11 ms·
I used to pay for YouTube premium. I stopped doing that, uninstalled the apps, and now use it through the browser with adblockers. (Yes, on my phone and iPad.)
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
I used to pay for YouTube premium. I stopped doing that, uninstalled the apps, and now use it through the browser with adblockers. (Yes, on my phone and iPad.)
It works so well I’ve gotten at least half a dozen neighbours to do the same. If you haven’t tried it, it’s a definitive step up in UX.
- danpalmer 1y agoI do pay for YouTube Premium, I see no ads, and everything works pretty conveniently. What's your point, that with a bit of extra effort you can pirate content?
- ahartmetz 1y agoIt's not piracy.
- tcfhgj 1y agoBlocking ads is hardly "pirating" content
- crazygringo 1y agoI don't really see what the difference is. They're not getting the payment for the video either way. Morally I don't see how they aren't equivalent. I'm not going to stand on a high horse saying you shouldn't do either, but I don't really see how you can pretend one is less harmful to creators than the other, in terms of the basic principles involved.
- akersten 1y ago> the payment for the video either way. "the payment for the video" as if it's a given that my ad impression is required for me to watch some video that they made available to me on their website for free. Morally, YouTube shows the most heinous and scummy ads 24/7 on their platform and fails to take them down when reported. Gambling, AI sex games, "cure what doctors miss" ads for human use of Ivermectin - it's your moral duty to block them.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Nextgrid 1y agoPiracy involves obtaining media content for free for which you should normally pay for, as a result of someone sharing the media meant for their own personal use to the general public. YouTube does not ask for payment, it sends the video data you want alongside some bullshit you’ll ignore and waste precious human time doing so. Ad blocking just involves offloading the ignoring to the computer, as it should, since computers are meant to automate menial tasks.
- renewiltord 1y agoI've tried to explain this to people repeatedly and they don't get it. They're always like "oh no the AI scraper is slamming my website it's ruining everything". Um, maybe configure your web browser to not send me data if you don't want me 'scraping' your website. It's literally your server's choice to send me data. I'm just asking from a few IPs. If you want to send data to all of them that's your server's choice. But I think people don't get the fact that they can just request payment or only send to authenticated users from authorized IPs and so on. Instead they want to send to all IPs without payment but then get upset when I use a bunch of IPs without paying. Weird. I'm trying to read a bunch of stuff. The entire point of a computer is to make that easy. I'm not going to repetitively click through a bunch of links when a bot can do that way faster.
- gusgus01 1y agoAnd what is the surefire way to stop AI scrapers from accessing your website? If there is no way, how can this be an acceptable ask? It already sounds like you're using several IPs to access sites, which seems like a work around to someone somewhere trying to limit the use of one IP (or just lack of desire to host and distribute the data yourself to your various hosts). Just because you can do something doesn't mean everyone must accept and like that you are doing that thing.
- renewiltord 1y agoThe answer is right there: use authentication with cost per load, or an IP whitelist. GP is absolutely right. If your server is just going to send me traffic when I ask I’m just going to ask and do what I want with the response. Your server will respond fine if I click through with different IPs and it’s just a menial task to have this distribution of requests to IPs, which is what we made computers for. Yeah, you’re right of course that no one has to like the “piracy” or “scraping” or whatever other name you’re giving to a completely normal request-response interaction between machines. They can complain. And I can say they’re silly for complaining. No one has to like anything. Heck you could hate ice cream.
- danpalmer 1y agoTo be clear, this is not a value judgement. I pirate content sometimes, and I use adblockers, but ad blocking is definitely piracy – you're circumventing the method of paying for content. I realise that online ads have other implications such as tracking that, say, a blu-ray rip downloaded from a torrent doesn't have, but the reason for piracy doesn't change the fact that it is.
- komali2 1y ago> but ad blocking is definitely piracy This is a huge escalation of an already over-stuffed term. Equating piracy to theft was bad enough, now choosing to not view ads is also piracy, which is theft? I try to be chill here but no, foot down, absolutely not. Blocking ads is nothing more than determing what content comes in on the wire to the computer you own, or what content is rendered in your web browser. That's it. If that means someone isn't making money when they could be, well, too bad so sad. It's like, "if you walk past a Nike store without pausing to hear the sales pitch, you are stealing from Nike." Capitalist hellscape.
- HDThoreaun 1y ago[flagged]
- Nextgrid 1y agoI don’t make a deal when I visit a website, and especially not when I have to visit it because it became the de-facto standard when sharing video content. I just get my computer to ask for some bytes and the server happily sends them to me. If the server happened to send me some garbage in addition, I am free to make my computer ignore it.
- JAlexoid 1y ago[flagged]
- 1y ago
- tonyhart7 1y agoits pirating content in a way that you dont generate revenue for youtuber that expect from ads
- akersten 1y agoI'm sure that trillion-dollar analytics empire is worth something even without my eyeballs consuming some shitty pre-roll.
- JAlexoid 1y agoMost of the ad revenue actually goes to the people uploading content. But sure... they're all clearly are "trillion-dollar analytics empire"
- archargelod 1y agoMost content creators have links to support them with donation or patreon. Once a year choose 3 small youtubers (larger ones are already multi-millioners, they don't need your help) and drop them $5 each. Now you just did 1000% of what they could get from you watching ads.
- chrneu 1y agowhat's insane, even $1 is more than they'll get from you watching every single one of their videos. The issue is processing fees on that payment, so might as well give em a bit more. It's wild how low the payout on ads is. Seriously, just flip people $1 every once in a while and it's more support than ads. It's so stupid how people get all morally superior when they figure out that someone block ads.
- tonyhart7 1y ago"what's insane, even $1 is more than they'll get from you watching every single one of their videos." how can you confidence with being so wrong btw ???? Ads bringing more money than donation ever would be
- 1y ago
- thaumasiotes 1y agoYou wouldn't not download a virus.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mattacular 1y agoI pay for YouTube Premium too (probably not much longer) but can only 'comfortably' use the site through a series of increasingly hacky extensions for Firefox. On non-web apps, there is no recourse from the UI enshittification. The general theme is the same as the article: less real estate dedicated to actual videos you might want to watch. There were two rows of completely useless garbage that I had to add to my uBlock Origin filter just now: one for Shorts (which I have blocked in the past) and a new one for some sort of Youtube Games thing (?) that looked like the worst AI generated slop you'd never want to play. If this is the premium experience then I don't want it.
- zahlman 1y ago> The general theme is the same as the article: less real estate dedicated to actual videos you might want to watch. There were two rows of completely useless garbage that I had to add to my uBlock Origin filter just now: one for Shorts (which I have blocked in the past) and a new one for some sort of Youtube Games thing (?) that looked like the worst AI generated slop you'd never want to play. This is the same stuff you get without buying Premium. So I guess they figure you're only paying to dodge the ads. Which seems, to me, like a lot of money compared to (ad cost * number of ads you would see).
- makeitdouble 1y agoYou still get the autogenerated dubs by default, the comments moved to end of the earth, and many other stuff (shorts etc.) people get pissed about. At this point ads are just one of the annoyances amoung so many others.
- polotics 1y agoThe massive overlays of what-to-watch-next hiding most of the video much too early, ie. before the very end, of the video you were trying to watch until the end but now just ragequit and downloaded instead... are very ugly
- jonas21 1y agoThose are there because the content creator you’re watching decided to put them there. It’s entirely up to them whether they show up and when they show up.
- opello 1y agoAnd they can be hidden, so it's not exactly entirely up to them, nor should it be. If they wanted them in the video content they could put them there.
- polotics 1y agohow can they be hidden?
- opello 1y agoMost easily using an add-on like Enhancer for YouTube[1], which has been hidden in addons.mozilla.org[2] but is still available on the author's site. But the player is HTML so writing element hiding rules (like `youtube.com##.ytp-ce-element`) is the easiest, which I figure out the relevant element using the Developer Tools Inspector tool, but the uBlock Origin Element Picker tries to make that easier. In this case the .ytp-ce-element-shadow is chosen first in the uBlock picker and then you can pick the element class I mentioned first, but it's nicer to have fewer rules to effect the desired outcome. [1] https://www.mrfdev.com/enhancer-for-youtube https://www.mrfdev.com/enhancer-for-youtube [2] https://www.mrfdev.com/contact https://www.mrfdev.com/contact
- chrneu 1y agoFor me, and many people, advertising is a mental health issue. I don't enjoy those ads, they are very disturbing and jarring. It causes me anxiety and I don't like the things that those ads normalize. I don't think most people, especially americans, realize how far off the rails our society is in terms of our normalization of insane shit. So, for health reasons, I block nearly all advertisements. It is a HUGE mental health win. There is a ton of research behind this, as well. I'm not going to pay extra money to disable a health concern. I'll block ads instead. I should not have to PAY MORE for a product that doesn't damage my health. I will always happily directly support content creators. I will not watch ads.
- cindyllm 1y ago[dead]
- timcobb 1y agoYou're responding to a comment that says they pay and don't see ads
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- andrewinardeer 1y ago> I should not have to PAY MORE for a product that doesn't damage my health. Is this the same way of saying your mental health is important to you but you're not prepared to pay a service money to protect said mental health and support creators you like?
- DocTomoe 1y ago> I'm not going to pay extra money to disable a health concern. Honest question: Why? You do pay for toothpaste, right? If you have a gym membership, you pay extra for the convenience not to do cardio in the woods (which is great in late May, much less so in late November). You tend to pay more for nutritious food as compared to things you get at a fast food joint. What makes a health concern related to $genericOnlineService different?
- brikym 1y agoAs a premium user I'd like to block shorts.
- thomassmith65 1y agoIf it weren't for piracy, there would be nothing on Youtube except highschool dropouts lobbing accusations at each other, and AI-generated slop.
- snicky 1y agoJust here to say thank you to everyone arguing/explaining why ad blockers are not piracy using interesting arguments better than my own. You will never walk alone.
- Brian_K_White 1y agoI also pay for premium, and have for at least 15 years since it was called Red, and the experience is complete garbage. If you turn off history, you get zero videos on your home screen. This is not because the history is needed to generate the suggestions, because the blank home only started a few years ago. I used to never subscribe to any channels, I just got reasonable feed of suggestions based off of whatever I happened to search for explicitly or if I got there by clicking a link, or by what I chose to click on even if the list starts out totally random, except of course it never was totally random because they still have ip address and other fingerprnting signals. After they blaked out the home screen and started showing the "you're not logged in, go here to fix this error", I subscribed to a bunch of channels to provide data for generating a feed. They still don't provide any. You can take extra clicks (which is agonizing on the Roku since it just doesn't react well and misses button presses all the time) to get to the subscriptions page, which will show recent uploads exactly from those channels and no others. I also still get several other forms of ads in the form of the embedded/native ads and the irrelevant suggestions that come from youtube's interests instead of my own, like shorts. I also still get ads simply because I don't get to use my own account all the time. When you watch youtube anywhere but your own laptop by yourself, you are at the whims of someone else's account and some other platforms app limitations. And even on your own machine, I absolutely resent having to tie my viewing history to my identity and have someone else log all of that. So there is reason to intentionally use no account even if you otherwise have no problem paying to support not only the content producers but even the delivery system. Why can't I disable shorts? There is no amount I can pay to hide all shorts, but I can have it for free i=on a pc with a tampermonkey or ublock script. But that only helps on a pc. I watch mostly on a TV and I have no ability to hack the roku app. Maybe if I switch to a google tv I could use newpipe or something. Paying for premium does not make youtube good. It does not resolve much of anything. It is not remotely the touche this smarmy comment attempts to suggest. Paying for premium takes youtube from being like pulling out 10 of your fingernails to only pulling out 8 of your fingernails. That 2of10 fingernals relief and for the sake of the creators, that's the only reason I still pay for premium.
- nullc 1y agoThey keep doing it because you keep paying them. Use the money you save to buy a media pc that can block shorts to use to watch youtube on the tv.
- DocTomoe 1y agoI do pay for YouTube Premium - and I still get ads when someone has YT Videos embedded on their website. YouTube knows who I am, the cookies are set, there is no reason to give me ads. It is not yet painful enough for me to invest time and energy to research less convenient ways of UX improvement. Not ... yet.
- array_key_first 1y agoThe point is that the pirated experience is both easier to access and more convenient. If I'm paying, I expect the best possible experience, and you just don't get that. It's not just YouTube, many streaming services are objectively inferior to pirating.
- joquarky 1y agoIf I go to the bathroom during an ad break, am I "pirating" the content?
- nojs 1y agoI also like that there’s no ads in premium. Speaking of premium things, I also really like Brilliant for learning things quickly and Surfshark VPN because it protects my privacy when I’m on the go.
- brcmthrowaway 1y agoWhat is a set and forget adblocker for the Apple ecosystem?
- Nextgrid 1y agoAdGuard Pro.
- nozzlegear 1y agoWipr, Adblock Pro, Ghostery or uBlock Origin Lite. I've used all four and they perform about as well as you need them to for an adblocker. I'm currently using uBlock.
- koakuma-chan 1y agoYouTube hasn't been working for me past two weeks with uBlock Origin. Video doesn't play.
- misiek08 1y agoMake sure to update and restart Firefox.
- da02 1y agoHave you tried "uBlock Origin Lite"? It is by the same author, Raymond Hill (gorhill). It has been working fine. I use "optimal" level for the filtering mode. (Note: I use Chromium on Linux)
- koakuma-chan 1y agoI'm gonna try, thanks.
- koakuma-chan 1y agoOh shit https://itc.ua/en/news/ublock-origin-lite-ad-blocker-has-been-removed-from-the-firefox-store-now-the-extension-is-only-available-on-github/ https://itc.ua/en/news/ublock-origin-lite-ad-blocker-has-bee...
- fn-mote 1y agoParent should include text not just a link. UBlock Origin Lite pulled from the Firefox extensions after being flagged for policy violation, now only available from GitHub.
- koakuma-chan 1y ago"The Firefox version of uBO Lite will cease to exist, I am dropping support because of the added burden of dealing with AMO nonsensical and hostile review process. " https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/issues/197#issuecomment-2377395301 https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/issues/197#issueco...
- adrianpike 1y agoWhich adblocker are you currently using? The arms race is getting pretty tiring...
- Nextgrid 1y agoEven on Safari with Apple’s braindead “content blocker” API, AdGuard manages to successfully block YouTube ads.
- nozzlegear 1y agoNot so braindead after all
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Which adblocker are you currently using? I’m really shooting myself in the foot right now aren’t I. 1Blocker and Wipr on mobile. Plain old Orion by Kagi on my Mac.
- AndrewKemendo 1y agoThank you very much for taking that risk I just updated to this setup
- Hnaomyiph 1y agoLike another poster mentioned, I use Orion on my iPad with ublock origin installed as an extension. It’s a really great browser, only a few bugs here and there.
- secondcoming 1y agoI use Brave 99% of the time just for Youtube.
- JoshTriplett 1y agouBlock Origin continues to work well, on both desktop and Android.
- 1y ago
- deanCommie 1y agoI mean I pay for Youtube Premium because I use Youtube Music instead of Spotify. I get a very unopinionated but effective music player that has all the music I need, and it doesn't try very hard to "upsell" itself to me unlike Spotify because to Google YouTube is the real money driver. So to me getting no YouTube ads as well is well worth it.
- JAlexoid 1y agoAnd I pay for Premium, because each premium view is more valuable to the creators than the ad supported one.
- chrneu 1y agofor what it's worth, you could divide up your youtube premium membership cost and give that to 500 creators and they would see more revenue in their pocket than your premium watches get them. Premium viewcount is grossly over valued by the people who pay for it, because they need to justify their sunk cost. I doubt most content creators even track it because the difference is minimal. We're talking a few bucks a month, tops. I remember when youtube premium first came out and YT pimped this trope super hard. Then it came to light that the difference is basically nothing because most people don't pay for premium.
- pitaj 1y agoCreators say that premium is a huge chunk of their YouTube revenue. I'm inclined to believe them over some random like you.
- iamtedd 1y agoEither: I watch ten creators. I divide $10 per month between them evenly. They each get $1 per month. Or: I pay for YouTube premium. It costs $10 per month. I watch ten creators. The $10 goes to YouTube. I make the following assumptions: * YouTube only takes a portion of that $10 * YouTube divides the remaining money evenly across the creators I watch (10) Each creator gets less than $1 per month Which gives the creators more revenue?
- ElectricalTears 1y agoRevanced is the best UX for Android, can remove a lot of things as well (like shorts).
- NooneAtAll3 1y agoI never managed to install it it complains about youtube app being separated into parts or smth like that
- bcraven 1y agoThat's a feature: if you can't work out which YouTube apk to patch them you'll never work out the rest of the installation process.
- NooneAtAll3 1y agoIts a bold strategy, Cotton, lets see if it pays off for em
- nhumrich 1y agoIt also contains more ads then you tube itself.
- vitorgrs 1y agoThere's no ads on Revanced...
- charcircuit 1y agoYes, there are. But there is a toggle to switch them on and off.
- vitorgrs 1y agoNot sure why mine there's no ads... Never had to toggle, as far I remember. I used Revanced Manager.
- komali2 1y agoI've loved Grayjay as an alternative YouTube client. It can pull in videos from other platforms as well, and it can Cast videos! AdBlock and sponsorblock built in too.
- walt_grata 1y agoI did the same, but I also added in a tamper monkey script to get rid of the picture in picture thing they force on you as part of their "core experience". I wish their ux designers and PMs were less arrogant and realized their preferences are just preferences and gave us back the ability to disable stuff like this in the app.
- bronco21016 1y agoAre they the PMs' preferences? Or are they A/B tested "optimizations" to hit their KPIs?
- kevincox 1y agoI think it is worse than that. Yes they A/B test. But they also have incentive to show how great their new feature idea is. So they are always picking the metrics that make their feature look better and ignoring the ones that make it look worse. So there is a thumb on the scale here.
- walt_grata 1y agoI honestly don't care. I've taken the stance of just looking for alternatives. Chrome on Android forced grid for tabs, boom changes to Firefox everywhere. YouTube doesn't allow me to disable picture in picture, canceled my paid account and mostly stopped using it, etc...
- tdeck 1y agoI've been doing this for years, but recently they have nerfed mobile web YouTube and it's limited to 360p (at least it seems to be for me).
- aidenn0 1y agoAnyone else notice that most youtube ads are really bad. Seeing a product in a youtube ad now causes me to be more likely to believe it's a ripoff. Things like a cheap $5 fan being sold for $60 as roughly: "Super efficient A/C that will save you $100s on your electricity bill and can cool a room down in just minutes"
- R_D_Olivaw 1y agoWhen ai slop makes it cheap to churn out the ads this is what you get. What does YT care, they get the money either way. Enshittification continues
- riffraff 1y agowhat I don't understand is how paying for YT ads can be profitable. I've never clicked on a YT ad _intentionally_ nor I know anyone who did, having asked a few people. I admit the brand awareness works tho.
- gosub100 1y agoThere's a counterintuitive effect sometimes, which is that the person who tolerates a stupid ad is also more likely to buy the product. This was used by email spammers whose messages came littered with deliberate grammatical errors as an efficient filter against too-smart targets.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- schmuckonwheels 1y agoI assume you mean all the snake oil pre-playback ads? Mostly dangerous medical advice, solar scams, or wellness quackery. This week, an instructional video I was watching on how to repair my water heater was suddenly interrupted by a campy ad for pussy-hair razors. It was so ill-timed, bizarre, and inappropriate I burst out laughing. The other one I was seeing a lot of, until very recently, was pornographic static ads that were implemented as an optical illusion. If you viewed it at full scale it was an innocuous image of a closet or chair or something, so it passed all checks, but when scaled into a thumbnail, it turns into a silhouette of a woman giving oral or something else obscene. Not sure what this technique is called or how it's done. (It's not a schooner, it's a sailboat.)
- phendrenad2 1y agoI used to pay for YouTube premium. I stopped doing that, uninstalled the apps, and now use... rumble and tiktok.
- alex1138 1y agoYoutube's censorship is one reason I won't pay for it. Rumble is a legitimate site even as people decry its existence (it would be less necessary if Youtube didn't decide on being the world's opinion police)
- immibis 1y agoWhich opinions are you trying to access?
- mrguyorama 1y agoA non-comprehensive list of things youtube tells you to self censor or you will be financially punished, or punishes you for showing or telling despite not being listed in their community guidelines in any way Swears (recently backed down somewhat on this) Anything to do with guns at all, whether you are right wing or vocally and loudly left wing. Mummmifying a chicken on a science channel gets you demonitized. Chemistry that results in an explosion. Fucking any footage of any war ever so no WW2 history videos, no videos educating you about previous genocides or war crimes or crimes against humanity, you can't show pictures of the holocaust or Armenian genocide no matter how educational your content is. A highlight reel compiled exclusively from clips pulled from your previous videos that were not demonitized will get demonitized, and when you reach out to your dedicated account manager because you are that big, they say "that shouldn't have happened" and promise you to fix it and that it will never happen again, which you take to hear, and then you produce a new highlight reel the next year following the same procedure it again gets demonitized so you reach out to your account manager again and they apologize profusely and say they will fix it and then every single video on your channel gets demonitized and your account is suddenly in peril for doing something that your account manager told you to do. You are a channel that shows pictures of planes and documents and talks about the development of these aircraft. One day your channel is suddenly scheduled for deletion because you are a "content mill". This is an utterly baseless accusation that would take five minutes of watching your content to dispel, but you still are left waiting until T-1 for an actual human to look and turn off the "Purge you" schedule. It's just absurd. Sure, the racists are pissed they can't put hate content on youtube, but lets not pretend they should be the only ones. "Forgotten Weapons" is just a gun centric antiques roadshow but "selling guns" is explicitly against policy, and all the things with guns that aren't against policy "weirdly" also get demonitized all the time. A reminder that "demonitization" on youtube is also what gets your video not recommended to anyone to watch, including your literal subscribers (yes even if you clicked the fucking bell) Note that Youtube provides an entire set of tooling and functionality to automatically A/B test thumbnails and titles, yet claims in their community guidelines that you should not use "A thumbnail that misleads viewers to think they’re about to view something that’s not in the video" so they just DGAF
- sreya 1y agoNot being able to play Youtube in the background on your phone is unfortunately one of the main appeals of Premium. There's a lot of good mixes, concerts, etc that I play for the audio while doing something else that I can't do without Premium unless I wanted to leave my phone unlocked (and pray I don't pocket click a link).
- R_D_Olivaw 1y agoI'm fairly certain if you use a browser and the desktop version of the site you can listen with the screen off/locked.
- cjameskeller 1y agoFirefox Android can play audio even when the phone is locked, and I use it regularly.
- just-another-se 1y agobrave on android can also do the same, not sure about ios
- TheCapeGreek 1y agoNote: If you have a mid-range to lower end phone, battery optimization might stop your playback anyway by default. You can exclude Firefox from battery optimization though.
- shminge 1y agoIf you're on Android, YouTube Revanced does this (+many other premium features)
- qwerpy 1y agoMy iPhone running Safari and uBlock Origin lite is able to do this. I don't have the youtube app installed. I don't even think the ad blocker is necessary for background audio, but I don't want to see ads. 1. Go to youtube.com in the browser, play the video, switch back to the home screen. Video playback will stop, which is a good default behavior. 2. Swipe down from the top of the screen which brings up "Notification Center" which somewhat strangely contains a playback control for the browser. 3. Press play. Audio resumes. If it's part of a playlist, you don't have to manually advance, it will play automatically. No ads, no youtube premium subscription, no "desktop mode", no sideloading, no additional apps other than the beloved ad blocker.
- stack_framer 1y agoI also stopped using the YouTube app in favor of the Brave browser on my desktop and my Android phone (no extensions needed). I can't remember the last time I saw an ad on YouTube!
- strix_varius 1y agoI also use Brave on all my devices - it also works on Amazon Prime. Prime frequently made me offers to upgrade to an ad-free experience that I didn't understand... surely this is a bug, I already have an ad-free experience. Then I installed the Prime app on my TV and realized the constant barrage of ads that Brave has been protecting me from!
- a96 1y agoBrave is a series scam company.
- thoroughburro 1y agoWhy do you think this?
- TheCapeGreek 1y agoThere's odd and end features that some people prefer with Premium. E.g. offline downloads to watch when you're out of signal, background play, etc. And they don't want to go through alternative workarounds to do so. For me, it's actually just being able to easily share premium with other users in my household, so that I don't have to have my ears blasted with ads when they open YT on the TV. Less effort than playing around with things like pihole and hoping it doesn't break other things.
- ksec 1y ago>I used to pay for YouTube premium It would have been amazing value had Youtube Music, which came with YouTube Premium were half decent. But it is not. We got Spotify which isn't perfect, and then Apple Music, which for years didn't know what they were doing, and then Youtube Music, which is basically a company doesn't give a damn about Music. We now have three Giant companies over the history of the past 30 - 40 years, once they grow big that make junk.
- kevincox 1y agoYes, I very happily payed for YouTube Premium when it came with Google Play Music. Them turning that off in favour of the awful YouTube Music was the straw that broke the camels back.
- FridgeSeal 1y ago> Apple Music, which for years didn't know what they were doing You pay them money, they let you stream music and otherwise stay out of your way. I don’t know about you, but that’s pretty much ideal as far as I’m concerned.
- ksec 1y agoI still remember Apple Music App was all about the magical "Next Song" and they went their way to hide Repeat One button because they want you to do "Discovery". It wasn't until about 2020 before they relented. But that ideal is still true with Apple Music today.
- tanjtanjtanj 1y ago... and they let you upload music and have it exist natively in the interface and streamable anywhere you're logged in, the exact feature I was using Google Music for. Even beyond Apple Music, considering the other competitors I legitimately don't know what the use case for Spotify is beyond social these days.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jdhwosnhw 1y agoI would genuinely like to understand this perspective. Ads or paying for premium is how the underlying business makes money. The UX might suck but you have a choice - you can just not watch YouTube. The approach you describe (which i understand is a popular one) is equivalent to justifying robbing a store because their prices are too high.
- allarm 1y agoIt’s not a robbery if noone is getting robbed. That’s a very bad analogy really.
- jdhwosnhw 1y agoYou are using a service without paying for the service by actively circumventing the payment mechanism. Is that not stealing?
- asldfkasgkj 1y agoIs it okay if I go the bathroom or get another beer while the commercials play? If so, why?
- jdhwosnhw 1y agoThats like saying the grocery store is ok with me eating some of the grapes while I shop so they must be ok with me walking out without paying for my groceries. I’m not trying to be obtuse here. I really want to understand some sort of reasonable moral justification for actively avoiding paying for a service that you are using / circumventing the mechanism by which the business makes money.
- AlexeyBelov 1y ago> circumventing the mechanism by which the business makes money This is generally of no interest to consumers.
- 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]