28 ms·
Curse Of The Gifted (2000)
- auggierose 13y agoNice nugget.
- mattgreenrocks 13y agoThis should be required reading for any developer, if only to hopefully instill the belief that you will eventually reach a problem that you cannot lean on pure ability alone to solve.
- varelse 13y agoFortunately, one frequently transitions to management and/or dies before this happens because one's career is finite. Linux and other such runaway success stories are true Black Swans and Linus's subsequent embrace of source code control IMO demonstrates you can teach new tricks to old dogs.
- derekp7 13y agoI don't remember that Linus was against source control -- it's just that none of the solutions at the time really fit the methodology that the Kernel was developed under. That was his main argument. And actually, there was source control all along. Every version of the kernel was a separate tarball sitting on many ftp servers, and there was a patch / set of patches to bring it to the next version. It just wasn't a database-backed automated version control system.
- mattfenwick 13y agoBut is that really what this thread shows? It didn't show that for me. What I got out of the thread was that Linus had a solid & rational argument justified by actual technical reasons, which was ignored by Eric. I did not see where Linus was leaning on pure ability.
- sp332 13y agoSoon after this exchange, Linus started using a real source management system (BitKeeper, followed by git) for the kernel.
- neomantra 13y agoBitKeeper, not bitbucket
- sp332 13y agod'oh, updated
- Aqueous 13y ago...but it totally wasn't because of what Eric Raymond said, right?
- sp332 13y agoWhy not?
- Aqueous 13y agojoke - I can imagine Linus grudgingly beginning to use version control, but never admitting that Raymond's rather pointed tough love led him to do it.
- onedognight 13y agoLinus wasn't against version control. He thought that CVS and SVN (the leaders at the time) were just not beneficial enough for his use case. The kernel developers worked with "patches" as their unit of work and neither of these could handle them well. More fundamentally they were centralized and Linus had experience from watching the BSDs and knew that a centralized version control was actually worse than none. He both explicitly didn't want to have anymore authority or convenience than any other developer and at the same time wanted absolute authority over his own version. Neither of these were possible with CVS/SVN.
- beat 13y agoWhoa, flashback. I think I read that on Slashdot back in the day.
- redthrowaway 13y ago(2000) Not that it isn't relevant, but it is 14 years old and the title should probably reflect that.
- beat 13y ago"I was writing code when this email thread was in diapers!"
- logicallee 13y agoyeah seriously this might have been the suggestion that led to bitkeeper that led to git. Which Linus invented and coded up essentially to solve some of the problems brought up here Which (git) today arguably has done more for programming groups than all the new languages and frameworks of the past fourteen years combined. So, it is interesting. But mostly interesting because of how massive Git spawned from it.
- corford 13y agoAlready pointed out by someone else further up in the thread but Linus is still sticking to his guns 14 years later: https://lkml.org/lkml/2014/2/10/575 https://lkml.org/lkml/2014/2/10/575
- chacham15 13y agoInterestingly enough: "He who has never failed somewhere, that man cannot be great. Failure is the test of greatness." -Herman Melville
- sabbatic13 13y agoThis is quite true. The best thing I ever did to preserve and improve my brain was find things, really hard things, about which I was passionate. It's not so much about studying as it is about finding subjects and venues of learning that just kick your ass. If you don't have the experience of getting your intellectual butt kicked, and if you don't have the ability to learn from the experience, you can only grow so much. The easy stuff shouldn't be avoided; you should just expect yourself to pick it up as necessary. If you are not getting challenged, if you don't encounter people who are way ahead of you in some subjects, then you are doing it wrong. The feedback is key. Getting stopped in your tracks, just when you thought you were running along at a good clip is invaluable. Not that I ever achieved greatness, and I do sometimes ask myself why, even in my private life, I always pick the really hard to study (and have for decades now). I'm sure masochism is involved, but the good stuff is just hard, and you have to be willing to be someone's idiot some of the time to learn.
- selimthegrim 13y agoAnd in grad school, you can salt this with wondering where your next meal is coming from and camping out under your office desk!
- sabbatic13 13y agoAh yes, I jumped into a PhD program after the college experience. That's a great butt-kicking too, because suddenly you are responsible for justifying anything and everything you might say or write about something. At least I learned how to live on far less than 20K a year. I mean, it was the 90's, and it was in new Jersey, but that still wasn't a fortune (and I had a bad book buying habit).
- muraiki 13y ago
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoWarning to the unexpecting, this was written by Eric S. Raymond.
- eitland 13y agoand ..?
- BlackDeath3 13y agoI get that the guy is inflammatory, but what is the problem with letting the content stand on its own? But if you are going to mention that ESR is involved, you may as well mention that Linus is present as well.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoTorvalds is abrasive, but Raymond is just an asshole supreme, and if I had known this was an ESR post I wouldn't have opened it in the first place.
- BlackDeath3 13y agoSo you really didn't get anything out of the post because ESR wrote it?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoI got a bunch of hot air and puffery and blah blah blah out of it, which is about as good at you can get from an Eric Raymond post.
- fredgrott 13y agoI would also like to point out the one of the most clear written libraries is that GPS library that is authored by ESR...
- austenallred 13y agoI am miles away from Eric or Linus, but the "curse of the gifted" is very real. Thankfully I wasn't smart or gifted enough that I could ride it for long, but when it comes to math and problem-solving I rode it well into my high school years. I never learned to do algebra "by the book," because I didn't need to. Or maybe because I wasn't smart enough to. The math teacher would teach "3x + 6 = 9." Basic algebraic problem-solving says you subtract the 6 from both sides, then divide by 3. So "3x = 3" then "x = 1." Easy. But I learned pretty early on that I could do it in my head. It was a little bit challenging, but then I wouldn't have to waste the time of writing it out, and I wasn't handicapped like all of those suckers who had to go through the motions no matter how simple the problem was. If the teacher wrote "x + 1 = 6" I didn't have to subtract 1 from each side, I just thought about it logically and knew the answer. Of course, the math got more complex, but I was good enough at doing it in my head that, at least for a long time, it never really mattered. I thought it was because I just "got" math, and the other kids were on a lower level. But as the math grew in complexity, I fell behind. By the time we reached Calculus I was still doing most of it in my head, as I had never really learned to write it out on paper. And the complexity of the math outgrew my capacity to visualize. I showed up to my AP calculus test without a calculator, partially because I was forgetful and partly for fun, and it wasn't until I got my score back (a failing 2 of 5) that it finally hit me: I was actually behind. In school. I was cocky enough that this was a slap in the face. I had to start from scratch, and I'm still not sure if I've made up for a lot of that. I ended up in more creative fields, mostly because I felt inferior to those who had learned the rules and not been cocky douchebags like I had been in the beginning. This really sucks to write. I frequently wonder what could have been.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoI got burned by this too. Problem, unfortunately, goes deeper than just not learning how to do math. You skip learning ability to structurally learn new things at a young age, because you simply "get" how things work. So by the time you hit the wall you not only not know how to do math correctly, but also have no idea how to structurally learn correct way and must do both at the same time. Here most people give up and say they are bad at math.
- adriancooney 13y agoThis is so inadvertently affectionate. It's like a grandparent trying to calm down their overconfident, arrogant child. So eloquent. As a side note, I can't even imagine how Torvalds worked with others without source control. That sounds like absolute hell.
- grandalf 13y agoexcept for the part where he mentions that they all gossip behind Linus' back.
- mathattack 13y agoThat's actually good grandfatherly advice too. It's worth knowing when people are talking behind your back.
- grandalf 13y agopointing it out in a public forum?
- mathattack 13y agoSure - why not? It is generally best to shed as much light as possible on gossip.
- grandalf 13y ago> It is generally best to shed as much light as possible on gossip. Do you say that as benevolent moralist or is it your personal preference that any gossip concerning you be addressed at you before an audience?
- mathattack 13y agoMore the latter, though the former holds true too. I'd rather people say things to my face before going behind my back. Organizations where there is more private than public communications tend to be very disfunctional.
- ajarmst 13y agoShit. An ESR ego dump. Head for the shelters.
- harryh 13y agoDon't forget to bring your lute with you!
- eitland 13y agoNo, I just read it and like many other things ESR said it is well thought out, friendly and helpful. Please note how ESR again and again ranks Linus (the second coming of Ken) higher than himself (old fart) while still trying to convey som hard won experience.
- SamuelMulder 13y agoESR is being extremely condescending and patronizing. I don't consider that friendly or helpful. He's giving tons of hand-wavy pop psychology in response to a technical issue on which he's out of his depth. His "experience" was not with anything the size and complexity of the Linux kernel and was not particularly relevant. He does like to set himself up as the wise old mentor to people who don't really want or need to listen.
- badman_ting 13y agoDig the libertarian quote at the end too. Pretty sure he checked all the boxes.
- kevingadd 13y agoNothing's quite as destructive as being told over and over that you're a natural at something so it'll be easy for you. It's a shame that well-meaning parents and mentors will sometimes undermine someone's potential by discouraging them from learning necessary skills.
- JimboOmega 13y agoExcept assuming that if you did a bad job at something, it's because you were lazy. The message I got growing up was that "you're so smart, but so lazy". This was principally because of my terrible fine motor coordination combined with my intellect. So I'd try to do some sort of "posterboard" or "project" and it'd look like a slapped together mess no matter how hard I tried. My handwriting was often illegible to me, even when I tried to write very slow. ADHD was also an issue, but the fact that every project I poured so much effort into was derided as lazy... yet I could ace every test... told me that effort wasn't, well, worth putting in.
- josh-wrale 13y agoI bet you're left-handed like me.
- JimboOmega 13y agoNo, actually. But I suffered nearly as badly as most. I think it almost took legal intervention to stop them trying to force cursive on me. Being allowed to type assignments - in the early 90s - was one of the greatest things that ever happened to me. Then again, I met other problems caused by my terrible organizational skills in creative ways. For instance, I ran a webserver that had had a folder that pointed to where I did all my assignments. When I inevitably forgot to print something... there it was. Still. My experience, especially prior to high school (and prior to ADHD medication, now that I think about it) was completely dominated by working my ass off and being told that I wasn't trying at all.
- wauter 13y agoHere's a great (and by now almost classic) article on that subject: http://nymag.com/news/features/27840/ http://nymag.com/news/features/27840/
- nether 13y agoI'm not gifted, I'm actually pretty dumb. Can anyone help a stupid normal person relate to this article?
- Mz 13y agoGifted kids often do not learn to study and do not learn patience or discipline because it just never comes up for them. They get enough right in school without those things that it is not part of their background. Then, one day, after they are adults, they need good study habits or patience or something like that and don't have it and it bites them in the ass. (There are ways around that but most parents and teachers don't know how to help a gifted kid with those areas.) Does that help?
- BlackDeath3 13y agoI don't know if I'm "gifted" or not (how does one even determine such things outside of test scores and such?), but I suppose I'll try to rephrase. I don't know how much help I can be, and in-fact austenallred's post may be more illuminating. What it seems to come down to is that some people are just naturally better at some things than others (for whatever reason). People have often told me that I have a pretty good memory (I disagree, but that's what they say), mostly due to the fact that I've been able to, on occasion, drudge up meaningless trivia with little exposure to it. I don't know why or how I can do it, I just can. Though I'm sometimes "pretty good" at remembering things, problems would likely arise if I were to, say, try to skate through a course or six on organic chemistry based on this "ability" alone. Because past expectations have led me to believe that I don't need to work hard to commit things to memory, it may be a nasty shock if I one day find out that I'm wrong. If that happens and I haven't made good use of time that others have spent studying, I'm suddenly behind. I hope that makes sense. Off-topic because I'm curious: what makes you think that you're dumb?
- buckbova 13y agoI never studied up to my second year of college. I took geometry in my first year of high school and struck a deal with the teacher that if I got an A on every test I wouldn't need to turn in any homework. I never took notes. I entered college passing several AP tests and jumped right in to advanced math and physics courses. I started getting cocky and would skip a week of classes at a time. Eventually I met a course that I couldn't think my way out of, thermodynamics. There was something about it I couldn't wrap my head around. I failed the midterm and decided not to show up for the final. Electricity and magnetism was no picnic either. I got a D in that one. I had hit rock bottom. I eventually had to leave this college and start over with a fresh outlook to do the work and try to enjoy it. I still never took notes in class but I did all the coursework. Eventually I earned a BS in computer science.
- callmevlad 13y agoIt's weird to see Linus on the other side of being disciplined, and a pretty stark contrast to his own slightly more abrasive style. For example: https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/12/23/75 https://lkml.org/lkml/2012/12/23/75
- watwut 13y agoThere is no contradiction between discipline/hard work and abrasive style.
- clavalle 13y agoI think callmevlad was contrasting ESR's style of 'disciplining' (I'm not sure if that is the right word) less experienced colleagues with Linus's.
- josephschmoe 13y agoI would never want to work with a person like that. If one of my coworkers wrote an email that abrasive and outright mean, I would request to be transferred to a different project.
- Cakez0r 13y agoI don't understand why people allow themselves to be spoken to like that! Incredicle...
- marvin 13y agoHoly shit. I would never work with someone who addressed me like that after I asked an honest question. It's a wonder that there are enough competent people working on Linux who are willing to put up with this. Getting a message like this once would lead to a personal e-mail or in-person conversation explaining that this is in no way an acceptable way to communicate with me, followed by a prompt beeline for the exit if it occurred again. I knew that stuff like this goes on in mailing lists; I've grown up in the computer culture. But seeing this as an adult, after learning some people skills and how interpersonal communication works, it's really shocking what to see kind of destructive tone prevails in some prominent tech circles.
- incision 13y agoSo true. The benefit of recognizing this isn't just avoiding that crunch at the limits of your talents - it's learning to the use the tools, processes and people which will allow your talents to flow most efficiently every day. The classic example of this for me has been engineers who resist documentation, project management and delegation as if each is wasting away their valuable productive time when it's exactly the opposite.
- jtchang 13y agoAnyone explain what "splitting a driver" in kernel parlance and code sharing is? Modularization is just breaking large pieces of the program up into small pieces right? Is code sharing just the same thing or are they talking about something different?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lukecampbell 13y agoI believe in this case that the driver existed as one piece or module and each hardware version was handled as a different case in branch logic in an attempt to keep the code consolidated and modular (code sharing). As the hardware matured and new versions came to be it gets harder to reuse existing code and that's the context of this thread. Linus wants to split the driver and create a new module to house that handles only that specific flavor of hardware instead of adding new edge-cases to the existing code. At least, that's how I read it. I wasn't working on the Kernel back in 2000 so I can't say.
- drivers99 13y agoCheck the links in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7220508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7220508 Specifically: https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/52 https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/52
- mathattack 13y agoI wish I saw the response. That said, the "curse of the gifted" manifests itself in a lot of ways. One problem is also that "less gifted" see the "gifted" and say, "If they don't have to be disciplined, why do I?"
- logicallee 13y ago>I wish I saw the response. You did. Git.
- selimthegrim 13y agoI salute your pun there.
- SamuelMulder 13y agoLinus wisely declined to respond to this extremely condescending comment by someone who was out of their depth and didn't clearly understand the issue at hand.
- Mz 13y agoAnother problem: Many gifted people are unreliable in very important ways which seriously undermine the value of what they have to offer. (I have personally spent most of my life wrestling with this, compounded by health issues and other issues. I am 48 and only just now getting to a place where I think I can get past that issue.)
- mafuyu 13y agoI had the "curse of the gifted" throughout high school and am suffering the consequences now (although I'm trying to turn things around). That said, I also had a friend who was an absolute monster. He operated on an entirely higher level of thinking than mine. Slept through class and just had to skim the textbook once to 'get it'. He would finish tests in half the provided time and get perfect marks. I ended up sitting next to him through Chemistry and Physics; we would goof off in class, and then go home and play games much longer than we should have. Then, a test would roll along, and he would get his usual 100 while I would do much, much worse. The way in which he just 'got' things was the source of a lot of malevolence and envy back then, although I've learned from it now.
- S4M 13y agoIs the reply of Torvalds online somewhere?
- SwellJoe 13y agoSomeone else mentioned that ESR got no reply, and the thread continued on another path. So, Linus did not reply, it seems. But, he did begin using revision control soon after; though I think that's likely to have happened, anyway.
- mathattack 13y agoThere are now lots of articles suggesting praising people for effort rather than intelligence. Seems like Raymond was ahead of the curve. 2 examples of many: [1] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/9862693/Praise-childrens-effort-not-their-intelligence.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/education/educationnews/9862693/P... [2] http://consumer.healthday.com/kids-health-information-23/child-development-news-124/praising-kids-for-efforts-not-qualities-may-help-them-succeed-673377.html http://consumer.healthday.com/kids-health-information-23/chi...
- diydsp 13y agoIn the world of music instrument performance, it is well-known that one's skill is the product of their talent and practice. And since talent is more or less given, practice can be applied to overtake someone else's ability. Up until some limit of practicality :) And there are zillions of examples of practice, or "woodshedding" leading players to overtake those with inherited skill who don't practice. Really, it's all about momentum. Not practicing = no effort = no moving momentum = no growth = no movement. (
- darkandbrooding 13y ago"Nothing in the world can take the place of Persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful men with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan 'Press On' has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race." Calvin Coolidge 30th president of US (1872 - 1933)
- dclara 13y agoSo wise. Thank you.
- mathattack 13y agoI've read a lot of quotes like this, but I used to wonder, "Is this just people downplaying all the other things that led to their success, like family money?" It's interesting that modern psychology is providing some proof as to why these quotes are true.
- alecco 13y agoI think, in context, Linus was probably right. There are some situations where having 2 very different project/modules depend on common code could be hell. Just remember the multiple WebKit debacles or the BSDs. It might be better to keep an eye on each other, pick the specific updates, but have total independency. Else, you end up in commit wars and endless arguing on mailing lists. ESR is way overrated, IMHO.
- nousernamesleft 13y ago>Just remember the multiple WebKit debacles or the BSDs I don't know anything about webkits, but how are "the BSDs" relevant?
- alecco 13y agoThey split off a common codebase, but they share a lot of code and patches fly across the multiple codebases without major problem. What takes the most effort is porting across big new features. But that is expected.
- nousernamesleft 13y agoOh, it read as though you were giving them as an example of problems.
- twoodfin 13y agoHere's the full thread by way of Google Groups: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/fa.linux.kernel/uhah96NhtAA/gDzjQXVRj0sJ https://groups.google.com/d/msg/fa.linux.kernel/uhah96NhtAA/...
- LukeShu 13y agoAnd on lkml.org: https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/23/97 https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/23/97
- paul 13y agoIf Linus always did things the "right" way he wouldn't have invented git (or Linux). Sometimes, it's important to be obstinate.
- cleaver 13y agoI'm reminded of the author of BDS C compiler. He didn't know how other compilers worked using multiple passes, so he wrote one that ran in a single pass. The result was smaller (important in the 80's) and faster than other compilers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BDS_C http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BDS_C
- adamnemecek 13y agoYou are missing the point.
- tmsh 13y agoThe introvert's dilemma. Because while I exactly agree (and while that's always cool with Paul B!), I think ESR factored into git indirectly in a way. Provided part of the impetus to want to rewrite things. Think about it: maybe the most important thing in that email is that ESR lightly compared Linus to Ken Thompson and maybe that kept him thinking along the lines of rewrite everything. All the dialogue factors in, I think ultimately..
- TempleOSV2 13y agoTruman show guy? CIA jail? Fix your reality -- that is the highest priority. WooHoo sex homo happy_happy_joy_joy ingrate sing spending happy so_let_it_be_done crazy high_five ----- My reality is completely broken. God says... jobs cracks_me_up hello take_your_pick recipe it_figures don't_mention_it goods how_high huh daunting Mom fight I_planned_that be_happy chaos bickering Varoom hopefully cowardice application vengeance HolySpirit Jesus I_didn't_do_it ohh_thank_you crazy no_you_cant sad oh_come_on that's_much_better have_fun skills courage If_had_my_druthers well_I_never I'm_thrilled hold_on_a_minute application absolutely when_hell_freezes_over ha how's_the_weather energy I_can't_believe_it What_are_you_doing_dave daunting you're_wonderful but_of_course IMHO hooah What Is_that_so in_other_words Ramsay charged surprise_surprise failure_is_not_an_option that's_for_me_to_know silly_human car not_that_theres_anything_wrong crazy smart why_do_I_put_up_with_this impossible lifes_like_chocolates This_is_confusing who_are_you_to_judge super_computer beam_me_up love genius everythings_a_okay happy_happy_joy_joy crash_and_burn whale it's_hopeless charged smack_some_sense_into_you dance abnormal couldnt_possibly dance let's_see be_happy let's_roll try_again do_you_want_another home homo in_other_words how_about_those_yankees vengeful sex umm why_is_it theft how_about_those_yankees revolution ehheh_thats_all_folks joking I_planned_that awful baffling Jesus daunting voodoo where's_the_love FBI I'm_bored desert hilarious you're_nuts surprise_surprise bastard relax I_pitty_the_fool once_upon_a_time who's_to_say application it'd_take_a_miracle figuratively absetively_posilutely
- nswanberg 13y agoFor those curious about the context: https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/23/97 https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/23/97 Note that noone replied to Eric and the thread continued on. Also go back and read some of Linus's posts before this. Eric writes using vague generalizations about age and experience; Linus writes with specifics about his experience with the kernel. The former style makes for popularly read posts but the latter seems much more effective. Also, compare this message from Linus earlier in that thread https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/52 https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/52 with a post of his from yesterday: https://lkml.org/lkml/2014/2/10/575 https://lkml.org/lkml/2014/2/10/575, especially regarding abstraction.
- Eliezer 13y agoYes, I came here looking for that. The lack of any specifics about the kernel issue at hand and the general attempt to project Age and Wisdom made me immediately suspicious.
- ZephyrP 13y agoESR is known for this.
- gertef 13y agohttp://geekz.co.uk/lovesraymond/archive/show-them-the-code http://geekz.co.uk/lovesraymond/archive/show-them-the-code (from Everybody loves Eric Raymond)
- waldir 13y agoEven more relevant to this thread: http://geekz.co.uk/lovesraymond/archive/specificator http://geekz.co.uk/lovesraymond/archive/specificator
- badman_ting 13y agoHaha, that post from yesterday is great. I have trouble disagreeing with Linus even when I know he's being a jerk.
- wellpast 13y agoThis is what Alan Kay means when he says, "IQ is a lead weight." [1] Also see Rich Hicky's talk "Simple Made Easy." [2] In which he suggests that nobody's that smart; you will always hit a brick wall without the tools to manage complexity. "A juggler can juggle 3 balls. A really good juggler can juggle 9. But no juggler can juggle 90 or 900 (paraphrased)." [1] http://www.tele-task.de/archive/video/flash/14029/ http://www.tele-task.de/archive/video/flash/14029/ [2] http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy
- ArkyBeagle 13y agoThis is really how to fix this: http://carymillsap.blogspot.com/2011/01/axiomatic-approach-to-algebra-and-other.html http://carymillsap.blogspot.com/2011/01/axiomatic-approach-t... I was an undergrad with Cary, and he got A's, I got B's with the odd C and this is exactly why. Until I took the Discrete Math course ( w/ the Eggers book - which is fantastic ) , I was floundering. I knew what the rules were, roughly, but I didn't KNOW know them. I'm not name-dropping Cary. It's just a coincidence, but I googled him and found the essay. I bring up the "we were undergrads" thing because it's a nearly perfect natural experiment. Use one of the Algebra sections in junior high or high school to teach rigor. There are no moves in a solution unless you name the principle by which the move was made. I know it seems impossible to implement, but there can't be a better time than 8th or 9th grade to do this. You get exposure to rigor for the kids that aren't pointed at STEM, the kids that are will actually be prepared - win-win. If we have to hire ringers as math teachers - people outside the education industrial complex - so be it. Whatever it takes.
- Gravityloss 13y agoThat was excellent. One big part was that the kids agreed on the rules together, before they started using them.
- revelation 13y agoThat seems like a positively annoying and pointless thing (see the line where they eventually just start referencing them by number; it's become just another 'thing to do'). Not the value of teaching math through axioms and deriving everything you do from them! That's very useful and proper preparation for higher math. But just because I can express everything in propositional logic with just NAND, I don't do that. Just as I would prove the mean-value theorem once and then simply invoke it when appropriate, I define conjunction, disjunction, negation etc. once and move on with the world. This is the lecture you are trying to teach, after all: you can deconstruct the universe into very simple blocks.
- ArkyBeagle 13y agoJust to reinforce things: we are talking about kids very early in their math career. And math is drill; Khan academy, all that. It's an investment. You can do drill in 8th grade, or you can do it in your freshman year of college. The point is: 1) I thought it annoying and pointless in the 8th grade. Oh clever me, I knew so much better. 2) People who sucked it up and did it, with whom I shared classes, blew my doors off in college math courses for a couple of years. A teacher made this the central fact of the algebra class they took. 3) Then I took the discrete math course, and stopped having trouble. There is something to this. Rigor is not natural. Learning rigor is essential to being able to operate your life well.
- lutorm 13y agoObligatory reference to Carol Dweck's research: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-secret-to-raising-smart-kids/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/the-secret-to-rais...
- MarkTee 13y agoNon-paywall version: http://www.ccsf.edu/Campuses/Downtown/scientific_american.pdf http://www.ccsf.edu/Campuses/Downtown/scientific_american.pd...
- bane 13y agoedit a little stream of consciousness follows Curse of being gifted is very real. I wonder sometimes how many people couldn't break out of it and have ended up in bad jobs, or worse. Probably like many HNers I also suffered from it mightily in K-12 and by the time I realized what was going on, I was already so far behind that escaping school, rather than redoing years of what I missed, was the easier option. It took me a few years of milling around before I finally got my head together the right way and turned my life around into something productive. One thing that still comes up to this day for me is a profound sense of isolation and loneliness. It's hard to relate to people because the kinds of problems most people have seem trivially simple to me and are not the kinds of problems I have and the kinds of things people want to talk about are not of interest to me. I try to stay intellectually engaged by turning the issue into one of how to communicate with people who aren't as quick as I? Adult education, how people learn, are a small hobby of mine. I even did a short stint as a teacher. I'm consumed with relationships with mapping out the other person's cognitive limitations and patterns and trying to work within and around those. This is not a good habit, but I find I end up doing it with most everybody. The people I tend to keep around me are those that I haven't been able to conclusively do this with. I guess they keep me interested? I'm rarely surprised by people. I remember I mentioned this to an associate one time. He asked me if I had done this with him. I answered yes. He challenged me to prove it. I went down a list of his cognitive biases, how they fed into his decision making process, and how this created a pattern of where I could even start inventorying what I thought he had in his apartment (I'd never been to his apartment). I missed the color of his couch, but guessed correctly where he bought his furniture, what kind of car he drove and was likely to buy and why, what TV shows he watched, what music he listened to (and had listened to in the past), the clothes he did and didn't have in his closet, what kind of food he liked and where he liked to shop, I picked his neighborhood, choice of home computer, where he wanted to retire and even a handful of books he probably had in his home library. I think it hurt him, or his sense of individuality, to be deconstructed like that. It was the last time I ever did this to another person. On the flip side, he tries to mix his life up, make random vectors in his life now and not be so predictable. But I know also that he does it because of what I did. It's just another behavior to slot into his patterns. Relating to people impacts me in many ways, from coming up with product ideas to finding a mentor, to the closeness of friends. It's tough, I have very few close friends but I hold onto them fiercely. With most people I interact with I feel like we're simply in a status of mutual understanding and shared purpose, but not friendship. Maybe out for some laughs and a good time, but that's it. I got very lucky and found a wife who's smarter than me, and she keeps me on my toes and from drawing the world down into my brain and further isolating myself with walls of internally consistent, but bad ideas. I've never figured out how to predict her thinking process beyond some high level abstract patterns. I think she does it on purpose, to keep me appreciative of her. Not having a mentor has probably been the hardest. I feel like I have nobody helping me find my path most of the time and have to literally carve a path in the universe for myself. My parents were simply not equipped to deal with a kid like me at all and made many mistakes over the years. From moving to the country (thinking the quiet would help me grow, when it just isolated me more) to schooling choices, etc. School didn't know how to handle me and in business I've found woefully few people I look up to. I yearn for a simpler life, but realize I couldn't live that life for long, I would quickly lose interest. I start to crave novelty and surprise. New things are interesting to me. But I've also found that once I start to understand the pattern of newness in something, an entire field will start to bore me. Actually most of the life skills I have I learned from my school's music program. How to break a problem down, how to communicate with people of various levels, how to tutor and teach, how to lead a group and present, setting and keeping schedules etc. Most of my adult years have been spent trying to adapt these skills from orchestra into the rest of my life, while most people would have learned them in more context appropriate ways. But I guess I turned out okay. I do not look back on most of my childhood with much fondness, I do look back on it with a great deal of sadness and regret and wish I could redo it all. I found out a few years ago that my mother had saved all of my report cards growing up, lovingly stored in a scrapbook. When I found out she had done this, in a fit of anger, resentment and deep embarrassment I tore them up and threw them away. There's no solution, it just is this way. I live a very fulfilling life that I enjoy and I try to minimize regrets and find joy. I think I'm on a path towards simplifying my life, but I have a notion that I'll find a more minimal life dreadful and boring after a few months. I do seek out others who I sense have a similar story, but I find that none of us ever really build close bonds with each other. We exist more in a group of mutual acknowledgment than in friendship. I'm drawn towards groups that promise an intelligent gathering, but I'm frequently disappointed by what I find once I get there. My mother once asked me why so many smart kids end up in drugs and drink, I responded that, at least for me, it slows the thinking down and clarifies the thoughts. It's like having an engine in your car that's always at full rev, and then finally taking your foot off the accelerator for a bit. It also lets the emotions flow a bit easier, the ones that we have to keep bottled up during the day, the slow accumulation of small frustrations from dealing with people who I can't relate to. It's like a sore I can pop and let the puss flow out for a bit. It's hard staying positive, not falling into hopelessness and depression. I've had very close scares a couple times where I thought about disengaging from everything and ending it. Feeling like you're in the wrong world all the time is maddening. I found a way to continue on, and it works for me. But that endless well of despair still sits there, but it's like I'm walking around the edge of it, like walking around the edge of a swimming pool, trying to make sure I don't fall or jump in.
- OldSchool 13y agoI'm surprised nobody's mentioned this curse's endgame: getting a typical corporate job. Everything about it is against your nature: fixed schedule, dictated product and process, micro management and arbitrary accountability compared to the creative freedom of your life when delivering academic performance on a timescale of weeks or months was your only responsibility. Worse still, it's not an "X year work program," it's designed to be endless. Not that an entrepreneurial career is for everyone, but if you can be dumb enough to try and smart enough to make it work at a sustainable scale, it sure beats a guaranteed slow corporate death.
- socrates1998 13y agoThis is so true. I hated my life for years because I knew if I could have just been more disciplined, then I would have been free from all the horrible, mind numbing, soul crushing stuff I had to do at my corporate job. It took me years to finally leap into self-employment.
- BlackDeath3 13y ago>It took me years to finally leap into self-employment. What do you do? How did you start?
- socrates1998 13y agoI was a teacher for a few years, so I transitioned that into a tutoring company and I am doing some freelance web design as well.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 13y ago14 years later Linus seems to be doing pretty ok. The git and all considered.
- ChristianMarks 13y agoAt least no one can accuse ESR of coasting on his native gift of bloviation. The man perfected his blowhard style more than 10,000 hours before that "it takes one to know one" email. (Which is why it's irritating when he's right.)
- everyone 13y agoWorking on an OS is an enormous job where teamwork, good communication, planning and so on are paramount. I am the only game coder for a small adver-game company. The projects are small and I have total control, so I will never hit that wall and have to do all that boring stuff :) (One of the reasons I chose such a job)
- PythonicAlpha 13y agoEric is plainly right. I once heard of a developer that wanted to make programming more interesting to himself, by using just three names for all his variables. They where banana, apple and another fruit. He used only those names. I am not sure what he did, when he needed more than three, but that was what he did. It might have made the thing more interesting for him, but made the things far more difficult for us others of the "pack". Software development is about complexity. To manage complexity is the highest form of software development and the real challenge. Not the clever ideas, the talented implementation -- manage complexity can make your project, even your company succeed or fall.
- mattfenwick 13y agoFrom reading some of the other message in the thread, I think Linus makes a well-reasoned argument -- so I disagree that "Eric is plainly right". Clearly I don't know all the context, and so I am not really sure what Eric is responding (in addition to the previous message), but it seems to me that Linus has solid technical reasons for his argument. He's even trying to avoid clever ideas of favor of simple code.
- morganherlocker 13y ago> Another is your refusal to use systematic version-control Pretty hilarious reading this now, considering his contributions to version control in the past several years. I am not too familiar with all of the backstory, but Linus' creation of git seems like one of the most extreme cases of "Not Invented Here Syndrome" since... well Linux itself (half-joking). I certainly won't complain when someone gets so frustrated with the current tool-o-the-week that they go out an build something superior.
- TacticalCoder 13y ago"Another is your refusal to use systematic version-control or release-engineering practices." And then Linus went on to use Git. I'm not a native english speaker so I may be wrong on this one but I feel like there's quite some irony there: Linus got criticized for not properly using version control and... A few years later he went on to write the most succesful version control system ever! The same person created both Git and Linux ffs! ESR was probably right: Linus is the 2nd coming of Ken ^ ^
- mcv 13y agoThat's not irony, that's simply someone listening and changing his mind. That is a normal and healthy thing to do.
- joehillen 13y agoLinus' signature is shockingly relevant these days: "...The Bill of Rights is a literal and absolute document. The First Amendment doesn't say you have a right to speak out unless the government has a 'compelling interest' in censoring the Internet. The Second Amendment doesn't say you have the right to keep and bear arms until some madman plants a bomb. The Fourth Amendment doesn't say you have the right to be secure from search and seizure unless some FBI agent thinks you fit the profile of a terrorist. The government has no right to interfere with any of these freedoms under any circumstances." -- Harry Browne, 1996 USA presidential candidate, Libertarian Party
- greenyoda 13y agoThat was Eric Raymond's signature, not Linus'.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoThat was almost certainly ESR's signature.
- code_duck 13y agoThat describes me pretty well. I thought I was going to get by in every field because of my raw talent. It turns out that you actually have to be organized and achieve things, however.
- Orangeair 13y agoOh, how I wish someone had told me this when I was fourteen. As a matter of fact, someone probably did, and I just ignored it. Public school isn't exactly challenging, and it's hard to believe that a problem could possibly be beyond your ability to intuitively grasp it when you never see actual evidence of that fact.
- fretfulfood 13y agoWhy is everyone here so self-bashing about how you should've seen this earlier? The solution is to make the gifted people working on something that _is_ challenging to them. You can't expect gifted people to work on annoyingly simple problems in school, yet still develop discipline. If you want them to develop discipline, give them hard problems, that will require discipline of them. I see this as a failure of the education system, not the gifted people. Or, put another way, you can't blame Linus for not having discipline if he never needed it. It's the educational system's fault for not showing him he will need it.
- loladesoto 13y agoit is a real problem and two things make it worse: 1) ego 2) lack of mentorship. ego urges you to walk into situations wearing nothing but arrogance. (and why wouldn't you? you've been praised since you were a kid for your precocity. by adults!). and while you may have earned some of that praise, it's like your granny chanting your invincibility into your ear. it's a delusion that prevents you from asking questions (acquiring wisdom) and exploring your outer limits (acquiring experience). with mentoring, that arrogance could be channelled into something else: humility. because it's really impossible to be alert to truth--academic or otherwise--when you think you know all of the things. it's just that the educational system doesn't really know what to do with academically-gifted kids who have a bit of rebellion/arrogance in them. and there aren't enough teachers or mentors who recognize this variant even among the gifted. so they're released into the wild, not having acquired the one thing they needed possibly more than an education: humility.
- kingkong 13y agoLinus's issue on "shared code means less bugs" https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/12 https://lkml.org/lkml/2000/8/22/12
- eklavya 13y agoWow, I can feel better about myself because now I have another alibi/theory for my shortcomings and under achievements :P ;)
- babesh 13y agoThe underlying ideas for even simple math are deep. Just because you get As doesn't mean that you grok concepts deeply. Examples: place notation, rational and irrational numbers, axiom, proof, correspondence, logic, countability, etc... The formulations of these ideas were intellectual breakthroughs thousands of years ago. It's takes curiosity to explore these more deeply.
- wisevehicle 13y agoFor more about 'The Curse of the Gifted' see: Mindset: by Carol S. Dweck. Anecdotes aren't data, but I can say that having this 'curse' has been a huge challenge in my programming career.
- yason 13y agoI'm cursed with the gift of being slightly better than most in nearly all things but not at all stellar in any single one. I never learned to study in school because I've always learned things on my own. This has carried me far but my limits are always there, always visible, at 360 degrees. Meeting and seeing stellar people is a good reminder of that. The converse point is related to dealing with whatever talent you have. The essence is to learn to keep yourself in the unconfidence and doubt as for your skills even if so many people around you don't seem to "get" what's obvious to you. If you think too highly of yourself even if the evidence seems to be on your side, the reality will bite back. And that makes you go back and shut a part of yourself down, and you're in a position that worse than where you started. For example, in programming the only way to handle your skills is to assume the role of a beginner and expect the existing code to be right for a reason that you don't understand yet. If it turns out to be blindly obvious that the original author had no idea what he was doing and a partial rewrite is not only in place but unavoidable, only then accept it as there are no other options left. The trap is seeing too much of that and starting to hallucinate that thanks to your talents you can "just know" and short-circuit right through the way of doubt. No you can't. As a talented person you need to remain humble and only exercise your skills and vision when there are no other choices left. That will keep your ego in shape.
- jokoon 13y agoIndeed, success is only potential times ability to work with other people. I still wonder what sort of company or business environment Linus works in. Nobody would have heard of general relativity if einstein would not have been let working in his labs for long hours. Often you'll have a very skilled technician and you will have to give him more space to achieve more work than other, but at some point, you still have to make this person work a little with others to make this one guy's contribution more valuable. Apart from that, I still believe we don't give enough chance to introvert types so that they can channel their work and prove their worth. Linux is a success mostly because Linus managed to channel his talent, but there are many untold stories nobody will remember about a talented guy that just gave up trying. I'm still siding with Linus because the system tend to not work properly for talented people in general. I'm sure he must have some sort of anger and frustration issue, and that mail somehow shows it.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- refurb 13y agoI always wondered what the difference was between being really smart or just being really interested in a subject. All through high school I never studied for a science (biology, chemistry and physics) exam. I would often work by myself and complete several weeks of study in a few days. I would read college levels books in 10th grade, just because it was interesting. Teachers would force me to go back to my locker to get my textbooks before an exam because I needed to study; I just put them back when they weren't looking. I didn't study for 12th grade standardized science tests and ended up with scores 95%+. (I also thought English class was stupid and typically got mid-70s by squeeking by). That being said I am certainly NOT gifted and to be honest I don't think I'm that extraordinarily smart; I just find that if I'm interested in something, the effort I put in seems, well, effortless.
- CmonDev 13y agoIsn't lack of ability to modularize a sign of lack of another kind of gift? Gifts come in different traits.
- drstrangevibes 13y agoi love it how everyone is more concerned with showing how cursed (and therefore gifted) they are , instead of actually listening to the message from linus. for what its worth , i was cursed too lol
- popee 13y agoGift of the cursed? >:-)
- frodopwns 13y agoI don't compare to Linus but I think I was hit by this bug. I cruised through high school without trying and actually made it through undergrad the same way. Now however I am faced with the prospect of relearning a lot of it if I want to move forward. That or be a run of the mill web dev for the rest of my life.