9 ms·
Meta announces nuclear energy projects
- happyPersonR 10mo agoThese companies abandon software? Does anyone really think this is going to end well?
- HPsquared 10mo agoAre there regulations in the US that you need to fund decommissioning up-front? I think that's the case in the UK at least.
- aCoreyJ 10mo agoDon't think so but after seeing electricity prices rise and even double in areas by giant data centers many areas are requiring them to provide their own power
- arjie 10mo agoYeah, there's a lot of stuff for nuclear. I wrote to the government to get them to remove 10 CFR Part 20 Subpart E financial requirements but obviously that hasn't happened. You can start from there and branch out.
- vvpan 10mo agoAll that energy will surely translate into quality of life for the rest of us.
- margalabargala 10mo agoIt likely will. Not immediately but in a decade or two. Infrastructure investment is a good thing, and almost always strictly better than not having it.
- s1mplicissimus 10mo agoIt's not a good thing when said infrastructure produces ridiculously dangerous waste & fallout risk though.
- xvector 10mo ago"Fallout risk" and "dangerous waste risk" are such non-issues that have been so absurdly elevated in the public perception that the fear of them has caused far more deaths than the risks themselves.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- estearum 10mo ago"Infrastructure investment" is not fungible. There's either demand for this power where they're adding it, or there's not. If there is demand, then it's created by AI. If there's not (i.e. AI bubble pops), then there's excess capacity where we don't need it.
- shimman 10mo agoI'm glad that individuals with no democratic control are allowed to declare large swaths of society to suffering because, maybe, in the future things might get better. FWIW, it took nearly 150 years for commoners to benefit from the industrial revolution. The idea that I must suffer and my children must suffer and their children must suffer so some future plutocrat can get a fatter nut is pathetic.
- cpursley 10mo agoI mean, we could just give up and go back into the swamps that we crawled out off millions of years ago. But I'd rather have more clean power come online. Energy is EVERYTHING.
- taurath 10mo agoCan you or anyone else please take us through this likely outcome?
- jamescrowley 10mo agoHow exactly? Meta isn’t doing this out of generosity to society. They’ll be consuming this and vastly more energy to ultimately increase their own profits?
- lpcvoid 10mo agoThey were being sarcastic.
- aappleby 10mo agoWhile I'm sure that the vast majority of this energy is going straight to AI server farms, I'm also hopeful that this will renew efforts to switch to sustainable energy sources.
- add-sub-mul-div 10mo agoI'm sure some people were hopeful that the proliferation of fast food would lead to more exercise and healthy eating to balance it out.
- epistasis 10mo agoThe entire world is switching to sustainable energy at a tremendous rate because they are the cheapest source of electricity, and storage is economical on every grid's peak price to low price swing that I have seen. In places like Pakistan solar is taking over because the grid made really poor investments in very expensive fossil fuels. In Africa, a panel and a battery is cheaper to run than a generator, which is life changing. As that scales up it will revolutionize entire economies. In the US, the vast majority of new generation is renewables, matched with a ton of storage. There's some gas too, but it will be uneconomical to run these gas plants before their end of life: https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/08/21/eia-projects-record-64-gw-us-power-capacity-buildout-in-2025/ https://www.pv-magazine.com/2025/08/21/eia-projects-record-6... The biggest impediment to cheap sustainable electricity is political and basic ignorance of the voting public that allows utilities to continue installing familiar, but more expensive fossil generation.
- Moldoteck 10mo agowhat has home solar to do with country's grid and industrial needs? No country has a VRE+BESS solution to fully sustain itself. South Australia might get close having extremely nice weather patterns but even they will periodically import from fossils neighbors. Nuclear was dirt cheap in US but it didn't help to expand it. and now it's not that cheap since supply chain is gone
- epistasis 10mo ago
- tonetegeatinst 10mo agoRemember prior to the AI boomb electrical bills were still high. Now we see more demand and the building of the grid to meet that demand....yet the high cost is still remaining the same.
- seydor 10mo agoHow much increase in consumption is due to AI ?
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- throwup238 10mo agoMost of the cost of residential electricity is the distribution network, not generation. Supply/demand dynamics only really come into play during extreme scenarios like the Texas winter outage a few years ago.
- sergiotapia 10mo agoI've begun to realize that the prices of everything seem artificially set to lock us into some form of farming. Carefully balanced. Look for home prices, doesn't matter where in the US it's always like $350-$400k. Why?
- lacunary 10mo agoWhy do you think home prices are always in that price range? That's not been my observation.
- aaronbrethorst 10mo agoStares in Seattle home market.
- DrewADesign 10mo agoThe price isn’t the same, it’s more expensive, and it’s going to get worse before it gets better. This particular project is slated to take a decade — the last nuclear reactor that the US built was also slated to take a decade. It just opened in 2024, and was approved for construction in 2009. This is a long-view solution to a right-now problem. We should have been keeping up with this infrastructure stuff all along… but I’m really not convinced all of these companies are going to be using this shit in 5 years, anyway.
- falloutx 10mo agoTo do what Grok has been doing?
- lostlogin 10mo agoYikes.
- brcmthrowaway 10mo agoDo any of their vendors have existing products or is this a Boom Aerospace situation?
- credit_guy 10mo agoYes. Vistra is the largest power generator in the US [1]. Most of the deal that Meta announced is with Vistra, and the power will come from some existing facilities. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vistra_Corp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vistra_Corp.
- brcmthrowaway 10mo agoHow does Vistra compare to PG$E?
- usrnm 10mo agoI'm glad somebody is doing it, even if it's Meta. The world really needs more energy and nuclear is a great option
- sergiotapia 10mo agohell yeah!
- dakiol 10mo ago[flagged]
- tombert 10mo agoNot the OP, but I think the argument is that even if they're doing it for the wrong reasons, it might still end up being a good thing.
- dakiol 10mo agoWhat kind of logic is that? It reminds me some people I know that vote to extreme-right parties because "well, we know that the regular parties are not gonna change anything. These new guys may do something new. Who knows, let's vote them and find out"
- tombert 10mo agoWell, no, I think that the claim is that having nuclear power plants is better than not having them. If they're not sucking energy off the grid (like what is happening right now), that at least will help avoid regular people like us having to pay the increased prices and indirectly subsidizing them. And nuclear energy is clean (from a climate change perspective at least), and so if they're going to keep spending huge amounts of energy AI training anyway, it's probably better to do that in a way that isn't going to keep boiling the planet. Also, if there is any kind of excess energy then it can be fed back into the grid, meaning that grid power can be fed from something relatively clean compared to something dirty (like coal). I'm not entirely sure how this relates to the party thing. I'm saying that sometimes something selfish in a capitalistic system can occasionally still be a net good. I didn't think that was controversial. I'm not saying we give Zuckerberg a trophy or anything.
- ck2 10mo agoif you think it's near impossible to reach a real human for a difficult customer service problem now, imagine by the end of this decade
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- philipallstar 10mo agoI also think nuclear energy is responsible for customer service.
- ck2 10mo agousually don't have to explain steps in thinking on HN what do you think the end result is for the amount of machine-learning in use once the resource barriers go away? like first the power availability limit, next cpu+memory availability? result: every human job goes away that can be turned into a survey of questions like all callcenters
- philipallstar 10mo agoIt'll either work well, and then that's what'll happen, hooray, or it won't work well, and competition will allow businesses to differentiate. Just make sure you're not voting for the people who disable competition if you're worried.
- 6r17 10mo agoLet's be honest it's one of the smartest and most useful place anyone could be investing - it's literally is whatever happens a way to contribute to mankind - even if it's just so that FB servers are off-grid ; it's still a huge win, I just hope Mark realize he has much more potential than what he is doing rn
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- idiotsecant 10mo agoThey're just purchasing power from existing nuke plants. All this is doing is making a formerly publicly available resource private. This will drive up energy prices for everyone else. These datacenters need to build their own generation. When people talk about how important it is that the US lead innovation in AI what they're really saying is how important it is for their quarterly results
- epistasis 10mo agoWell in a way they are building their own generation by paying elevated prices for nuclear to keep it running, as most nuclear will be shutting off pretty soon due to cheaper alternatives. Electricity generation is getting cheaper all the time, transmission and generation are staying the same or getting more expensive. Nuclear plants get more expensive the more of them we build, but for already paid-off nuclear reactors there's a sweet spot of cheap operations and no capital costs before maintenance climbs on the very old reactors. Meta paying for all that very expensive maintenance is not a bad deal for others, unless market structure is such that the price for entire market is set by this high marginal generation from uneconomic aged plants.
- fuzzfactor 10mo ago>Unlocking Up to 6.6 GW You could just as accurately sum it up by saying they would like to tie up nearly 6.6 GW, otherwise they wouldn't be making quite as large a deal. They wouldn't be doing it if they didn't have a financial technique to afford it, and it's still taken a while to make the commitment. What about less-well-heeled consumers who would be better served if the effect of increased demand were not in position to put upward pressure on overall rates? To the extent that new debt comes into the mix, that's just an additional burden that wasn't there before and this is a very sizable investment at this scale. So the compounding cost will have to be borne for longer than average if nothing else. Naturally some can afford it easily and others not at all.
- seydor 10mo agoNuclear energy company valuations are in the puny low ~100s of billions. But Meta can be sued for so much more ...
- epistasis 10mo agoI wish that Meta would pay for the extension of Diablo Canyon in California. They have had to jack up already sky-high electricity rates to keep it going, after deciding nearly a decade ago that it would be uneconomical to try to extend its lifetime. Meta's nuclear intention is a perfect example of how tech is willing to pay far more for energy than other customers, and how it's driving up everybody's costs because we are all paying for that increase at elevated prices. Nuclear is extremely expensive, higher than geothermal, renewables backed by storage, and natural gas. Nuclear is good for virtue signaling in some communities, but from the technological and economical perspectives, nuclear is very undesirable and unattractive. It's only social factors that keep alive the idea of new nuclear in advanced Western economies, not hard nosed analysis. Here's a new preprint from Germans showing that even for Europe, a continent with very poor solar resources for many countries, new baseload is not the most economical route: https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/fulltext/S2666-3864(25)00649-6 https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-physical-science/fulltext/...
- legitster 10mo ago> Nuclear is extremely expensive Nuclear compliance and certification is extremely expensive. The actual construction and maintenance costs are fairly trivial. The largest cost associated with a new nuclear plant are the interest payments given that a plant may need to spend 10+ years sitting idle before it can be activated.
- anonymousDan 10mo agoWhat, we should have a wild west where everyone can set up their own nuclear power station without any compliance or certification? If not then these are part of the build cost... it's like saying we shouldn't include testing as part of the cost of building software.
- estearum 10mo agoConstruction is actually very expensive and also the plant doesn't "sit idle" for 10+ years before activation.
- 10mo ago
- internet2000 10mo agoExtremely awesome. If you can't praise this in spite of however you feel about AI, or about Meta, you need to reevaluate your priors.
- hambes 10mo agosure, let's build more energy sources with finite fuel supply and negative environmental impact while there's better options available <.<
- sheikhnbake 10mo agoThis is cool, but I'm waiting for the announcements for datacenters to start establishing on-site geothermal power for baseload power supply.
- AnishLaddha 10mo agohttps://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250612778008/en/XGS-Energy-and-Meta-to-Partner-on-150-MW-Advanced-Geothermal-Project https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250612778008/en/XGS... seems like they're getting the ball rolling, will be interesting to see how this scales
- caminante 10mo agoTech scale isn't the problem. The problem is geographic. You need hot rock near the surface. It's too expensive to drill deep in most places.
- caminante 10mo agoOn-site? (Behind the meter) You'll be waiting a while as the subsurface siting is highly specific. These would be unicorn projects. Datacenters are trying to just pull geothermal electrons from same geographic grid, at best.
- kibwen 10mo agoFor reference, China installs about 1 GW of solar per day. By this time next week, they will have surpassed the output of this entire project.
- softwaredoug 10mo agoThe US, in 2024, installed ~0.13 GW of solar per day. https://seia.org/research-resources/solar-market-insight-report-2024-year-in-review/ https://seia.org/research-resources/solar-market-insight-rep... 6 GW Nuclear is either a tech company getting ahead of bad PR with a token gesture. Or its maybe? the start of something real.
- echelon 10mo agoTwo years ago we were installing 1/10th of Chinese solar today? Where are we at today? Can we catch up under this administration? Where do we compare on a nuclear basis? I know my state installed nuclear reactors recently, but I'm not aware of any other build outs. In a war game scenario, China is probably more concerned about losing access to oil and natural gas than we are. Not that we shouldn't be building this stuff quickly either.
- worik 10mo ago> Can we catch up under this administration? No. The future is Chinese, if the Chinese can maintain good governance. A big "if"
- boringg 10mo agoSolar and Nuclear energy are different energy products. China is also bringing on an insane amount of nuclear energy.
- epistasis 10mo agoChina is building a tiny amount of nuclear in comparison to their wind, solar, storage, and HVDC builds. Only something like 50-100GW over thw coming decades. The quantity being built only makes sense as a strategic hedge, not as a primary strategy.
- LePetitPrince 10mo ago[dead]
- legitster 10mo agoThe biggest barrier to nuclear energy in our country is the linear no-threshold safety model. We know the model is wrong, opens up operators to infinite liability, and since adopting it the nuclear industry has effectively been dead. Even just a basic common sense threshold would make nuclear more viable overnight.
- kmeisthax 10mo agoAgreed, but I don't think that dumping ALARA will fix nuclear cost. There's still plenty of stuff in a nuclear reactor hot enough that we have to worry about keeping it from being inadvertently released.
- Moldoteck 10mo agoit's one of but not biggest. Biggest is poor supply chain. Try copy rosatom first in their variety of services...
- ViewTrick1002 10mo agoAfter reading through all press releases I still haven't seen any details on any money changing hands? The previous ones from Google and Amazon at least specified that it was based on PPAs. Where all they did was bind themselves to buy X amount of power at Y cost if the company could deliver. Taking a step back I have an incredibly hard time seeing how new built nuclear power will cope with renewables fundamentally reshaping our grids. We're seeing the unraveling of the grid monopoly infront of our eyes [1] and renewables are set to completely crash all "baseload" markets. [2] Likely forcing them to become stranded assets. [1]: https://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/The-Quiet-Unraveling-of-the-Power-Grid-Monopoly.html https://oilprice.com/Energy/Energy-General/The-Quiet-Unravel... [2]: https://oilprice.com/Alternative-Energy/Renewable-Energy/What-the-Market-Gets-Wrong-about-Renewables.html https://oilprice.com/Alternative-Energy/Renewable-Energy/Wha...
- gip 10mo agoCurious how this new design addresses the biggest safety challenge of nuclear reactors (the issue that was the root cause of the Fukushima accident and an indirect cause of Chernobyl): how do we ensure that the nuclear core temperature remains controlled during exceptional events (e.g., earthquakes, structural failures) when the reactor must shut down abruptly?
- boringg 10mo agoChernobyl and Fukushima were different accidents and causes. Chernobyl was a systemic failure of the soviet system. Fukushima was a wild edge case that an earthquake and tsunami drained the coolant.
- littlecranky67 10mo agoEdge cases don't count? The truth is, all reactors ever built were considered safe at their time with whatever definition of safe. No one builds unsafe reactors. Yet they turned out not to be safe.
- ethmarks 10mo agoNothing is ever perfectly safe and a lack of perfect absolute safety is not a valid objection. All sources of power have associated risks, even renewables. Wind power has 0.04 deaths per terawatt hour and solar has 0.02 [1]. Nuclear power has 0.03 deaths per terawatt hour (safer than wind), and it's worth noting that almost all of those are from Chernobyl, which was considered unsafe even at the time (they knew about the positive void coefficient). I'm not arguing that nuclear power is perfect, mainly because it isn't. But it's not like all other sources of power are idyllic havens of safety. There are always tradeoffs. [1]: https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
- TheOtherHobbes 10mo agoThose figures seem very optimistic. Uranium miners die early, often of horrific cancers. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33232447/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33232447/ But the bottom line is that renewable costs are trending down, hard and fast, battery tech is just getting started, and development time for wind and solar is comparatively fast. Future nuke costs at this point are speculative, development time is very slow, and even if new reactors were commissioned tomorrow, by the time they came online it's very, very likely solar and wind + storage would make them uneconomic. IMO the attachment to nukes is completely irrational. There are obvious economic downsides, no obvious economic benefits - and that's just the money side.
- shmerl 10mo agoSome Shreck Power vibes.
- blondie9x 10mo agoThis is to appease the current US administration running the federal government that for some odd reasons is abhorrent to the idea of using cheap, cleaner renewable energy and battery storage to decarbonize our air and grid.
- jmyeet 10mo agoThis is a purely political move. It will take a decade or longer if ever to ever get power from this. And yes it says "as early as 2032" but we know how that goes. Why nuclear? Because it's cleaner than fossil fuelds but appeases the administration because it isn't wind or solar, which would immediately solve any power generation problems. You might be tempted to say, since this always comes up, "what about base load?" FFirst, batteries can solve that problem. Second, you use a mix of power and when the Sun isn't out (ie night) is when power is cheaper from other sources. Third, data centers don't really need base power at all. You just run the DC when you have power and don't when you don't. There's precedent for this. Google has a DC in Scandanavia that they shut down a few days a year when it gets too hot, otherwise it's just cooled by ocean water. What I find most funny about all this is that all these big tech companies are kowtowing to the state in the exact same way they accuse Chinese companies of doing.
- ttkari 10mo ago> Google has a DC in Scandanavia that they shut down a few days a year when it gets too hot, otherwise it's just cooled by ocean water. They do? Which facility is this? I'm quite surprised to hear this would happen, in Scandinavia of all places.
- Moldoteck 10mo agowind and solar need firming. Currently firming capacity in US is getting scarce. It can be fixed a bit with better transmission but otherwise you need to expand it. China is expanding firm power with coal, gas and nuclear. Germany will expand gas. Bess will not solve the firming problem. And no, if you build a multibillion datacenter you want to run it around the clock as much as possible. But yes, some datacenters don't have such requirements, but here we are talking about meta
- saalweachter 10mo agoI am pro-nuclear power, but I miss the days when companies would, you know, return their profits to investors, so those investors could then invest in other companies doing different things, instead of all corporations tending towards generic everything-investment vehicles.
- reducesuffering 10mo agoThis is partly due to tax policy. Investors don't want this. Distributing dividends is less efficient capital distribution because those capital gains are immediately taxed rather than be deferred into a higher share price with no tax drag.
- HDThoreaun 10mo agoThis is why every tech company does buybacks(other than meta which started a dividend when Mark got sick of high interest rates on his debt, they still mainly do buybacks though)
- saalweachter 10mo agoOh no, capital would be taxed! Don't threaten me with a good time.
- cdolan 10mo agoMeta (seemingly) bought the local race track in Beaver PA for a large data center. We were sad to see a world class racing facility go away as it finally started to hit its stride. But the offer was too hard for ownership to pass up
- zozbot234 10mo agoRacetrack memory is an emerging alternative that might obviate the current DRAM shortage especially for datacenter use, so in a way this makes a whole lot of sense.
- adastra22 10mo agoIs that word salad?
- logicchains 10mo agoIt's called a "pun", albeit maybe not a very good one.
- formerly_proven 10mo agoIsn’t that just quantum bubble memory?
- hnrodey 10mo agoGood bot.
- shepherdjerred 10mo agohttps://www.ibm.com/history/racetrack-memory https://www.ibm.com/history/racetrack-memory
- tolerance 10mo agoI won’t take Meta’s new ambitions serious unless Zuckerberg does something like have a “fireside chat” next to Ezra Klein moderated by Kara Swisher where he awkwardly spams the word “abundance” while staring Klein square in the brow. And then buys Vox Media.
- jppope 10mo agoThis may just be me... but is anyone else in their head saying: "whats the catch?" ~~Meta~~ Facebook has made their money by de-stabilizing people's emotional state to keep them engaged and buying stuff via ads. I'm having a tough time connecting the dots between that and nuclear power.
- giancarlostoro 10mo agoSo they can power all the AI data centers.
- morcus 10mo ago"AI" is in the title. It's to power their data centers.
- jppope 10mo agoI get that and scanned the article. they are currently, and have been, working on "AI" for a bit, but strategically they aren't positioned to provide a service offering right now. Even if they are going all in and they got regulatory love, it would make way more sense to go after an energy source/provider that could provide it on a faster timeframe. they'll get their energy in what? 7-10 years?
- lostlogin 10mo agoIn terms of $ per unit of energy, would shutting down Meta give best bang for buck? Power prices would presumably fall.
- chiengineer 10mo agoIf they want this to work trump and co gotta be out asap Theyll just steal it
- preommr 10mo agoSo is the metaverse completely dead and over with?
- dj_gitmo 10mo agoOkla really seems like a meme stock. Their original design was rejected by the NRC, so they are very far from ever breaking ground. I don’t understand why their valuation is so high. Why not just take all this money and build an existing, approved design?
- fakedang 10mo agoThe expectation is that their close-to-Trump investors will push for the dismantling of the NRC, which is something Republicans wholly support, which will of course make their rejection moot.
- boringg 10mo agoMaybe but the underlying tech still needs to perform which, as i understand it from public docs, has not. No amount of clear runway will make up for an airplane not being able to take flight.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- SilverElfin 10mo agoThe NRC is now mostly composed of Trump appointees. They’ve been quietly doing that. His most recent appointee was just made chair. Expect permits for friends of the Trump family and heavy regulation for competitors. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/policy/energy-and-environment/4412927/trump-new-chair-nuclear-safety-agency-ho-nieh-pivotal-period-change/ https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/policy/energy-and-environ...
- pseudalopex 10mo agoDOGE told regulator to ‘rubber stamp’ nuclear[1] [1] https://www.eenews.net/articles/doge-told-regulator-to-rubber-stamp-nuclear/ https://www.eenews.net/articles/doge-told-regulator-to-rubbe...
- 10mo ago
- losvedir 10mo agoI'm kind of surprised there's so many nuclear power companies. I remember Google signed a deal a year or so ago [0] with a different one (Kairos). I wonder why they're not in this deal? Is it all connections and funny money? Or do any of these have real shots at making something useful? I was thinking how the dotcom bust left a lot of dark fiber infrastructure which helped the internet take off after that. It would be great if the upcoming AI bust (if it happens) leaves a bunch of power generation and new nuclear tech behind. [0] https://blog.google/company-news/outreach-and-initiatives/sustainability/google-kairos-power-nuclear-energy-agreement/ https://blog.google/company-news/outreach-and-initiatives/su...
- Moldoteck 10mo agowith small companies it's like with startups - some might fail so maybe it's better to have more players. I still think this is strange - if they wanted nuclear - could have approached GE for some BWRX of ABWR or W-house & KHNP for some nice AP1000/alike units
- Animats 10mo agoRight. Meta wants big enough plants that an AP1000 or two would be the right size. They're known to work. There are four in operation, two in the US, and another dozen or so under construction. Most of the small nuclear reactor startups hand-wave the failure modes and argue that they don't need the hulking big expensive containment building. NuScale claimed that. They wanted multiple reactors sharing the same cooling pool. If they ever had a leak, the whole set of reactors would be contaminated, even without a meltdown. If we look at the big reactor accidents so far, there's Chernobyl, with no containment building. There's Fukushima, with too small a containment unable to contain the pressure. And there's Three Mile Island, where a large, strong containment building contained a meltdown. Three Mile Island was an expensive disaster, but not hazardous outside the plant. That's the failure mode you want. We might be better off at developing better techniques for welding thick sections to make hulking big, strong containment vessels. There's been progress with robotic welding of thick sections.[1] [1] https://www.agrrobotics.com/trends-s-industry-analysis/roadmap-robotic-co2-mag-welding-thick-plate.html https://www.agrrobotics.com/trends-s-industry-analysis/roadm...
- CrzyLngPwd 10mo agoSo, the result will be rising energy bills for everyone?
- mrtracy 10mo agoHow big are the commitments here? I’m having trouble finding actual dollar amounts. Does this actually represent an infusion of money into these SMR efforts, or are these “commitments” tied to so many missable targets that it’s actually meaningless? Oklo in particular seems to be total vaporware, I can’t find a single technical picture anywhere of anything this company’s reactor is seeking to do. They seem to raise money based on a rendering of a ski lodge. A huge, concrete investment in TerraPower would be more interesting, but as a molten salt SMR which has never been built, this also looks extremely non-committal. SMRs in general seem like a dead end, we’ve heard about them for decades and they don’t seem to be any closer to making nuclear power buildouts less expensive. Everything that makes proven nuclear power plant design expensive seems to revolve around the same drivers of expense for all long-term construction: large up front capital requirements, changing regulations, failure to predict setbacks, and pervasive lawsuits. SMRs purport to tackle a couple of these (shorter-term builds, fewer setbacks), at the cost of considerable efficiency, but so far this seems like an inferior alternative to “just get better at building proven nuclear plant designs”.
- colechristensen 10mo agoThe thing which can make nuclear cheap is building a large number of the same plant design.
- dalyons 10mo agoCheap-er, not cheap. They’re still fundamentally massive complicated constructions. They will never be as amenable to mass production cost reductions as things like solar and battery
- colechristensen 10mo ago>Cheap-er, not cheap. Can we please not have these "slightly improved language" comments? You're arguing against something I didn't say and making a meaningless nitpick on word choice.
- qubex 10mo agoSo now we’re harnessing a the dicy and capital intensive power of the atom to create the illusion of speaking to people because we can no longer strike up a conversation with a stranger on the street. Cool, cool. Personally I’m going to stick to real people with no divergent neutron chain-reactions involved.
- IceHegel 10mo agoI despise Facebook and all that it stands for, but if the surplus value that it has extracted from humanity over the last two decades is reinvested intelligently into nuclear energy, I'm actually okay with it. Despite the hype that you see on Twitter, the hard tech startup scene is actually incapable of large-scale engineering coordination on the level needed for a nuclear power plant, or even a gas turbine. If any innovation on fission reactors is going to be successfully commercialized, we will need to see billions of dollars of investment over medium to long time horizons. Of course, the millstone around the neck of nuclear power is that it's a dual-use technology. There's probably a lot more behind the scenes that's been done to stifle the industry effectively for non-proliferation reasons, but masquerading as cost, regulatory problems, environmental concerns, etc.
- pessimizer 10mo agoMonopolies are insane. Why is myspace working on nuclear power?
- aucisson_masque 10mo agoThat’s something that is possible only in the USA, for the best and the worst. I don’t know any other country that would allow a truly private company to mess around with nuclear reactor.
- nephihaha 10mo agoThe UK would quite happily.
- riffraff 10mo agoI remember when terrapower was supposed to build a kind of reactor which would use depleted/unenriched uranium which was basically a hole in the ground slowly burning up, but now it seems they're doing a molten sodium "classic" reactor, is that the same thing and I am confused, or did they change their strategy?
- pyrale 10mo agoNuclear power from the company that moves fast and breaks things?
- zelphirkalt 10mo agoI would be very skeptical about Meta on top of running any reactor. Move fast and break things doesn't work out well in that area of business. Why don't they invest money into more renewables instead, to power their data centers? That seems a safer bet and choice.
- the_gipsy 10mo agoAre all these techbros drunk with power? The other day it was cloudflare guy trying to play international politics, now Zuck wants to get into nuclear.
- classified 10mo agoIf you're ruining the climate with your AI data centers, you really should bring your own nuclear reactor.