8 ms·
Sam Altman's pants are on fire
- rhetocj23 1y agoI personally called it within my circle that when Friar was hired she was going to commit a tremendous blunder. It may have been innocent, but the trend is now reversing in regards to its mantlehold of mindshare of consumers. Someone I know who has been an absolute staunch advocate of chatgpt,and has been for the best part of the past 1.5 years suddenly changed their tune earlier this week. That is my signal that things are turning south. There will be a reprieve for some time, with increasing revenue. But eventually that will jam to a halt and all the doubts will intensify.
- an0malous 1y agoThe VCs and bloggers have also shifted tone and are hedging to save themselves from embarrassment. It used to be “AGI is just around the corner” and now it’s “Just because we haven’t figured it out yet doesn’t mean we never will” (Andreesen) or “Actually bubbles are good” (Stratechery). Gary called it a long time ago but I think the Dwarkesh and Karpathy podcast is when the shift started.
- rhetocj23 1y agoSomething to note about this craze and Crypto is that the world is full of bozos who do not think deeply whatsoever.
- pinnochio 1y agoSo many goons on here who keep flagging submissions like these, or trying to discredit them with superficial criticism ("he keeps saying the same thing!"). It's sad this behavior doesn't get modded. Edit: lol at the downvotes. You're just proving my point, goons.
- rhetocj23 1y agoI pity them. They are not as far ahead in life and understanding as they want to be or are supremely deluded. I just wished the bozos actually replied to the post instead of hiding behind a button.
- an0malous 1y agoI’d also add these lessons I’ve personally learned: - Greed is blinding even to intelligent people, especially greedy people in groups - Society is incredibly vulnerable to lying, we mostly rely on the disincentive that people usually feel bad about it, but the ones who don’t can get away with anything. - There’s really only a subtle difference between many successful startups and Ponzi schemes. Sam Altman’s grift is only one level more sophisticated than SBF or Elizabeth Holmes
- goatlover 1y ago- Thinking the present is somehow special and unlike similar past events or trends.
- Spooky23 1y agoI don’t think that’s the case. The relatively small cabal of people driving this stuff are all pretty weird people who live atypical lives and are hella smart, aware, and unconstrained. They don’t care about the wake of destruction, and likely believe that it is virtuous to bring it on.
- Spooky23 1y agoThe Ben Thompson take attempting to find a lemonade in the lemons is the most terrifying: the bubble will pop and leave us with… excess electric generation capacity? (And bankrupt power producers?) We truly live in the dumbest timeline.
- Neywiny 1y agoThere was also some woman (maybe a high up exec, I don't know their full roster) in one of those live audience interviews saying they were looking towards a government backstop on the loans. They know they have no way of ponying up 1.4T. That's an insane amount of money. Honestly if more investing and startups were "we have x front-runners, if he dies he dies" I think we'd be in s better spot. Maybe don't invest in capturing-helium-in-a-colander.ai just because it ends in "AI"
- mitthrowaway2 1y agoI think you must mean Sarah Friar, CFO of OpenAI.
- Neywiny 1y agoMost likely. Who better to know their financial status is fried than the CFO
- bpodgursky 1y agoYou can criticize OpenAI for many things but this was blatantly misquoted. They were talking about backstops for chips, to get fabs constructed in the US. If anyone else said this, it would have been considered a great idea, both republicans and democrats talked about the same thing to get TSMC production into the US, but everyone pretended that OpenAI was talking about data centers in this context. They weren't/
- Neywiny 1y agoMy goodness is there a huge difference between TSMC and OpenAI. TSMC moving to the US is a benefit to all US fabless companies and fabless companies that want to do business in any sensitive US industry, and they have an incredible track record as an industry leader. Open AI's chip manufacturing is much more risky and much less payoff. I wouldn't want the government to pay a penny towards it. Especially because an estimated cost for a leading edge chip is maybe $500 million. If they can commit to $1.4T, they can do it on their own. It's almost an omen they don't feel comfortable spending that without a guarantor.
- neuvarius 1y agoFor sake of HN can we get a rundown that isn’t Gary Marcus flinging shit on people? I’d like something a bit more objective.
- samrus 1y agoYou could just read the primary sources. The things hes showing people to have said. The gist is altman was trying to be slick about requiesting a government bailout, got called out on his bullshit, and then decided to lie and say he never wanted a bailout The implication being the bubble is getting closer and closer to popping, since even altman is thinking about how to survive the pop
- ungreased0675 1y agoSomehow people like him seem to survive just fine. Adam Neumann still has infinite money and Billy McFarland is still getting investors for various schemes.
- NBJack 1y agoYep; it will just screw the employees, the investors (or at least those that didn't suddenly get clairvoyant and find an exit right before it hits the fan), and many, many apps relying on their APIs.
- samrus 1y agoThe correction is good in the long run. It will settle to sane understanding of AI's capabilities, competent applications, and the unsuing AI winter will be when real research is done rather than "we fed its garbage back into itself hoping something else came out" It will ruin some lives. I hate that the american economy runs on these speculative cycles. If we tempered our expectations to what was sane, but still bullish, we'd have far less to fall
- NBJack 1y ago
- nostrebored 1y agoNo particular love for Sam Altman, but the article reads as “I was right about X, so my interpretation of Y is correct.” I don’t see any particular contradiction. Moving fabs onshore is absolutely in the interest of both parties.
- samrus 1y agoThe crux of the article was altman trying to get a bailout, and when people called him on his bullshit, lying thay he never wanted a bailout. You cant trust the man
- ineedasername 1y agoIt looks like the actual crux was Altman's plea that the backtops be granted... Not to OpenAI? The document linkedfrom the article that had the actual ask, rather than cleanup over deliberate misatributions by others, was to... "Extend eligibility", for the AMIC money already carved out, to companies that are producers of things such as "grid components such as transformers and specialized steel". So: Altman did not ask for OpenAI loans to be guaranteed, nor did the CFO. It was on behalf of others drawn into the needs of the industry the AMIC grant was supposed to support. Self interested by OpenAI? Sure! And also not about to make the top 10k leaderboard for "sleezy things companies do".
- samrus 1y agoYou cant be this naive. You have to read between the lines. Altman has laready shown hes willing to boil us frogs with his attempts IPO a non profit. Hes slimy, he doesnt just say things and stand by them, he tests the waters and lies about ever wanting to swim if its too cold. He called for general bailouts, which would benefit OAI far far more than others since its spending the most, and then he got backlash, he lied and said that OAI doesnt want bailouts at all. You cant be so literalist to just take the man at his exact word and not try to determine his motivations. Especially this guy, whos made a career out of dancing around silicon valley's "no assholes" policy
- techblueberry 1y ago
- option 1y agoThis isn't a comment about Sam Altman, but given Gary's track record, why would anyone listen to him?
- spiderice 1y agoCare to enlighten those of us that know nothing about Gary's track record?
- hiddencost 1y agoHe posts some variant of this kind of anti AI piece roughly every two months for over 20 years. He's been wrong so far. Eventually he'll get lucky, but his track record is abysmal.
- rhetocj23 1y ago[flagged]
- ta9000 1y agoI don’t think they kind of comment belongs here.
- ineedasername 1y agoOn this board, there's an exceptionally good chance a response will come from someone who wrote code or published research fundamental to your daily life, perhaps your favorite sci novel, etc. Not that such questions are ever a reasoned entrance into discussions you aren't burning down-- they're not. But there are still some few places on the internet where a bit if discussion can happen, and this is usually one where the noise doesn't fully drown that out.
- goatlover 1y agoHas he been wrong about everything? I doubt that. It's also a logical fallacy to dismiss his current argument because he's made wrong arguments before. What he's saying about Altman lying is true or false independent of anything else he's said prior.
- superconduct123 1y agoI don't understand, what prompted OpenAI recently to need this 1.4T investment?
- pinnochio 1y agoBelieve it or not, that's actually a walkback from the $5 to $7 trillion he was pushing for almost two years ago. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2024/02/report-sam-altman-seeking-trillions-for-ai-chip-fabrication-from-uae-others/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2024/02/repor...
- tootie 1y agoI remember and it lends some credence to the notion that Altman is just making up big numbers.
- jgalt212 1y agoHe was just anchoring. https://www.pon.harvard.edu/daily/negotiation-skills-daily/what-is-anchoring-in-negotiation/ https://www.pon.harvard.edu/daily/negotiation-skills-daily/w...
- pinnochio 1y agoAbsolutely. It's anchoring in the service of a massive con.
- Gigachad 1y agoThey are going all in, promising so many deals to so many companies that if OpenAI fails, the entire US economy will explode. Expecting the government will bail them out to prevent such a disaster.
- goatlover 1y agoBillionaires and corporations too big too fail are bad for democracy. They have an oversized impact on society and the government.
- chaosprint 1y agoOpenAI's Bailout Blunder: How a CFO's Words Ignited a Firestorm https://entropytown.com/articles/2025-11-06-openai-cfo/ https://entropytown.com/articles/2025-11-06-openai-cfo/ "If you want to sell your shares, I'll find you a buyer." OpenAI and Microsoft Detail Landmark Partnership, Navigate Future of AI and Compute https://founderboat.com/interviews/2025-11-01-openai-sam-satya-microsoft/ https://founderboat.com/interviews/2025-11-01-openai-sam-sat... Crazy sequences in a week...
- lumost 1y agoThe "I don't need to answer your simple questions on profit and loss statements" sentiment was odd. Likely odd enough to spur institutional investors to dig deeper or attract short interest.
- mrtksn 1y agoThis site(entropytown) has a certificate problem: https://a.dropoverapp.com/cloud/download/c3bc66a4-40a3-49fe-ac02-2627e0b8ccdb/7f094fd6-b99e-4d16-ae28-fe589acc4380 https://a.dropoverapp.com/cloud/download/c3bc66a4-40a3-49fe-...
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago“Altman, sensing that he had massively blundered…” Altman is in bed with Trump. He isn’t all in. But Tuesday evidencing an electoral shift makes Friar’s comments exceptionally ill timed.
- throwaway984393 1y ago[dead]
- siliconc0w 1y agoThat agro response to a perfectly reasonable question, "if you don't want your shares, we'll find you a buyer" instantly reminded me of that Bernie Madoff movie.
- ozozozd 1y agoSpot on!
- Animats 1y agoLoan guarantees? Where did that come from? The AI bubble must really be about to pop.
- octoberfranklin 1y agoYeah that and the rush to IPO OpenAI....
- sidcool 1y agoI'm no Sam fan. But Gary Marcus is quite publicly a Sam critic. So I'd not dismiss it, but would also take it with a pinch of salt.
- meander_water 1y agoHere's the juicy stuff mentioned in the article: https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.433688/gov.uscourts.cand.433688.340.1.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.43...
- octoberfranklin 1y agos/pants/hair/ Somebody please tell me how to short this. I'm going all in.
- rsync 1y agoYou buy puts on TQQQ.
- BluSyn 1y agoI'm confused about language, as "loans" to me do not equal "bailout". The equating of the two seems odd, as many government incentives use loans that pay back with high interest, so governments MAKE money on those kinds of deals. Also clear that the 1.4T figure includes some accounting for spend that does not come directly from OpenAI (grid/power/data infra for example). Obviously some government involvement is needed, but more at EPA/State/Local level to fast track construction permits, more-so than financial help from Treasury. I'm confused why this generates such sensational headlines.
- octoberfranklin 1y agoThis is the same kind of bullshit rationalization they used to say that the bank bailouts of 2009 weren't really bank bailouts. They were bank bailouts. Unsecured government loans are either bailouts, entitlements in disguise, or (usually misguided) attempts at broad economic stimulus. This definitely isn't either of the latter two.
- BluSyn 1y agoUnsecured government loan to a successful company to fund acceleration and growth is a "handout". A "bailout" is what happened in 2009, in the sense the banks would literally have collapsed without it (and they probably should have). OpenAI is not going to collapse without these loans. Huge difference. Also for the record, not rationalizing, because I'm not in favor of either handouts or bailouts.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tim333 1y agoI'm with you on that - people use the wrong terms. Bailouts are supporting things like GM or failing banks because the government is worried about GM workers losing jobs or bank depositors losing money. Altman's 1.4T isn't like that - it's a proposed new investment in stuff that doesn't exist yet and there would be no job losses or the like if it fails to exist. They have been talking about potential government support for the new ventures, partly to keep up with China which uses similar government support. I'm not sure if it's a good idea but it would not be a bailout, more a subsidy.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- RexFactorem 1y ago[dead]
- palmotea 1y ago> Gary Marcus was blocked on X by Kara Swisher in November 2022 for saying that the board did not trust Sam Altman. Marcus remains blocked by Ms. Swisher to this day. There was an Ezra Klein podcast awhile back where Swisher (a journalist) made it sound like she'd been buddy-buddy with Elon Musk for some time. What is/was her relationship to Altman?
- blobbers 1y agoThe crazy thing about Sam Altman is that he's basically a deal maker; does it remind you of anyone currently in power? No substance, no skill, just wheeling dealing, constantly saving his own neck from things that really should have ended his career. Read: https://www.paulgraham.com/fundraising.html https://www.paulgraham.com/fundraising.html " Sam Altman has it. You could parachute him into an island full of cannibals and come back in 5 years and he'd be the king. " Meanwhile America is having no Kings protests.
- lioeters 1y agoHilarious how there's vigorous discussion happening under a post with 200 votes and 100 comments, while it's been flagged the whole time. > No substance, no skill, just wheeling dealing That's their only real skill. There's an entire class of people who specialize in exploiting society's hard work.
- blobbers 1y agoI think one thing I liked when I was in start-ups was working for folks straight out of grad school that genuinely cared about a problem, had some advanced knowledge about a topic and were just trying to turn it into a business. I felt like those were the kind of folks I could get on board with; not someone with an MBA that needs head count to reach their KPIs. Someone that cared about solving a problem and was genuinely smart.
- blobbers 1y agoWhy is this post flagged?