8 ms·
I built a faster Notion in Rust
- johnisgood 1y agoIrrelevant, but "a faster", not "an faster".
- ls-a 1y agoIt's actually an faster if they used rust
- lagniappe 1y ago'an' precedes a vowel sound, 'a' precedes a consonant sound.
- not-so-darkstar 1y agoit's a joke
- nicoburns 1y agoLooks like the original title was "an actually faster" and HN stripped out the "actually"
- lagniappe 1y agoAutomated or not, editing titles is not cool. What an odd double standard.
- hresvelgr 1y agoLooks promising. Where I think Notion really succeeds is letting people easily make attractive live documents. Where they've meandered off imho is trying to shoehorn in an RDBMS. If you can enable people to make pretty pages, and keep your document format simple, you'll be off to a very good start.
- dabbz 1y agoThe people yearn for a database. Everything ends up trying to be MS Access, the perfect software.
- airstrike 1y agoReally cool stuff. I will spend some time here digging into the details. I've built a Cursor for business users in Rust. Spreadsheets, slideshows, and an agentic loop. If you're up for it, it would be nice to chat and share stories and vision. Email is andy at inboard dot ai
- aswegs8 1y agoWhats your pricing? Will early access be free?
- Sekhmet 1y ago> Each seat will cost around €/$10. If you see yourself using this product, consider sponsoring Outcrop today for €/$100; you’ll get €/$200 as credits on launch. From the linked blog.
- arnaudsm 1y agoThis is great, I wish tech giants focused more on latency. Gmail, Notion, Facebook, are painfully slow on my high-end laptop with gigabit ethernet. Something is wrong in our modern engineering culture.
- DarkNova6 1y agoI think the problem is a lack of "engineering culture".
- CuriouslyC 1y agoObviously not with Gmail/Facebook, in that case it's just 100% incentive misalignment. The others, probably, VCs are incentivized to fund the people who allocate the most resources towards growth and marketing, as long as the app isn't actively on fire investors will actively push you away from allocating resources to make your tech good.
- School-Cotton 1y agoYou would be surprised at how bad the “engineering culture” is at meta. There are surely people who care about page load latency but they are a tiny minority.
- samdoesnothing 1y agoI mean, if you look at Meta's main product it's hard to imagine anyone there cares about engineering. It might be the single worst widely used tech product in existence, and considering they produce the frameworks it's built on it's even more embarrassing.
- School-Cotton 1y agoThere are a few people who care A LOT about engineering, otherwise everything would completely collapse and not work at all. But they are far from the majority.
- beswalod 1y agoAnother Notion-like app. But it's already many FOSS alternatives
- crashabr 1y agoWhat are they? The thing I value the most is the collaboration and the relational part, allowing to build pages that are essentially views on other data. The only one I'm looking forward currently is the next version of Logseq which will enable collaboration on their existing block-based authoring model.
- Sytten 1y agoThe prosemirror port would make for a nice OSS library if OP is willing to put it on crates.io.
- metaketa 1y agoI was thinking the same. This would have actually been awesome
- drcongo 1y agoLoved the thought processes in this post, so definitely interested. Notion always feels half-baked.
- woile 1y agoprosemirror in rust? I'd like to see something like that!
- sgarland 1y agoIt certainly looks like the author has given careful thought to making this performant, but I am skeptical about it at scale. While OT means there should be fewer updates than CRDT, you still wind up with a fair amount of them, and you have to periodically rebuild the base document from accumulated steps, which can be quite large. Assuming your backing store is Postgres, I’d experiment a lot with the various column storage strategies, at various sizes of documents and varying amounts of writes. The TOAST overhead can become a huge bottleneck.
- xanth 1y agoThis looks like it has great potential, but what I really want is an open source "notion" with a well considered plugin & schema model. I desperately want to sync back all my data into a single cohesive graph; notes, reading list, messages, exercise activity in a more compute friendly format than MD files.
- bakli 1y agoLike Obsidian?
- shmoogy 1y agoObsidian isn't open source
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- echelon 1y agoI'm still happy to use it. It's not like they can rug pull on the data or even the existing app binaries. I'd really like to see the team get rewarded for their work, too. I'd be sad if it went 100% open and they didn't so much as draw a market salary from it. I think if it went open, they'd get nothing. That's the one thing I strongly dislike about open source is that only hyperscalers really economically benefit from it. They've done a remarkable service for all of us.
- alabhyajindal 1y agoI used to be very against closed source products but changed my mind recently. One of the founders of Obsidian makes some great points here: https://forum.obsidian.md/t/open-sourcing-of-obsidian/1515/11 https://forum.obsidian.md/t/open-sourcing-of-obsidian/1515/1...
- echelon 1y ago
- thiago_fm 1y agoI see a big amount of naiveness on his post, I tried to view it with a positive mindset, but I can't help myself and think how naive his perspective on that is. First, lots of server-side code is IO-bound, writing it in Rust vs. Java/C# would barely show any difference in a Monitoring tool, in a real-life scenario. His authorization system is very limited in scope, of course it can be fast! Get real users and we will see if that will still be fast. When you are running it in production, even if using Zanzibar's approach of loading everything into memory, you'd still need to handle many aspects he didn't think of, like updates to such permissions, and dealing with sharding etc. Things are always more complex in real life. And last not but the least, Notion is really fast as it is. I never knew it was slow. Without bringing any new concept to "Notion", I find it hard to believe this will ever work. I hope he finds happiness building it though, building is fun!
- wjsdj2009 1y agoInteresting perspective. Thanks for sharing.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- braza 1y agoLast year after a thread around Obsidian and the downhill of Evernote I took almost 6 months to migrate more than 100K clippings and notes and it's so refreshing to have your own data in sync in your terms and not be in any proprietary format, that I do not image myself going to anywhere that I cannot push/retrieve my notes in my own terms in a portable format. Notion is a great product for corporations, and I get why companies are jumping on this bandwagon so fast; however, as a consumer, I wouldn't consider it or any option based on seat (like Outcrop) or any that wouldn't give me a binary that I can use in whatever machine that I want.
- 0dayman 1y agoObsidian is much better
- bomewish 1y agoThis looks like a tidy little out of the box fts system. I’d use it as a tantivy interface basically. And I’d pay for it if it had good and simple document ingestion and metadata search semantics. Not the intended use case really but this doesn’t exist.
- yomismoaqui 1y agoIs this the new "I built a Twitter clone in a weekend"?
- ancharm 1y agoWill this also be available on the web via WASM compilation, in addition as a desktop app?
- mellosouls 1y agoUnless its open source I can't really see the point with bragging about it being in Rust. Its just another product, and its either faster or its not - the underlying language or platform is pretty irrelevant.
- CalvinClare 1y agoWhile it's possible to develop a more convenient version of Notion, I think it's only suitable for practice, since we can't compete with companies that monopolize the AI note-taking industry.
- tonyoconnell 1y agoYou can make your website run fast as well with https://astro.build https://astro.build - it strips the Javascript and uses HTML until js is needed. You can get 300ms page loads for outcrop.app with Astro on Cloudflare Pages. Good luck with the project. I requested early access - You should use the response to the form submit requesting access better - I mean somebody who added their email expressed a lot of intent - why end the conversation with a toast notification? I hope life is going well in Dublin.
- denysvitali 1y ago> Something went wrong! Cannot read properties of null (reading 'enable') (On outcrop.app)
- nixpulvis 1y ago> It’s not decentralised, it’s persisted to Postgres, but loaded in memory on startup. How are changes to permissions managed I wonder.
- hexo 1y agoNice. I dunno what is Notion but I suppose - I tried Obsidian and some other sw i dont recall anymore, never liked it. Then I found org-mode in emacs and gave it a try. I did not look back except for one feature - mind maps or 2D note taking. For this I've tried mind maps but it just wasnt really what i needed or wanted. I probably dont really know what I want or mean by 2d note taking, I just have some vague idea.
- WillAdams 1y agoThe thing which I've always wanted to see is a knowledgebase system which uses a company's e-mail as an interface: - new e-mail from client comes in which can't be matched to an existing project? New page in the knowledgebase - second e-mail from client comes in w/ an attachment? It's stripped off and added to that page in the kb - employee sends out e-mail with link to the initial version of the project? The link is added to that page &c. Maybe AI could make something like that work now?
- smodo 1y agoStill baffles me that Outlook won’t let me tie together emails, calendar items and documents. It makes so much sense to combine these things. All my meetings are about documents and their related correspondence but you never have a coherent information space for them.
- WillAdams 1y agoI spend a lot of time saving Outlook messages to the file system and storing them for reference later.
- bryanhogan 1y agoI can highly recommend Obsidian for long-term knowledge bases. Have been writing about using it well: https://bryanhogan.com/tags/obsidian https://bryanhogan.com/tags/obsidian It's missing collaboration at the core, although it's possible to achieve this currnetly with third party solutions, or the next major update should also include it as it's the "multiplayer" update.
- bad_username 1y agoObsidian is nothing less than a complete IDE for text.
- dtkav 1y agoI work on one of the third party plugins enabling real-time collaboration in Obsidian called Relay [0]. We have a novel architecture where you can optionally register a self-hosted relay server with our control plane for complete privacy for all of your docs and attachments. We know that people typically prefer to have a unified vault, so you can share individual folders with different groups of people within your vault. Relay is free for markdown docs up to 3 users, and then we have a hobby plan which includes attachment storage (especially popular with D&D and TTRPG players), as well as per-seat plans for businesses and universities. There are a couple of cloud-only alternatives like peerdraft and screen garden as well. [0] https://relay.md https://relay.md
- henryhchchc 1y agoI am using Obsidian with the markdown-oxide [0] language server in my favorite text editor. It works pretty well for link navigation and completion. [0] https://oxide.md/ https://oxide.md/
- backscratches 1y agoFantastic tool.
- small_scombrus 1y agoHow do you manage the more Obsidian-y sync side? Do you have it open with no tabs, or something else going on?
- perfmode 1y agoCurious about the authors authz implementation. Preloading authorization data into memory does not, by itself, provide the specific security guarantee (consistency) that defines Zanzibar. The Zanzibar model is famous not just because it is fast, but because it solves the "New Enemy" problem (or causal consistency). Simple in-memory caching (preloading) often fails this test unless it is paired with complex invalidation logic that mimics Zanzibar's Zookies.
- jschorr 1y agoIt is actually slightly worse than even that: while New Enemy [1] is the primary concern, caching like this can also introduce a staleness issue from the other direction: let's say a user adds a new row or document, and immediately sends the link to their coworker... who tries to load that piece of data, but the (stale) access control dataset is cached and they are not in it... they get a "no access" error. While certainly fail safe (vs fail dangerous for New Enemy), it can be a fairly important UX concern as well. Generally, the solution is to keep a timestamp of when the data changed (Zookies as you mentioned) or you can proactively reload or recompute the cache when the underlying data changes (sometimes in very smart ways), but yeah: it adds significant complications over a "simplified" approach to Zanzibar. Disclaimer: I'm the cofounder and CTO of AuthZed and we develop the SpiceDB [2] and Materialize [3], which have quite a bit of logic around these exact problems [1]: https://authzed.com/blog/new-enemies#the-new-enemy-problem https://authzed.com/blog/new-enemies#the-new-enemy-problem [2]: https://spicedb.io https://spicedb.io [3]: https://authzed.com/docs/authzed/concepts/authzed-materialize https://authzed.com/docs/authzed/concepts/authzed-materializ...
- fud101 1y agoHi, i'd like to implement my own version for learning purposes. Do you have any recommendations?
- jschorr 1y agoI'd start with reading the Zanzibar Paper. We built an annotated version [1] that provides additional guidance on some of the denser sections and how we interpreted them. Then, I'd take a look at the history of SpiceDB [2] for how we developed the system over time. Finally, if you have any questions, feel free to jump into our Discord [3] and ask: we're happy to answer! [1]: https://zanzibar.tech/ https://zanzibar.tech/ [2]: https://spicedb.io https://spicedb.io [3]: https://discord.gg/spicedb https://discord.gg/spicedb