14 ms·
A new chapter begins for EV batteries with the expiry of key LFP patents
- cyberax 1y agoWhat? Patents have been a non-issue for LFP batteries, and the original LFP patents are almost useless today. All the new advances that made LFPs competitive are still well-protected by patents, for at least another decade.
- mitthrowaway2 1y agoWhat makes you say they've been a non-issue? As far as I'm aware they've been an issue (outside of China) for the last 20 years.
- Tostino 1y agoSorry we handicapped ourselves and are now complaining about a competitor? Seems silly. The west made this tech unusable. I was building ebikes in 2006/7 and A123 was entirely unavailable unless you went and salvaged power tool packs. They never became available at a competitive price, and then China bought the rights.... Now I can buy them in bulk as a consumer for 1/15th the price. Our system is not meant for innovation by small players or consumers. We want tech easily locked away behind a contract.
- cyberax 1y agoThe total lithium battery patent licensing market is estimated at less than 600 million USD a year. This is approximately nothing, given that the overall battery market is estimated at about $200B. The pace of innovation is furious, and companies are treating patents more as a way to ensure MAD (Mutual Assured Destruction) rather than as a tool to get income. I think we'll start seeing the first large lawsuits once the losers start realizing that they lost the innovation race.
- modeless 1y agoDoesn't that indicate that patents are being used to suppress competitors rather than as a direct revenue source? I don't see how that indicates patents aren't an issue.
- AnthonyMouse 1y ago> The total lithium battery patent licensing market is estimated at less than 600 million USD a year. This is often because someone holds an important patent but either isn't licensing it to others because they're actually manufacturing it (implying they're holding back everyone else in the market), or they're asking too much and then almost everyone uses the existing technology instead of licensing the patent, again holding things back. As soon as the patent expires everyone starts using it. > The pace of innovation is furious, and companies are treating patents more as a way to ensure MAD (Mutual Assured Destruction) rather than as a tool to get income. This is often even worse, because then you have a hundred companies with patents and as soon as one of them goes out of business the patents go to a troll who starts shaking everyone down because MAD doesn't apply to trolls who don't make anything. And then companies wary of being subjected to that will be avoiding doing anything under patent until the patents expire. Companies in industries like this should probably start using some kind of patent GPL where you have to permanently license all your patents to everyone else who does the same, the purpose of which is to thwart trolls because everyone has to put their patents in while they're still in business or they'll be sued, and then the patents are already in by the time a failing company gets liquidated.
- NewJazz 1y agoIn your last paragraph you are basically talking about a licensing authority like MPEGLA is.
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoExcept that they charge fees, which retains the perverse incentive to accumulate low-quality patents and for smaller companies to avoid the pool's patents instead of joining it. And then when one that didn't join goes out of business everybody's got troll problems again.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- silon42 1y agoSo, mass switch-over to electric cars is delayed for a decade or two.
- rule2025 1y agoLithium iron phosphate batteries are very practical. Chinese BYD has developed blade batteries using this type of battery and has become the global sales leader in new energy vehicles. However, this battery faces range limitations and the issue of how to improve charging speed. Solid-state batteries should be the next big thing, but mass production may not be feasible yet. At least, it might take 3 more years for commercialization, and that's still an optimistic prediction.
- idiotsecant 1y agoSolid state batteries and fusion power, always 3 years away.
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoIt’s always 20 years away until it isn’t. Self driving cars are…I guess they are here already. AGI? Well, we have to move the goal post on that constantly.
- stevage 1y ago>Self driving cars are…I guess they are here already. They may be where you are, but they aren't generally here.
- seanmcdirmid 1y agoIf by here I meant planet Earth I think it is well qualified. Yes, they aren't using self driving car tech for ice trucking during winter down from Purdhoe Bay yet (another form of goal post moving), but the biggest challenges have already been solved and only capital and societal barriers remain.
- rootusrootus 1y agoI think it depends on what you mean by big challenges. City driving is maybe the easiest 80% of driving. There’s a long tail of odd challenges you run into in less controlled environments, and I’d call that the biggest challenge.
- Ryan07 1y ago[flagged]
- amluto 1y ago> EU regulations requiring lithium-ion batteries to contain at least 6% recycled lithium by 2031, rising to 12% by 2036. Seriously? The EU should aim for massive growth in battery deployment in transportation and grid storage. If they hope for, say, 10x growth in deployed battery capacity within a time frame comparable to the lifespan of a battery, then even a 100% recycling rate would not produce enough lithium. I suppose people could recycle batteries just to produce new batteries and acquire recycling credits, but this is absurd.
- ehnto 1y agoIt will probably amount to recycling credit schemes I am sure. But that would definitely boost lithium recycling efforts. From memory over 1million disposable vapes are thrown away each day, from 500 of the bigger cell vapes a Youtuber was able build a home battery to power his house. I don't think 100% recycled makes sense but there sure is a lot of lithium getting thrown into the bin. Incentives to recapture that are good.
- DoctorOetker 1y ago500? thats just 5x10x10, even the bigger cell vapes would result in a tiny battery to power a house...
- Dylan16807 1y agoIt was under 3kWh.
- ehnto 1y agoIt wasn't huge no, but we are talking about cells we throw away in the millions. Scale up the battery as needed, the cells are basically free.
- csomar 1y agoThat's 730k households in a year. Cool but since these batteries will probably die within a year, then you are only able to cover 1.5 million people or so. I am not against it, but 1.5m in 8b is a drop in the ocean.
- kopirgan 1y agoBut this is 2022? By now the dust must have settled. Anyone that wanted to copy and use likely planned out before they expired and got moving once it did?
- thebeardisred 1y agoExactly, this is a 3 year old post. That's why you started seeing LFP battery banks showing up on Amazon a few years ago.
- btilly 1y agoIt is worth noting that this is an ad. It is a law firm that is advertising their expertise in this field. And the product that they want people to buy is revealed in this passage: Freedom-to-operate (FTO) analysis therefore remains critical for market entrants. Whilst the primary patents have expired, a dense web of secondary patents, covering additives, coatings, and production methods, still poses infringement risks. Of course Shoosmiths would be happy to do a FTO analysis for your potential product...for a fee. That doesn't mean that it doesn't contain quality information. Law firms tend to make this kind of ad informative. But it does mean that there is an agenda.
- epistasis 1y agoIt may be an ad but it has every reason to be perfectly accurate. The law firm is not selling LFP batteries. Edit: for example, if somebody was selling their AWS course by providing detailed information on some aspect of AWS, that wouldn't be a reason to doubt the information itself. It serves as a sample.
- lmpdev 1y agoI mean one would take the ad with a grain of salt If it gets people to pull the trigger on engaging with the firm - it’s likely to embellish how massive the changes are of these patent lapses
- IshKebab 1y agoIt has plenty of reasons to be inaccurate. They may be exaggerating the promise of LFP or overplaying how many secondary parents there are.
- bluGill 1y agoAnyone who needs their help already knows the promise of LFP in at least enough details that they would need the patent search anyway as part of their efforts to learn if it is right for them. All secondary patents are important, the only question is: do you license them, work around them, or not infringe in the first place. (I'm going to ignore the possibility of intentional infringing though that happens)
- 0xbadcafebee 1y agoI still find it borderline criminal that a few nations continue to be ruled by the hegemony of the automobile market. EVs have a place in the world. But there should be ten times fewer of them, because we should have cheap and plentiful public transit for most of our transportation needs. How long will we simply sit and wait for that future, complacent and docile? When will we do what's necessary to progress our society? (if we ever do)
- lmpdev 1y agoLikely once sufficient numbers of boomers die off - and their property inheriting children don’t take up their parent’s views
- toast0 1y ago> How long will we simply sit and wait for that future, complacent and docile? The people who don't want to sit and wait have bought personal vehicles. Mass transit can be great, but when it isn't, there's no sense of agency. At least with a personal vehicle, if it's not working, I can try to fix it or get it to someone who is more likely to be able to fix it. When transit isn't running, I just have to wait. If it can't get me to where I want to go in a reasonable time, sucks to be me. If my stop is removed from service, I guess I better move.
- Gigachad 1y agoIn the last year, the number of times my car owning friends have not been able to make it to an event because their car is broken is surprisingly high. While I have never not been able to get somewhere because public transport is not working. If the train is down I can take the tram, if somehow both of them are down there will be replacement busses scheduled. And if somehow everything stops working I can book an uber which is still massively cheaper than owning a car.
- lkbm 1y ago> While I have never not been able to get somewhere because public transport is not working. Oh man, when I first moved to Austin and used the bus as my only method of transport, getting to work was usually straightforward, but whenever I wanted to go somewhere on the weekend, I prepared for the fact that there'd be a detour around downtown, where I normally make my transfer. I'd have to get off the bus somewhere new and try to figure out where to catch the bus for the next leg. There were also a few occasions where there was over an hour between the "every 30 minutes" bus. Rare, but it happened. Buses naturally tend to clump together, so they need careful, intentional management to prevent this. Public transit is great, and we need more, but it's not as reliable as I'd like. Cars are far more reliable, at least for moderately wealthy people who can afford to buy new-ish and keep them well-maintained. Bikes, too, if you're able to bike in rain and snow. (I ended up switching to almost 100% bike travel after about three years, and just kept a change of clothes at work, and at least dry socks, shirt, and underwear in my bag. Spare pants added too much bulk to lug around.)
- martinpw 1y agoWho owned these key LFP patents? It was not clearly laid out in the article which countries owned them, let alone which companies. If they were owned by Chinese companies, then is there some faint hope that Western companies can finally start making EVs that are no longer embarrassingly inferior to their Chinese counterparts?
- k1musab1 1y agoA foundational research team in a Canadian university in Quebec, if I recall correctly. They licenced these patents to the Chinese companies royalty free when used the Chinese domestic market. The Chinese spent the time developing LFP to where it's now a bleeding edge of batteries, while practically no-one else was interested. In a retaliatory fight over the EVs, in October 2025, the CCP issued a ban on transfer of advanced technology for LFP batteries, and battery manufacturing equipment.
- rasz 1y ago>They licenced these patents to the Chinese companies royalty free when used the Chinese domestic market. Smells like second Nortel. Wonder who made that decision and where are they now.
- sudosysgen 1y agoI've talked to people from that very lab at the Université de Montréal many years ago, before the parent expired. The IP was licensed by Hydro-Quebec first, and some of it was also held by UT. A123 was a US company manufacturing LFP batteries in 2005 in infringement of the patents. A123, Hydro-Quebec, UT spent 15 years suing each other (and also suing BAK technology in China and other companies that used the technology), complete with secondary patents, etc... Hydro-Quebec actually was producing LFP batteries commercially, along with an EV program. Those ventures were cancelled, in no small part because of the political issues when Canadian SoEs compete with American businesses (but also for other reasons). HQ is restarting the LFP manufacturing program now, though, through a new spinoff. Anyways, this is not like Nortel at all - we had two decades of a headstart and we didn't give the license to Chinese companies until quite a few years later. A big part of the issue is because an American company violated the IP, then filed secondary pattents and tried to get the originals invalidated, which led to a huge legal battle strongly discouraging investment. There was really no mistake done in licensing it to Chinese companies.
- dust42 1y agoBloombergNEF has over the years proven to have pretty solid forecasts. The current one about NEVs [1] has a few interesting points. Adoption of EVs is slowing down in the US due to policy changes but going to explode in countries like Vietnam because they are cheeper to buy an run. It is not BMWs and Mercs but Chinese brands. In Europe and the US the Chinese EVs are kept outside with the help of tariffs but that is just closing the eyes to avoid facing the inevitability. Battery technology, production and raw materials is all China. Last not least Europe is driving up KWh costs by an ideologically driven push for renewables which also doesn't help. [1] https://about.bnef.com/insights/clean-transport/electric-vehicle-outlook/ https://about.bnef.com/insights/clean-transport/electric-veh...
- hgomersall 1y agoElectricity costs in the UK (which I believe is still in Europe) are cheaper now than they've ever been if you have the right tariff and that's all due to renewables. Granted, that's primarily at night, but for EVs that's perfect. One can get a tariff at <7p/kWh for 6 hours in the night. That's cheaper than gas (actual gas, not gasoline).
- marcosscriven 1y agoIf that’s Octopus Intelligent Go, then it will also give you the 7p rate outside the normal nighttime slot if the car is charging and their algo calculates they can do it.
- IshKebab 1y agoRenewables definitely help and I think the UK is doing quite well there but it's a little disingenuous to not even mention the price cap that the government has imposed!
- hgomersall 1y agoWhat's the price cap got to do with it? You can get tariffs that are very cheap and outside of the price cap: https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Good-Energy-EV-Charge-TIL-Nov26.pdf https://www.goodenergy.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/Good...
- dabinat 1y agoI really wish we could get Chinese EVs in the US. They’re very aesthetically appealing, have great performance and specs, and cost only $20-30k. I think there should be a modest tariff on them that doesn’t kill US manufacturers but makes it so they have to actually compete.
- purpleidea 1y agoThey have the same problem the U.S. EV's have: sketchy spyware software. Make everyone honest and open up the code / let people write their own code, and then let the true market rule. U.S. don't want the Chinese cars collecting data, but they're content with U.S. ones doing it.
- fedeb95 1y agoImagine a world without patents and tariffs. Imagine a world where companies can freely compete (no patents) and, most importantly, *have* to (no tariffs).
- ZeroGravitas 1y agoThere was some kind of patent shenanigans about a decade ago around LFP. I'm not sure if China invalidated dodgy patents or threatened to and got a good deal (or some combination) but I think LFP in China escaped a lot of patent fees as long as they were sold in China. This probably partly explains the regional nature of LFP success so further expiries might help the rest of the world catch up on LFP prices and adoption.
- jacquesm 1y agoLFP is a nice chemistry but I think https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium-titanate_battery is the future. There is still the power density issue but that's improving steadily. The thing that really sells me on this is the speed with which you can charge the cells.