8 ms·
> The problem has become that a lot of kids coming out of college have done little more than memorize Leetcode problems and outsourced classwork to AI. I've als
by Aurornis 1y ago
> The problem has become that a lot of kids coming out of college have done little more than memorize Leetcode problems and outsourced classwork to AI. I've also seen less and less passion for the career as the years go by (ie. less computer nerds).
I started browsing spaces like /r/cscareerquestions and joined a few Discords to get a sense for what young devs are being exposed to these days. It's all very toxic and cynical.
I've noticed an inverse correlation between how much someone is immersed in Reddit, Twitter, and Discords and how well they function in a business environment. The Reddit toxicity seems to taint young people into thinking that their employer is their enemy and that they have to approach the workplace like they're going into battle with evil managers. I've had some success getting people to chill out and drop the Reddit vibes, but some young people are so hopelessly immersed in the alternate reality that they see in social media that it's hard to shake them free.
- rtpg 1y ago10 years ago I'd pretty consistently run into 4chan-types as well (I was browsing 4chan as well, so I'm not immune to this). There's definitely an aversion to treating real life and "the internet" separately in a certain cohort of people. But the kinda edge-y meanness gets really weird when it's applied to coworkers and the like.
- normie3000 1y ago> I've had some success getting people to chill out and drop the Reddit vibes How did these issues manifest? And what approach worked for tackling them?
- darth_avocado 1y ago> The Reddit toxicity seems to taint young people into thinking that their employer is their enemy and that they have to approach the workplace like they're going into battle with evil managers What you’re saying is very true unfortunately and is going to be a real problem. It not only affects how you view your employers and companies but also your peers. If you’re exposed to extreme views even before you start your first job, what happens when you eventually start your first job?
- LtWorf 1y ago> If you’re exposed to extreme views even before you start your first job, what happens when you eventually start your first job? You are less likely to be taken advantage of?
- darth_avocado 1y agoThe more likely outcome is going to be that these people will be left behind. If you came in with extreme views like say for things like DEI, would you be able to work that well with a female manager or a black coworker? If you came in with extreme views about lofty wage expectations or not working extra as a salaried employee, how likely are you to be hired or be put up for promotion? Keep in mind, we are not talking about reasonable takes, we are talking about extreme views that are formed solely through online spaces and not personal experiences.
- bluefirebrand 1y ago> not working extra as a salaried employee This is not an extreme view :/
- paulhebert 1y agoAgreed. I’m a senior dev. With rare exceptions I work 8:30 to 4:30. My previous job gave us every other Friday off. I get things done, do a good job and get nothing but positive feedback from my bosses.
- darth_avocado 1y ago> Keep in mind, we are not talking about reasonable takes, we are talking about extreme views that are formed solely through online spaces You’re taking it out of context. I’m not talking about a 996 culture or regular overtime, I’m talking about ocasional extra push to make things work. Any full time salaried employee will tell you that it is completely acceptable to work extra here and there, when you are allowed to take it slow at times.
- krackers 1y ago>seems to taint young people into thinking that their employer is their enemy Is this not true to a first approximation though? I mean you do have to "hide your power level" in some way, but the fact that the employer isn't your friend or family is a good working model to keep in the back of your mind. It's a prisoner's dilemma type situation, and defect/defect seems to be the equilibrium we've converged at.
- zachthewf 1y agoIt’s not that simple. Even if you take the cynical view that the company is your adversary, the other people who work at the company (including founders, investors and execs) are actually playing a career-long collaborative game rather than a one-off prisoners dilemma.
- michael1999 1y agoThat's only true for the young. As they get older, or the exit grows large enough, some people smell that last iteration and defect hard.
- aspect0545 1y agoThere’s a big difference between somebody not being your friend and somebody being your enemy. I’ve had a similar experience with a sub par employee, who at some point admitted that he wasn’t doing his best at work because he was "only there to exchange his time for money, not make any meaningful contributions". That guy was absolutely immersed in internet culture, making him less self-aware and very unpleasant to work with.
- lloeki 1y agoThis mindset existed well before reddit; hell, it existed well before the Internet. Some people simply show up at work solely to put food on the table, doing the minimum amount of work so as not to get fired.
- 1y ago
- yupyupyups 1y agoOutrage yields clicks/revenue. So there is a financial incentive for media and influencers to fuel extreme narratives. With that said, there are truths and lessons to be learned on the internet. I think it's possible to take that benefit without developing an overly negative outlook on everything.
- Aurornis 1y agoIt’s not media and influencers doing this, though. It’s Reddit comments and chronically online peers in their Discords. Weirdly enough, streamers like Primeagen are actually disabusing juniors of some of these notions. It’s the grassroots commentary sowing the seeds of discontent.
- zwnow 1y agoThe employer might not be the enemy but the employer certainly is not a friend either. Also its expected of young people to spend their time off with these things as well. All this plus the constant fear of being laid off results in people simply not caring too much. Which is reasonable. Maybe the bar is simply too high for what you get?
- rectang 1y agoCompanies are amoral profit-seeking automata. Individuals, even those in senior leadership, have only limited capacity to act in opposition to the company's nature. Workers can definitely forge mutually beneficial relationships with such entities but anthropomorphizing them leads to sorrow.
- zwnow 1y agoCorporations are the reason for lobbyism and wealth accumulation which actively damage my personal quality of life. Its only fair for me to not view them in a positive manner. They view me as an asset, I view them as necessary evil to afford housing and food. I should not anthropomorphize them, yes, but I can anthropomorphize the management and stakeholders. And if they are greedy and behave as such, its my good right to be repulsed by them.
- 1718627440 1y agoThis only applies to large monopolistic companies in an unregulated, thus nonfree market. The most companies, which actually perform the work in the country are small people, who have huge risk and not much money and generally have the company, because they like the work and want to create things. Most people are moral, otherwise we had far more crimes.
- zwnow 1y agoThis applies to any CEO no matter the business size. Otherwise most people could afford life.
- pjmlp 1y agoAs someone approaching 50 years old, "workplace like they're going into battle with evil managers", not sure where you are located, but in southern europe countries it has always been like this, regardless of the job. That is why many countries still have a strong union culture, everyone gets exploited to the bones and they should be happy to have a job if at all. It is quite depressing sadly, but that is what happens when many managers lack business education and see employees as replacable cogs without rights.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- tsumnia 1y agoThanks for fighting the good fight. I know I left Reddit for Digg (btw Digg's back) because of all that negativity.
- danaris 1y ago> thinking that their employer is their enemy and that they have to approach the workplace like they're going into battle with evil managers. Given how many managers are strongly steeped in the mindset that every IC is an innately lazy bastard out to scam the company out of as much money as possible for doing as little work as possible, and explicitly design their policies that way (not to mention structuring their personal conduct that way), this is probably wise. Hopefully it can galvanize more of them to form or join unions! Labor power is a vital tool in the current age to take back some of what we have lost over the past few decades to burgeoning corporate power.
- Cornbilly 1y agoYeah, a lot of Reddit seems to be people wallowing in their own unhappiness. As far as the attitude toward employers, I kinda get it. A lot of these kids were sold the idea that college will mean a solid, lasting career and, pre-pandemic, a lot of companies were trying to sell themselves as a “family” and throwing cheap benefits around (ie. free food, beer, etc) only to yank most of that back during/after the pandemic. It also doesn’t help that, inside US, it sometimes just feels like we’re trying to scam each other constantly. All of this is breeding a ton of cynicism.
- Aurornis 1y ago> lot of companies were trying to sell themselves as a “family” Has your company actually done this? When I was doing mentoring I heard this complaint all the time, but literally no one (juniors on first jobs in this case) could point to an instance of their employer saying it. They had all picked it up from Reddit as something the archetypical company did, and they felt obligated to punish their company for it. Similar problem happens with take-homes: About 90% of the take-home interview problems people shared in the #interviewing channel were entirely reasonable, short, and clearly not real work. Yet many had picked up this idea that take-home problems were unfair because they were “a week of unpaid labor” or that companies were using them as a tool to extract free work from candidates. So they tried protest the concept of take-homes and stated they would refuse to do them in protest. Of course, when they actually received one for a job they wanted they would abandon that mentality and do the problem, and in many cases they preferred that to doing in-person interviews. Yet the mentality remained that take-homes were evil exploitation and they must rally against it because they read so many Reddit comments about it being “unpaid labor”.
- pydry 1y ago>Has your company actually done this? Ive worked for plenty of companies that pretended that they cared about the human resources and not one that has ever been upfront about the fact that they will lay you off for a bump in the stock price without blinking. >Similar problem happens with take-homes: About 90% of the take-home interview problems people shared in the #interviewing channel were entirely reasonable, short, and clearly not real work. Yet many had picked up this idea that take-home problems were unfair because they were “a week of unpaid labor” It's largely been my experience that a lot of companies think an 8 hour take home is actually 2. They tend to be badly constructed and full of ambiguities that require you to read the mind of the test setter. Of course the people who set them dont know this and they never test their tests. My experience on the other side of the hiring desk is that rank amateur shit is the norm. The "unpaid labor" thing happened to me once, I think. It was a company that wanted somebody to build an X. Take home was "build an X". Not common, doesnt happen to juniors, but it happens. Corporate America could clean up its act or Gen Z could force itself to grin and bear it with a smile it like you seem to want. I wont hold my breath for either to happen.
- qwert-e 1y ago>It's all very toxic and cynical You're commenting on a blog post by a B2B SaaS company that sells AI engineer stack ranking with a cute ball of yarn mascot and you're wondering why they're cynical?
- Varelion 1y agoThe need to search for what they are being exposed to already outs them as being out of touch. Them coming to the wrong conclusion only cements their misunderstanding for both the industry's status-quo and the experiences lived by up-and-commers.
- paulhebert 1y agoHaha good catch. I wondered why the article leaned into AI so heavily in the second half
- halayli 1y ago> I've noticed an inverse correlation between how much someone is immersed in Reddit, Twitter, and Discords and how well they function in a business environment. That's probably due to the sample bias.
- georgeecollins 1y agoThere are also people marketing things on Reddit to young people: alt coins, option trading, sports gambling that have an incentive to say working is for suckers, your only hope is to get rich quick. I think most young people are smart enough (or cynical enough) to reject the get rich quick schemes. But the same cynicism allows them to accept the messages that tell them that things are hopeless for their generation, work is unrewarding and you are way behind.
- pyuser583 1y ago> some young people are so hopelessly immersed in the alternate reality that they see in social media that it's hard to shake them free. One of my favorite staff/principal engineers always begins Monday's by asking people what they did on the weekend. He always talks about the things he did - farmers market, local parade, etc. It's shocking to many of the junior engineers. They generally do "nothing".
- LtWorf 1y agoThey just don't want to tell you because they don't think it's your business.
- lexarflash8g 1y agoAnyone who thinks their boss/coworkers are their friend is surely deluded. There is no loyalty in this day and age-- both from the employer and employee side. Even asking "how was your weekend?" -- its implied that you just say good rather than sharing details of what you actually did -- they don't really care.
- pyuser583 1y agoEven if you want the most cynical approach - networking is an essential aspect of career development. If you stick to just "job description during work hours" you won't get far. Building a cohesive team involves sharing interactions like this. If you truly value your privacy, I suggest you come up with an alternative thing to discuss: sports, weather, funny stories, etc. I've certainly had weekends where I very much did not want to share what i did, so I deflected in a way that kept the conversation going. If HR is asking about where you were at 3:15pm on Saturday, and who you were with, and whether you were using work resources at that time, I would start to worry. But a very large and generic, "so what did you do this weekend" - where you are in the driver's seat, that's not the same thing. When I look back at previous jobs, my strongest regrets are not building stronger interpersonal relationships with my coworkers. I've since rectified that. Think of it this way, if you must: coworker relationships are owned by the company - personal relationships are owned by the employees. When you become friends with a coworker, you acquire an asset that will go with you when you leave the company. Much like a new skill, this asset will allow you to get higher pay somewhere else.
- znpy 1y ago> The Reddit toxicity seems to taint young people into thinking that their employer is their enemy and that they have to approach the workplace like they're going into battle with evil managers. They aren't that wrong however. Over the last two-three years alone we've seen waves of layoffs. Layoffs from FAANGs hit the headlines, but so many more happened without hitting the news. And the thing is young people... They adapt. They usually don't have the cultural baggage we older people have, so they often see things for what they truly are without any rose-tinted-glasses from past better times. Their grandparents were able to get a fairly stable job at a company, stay there until retirement and grow a family. Their grandparents were able to switch jobs IF they wanted to. On the other hand, kids nowadays know they will likely be fired at some point, irrespective of their performance, and that they need to play the game for what it is. Can you really blame them?
- kelnos 1y agoIt feels like a self-fulfilling prophecy, though. If you go into a new job, full of cynicism, doing the bare minimum (or less), acting like everyone there is out to get you, then you shouldn't be surprised when you're the first to go when layoffs happen (or sooner, even). Yes, the labor market has changed, and in many ways not for the better. But layoffs are not new. I remember my dad being afraid of them back when I was a teenager in the 90s. I remember him getting hit by one of them, even, and scrambling to figure out what to do (fortunately he was re-hired by the same company, in a different group). I survived layoffs in the three following decades; yes, the most recent waves were brutal, but I wouldn't say they were anything special compared to, say, ~20 years ago. You can recognize a company for what it is (a capitalist organization that cares more about next quarter's numbers than whether or not you still have a job), but also be a positive, professional person, who goes in and does good work every day, gets along with coworkers and managers, and doesn't play games. You can be realistic without being a toxic cynic.
- znpy 1y ago> You can recognize a company for what it is [...] but also be a positive, professional person, who goes in and does good work every day, gets along with coworkers and managers, and doesn't play games. One one hand I agree, but on the other hand I say: it's something that comes with time and experience. Your examples by the way all come from of way better economic times, and more abundance of jobs. It's easy to be optimistic (naive?) when times are good. But it's not what the current kids are experiencing, far from it.
- AngryData 1y agoTo be fair in most jobs that is the relationship approach you need to not get screwed a lot of the time. Cs work has been one of the few exceptions because it was flush with money and in need of workers for so long.
- cyanydeez 1y agoNo offense, but in America, this is true, employer are an enemy. Reddit is american and trusting businesses is how we continue to fail. Like mike tysons iconicquote, everyone has a plan until they get hit in the mouth. You may have good intentions as a managsr until theres a "market correction". In america, this business toxicity is well deserved and will only get worse. Sure some may take defensive employee relationships to far but acting like this posture is toxic to appropriate self care is gaslighting.
- trod1234 1y agoIn fairness, many employers exploit their workers. Wages have been supressed for multiple decades. Rights stripped through arbitrary pay-for-play work agreements, etc. Eventually you lose all goodwill and get a saturation of ill-will related to that exploitation, debt slavery through student loans or worse. Quite a lot of business people blind themselves to the reality. Those that drink the kool-aid are always in the next round of layoffs, after they pulled 80 hour weeks to have a project come in on time. Its not reddit fueling this, its bad business behavior at scale unfortunately. No one can fool everyone all the time. The deceivers are always eventually found out, and then its "we can't find anyone"... The young listen to the stories of people who have accrued a certain amount of experience who are in their 40s now, and quite a lot of those stories are not success but rather exploitation, use and abuse, oh and now all the jobs went to AI... its a trend, and its going to get real bad because the old needed the young to take over those jobs to fuel their money-printing debt spree over the past 30 years. Demographics are destiny, and you either get slave labor, or you get movements towards letting things rot when the environment reaches a certain threshold, and is disadvantaged in the fullest sense of the term.
- krageon 1y ago> their employer is their enemy Without significant safeguards and in the average case, the employer seeks to extract more from you than it gives back. You on the other hand, must work or you will die. This is a power dynamic that positively stimulates the growth of bad behaviour. Knowing that has nothing to do with Reddit, it is an inherent fact of this system.