
- icebraining 12y agoI can attest. It supports both "one shot" cards as well as multi-use (with a time limit, up to one year), both with a limit on how much they can be charged. That said, I don't think it has an Android app, just a mobile website. The app that shows in Google Play is just a shortcut to the website (built by an unaffiliated developer). And of course, it doesn't even any of the notification stuff, it's just a gateway to your regular bank account. Nor does it have physical cards.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoYeah, I mistook it for the Caixadirecta app, it's a different thing. MBnet is made by SIBS, the same entity that controls all the ATM.
- dcustodio 12y agoyes, MBnet is awesome. but sometimes some sites don't accept it (when they test the card doing some transactions first), I wonder if Final will have the same issues.
- lm2s 12y agoThat used to happen but I haven't experienced that in a while. Even before the introduction of multi usage virtual cards.
- riffraff 12y agointesa/sanpaolo/bci/cib/whatever (has a ton of brands in europe) has virtual cards with time-based expiration (at most 12 months) or single use. I am reasonably sure ING and unicredit did that too some years ago.
- riquito 12y agoAs an european I'd like to know which are the best product (until you open your business) :-P
- danellis 12y agoI've thought about the feasibility of such a service for a long time, but I always figured you'd run out of numbers. If there are nine digits available (16 - 6 - 1), that's 1,000,000,000. If you have, say, 100,000 customers, that's 10,000 per customer, which would quickly get used up if they're using one per transaction.
- dangero 12y agoCouldn't you reuse a disposable number given some time interval?
- danellis 12y agoI don't know enough about how it all works, but perhaps -- because the number isn't valid on its own -- giving the number to a different customer, with a different name, effectively invalidates its previous use and means it can be safely reused.
- andyjohnson0 12y agoSome information here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controlled_payment_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controlled_payment_number
- AznHisoka 12y agoIt's been around, but the most user friendly way I found was through a Paypal plugin but they indespicably removed that years ago. Been looking for a more convenient method ever since. Signed up for Final, looking forward to it. Finally someone that wants to get this right.
- joshfraser 12y agoI loved the Paypal plugin. Never understood why they discontinued it.
- pbreit 12y agoIt may sound appealing (not to me, at all) but it's just not a very good user experience.
- angryasian 12y agoI think it was because it violates some patent and they have to pay to add that functionality. If that was the reason , I'm curious how they are getting around the issue.
- MWil 12y agoLook up MaskMe - among other services like alternate phone numbers you can give out to spam/signups they have disposable CC numbers
- toomuchtodo 12y agoCounterpoint. If you get taken to collections over a trivial amount (<$100), its not into taken account for your credit score (latest FICO model fixed that). Have to go to court for collections? The first words out of your mouth need to be, "Verify the debt." Ask them to produce the document you signed and agreed to. In the vast majority of cases, without this, your case will be dropped with prejudice. This is based on research I did while dealing with a personal mortgage "issue". http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/532/magic-words http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/532/m...
- eli 12y agoNot all collections agencies are so sloppy and unscrupulous. If you do owe the money and they do have the documentation to support it, you may well have a judgement against you and that definitely will hurt your credit score. Some companies (like say gym membership) have internal collections departments that can be quite aggressive. They would certainly be able to back up any lawsuit. In general, you really want to try to avoid being sued.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoYou're right; occasionally you'll find a collection agency that has their act together. Luckily, collection agencies purchase their debt for pennies on the dollar, so they're happy to get anything. Start by offering them 10% of the debt, and go from there up to no more than 25% of the debt, stipulating (in writing) that its "Pay For Delete". This will require them to remove the negative credit information from your credit report/profile in return for payment. 4 states prohibit wage garnishments at all, and other states set the maximum at between 15-25% of your disposable income: http://www.walkawayfromdebt.com/worksheets&charts/wage-garnishment.html http://www.walkawayfromdebt.com/worksheets&charts/wage-garni... (Disclaimer: Colorado SUCKS. They permit up to 75% of disposable income to be collected). I've helped negotiate away quite a bit of unsecured debt for close friends. Its easier than you think.
- eli 12y agoThat isn't really something I would brag about, but good for you I guess.
- e40 12y agoI've been using this for many years with my Citicard Mastercard. I go to the Citibank website and get a virtual CC#, where I can set a $ limit and date limit (up to 12 months in the future).
- EvanAnderson 12y agoMBNA offered one-time-use, limited-time use, and limited total charge disposable credit card numbers in the early 2000's. It was very handy, then Bank of America took them over and discontinued the feature. Boo.
- anonetal 12y agoAs mentioned in other comments here, BOA currently supports it. I use it on a regular basis.
- gdilla 12y agoBOA had this. I used to buy MP3s off a russian site that I didn't trust. It makes a temp credit card number (a pop up basically) with an expiry date you can set, and an amount you can set. So I would do 30 day credit cards with like $20 on them. I think it was called shopsafe.
- Animats 12y agoBank of America still has this. Log into your BofA account, then go to Accounts->Credit Card->Information and Services. Look under Features for ShopSafe. I use it when I buy from Alibaba.
- zippergz 12y agoDoes it still require Flash? I always found that incredibly annoying.
- anonetal 12y agoYes it still requires flash. I use it on a regular basis for most of my one-off online purchases.
- splintercell 12y agoLets fire up Charles and reverse engineer it to make our own client using BOA API
- azinman2 12y agoAwesome! Who knew? They certainly don't promote that at all!
- JoblessWonder 12y agoSo does Citibank. I use it all the time for shady-internet purchases.
- exhilaration 12y agoDo you need to have a BOA credit card or can you do the same thing with just a BOA checking account (i.e. debit card)?
- andrewdietrich 12y agoOn collections - if you sign an agreement to pay and you don't make a payment, you run the risk of that going to collections. However, many monthly subscriptions have you prepay and charge you without your direct consent. There are many unscrupulous businesses out there, and it's easy to put a simple control over those charges to limit your exposure and the "grey charges" on your statement that are tough to get rid of.
- eduardordm 12y ago> People on here claimed it was "impossible" because of how credit cards work Hi, Definitely not impossible, but if you are following the ISO you might end up running out of numbers somewhat quickly or having to reuse them, which I'm not sure it's very safe. But it really comes down to how many users you will have. The IIN (first 6 digits) are fixed and only one can be issued for each company, etc. I built a small gem that implements the ISO if you want to have a look: https://github.com/eduardordm/iso7812 https://github.com/eduardordm/iso7812
- kareemm 12y ago>> Final lets you give a unique credit card number to every merchant, or a disposable one-time use number for one-off purchases. > This is something I have been asking for since forever! People on here claimed it was "impossible" because of how credit cards work, I guess not... My Bank of America Visa had a "temporary number generator" feature that I used when buying from sites that I thought were sketchy. I haven't used the card in some time so don't know if it still exists.
- habith 12y ago> My Bank of America Visa had a "temporary number generator" feature ... don't know if it still exists. It exists still, but you have to login to the site to use it, and the card generator is written in Flash. Aside from that, it's very good. It ties the number to the merchant and you can set a limit and expiration date. I use it for a lot of recurring subscriptions, and "sketchy sites" purchases.
- makmanalp 12y agoThis is too funny - my bank in Turkey (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garanti_Bank http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garanti_Bank) had this 10 years ago! I wonder why banks in the US are so ingrained in their ways and horribly slow at updating themselves. edit: They also had an SMS cash thing where you can "send" cash to anyone, which is really a code you can use at any ATM to redeem cash.
- alkonaut 12y agoI was recently in the U.S. and saw a person use a paper cheque. I'm not joking.
- makmanalp 12y agoYup, that's the most common way to pay rent in the US - it's easier , cheaper, and faster than an inter-bank transfer. Can you believe it?
- mason240 12y agoAs recently as 2 years ago, our apartment complex actually charged a $30/month fee for paying rent online (as opposed to sending a check).
- danellis 12y agoThe first time I went to pay something via online banking, I was stunned to discover that it meant that the bank would mail out a cheque on my behalf!
- raverbashing 12y agoThe US banking system is frankly, ridiculous In Europe anyone can send money online to any other account in the EU, given the account number, usually for free. The fact that the US doesn't have that as commonplace as in Europe is ridiculous Canada is slightly better, they already are ditching the magnetic stripes off cards.
- dkarapetyan 12y agoWho exactly told you it is impossible? My chase card lets me generate virtual numbers and use them during online transactions. I always use one when a trial requires a credit card. The number expires in one month and I don't have to worry about any shady billing practices.
- lobster_johnson 12y agoChase debit or credit? I don't see an option for that in the online menus.
- dkarapetyan 12y agoSorry for sending you on a wild goose chase. I meant to say citi offers the service.
- jrochkind1 12y agoOkay, seriously, I spent like 4 hours a couple months ago trying to figure out if I could do this with a Chase card, and failed. Can you provide URL/directions? I'm not kidding. As far as I could tell, they used to have such a service but didn't anymore; but maybe it's still hidden somewhere but just not advertised, and I couldn't find it?
- dkarapetyan 12y agoReally sorry about the misinformation. I meant to say citi.
- skynetv2 12y agoumm .. BOA credit cards allow you to generate credit card numbers that are tied back to your card. had this is 2007
- Igglyboo 12y ago> They need to be careful what they advise. That advice could (and likely WILL) result in people getting taken to collections. I do this all the time with PayPal. It's way easier to just sign up for a free trial then immediately deactivate the recurring payment than having to remember to cancel it later.
- burnte 12y ago> This is something I have been asking for since forever! People on here claimed it was "impossible" because of how credit cards work, I guess not... Not only is it not impossible, Paypal did it for YEARS, I loved it, it was a great service. http://www.quora.com/Why-did-PayPal-discontinue-their-one-time-credit-card-numbers http://www.quora.com/Why-did-PayPal-discontinue-their-one-ti...
- paulornothing 12y ago> Tired of your monthly yoga pants subscription? Or a two-week "free" trial that lasted four months? Just deactivate that card number. It's that easy. Why not just cancel the subscription? If you remembered you are getting charged for a subscription, and took the effort to cancel that card number. Why wouldn't you just cancel the subscription in the first place?
- drey08 12y agoThis sort of reminds me of public key cryptography. I generally really like the idea. I've always felt really uneasy about credit cards, the fact that all I have to do is enter the same numbers to every single website I purchase from. The programmer in me tells me "this just can't be secure", and the only hope I have that my card number is never stolen is, well, hope.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- MWil 12y agoMaskMe does this and I've been using it for the last 2 years
- zyxley 12y ago> They need to be careful what they advise. That advice could (and likely WILL) result in people getting taken to collections. I previously worked at a web hosting company where people would pull this kind of thing. Generally we didn't bother with collections because it was often more hassle than it was worth (the biggest part of our cost was the support and anti-fraud process, not the actual service), but nonpayment would get accounts deactivated and blacklisted automatically, so they'd have to call in to us (and get recorded in our tracking system in case of repeat incidents) to pay and get things turned back on. I had some sympathy for people dealing with accidental credit card expirations, but there was always a weird minority of people who would knowingly and sometimes repeatedly cancel cards or dispute payments and yet get angry at us for the audacity of turning off their websites.
- laumars 12y ago> They need to be careful what they advise. That advice could (and likely WILL) result in people getting taken to collections. > Don't like your ISP? Just cancel the CC number, then 12 months later get a bailiff turn up and seize your stuff... Cancelling payments like that is what a lot of UK banks do advise their customers to do. Particularly with (but not exclusive to) insurance services. I've known banks actually recommend cancelling the payments through them instead of trying to cancel via the company itself. Services like internet / phone lines, gas and electric would be different though since they're paid in arrears.
- healthenclave 12y agoIn developing countries (INDIA) because many people do not have CC many good banks allow you to generate Virtual Credit Cards No with predefined amount for single use -- for 5+ years now. So the point is technology and the idea is pretty old but finally someone has implemented it right.
- mwexler 12y agoActually, this unique cc # per merchant has been available for years. Different issuers call it different things (Citi calls it Virtual Account Numbers, for example: https://www.cardbenefits.citi.com/Products/Virtual-Account-Numbers.aspx https://www.cardbenefits.citi.com/Products/Virtual-Account-N...) but it's not "automatic" like this sounds; you usually have to click on something to generate the number and type it into the ecomm site or whatever, and your card number never changes in this model. Check with your bank or issuer, they probably have something similar. ApplePay and other phone wallets do something similar, generating new numbers for the payment but leaving the original number on the device or in the account. This is indeed more transparent to the user, but it doesn't give the control of capping or other levers. Doing it via the card is clever, if that's what they are doing; if they are just doing it via the mobile app, that's somewhat old news... except for the other features, and the elegant giving of control to the consumer.
- new299 12y agoI'd be interested to know if cancelling the card number actually cancels recurring payments. Last time I tried this, my bank told me the recurring payments would still continue even if the card was cancelled. And I needed to contact the vendor and raise a depute before they would consider cancelling the recurring payment. This was however for a debit card, rather than credit. In general, the way recurring payments are setup seems really bad.