21 ms·
America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy
- SunshineTheCat 1y agohttps://archive.ph/enwf6 https://archive.ph/enwf6
- reactordev 1y agoYes yes it’s the children’s fault. We didn’t hold them to high standards. We didn’t… give me a break. It’s declining because media is shifting. It’s declining because tools are replacing that need. Smartphones yes but more advanced computers as well. Communication has increased in speed and people have never had more access to speech platforms to spread whatever diatribe they wish. Test scores that test one’s general knowledge are going to show gaps as we specialize.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- eximius 1y agoThere is (some) truth to this but it fundamentally _does not_ replace foundational learning.
- reactordev 1y agoNot saying it does but what I am saying is it’s not two brackets anymore. It’s not Math & Literacy defined by one’s ability to do long divisional polynomials and identify the problematic grammar of some sub paragraph from a book from 1880s. The reality is the testing and scores don’t reflect reality and everyone’s in arms over it instead of looking at the testing methodology.
- eximius 1y agoBut they do reflect ones ability to learn to get to the heights of education where you can be trusted to wield the new tools wisely.
- reactordev 1y agoRight… like a trained monkey to put the blocks in the hole. I have yet to see anyone wield tools wisely that requires higher education outside of CERN.
- b00ty4breakfast 1y agothe problem isn't test scores. if anything, that kind of metrification of education is precisely the cause of this inability to comprehend and understand. And that is what is actually happening here; it's not merely a matter of literally being unable to read and it's not merely limited to the written word. And it's frankly not even a matter of people being stupid or ignorant.
- reactordev 1y agoCompletely agree. The tests aren’t up to snuff with technology and how the world consumes media - text and academia included.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jf 1y agoIt’s weird, and a little unnerving, to have a line from Anathem by Neil Stephenson immediately come to mind: “Can you read? And by that I don’t just mean interpreting Logotype…” “No one uses that any more,” said Quin. “You’re talking about the symbols on your underwear that tell you not to use bleach. That sort of thing.”
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Jtsummers 1y agoI haven't read that book, but the concept is also in his book The Diamond Age.
- Liquix 1y agoMediatronic glyphs on our chopsticks when? Love the way the Nell's vocabulary and disposition evolve as the Primer (or Miranda) teaches her to spell, read, and eventually understand Turing machines via binary and logic gates.
- trenchpilgrim 1y agoI don't remember that line in Anathem. It seemd pretty clear that the Saecular society at the time of the novel was a literate, 21st century tech level. e.g. there were characters like Samman who was basically a sysadmin.
- WolfeReader 1y agoIt's in the first chapter. The quote you were replying to was in the book, verbatim.
- ashton314 1y agoThey all use Kinagrams—a moving picture script. Very few are literate. Well-off burgers typically can read and write, but lots of the workers and virtually all the slines can't read.
- baggy_trough 1y agoThey pretend to learn and we pretend to test them.
- 0xEF 1y agoSliding? I'd say we're running toward it, what with all the anti-intellectualism and attacks on education. After all, can't have all those smarty-pants kids turning into bossy-pants adults, now can we?
- bad_haircut72 1y agoBetween this, Chinas rise (the lights-out factories etc) and the gestures around general atmosphere here in the USA it really doesnt seem like we're in for a good 20-50 years.
- techblueberry 1y agoI do wonder, and this is probably way too optimistic - but if China or another country were to open their economy, I wonder if there would be benefit to perhaps some of the wealth leaving the US, especially as too many of our modern businesses are too extractive.
- davidw 1y agoWhat's kind of depressing about this moment in general is that there isn't really a 'shining beacon on the hill'. If you don't like autocracy, China is way worse than the US. Europe is good in a lot of ways, but kind of muddling along in others - and won't even policy democratic backsliders like Hungary.
- esafak 1y agoCanada could benefit.
- nawgz 1y agoAs a Canadian... Canada is weak, poor, and corrupted by the same plague that has lead America to where it sits. The rule of law is holding on a bit tighter, and quality of life isn't as bleak as the States, but Canada needs some serious reforms to break the hold of the elite class. Seriously, look at how the temporary foreign worker program enriched the elites and then is used by their centralized media machines to radicalize the population against immigrants. It's a bad joke, and this exact regulatory capture runs deep and wide.
- I-M-S 1y ago
- mandeepj 1y agoI love the poorly educated - DJT. Sure, that’s what republicans want and it serves them well. Dismantling, arms twisting, and attacks on universities - is all from their playbook. They’ve started saying universities are indoctrinating kids. If you don’t speak against these evil creatures now, there isn’t going to be another chance. They are just taliban in a suit!!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tyleo 1y agoThis take is partisan and not aligned with fact. You may be surprised to hear that Mississippi, Louisiana, Alabama, and Tennessee are all seeing improvements. Here’s more information on that: https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choice https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choi...
- gowld 1y agoPutting a kidin 3rd grade twice, and then saying "more 4th graders can read" is just gaming the metrics. Are MS, LA, AL, TN students reading at a higher level by age ?
- tyleo 1y agoI disagree because learning is cumulative. If you can’t read or do math at a 3rd grade level and we shove you through 4th, 5th, etc, you enter an unrecoverable state.
- consumer451 1y agoThe reason to fight against university education was laid out plainly in the 2012 Texas GOP platform. While not directly related to TFA, it clearly shows the reasoning to limit aspects of education. > Yes, you read that right. The party opposes the teaching of “higher order thinking skills” because it believes the purpose is to challenge a student’s “fixed beliefs” and undermine “parental authority.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/texas-gop-rejects-critical-thinking-skills-really/2012/07/08/gJQAHNpFXW_blog.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/texas... https://www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2012/07/01/texas-gop-platform/?sh=8496cd5666da https://www.forbes.com/sites/johntharvey/2012/07/01/texas-go...
- squidsoup 1y agoPurely anecdotal, but most of the kids in my son's cohort, early 20s, have received what would be considered by most to be a good education, but don't read for pleasure. I find that worrying.
- saulpw 1y agoI also didn't read for pleasure in my 20s and even much of my 30s. Forced reading in high school (of material I didn't enjoy, in quantity, and frequently fell behind on, and felt bad about failing) ruined it for me for about 15 years. But the trauma faded with time and now I read some 10-30 books a year. So maybe it's not permanent for your son's cohort either.
- JLO64 1y agoI second this. I hated (perhaps not consciously) being forced to read books in high school, however recently I’ve gone back and started rereading those books I was assigned and have loved it!
- anon291 1y agoIt's probably not a good education. If your kid is in an average public school they were probably not taught to read phonetically. Unless you as parents taught that separately, all these kids are handicapped.
- nxor 1y agoDon't we though? My generation is also known for watching hour long youtube videos (video essays), and even if that's not all of us, that's more than past generations (of course). And we are known for listening to hour long podcasts. Even if these podcasters are not necessarily as informed or as rigorous (same for youtube), I think my generation still in some ways shows a curiosity for information That said I mostly agree with this and think for one, if foreign language was appreciated more here, maybe people would read more
- nawgz 1y agoPodcasts are horrible content slop that are appealing more because one can enjoy the parasocial relationship it offers rather than because the podcasters are insightful or informative.
- Apreche 1y ago> School spending did not decline from 2012 to 2022. In fact, it increased significantly, even after adjusting for inflation, from $14,000 a student to more than $16,000. Is this average spending per student? If so, then that is just a cover for inequality. Spending a vast amount on educating elite students, and spending hardly enough on the majority. Other countries with much better education than the US spend less than $16,000 per student, but I imagine they are spending much more equitably. They don’t have one school that is incredible and then another school so broke that teachers and parents have to foot the bill for supplies.
- gowld 1y agomost spending-per-student goes to the poorest or most-disabled students, not to the elite students. By definition, elite students are a tiny fraction, so evern if they get overspending, it won't move the average unless they are getting absurd multiples of the median, which they are noy getting.
- WillPostForFood 1y agoThe top elite kids aren't in public schools, so they don't even factor into the equation. Whether there is inequality in spending will depend on the state and whether the funding is local, or redistributive. But if you take California as an example, they do try to make sure money goes to poor students, and it has had no positive effect. California sends mor to Black, Latino, and low income students than white or high income students. https://www.ppic.org/publication/financing-californias-public-schools/ https://www.ppic.org/publication/financing-californias-publi...
- rezonant 1y agoActually this isn't the whole picture. Because a lot of funding for schools comes from local property taxes, affluent areas tend to have more resources for education than poorer areas, regardless of how they school their kids. And if a lot of higher income students aren't utilizing public school, that's less students to spend the increased money on, which would exacerbate the view when looked at as a national per-student average.
- nabla9 1y agoYou must read well to write well. Writes and Writes not (October 2024) https://www.paulgraham.com/writes.html https://www.paulgraham.com/writes.html >I'm usually reluctant to make predictions about technology, but I feel fairly confident about this one: in a couple decades there won't be many people who can write. >One of the strangest things you learn if you're a writer is how many people have trouble writing. Doctors know how many people have a mole they're worried about; people who are good at setting up computers know how many people aren't; writers know how many people need help writing. >The reason so many people have trouble writing is that it's fundamentally difficult. To write well you have to think clearly, and thinking clearly is hard. ...
- _qswe 1y agoAnyone who spends any amount of time perusing discussions on social media will quickly observe what a rare gift strong reading comprehension turns out to be.
- tyleo 1y agoThis was on HN a few weeks ago and provides a similar take: https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choice https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choi... It has examples of states which are seeing some improvements. Those states seem to be addressing one of the main problems this article highlights: they hold students to expectations and prevent them from advancing grades if they don’t meet the bar.
- rglover 1y ago"You'll graduate more competent students with this one simple trick." /s
- tyleo 1y agoThere’s a few other things they do. The link I shared actually provides 3 examples. I just thought it aligned particularly well with the OP on that specific point.
- mindslight 1y agoUgh, 3 simple tricks sounds too hard. I'm not going to read something that long. (/s)
- gjsman-1000 1y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> remember when the popular academic consensus was "you can't imprison your way into a safe society." Who said this? I thought the argument was always you can’t do this and maintain the high living standards of a modern economy built on the rule of law. It’s essentially a challenge to a society: fuck up enough on security and you lose the fruits and freedoms of a modern state fielding a growing economy. > more or less saying "you can't just discipline children." Who said this? I thought the argument was it inhibits learning in the long run and is not fair to poor kids or something. (We know that’s B.S. now.) But totally unrelated to El Salvador.
- throw7 1y ago[flagged]
- edoceo 1y agoWhat the hell?
- anon291 1y agoIt's declined because a generation of students was not taught to read because teachers decided that phonics was a conservative dog whistle. To not be associated with George w Bush, they failed our children. There's really not much else to it. Laura Bush's push for literacy was well intentioned but she did not anticipate the anti phonics backlash that would ensue due to her husband's politics. The is not some kook take, yet no one talks about it in general discourse, despite plenty of reporting on it. Teachers unions and public schools in general, which typically lean left, have been fighting a war on phonics for several decades. My mother, who was a teacher herself, noted this. She was not born in the US, so didn't understand why it was seen as political to teach children sounding out words. https://www.forbes.com/sites/nataliewexler/2022/04/12/lets-not-make-phonics-political-again/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/nataliewexler/2022/04/12/lets-n... We have this idea in America that conservatives are dumb and want lower standards for education. Of course, figures like Trump totally substantiate this idea, but in reality, both sides are invested in making America stupider. Yes, Democrats attract more educated voters, but often times these voters are exceptional and their kids wouldn't suffer the same fate as a typical child. Until at least one party takes education seriously, nothing will change
- a1pulley 1y agoThis is (anecdotally) not true for families in the highest income decile (in California). Kids are pushed harder to learn things earlier than when I was growing up. For example, nearly all of my kid's classmates could read before they started kindergarten. All could do basic arithmetic. Now that he's in first grade, most can read chapter books and have a grasp of multiplication. My mom pushed me hard to get me ahead of my peers, but I didn't hit those milestones until a year later. The standards and expectations are extremely high now because it's never been harder to get a spot at a top 20 university—perhaps because a top 20 school is the best chance you can get to maintain your living standards.
- kulahan 1y agoI've not seen anything saying all kids are lacking in important skills these days, but rather they all seem (to me) to imply that we're on the way to an even more-stratified society. Smart kids will be just as educated as smart kids used to be - probably even moreso. Dumb kids will fall further and further behind, and the middle range of "kinda smart at a bunch of stuff" will disappear. With the extreme stratification of wealth follows the stratification of... everything else, really.
- BrenBarn 1y ago> With the extreme stratification of wealth follows the stratification of... everything else, really. That's one reason that the solution to educational inequalities may not lie in education policy at all, but in tax/economic policy. Maybe the most expedient way to improve education outcomes is to just take a large amount of money from wealthy people and give it to everyone else.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Maybe the most expedient way to improve education outcomes is to just take a large amount of money from wealthy people and give it to everyone else Given the evidence in the article, wouldn't it make sense to try simply holding students to standards--the thing that caused the last wave of achievement gain--instead of another novel and divisive policy treatment?
- gjsman-1000 1y agoIf Mississippi can read, and California can't, the future of Silicon Valley might be in red states.
- gowld 1y agoCalifornia is an economic powerhouse because people who could read (and more) moved to California for opportunity, not because they were educated in California.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoPerhaps. Growing up though in the 70's, it was well known that California public schools ranked best in the country.
- gdulli 1y agoI know why saying those words makes you feel good in the moment, but read them back to yourself and imagine how they sound to someone who's not coming from that same place as you.
- darth_avocado 1y agoSilicon Valley is full of immigrants. Any place that actively dislikes them and is hostile to them is probably not going to replace it. And contrary to popular narrative, the Bay Area boast school districts in the country. And if you look at top school districts in the country by any measurable metric, most of them are in blue states. I think Silicon Valley will be fine where it is.
- estimator7292 1y agoThis was an intentional plan to keep the population stupid and fearful. It's been happening for the last 40 years or so. We've been systematically and intentionally dismantling and rendering ineffective, our education system.
- someothherguyy 1y ago> This was an intentional plan to keep the population stupid and fearful A plan by whom and to what end? What does keeping the population afraid and stupid do that benefits the planner?
- genghisjahn 1y agoWho’s intentional plan? Where is this plan documented?
- legitster 1y ago> But the smartphone thesis has a few weak spots. It’s not just middle schoolers and high schoolers whose performance is declining; it’s also kids in elementary school. Phone use has certainly increased among young children, but not to the ubiquitous proportions of adolescents. Easy. Parents of young children are on their phones more than ever before. That means less reading and more screen time. One of the single largest determiners of schooling success is the number of books at home. Kids who are exposed to books and reading at home overwhelmingly out-achieve kids who are not. It starts earlier than people think and the effects are longer lived than people think. School standards have almost nothing to do with it.
- greygoo222 1y ago> One of the single largest determiners of schooling success is the number of books at home. This "effect" is the textbook example of correlation != causation. By which I mean, it was literally in my AP Psych textbook in high school.
- bodiekane 1y agoExcept, programs which give free books to children in households without books demonstrably improve reading. There's a correlation component, but also there absolutely is a causal connection of access to books and parents reading to children.
- devilbunny 1y agoBut it’s also a big potential confounder, and I certainly don’t know the literature well enough to say how well they managed to account for that - not that education research has a ton of great studies, but they’re unlikely to all be colossal mistakes. Lots of books in the home? Great: you have parents who read for enjoyment, have a stable space for living that has lots of room for books (in the pre-eBook/tablet era, my book collection at college was maybe 1/10 of the books in my parents’ house that were specifically mine, not theirs; just their casual reading filled a wall, and they could afford to install built-in shelves as opposed to moving frequently and having to move both books and shelves), and enough money to buy books. Imagination Library (or similar) can fix the last one, but not the first two.
- ThrowMeAway1618 1y agoTL;DR Isn't there a video or a podcast of this? /s
- higgins 1y agocan someone summarize this with emoji or an animated gif please?
- nostrademons 1y agoIt seems to be reversing, at least among affluent kids. "Sold a story" had a huge impact on the educational establishment. My local district reintroduced phonics for the 2023-2024 school year, and reintroduced it in kindergarten. By the end of kindergarten, every single one of my kid's classmates could read. This class is today's 2nd graders; they are avid readers today, I'll usually run into one of them walking with a book in front of their face at aftercare. They're too young to show up in the test scores, though, because these kids won't have their first round of standardized testing for another 2 years. Schools and parents are also banning cell phones and cutting down on computer use, which should help with the distraction angle. The socioeconomic divide mentioned in the article is still worrisome, though. I doubt that kids in the bottom 30% of America have the same experience. And simultaneously, the middle class has largely stopped having kids, which means there's a top 20% and a bottom 30% and pretty much nothing in between. If this continues for another couple generations, we're potentially faced with an America of an educated nobility and illiterate peasantry, and the future may look very Medieval indeed.
- coliveira 1y agoThe enemy of reading nowadays is not phonics alternatives, it is the excessive use of screens that kills focus and the desire to learn anything that doesn't move.
- sixtyj 1y agoThis. People skim, they don’t read. Back in the 90's when they were looking for a killer app for browsers, who knew that video would be the real killer app (of the brain and attention).
- jihadjihad 1y agoI think it's counterproductive to provide Chromebooks and iPads to students, but the "excessive use of screens" in my experience is by and large a parenting issue. And it's not just about boundaries around devices, like time limits or app restrictions. It's about setting the right example and providing an environment where reading a book is as stimulating and desirable and encouraged as playing a game every once in a while on an iPad. It's telling that the second part of your sentence applies equally well to adults as children. And children cannot be held accountable for poor habits that are largely a consequence of their environment.
- constantcrying 1y agoI think the most important thing for literacy is a nationwide culture of reading. That has stopped existing over the last decades. Parents do not read and so neither do their children. Reading is now a niche hobby. If you visit a book store you will also find out that most "readers" are a very niche group, who mostly read genre fiction or crime slop. The amount of people actually reading intellectually challenging literature is miniscule. Is it any surprise to have an illiteracy problem in a country where nobody reads?
- WolfeReader 1y ago"We should read fewer books that I don't like, and more books that I do like." https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/nov/23/science-fiction-triggers-poorer-reading-study-finds https://www.theguardian.com/books/2017/nov/23/science-fictio...
- constantcrying 1y agoI have read maybe a thousand books of fantasy or science fiction, including 10k pages long fantasy series. Some of it was good, but most of it was pure slop. People read for a variety of reasons and I am not saying that people should not be reading their genre fiction slop. But to a culture of reading belongs the idea that reading challenging works is also important and that a deeper meaning is to be found in classical works. If we want a society which reads we need books which are more than movies without images. We need to tell adults that reading is a worthwhile endeavor, especially when reading complex material. Only then literacy can rise again, because only then will people believe that it is important to be able to read.
- WolfeReader 1y agoWho is it that distinguishes the "slop" (you love that word) from the complex? You seem to be focused on the idea of genre, which is orthagonal to the quality of the prose, the depth of the characters, the complexity of the themes, etc. You might as well focus on the size of the font.
- bendigedig 1y ago> America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy America is Sliding Towards Autocracy - FTFY
- lukewrites 1y agoThe authoritarian creep has certainly been facilitated by developing a culture of intellectual apathy.
- programjames 1y agoI believe the issue is measures of 'achievement' and 'excellence' typically use the 20th and 50th percentiles, respectively. For example, most education studies focus on what improves graduation rates, passing rates, or the bottom 10–20% on standardized assessments. Most school districts' financial incentives rely on these metrics as well. Occasionally you'll get a study that looks at the median (and even more rare, the 90th percentile), but no standardized assessment even showcases the bellends of the distribution. This is why you get claims like this > High-achieving kids are doing roughly as well as they always have, while those at the bottom are seeing rapid losses in the article, when they're actually doing much worse as well, which can be seen from the median (or top) scores in STEM competitions. All the financial incentives are for schools and teachers to focus on their bottom 20% of students, and even if they cared about their top students (culturally, most education departments do not), it's not even feasible to collect that data, short of signing everyone up for the AMC 12. So, naturally, the percent of elementary schools offering gifted programs has declined by fifteen (twenty?) percent in the last twenty years, and the general standards and curricula have been lowered to teach to the 20th percentile. This also creates a cultural issue where many students recognize they're bored, and that schools are not trying to teach them, so they become disaffected and stop caring. My friends in high school joked that school was for socializing, and frankly, what other purpose does it serve anymore for most kids?
- jltsiren 1y ago> My friends in high school joked that school was for socializing, and frankly, what other purpose does it serve anymore for most kids? Schools have always been like that, at least if you ask the kids. The difference is whether the parents value education and expect their kids to work hard and study, or if they only see the school as a daycare center that allows them to work full time. And whether the wider society values education.
- programjames 1y agoI don't think schools have always been like that. I especially don't think schools have been like that for the top 10% of students until very recently (<20 years).
- mcphage 1y agoThis article is a weird mix of things. Early on we see: > States were given latitude to spend their funds as they saw fit, which, it seems, was a mistake. Instead of funding high-quality tutoring programs or other programs that benefited students, districts spent money for professional development or on capital expenditures such as replacing HVAC systems and obtaining electric buses. And then later, discussing Mississippi: > it began screening kids for reading deficiencies, training instructors in how to teach reading better (by, among other things, emphasizing phonics), and hiring literacy coaches to work in the lowest-performing schools. Leaving aside the idea that capital expenditures on aging school buildings and busses is a mistake instead of an absolute requirement, the author criticizes states that spent money on professional development, and then later praised Mississippi for (among other things) training instructors—that's what professional development is.
- mhink 1y agoAn article posted elsewhere in the comments (https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choice https://www.theargumentmag.com/p/illiteracy-is-a-policy-choi...) has a take that might explain a distinction: > Billions of dollars are spent — and largely wasted — every year on professional development for teachers that is curriculum-agnostic, i.e., aimed at generic, disembodied teaching skills without reference to any specific curriculum. > “A huge industry is invested in these workshops and trainings,” argued a scathing 2020 article by David Steiner, executive director of the Johns Hopkins Institute for Education Policy. “Given, on average, barely more than a single day of professional support to learn about the new materials; knowing that their students will face assessments that lack any integration with their curriculum; and subject to principals’ evaluations that don’t assess curriculum use, teachers across America are barely using these new shiny objects — old habits win out.” > Mississippi improved its training through a 2013 law mandating that elementary school teachers receive instruction in the science of reading. It also sent coaches directly into low-performing classrooms to guide teachers on how to use material.
- afpx 1y agoDoes it take into account ESL? I know at least at my daughters school, kids with English-speaking parents score very well. The others score very low, on average. I notice when I pick up my daughter that the ESL kids group together and only speak their native language though. So, it's not surprising.
- bariumbitmap 1y agoThe article does not take into account ESL. In fact, greater participation of ESL kids or those with disabilities appears to be a major reason the NAEP test scores have changed over time: > In addition, since 1996, main NAEP assessments have been providing accommodations to allow more students with disabilities and students who were not fluent in English to participate. Traditionally, the long-term trend assessments have not provided such accommodations. However, in 2004, it was possible to provide accommodations and assess a greater proportion of students. https://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/ltt/bridge_study.aspx https://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/ltt/bridge_study.aspx
- jMyles 1y ago> What exactly went wrong? The decline began well before the pandemic, so COVID-era disruptions alone cannot explain it. The NEAP follows cohorts which are four years apart in age - where (and how, and why) did The Atlantic rasterize this to "the decline"? ...and yes, the NEAP shows that all three of these cohorts suffered terribly from the school closures in parts of the USA, just as every serious expert predicted. The differences in the NEAP math unit are particularly obvious. It feels very strange to cast this aside with a single sentence and no further analysis.
- lukewrites 1y agoThere's really interesting research about children/people learning to read without formal instruction; as John Taylor Gatto points out in Dumbing Us Down, back when Thomas Paine was writing, there were ~600,000 copies of Common Sense printed for a population of three million. People learned to read on their own or with very little instruction because they were interested in reading. There's a convincing body of evidence that the way you get kids to read books is pretty simple: read them books that interest them and then give them access to more interesting books as well as time to read to self. Unfortunately, the lethal combo of Common Core and No Child Left Behind has left teachers at best too time-strapped (or, at worst, uninterested) in doing so because of mandatory curriculum and testing. I read to my kids, make sure they see me reading, and talk to them about both what I'm reading and what they're reading. They've done fine despite awful reading instruction at school.
- JohnMakin 1y agoCrazy not one mention of whole word learning and the disaster it has been since it's been rolled out across the country: https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-how-schools-teach-reading https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-ho... It's largely discredited, yet it still persists.
- tyleo 1y agoTruthfully I think this is actually getting phased out. That’s one win at least.
- pessimizer 1y agoThis is a new and bad definition of illiteracy. America is more literate than it has ever been; it started with Harry Potter, and grew with the internet. Everybody can read, and that was not true when I was a kid, because English is hard to read. You mostly have to read to participate on the internet. The lack of basic communication ability of the people on the early internet was shocking, and that's all gone. I rarely run into people who capitalize Every Single Word any more, and I never thought that would happen. The problem is that kids are stupid, because their parents are teaching them (and demanding they repeat) a number of bizarre views of the world, and all of the media they consume is propagandistic and dumb. That's what's showing up on reading comprehension tests. Not that they don't understand the words, but that they lack the ability to put together a complex thought because they have been encouraged not to have them; that complex thoughts are suspicious, weird, and try-hard and make them feel like they're about to look stupid; and that having a thought by yourself is the surest way to be ostracized and to deserve to be. They're scared to think, they've been crippled. They just want you to tell them what to say, so they can get back to their video game, or to TikTok.
- pavon 1y ago> From 2000 to 2007, the bottom tenth of fourth graders in reading ability showed substantial improvement, before stagnating. But by 2024, those gains had been erased. Your interactions with people online include the cohort whose reading scores improved while they were in school, and is unlikely to include many current young school children whose scores are falling.
- recallingmemory 1y ago“I have a foreboding of an America in my children's or grandchildren's time -- when the United States is a service and information economy; when nearly all the manufacturing industries have slipped away to other countries; when awesome technological powers are in the hands of a very few, and no one representing the public interest can even grasp the issues; when the people have lost the ability to set their own agendas or knowledgeably question those in authority; when, clutching our crystals and nervously consulting our horoscopes, our critical faculties in decline, unable to distinguish between what feels good and what's true, we slide, almost without noticing, back into superstition and darkness. The dumbing down of America is most evident in the slow decay of substantive content in the enormously influential media, the 30 second sound bites (now down to 10 seconds or less), lowest common denominator programming, credulous presentations on pseudoscience and superstition, but especially a kind of celebration of ignorance.” - Carl Sagan, 1995
- kouru225 1y agoWhat I’m most surprised by is how visually illiterate the older generations seem to be. As a video editor, I’ve encountered multiple moments where an older person is incapable of even noticing that we’ve cut from one angle to another, and the amount of times I’ve had to convince them that “yes the audience will absolutely notice that incredibly obvious mistake and we need to fix it” is astronomical. I’ve seen video after video of old people seemingly incapable of identifying even the most basic CGI or AI videos. And all you techies know how clearly this issue extends into the basic usage of a computer interface. How many times do I need to remind my dad how to turn on the subtitles? We can sit here and lambast the younger generations all we want, but I refuse to do it without accurately comparing them to the previous generations, which IMO were clearly less capable than we previously thought.
- criddell 1y agoBack when high def TVs were relatively new and cable TV and separate channels for SD and HD feeds, it used to drive me crazy that my parents would watch the SD channel with the image stretched to fit the screen. I’d show them where the HD channel was (it was something like SD channel # + 200) but they just didn’t care. The stretched SD image was good enough.
- kouru225 1y agoI’m almost certain that if we were to do a test, less than 10% of 60+ year olds would be able to identify a messed up aspect ratio.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoTech illiteracy at some age groups is insane to me. I understand that my 93 year old grandma wasn't great at this sort of thing. But I encounter people who are in their 20s who don't know how to print a document, or people in their 50s falling for obvious AI scams. Didn't Jurassic Park come out in 93? Did they just think people were getting eaten by dinosaurs?
- walkabout 1y agoMedia literacy seems to be one of those things it's easy to forget you ever had to learn. I'm routinely amazed at how little of it most other people are capable of, when a lot of it is now so automatic for me that I can't turn it off, it's just a permanent part of how I experience things—but at some point I'm sure I was about that limited, and I'm better at it now only because I found improving my literacy to be interesting and fun, so I effortlessly put a lot of time into it. Still, the idea of watching as much video, listening to as much music, et c., as most people do and not putting a little thought & effort into "reading" it better/more-fully seems like an odd choice, yet it's the norm. Apparently not even wanting to engage with the "why did the creator make that choice? OK, this part achieves effect X, but how does it do that? What does it seem like this other part was trying to do, and does that illuminate or enhance any elements of or mysteries in the rest of the work?" side of things seems totally alien to me.
- sgustard 1y agoThe performance of kids in school reflects adult behaviors. Number of books Americans read per year is "a smaller number than Gallup has measured in any prior survey dating back to 1990" per https://news.gallup.com/poll/388541/americans-reading-fewer-books-past.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/388541/americans-reading-fewer-...
- lexarflash8g 1y agoI notice the trend that people are reading much less in public and on public transporation -- before if you went on a long-haul flight you would bring a couple of books or magazines, now people much prefer to consuming video content. On a flight every row I saw passengers either watching a movie on their phone/laptop/ or screen seat. If you walk into a cafe it would be odd to see someone reading a book. And its almost impossible to buy physical newspapers even the Sunday edition for the NY Times as most grocery stores or convenience stores don't carry them. Personally I'm also guilty of listening to more podcasts and background play -- but I only watch YT visual content when its interesting there is just too much stuff out there. I consume most of my news online -- so my reading comes from mostly articles. Its just more convenient and practical now -- though requires much less effort than say reading longer form content of a book or long essay. Lately I've been going on TikTok just out of curiosity for entertainmentto watch amusing or funny videos. Its basically like digital crack -- before you know it you spent an hour just watching mindless content and its designed to get you hooked. It really is low-effort instant gratification at its worst (probably worse than porn -- because you stop after a while once satisfied.) And you see kids as old as 1-2 years old with personal devices watching videos -- so it seems to be a disturbing trend And I heard that professors don't even assign books since they know their students won't read them and will just ChatGPT for summaries.
- stronglikedan 1y agoNot surprising considering the DoE has been failing the American people for decades. Now that we're slowly giving education back to the states, where it belongs, the trend will start to reverse if it hasn't already.
- bariumbitmap 1y agoThe article argues that giving control of education back to the states was a mistake: > States were given latitude to spend their funds as they saw fit, which, it seems, was a mistake. Instead of funding high-quality tutoring programs or other programs that benefited students, districts spent money for professional development or on capital expenditures such as replacing HVAC systems and obtaining electric buses. “The scientific term for this is that we didn’t get jack shit out of that money,” says Michael Petrilli, the president of the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, an education-policy think tank. “There are some studies that can detect small impacts, but they’re small. I think it’s also fair to say that a lot of the money was wasted.” > Then, in 2015, Congress passed the Every Student Succeeds Act, which returned responsibility for improving low-performing schools to the states. But according to Martin West, the academic dean of Harvard’s education school, “most states have not been particularly ambitious in the design of those systems.”
- btown 1y agoReading https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-how-schools-teach-reading https://www.apmreports.org/episode/2019/08/22/whats-wrong-ho... (2019) was eye-opening for me. It's a must-read companion piece if you want to take this Atlantic article seriously, particularly with some of the politicization the Atlantic article tries to inject. From the Atlantic article: > An explanation that deserves equal consideration is what one might call the low-expectations theory. In short, schools have demanded less and less from students—who have responded, predictably, by giving less and less. The APM Reports article I linked above, in this context, would likely suggest that "low-expectations theory" might actually be an effect of a specific and well-intentioned methodology change: one that replaces phonics-based approaches with an effort to get pupils through books rather than being able to read every word. From APM Reports: > For decades, reading instruction in American schools has been rooted in a flawed theory about how reading works, a theory that was debunked decades ago by cognitive scientists, yet remains deeply embedded in teaching practices and curriculum materials. As a result, the strategies that struggling readers use to get by — memorizing words, using context to guess words, skipping words they don't know — are the strategies that many beginning readers are taught in school. This makes it harder for many kids to learn how to read, and children who don't get off to a good start in reading find it difficult to ever master the process. It goes on to describe the origins of the different methodologies, historical reactions, plenty of context on adoption, visual examples. There's an ongoing debate here, but it provides real food for thought. The Atlantic article could have done something similar, focusing on the methodologies at hand. Instead, it tries to conclude by assigning blame based on political affiliation: > But for Democrats, who pride themselves on belonging to the party of education, these results may be awkward to process. Not only are the southern states that are registering the greatest improvements in learning run by Republicans, but also their teachers are among the least unionized in the country. And these red states are leaning into phonics-based, “science of reading” approaches to teaching literacy, while Democratic-run states such as New York, New Jersey, and Illinois have been painfully slow to adopt them, in some cases hanging on to other pedagogical approaches with little evidentiary basis. The article provides no quantitative backing for these statements, much less evidence of causality. (The research they do cite has Massachusetts in 4th place, and New York in 10th place, for adjusted reading scores: https://www.urban.org/research/publication/states-demographically-adjusted-performance-2024-national-assessment https://www.urban.org/research/publication/states-demographi...) It's a good reminder to read articles critically, and seek external sources, when blame is being ascribed.
- Animats 1y agoFrom the article: "One in four students today is chronically absent, meaning that they miss more than a tenth of instructional days, a substantial increase from pre-pandemic averages. ... Roughly 40 percent of middle-school teachers work in schools where there are no late penalties for coursework, no zeroes for missing coursework, and unlimited redos of tests." That alone may explain the declines in at the bottom. "80% of success is showing up", as Woody Allen once said.
- panny 1y agoMy favorite paragraph in the article: The experience of a few outlier states gives reason for optimism. Matthew Chingos and Kristin Blagg, two scholars at the Urban Institute, computed “demographically adjusted NAEP scores,” examining how effective states are at educating kids after accounting for significant differences in socioeconomic status. Their analysis of the 2024 NAEP results found that Mississippi was best at educating kids in fourth-grade math, fourth-grade reading, and eighth-grade math. (In 2013, Mississippi was at the bottom of the unadjusted league table.) When I computed the correlation between these demographically adjusted scores and state spending, I found that there was none. If you’re an underprivileged kid in America, you will, on average, get the best education not in rich Massachusetts but in poor Mississippi, where per-pupil spending is half as high.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- IT4MD 1y agoSliding? You mean racing. A simple example. We recently blocked chatgpt in our org. A large number of people sent in tickets with justifications like, "I use it to write reports", "I use it to write email" and more. My partner teaches at a major university (top 200 in the US). You know how they spend about 30 mins on test days? Making sure the students mark their scantrons correctly, so it matches the version of the test they took! The test are color coded, so if you took the "blue" test, then it's pretty obvious you need to mark the answer card with the Blue Test, not the yellow test, you've never took. Bridge too far. I won't go into how many have their fucking parents call the teacher to beg for grades, extensions, etc. Talk about disheartening. The Last Question book seems more prescient every single day.
- susiecambria 1y agoMy concern for illiteracy, dropping participation in summer reading programs, and the like has informed some of my gift giving and material donations. All the grands get books. And holiday giving to Angel Trees or Toys for Tots includes books and/or comic books. I know this annoys the latter and it frustrates and annoys the hell out of me.
- gregwebs 1y agoThe recent move away from phonics has been disastrous, and states that are using phonics now are seeing better results. > Some have called it the “Mississippi miracle” ... > A clear policy story is behind these improvements: imposing high standards while also giving schools the resources they needed to meet them. In 2013, Mississippi enacted a law requiring that third graders pass a literacy exam to be promoted to the next grade. It didn’t just issue a mandate, though; it began screening kids for reading deficiencies, training instructors in how to teach reading better (by, among other things, emphasizing phonics), and hiring literacy coaches to work in the lowest-performing schools. Louisiana’s improvements came about after a similar policy cocktail was administered, starting in 2021. I would be interested to know more about the approach with literacy coaches. I donate to a charity that does 1 on 1 reading tutoring: https://readingpowerinc.org/ https://readingpowerinc.org/ If we cannot as a society teach our children how to read, something is very wrong and we need to invest heavily in fixing it.
- joemi 1y agoI don't even understand how one could learn to read without phonics.
- Nasrudith 1y agoI know from my earliest memories that reading is possible from whole words if you are read to enough without being formally taught. Granted at that point my attention span was too lacking to really read books by myself, compared to being read to. But that basically amounts to probably just learning phonics indirectly through examples and drawing patterns, and specifically is an exception and not the norm. And children's books even if they don't use the phonetic alphabet teach through example when read properly. I don't know enough about whole language learning theory and its development aside from the fact that it has been discredited. Perhaps it was based off of the outliers and wrongly assuming that the higher end of the early literacy bell curve's techniques would be generally applicable?
- rayiner 1y ago> Around 2013, this progress began to stall out, and then to backslide dramatically. What exactly went wrong? The decline began well before the pandemic, so COVID-era disruptions alone cannot explain it. There is actually no change in reading scores before covid if you adjust for demographic change in the student population: https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/ltt/reading/student-group-scores/?age=9 https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/ltt/reading/student-group-.... Scores for white, black, and hispanic students went up consistently from 2000-2012 then stayed flat until 2020. The drop came only after covid.
- trentnix 1y agoIf you could quantify the benefits of literacy, I think you'd find a similar decline. The incentives for literacy, especially among kids, are less compelling than they used to be.
- anarticle 1y agoI was a product of DoDDS system: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/10/us/schools-pandemic-defense-department.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/10/us/schools-pandemic-defen... Somehow I ended up with a really high end education system, and went to public school my last few years. As I get on in age, I realize that school systems vary so wildly it is shocking. I thought that English was taught in a specific way letters -> phonics -> words -> sentences, but it appears that was abandoned for "Whole Language" approach which upon reading sounds insane to me! Some of my younger friends (young millennial, early Z) have real issues "sounding out words", and I guess that is the effect of no phonics. As much as it is socioeconomic divide, a nice part of DoDD schools is that the corporal's kids and the general's kids all go to the same school. To be fair, they are usually well funded and have career teachers, along with what is shaped like a national curriculum. The reason for this is if you move, and you will in the military, you can continue grades easily without having to interrupt your path. Ex: in DoDD school, 9th grade had "world history", which didn't coincide with my 10th grade move to public school which required "American history" in 9th grade, so I was held back(!) in history to take American with 9th graders when I was in 10th grade. Education, for the basics, in my mind should not deviate too hard from what we have learned over the years. It is fun and exciting to experiment with "new methods" but pretty much everyone I know that had common core or new math or xyz new 21st century teaching method is abysmally behind both in speed and skill from people that were taught in more traditional methods. It's very bad in the ~20yo segment from HS no college. My mom works at a deli shop and people don't understand fractions. Let alone fraction<->decimal conversions on the scales. She is in complete disbelief this is real. (She is 68, retired, and still works because she wants to be useful!)
- carefulfungi 1y agoAs another DoDDS graduate, I'd add that (a) the military makes parents responsible for their children; (b) the worst kids gets deported back to the US; (c) the military can compel parental behavior (like family therapy); (d) DoDDS teachers are a self-selection for people with curiosity and an interest to travel and live abroad; (e) unit rotations mean a 1/3rd or more of the school population changes year to year - naturally breaking cliques.
- torginus 1y agoWhat I find slightly amusing is I strictly remember education people writing scathing articles about the 'No Child Left Behind' policies and how mechanistic and cruel was it towards children, and how could these evil fascists controlling education reduce children to simple numbers. Now it's getting praised in retrospect. I'd wager this article is written if not necessarily by the same people, but most definitely by the same kind of people writing those previous critiques.
- treetalker 1y agoFear not! Teaching kids to read and running national education policy are just like professional wrestling.
- georgeburdell 1y agoIt's new information to me that parts of the South are improving the average student (relatively speaking). One thing they had already done well, in my experience, was cultivate the smarter poor kids. When I was a kid in the Deep South, they funneled kids testing above about 125 IQ to magnet schools, busing them in from all over the metro. My friend and I escaped our working class neighborhood school that way. Now, I live in Silicon Valley, where no such programs exist, and by-and-large the public school you go to is based on how expensive your zip code is. Talk about reinforcing inequality.
- olelele 1y agoSlash education for a few generations, alienate & scare immigrants. In 20 years you will have American manufacturing jobs manned by illiterate children who cannot organise or unionize. Joe hill died for nothing it seems.
- vaisa99 1y agoReading is the most challenging thing we ever learn to do. Each letter is a symbol, those symbols make sounds, then add them together and the sounds and meanings changes. What we need to be ready for is adjusting our expectations that every kid has to perform at the same level. “Standards” are business models, and they don’t apply to children and developing minds. Schools should be willing (and allowed) to organize classes where students read and write at the same level. That would be more equitable than working towards the middle of the statistical range, which neglects both those students at the top as well as those at the bottom. Focus instruction where it’s most needed, and work just beyond where those students are capable of. That is what leads to progress. And stop giving everyone the same test. Start there and adjust downward.
- bariumbitmap 1y agoThis article appears to tell a compelling story, but looking closer at the cited evidence, I don't see support for that story; it looks more like reading test scores have been mostly static, or have changed slightly due to how the test is administered. For example, here's a claim from the article: > Test scores from NAEP, short for the National Assessment of Educational Progress, released this year show that 33 percent of eighth graders are reading at a level that is “below basic”—meaning that they struggle to follow the order of events in a passage or to even summarize its main idea. That is the highest share of students unable to meaningfully read since 1992. However, looking the NAEP report card, they say reading scores in 2024 are not significantly different from 1992, i.e. test scores stayed roughly the same, both for grade 4 and grade 8. For 4th graders, the average reading score went 217 (1992), 220 (2019), and 215 (2024). For 8th graders, the average reading score went 260 (1992), 263 (2019), and 258 (2024). In fact they state explicitly that there is no statistically significant difference in reading scores between 1992 and 2024. > Compared to the first reading assessment in 1992, the average score was not significantly different in 2024. https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reports/reading/2024/g4_8/?grade=8 https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/reports/reading/2024/g4_8/... Furthermore, the test was re-designed in 2004 to allow more students with disabilities to take the test: > In addition, since 1996, main NAEP assessments have been providing accommodations to allow more students with disabilities and students who were not fluent in English to participate. Traditionally, the long-term trend assessments have not provided such accommodations. However, in 2004, it was possible to provide accommodations and assess a greater proportion of students. https://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/ltt/bridge_study.aspx https://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/ltt/bridge_study.aspx This would suggest that the decline in scores for the lowest-performing students is due to ESL students or those with disabilities having greater access. The idea that literacy rates are basically the same as they were in the 1990s is not as exciting or eye-catching as "America Is Sliding Toward Illiteracy", but it seems better supported by the actual data.
- johnnyApplePRNG 1y agoI volunteered to help grades 1-5 read in the GTA in Canada last year, and I was shocked not only at their deplorable reading levels but also their lack of concentration. The only kids I could manage to get to actually read anything were the kids who admit their parents read to them every night, and they were proud to read/show off essentially in front of the other kids. The majority of the kids couldn't do much more than look at the pictures and got bored (of their 15 page books!) before even flipping through all of the pages. It seemed pretty obvious that "school" meant more of a daycare/vacation for the parents than a learning experience for the children.