6 ms·
> Can someone explain to me why California would believe Sam Altman plans to stay in California? The simple answer is unless developing LLMs becomes commoditis
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Can someone explain to me why California would believe Sam Altman plans to stay in California?
The simple answer is unless developing LLMs becomes commoditised, the best place in the world to do it is in San Francisco. You don't take your manufacturing business out of Shenzhen without very good reason.
- booi 1y agoexcept developing AI is very much a knowledge exercise with very little dependency on location. You don't move your manufacturing business out of Shenzhen because the entire hard supply chain from mining, refining, manufacturing, test, ship and trade are all there. You can't move a refinery that easily much less the entire supply chain.
- brokencode 1y agoSure, but most of the country’s AI talent is concentrated there. Not to mention venture capital. What’s the advantage of moving? Maybe lower taxes and a cheaper rent. That seems like a small price to pay compared to the hundreds of billions they’re putting into data centers.
- alfalfasprout 1y agoThey're concentrated there because they've been asked to concentrate there. That can change on a dime. It's not like data centers are mainly in SF.
- vessenes 1y agoI think you're wrong. The concentration is for a host of reasons. Witness the large number of cities and countries that have tried to create a local Silicon Valley competitor unsuccessfully over the last 25 years. The data centers I think prove this point, and disprove yours -- huge spend has gone into data centers, but places like Wenatchee remain stubbornly not Silicon Valley. Intel has not made Portland into SV. Austin, while a tech hub and one of the US supply chain centers for hardware, is multiple orders of magnitude less productive than SV for tech startups. Productive as in numbers of unicorns, total value creation, however you want to spin it.
- shuckles 1y ago> That can change on a dime. People tried very hard to change it between 2020-2023 and utterly failed.
- hamdingers 1y agoYou've got it backwards. Well paid engineers congregate in California because it's a nice place to live if you can afford it. Therefore if you want to hire the best engineers, and want an in-office work culture, you need to go to California.
- terminalshort 1y agoWell paid engineers congregate in CA because that's where the companies that hire well paid engineers congregate, and they (mostly) want those well paid engineers to come to the office every couple of days. I don't know how you could get the causality so completely backwards on this.
- AdamN 1y agoDepends on the type of engineer - NYC for fintech is also a top spot, Boston for robotics, etc...
- ozozozd 1y agoAnecdotal evidence: I moved to CA twice as an engineer. Once to get my masters after college. Stayed for 13 years. Left during COVID. Second time to raise kids. Our reasons include weather, intellectual atmosphere, safety (in many regards), schools, and job opportunities. The geo area sandwiched between Berkeley and Stanford is only rivaled by Boston. You think Stanford and Berkeley are in the Bay because they’re told to? And I would also question: what’s the point of living in US if you’re not in California? Once you decide to not live in CA, a bunch of other countries rank better than other US states. Such as Canada, Australia, New Zealand. If I were to not live in CA, even the imperial units would quickly become annoying.
- FajitaNachos 1y agoHow many other places, inside and outside the U.S., have you lived?
- yellow_postit 1y agoThe Texas Stock Exchange launches next year and I predict we will see a lot of tech try to move to launch there given txse claim to have lower compliance and less esg needs.
- afavour 1y agoIt’s frauds all the way down
- vessenes 1y agodownvoted -- this is a low quality comment, and worse, it's uninformed. Texas may be lower reg than NASDAQ at launch, and it may compete for business that way, and consumers may or may not like this and may or may not benefit from it. However, post Sarbox US is vastly more regulated than the markets that "built" Silicon Valley, and there are many costs to corporations, founders and employees of that heavier regulation -- including a radically less friendly public capital market for companies worth hundreds of millions of dollars.
- everfrustrated 1y agoI learned recently that Nasdaq imposes DEI on companies as a requirement of listing.
- kasey_junk 1y agoThe 5th circuit struck those rules down last year.
- nradov 1y agoI doubt it. The state where a company is incorporated or has its headquarters located doesn't impact where it can list shares. There are several foreign companies with no significant US operations which are listed on US stock markets just to gain access to capital.
- kasey_junk 1y ago
- wubrr 1y agoThe location you're physically sitting in doesn't really matter. Saying 'san francisco cause san francisco' is also kinda boring and meaningless.
- vessenes 1y agoThis is the opposite of true. It's actively wrong. Location is almost everything; people move to financial and tech centers for a reason -- it matters where you are and who you know.
- wubrr 1y agonah also, where you are and who you know are very different things
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> where you are and who you know are very different things Different but related. Getting a purposeful introduction involves a lot more friction than being invited to someone's home for dinner with their colleagues and contacts.
- wubrr 1y agoYou seem to assume dinner parties and in-person social engineering is the key to success. I guess I have a different opinion - the tech, the product, the efficiency is the key to success.
- Jackpillar 1y agoThis is so funny to imply that you (living in East Jesus, Texas) have a better or similar opportunity to me (living in SF) in making more relationships and connections to AI related companies, engineers, investors, customers, acquirers, scientists, etc.
- wubrr 1y ago
- BobaFloutist 1y agoThat still doesn't explain the value of Sam Altman's pinky promise.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> doesn't explain the value of Sam Altman's pinky promise The MOU [1] requires OpenAI "provide at least 21 days’ prior written notice to the Attorney General before consenting to: (a) a change of control of the PBC; (b) any change to the PBC mission as set out in the PBC Delaware charter; (c) any amendment to the PBC Delaware charter that would remove the NFP’s sole right, as holder of the Class N shares, to appoint PBC directors or otherwise reduces in any material respect the rights of the Class N shares; or (d) the relocation of the headquarters of the NFP or PBC outside of California" [1]. The meat appears to be in the agreements by OpenAI to not change its ownership and control structure. California's real leverage would be in re-opening this dispute, though ¶ 22 seems to water down that power somewhat. (Maybe go after the donors?) [1] https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press-docs/Final%20Executed%20MOU%20Between%20OpenAI%20and%20California%20AG%20re%20Notice%20of%20Conditions%20of%20Non-Objection%20%2810.27.2025%29%20%28Signed%20by%20OpenAI%29%20%28Signed%20by%20CA%20DOJ%29.pdf https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press-docs/Final... ¶ 19
- terminalshort 1y agoSeems a little easier than that, though, because there are no supply chains involved (other than for the data centers, but those are already not in SF). Why else would the CA government be worried?
- standardUser 1y agoThere's books written about the Bay Area and the factors that make (or made) it uniquely suited for developing new technologies. There's even college courses about it. Some of it's surely provincial fluff, but it's undeniable that California has been an essential incubator for a whole series of world-changing, fortune-making technologies.
- okdood64 1y ago> There's books written Which?
- terminalshort 1y agoI don't want to downplay the network effects here, but it's in CA entirely by coincidence. SV is in CA because William Shockley's family is there, which is why he founded Shockley Semiconductor there. It could have been somewhere else. The 2nd largest tech hub is in Seattle. It's there because that's were Bill Gates is from. Is SF the best place to start a startup if you want in office talent in 2025. 100% yes, but that has nothing to do with the Bay Area and everything to do with accidents of history.
- CPLX 1y agoIt goes back way way further than that. The special mix of government funded technology, ruthless entrepreneurship, and social engineering predates Shockley by almost 100 years. Start by figuring out who Leland Stanford is and how he got rich. Read the book ‘Palo Alto’ if you’re looking for a good starting point.
- vlovich123 1y ago