24 ms·
The Elves Leave Middle Earth – Sodas Are No Longer Free (2009)
- rayiner 14y agoPeople are totally irrational about free soda/snacks. If you gave them a $50/month raise (to cover the cost of soda and snacks), they'd be offended. If you put out soda and snacks, well you're just the most awesome employer ever!
- mashmac2 14y agoSo why not give them soda and snacks? It's cheap and easy retention, if that's what they want. The author is right, getting rid of $10k in expenses isn't worth it if it costs your the core of your team.
- comatose_kid 14y agoIt's a little more nuanced - things like this change the focus of the relationship from a 'we're in this together' approach to a more transactional one.
- guard-of-terra 14y agoYou're forgetting about transaction costs. The transaction cost of spending money (and therefore time) to buy a can of soda is much more than cost of that can.
- dman 14y agoTheres often a time at 6:15 - 6:30pm where if I can have a light snack I return to my desk to work peacefully in a half empty office. In the absence of any options to satiate my hunger I just leave for home. Wonder if there are more people out there who do something similar.
- witek 14y agoDefinitely. I don't like having very late dinners so would rather go home and cook if a good alternative is not provided.
- disgruntledphd2 14y agoYup. Me too. I recently changed jobs from one that didn't even provide tea and coffee, to one which provides meals all day, soda, snacks etc. I find that I am far more inclined to actually stay a little later and get stuff done when I'm not ridiculously hungry. Additionally, I can stay later after dinner and still have the same amount of free time when I get back home, which is nice for me, and for the company.
- Fishkins 14y agoI'm the same. Hunger is often my limiting factor. I'll be in the middle of working on something in the late afternoon or early evening and want to finish it, but I get too hungry. Then I have to leave the office and decide where to get food. By the time I'm done I'm not focused on the problem anymore. I do keep my own food at the office, but it's hard to always be properly stocked (I eat a lot). edit: soda wouldn't do anything for me, though. Substantial snacks or "real" food would be much better.
- ansible 14y agoIrrational? Yes, that can be argued. There's more going on though. If soda/snacks are free (and always in stock), there is less mental effort involved for the employees. They feel reassured that the snacks are always there when they want them. They don't have to make decisions about whether or not to buy them... actually this is a whole 'nother discussion about micro-transactions, which haven't worked well for the Web. If you give your employees a raise, that disappears into the general fund, and is no longer a separate benefit.
- ebiester 14y agoIt's a social signal, and it's rarely about the soda or snacks themselves but rather the social and hierarchical changes that are to come.
- carbocation 14y agoIt's not irrational. Is your goal wealth maximization? If so, you might understand that you're now getting an extra $50/mo for food purposes, but now you feel like you should hold it and not spend it. Is your goal to suck down some minor pleasure to keep your brain mollified as you ponder some unsolved task? Well maybe the distraction posed by thinking of soda; thinking of buying a soda; thinking of buying a soda and wondering if you have the right change for it; thinking of buying a soda and wondering if you should really save that money to spend on a larger purchase later; etc... Anyway, maybe that distraction is greater than the distraction posed by grabbing a free soda. People's different reaction to free vs non-free things, especially in the context of engineering work, does not strike me as irrational in general—only if you think that people maximize for present dollars does it seem particularly irrational.
- jtbigwoo 14y agoIf the snacks are provided by the company: -I don't have to carry change/cash. -I don't have to deal with a vending machine that will fail to give me what I want 2% of the time. -If something that I want is not there, I can ask the boss to get it next time rather than hoping for a machine to be restocked (probably by a vendor that may or may not carry what I want). -The price of soda/snacks never changes. -If I ask my neighbor to grab a soda for me, there's no need for her or me to keep a mental account of gifts. EDIT: Typing too fast; missed a word
- benjamincburns 14y ago- I'm more likely to skip lunch when I'm enthralled with solving a problem, since I can just grab a snack when I finally snap out of it.
- jrs99 14y agoexactly. It's all about producing a frictionless environment for your workers so they can actually be massively productive. Especially when a machine break down, takes your dollar, and makes you go to your car to look for some change. Then when you get back with quarters instead of bills, and the machine STILL doesn't work, that is just more friction and a waste of your brain thinking about these issues. At home, you have to remind yourself to bring a drink in case the machine isn't working, and bring enough change to get as many drinks as you need. The best coders, in my experience, are very sensitive. They understand what great quality is. One little thing is off, and it will bug them. That's what makes them great.
- ameister14 14y agoThat or you spend an hour figuring out what's broken about the machine.
- namdnay 14y agoI've never worked somewhere with "free non-lunchtime calories" (i.e. not tea and coffee). Wouldn't this encourage unhealthy consumption? Rather like the "fixed monthly cost eat as much as you want 24/7" cafeterias in many US universities. I know, it's your own responsibility etc etc, but surely an abundance of free stuff will encourage over-consumption. Especially if you factor the psychological "if I don't eat it I'm getting stiffed" factor.
- angersock 14y agoPeople are totally irrational about sex and love, too, but you can still screw up royally and hurt relations that way. Rationality don't enter into it. Really, I think part of the affront here is that the absence of such a minor thing--perhaps especially because it's so cheap--is a really bad sign about how much the company values its people. ~ An anecdote: About the best thing that my previous employer did was offer free coffee, if you could be bothered to make a pot from the existing supplies. So, a coworker and I took to taking coffee breaks to buy some from a local coffee shop. Usually done after lunch, but still, it got us out of the office for maybe a half-hour or so. We really enjoyed this, because it gave us a chance to talk about other things and get some fresh air. Said coworker also took to making runs to a convenience store to buy sodas--offering, of course, to do the same for other folks. All told, these little expeditions probably amounted to a few hours every week in not-working time. Had the business been particularly ruthless, they would've noted that perhaps $10-12 every week in drinks could have kept some of their $50K/yr engineers from being useless for a few hours in search of nourishment. I'm not claiming that this was right, and we're more experienced now, but the fact remains. A similar story was us getting kicked out of a conference room during a major refactor--we needed to pair program and use a lot of whiteboard space, and after a day or two (this was a really, really hairy unfucking of some core code that had no test suite), and got thrown out mid-project. That code and project went down in true viking fashion a week or two later, and I left shortly thereafter.
- lmm 14y ago>All told, these little expeditions probably amounted to a few hours every week in not-working time. Had the business been particularly ruthless, they would've noted that perhaps $10-12 every week in drinks could have kept some of their $50K/yr engineers from being useless for a few hours in search of nourishment. I'm not claiming that this was right, and we're more experienced now, but the fact remains. Are you sure you were less productive overall? When I'm stuck on a tricky problem getting out of the office can do wonders.
- krschultz 14y agoIt has a lot more to do with how you are treated. I don't drink soda, so free soda does nothing for me. But the fact that company I work for has those things and asks the employees what they want in the fridge is a very different experience than at a company without that concern. It starts with the snacks, but it goes all the way up to sitting down and asking what I actually want to get out of the job. It's the difference between a company acting like you should feel lucky to have a job there, and a company acting like they are trying to keep you in your job there.
- dspillett 14y agoIt isn't really about the snacks as such. We don't have free snacks here but we never ave so I don't care but I can see why such a change is very noticeable. If the company used to given free snack but is now so short on cash that they can't, then perhaps people's positions aren't as safe as they thought they were previously. Whether or not there is a real problem, that is likely to be the perception. Also we have an informal arrangement here: if I'm working late and get hungry I'll have food delivered and expense it. If I couldn't do that I'd have to go home instead, so if people are using the free snacks to stave off hunger at busy times this could be a detriment to the company.
- mattmanser 14y agoBecause it's an indication of intent, a change in the winds. It's feels like your employer saying 'numbers are now more important than getting things done'. It's basically signalling the beginning of bureaucracy. And that's exactly what happened in Derek's example. So they were not irrational at all, it's a very powerful social cue that the company didn't even know it was giving.
- ja27 14y agoYes they are, but that works in your favor as an employer or boss. A box of leftover marketing swag goes a long way when you're not allowed to offer raises or bonuses. When we briefly stopped free sodas in our office, I said I'd just pay for them myself our of my own pocket but my boss reamed me out. That's the same boss that invited our whole department and more out to lunch then asked for 20 separate checks. I still kick myself for not just picking up everyone's check that day, but I think she would have fired me on the spot. She was gone within a year.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- michaelochurch 14y agoAt work, I think decision overload is a factor. It's not irrationality; they don't want more stuff to think about, especially because food is a break. People like free food because it doesn't require thinking. You just walk over and get a soda and chips. You don't think about it. You don't have to make another damn decision (even though, with 200+ empty calories on the line, one probably should) in your workday. Of course, then they gain 20 pounds over 3 years and resent their employers (and commutes) for all those extra hours and such... or, if the employer switches over to healthy food, they get angry about the paternalistic aspect... this is hard one to win.
- nilkn 13y agoI agree that there's a lot of irrationality about it. You point out an example of that. However, you're talking about going from no free snacks to free snacks. The other direction--free snacks to non-free snacks--is a bizarre change that sends a negative message to employees. In fact, as you say, it's equivalent to a small loss in pay, as now you have to cover those snacks yourself. Not a big deal... but why is the company effectively docking the pay of every employee?
- addlepate 14y agoYeah, why take a pay cut or cut something you as a board member personally care about, when you can just cut something stupid peon employees care about. Engineers in such an organization are right to leave, though granted it is stupid that they are getting upset about sodas.
- fournm 14y agoI'm always amused by how quickly drinks seem to go in order to save costs when the cost of drinks for an entire small department of developers is nothing compared to the salary of a single one of them, yearly. Not to mention the whole "developers and loose change" not going together thing so we tend to value them as worth far more than we should.
- dangoldin 14y agoThe old discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750
- jessaustin 14y agoThat discussion seemed to be about server names? b^)
- meritt 14y agoNaming servers something cute, witty or clever is a gold standard of freedom among engineers. When engineer perks (server naming, or free sodas/snacks/food, lax daily start-times, etc) are taken away, the good engineers will quit.
- 16s 14y agoI'm not sure about that. If management won't let you name the servers after characters in your favorite sci-fi movie, then that is an indication that names matter (ns1 for DNS rather than gandolf or papa_smurf or whatever) and that management is playing the role of the adult while you are acting like a child. If you want to name servers after fairy tale characters and you will have a tantrum if management won't let you, then you are not mature enough to work for a company. It's called growing-up and being responsible.
- lmm 14y agoEngineers are the ones who will have to use the server names. When management starts insisting things be done a certain way that's called micromanagement and it's the biggest sign your company is about to fail. And good engineers understand the value of memorable names, as well as the less tangible value of good corporate culture.
- qu4z-2 13y agoIt's the difference between being a hacker shop or a corporate drone shop. Both are somewhat viable strategies, but don't expect people to stay around for the transition. (also, it tends to be irreversible)
- jlarocco 14y agoIt's funny, to me, that the guy will sit in a meeting with a bunch of executives and VCs, all making significantly more money than he is from the software he's writing, and the major complaint he has is that they're cutting off free soda.
- brudgers 14y agoSteve Blank is a VC or Angel or something like that or all three.
- jdboyd 14y agoAs the article says, losing the free soda isn't the major complaint, it is the wake-up call.
- mikeash 14y agoHis major complaint is that they scared away all the good talent.
- jlarocco 14y agoOkay, I didn't make my point very well. To put it another way, it's amusing that the software engineers make a big deal out of free food and drinks, when the people "above" them are getting massive pay checks from the software engineer's work. It's no wonder we're getting another tech bubble when software engineers will sell themselves out for $5 worth of snacks.
- tompko 14y agoI'll quite happily take the snacks if it means I can code in peace all day and not have to worry about finding funding, talking to investors, keeping the company running, etc. They're the ones with money on the line too, they probably deserve the "massive checks".
- mikeash 14y agoWell, that's how people work. It's the job of management to understand how people work.
- troymc 14y agoI've read that the same thing happened at TechTV. When the free food disappeared, it sent a signal, "Cash is tight. We're in trouble. Be worried."
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ryguytilidie 14y agoIts really weird. I feel like the business school experience for most people was like "look at a balance sheet, find costs to cut". The program I did, at a not very prestigious school (my employer paid) the focus was much more on the long term impact and trade offs of the decisions you make. So you think "Ok, we will save 10k, but what will we lose?" When the answer is "we will lose the happiness of our team" this becomes an obvious bad idea. As an employer this is such an easy way to make your employees happy and reward them for working super hard for you. Once you lose sight of that and look at it as a cost to cut you might as well just not run a business because you're missing the bigger picture.
- witek 14y agoThere are various aspects to that. For example, I recently took over a project, where the hardware part needs to be cost optimised. Basically, when the product was put together, two elements pushed the cost higher than I'd like: 1) Both software and hardware teams like using the best components possible, without necessarily putting enough thought into the target market, which the product is serving. I'm not saying that the product should be as cheap as possible, compromising on quality, but there needs to be a ceiling, depending on the market requirements. 2) Not enough thought was put into the most efficient structuring of the supply chain, resulting in unnecessarily high shipment and tax expenses. So, the first exercise was very much similar to what you're describing - go through the bill of materials and one by one try to identify any cost savings. This is causing some loss of happiness (treading on people's toes, having to push for different solutions, in their eyes compromising on quality) but is necessary in making a better product.
- hkarthik 14y agoI don't think this is the b-school experience, more likely it's a result of management consulting experience. Consultants often get into this mindset that they need to find a way to show their value in the most immediate way to their clients, in order to justify their high fees. Basically showing how quickly they "pay for themselves". Coming in as a brand new CFO, you have to prove yourself quickly and justify the high salary you just took. The easiest way is to do that, is to find cost savings within the company and implement them expediently.
- hkarthik 14y agoI've seen such things happen, and I almost universally blame the founders and top level leadership when this kind of thing happens. Dedicated CFOs and accounting types are simply doing their job. Their singular focus is often the bottom line and the company's financial health. It's not their job to maintain, foster, or enhance company culture. That is the job of the CEO. In situations like this, it's the CEO's responsibility to make statements like "there are intangible benefits to free snacks and sodas. Small things like that help people that make money for the company stay focused longer and help them get through their day." Help the accountants understand where the cost cutting boundaries are early, so you don't have to micromanage every decision they make later on. Over time they'll start to "get it" with your culture and they'll focus their attention on real problems like getting financing, making sure invoices are paid, setting up M&A deals, etc that they were hired to do.
- walshemj 14y agoI remember being told that one of the CEO's of British Telecom is said to have said to his CFO "thank you for telling me what the cost of things are but I know the value of them" Ironically BT a huge company started to go towards free tea and coffee but this was stopped by HMRC (the taxman) who wanted to charge tax on this benefit in kind - and you think the IRS is bad.
- mattmanser 14y agoWhen? Food and drink are considered non-taxable benefits according to HMRC: http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/payerti/employee/changes/new-benefit.htm http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/payerti/employee/changes/new-benefit.... It's always been non-taxable as far as I can remember and a quick google is not bringing anything up.
- pbhjpbhj 14y agoI think you might be confusing the fact that [non luxury] food and drink are [generally] zero-rated for VAT purposes with the assessment of a value for food and drink provided as a "benefit in kind" for income tax and NICs purposes. That said the online guidance on what counts as a trivial benefit, http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/eimanual/EIM21863.htm http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/manuals/eimanual/EIM21863.htm, says: >"Tea and coffee >An employer may provide its employees with access in the workplace to tea, coffee or water from a cooling dispenser. If this refreshment is available generally to all employees, the benefit is exempt from charge (EIM21670). If the exemption does not apply, you should accept that these refreshments represent a trivial benefit." // But it very much depends on how the benefit is provided, voucher schemes work differently and there is an assessment of the value of the benefit involved. Other references: http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/paye/exb/a-z/a/ http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/paye/exb/a-z/a/ http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/paye/exb/a-z/m/meals.htm http://www.hmrc.gov.uk/paye/exb/a-z/m/meals.htm
- witek 14y agoOne of the key reasons why I decided to join my first employer was because they had amazing fruit baskets delivered every morning. It saved me from thinking about breakfast. Top banks and law firms have everything either free or heavily subsidised under one roof, from multiple restaurants to gyms, so that you don't waste any time looking for those things and carry on working like a dog (but feel privileged doing so). Just don't calculate your hourly rate...
- illumen 14y agoOld trick. This is taught as a way to get people to leave by themselves. Often followed by contracts not being renewed, and people moved into hours they don't like or into roles they don't like. Those people leave by themselves, then the firings happen... and stock goes up, targets are met... BONUSES ALL ROUND! Woo! (Or merger/new investment/whatever needs a up+right graph).
- drharris 14y agoCynical, but true. Once the company reaches a certain stage, this is a valid (albeit evil) path to travel down. Upper management gets rich, everyone else gets the shaft.
- Deestan 14y ago> Cynical, but true. More insane than cynical, I think. Cynicism is seeing things clearly without any romantic or emphatic filters. Insanity is making sure the most able part of the workforce finds other employment.
- davidw 14y agoActually it's not true that it's a good sign for the company: once things start going downhill, the best people look for somewhere better to work. I recall at one company, they fired a bunch of people, many of whom really were not top performers. Immediately after, the best people started trickling out. A few years later, the company was acquired and a few years after that, the whole thing fell apart.
- DanBC 14y agoGood staff can get new jobs. So they leave first. You're left with people who are duffers, and possibly doing harm to the company. Or with people who have many years with the company and who will be expensive to layoff with redundancy payments.
- kefka 14y agoNo, you have it all wrong. Firstly, I'm sure the work policy you signed off has tons of rules. Most of them are never enforced. Now, you enforce them stringently. Awwww.. People you didn't like now have cause for you to fire them.
- jmduke 14y agoThis reminds me of a great blog post, Goodbye Microsoft, Hello Facebook by Philip Su (http://worldofsu.com/philipsu/goodbye-microsoft-hello-facebook/ http://worldofsu.com/philipsu/goodbye-microsoft-hello-facebo...): We used to get Dove Bars and beers all the time. It felt like free food was on offer at least once a week, usually with a pretense of some small milestone to celebrate. Why did we cut stuff like this? (I know the boring fiscal reasons why. I’m asking the deeper why, as in, “Was it worth the savings? Is Microsoft better now that we’ve cut these costs?”) One day, a sign appeared on a soda fridge in RedWest saying something to the effect of, “Did you know that drinks cost Microsoft [ed: millions of dollars] a year? Sodas are your perk at work. Don’t bring them home.” This depressed me on too many levels to enumerate, but I’ll toss out a few: - Someone had enough time to get these signs professionally printed and affixed to our fridges. - It was someone’s salaried, 40-hour-a-week job to do things like this. - Someone thought soda smuggling was a big enough “problem” at Microsoft to draw attention to it.
- ajross 14y agoHm... more like: someone was smuggling sodas out of the building that were offered in good faith as an office perk. Frankly that would affect my morale more than even the removal would. What does it say about an office culture where that kind of petty thievery is tolerated? Honestly my feeling (and to be clear: like this whole subject this is subjective) would be that this response is not enough: better to name and shame the offenders.
- Anderkent 14y agoDefine smuggling. If I pick up a soda when leaving the office, I don't think I'm doing anything wrong. If I start taking boxes, that might be an issue.
- ajross 14y agoI think we both know that's not the situation at hand. Even Microsoft isn't going to go around writing HR nonsense about the occasional soda taken home. Really, this attitude is precisely the problem. You're looking at this as a confrontation from the start. Perks like this only work if they're offered and accepted in good faith. If you don't trust your employer to interpret your soda consumption charitably, your employer is getting no benefit from offering it. Basically, if you want your employer to offer snacks and soda, be grateful about it and don't look for trouble.
- lotharbot 14y agoMy wife was a software engineer at a very big company (Fortune 50 / Dow Jones Industrial). At one point they decided to take the water coolers out of several buildings -- a move estimated to save half a million dollars a year. But one top-notch software engineer adds a lot more than that to the company's bottom line, so the move can very quickly become value-subtracting if it pushes someone over the edge to "I'm going to go to [competitor]" or "I'm going to go become a contractor". Even if they don't leave, there's a morale penalty applied every day when someone walks past where there used to be refreshments, and has to keep walking another 30 feet to the water fountain or vending machine. If there's one thing every company should understand about software, it's that top-notch people operating at high levels of morale are great for your bottom line. Being cheap about things like refreshments and office equipment ("you have to buy your own second monitor") is a morale killer.
- pjungwir 14y agoIt occurs to me that it's not just about morale and retention. Refreshment sites are also where people communicate. So I wonder how many dollars someone in the company was paying management consultants to foster better internal communication when someone else pulled out the water coolers!
- kabdib 14y agoThe place I work understands this. We have a company-wide lunch every week (not every day), and the intention is to get people together who wouldn't ordinarily be talking. It seems to work. I try to sit with new people then, rather than with my immediate cow-orkers, and I usually learn interesting things.
- sixothree 14y agoI work for a small company looking for a more space. When the president asked what one thing I would request from a new office space my answer was a dedicated place to sit and eat. What we lose by not socializing and chatting about projects is immense. And standing in the hall or in our small kitchen can really be a disruptor.
- 14y ago
- st3redstripe 14y agoVery insightful!
- killerdark 13y agotest to see if I am hellbanned. Edit: Yep, hellban+slowban 828 days old account, positive karma. Must have annoyed PG I guess?
- hrktb 14y agoThere's a saying that when a company starts cutting pens and station office availability, it's time to search for an exit. I'd say it's the same kind of mechanics here: It's not that soda is so valuable, it's that the company reached a level where every little thing starts to get scrutinize and needs justification, and there's no going back from then.
- marshray 14y agoI've seen free snacks go away at one company - but it was during the company's first downsizing. The company was losing money. We engineers grumbled a bit but no one really faulted them for it. The Support department set up a cash shop with far more variety of snacks than we had before.
- adnam 14y agoAs long as free fizzy drinks are considered sacred, engineers will never reach the income levels seen in the legal, medical and financial sectors. Employers will treat like adolescents those who behave like adolescents.
- mmoche 14y agoEmployers will pay their employees what the market bears.
- tikhonj 14y agoI really don't see how the two are related. And besides, you can get free drinks in quantitative finance too, if you want to be paid well.
- epoxyhockey 14y agoOther professions have perks analogous to free soda for engineers. For example, medical sector professionals go bonkers over free samples.
- hga 14y agoWell, that's a little more directly connected to their jobs. It allows them to start a patient on a drug without friction, or to give a patient who's going through hard times a full course of treatment without him having to pay anything.
- epoxyhockey 14y agoThen to validate the point, if company X stopped offering free samples, competitor Y would probably benefit by still offering free samples. Or, the medical professional could just buy the samples from company X with their own money because they are no longer free.
- rthomas6 14y agoAre you implying that the aggregate cost of employer provided soda is equal to the difference in salaries between engineers and doctors?
- jimparkins 14y agoAs much as this story is meant to be about keeping staff happy and managing expectation. Actually what I think it really does a good job is illustrate that finance and hr teams are pretty bad at managing the complex cause and affect that balance sheet decisions make. How many times have you seen someone leave because they were turned down for a pay increase?. The company then has to pay 12%-18% of an increased annual salary in recruitment costs for a replacement - added to the costs spent for managers time during hiring.
- smacktoward 14y agoBack in the original dot-com bubble, I worked at a place that had the most amazing coffee machine I've ever seen. It was the size of a Coke machine and made ten thousand varieties of boutique coffee, most of which I'd never even heard of, all made to your specifications. It was incredible. Then one day a guy came in with a hand cart, loaded the coffee machine on it, and rolled it away. A week later the layoffs started. The lesson here isn't that there's something intangible or magic about free sodas or coffee. It's that when you used to give out free sodas and coffee, and then you stop, you're telling everyone in the company that business isn't as good as it used to be. Beverages are an easy thing for the bean-counters to get approval to cut, so when times get tough, they get cut first. But they're also a small line item, so while they're the first thing to get cut, they're usually not the last. In other words, the free sodas are the proverbial canary in the coal mine. When they die, it's time to get out if you don't want to die with them. This is why, when I visit clients these days, I make a point of going with them to their break room to get some coffee before our meeting starts. If their beverage situation has been upgraded since my last visit, they're doing well. If it's been downgraded, I know to be on guard for bean-counters coming after my relationship with them.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- danso 14y agoIn the case of your company, it seems that the loss of the coffee machine was just the start of an impending death spiral (er...or am I judging too much from the preface of "in the original dot-com bubble")...but what about more moderate scenarios? Take, for example, Tumblr, which right now is a pretty big success. Just a month ago, they laid off their entire editorial team. Who knows if it was at all related to the Yahoo purchase, or if it was a decision made because Tumblr really need to cut expenses? But sometimes companies change course and cut because of ostensibly responsible financial concerns. In the case when an exciting company has to trim (but not just die), how should it handle the case of having a fancy coffee machine and possibly saving a job? It seems it would be a bit awkward if the company laid people off but kept all of its original ostentatious perks.
- will_brown 14y agoVery bizarre to read these kinds of business stories. I was a business major and recall all the case studies regarding the unmeasurable, but vast, benefits to the company of providing ancillary benefits such as free gym membership, free child care and free drinks/snacks. Sure these things are measurable monetarily, but the increase in employee moral, employee retention, productivity and general PR over company culture are immeasurable. (Admittedly they are measurable to a degree, but so many variables can allow business people to end up with numbers that support their decisions) I guess that is where academia collides with corporate politicking, as an MBA hired in a tech start-up it is easy to justify a 6 figure salary and stock options when you can show you are directly responsible for cost cutting of $x, rather than an MBA explaining they are responsible for $x increase in cost, but that company moral is up.
- seivan 14y agoI once was scolded for taking too much of what did eventually become the "managements" coffee.I was offered the ability to purchase packs so I could drink from that particular coffee machine, price tag: $60. The "others" were directed to another coffee machine, slightly inferior. The fact that I worked more than 14 hour days, weekends, had to pay for my own cab fares home (because trained stopped at 23:45) and occasionally had to spend nights working on features to hit marketing deadlines. At one time they hired a freelancer who wasn't up to par so I had to do all of his + my stuff, four nights in a row. At some point all nighters was more common than non all nighters. This is what happens when non devs take over and we become machines. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1008178 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1008178
- Jabbles 14y agoWhy didn't he say anything? Why sit on a board if you're not going to offer advice?
- mratzloff 14y agoHa, I had the same thought.
- ecspike 14y agoI noticed this at my first Silicon Valley job. When I joined, about a year after its acquisition, the kitchen was fully stocked and they had to ask people to take pizza home with them. First the soda orders went from a variety to a few brands and the pantry which was always open, started getting locked. Then it was cut to just cold cuts in the fridge and you had to run once the pizza guy got there or you were hungry. Attrition started soon after. It was apparent to all that our European parent corporation didn't quite understand how Silicon Valley worked. After about a year of everyone who could leaving (CEO, Dir of Eng, most of pre-acqu and post-acqui employees who weren't H1-Bs), the office ceased to exist. Like the OP, I saw the cutting sodas as a sign. If they are going to nickel and dime on something that keeps people from having to take a 20 min break to quench their thirst, where will they stop?
- alexmchale 14y agoI promise I'm not trying to troll here. When I hear "free soda" I hear "free diabetes and heart disease". Free soda is the worst kind of encouragement to have your employees living a healthy lifestyle. I'd love to hear about a company who seeks to provide fresh local fruits and vegetables at its snack table. I really don't mean to come off as a Debbie Downer, but soda is such a terrible scourge on society as a whole.
- pnathan 14y agoFree... soda, selzer water, coffee, Naked juice, fruit baskets daily... The point is that these stupid small things make (or not make) you feel appreciated. Although I don't hardly drink soda, having free soda available would allow me to believe that the company is willing to spend a few K/yr to say "We appreciate your hard work, have something small as a token of our appreciation"
- conradfr 14y agoYahoo! Ireland used to have free fruits, at least around 2006/2007. I'm with you about the sodas. They are free at my work (with a loose rule of one per employee per day) and I always say to my fellow colleagues that it's terrible, sugar sugar sugar.
- ionforce 14y agoSoda is symbolic for free perks. Free water, free tea, free snacks, free cabs, free dinner, etc.
- 14y ago
- jhull 14y agoWe were a 6 person startup that hired a CFO and cut soda because our burn was too high and we hadn' t raised money in 3 years. We experienced that exact same meeting and resulting effect at our company. It probably seems strange that we would get a CFO this early, but our finances were a total mess and we had a co-founder who dipped so 4 years after the founding we were hamstrung when going out to raise money.
- liquidise 14y agoAs a senior engineer who recently left a company undergoing a very ugly transformation, this strikes remarkably close to home. As with this case, the major pressure to change came not through the executives but rather the board. I have strong aspirations of starting a company, but have seen too many examples of a board's personality being at odds with [what feels like] common sense business interests. Anyone have any advice on ways to a) properly vet your investors and b) curb these situations down the line?
- mindcrime 14y agoThis is something I think about a lot. Right now, our startup is just the co-founders and one intern, and we don't even have office space yet. But assuming we are successful and start growing, at some point we will have employees, office space, offices, etc. And what I find myself pondering is "how do we make sure we create the kind of culture and environment that we want to work in, and that other people will want to work in... and how do we preserve it as we grow?" Now, you might say "Mindcrime, you're in a 2 person startup with no revenue yet, if you spend 2 seconds a year thinking about this stuff you're wasting time". But I think it's important for the founders to think hard about culture and work to start embedding that culture into the very DNA of the company, from the early days, and actively look for ways to resist the "culture decay" that @sgblank talks about in this post. Assuming you have a founding team who retain a substantial degree of control over the firm as it grows (ala, say, Sergey and Larry, or Zuck) you wonder "is it possible to preserve the best part of what makes the company great, even if grows in size 10x, 100x, or more"?
- untog 14y agoThere's an understated point in this article- that once they get beyond a certain point, startups rely on the obliviousness of early employees to blind them from negative changes that surround them. I mean, sure, the sodas were the wake up call that made engineers realise they wanted to leave. But the article seems to suggest that leaving the sodas free would solve the problem. Surely the core problem is that the company has changed, not that the engineers noticed it?
- pjungwir 14y agoThat struck me also. The mistake wasn't removing a perk per se, it was signaling that things had changed. But surely the employees would have noticed that sooner or later? So it seems there is a deeper problem, with no advice about how to address it.
- cinquemb 14y agoMight be a far out idea, but I wonder if around this stage, bringing in an anthropologist to study the culture of the company and suggest ways how to preserve some of the characteristics that originally attracted the first engineers would help address this problem.
- MartinCron 14y agoI worked for a company that brought in an organizational psychologist who tried to get a handle on what ways the company worked well and didn't work well. It seemed like an interesting exercise. And then we were purchased by a company run by insecure petty tyrants who alternated between neglect and micro-management, so none of it mattered. Sigh.
- cinquemb 14y agoDid you get at least any of that sweet equity that people say is one of the best points of tech sector to balance out your disappointment?
- 14y ago
- ejrowley 14y agoI work for a small company, not a startup (I've been here 9 years), about 20 people. Yesterday we launched a website, today we got Pizza. I was happy. It cost the company £100 but it made all of us feel appreciated. A couple of weeks ago I ask an owner how much he wanted for an old TV we had in the office, hoping that he would say just take it (the tv was 8 years old and not been used for about 3), he didn't, he wanted its ebay value. We agreed £30. That made me feel sad, less appreciated. tldr; Small things can affect people in a big way.
- h2s 14y ago> wanted old equipment for free > had to pay a nominal price for it instead > felt sad and less appreciated Gotta say, your disappointment really isn't resonating with me. Sounds like quite a reasonable response on their part. People in management perform a constant balancing act with things like morale and expectations. Perhaps it wouldn't have been prudent to have you be seen to be getting "special treatment". Unless there were 19 similar old TVs to give to the rest of the team, then you can guarantee several people would have felt resentful about you getting yours for free.
- qu4z-2 13y agoAt my workplace it'd probably have been given for free, and I'm pretty sure none of my co-workers would resent the recipient. Come on, it's an 8 year-old TV. Everyone who wants a TV has a better one already. Are we really so petty?
- Xylakant 13y agoA company can't just write off things that are in it's inventory. They can either be lost, destroyed, trashed or sold. If you sell them, it has to be at a reasonable market value or you're in trouble with the IRS. So it's not unreasonable to ask for the ebay value. Ask for a low ebay value if you're being nice.
- siavosh 14y agoAt my previous firm, cuts in these sorts of things was a rounding error in their balance sheet--completely immaterial. BUT it was viewed as an indirect signal to everyone to think frugally in your projects, work harder, and temper feelings of entitlement during difficult economic times. So I've always viewed these sorts of actions as a management technique, not necessarily a financial cost cutting one.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoSteve Blank says its a sign of a company growing and you didn't notice. So that sounds natural and should be expected. So is he criticizing soda-jerking or not? I would think if it were managed, with lots of communication about new benefits that reflect the changing company behavior (more execution-centric, less skunk works) and new work-hour expectations, then it can seem ok.
- Choronzon 14y agoBenefits should be added slowly and if they must be taken away it should not be piecemeal. Few things offend people as a continuous loss of status. Machevelli,the Prince (From obtaining a state by Wickedness!).. Hence it is to be remarked that, in seizing a state, the usurper ought to examine closely into all those injuries which it is necessary for him to inflict, and to do them all at one stroke so as not to have to repeat them daily; and thus by not unsettling men he will be able to reassure them, and win them to himself by benefits. He who does otherwise, either from timidity or evil advice, is always compelled to keep the knife in his hand; neither can he rely on his subjects, nor can they attach themselves to him, owing to their continued and repeated wrongs. For injuries ought to be done all at one time, so that, being tasted less, they offend less; benefits ought to be given little by little, so that the flavour of them may last longer.
- jacques_chester 13y agoMachiavelli is underrated as a social psychologist. People just don't want to believe it's true.
- archon 14y agoThe company I'm with now recently started implementing "cost cutting measures." Coffee is no longer free (.50 cents per cup). Annoying, but not really a huge deal. You can pay once a month and get it out of the way instead of having to keep quarters on hand. The bigger issue, to me, is that management decided to stop using a cleaning service. The 30-employee workforce is now part of a cleaning rotation. So, once a week, we are all expected to stop what we're doing and spend 30 minutes to 2 hours cleaning something, depending on our assigned area. How can that possibly be cost efficient? You derail the thought processes of all 30 of your employees for at least a half hour every week. 15+ man hours that your highly skilled employees could be using elsewhere. In the case of the half-dozen programmers here, it's even less efficient. It takes a lot of concentration for me to get into a mental state conducive to good programming. 30+ minutes of cleaning is enough to get me out of that programming "mode", and it is very difficult to regain that state of mind once lost. I think that's at least part of the reason why these progammers were so up in arms about the soda machine: Because now they have to think about it. The company has introduced an annoyance and distraction (I'll admit, a trivial one) into their work day, for very little apparent effect on the company's bottom line.
- rdl 14y agoThis seems like one of those cases where having your email address in profile would get you spammed by recruiters :)
- michaelochurch 14y agoThe bigger issue, to me, is that management decided to stop using a cleaning service. The 30-employee workforce is now part of a cleaning rotation. So, once a week, we are all expected to stop what we're doing and spend 30 minutes to 2 hours cleaning something, depending on our assigned area. Wow. You only clean (aside from desk clutter and kitchen spills) at work if: (A) Your job is literally to be a full-time cleaner. (B) You are a partner in the company (0.05% stock options don't count.) Ask for (B)-- being a real owner means you do some of that unpleasant stuff-- but if that doesn't happen, then quit.
- archon 14y ago
- michaelochurch 14y agoThis seems to indicate to the power of common knowledge (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_knowledge_(logic) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_knowledge_(logic) ) which is not the same thing as shared knowledge. Common knowledge means everyone knows that everyone knows (that everyone knows, to infinity) and that's far more powerful. The real crimes have nothing to do with soda. Some manager is hired from outside and is mandating daily status reports. Complain about that and you get in trouble, or people think you're a slacker upset that he can no longer hide. Or, let's say that you find out that some newly-hired VP/NTWTFK (Non-Technical Who-The-Fuck-Knows) is outearning engineering old hands who took actual risk; it's unjust, but if you complain about it, you endanger not only your career but the careers of the people who gave you that information. The thing about free soda is that you can complain about the loss of it without showing insecurity or political bias because the change is in the common knowledge. Companies get away with much worse crimes than free-food reductions (which aren't even crimes at all if (a) they were never part of the promised employment deal and (b) times are legitimately tough) but because there's no way to hide that stuff, those end up being the touch-points for complaints. You can't complain about the new stack-ranking system without seeming insecure-- so executives can divide-and-conquer along those lines (we're firing 5% each year in a "low performer" witch hunt, but the top 15% get bonuses!)-- but the loss of free food is a more socially acceptable and universal grudge. I actually like the fact that when Douchetember 11th happens, these trivial perks get phased out as well. If the executive shitfucks knew how to rob a company, they'd keep the free soda while turning the crank slowly on the robberies that actually matter (meaner performance review systems, equity clawbacks and cliffing). Imagine what would happen if a large company kept its trivial perks but still disempowered engineers, gradually, over time. It might manage to hold a "best company out there" reputation 10 years beyond actually deserving it. Not that I know of any companies like that, but just imagine how effective it might be and how much executive robbery (at the expense of clueless talent) could go on.
- GhotiFish 14y ago"Not that I know of any companies like that" I don't believe you.
- deleted 13y ago
- mistermcgruff 14y agoI worked at a large consulting firm that went public a while back. As part of that process, they took away the candy bowls from the front office. Fast forward a few years after going public, benefits are cut to the bone. Vacation has been slashed in half. Cutting costs (especially silly ones) is often a sucker's way to profitability. When people cut costs, they like to think they're being analytical. They often end up ignoring some indirect costs. A better model would include the expected cost in efficiency and human resources via departures and low morale.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoI think part of the issue in a lot of these circumstances is irresponsible spending to start out with. If the people in charge are spending exorbitant amounts of money on snacks to begin with, that's partially a nice perk, but it's also short-sighted: Benefits are important, but setting expectations is, too. I've worked in startups that made this mistake, and once you've been down that road a few times, you can tell when people didn't think enough before they started placing those early food and drink orders. There's a line to walk between nice perks unmaintainable/excessive spending. Of course, if you do decide you've gone too far, the article's scenario can play out, whether it's coincidental or whether the cut actually is because of financial problems (in which case it's unlikely the snacks broke the company, but they certainly don't help in that regard, and they do make it that much harder to effectively manage budget cuts without incurring even more employee ire and attrition than absolutely necessary).
- Jun8 14y agoWell, at our place can sodas cost 85c, so they're making a cool profit from us instead of it being a perk! But, I was wondering, how much soda did these guys drink? He says the cost was about $10k. Correcting for inflation (http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/ http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/) that's $10,838. Assuming 11.45 for a 24-pack (http://www2.costco.com/Browse/Product.aspx?ec=BD_563-EC27726-ProdID11338136&pos=0&whse=BD_563&topnav=bdoff&prodid=11338135&lang=en-US http://www2.costco.com/Browse/Product.aspx?ec=BD_563-EC27726...), gives us 22,704 cans of coke. Assuming this was an annual expense and all 50 people in the company drank about the same, that's 37 cans of coke per person per month! That's a lot of coke.
- breadbox 14y agoEh, not really. Think about it, when the soda is free: You drink a can in the morning, because if you're a soda drinker you're probably not a coffee drinker, so this is your morning caffeine hit. Then you'll have one at lunch, because you're eating. Sooner or later you'll get thirsty again, so you'll have one in the afternoon. Maybe two (since the afternoon is about twice as long as the morning). So, 3-4 cans of soda per day, multiplied by 20 working days in a month gives you 70 cans per month. Assume this is near the high end of a spectrum of soda-drinking behavior, and you'll get an average of around 37 per month.
- conjecTech 14y agoThat's also a dollar per day per employee, which is absolutely nothing. If the all-in cost of that employee is over $120,000/year, you are bickering over what you are paying them for 1 minute of their time per day. And I definitely known coders that put down a hell of a lot more than 2 cokes per day.
- fencepost 14y agoIt isn't healthy, but a free soda with lunch, maybe one during afternoon doldrums or early evening depending on how late you're working, multiply by roughly 20 work days / month, looks like ~40 to me.
- cowpewter 14y agoI don't know. That's less than two per day per person, assuming ~20 work days per month. Sure, it's not healthy to drink two cans of coke per day, but I can easily see it happening. One when you get in, one after lunch...
- ArbitraryCrow 14y agoForeshadowing aside, I neither expect nor care if my employer provides me with beverages. Not even coffee. If it's there, I'll probably take advantage of it from time to time, but it wouldn't actually influence my decision on where to work.
- jimmaswell 14y agoI didn't know it was a normal thing for companies to just give out free food/soda to employees like this, moreso to complain about not having them. How common is this?
- gdulli 14y agoAre you asking how common the free food/soda is, or the feeling of entitlement to it? The former exists where there's competition for employees. The latter is a pre-existing but latent condition that comes out in proportion to the presence of the former. Personally, I've never forgotten that I'm lucky to have "extra" benefits, and I've never started believing I'm owed them.
- jimmaswell 14y agoI guess I haven't thought about competition for employees - I've only tended to think of the situation as employees competing for jobs. Does competition for employees only tend to happen in places like SF?
- gdulli 14y agoIt's also this way in Cambridge, MA. And probably other places where there's more demand for highly-skilled developers than there are candidates. Maybe in smaller cities that are trying to bootstrap a startup scene.
- qu4z-2 13y agoChristchurch, New Zealand here. If you're a good programmer, there'll be competition for you here.
- creatiwit 14y agoThis reminds of the scene at the biggest virtualization companies and their great debacle of 2008. A certain VP was hired from one of the old order companies and the first order of business was cutting free dinners. Never mind the dinners were for folks that stayed late working crazy hours to finish the release. Next to go was the stuff in the kitchens. All said done there was a huge revolt, the VP went back to the company he came from. But the damage was already done, months later the CEO gets fired and that was the end of one of the best work cultures in the Bay. The exodus had already started. At the end of day these are tiny costs when compared to the overall productivity of engineers. Yes, there are folks who will misuse it but those are a tiny fraction and cannot outweigh the positive effects. It shows that a company cares for it employees and is willing to go the extra mile.
- zeidrich 14y agoI think that a lot of times these sorts of things come down to peoples inability to rationalize large numbers. It reminds me of a story posted a while ago about the City of Boston moving from Microsoft products to Google Cloud products. One of the prime motivators of this move was claimed to be cost. Boston would save $280,000 in the move. $280,000 seems like a lot of money, a quarter million dollars. However, the story also quoted that there were 20,000 employees using the software. This means that the city would actually be saving $14 per year per employee, or a little more than a dollar per month. If the employee spent more than a minute or two of paid time learning to use the new system, a year's worth of savings would be eliminated. Now, it's possible that the city would see efficiency improvements by using google apps, but that wasn't the reason claimed for the move. The reason claimed was that the switch would cost only $800,000 but save $280,000 per year. Within 3 years they would recover those costs and realize some savings. When a new CFO comes in and sees that your 100 employees consume $50,000 worth of soda in a year, it looks like an easy place to recover a nice chunk of change. However, in reality the difference is a couple of dollars a day per employee. If those employees now end up going across the street to the coffee shop instead of getting free soda in the office you've just wiped out any gains. The larger the organization gets, the bigger this feels. 1 employee spending $500/year on soda is not worth considering. 10 employees spending $5,000 per year on soda isn't really a big deal. 100 employees spending $50,000 on soda raises some eyebrows. 2,000 employees spending $1,000,000 on soda means it's going to get cut and someone's going to get a sweet bonus for cutting it.
- Ensorceled 14y agoEvery one of these Windows/Office -> Linux/Cloud/Google analysis I've looked at included staff retraining and retrofitting costs. Not saying they aren't rosy estimates, but CIO's tend not to be complete idiots.
- zeidrich 14y agoThe costs of retraining and retrofitting was mentioned and bundled in at $800,000. My point wasn't that they didn't do their calculations, nor do I mean to show bias towards MS or Google. My point was that the amount of savings they would realize ($280,000 per year) was so marginal when the number of affected employees were taken into account. If I came up to you and said "I can give you a piece of software that will save you $1.17 per month, but I will have to sell it to you for $40", would that be a good deal? Why is it that when you multiply those numbers by 20,000 that it all of a sudden becomes a good deal? Especially when you can't be 100% certain that your cost projections are perfectly accurate, being a bit too optimistic can wipe out any hope of any savings. My point was just that because the numbers are big they look really important. But when you look at them spread across the workforce it looks different. Saving $280,000/year after 3 years is just fine. Saving $14/year after 3 years is fine too. One looks far more important than the other. If the news story said that it would save them $1.17 per user per month after 34 months, would it have the same impact? If a company says they spend 2 million dollars a year on free soda for staff, that sounds excessive. If they spend 2 million dollars per year on soda but they say that they spend 45 cents per day on average on soda per employee, does that have the same impact? In the former, you don't have any point of reference 2 million dollars is a lot of money. In the latter you immediately consider things like how much the employee's wage is, how much electricity they use, how much water they use washing their hands after using the toilet. If you have someone using a Xerox copier that charges a few cents per copied page, now their copier usage is majorly competing with the cost of soda. In the grand scheme of things though, a couple of dollars per day per employee, for professionals, can be pretty much ignored. But if you think of it instead of $1,000,000 per year, it's harder to ignore, even though it's the same thing.
- varunkumarm 14y agoIsn't this posted already at HN. Interesting to see so much discussion on a repost. Link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1007750
- rachelbythebay 14y agoInteresting that this was written in 2009. In 2009, that's when I snapped a picture in Charlie's which said "Googlers: badging today will allocate funds for your meal tomorrow": http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/10/17/badging/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2011/10/17/badging/ - they added ProxCard readers hooked to laptops in every cafe. "Badging in" would make it play the PING! noise from Gattaca (or a vuvuzela, but that's another story). The food was still "free" [1] but things had definitely changed at high levels. This was just a small part of it. It's taken some time for the change to become evident on the outside world. I wonder if this post is related to the things I was seeing at the time. [1] As seen on HN: http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/01/21/notfree/ http://rachelbythebay.com/w/2012/01/21/notfree/
- pasbesoin 14y agoI've been through this more than once. Adding my experience to the data points of anecdote -- from working outside the Valley and in larger, more "traditional" corporations (albeit ones where sodas and at times meals were made free as perks -- either an historical legacy or a management practice gleaned from magazines and consultants). When the soda stops being free (or meals, if you're so lucky, etc.), it's time to go. If don't simply want to take this external advice, listen for yourself to the explanations that are given when this is done. After absorbing a bit of that language and convolution and misdirection, if you don't want to go on your on accord and the basis of direct experience... well, some people do do all right. But, from my perspective, they don't tend to be people I enjoy.
- Imagenuity 14y agoTell the executives they're wasting money on free parking. From now on., all executives will be charged $20 a month (or $1 a day) for parking. The primo parking spaces will be $50 a month. Surely that is reasonable! And watch the executives go into an uproar. This might help them understand in a way they can relate to.
- pvdm 14y agoI left Cisco after the free soda's went away.
- Ensorceled 14y agoI once worked at a startup where the company gave an "across the board" 10% raise to the engineering team in a way that caused 3 key people to leave. Essentially in a company meeting that reviews were being delayed for 3 months because of how crazy things were but there was an across the board raise of 10% to make us competitive. The catch, the raises took effect immediately but would not be paid until reviews were done, then everybody would get a lump sum catch up payment along with any increases from the raise. The meeting dissolved into a huge mess where engineers kept asking "Why not give us the 10% raise now" and the VP Engineering got increasingly irate at the ingratitude without ever adequately explaining the delay. I went after the meeting and asked the CFO what the hell was going on. Basically, changing all of payroll was a pain in the ass, had a fee of $25 per headcount, and it was going to take a week for our overworked accounting department to accomplish. So they didn't want to take the hit in accounting twice in such a short period of time. I went back and explained it to my team and things were all better. Reasonable, and if the VP had just said that, all the engineers would have nodded and said "Good thinking!" but the damage had been done. 2 key developers resigned that same day and one two days later. There are people in this industry who can send emails to their network and get a new, good job in the space of an afternoon. Don't do stupid crap to them.
- bdunbar 14y agoWhere I work people still talk about 'the year they stopped giving away turkeys at Thanksgiving'. That was in 1986.
- Gravityloss 14y agoBut why does anyone bother counting such small money? Hell, we don't even use one or two cent coins in this country at all. The time and effort saved is much more than the nitpicking about a cent here or there.
- astangl 14y agoOne place I worked went in a few short years from having free fancy coffees, etc. (for developers in their skunkworks office) to departmental secretary sending out an email complaining about the rate of consumption of cheap ballpoint pens from the supply closet. (A quick check online confirmed that if the consumption was reduced to zero, it would save less than $20/yr -- hardly worth the alienation and bitterness it caused.) At that company I coined a rule that once companies start to focus heavily on "branding", it's time to bail.
- marshray 14y agoI have a simple technical solution to this problem: 1. Charge employees by volume for sodas. 2. Reimburse them for their urine.
- jpatokal 13y agoUnintended consequence of your technical solution: employees start chugging gallons of water. (But yes, I LOL'd.)
- jaimebuelta 14y agoThere is a classic quote by Machiavelli: "People should either be caressed or crushed. If you do them minor damage they will get their revenge." There is something in "small details" that make us just to feel humiliated. The kind of thing that is not serious enough to understand is needed "well, I get the company is in bad shape", but it feels like a personal offense "What?? I just got a word from my manager because I left yesterday 10 minutes earlier, when we have 'flexible hours'? F*ck you!" When I think about the times I've been most upset with my workplace, it's always for those stupid details. They fell like personal humiliations. And personal problems are way worse than profesional ones...
- Rickasaurus 13y agoSolution: Soda fountains instead of cans. Lets seem the take that thing home!
- rusbra 13y agoI used to work at a small company / startup... once we got rid of the snacks everyone started jumping ship... how true this is... how true.
- rusbra 13y agoI used to work at a small company / startup... once we got rid of the snacks everyone started jumping ship... how true this is... how true.